THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
t Mr. WELLS has also written the fol-
lowing novels :
LOVE AND MR. LEWISHAM
KIPPS
MR. POLLY
THE WHEELS OF CHANCE
THE NEW MACHIAVELLI
ANN VERONICA
TONO BUNGAY
MARRIAGE
BEALBY
THE PASSIONATE FRIENDS
THE WIFE OF SIR ISAAC HARMAN
THE RESEARCH MAGNIFICENT
MR. BRITLING SEES IT THROUGH
THE SOUL OF A BISHOP
JOAN AND PETER
THE UNDYING FIRE
^[ The following fantastic and imaginative
romances :
THE WAR OF THE WORLDS
THE TIME MACHINE
THE WONDERFUL VISIT
THE ISLAND OF DR. MOREAU
THE SEA LADY
THE SLEEPER AWAKES
THE FOOD OF THE GODS
THE WAR IN THE AIR
THE FIRST MEN IN THE MOON
IN THE DAYS OF THE COMET
THE WORLD SET FREE
And numerous Short Stories now collected in One
Volume under the title of
THE COUNTRY OF THE BLIND
^ A Series of books on Social, Religious,
and Political questions :
ANTICIPATIONS (1900)
MANKIND IN THE MAKING
FIRST AND LAST THINGS
NEW WORLDS FOR OLD
A MODERN UTOPIA
THE FUTURE IN AMERICA
AN ENGLISHMAN LOOKS AT THE
WORLD
WHAT IS COMING?
WAR AND THE FUTURE
IN THE FOURTH YEAR
GOD THE INVISIBLE KING
f And two little books about children's
play, called
FLOOR GAMES and LITTLE WARS
THE OUTLINE OF
HISTORY
Being a Plain History of Life and Mankind
BY
H. G. WELLS
WRITTEN WITH THE ADVICE AND EDITORIAL HELP OF
MR. ERNEST BARKER,
SIR H. H. JOHNSTON, SIR E. RAY LANKESTER
AND PROFESSOR GILBERT MURRAY
AND ILLUSTRATED BY
J. F. HORRABIN
VOLUME II
|9otft
THE MACMILLAN COMPANY
1920
All righto
p
2U
COPTBIGHT, 1920,
BY THE MACMILLAN COMPANY.
COPYRIGHT, 1920,
BY H. G. WELLS.
Set up and electrotyped. Published November, 1920.
NorfaooU
J. 8. Cashing Co. — Berwick & Smith Co.
Norwood, Mass., U.S.A.
SCHEME OF CONTENTS
BOOK VI (CONTINUED)
PAGE
CHAPTER XXXII. MUHAMMAD AND ARAB ISLAM
§ 1. Arabia before Muhammad 1
§ 2. Life of Muhammad to the Hegira . . . . . . 4
§ 3. Muhammad becomes a fighting prophet 8
§ 4. The teachings of Islam 14
§ 5. The caliphs Abu Bekr and Omar ...... 16
§ 6. The great days of the Omayyads 22
§ 7. The decay of Islam under the Abbasids 31
§ 8. The intellectual life of Arab Islam 34
CHAPTER XXXIII. CHRISTENDOM AND THE CRUSADES
§ 1. The Western world at its lowest ebb 40
§ 2. The feudal system 42
§ 3. The Frankish kingdom of the Merovingians . . . .46
§ 4. The Christianization of the western barbarians ... 48
§ 5. Charlemagne becomes emperor of the West .... 54
§ 6. The personality of Charlemagne ...... 59
§ 7. The French and the Germans become distinct . . .61
§ 8. The Normans, the Saracens, the Hungarians, and the Seljuk
Turks 64
§ 9. How Constantinople appealed to Rome 72
§ 10. The Crusades 76
§ 11. The Crusades a test of Christianity 84
§ 12. The Emperor Frederick II 86
§ 13. Defects and limitations of the papacy 90
§ 14. A list of leading Popes 96
BOOK VII
THE GREAT MONGOL EMPIRES OF THE LAND WAYS
AND THE NEW EMPIRES OF THE SEA WAYS
CHAPTER XXXIV. THE GREAT EMPIRE OP JENGIS KHAN AND HIS
SUCCESSORS
§ 1. Asia at the end of the twelfth century 105
§ 2. The rise and victories of the Mongols 108
§ 3. The travels of Marco Polo 114
§ 4. The Ottoman Turks, the Turkish Caliph, and Constantinople 120
v
vi SCHEME OF CONTENTS
PAGE
§ 5. Why the Mongols were not Christianized .... 126
§ SA. Kublai Khan founds the Yuan dynasty .... 127
§ SB. The Mongols revert to tribalism 128
§ 5c. The Kipchak empire and the Tsar of Muscovy . . . 128
§ 5o. Timurlane 130
§ SB. The Mongol empire of India 133
§ SF. The Mongols and the Gipsies 137
CHAPTER XXXV. THE RENASCENCE OF WESTERN CIVILIZATION
§ 1. Christianity and popular education ..... 139
§ 2. Europe begins to think for itself 148
§ 3. The Great Plague and the dawn of communism . . .153
§ 4. How paper liberated the human mind ..... 158
§ 5. Protestantism of the princes and Protestantism of the peoples 160
§ 6. The reawakening of science 167
§ 7. The new growth of European towns . . . . .177
§ 8. America conies into history 184
§ 9. What Machiavelli thought of the world 194
§ 10. The republic of Switzerland 198
§ HA. The life of the Emperor Charles V 199
§ HB. Protestants if the prince wills it 210
§ lie. The intellectual under-tow 210
BOOK VIII
THE AGE OF THE GREAT POWERS
CHAPTER XXXVI. PRINCES, PARLIAMENTS, AND POWERS
§ 1. Princes and foreign policy 213
§ 2. The English republic 218
§ 3. The Dutch republic 228
§ 4. The break-up and disorder of Germany 232
§ 5. The splendours of Grand Monarchy in Europe . . . 236
§ 6. The growth of the idea of Great Powers 243
§ 7. The crowned republic of Poland and its fate .... 248
§ 8. The first scramble for empire overseas 251
§ 9. Britain dominates India 254
§ 10. Russia's ride to the Pacific 259
§ 11. What Gibbon thought of the world in 1780 . . . .262
§ 12. The social truce draws to an end 269
CHAPTER XXXVII. THE NEW DEMOCRATIC REPUBLICS OF AMERICA
AND FRANCE
§ 1. Inconveniences of the Great Power system .... 278
§ 2. The thirteen colonies before their revolt .... 280
SCHEME OF CONTENTS vii
§ 3. Civil war is forced upon the colonies 286
§ 4. The War of Independence 291
§ 5. The constitution of the United States 294
§ 6. Primitive features of the United States constitution . .301
§ 7. Revolutionary ideas in France 307
§8. The Revolution of "the yea* 1789 311
§9. The French "crowned republic" of '89-'91 . . . .313
§ 10. The Revolution of the Jacobins 321
§ 11. The Jacobin republic, 1792-4 331
§ 12. The Directory 337
§ 13. The pause in reconstruction and the dawn of modern Socialism 339
CHAPTER XXXVIII. THE CAREER OF NAPOLEON BONAPARTE
§ 1. The Buonaparte family in Corsica ...... 348
§ 2. Bonaparte as a republican general 349
§ 3. Napoleon First Consul, 1799-1804 354
§ 4. Napoleon I Emperor, 1804-1814 360
§ 5. The Hundred Days 368
§ 6. The cult of the Napoleonic 373
§ 7. The map of Europe in 1815 377
CHAPTER XXXIX. THE REALITIES AND IMAGINATION OF THE NINE-
TEENTH CENTURY. THE INCREASE OF KNOWLEDGE AND CLEAR
THINKING. THE NATIONALIST PHASE
§ 1. The mechanical revolution ....... 384
§ 2. Relation of the mechanical to the industrial revolution . . 393
§ 3. The fermentation of ideas, 1848 399
§ 4. The development of the idea of Socialism . . . .401
§ 5. Shortcomings of Socialism as a scheme of human society . 411
§ 6. How Darwinism affected religious and political ideas . . 416
§ 7. Mr. Gladstone and the idea of Nationalism .... 426
§ 8. Europe between 1848 and 1878 436
§ 9. The (second) scramble for overseas empires .... 449
§ 10. The Indian precedent in Asia 461
§ 11. The history of Japan 464
§ 12. Close of the period of overseas expansion .... 469
§ 13. The British Empire in 1914 470
CHAPTER XL. THE INTERNATIONAL CATASTROPHE OF 1914 AND THE
CLOSE OF THE GREAT POWER PERIOD
§ 1. The armed peace before the Great War 475
§ 2. Imperial Germany . . 477
§ 3. The spirit of Imperialism in Britain and Ireland . . . 486
§ 4. Imperialism in France, Italy, and the Balkans . . . 499
§ 5. Russia still a Grand Monarchy in 1914 502
Viii SCHEME OF CONTENTS
PAOH
§ 6. The United States and the Imperial idea .... 503
§ 7. The immediate causes of the Great War 508
§ 8. A summary of the Great War up to 1917 .... 513
§ 9. The Great War from the Russian collapse to the armistice . 524
§ 10. The political, economic, and social disorganization caused by
the Great War 532
§ 11. President Wilson and the problems of Versailles . . . 543
§ 12. Summary of the first Covenant of the League of Nations . 558
§ 13. A general outline of the treaties of 1919 and 1920 . . . 562
\ § 14. A forecast of the "next war" 567
>V § 15. The state of men's minds in 1920 572
BOOK IX
THE NEXT STAGE IN HISTORY
V1 CHAPTER XLI. MAN'S COMING OP AGE. THE PROBABLE STRUGGLE
FOR THE UNIFICATION OF THE WORLD INTO ONE COMMUNITY
OF KNOWLEDGE AND WILL
§ 1. The possible unification of men's wills in political matters . 579
§ 2. How a Federal World Government may come about . . 583
§ 3. Some fundamental characteristics of a modern world state . 586
§ 4. What this world might be like, were men united in a common
peace and justice 588
§ 5. The stages beyond? 594
FIVE TIME CHARTS OF THE WORLD'S AFFAIRS FROM B.C. 1000 TO A.D. 1920 599
A CHRONOLOGICAL TABLE FROM 800 B.C. TO A.D. 1920 . . . 605
INDEX , 625
LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS
PAGE
Arabia and Adjacent Countries 2
The Beginnings of Moslem Power 19
The Growth of Moslem Power in 25 Years 23
The Moslem Empire 25
Europe, 500 A.D 44
Frankish Dominions in the Time of Charles M artel .... 45
England, 640 A.D 49
England, 878 A.D 52
Europe at the Death of Charlemagne 55
France at the Close of the 10th Century . . . . . .65
Empire of Otto the Great 68
The Coming of the Seljuks (Map) 70
The First Crusade (Map) 77
Europe and Asia, 1200 107
Empire of Jengis Khan, 1227 Ill
Travels of Marco Polo .115
Ottoman Empire before 1453 123
Ottoman Empire, 1566 125
Empire of Timurlane 131
Europe at the Fall of Constantinople . . . . . . .141
"We have the payne ...." John Bull's Speech 155
Ignatius of Loyola . . . . . . . . . . .164
European Trade Routes in the 14th Century 183
The Chief Voyages of Exploration up to 1522 191
Mexico and Peru 192
Switzerland 198
Europe in the Time of Charles V 201
Martin Luther 203
Francis I 294
Henry VIII 206
Charles V 207
Central Europe, 1648 233
Louis XIV 237
The Partitions of Poland 250
Britain, France, and Spain in America, 1750 255
Chief Foreign Settlements in India, 17th Century . . . . .256
India in 1750 . 260
American Colonies, 1760 283
ix
LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS
PAGE
Boston in 1775 292
The United States in 1790 295
The United States Showing Dates of the Chief Territorial Extensions . 299
Benjamin Franklin 303
George Washington 304
The Flight to Varennes (Map) 322
North Eastern Frontier of France, 1792 330
Napoleon's Egyptian Campaign 352
Napoleon as Emperor 360
Tsar Alexander I 362
Napoleon's Empire, 1810 365
The Trail of Napoleon 369
Europe after the Congress of Vienna 379
The Natural Political Map of Europe 383
Mr. Gladstone 427
Tribal Gods of the 19th Century 434
Map of Europe, 1848-1871 439
Italy, 1861 441
Bismarck 443
The Balkans, 1878 448
Comparative Maps of Asia under Different Projections .... 450
The British Empire in 1815 452
Africa in the Middle of 19th Century 458
Africa, 1914 459
Japan and the East Coast of Asia 468
Overseas Empires of European Powers, 1914 474
Emperor William II 482
Ireland 491
The Balkan States, 1913 501
The Original German Plan, 1914 514
The Western Front, 1915-18 517
Time Chart of the Great War, 1914-18 528-29
President Wilson 551
M. Clemenceau 552
Mr. Lloyd George 553
Germany after the Peace Treaty, 1919 561
The Turkish Treaty, 1920 563
The Break-up of Austria-Hungary 565
Time-chart 1000 B.C.-300 B.C 599
Time-chart 400 B.C.-A.D. 300 600
Time-chart A.D. 200-A.o. 900 601
Time-chart A.D. 800-A.D. 1500 602
Time-chart A.D. 1220-A.D. 1920 603
BOOK VI (Continued)
CHRISTIANITY AND ISLAM (Continued)
THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
XXXII
MUHAMMAD AND ISLAM1
§ 1. Arabia before Muhammad. § 2. Life of Muhammad to the
Hegira. § 3. Muhammad becomes a Fighting Prophet. § 4.
The Teachings of Islam. § 5. The Caliphs Abu Bekr and Omar.
§ 6. The Great Days of the Omayyads. § 7. The Decay of Islam
under the Abbasids. § 8. The Intellectual Life of Arab Islam.
§1
WE have already described how in A.D. 628 the courts of Hera-
clius, of Kavadh, and of Tai-tsung were visited by Arab
envoys sent from a certain Muhammad, "The Prophet of God,"
at the small trading town of Medina in Arabia. We must tell now
who this prophet was who had arisen among the nomads and
traders of the Arabian desert.
From time immemorial Arabia, except for the fertile strip of the
Yemen to the south, had been a land of nomads, the headquarters
and land of origin of the Semitic peoples. From Arabia at various
times waves of these nomads had drifted north, east, and west
into the early civilizations of Egypt, the Mediterranean coast, and
Mesopotamia. We have noted in this history how the Sumerians
were swamped and overcome by such Semitic waves, how the Semitic
Phoenicians and Canaanites established themselves along the east-
ern shores of the Mediterranean, how the Babylonians and As-
syrians were settled Semitic peoples, how the Hyksos conquered
Egypt, how the Arameans established themselves in Syria with
Damascus as their capital, and how the Hebrews partially con-
quered their "Promised Land." At some unknown date the
Chaldeans drifted in from Eastern Arabia and settled in the old
1 See Margoliouth's Mahommedanism and his Life of Mahomet. — E. B.
B 1
2 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY,
southern Sumerian lands. With each invasion first this and then
that section of the Semitic peoples comes into history. But each of
such swarmings still leaves a tribal nucleus behind to supply fresh
invasions in the future.
The history of the more highly organized empires of the horse
and iron period, the empires of roads and writing, shows Arabia
oC ARABIA and
5
thrust like a wedge between Egypt, Palestine, and the Euphrates-
Tigris country, and still a reservoir of nomadic tribes who raid and
trade and exact tribute for the immunity and protection of cara-
vans. There are temporary and flimsy subjugations. Egypt,
Persia, Macedonia, Rome, Syria, Constantinople, and again Persia
claim some unreal suzerainty in turn over Arabia, profess some un-
substantial protection. Under Trajan there was a Roman province
of "Arabia," which included the then fertile region of the Hauran
and extended as far as Petra. Now and then some Arab chief and
MUHAMMAD AND ISLAM 3
his trading city rises to temporary splendour. Such was that
Odenathus of Palmyra, whose brief career we have noted in chap,
xxxi, § 2, and another such transitory desert city whose ruins still
astonish the traveller was Baalbek.
After the destruction of Palmyra, the desert Arabs began to be
spoken of in the Roman and Persian records as Saracens.
In the time of Chosroes II., Persia claimed a certain ascendancy
over Arabia, and maintained officials and tax collectors in the
Yemen. Before that time the Yemen had been under the rule of
the Abyssinian Christians for some years, and before that for seven
centuries it had had native princes professing, be it noted, the
Jewish faith.
Until the opening of the seventh century A.D. there were no signs
of any unwonted or dangerous energy in the Arabian deserts.
The life of the country was going on as it had gone on for long
generations. Wherever there were fertile patches, wherever, that
is, there was a spring or a well, a scanty agricultural population
subsisted, living in walled towns because of the Bedouin who wan-
dered with their sheep, cattle, and horses over the desert. Upon
the main caravan routes the chief towns rose to a certain second-
rate prosperity, and foremost among them were Medina and Mec-
ca.1 In the beginning of the seventh century Medina was a town
of about 15,000 inhabitants all told ; Mecca may have had twenty
or twenty-five thousand. Medina was a comparatively well-
watered town, and possessed abundant date groves ; its inhabitants
were Yemenites, from the fertile land to the south. Mecca was
a town of a different character, built about a spring of water with
a bitter taste, and inhabited by recently settled Bedouin.
Mecca was not merely nor primarily a trading centre ; it was a
place of pilgrimage. Among the Arab tribes there had long
existed a sort of Amphictyony (see chap, xxii, § 1) centring upon
Mecca and certain other sanctuaries ; there were months of truce
to war and blood feuds, and customs of protection and hospitality
for the pilgrim. In addition there had grown up an Olympic
element in these gatherings; the Arabs were discovering possi-
bilities of beauty in their language, and there were recitations of
war poetry and love songs. The sheiks of the tribes, under a
» Should be spelt Madina and Makka, — H. H. J.
4 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
"king of the poets/' sat in judgment and awarded prizes ; the prize
songs were sung through all Arabia.
The Kaaba, the sanctuary at Mecca, was of very ancient date.
It was a small square temple of black stones, which had for its
corner-stone a meteorite. This meteorite was regarded as a god,
and all the little tribal gods of Arabia were under his protection.
The permanent inhabitants of Mecca were a tribe of Bedouin who
had seized this temple and constituted themselves its guardians.
To them there came in the months of truce a great incourse of
people, who marched about the Kaaba ceremonially, bowed them-
selves, and kissed the stone, and also engaged in trade and poetical
recitations. The Meccans profited much from these visitors.
All of this is very reminiscent of the religious and political state
of affairs in Greece fourteen centuries earlier. But the paganism
of these more primitive Arabs was already being assailed from
several directions. There had been a great proselytizing of Arabs
during the period of the Maccabeans and Herods in Judea ; and,
as we have already noted, the Yemen had been in succession under
the rule of Jews (Arab proselytes to Judaism, i.e.), Christians, and
Zoroastrians. It is evident that there must have been plenty of
religious discussion during the pilgrimage fairs at Mecca and the
like centres. Naturally enough Mecca was a stronghold of the old
pagan cult which gave it its importance and prosperity ; Medina,
on the other hand, had Jewish proclivities, and there were Jewish
settlements near by. It was inevitable that Mecca and Medina
should be in a state of rivalry and bickering feud.
§2
It was in Mecca about the year A.D. 570 that Muhammad, the
founder of Islam, was born. He was born in considerable poverty,
and even by the standards of the desert he was uneducated ; it is
doubtful if he ever learnt to write. He was for some years a shep-
herd's boy ; then he became the servant of a certain Kadija, the
widow of a rich merchant. Probably he had to look after her cam-
els or help in her trading operations ; and he is said to have travelled
with caravans to the Yemen and to Syria. He does not seem to
have been a very useful trader, but he had the good fortune to find
favour in the lady's eyes, and she married him, to the great annoy-
MUHAMMAD AND ISLAM 5
ance of her family. He was then only twenty-five years old.
It is uncertain if his wife was much older, though tradition declares
she was forty. After the marriage he probably made no more long
journeys. There were several children, one of whom was named
Abd Manif — that is to say, the servant of the Meccan god Manif ,
which demonstrates that at that time Muhammad had made no
religious discoveries.
Until he was forty he did indeed live a particularly undistin-
guished life in Mecca, as the husband of a prosperous wife. There
may be some ground for the supposition that he became partner
in a business in agricultural produce. To anyone visiting Mecca
about A.D. 600 he would probably have seemed something of a
loafer, a rather shy, good-looking individual, sitting about and lis-
tening to talk, a poor poet, and an altogether second-rate man.
About his internal life we can only speculate. Imaginative
writers have supposed that he had great spiritual struggles, that
he went out into the desert in agonies of doubt and divine desire.
"In the silence of the desert night, in the bright heat of noontide
desert day, he, as do all men, had known and felt himself alone yet
not in solitude, for the desert is of God, and in the desert no man
may deny Him." 1 Maybe that was so, but there is no evidence of
any such desert trips. Yet he was certainly thinking deeply of the
things about him. Possibly he had seen Christian churches in
Syria ; almost certainly he knew much of the Jews and their re-
ligion, and he heard their scorn for this black stone of the Kaaba
that ruled over the three hundred odd tribal gods of Arabia. He
saw the pilgrimage crowds, and noted the threads of insincerity
and superstition in the paganism of the town. It oppressed his
mind. The Jews had perhaps converted him to a belief in the One
True God, without his knowing what had happened to him.
At last he could keep these feelings to himself no longer. When
he was forty he began to talk about the reality of God, at first
apparently only to his wife and a few intimates. He produced
certain verses, which he declared had been revealed to him by an
angel. They involved an assertion of the unity of God and some
acceptable generalizations about righteousness. He also insisted
upon a future life, the fear of hell for the negligent and evil, and the
i Mark Sykes.
6 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
reservation of paradise for the believer in the One God. Except
for his claim to be a new prophet, there does not seem to have been
anything very new about these doctrines at the time, but this was
seditious teaching for Mecca, which partly subsisted upon its poly-
theistic cult, and which was therefore holding on to idols when all
the rest of the world was giving them up. Like Mani, Muhammad
claimed that the prophets before him, and especially Jesus and
Abraham, had been divine teachers, but that he crowned and com-
pleted their teaching. Buddhism, however, he did not name,
probably because he had never heard of Buddha. Desert Arabia
was in a theological backwater.
For some years the new religion was the secret of a small group
of simple people, Kadi j a, the prophet's wife, Ali, an adopted son,
Zeid, a slave, and Abu Bekr, a friend and admirer. For some
years it was an obscure sect in a few households of Mecca, a mere
scowl and muttering at idolatry, so obscure and unimportant that
the leading men of the town did not trouble about it in the least.
Then it gathered strength. Muhammad began to preach more
openly, to teach the doctrine of a future life, and to threaten idol-
aters and unbelievers with hell fire. He seems to have preached
with considerable effect. It appeared to many that he was aiming
at a sort of dictatorship in Mecca, and drawing many susceptible
and discontented people to his side ; and an attempt was made to
discourage and suppress the new movement.
Mecca was a place of pilgrimage and a sanctuary ; no blood could
be shed within its walls ; nevertheless, things were made extremely
disagreeable for the followers of the new teacher. Boycott and
confiscation were used against them. Some were driven to take
refuge in Christian Abyssinia. But the Prophet himself went
unscathed because he was well connected, and his opponents did
not want to begin a blood feud. We cannot follow the fluctuations
of the struggle here, but it is necessary to note one perplexing in-
cident in the new prophet's career, which, says Sir Mark Sykes,
"proves him to have been an Arab of the Arabs." After all
his insistence upon the oneness of God, he wavered. He came
into the courtyard of the Kaaba, and declared that the gods
and goddesses of Mecca might, after all, be real, might be a species
of saints with a power of intercession.
MUHAMMAD AND ISLAM 7
His recantation was received with enthusiasm, but he had no
sooner made it than he repented, and his repentance shows that
he had indeed the fear of God in him. His lapse from honesty
proves him honest. He did all he could to repair the evil he had
done. He said that the devil had possessed his tongue, and de-
nounced idolatry again with renewed vigour. The struggle against
the antiquated deities, after a brief interval of peace, was renewed
again more grimly, and with no further hope of reconciliation.
For a time the old interests had the upper hand. At the end of
ten years of prophesying, Muhammad found himself a man of
fifty, and altogether unsuccessful in Mecca. Kadija, his first wife,
was dead, and several of his chief supporters had also recently
died. He sought a refuge at the neighbouring town of Tayf,
but Tayf drove him out with stones and abuse. Then, when the
world looked darkest to him, opportunity opened before him. He
found he had been weighed and approved in an unexpected
quarter. The city of Medina was much torn by internal dissen-
sion, and many of its people, during the time of pilgrimage to
Mecca, had been attracted by Muhammad's teaching. Probably
the numerous Jews in Medina had shaken the ancient idolatry of
the people. An invitation was sent to Jhim to come and rule in
the name of his God in Medina.
He did not go at once. He parleyed for two years, sending a
disciple to preach in Medina and destroy the idols there. Then
he began sending such followers as he had in Mecca to Medina
to await his coming there ; he did not want to trust himself to
unknown adherents in a strange city. This exodus of the faithful
continued, until at last only he and Abu Bekr remained.
In spite of the character of Mecca as a sanctuary, he was very
nearly murdered there. The elders of the town evidently knew of
what was going on in Medina, and they realized the danger to
them if this seditious prophet presently found himself master of a
town on their main caravan route to Syria. Custom must bow to
imperative necessity, they thought ; and they decided that, blood
feud or no blood feud, Muhammad must die. They arranged that
he should be murdered in his bed ; and in order to share the guilt
of this breach of sanctuary they appointed a committee to do this,
representing every family in the city except Muhammad's own.
8 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
But Muhammad had already prepared his flight ; and when in the
night they rushed into his room, they found Ali, his adopted son,
sleeping, or feigning sleep, on his bed.
The flight (the Hegira1) was an adventurous one, the pursuit
being pressed hard. Expert desert trackers sought for the spoor
to the north of the town, but Muhammad and Abu Bekr had gone
south to certain caves where camels and provisions were hidden,
and thence he made a great detour to Medina. There he and his
faithful companion arrived, and were received with great enthu-
siasm on September 20, 622. It was the end of his probation and
the beginning of his power.2
I §3
Until the Hegira, until he was fifty-one, the character of the
founder of Islam is a matter of speculation and dispute. There-
after he is in the light. We discover a man of great imaginative
power but tortuous in the Arab fashion, and with most of the vir-
tues and defects of the Bedouin. .
The opening of his reign was "very Bedouin." The rule of the
One God of all the earth, as it was interpreted by Muhammad,
began with a series of raids — which for more than a year were
invariably unsuccessful — upon the caravans of Mecca. Then
came a grave scandal, the breaking of the ancient customary truce
of the Arab Amphictyony in the sacred month of Rahab. A
party of Moslems, in this season of profound peace, treacherously
attacked a small caravan and killed a man. It was their only
success, and they did it by the order of the Prophet.
Presently came a battle. A force of seven hundred men had
come out from Mecca to convoy home another caravan, and they
encountered a large raiding party of three hundred. There was a
fight, the battle of Badr, and the Meccans got the worst of it.
They lost about fifty or sixty killed and as many wounded. Mu-
hammad returned in triumph to Medina, and was inspired by
1 Should be spelt and pronounced Hijra. — H. H. J.
2 From the year of this flight ( = Hegira) from Mecca through the desert to
Medina, the Moslem world dates its era. The Moslem year is a year of twelve lunar
months (354 days), and is therefore shorter than the year of Western chronology
by eleven days. A.H. (the Moslem reckoning) gains a year on A.D. once in every
33 years (about). A.D. 1920 is A.H. 1338 until September 15, when A.H. 1339
begins. A.D. 20,526 and A.H. 20,526 will be partly coincident.
MUHAMMAD AND ISLAM 9
Allah and this success to order the assassination of a number of
his opponents among the Jews in the town who had treated his
prophetic claims with a disagreeable levity.
But Mecca resolved to avenge Badr, and at the battle of Uhud,
near Medina, inflicted an indecisive defeat upon the Prophet's
followers. Muhammad was knocked down and nearly killed,
and there was much running away among his followers. The
Meccans, however, did not push their advantage and enter Medina.
For some time all the energies of the Prophet were concen-
trated upon rallying his followers, who were evidently much
dispirited. The Koran records the chastened feelings of those
days. "The suras of the Koran," says Sir Mark Sykes, "which
are attributed to this period, excel nearly all the others in their
majesty and sublime confidence." Here, for the judgment of the
reader, is an example of these majestic utterances, from the recent
orthodox translation by the Maulvi Muhammad Ali.1
"Oh, you who believe ! If you obey those who disbelieve, they
will turn you back upon your heels, so you will turn back losers.
"Nay ! Allah is your Patron, and He is the best of the helpers.
"We will cast terror into the hearts of those who disbelieve,
because they set up with Allah that for which He has sent down
no authority, and their abode is the fire ; and evil is the abode of
the unjust.
"And certainly Allah made good to you His promise, when
you slew them by His permission, until when you became weak-
hearted and disputed about the affair and disobeyed after He
had shown you that which you loved; of you were some who
desired this world, and of you were some who desired the here-
after; then He turned you away from them that He might try
you ; and He has certainly pardoned you, and Allah is Gracious
to the believers.
"When you ran off precipitately, and did not wait for anyone,
and the Apostle was calling you from your rear, so He gave you
another sorrow instead of your sorrow, so that you might not
grieve at what had escaped you, nor at what befell you; and
Allah is aware of what you do.
"Then after sorrow he sent down security upon you, a calm
1 Published by the Islamic Review.
10 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
coming upon a party of you, and there was another party whom
their own souls had rendered anxious; they entertained about
Allah thoughts of ignorance quite unjustly, saying : We have no
hand in this affair. Say, surely the affair is wholly in the hands
of Allah. They conceal within their souls what they would not
reveal to you. They say: Had we any hand in the affair, we
would not have been slain here. Say : had you remained in
your houses, those for whom slaughter was ordained would cer-
tainly have gone forth to the places where they would be slain,
and that Allah might test what was in your breasts and that He
might purge what was in your hearts ; and Allah knows what is
in the breasts.
" As for those of you who turned back on the day when the two
armies met, only the devil sought to cause them to make a slip on
account of some deeds they had done, and certainly Allah has
pardoned them ; surely Allah is Forgiving, Forbearing."
Inconclusive hostilities continued for some years, and at last
Mecca made a crowning effort to stamp out for good and all the
growing power of Medina. A mixed force of no fewer than
10,000 men was scraped together, an enormous force for the time
and country. It was, of course, an entirely undisciplined force
of footmen, horsemen, and camel riders, and it was prepared
for nothing but the usual desert scrimmage. Bows, spears, and
swords were its only weapons. When at last it arrived amid a
vast cloud of dust in sight of the hovels and houses of Medina,
instead of a smaller force of the same kind drawn up for battle
as it had expected, it found a new and entirely disconcerting
phenomenon, a trench and a wall. Assisted by a Persian con-
vert, Muhammad had entrenched himself in Medina!
This trench struck the Bedouin miscellany as one of the most
unsportsmanlike things that had ever been known in the history of
the world. They rode about the place. They shouted their
opinion of the whole business to the besieged. They discharged
a few arrows, and at last encamped to argue about this amaz-
ing outrage. They could arrive at no decision. Muhammad
would not come out ; the rains began to fall, the tents of the allies
got wet, and the cooking difficult, views became divergent and
MUHAMMAD AND ISLAM 11
tempers gave way, and at last this great host dwindled again
into its constituent parts without ever having given battle (627).
The bands dispersed north, east, and south, became clouds of
dust, and ceased to matter. Near Medina was a castle of Jews,
against whom Muhammad was already incensed because of their
disrespect for his theology. They had shown a disposition to
side with the probable victor in this last struggle, and Muhammad
now fell upon them, slew all the men, nine hundred of them, and
enslaved the women and children. Possibly many of their late
allies were among the bidders for these slaves. Never again
after this quaint failure did Mecca make an effective rally against
Muhammad, and one by one its leading men came over to his
side.
We need not follow the windings of the truce and the treaty
that finally extended the rule of the Prophet to Mecca. The
gist of the agreement was that the faithful should turn towards
Mecca when they prayed instead of turning towards Jerusalem,
as they had hitherto done, and that Mecca should be the pil-
grimage centre of the new faith. So long as the pilgrimage con-
tinued, the men of Mecca, it would seem, did not care very
much whether the crowd assembled in the name of one god or
many. Muhammad was getting more and more hopeless of any
extensive conversion of the Jews and Christians, and he was
ceasing to press his idea that all these faiths really worshipped
the same One God. Allah was becoming more and more his own
special God, tethered now by this treaty to the meteoric stone
of the Kaaba, and less and less the father of all mankind. Already
the Prophet had betrayed a disposition to make a deal with Mecca,
and at last it was effected. The lordship of Mecca was well
worth the concession. Of comings and goings and a final con-
flict we need not tell. In 629 Muhammad came to the town as
its master. The image of Manif , the god after whom he had once
named his son, was smashed under his feet as he entered the
Kaaba.
Thereafter his power extended, there were battles, treacheries,
massacres; but on the whole he prevailed, until he was master
of all Arabia ; and when he was master of all Arabia in 632, at the
age of sixty-two, he died.
12 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
Throughout the concluding eleven years of his life after the
Hegira, there is little to distinguish the general conduct of Mu-
hammad from that of any other welder of peoples into a mon-
archy. The chief difference is his use of a religion of his own crea-
tion as his cement. He was diplomatic, treacherous, ruthless,
or compromising as the occasion required and as any other Arab
king might have been in his place ; and there was singularly little
spirituality in his kingship. Nor was his domestic life during
his time of power and freedom one of exceptional edification.
Until the death of Kadi j a, when he was fifty, he seems to have
been the honest husband of one wife; but then, as many men
do in their declining years, he developed a disagreeably strong
interest in women.
He married two wives after the death of Kadi j a, one being the
young Ayesha, who became and remained his favourite and
most influential partner; and subsequently a number of other
women, wives and concubines, were added to his establishment.
This led to much trouble and confusion, and in spite of many spe-
cial and very helpful revelations on the part of Allah, these com-
plications still require much explanation and argument from the
faithful. There was, for example, a scandal about Ayesha; she
was left behind on one occasion when the howdah and the camel
went on, while she was looking for her necklace among the bushes ;
and so Allah had to intervene with some heat and denounce her
slanderers. Allah also had to speak very plainly about the general
craving among this household of women for "this world's life and
its ornature" and for "finery." Then there was much discussion
because the Prophet first married his young cousin Zainib to
his adopted son Zaid, and afterwards, "when Zaid had accom-
plished his want of her," the Prophet took her and married her
— but, as the inspired book makes clear, only in order to show the
difference between an adopted and a real son. "We gave her to
you as a wife, so that there should be no difficulty for the be-
lievers in respect of the wives of their adopted sons, when they
have accomplished their want of them, and Allah's command
shall be performed." Yet surely a simple statement in the Koran
should have sufficed without this excessively practical demonstra-
tion. There was, moreover, a mutiny in the harem on account of
MUHAMMAD AND ISLAM 13
the undue favours shown by the Prophet to an Egyptian con-
cubine who had borne him a boy, a boy for whom he had a great
affection, since none of Kadija's sons had survived. These
domestic troubles mingle inextricably with our impression of the
Prophet's personality. One of his wives was a Jewess, Safiyya,
whom he had married on the evening of the battle in which her
husband had been captured and executed. He viewed the cap-
tured women at the end of the day, and she found favour in his
eyes and was taken to his tent.
These are salient facts in these last eleven years of Muhammad's
career. Because he too founded a great religion, there are those
who write of this evidently lustful and rather shifty leader as
though he were a man to put beside Jesus of Nazareth or Gautama
or Mani. But it is surely manifest that he was a being of a com-
moner clay; he was vain, egotistical, tyrannous, and a self -de-
ceiver; and it would throw all our history out of proportion if,
out of an insincere deference to the possible Moslem reader, we
were to present him in any other light.
Yet, unless we balance it, this insistence upon his vanity, ego-
tism, self-deception, and hot desire does not complete the justice
of the case. We must not swing across from the repudiation of
the extravagant pretensions of the faithful to an equally extrava-
gant condemnation. Can a man who has no good qualities hold
a friend? Because those who knew Muhammad best believed
in him most. Kadija for all her days believed in him — but
she may have been a fond woman. Abu Bekr is a better witness,
and he never wavered in his devotion. Abu Bekr believed in the
Prophet, and it is very hard for anyone who reads the history of
these times not to believe in Abu Bekr. Ali again risked his life
for the Prophet in his darkest days. Muhammad was no im-
postor, at any rate, though at times his vanity made him behave
as though Allah was at his beck and call, and as if his thoughts
were necessarily God's thoughts. And if his bloodstained passion
with Safiyya amazes and disgusts our modern minds, his love
for little Ibrahim, the son of Mary the Egyptian, and his pas-
sionate grief when the child died, reinstate him in the fellowship
of all those who have known love and loss.
He smoothed the earth over the little grave with his own
14 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
hands. "This eases the afflicted heart," he said. "Though it
neither profits nor injures the dead, yet it is a comfort to the
living."
§4
But the personal quality of Muhammad is one thing and the
quality of Islam, the religion he founded, is quite another. Mu-
hammad was not pitted against Jesus or Mani, and his relative
stature is only a very secondary question for us ; it is Islam which
was pitted against the corrupted Christianity of the seventh cen-
tury and against the decaying tradition of the Zoroastrian Magi
with which the historian has the greater concern. And whether
it was through its Prophet, or whether it was in spite of its Prophet,
and through certain accidents in its origin and certain qualities
of the desert from which it sprang, there can be no denying that
Islam possesses many fine and noble attributes. It is not al-
ways through sublime persons that great things come into human
life. It is the folly of the simple disciple which demands miracu-
lous frippery on the majesty of truth and immaculate conceptions
for righteousness.
A year before his death, at the end of the tenth year of the
Hegira, Muhammad made his last pilgrimage from Medina to
Mecca. He made then a great sermon to his people of which the
tradition is as follows. There are, of course, disputes as to the
authenticity of the words, but there can be no dispute that the
world of Islam, a world still of three hundred million people, re-
ceives them to this day as its rule of life, and to a great extent
observes it. The reader will note that the first paragraph sweeps
away all plunder and blood feuds among the followers of Islam.
The last makes the believing Negro the equal of the Caliph. They
may not be sublime words, as certain utterances of Jesus of Naza-
reth are sublime ; but they established in the world a great tradi-
tion of dignified fair dealing, they breathe a spirit of generosity,
and they are human and workable. They created a society more
free from widespread cruelty and social oppression than any
society had ever been in the world before.
"Ye people: Hearken to my words; for I know not whether,
after this year, I shall ever be amongst you here again. Your lives
MUHAMMAD AND ISLAM 15
and property are sacred and inviolable amongst one another
until the end of time.
"The Lord hath ordained to every man the share of his inher-
itance ; a testament is not lawful to the prejudice of heirs.
"The child belongeth to the parent; and the violator of wed-
lock shall be stoned.
"Whoever claimeth falsely another for his father, or another
for his master, the curse of God and the angels and of all man-
kind shall rest upon him.
"Ye people! Ye have rights demandable of your wives, and
they have rights demandable of you. Upon them it, is incumbent
not to violate their conjugal faith nor commit any act of open
impropriety; which things if they do, ye have authority to shut
them up in separate apartments and to beat them with stripes,
yet not severely. But if they refrain therefrom, clothe them and
feed them suitably. And treat your women well, for they are
with you as captives and prisoners; they have not power over
anything as regards themselves. And ye have verily taken them
on the security of God, and have made their persons lawful unto
you by the words of God.
"And your slaves, see that ye feed them with such food as ye
eat yourselves, and clothe them with the stuff ye wear. And if
they commit a fault which^ye are not inclined to forgive, then sell
them, for they are the servants of the Lord, and are not to be tor-
mented.
" Ye people ! hearken to my speech and comprehend the same.
Know that every Moslem is the brother of every other Moslem.
All of you are on the same equality."
This insistence upon kindliness and consideration in the daily
life is one of the main virtues of Islam, but it is not the only one.
Equally important is the uncompromising monotheism, void of
any Jewish exclusiveness, which is sustained by the Koran. Islam
from the outset was fairly proof against the theological elabora-
tions that have perplexed and divided Christianity and smothered
the spirit of Jesus. And its third source of strength has been
in the meticulous prescription of methods of prayer and worship,
and its clear statement of the limited and conventional signifi-
cance of the importance ascribed to Mecca. All sacrifice was
16 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
barred to the faithful; no loophole was left for the sacrificial
priest of the old dispensation to come back into the new faith.
It was not simply a new faith, a purely prophetic religion, as the
religion of Jesus was in the time of Jesus, or the religion of Gau-
tama in the lifetime of Gautama, but it was so stated as to remain
so. Islam to this day has learned doctors, teachers, and preachers ;
but it has no priests.
It was full of the spirit of kindliness, generosity, and brother-
hood ; it was a simple and understandable religion ; it was instinct
with the chivalrous sentiment of the desert ; and it made its ap-
peal straight to the commonest instincts in the composition of
ordinary men. Against it were pitted Judaism, which had made
a racial hoard of God; Christianity talking and preaching end-
lessly now of trinities, doctrines, and heresies no ordinary man
could make head or tail of ; and Mazdaism, the cult of the Zoro-
astrian Magi, who had inspired the crucifixion of Mani. The
bulk of the people to whom the challenge of Islam came did not
trouble very much whether Muhammad was lustful or not, or
whether he had done some shifty and questionable things ; what
appealed to them was that this God, Allah, he preached, was by
the test of the conscience in their hearts a God of righteousness,
and that the honest acceptance of his doctrine and method opened
the door wide in a world of uncertainty, treachery, and intolerable
divisions to a great and increasing brotherhood of trustworthy
men on earth, and to a paradise not of perpetual exercises in
praise and worship, in which saints, priests, and anointed kings
were still to have the upper places, but of equal fellowship and
simple and understandable delights such as their souls craved for.
Without any ambiguous symbolism, without any darkening
of altars or chanting of priests, Muhammad had brought home
those attractive doctrines to the hearts of mankind.
§5
The true embodiment of tne spirit of Islam was not Muhammad,
but his close friend and supporter Abu Bekr. There can be little
doubt that if Muhammad was the mind and imagination of
primitive Islam, Abu Bekr was its conscience and its will.
Throughout their life together it was Muhammad who said the
MUHAMMAD AND ISLAM 17
thing, but it was Abu Bekr who believed the thing. When Mu-
hammad wavered, Abu Bekr sustained him. Abu Bekr was a
man without doubts, his beliefs cut down to acts cleanly as a
sharp knife cuts. We may feel sure that Abu Bekr would never
have temporized about the minor gods of Mecca, or needed in-
spirations from Allah to explain his private life. When in the
eleventh year of the Hegira (632) the Prophet sickened of a fever
and died, it was Abu Bekr who succeeded him as Caliph and
leader of the people (Kalif a = Successor), and it was the unflinch-
ing confidence of Abu Bekr in the righteousness of Allah which
prevented a split between Medina and Mecca, which stamped
down a widespread insurrection of the Bedouin against taxation
for the common cause, and carried out a great plundering raid into
Syria that the dead Prophet had projected. And then Abu Bekr,
with that faith which moves mountains, set himself simply and
sanely to organize the subjugation of the whole world to Allah
- with little armies of 3000 or 4000 Arabs — according to those
letters the Prophet had written from Medina in 628 to all the
monarchs of the world.
And the attempt came near to succeeding. Had there been
in Islam a score of men, younger men to carry on his work, of
Abu Bekr's quality, it would certainly have succeeded. It came
near to succeeding because Arabia was now a centre of faith and
will, and because nowhere else in the world until China was
reached, unless it was upon the steppes of Russia or Turkestan,
was there another community of free-spirited men with any power
of belief in their rulers and leaders. The head of the Byzantine
Empire, Heraclius, the conqueror of Chosroes II, was past his
prime and suffering from dropsy, and his empire was exhausted
by the long Persian War. Nor had he at any time displayed
such exceptional ability as the new occasion demanded. The
motley of people under his rule knew little of him and cared less.
Persia was at the lowest depths of monarchist degradation, the
parricide Kavadh II had died after a reign of a few months, and a
series of dynastic intrigues and romantic murders enlivened the
palace but weakened the country. The war between Persia and
the Byzantine Empire was only formally concluded about the time
of the beginning of Abu Bekr's rule. Both sides had made great
18 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
use of Arab auxiliaries ; over Syria a number of towns and settle-
ments of Christianized Arabs were scattered who professed a
baseless loyalty to Constantinople ; the Persian marches between
Mesopotamia and the desert were under the control of an Arab
tributary prince, whose capital was at Hira. Arab influence
was strong in such cities as Damascus, where Christian Arab
gentlemen would read and recite the latest poetry from the desert
competitors. There was thus a great amount of easily assimi-
lable material ready at hand for Islam.
And the military campaigns that now began were among the most
brilliant in the world's history. Arabia had suddenly become
a' garden of fine men. The name of Khalid stands out as
the brightest star in a constellation of able and devoted Moslem
generals. Whenever he commanded he was victorious, and
when the jealousy of the second Caliph, Omar, degraded him un-
justly and inexcusably,1 he made no ado, but served Allah cheer-
fully and wellras a subordinate to those over whom he had ruled.
We cannot trace the story of this warfare here ; the Arab armies
struck simultaneously at Byzantine Syria and the Persian fron-
tier city of Hira, and everywhere they offered a choice of three
alternatives : either pay tribute, or confess the true God and
join us, or die. They encountered armies, large and disciplined
but spiritless armies, and defeated them. And nowhere was
there such a thing as a popular resistance. The people of the
populous irrigation lands of Mesopotamia cared not a jot whether
they paid taxes to Byzantium or Persepolis or to Medina;
and of the two, Arabs or Persian court, the Arabs, the Arabs of
the great years, were manifestly the cleaner people, more just and
more merciful. The Christian Arabs joined the invaders very
readily and so did many Jews. Just as in the west, so now in the
east, an invasion became a social revolution. But here it was
also a religious revolution with a new and distinctive mental
vitality.
It was Khalid who fought the decisive battle (634) with the
army of Heraclius upon the banks of the Yarmuk, a tributary
1 But Schurtz, in Helmolt's History of the World, says that the private life of the
gallant Khalid was a scandal to the faithful. He committed adultery, a serious
offence in a world of polygamy.
MUHAMMAD AND ISLAM 19
of the Jordan. The legions, as ever, were without proper cavalry ;
for seven centuries the ghost of old Crassus had haunted the east
in vain; the imperial armies relied upon Christian Arab aux-
iliaries, and these deserted to the Moslems as the armies joined
BEGINNINGS of idi* MOSLEM POWER,
issue. A great parade of priests, sacred banners, pictures, and
holy relics was made by the Byzantine host, and it was further
sustained by the chanting of monks. But there was no magic
in the relics and little conviction about the chanting. On the
Arab side the Emirs and sheiks harangued the troops, and after
the ancient Arab fashion the shrill voices of women in the rear
encouraged their men. The Moslem ranks were full of believers
20 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
before whom shone victory or paradise. The battle was never
in doubt after the defection of the irregular cavalry. An attempt
to retreat dissolved into a rout and became a massacre. The
Byzantine army had fought with its back to the river, which
was presently choked with its dead.
Thereafter Heraclius slowly relinquished all Syria, which he
had so lately won back from the Persians, to his new antagonists.
Damascus soon fell, and a year later the Moslems entered Antioch.
For a time they had to abandon it again to a last effort from
Constantinople, but they re-entered it for good under Khalid.
Meanwhile on the eastern front, after a swift initial success
which gave them Hira, the Persian resistance stiffened. The
dynastic struggle had ended at last in the coming of a king of
kings, and a general of ability had been found in Rustam. He
gave battle at Kadessia (637). His army was just such another
composite host as Darius had led into Thrace or Alexander de-
feated at Issus ; it was a medley of levies. He had thirty-three
war elephants, and he sat on a golden throne upon a raised plat-
form behind the Persian ranks, surveying the battle, which throne
will remind the reader of Herodotus, the Hellespont, and Salamis
more than a thousand years before. The battle lasted three
days; each day the Arabs attacked and the Persian host held
its ground until nightfall called a truce. On the third day the
Arabs received reinforcements, and towards the evening the
Persians attempted to bring the struggle to an end by a charge
of elephants. At first the huge beasts carried all before them;
then one was wounded painfully and became uncontrollable,
rushing up and down between the armies. Its panic affected
the others, and for a time both armies remained dumbfounded
in the red light of sunset, watching the frantic efforts of these
grey, squealing monsters to escape from the tormenting masses
of armed men that hemmed them in. It was by the merest chance
that at last they broke through the Persian and not through the
Arab array, and that it was the Arabs who were able to charge
home upon the resulting confusion. The twilight darkened to
night, but this time the armies did not separate. All through
the night the Arabs smote in the name of Allah, and pressed upon
the shattered and retreating Persians. Dawn broke upon the
MUHAMMAD AND ISLAM 21
vestiges of Rustam's army in flight far beyond the litter of the
battlefield. Its path was marked by scattered weapons and war
material, abandoned transport, and the dead and dying. The
platform and the golden throne were broken down, and Rustam
lay dead among a heap of dead men. . . .
Already in 634 Abu Bekr had died and given place to Omar,
the Prophet's brother-in-law, as Caliph ; and it was under Omar
(634-643) that the main conquests of the Moslems occurred.
The Byzantine Empire was pushed out of Syria altogether. But
at the Taurus Mountains the Moslem thrust was held. Armenia
was overrun, all Mesopotamia was conquered and Persia beyond
the rivers. Egypt passed almost passively from Greek to Arab ;
in a few years the Semitic race, in the name of God and His Prophet,
had recovered nearly all the dominions it had lost to the Aryan
Persians a thousand years before. Jerusalem fell early, making a
treaty without standing siege, and so the True Cross which had
been carried off by the Persians a dozen years before, and elab-
orately restored by Heraclius, passed once more out of the rule
of Christians. But it was still in Christian hands; the Chris-
tians were to be tolerated, paying only a poll tax; and all the
churches and all the relics were left in their possession.
Jerusalem made a peculiar condition for its surrender. The
city would give itself only to the Caliph Omar in person. Hitherto
he had been in Medina organizing armies and controlling the
general campaign. He came to Jerusalem (638), and the manner
of his coming shows how swiftly the vigour and simplicity of
the first Moslem onset was being sapped by success. He came
the six-hundred-mile journey with only one attendant; he was
mounted on a camel, and a bag of barley, another of dates, a water-
skin, and a wooden platter were his provision for the journey.
He was met outside the city by his chief captains, robed splendidly
in silks and with richly caparisoned horses. At this amazing
sight the old man was overcome with rage. He slipped down from
his saddle, scrabbled up dirt and stones with his hands, and pelted
these fine gentlemen, shouting abuse. What was this insult?
What did this finery mean? Where were his warriors? Where
were the desert men? He would not let these popinjays escort
him. He went on with his attendant, and the smart Emirs rode
22 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
afar off — well out of range of his stones. He met the Patriarch
of Jerusalem, who had apparently taken over the city from its
Byzantine rulers, alone. With the Patriarch he got on very well.
They went round the Holy Places together, and Omar, now a
little appeased, made sly jokes at the expense of his too magnificent
followers.
Equally indicative of the tendencies of the time is Omar's
letter ordering one of his governors who had built himself a palace
at Kufa, to demolish it again.
"They tell me," he wrote, "you would imitate the palace of
Chosroes,1 and that you would even use the gates that once were
his. Will you also have guards and porters at those gates, as
Chosroes had? Will you keep the faithful afar off and deny
audience to the poor? Would you depart from the custom of
our Prophet, and be as magnificent as those Persian emperors,
and descend to hell even as they have done?" 2
§6
Abu Bekr and Omar I are the two master figures in the history
of Islam. It is not within our scope here to describe the wars
by which in a hundred and twenty-five years Islam spread itself
from the Indus to the Atlantic and Spain, and from Kashgar on
the borders of China to Upper Egypt. Two maps must suffice
to show the limits to which the vigorous impulse of the new faith
carried the Arab idea and the Arabic scriptures, before worldli-
ness, the old trading and plundering spirit, and the glamour of
the silk robe had completely recovered their paralyzing sway
over the Arab intelligence and will. The reader will note how
the great tide swept over the footsteps of Yuan Chwang, and how
easily in Africa the easy conquests of the Vandals were repeated
in the reverse direction. And if the reader entertains any de-
lusions about a fine civilization, either Persian, Roman, Hellenic,
or Egyptian, being submerged by this flood, the sooner he dis-
misses such ideas the better. Islam prevailed because it was the
best social and political order the times could offer. It prevailed
because everywhere it found politically apathetic peoples, robbed,
1 At Ctesiphon.
2 Paraphrased from Sehurtz in Helmolt's History of the World.
MUHAMMAD AND ISLAM
23
24 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
oppressed, bullied, uneducated, and unorganized, and it found
selfish and unsound governments out of touch with any people
at all. It was the broadest, freshest, and cleanest political idea
that had yet come into actual activity in the world, and it offered
better terms than any other to the mass of mankind. The capi-
talistic and slave-holding system of the Roman Empire and the
literature and culture and social tradition of Europe had alto-
gether decayed and broken down before Islam arose ; it was only
when mankind lost faith in the sincerity of its representatives
that Islam too began to decay.
The larger part of its energy spent itself in conquering and
assimilating Persia and Turkestan; its most vigorous thrusts
were northwardly from Persia and westwardly through Egypt.
Had it concentrated its first vigour upon the Byzantine Empire,
there can be little doubt that by the eighth century it would have
taken Constantinople and come through into Europe as easily as
it reached the Pamirs. The Caliph Moawiya, it is true, besieged
the capital for seven years (672 to 678), and Suleiman in 717 and
718 ; but the pressure was not sustained, and for three or four cen-
turies longer the Byzantine Empire remained the crazy bulwark
of Europe. In the newly Christianized or still pagan Avars,
Bulgars, Serbs, Slavs, and Saxons, Islam would certainly have
found as ready converts as it did in the Turks of Central 'Asia.
And though, instead of insisting upon Constantinople, it first
came round into Europe by the circuitous route of Africa and
Spain, it was only in France, at the end of a vast line of com-
munications from Arabia, that it encountered a power sufficiently
vigorous to arrest its advance.
From the outset the Bedouin aristocrats of Mecca dominated
the new empire. Abu Bekr, the first Caliph, was in an informal
shouting way elected at Medina, and so were Omar I and Oth-
man, the third Caliph, but all three were Meccans of good family.
They were not men of Medina. And though Abu Bekr and Omar
were men of stark simplicity and righteousness Othman was of a
baser quality, a man quite in the vein of those silk robes, to whom
conquest was not conquest for Allah but for Arabia, and espe-
cially for Mecca in Arabia, and more particularly for himself and
for the Meccans and for his family, the Omayyads. He was a
MUHAMMAD AND ISLAM
25
26 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
worthy man, who stood out for his country and his town and his
" people." He was no early convert as his two predecessors had
been; he had joined the Prophet for reasons of policy in fair
give and take. With his accession the Caliph ceases to be a
strange man of fire and wonder, and becomes an Oriental mon-
arch like many Oriental monarchs before and since, a fairly good
monarch by Eastern standards as yet, but nothing more.
The rule and death of Othman brought out the consequences of
Muhammad's weaknesses as clearly as the lives of Abu Bekr
and Omar had witnessed to the divine fire in his teaching. Mu-
hammad had been politic at times when Abu Bekr would have
been firm, and the new element of aristocratic greediness that
came in with Othman was one fruit of those politic moments.
And the legacy of that carelessly compiled harem of the Prophet,
the family complications and jealousies which had lurked in the
background of Moslem affairs during the rule of the first two
Caliphs, was now coming out into the light of day. Ali, who was
the nephew, the adopted son, and the son-in-law of the Prophet
— he was the husband of the Prophet's daughter Fatima — he
had considered himself the rightful Caliph. His claims formed
an undertow to the resentment of Medina and of the rival families
of Mecca against the advancement of the Omayyads. But Ayesha,
the favourite wife of the Prophet, had always been jealous of
Fatima and hostile to Ali. She supported Othman. . . . The
splendid opening of the story of Islam collapses suddenly into this
squalid dispute and bickering of heirs and widows.
In 656 Othman, an old man of eighty, was stoned in the streets
of Medina by a mob, chased to his house, and murdered; and
Ali became at last Caliph, only to be murdered in his turn (661).
In one of the battles in this civil war, Ayesha, now a gallant,
mischievous old lady, distinguished herself by leading a charge,
mounted on a camel. She was taken prisoner and treated well.
While the armies of Islam were advancing triumphantly to the
conquest of the world, this sickness of civil war smote at its head.
What was the rule of Allah in the world to Ayesha when she could
score off the detested Fatima, and what heed were the Omayyads
and the partisans of Ali likely to take of the unity of mankind
when they had a good hot feud of this sort to entertain them,
MUHAMMAD AND ISLAM 27
with the caliphate as a prize? The world of Islam was rent in
twain by the spites, greeds, and partisan silliness of a handful of
men and women in Medina. That quarrel still lives. To this
day one main division of the Moslems, the Shiites, maintain the
hereditary right of AH to be Caliph as an article of faith ! They
prevail in Persia and India. But an equally important section,
the Sunnites, with whom it is difficult for a disinterested observer
not to agree, deny this peculiar addendum to Muhammad's simple
creed. So far as we can gather at this length of time, Ali was an
entirely commonplace individual.
To watch this schism creeping across the brave beginnings of
Islam is like watching a case of softening of the brain. To the
copious literature of the subject we must refer the reader who
wishes to learn how Hasan, the son of Ali, was poisoned by his
wife, and how Husein, his brother, was killed. We do but name
them here because they still afford a large section of mankind
scope for sentimental partisanship and mutual annoyance. They
are the two chief Shiite martyrs. Amidst the coming and going
of their conflicts the old Kaaba at Mecca was burnt down, and
naturally there^began endless disputation whether it should be
rebuilt in exactly its ancient form or on a much larger scale.
In this and the preceding sections we have seen once more the
inevitable struggle of this newest and latest unifying impulse in
the world's affairs against the everyday worldliness of mankind,
and we have seen also how from the first the complicated house-
hold of Muhammad was like an evil legacy to the new faith. But
as this history now degenerates into the normal crimes and in-
trigues of an Oriental dynasty, the student of history will realize a
third fundamental weakness in the world reforms of Muhammad.
He was an illiterate Arab, ignorant of history, totally ignorant
of all the political experiences of Rome and Greece, and almost
as ignorant of the real history of Judea ; and he left his followers
with no scheme for a stable government embodying and con-
centrating the general will of the faithful, and no effective form
to express the very real spirit of democracy (using the word in its
modern sense) that pervades the essential teaching of Islam. His
own rule was unlimited autocracy, and autocratic Islam has
remained. Politically Islam was not an advance, but a retrogres-
f
28 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
sion from the traditional freedoms and customary laws of the
desert. The breach of the pilgrims' truce that led to the battle
of Badr is the blackest mark against early Islam. Nominally
Allah is its chief ruler — but practically its master has always
been whatever man was vigorous and unscrupulous enough to
snatch and hold the Caliphate — and, subject to revolts and
assassinations, its final law has been that man's will.
For a time, after the death of Ali, the Omayyad family was in
the ascendant, and for nearly a century they gave rulers to Islam.
The Arab historians are so occupied with the dynastic squabbles
and crimes of the time, that it is difficult to trace the external
history of the period. We find Moslem shipping upon the seas
defeating the Byzantine fleet in a great sea fight off the coast of
Lycia (A.D. 655), but how the Moslems acquired this victorious
fleet thus early we do not clearly know. It was probably chiefly
Egyptian. For some years Islam certainly controlled the eastern
Mediterranean, and in 662 and again in 672, during the reign of
Muawiya (662-680), the first great Omayyad Caliph, made two
sea attacks upon Constantinople. They had to be sea attacks
because Islam, so long as it was under Arab rule, never surmounted
the barrier of the Taurus Mountains. During the same period
the Moslems were also pressing their conquests further and
further into Central Asia. While Islam was already decaying
at its centre, it was yet making great hosts of new adherents and
awakening a new spirit among the hitherto divided and aimless
Turkish peoples. Medina was no longer a possible centre for its
vast enterprises in Asia, Africa, and the Mediterranean, and so
Damascus became the usual capital of the Omayyad Caliphs.
Chief among these, as for a time the clouds of dynastic intrigue
clear, are Abdal Malik (685-705) and Walid I (705-715), under
whom the Omayyad line rose to the climax of its successes. The
western boundary was carried to the Pyrenees, while to the east
the domains of the Caliph marched with China. The son of
Walid, Suleiman (715), carried out a second series of Moslem
attacks upon Constantinople which his father had planned and
proposed. As with the Caliph Muawiya half a century before, the
approach was by sea — for Asia Minor, as we have just noted,
was still unconquered — and the shipping was drawn chiefly
MUHAMMAD AND ISLAM 29
from Egypt. The emperor, a usurper, Leo the Isaurian, dis-
played extraordinary skill and obstinacy in the defence ; he burnt
most of the Moslem shipping in a brilliant sortie, cut up the troops
they had landed upon the Asiatic side of the Bosphorus, and after
a campaign in Europe of two years (717-718), a winter of un-
exampled severity completed their defeat.
From this point onward the glory of the Omayyad line decays.
The first tremendous impulse of Islam was now spent. There
was no further expansion and a manifest decline in religious zeal.
Islam had made millions of converts, and had digested those
millions very imperfectly. Cities, nations, whole sects and races,
Arab pagans, Jews, Christians, Manichseans, Zoroastrians, Tu-
ranian pagans, had been swallowed up into this new vast empire
of Muhammad's successors. It has hitherto been the common
characteristic of all the great unifying religious initiators of the
world, the common oversight, that they have accepted the moral
and theological ideals to which the first appeal was made, as
though they were universal ideals. Muhammad's appeal, for
example, was to the traditional chivalry and underlying mono-
theistic feelings of the intelligent Arabs of his time. These things
were latent in the mind and conscience of Mecca and Medina;
he did but call them forth. Then, as the new teaching spread
and stereotyped itself, it had to work on a continually more un-
congenial basis, it had to grow in soil that distorted and perverted
it. Its sole textbook was the Koran. To minds untuned to the
melodies of Arabic, this book seemed to be, as it seems to many
European minds to-day, a mixture of fine-spirited rhetoric with
- to put it plainly — formless and unintelligent gabble. Count-
less converts missed the real thing in it altogether. To that we
must ascribe the readiness of the Persian and Indian sections of the
faith to join the Shiite schism upon a quarrel that they could at
least understand and feel. And to the same attempt to square
the new stuff with old prepossessions was due such extravagant
theology as presently disputed whether the Koran was and always
had been co-existent with God.1 We should be stupefied by the
preposterousness of this idea if we did not recognize in it at once
the well-meaning attempt of some learned Christian convert to
1 Mark Sykes.
30 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
Islamize his belief that "In the beginning was the Word, and the
Word was with God, and the Word was God." *
None of the great unifying religious initiators of ^the world
hitherto seems to have been accompanied by any understanding
of the vast educational task, the vast work of lucid and varied
exposition and intellectual organization involved in its proposi-
tions. They all present the same history of a rapid spreading,
like a little water poured over a great area, and then of super-
ficiality and corruption.
In a little while we hear stories of an Omayyad Caliph, Walid II
(743-744), who mocked at the Koran, ate pork, drank wine, and
did not pray. Those stories may have been true or they may have
been circulated for political reasons. There began a puritan re-
action in Mecca and Medina against the levity and luxury of
Damascus. Another great Arab family, the Abbas family, the
Abbasids, a thoroughly wicked line, had long been scheming for
power, and was making capital out of the general discontent.
The feud of the Omayyads and the Abbasids was older than
Islam ; it had been going on before Muhammad was born. These
Abbasids took up the tradition of the Shiite "martyrs," Ali and
his sons Hasan and Husein, and identified themselves with it.
The banner of the Omayyads was white ; the Abbasid adopted a
black banner, black in mourning for Hasan and Husein, black
because black is more impressive than any colour; moreover,
the Abbasids declared that all the Caliphs after Ali were usurpers.
In 749 they accomplished a carefully prepared revolution, and the
last of the Omayyad Caliphs was hunted down and slain in Egypt.
Abul Abbas was the first of the Abbasid Caliphs, and he began
his reign by collecting into one prison every living male of the
Omayyad line upon whom he could lay hands and causing them
all to be massacred. Their bodies were heaped together, a leathern
carpet was spread over them, and on this gruesome table Abul
Abbas and his councillors feasted.2 Moreover, the tombs of the
1 St. John's Gospel, chap. i. 1.
2 Thus Sykes. But Skrine and Ross say only that seventy members of the
Omayyad family were invited to a feast under promise of amnesty, and then
massacred by the attendants. Gibbon gives eighty victims, and tells his story
thus: "Four score of the Omayyads, who had yielded to the faith or clemency
of their foes, were invited to a banquet at Damascus. The laws of hospitality
MUHAMMAD AND ISLAM 31
Omayyad Caliphs were rifled, and their bones burnt and scattered
to the four winds of heaven. So the grievances of AH were
avenged at last, and the Omayyad line passed out of history.
There was, it is interesting to note, a rising on behalf of the
Omayyads in Khorasan which was assisted by the Chinese em-
peror.
§7
But the descendants of AH were not destined to share in this
triumph for long. The Abbasids were adventurers and rulers
of an older school than Islam. Now that the tradition of AH
had served its purpose, the next proceeding of the new CaHph
was to hunt down and slaughter the surviving members of his
family, the descendants of AH and Fatima.
Clearly the old traditions of Sassanid Persia and of Persia
before the Greeks were returning to the world. With the acces-
sion of the Abbasids the control of th'e sea departed from the
Caliph, and with it went Spain and North Africa, in which, under
an Omayyad survivor in the former case, independent Moslem
states now arose. The centre of gravity of Islam shifted across
the desert from Damascus to Mesopotamia. Mansur, the suc-
cessor of Abul Abbas, built himself a new capital at Bagdad near
the ruins of Ctesiphon, the former Sassanid capital. Turks and
Persians as well as Arabs became Emirs, and the army was re-
organized upon Sassanid lines. Medina and Mecca were now
only of importance as pilgrimage centres, to which the faithful
turned to pray. But because it was a fine language, and because
it was the language of the Koran, Arabic continued to spread
until presently it had replaced Greek and become the language
of educated men throughout the whole Moslem world.
Of the Abbasid monarchs after Abul Abbas we need tell little
here. A bickering war went on year by year in Asia Minor in
which neither Byzantium nor Bagdad made any permanent gains,
though once or twice the Moslems raided as far as the Bosphorus.
A false prophet, Mokanna, who said he was God, had a brief but
troublesome career. There were plots, there were insurrections;
were violated by a promiscuous massacre ; the board was spread over their fallen
bodies ; and the festivity of their guests were enlivened by the music of their
dying groans." History is not yet an exact science.
32 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
thty lie flat and colourless now in the histories like dead flowers
in an old book. One other Abbasid Caliph only need be named,
and that quite as much for his legendary as for his real importance,
Haroun-al-Raschid 1 (786-809). He was not only the Caliph of
an outwardly prosperous empire in the world of reality, but he
was also the Caliph of an undying empire in the deathless world
of fiction, he was the Haroun-al-Raschid of the Arabian Nights.
Sir Mark Sykes 2 gives an account of the reality of his empire
from which we will quote certain passages. He says : "The Im-
perial Court was polished, luxurious, and unlimitedly wealthy;
the capital, Bagdad, a gigantic mercantile city surrounding a huge
administrative fortress, wherein every department of state had a
properly regulated and well-ordered public office; where schools
and colleges abounded ; whither philosophers, students, doctors,
poets, and theologians flocked from all parts of the civilized globe.
. . . The provincial capitals were embellished with vast public
buildings, and linked together by an effective and rapid service
of posts and caravans; the frontiers were secure and well gar-
risoned, the army loyal, efficient, and brave ; the governors and
ministers honest and forbearing. The empire stretched with
equal strength and unimpaired control from the Cilician gates
to Aden, and from Egypt to Central Asia. Christians, Pagans,
Jews, as well as Moslems, were employed in the government
service. Usurpers, rebellious generals, and false prophets seemed
to have vanished from the Moslem dominions. Traffic and
wealth had taken the place of revolution and famine. . . . Pes-
tilence and disease were met by Imperial hospitals and govern-
ment physicians. ... In government business the rough-and-
ready methods of Arabian administration had given place to a
complicated system of Divans, initiated partly from the Roman,
but chiefly taken from the Persian system of government. Posts,
Finance, Privy Seal, Crown Lands, Justice, and Military affairs
were each administered by separate bureaux in the hands of
ministers and officials ; an army of clerks, scribes, writers, and ac-
countants swarmed into these offices and gradually swept the
whole power of the government into their own hands by separating
1 Harun-ar-Rashid = Aaron the Just. — H. H. J.
2 The Caliph's Last Heritage.
MUHAMMAD AND ISLAM 33
the Commander of the Faithful from any direct intercourse with
his subjects. The Imperial Palace and the entourage were equally
based on Roman and Persian precedents. Eunuchs, closely
veiled 'harems' of women, guards, spies, go-betweens, jesters,
poets, and dwarfs clustered around the person of the Commander
of the Faithful, each, in his degree, endeavouring to gain the royal
favour and indirectly distracting the royal mind from affairs of
business and state. Meanwhile the mercantile trade of the East
poured gold into Bagdad, and supplemented the other enormous
stream of money derived from the contributions of plunder and
loot despatched to the capital by the commanders of the victorious
raiding forces which harried Asia Minor, India, and Turkestan.
The seemingly unending supply of Turkish slaves and Byzantine
specie added to the richness of the revenues of Irak, and, com-
bined with the vast commercial traffic of which Bagdad was the
centre, produced a large and powerful moneyed class, composed
of the sons of generals, officials, landed proprietors, royal favourites,
merchants, and the like, who encouraged the arts, literature,
philosophy, and poetry as the mood took them, building palaces
for themselves, vying with each other in the luxury of their enter-
tainments, suborning poets to sound their praises, dabbling in
philosophy, supporting various schools of thought, endowing char-
ities, and, in fact, behaving as the wealthy have always behaved
in all ages.
"I have said that the Abbasid Empire in the days of Haroun-
al-Raschid was weak and feeble to a degree, and perhaps the
reader will consider this a foolish proposition when he takes into
consideration that I have described the Empire as orderly, the
administration definite and settled, the army efficient, and wealth
abundant. The reason I make the suggestion is that the Ab-
basid Empire had lost touch with everything original and vital
in Islam, and was constructed entirely by the reunion of the frag-
ments of the empires Islam had destroyed. There was nothing
in the empire which appealed to the higher instincts of the leaders
of the people; the holy war had degenerated into a systematic
acquisition of plunder. The Caliph had become a luxurious Em-
peror or King of Kings ; the administration had changed from a
patriarchal system to a bureaucracy. The wealthier classes were
34 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
rapidly losing all faith in the religion of the state; speculative
philosophy and high living were taking the place of Koranic ortho-
doxy and Arabian simplicity. The solitary bond which could
have held the empire together, the sternness and plainness of the
Moslem faith, was completely neglected by both the Caliph and
his advisers. . . . Haroun-al-Raschid himself was a wine-bibber,
and his palace was decorated with graven images of birds and
beasts and men. . . .
"For a moment we stand amazed at the greatness of the
Abbasid dominion ; then suddenly we realize that it is but as a fair
husk enclosing the dust and ashes of dead civilizations."
Haroun-al-Raschid died in 809. At his death his great empire
fell immediately into civil war and confusion, and the next great
event of unusual importance in this region of the world comes two
hundred years later when the Turks, under the chiefs of the great
family of the Seljuks, poured southward out of Turkestan, and
not only conquered the empire of Bagdad, but Asia Minor also.
Coming from the northeast as they did, they were able to out-
flank the great barrier of the Taurus Mountains, which had
hitherto held back the Moslems. They were still much the same
people as those of whom Yuan Chwang gave us a glimpse four
hundred years earlier, but now they were Moslems, and Moslems
of the primitive type, men whom Abu Bekr would have welcomed
to Islam. They caused a great revival of vigour in Islam, and they
turned the minds of the Moslem world once more in the direction
of a religious war against Christendom. For there had been a
sort of truce between these two great religions after the cessation
of the Moslem advance and the decline of the Omayyads. Such
warfare as had gone on between Christianity and Islam had been
rather border-bickering than sustained war. It became only a
bitter fanatical struggle again in the eleventh century.
§8
But before we go on to tell of the Turks and the Crusaders, the
great wars that began between Christendom and Islam, and
which have left a quite insane intolerance between these great
systems right down to the present time, it is necessary to give a
little more attention to the intellectual life of the Arabic-speak-
MUHAMMAD AND ISLAM 35
ing world which was now spreading more and more widely over the
regions which Hellenism had once dominated. For some genera-
tions before Muhammad, the Arab mind had been, as it were,
smouldering, it had been producing poetry and much religious
discussion ; under the stimulus of the national and racial successes
it presently blazed out with a brilliance second only to that of the
Greeks during their best period. From a new angle and with a
fresh vigour it took up that systematic development of positive
knowledge which the Greeks had begun and relinquished. It
revived the human pursuit of science. If the Greek was the father,
then the Arab was the foster-father of the scientific method of
dealing with reality, that is to say, by absolute frankness, the
utmost simplicity of statement and explanation, exact record,
and exhaustive criticism. Through the Arabs it was and not by
the Latin route that the modern world received that gift of light
and power.
Their conquests brought the Arabs into contact with the Greek
literary tradition, not at first directly, but through the Syrian
translations of the Greek writers. The Nestorian Christians,
the Christians to the east of orthodoxy, seem to have been much
more intelligent and active-minded than the court theologians
of Byzantium, and at a much higher level of general education
than the Latin-speaking Christians of the west. They had been
tolerated during the latter days of the Sassanids, and they were
tolerated by Islam until the ascendancy of the Turks in the
eleventh century. They had preserved much of the Hellenic
medical science, and had even added to it. In the Omayyad
times most of the physicians in the Caliph's dominions were
Nestorians, and no doubt many learned Nestorians professed
Islam without any serious compunction or any great change in
their work and thoughts. They had preserved much of Aristotle
both in Greek and in Syrian translations. They had a consider-
able mathematical literature. Their equipment makes the
contemporary resources of Saint Benedict or Cassiodorus seem
very pitiful. To these Nestorian teachers came the fresh Arab
mind out of the desert, keen and curious, and learnt much and
improved upon its teaching.
But the Nestorians were not the only teachers available for the
36 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
Arabs. Throughout all the rich cities of the east the kindred
Jews were scattered with their own distinctive literature and tra-
dition, and the Arab and the Jewish mind reacted upon one
another to a common benefit. The Arab was informed and the
Jew sharpened to a keener edge. The Jews have never been
pedants in the matter of their language ; we have already noted
that a thousand years before Islam they spoke Greek in Hellenized
Alexandria, and now all over this new Moslem world they were
speaking and writing Arabic. Some of the greatest of Jewish
literature was written in Arabic, the religious writings of Mai-
monides, for example. Indeed, it is difficult to say in the case
of this Arabic culture where the Jew ends and the Arab begins,
so important and essential were its Jewish factors.
Moreover, there was a third source of inspiration, more partic-
ularly in mathematical science, to which at present it is difficult
to do justice — India. There can be little doubt that the Arab
mind during its best period was in effective contact with San-
skrit literature and with Indian ideas, and that it derived much
from this source.
The distinctive activities of the Arab mind were already mani-
fest under the Omayyads, though it was during the Abbasid
time that it made its best display. History is the beginning and
core of all sound philosophy and all great literature, and the first
Arab writers of distinction were historians, biographers, and
quasi-historical poets. Romantic fiction and the short story fol-
lowed as a reading public developed, willing to be amused. And
as reading ceased to be a special accomplishment, and became
necessary to every man of affairs and to every youth of breeding,
came the systematic growth of an educational system and an
educational literature. By the ninth and tenth centuries there
are not only grammars, but great lexicons, and a mass of philolog-
ical learning in Islam.
And a century or so in advance of the west, there grew up in
the Moslem world at a number of centres, at Basra, at Kufa, at
Bagdad and Cairo, and at Cordoba, out of what were at first
religious schools dependent upon mosques, a series of great uni-
versities. The light of these universities shone far beyond the
Moslem world, and drew students to them from east and west.
MUHAMMAD AND ISLAM 37
At Cordoba in particular there were great numbers of Chris-
tian students, and the influence of Arab philosophy coming by way
of Spain upon the universities of Paris, Oxford, and North Italy
and upon Western European thought generally, was very con-
siderable indeed. The name of Averroes (Ibn-rushd) of Cor-
doba (1126-1198), stands out as that of the culminating influence
of Arab philosophy upon European thought. He developed
the teachings of Aristotle upon lines that made a sharp division
between religious and scientific truth, and so prepared the way
for the liberation of scientific research from the theological dog-
matism that restrained it both under Christianity and under
Islam. Another great name is that of Avicenna (Ibnsina), the
Prince of Physicians (980-1037), who was born at the other end
of the Arabic world at Bokhara, and who travelled in Khorasan.
. . . The book-copying industry flourished at Alexandria, Damas-
cus, Cairo, and Bagdad, and about the year 970 there were twenty-
seven free schools open in Cordoba for the education of the poor.
"In mathematics," say Thatcher and Schwill,1 "the Arabs
built on the foundations of the Greek mathematicians. The
origin of the so-called Arabic numerals is obscure. Under The-
odoric the Great, Boethius made use of certain signs which were
in part very like the nine digits which we now use. One of the
pupils of Gerbert also used signs which were still more like ours,
but the zero was unknown till the twelfth century, when it was
invented by an Arab mathematician named Muhammad-Ibn-
Musa, who also was the first to use the decimal notation, and who
gave the digits the value of position. In geometry the Arabs did
not add much to Euclid, but algebra is practically their creation ;
also they developed spherical trigonometry, inventing the sine,
tangent, and cotangent. In physics they invented the pendu-
lum, and produced work on optics. They made progress in the
science of astronomy. They built several observatories, and
constructed many astronomical instruments which are still in use.
They calculated the angle of the ecliptic and the precession of the
equinoxes. Their knowledge of astronomy was undoubtedly
considerable.
"In medicine they made great advances over the work of the
1 A General History of Europe,
38 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
Greeks. They studied physiology and hygiene, and their materia
medico, was practically the same as ours to-day. Many of their
methods of treatment are still in use among us. Their surgeons
understood the use of anaesthetics, and performed some of the
most difficult operations known. At the time when in Europe
the practice of medicine was forbidden by the Church, which ex-
pected cures to be effected by religious rites performed by the
clergy, the Arabs had a real science of medicine. In chemistry
they made a good beginning. They discovered many new sub-
stances, such as alcohol,1 potash, nitrate of silver, corrosive
sublimate, and nitric and sulphuric acid. ... In manufactures
they outdid the world in variety and beauty of design and per-
fection of workmanship. They worked in all the metals — gold,
silver, copper, bronze, iron, and steel. In textile fabrics they
have never been surpassed. They made glass and pottery of the
finest quality. They knew the secrets of dyeing, and they manu-
factured paper. They had many processes of dressing leather,
and their work was famous throughout Europe. They made
tinctures, essences, and syrups. They made sugar from the cane,
and grew many fine kinds of wine. They practised farming in a
scientific way, and had good systems of irrigation. They knew
the value of fertilizers, and adapted their crops to the quality
of the ground. They excelled in horticulture, knowing how to
graft and how to produce new varieties of fruit and flowers. They
introduced into the west many trees and plants from the east, and
wrote scientific treatises on farming."
One item in this account must be underlined here because of
its importance in the intellectual life of mankind, the manufacture
of paper. This the Arabs seem to have learnt from the Chinese
by way of Central Asia. The Europeans acquired it from the
Arabs. Until that time books had to be written upon parch-
ment or papyrus, and after the Arab conquest of Egypt Europe
was cut off from the papyrus supply. Until paper became abun-
dant, the art of printing was of little use, and newspapers and
popular education by means of books was impossible. This was
1 Alcohol as "spirits of wine" was known to Pliny (100 A.D.) The student
of the history of science should consult Campbell Brown's History of Chemistry
and check these statements in the text.
MUHAMMAD AND ISLAM 39
probably a much more important factor in the relative backward-
ness of Europe during the dark ages than historians seem disposed
to admit. . . .
And all this mental life went on in the Moslem world in spite of
a very considerable amount of political disorder. From first
to last the Arabs never grappled with the problem, the still un-
solved problem, of the stable progressive state ; everywhere their
form of government was absolutist and subject to the convulsions,
changes, intrigues, and murders that have always characterized
the extremer forms of monarchy. But for some centuries, be-
neath the crimes and rivalries of courts and camps, the spirit of
Islam did preserve a certain general decency and restraint in life ;
the Byzantine Empire was impotent to shatter this civilization,
and the Turkish danger in the north-east gathered strength only
very slowly. Until the Turk fell upon it, the intellectual life of
Islam continued. Perhaps it secretly flattered itself that it would
always be able to go on in spite of the thread of violence and un-
reason in its political direction. Hitherto in all countries that
has been'the characteristic attitude of science and literature. The
intellectual man has been loath to come to grips with the forcible
man. He has generally been something of a courtier and time server.
Possibly he has never yet been quite sure of himself. Hitherto
men of reason and knowledge have never had the assurance and
courage of the religious fanatic. But there can be little doubt that
they have accumulated settled convictions and gathered confidence
during the last few centuries ; they have slowly found a means to
power through the development of popular education and popular
literature, and to-day they are far more disposed to say things
plainly and to claim a dominating voice in the organization of
human affairs than they have ever been before in the world's
history.
XXXIII
CHRISTENDOM AND THE CRUSADES
§ 1. The Western World at its Lowest Ebb. § 2. The Feudal
System. § 3. The Prankish Kingdom of the Merovingians.
§ 4. The Christianization of the Western Barbarians. § 5.
Charlemagne becomes Emperor of the West. § 6. The Personality
of Charlemagne. § 7. The French and the Germans become Distinct.
§ 8. The Normans, the Saracens, the Hungarians, and the Seljuk
Turks. § 9. How Constantinople Appealed to Rome. § 10. The
Crusades. §11. The Crusades a Test of Christianity. § 12. The
Emperor Frederick II. § 13. Defects and Limitations of the
Papacy. § 14. A List of Leading Popes.
§1
LET us turn again now from this intellectual renascence in the
cradle of the ancient civilizations to the affairs of the Western
worldN We have described the complete economic, social, and
political break up of the Roman imperial system in the west,
the confusion and darkness that followed in the sixth and seventh
centuries, and the struggles of such men as Cassiodorus to keep
alight the flame of human learning amidst these windy confusions.
For a time it would be idle to write of states and rulers. Smaller
or greater adventurers seized a castle or a countryside and ruled
an uncertain area. The British Islands, for instance, were split
up amidst a multitude of rulers ; numerous Keltic chiefs in Ireland
and Scotland and Wales and Cornwall fought and prevailed over
and succumbed to each other; the English invaders were also
divided into a number of fluctuating " kingdoms," Kent, Wessex,
Essex, Sussex, Mercia, Northumbria, and East Anglia, which
were constantly at war with one another. So it was over most of
the Western world. Here a bishop would be the monarch, as
40
CHRISTENDOM AND THE CRUSADES 41
Gregory the Great was in Rome ; here a town or a group of towns
would be under the rule of the duke or prince of this or that.
Amidst the vast ruins of the city of Rome half -independent families
of quasi-noble adventurers and their retainers maintained them-
selves. The Pope kept a sort of general predominance there,
but he was sometimes more than balanced by a " Duke of Rome."
The great arena of the Colosseum had been made into a privately-
owned castle, and so too had the vast circular tomb of the Emperor
Hadrian ; and the adventurers who had possession of these strong-
holds and their partisans waylaid each other and fought and
bickered in the ruinous streets of the once imperial city. The
tomb of Hadrian was known after the days of Gregory the Great
as the Castle of St. Angelo, the Castle of the Holy Angel, because
when he was crossing the bridge over the Tiber on his way to St.
Peter's to pray against the great pestilence which was devastating
the city, he had had a vision of a great angel standing over the
dark mass of the mausoleum and sheathing a sword, and he had
known then that his prayers would be answered. This Castle of
St. Angelo played a very important part in Roman affairs during
this age of disorder.
Spain was in much the same state of political fragmentation as
Italy or France or Britain ; and in Spain the old feud of Cartha-
ginian and Roman was still continued in the bitter hostility of
their descendants and heirs, the Jew and the Christian. So that
when the power of the Caliph had swept along the North African
coast to the Straits of Gibraltar, it found in the Spanish Jews
ready helpers in its invasion of Europe. A Moslem army of Arabs
and of Berbers, the nomadic Hamitic people of the African desert
and mountain hinterland who had been converted to Islam, crossed
and defeated the West Goths in a great battle in 711. In a few
years the whole country was in their possession.
In 720 Islam had reached the Pyrenees, and had pushed round
their eastern end into France ; and for a time it seemed that the
faith was likely to subjugate Gaul as easily as it had subjugated
the Spanish peninsula. But presently it struck against some-
thing hard, a new kingdom of the Franks, which had been con-
solidating itself for some two centuries in the Rhineland and
North France.
42 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
Of this Frankish kingdom, the precursor of France and Ger-
many, which formed the western bulwark of Europe against the
faith of Muhammad, as the Byzantine Empire behind the Taurus
Mountains formed the eastern, we shall now have much to tell;
but first we must give some account of the new system of social
groupings out of which it arose.
§2
It is necessary that the reader should have a definite idea of the
social condition of western Europe in the eighth century. It was
not a barbarism. Eastern Europe was still barbaric and savage ;
things had progressed but little beyond the state of affairs de-
scribed by Gibbon in his account of the mission of Priscus to Attila
(see vol. i, p. 557). But western Europe was a shattered civiliza-
tion, without law, without administration, with roads destroyed and
education disorganized, but still with great numbers of people
with civilized ideas and habits and traditions. It was a time of
confusion, of brigandage, of crimes unpunished and universal
insecurity. It is very interesting to trace how out of the universal
melee, the beginnings of a new order appeared. In a modern
breakdown there would probably be the formation of local vigi-
lance societies, which would combine and restore a police adminis-
tration and a roughly democratic rule. But in the broken-down
western empire of the sixth, seventh, and eighth centuries, men's
ideas turned rather to leaders than to committees, and the centres
about which affairs crystallized were here barbaric chiefs, here a
vigorous bishop or some surviving claimant to a Roman official
position, here a long-recognized landowner or man of ancient
family, and here again some vigorous usurper of power. No
solitary man was safe. So men were forced to link themselves with
others, preferably people stronger than themselves. The lonely
man chose the most powerful and active person in his district and
became his man. The freeman or the weak lordling of a petty
territory linked himself to some more powerful lord. The pro-
tection of that lord (or the danger of his hostility) became more
considerable with every such accession. So very rapidly there
went on a process of political crystallization in the confused and
lawless sea into which the Western Empire had liquefied. These
CHRISTENDOM AND THE CRUSADES 43
natural associations and alliances of protector and subordinates
grew very rapidly into a system, the feudal system, traces of which
are still to be found in the social structure of every European
community west of Russia.
This process speedily took on technical forms and laws of its
own. In such a country as Gaul it was already well in progress in
the days of insecurity before the barbarian tribes broke into the
empire as conquerors. The Franks when they came into Gaul
brought with them an institution, which we have already noted
in the case of the Macedonians, and which was probably of very
wide distribution among the Nordic people, the gathering about
the chief or war king of a body of young men of good family, the
companions or comitatus, his counts or captains. It was natural
in the case of invading peoples that the relations of a weak lord
to a strong lord should take on the relations of a count to his king,
and that a conquering chief should divide seized and confiscated
estates among his companions. From the side of the decaying
empire there came to feudalism the idea of the grouping for mutual
protection of men and estates ; from the Teutonic side came the
notions of knightly association, devotion, and personal service.
The former was the economic side of the institution, the latter
the chivalrous.
The analogy of the aggregation of feudal groupings with crystal-
lization is a very close one. As the historian watches the whirling
and eddying confusion of the fourth and fifth century in Western
Europe, he begins to perceive the appearance of these pyramidal
growths of heads and subordinates and sub-subordinates, which
jostle against one another, branch, dissolve again, or coalesce.
"We use the term ' feudal system' for convenience' sake, but with
a degree of impropriety if it conveys the meaning 'systematic/
Feudalism in its most flourishing age was anything but systematic.
It was confusion roughly organized. Great diversity prevailed
everywhere, and we should not be surprised to find some different
fact or custom in every lordship. Anglo-Norman feudalism
attained in the eleventh and twelfth centuries, a logical complete-
ness and a uniformity of practice which, in the feudal age proper,
can hardly be found elsewhere through so large a territory. . . .
"The foundation of the feudal relationship proper was the fieft
44
THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
which was usually land, but might be any desirable thing, as
an office, a revenue in money or kind, the right to collect a toll, or
operate a mill. In return for the fief, the man became the vassal
of his lord ; he knelt before him, and, with his hands between his
lord's hands, promised him fealty and service. . . . The faithful
performance of all the duties he had assumed in homage constituted
-A -A
aF ^EUROPE about? 5OOA3.
the vassal's right and title to his fief. So long as they were ful-
filled, he, and his heir after him, held the fief as his property,
practically and in relation to all under-tenants as if he were the
owner. In the ceremony of homage and investiture, which is the
creative contract of feudalism, the obligations assumed by the
two parties were, as a rule, not specified in exact terms. They
were determined by local custom. ... In many points of detail
the vassal's services differed widely in different parts of the feudal
CHRISTENDOM AND THE CRUSADES
45
world. We may say, however, that they fall into two classes,
general and specific. The general included all that might come
under the idea of loyalty, seeking the lord's interests, keeping
his secrets, betraying the plans of his enemies, protecting his family,
etc. The specific services are capable of more definite statement,
and they usually received exact definition in custom and sometimes
in written documents. The most characteristic of these was the
military service, which included appearance in the field on summons
with a certain force, often armed in a specified way, and remaining
a specified length of time. It often included also the duty of
guarding the lord's castle, and of holding one's own castle subject
to the plans of the lord for the defence of his fief. . . .
" Theoretically regarded, feudalism covered Europe with a
network of these fiefs, rising in graded ranks one above the other
from the smallest, the knight's fee, at the bottom, to the king at
46 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
the top, who was the supreme landowner, or who held the kingdom
from God. . . ." x
But this was the theory that was superimposed upon the
established facts. The reality of feudalism was its voluntary
co-operation.
"The feudal state was one in which, it has been said, private
law had usurped the place of public law." But rather is it truer
that public law had failed and vanished and private law. had come
in to fill the vacuum. Public duty had become private obligation.
§3
We have already mentioned various kingdoms of the barbarian
tribes who set up a more or less flimsy dominion over this or that
area amidst the debris of the empire, the kingdoms of the Suevi
and West Goths in Spain, the East-Gothic kingdom in Italy,
and the Italian Lombard kingdom which succeeded the Goths
after Justinian had expelled the latter and after the great pestilence
had devastated Italy. The Frankish kingdom was another such
barbarian power which arose first in what is now Belgium, and
which spread southward to the Loire, but it developed far more
strength and solidarity than any of the others. It was the first
real state to emerge from the universal wreckage. It became at
last a wide and vigorous political reality, and from it are derived
two great powers of modern Europe, France and the German
Empire. Its founder was Clovis (481-511), who began as a small
king in Belgium and ended with his southern frontiers nearly
at the Pyrenees. He divided his kingdom among his four sons,
but the Franks retained a tradition of unity in spite of this division,
and for a time fraternal wars for a single control united rather than
divided them. A more serious split arose, however, through the
Latinization of the Western Franks, who occupied Romanized
Gaul and who learnt to speak the corrupt Latin of the subject
population, while the Franks of the Rhineland retained their Low
German speech. At a low level of civilization, differences in
language cause very powerful political strains. For a hundred
and fifty years the Frankish world was split in two, Neustria, the
nucleus of France, speaking a Latinish speech, which became at
1 Encyclopaedia Britannica, article "Feudalism," by Professor G. B. Adams.
CHRISTENDOM AND THE CRUSADES 47
last the French language we know, and Austrasia, the Rhineland,
which remained German.1
We will not tell here of the decay of the dynasty, the Mero-
vingian dynasty, founded by Clovis; nor how in Austrasia a
certain court official, the Mayor of the Palace, gradually became
the king de facto and used the real king as a puppet. The position
of Mayor of the Palace also became hereditary in the seventh
century, and in 687 a certain Pepin of Heristhal, the Austrasian
Mayor of the Palace, had conquered Neustria and reunited all
the Franks. He was followed in 714 by his son, Charles Martel,
who also bore no higher title than mayor of the palace. (His
poor little Merovingian kings do not matter in the slightest degree
to us here.) It was this Charles Martel who stopped the Moslems.
They had pushed as far as Tours when he met them, and in aj
great battle between that place and Poitiers (732) utterly de-
feated them and broke their spirit. Thereafter the Pyrenees \
remained their utmost boundary; they came no further into
Western Europe.
Charles Martel divided his power between two sons, but one
resigned and went into a monastery, leaving his brother Pepin
sole ruler. This Pepin it was who finally extinguished the de-
scendants of Clovis. He sent to the Pope to ask who was the true
king of the Franks, the man who held the power or the man who
wore the crown ; and the Pope, who was in need of a supporter,
decided in favour of the Mayor of the Palace. So Pepin was
chosen king at a gathering of the Frankish nobles in the Mero-
vingian capital Soissons, and anointed and crowned. That was in
751. The Franco-Germany he united was consolidated by his son
Charlemagne. It held together until the death of his grandson
Louis (840), and then France and Germany broke away again — to
the great injury of mankind. It was not a difference of race or
1 The Franks differed from the Swabians and South Germans, and came much
nearer the Anglo-Saxons in that they spoke a "Low German" and not a "High
German" dialect. Their language resembled plattdeutsch and Anglo-Saxon, and
was the direct parent of Dutch and Flemish. In fact, the Franks where they
were not Latinized became Flemings and "Dutchmen" of South Holland (North
Holland is still Friesisch — i.e. Anglo-Saxon). The " French" which the Latinized
Franks and Burgundians spoke in the seventh to the tenth centuries was remark-
ably like the Rumansch language of Switzerland, judging from the vestiges that
remain in old documents. — H. H. J.
48 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
temperament, it was a difference of language and tradition that
split these Frankish peoples asunder.
That old separation of Neustria and Austrasia still works out in
bitter consequences. In 1916 the ancient conflict of Neustria and
Austrasia had broken out into war once more. In the August of
that year the present writer visited Soissons, and crossed the
temporary wooden bridge that had been built by the English
after the Battle of the Aisne from the main part of the town to
the suburb of Saint Medard. Canvas screens protected passengers
upon the bridge from the observation of the German sharp-
shooters who were sniping from their trenches down the curve of
the river. He went with his guides across a field and along by the
wall of an orchard in which a German shell exploded as he passed.
So he reached the battered buildings that stand upon the site of
the ancient abbey of Saint Medard, in which the last Merovingian
was deposed and Pepin the Short was crowned in his stead.
Beneath these ancient buildings there were great crypts, very
useful as dug-outs — for the German advanced lines were not
more than a couple of hundred yards away. The sturdy French
soldier lads were cooking and resting in these shelters, and lying
down to sleep among the stone coffins that had held the bones of
their Merovingian kings.
§4
The populations over which Charles Martel and King Pepin
ruled were at very different levels of civilization in different dis-
tricts. To the west and south the bulk of the people consisted of
Latinized and Christian Kelts ; in the central regions these rulers
had to deal with such more or less Christianized Germans as the
Franks and Burgundians and Alemanni; to the northeast were
still pagan Frisians and Saxons ; to the east were the Bavarians,
recently Christianized through the activities of St. Boniface ; and
to the east of them again pagan Slavs and Avars. The "Pagan-
ism" of the Germans and Slavs was very similar to the primitive
religion of the Greeks ; it was a manly religion in which temple,
priest, and sacrifices played a small part, and its gods were like
men, a kind of "school prefects" of more powerful beings who
interfered impulsively and irregularly in human affairs. The
CHRISTENDOM AND THE CRUSADES
49
Germans had a Jupiter in Odin, a Mars in Thor, a Venus in
id so on. Throughout the seventh and eighth centuries a
steady process of conversion to Christianity went on amidst these
German and Slavonic tribes.
It will be interesting to English-speaking readers to note that
the most zealous and successful missionaries among the Saxons
and Frisians came from England. Christianity was twice planted
50 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
in the British Isles. It was already there while Britain was a part
of the Roman Empire ; a martyr, St. Alban, gave his name to the
town of St. Albans, and nearly every visitor to Canterbury has
also visited little Old St. Martin's church, which was used during
the Roman times. From Britain, as we have already said,
Christianity spread beyond the imperial boundaries into Ireland —
the chief missionary was St. Patrick — and there was a vigorous
monastic movement with which are connected the names of St.
Columba and the religious settlements of lona. Then in the
fifth and sixth centuries came the fierce and pagan English, and
they cut off the early Church of Ireland from the main body of
Christianity. In the seventh century Christian missionaries were
converting the English, both in the north from Ireland and in the
south from Rome. The Rome mission was sent by Pope Gregory
the Great just at the close of the sixth century. The story goes
that he saw English boys for sale in the Roman slave market,
though it is a little difficult to understand how they got there.
They were very fair and good-looking. In answer to his inquiries,
he was told that they were Angles. "Not Angles, but Angels,"
said he, "had they but the gospel."
The mission worked through the seventh century. Before that
century was over, most of the English were Christians; though
Mercia, the central English kingdom, held out stoutly against
the priests and for the ancient faith and ways. And there was
a swift progress in learning upon the part of these new converts.
The monasteries of the kingdom of Northumbria in the north of
England became a centre of light and learning. Theodore of
Tarsus was one of the earliest archbishops of Canterbury (669-
690). "While Greek was utterly unknown in the west of Europe,
it was mastered by some of the pupils of Theodore. The monas-
teries contained many monks who were excellent scholars. Most
famous of all was Bede, known as the Venerable Bede (673-735)i
a monk of Jarrow (on Tyne). He had for his pupils the six
hundred monks of that monastery, besides the many strangers
who came to hear him. He gradually mastered all the learning of
his day, and left at his death forty-five volumes of his writings, the
most important of which are 'The Ecclesiastical History of the
English' and his translation of the Gospel of John into English.
CHRISTENDOM AND THE CRUSADES 51
His writings were widely known and used throughout Europe.
He reckoned all dates from the birth of Christ, and through his
works the use of Christian chronology became common in Europe.
Owing to the large number of monasteries and monks in Northum-
bria, that part of England was for a time far in advance of the
south in civilization." 1
In the seventh and eighth centuries we find the English mission-
aries active upon the eastern frontiers of the Frankish kingdom.
Chief among these was St. Boniface (680-755), who was born at
Crediton, in Devonshire, who converted the Frisians, Thuringians,
and Hessians, and who was martyred in Holland.
Both in England and on the Continent the ascendant rulers
seized upon Christianity as a unifying force to cement their con-
quests. Christianity became a banner for aggressive chiefs —
as it did in Uganda in Africa in the bloody days before that
country was annexed to the British Empire. After Pepin, who
died in 768, came two sons, Charles and another, who divided his
kingdom ;' but the brother of Charles died in 771, and Charles then
became sole king (771-814) of the growing realm of the Franks.
This Charles is known in history as Charles the Great, or Charle-
magne. As in the case of Alexander the Great and Julius Caesar,
posterity has enormously exaggerated his memory. He made his
wars of aggression definitely religious wars. All the world of
north-western Europe, which is now Great Britain, France, Ger-
many, Denmark, and Norway and Sweden, was in the ninth
century an arena of bitter conflict between the old faith and the
new. Whole nations were converted to Christianity by the sword
just as Islam in Arabia, Central Asia, and Africa had converted
whole nations a century or so before.
With fire and sword Charlemagne preached the Gospel of the
Cross to the Saxons, Bohemians, and as far as the Danube into
what is now Hungary ; he carried the same teaching down the
Adriatic Coast through what is now Dalmatia, and drove the
Moslems back from the Pyrenees as far as Barcelona.
Moreover, he it was who sheltered Egbert, an exile from Wessex
in England, and assisted him presently to establish himself as
King in Wessex (802). Egbert subdued the Britons in Cornwall,
1 A General History of Europe, Thatcher and Schwill.
52
THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
as Charlemagne conquered the Britons of Brittany, and, by* a
series of wars, which he continued after the death of his Frankish
patron, made himself at last the first King of all England (828).
But the attacks of Charlemagne upon the last strongholds of
paganism provoked a vigorous reaction on the part of the un-
converted. The Christianized English had retained very little
of the seamanship that had brought them from the mainland, and
CHRISTENDOM AND THE CRUSADES 53
the Franks had not yet become seamen. As the Christian propa-
ganda of Charlemagne swept towards the shores of the North and
Baltic seas, the pagans were driven to the sea. They retaliated
for the Christian persecutions with plundering raids and expedi-
tions against the northern coasts of France and against Christian
England. These pagan Saxons and English of the mainland and
their kindred from Denmark and Norway are the Danes and North-
men of our national histories. They were also called Vikings,1
which means " inlet-men," because they came from the deep inlets
of the Scandinavian coast. They came in long black galleys,
making little use of sails. Most of our information about these
wars and invasions of the pagan Vikings is derived from Christian
sources, and so we have abundant information of the massacres
and atrocities of their raids and very little about the cruelties
inflicted upon their pagan brethren, the Saxons, at the hands' of
Charlemagne. Their animus against the cross and against monks
and nuns was extreme. They delighted in the burning of monas-
teries and nunneries and the slaughter of their inmates.
Throughout the period between the fifth and the ninth centuries
these Vikings or Northmen were learning seamanship, becoming
bolder, and ranging further. They braved the northern seas
until the icy shores of Greenland were a familiar haunt, and by
the ninth century they had settlements (of which Europe in j
general knew nothing) in America. In the tenth and eleventh \
centuries many of their sagas began to be written down in Ice- i
land. They saw the world in terms of valiant adventure. They
assailed the walrus, the bear, and the whale. In their imaginations
a great and rich city to the south, a sort of confusion of Rome and
Byzantium, loomed large. They called it " Miklagard " (Michael's
court) or Micklegarth. The magnetism of Micklegarth was to
draw the descendants of these Northmen down into the Medi-
terranean by two routes, by the west and also across Russia from
the Baltic, as we shall tell later. By the Russian route went also
the kindred Swedes.
So long as Charlemagne and Egbert lived, the Vikings were no
more than raiders ; but as the ninth century wore on, these raids
developed into organized invasions. In several districts of
„ * N. B. — Vik-ings, not Vi-kings. Vik = a fiord or inlet.
54 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
England the hold of Christianity was by no means firm as yet.
In Mercia in particular the pagan Northmen found sympathy
and help. By 886 the Danes had conquered a fair part of Eng-
land and the English king, Alfred the Great, had recognized
their rule over their conquests, the Dane-law, in the pact he
made with Guthrum their leader. A little later, in 912, an-
other expedition under Rolf the Ganger established itself upon
the coast of France in the region that was known henceforth as
Normandy (= Northman-dy). But of how there was presently
a fresh conquest of England by the Danes and how finally the Duke
of Normandy became King of England, we cannot tell at any length.
There were very small racial and social differences between Angle,
Saxon, Jute, Dane, or Norman ; and though these changes loom large
in the imaginations of the English, they are seen to be very slight
rufflings indeed of the stream of history when we measure them by
the standards of a greater world. The issue between Christianity
and paganism vanished presently from the struggle. By the Treaty
of Wedmore the Danes agreed to be baptized if they were assured of
their conquests ; and the descendants of Rolf in Normandy were not
merely Christianized, but they learnt to speak French from the
more civilized people about them, forgetting their own Norse
tongue. Of much greater significance in the history of mankind
are the relations of Charlemagne with his neighbours to the south
and east, and to the imperial tradition.
§5
Through Charlemagne the tradition of the Roman Caesar was
revived in Europe.1 The Roman Empire was dead and decaying ;
the Byzantine Empire was far gone in decay ; but the education
and mentality of Europe had sunken to a level at which new crea-
tive political ideas were probably impossible. In all Europe there
survived not a tithe of the speculative, vigour that we find in the
Athenian literature of the fifth century B.C. There was no power
to postulate a new occasion or to conceive and organize a novel
political method. Official Christianity had long overlaid and accus-
tomed itself to ignore those strange teachings of Jesus of Nazareth
1 Vide Stubbs' History of Germany in the Middle Ages, and Bryce's Holy Roman
Empire.
CHRISTENDOM AND THE CRUSADES
55
56 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
from which it had arisen. The Roman Church, clinging tenaciously
to its possession of the title of pontifex maximus, had long since
abandoned its appointed task of achieving the Kingdom of Heaven.
It was preoccupied with the revival of Roman ascendancy on earth,
which it conceived of as its inheritance. It had become a political
body, using the faith and needs of simple men to forward its
schemes. Europe drifted towards a dreary imitation and revival
of the misconceived failures of the past. For eleven centuries
from Charlemagne onwards, " Emperors" and " Caesars" of this
line and that come and go in the history of Europe like fancies
in a disordered mind. We shall have to tell of a great process of
mental growth in Europe, of enlarged horizons and accumulating
power, but it was a process that went on independently of, and in
spite of, the political forms of the time, until at last it shattered
those forms altogether. Europe during those eleven centuries
of the imitation Caesars which began with Charlemagne, and which
closed only in the monstrous bloodshed of 1914-1918, has been
like a busy factory owned by a somnambulist, who is sometimes
quite unimportant and sometimes disastrously in the way. Or
rather than a somnambulist, let us say by a corpse that magically
simulates a kind of life. The Roman Empire staggers, sprawls, is
thrust off the stage, and reappears, and — if we may carry the
image one step further — it is the Church of Rome which plays
the part of the magician and keeps this corpse alive.
And throughout the whole period there is always a struggle going
on for the control of the corpse between the spiritual and various
temporal powers. We have already noted the spirit of St. Augus-
tine's City of God. It was a book which we know Charlemagne
read', or had read to him — for his literary accomplishments are
rather questionable. He conceived of this Christian Empire as
being ruled and maintained in its orthodoxy by some such great
Caesar as himself. He was to rule even the Pope. But at Rome
the view taken of the revived empire differed a little from that.
There the view taken was that the Christian Caesar must be
anointed and guided by the Pope — who would even have the
power to excommunicate and depose him. Even in the time of
Charlemagne this divergence of view was apparent. In the
following centuries it became acute.
CHRISTENDOM AND THE CRUSADES 57
The idea of the empire dawned only very gradually upon the
mind of Charlemagne. At first he was simply the ruler of his
father's kingdom of the Franks, and his powers were fully occupied
in struggles with the Saxons and Bavarians, and with the Slavs to
the east of them, with the Moslem in Spain, and with various
insurrections in his own dominions. And as the result of a quarrel
with the King of Lombardy, his father-in-law, he conquered
Lombardy and North Italy. We have noted the establishment
of the Lombards in North Italy about 570 after the great pestilence,
and after the overthrow of the East Gothic kings by Justinian.
These Lombards had always been a danger and a fear to the Popes,
and there had been an alliance between Pope and Frankish King
against them in the time of Pepin. Now Charlemagne completely
subjugated Lombardy (774), sent his father-in-law to a monastery,
and carried his conquests beyond the present north-eastern bound-
aries of Italy into Dalmatia in 776. In 781 he caused one of his
sons, Pepin, who did not outlive him, to be crowned King of Italy
in Rome.
There was a new Pope, Leo III, in 795; who seems from the first
to have resolved to make Charlemagne emperor. Hitherto the
court at Byzantium had possessed a certain indefinite authority
over the Pope. Strong emperors like Justinian had bullied the
Popes and obliged them to come to Constantinople ; weak emperors
had annoyed them ineffectively. The idea of a breach, both sec-
ular and religious, with Constantinople had long been entertained
at the Lateran,1 and in the Frankish power there seemed to be
just the support that was necessary if Constantinople was to be
defied. So at his accession Leo III sent the keys of the tomb of
St. Peter and a banner to Charlemagne as the symbols of his
sovereignty in Rome as King of Italy. Very soon the Pope had
to appeal to the protection he had chosen. He was unpopular
in Rome ; he was attacked and ill-treated in the streets during a
procession, and obliged to fly to Germany (799). Eginhard says
his eyes were gouged out and his tongue cut off ; he seems, how-
ever, to have had both eyes and tongue again a year later. Charle-
magne brought him back and reinstated him (800).
1 The Lateran was the earlier palace of the Popes in Rome. Later they occupied
the Vatican.
58 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
Then occurred a very important scene. On Christmas Day,
in the year 800, as Charles was rising from prayer in the Church
of St. Peter, the Pope, who had everything in readiness, clapped a
crown upon his head and hailed him Csesar and Augustus. There
was great popular applause. But Eginhard, the friend and biog-
rapher of Charlemagne, says that the new emperor was by no
means pleased by this coup of Pope Leo's. If he had known this
was to happen, he said, "he would not have entered the church,
great festival though it was." No doubt he had been thinking
and talking of making himself emperor, but he had evidently not
intended that the Pope should make him emperor. He had had
some idea of marrying the Empress Irene, who at that time reigned
in Constantinople, and so becoming monarch of both Eastern and
Western Empires. He was now obliged to accept the title in the
manner that Leo III had adopted as a gift from the Pope, and in a
way that estranged Constantinople and secured the separation of
Rome from the Byzantine Church.
At first Byzantium was unwilling to recognize the imperial title
of Charlemagne. But in 810 a great disaster fell upon the Byzan-
tine Empire. The pagan Bulgarians, under their Prince Krum
(802-814), defeated and destroyed the armies of the Emperor
Nicephorus, whose skull became a drinking-cup for Krum. The
greater part of the Balkan peninsula was conquered by these
people. (The Bulgarian and the English nations thus became
established as political unities almost simultaneously.) After
this misfortune Byzantium was in no position to dispute this
revival of the empire in the West, and in 812 Charlemagne was
formally recognized by Byzantine envoys as Emperor and
Augustus.
So the Empire of Rome, which had died at the hands of Odoacer
in 476, rose again in 800 as the "Holy Roman Empire." While
its physical strength lay north of the Alps, the centre of its idea
was Rome. It was therefore from the beginning a divided thing
of uncertain power, a claim and an argument rather than a neces-
sary reality. The German sword was always clattering over the
Alps into Italy, and missions and legates toiling over in the reverse
direction. But the Germans could never hold Italy permanently,
because they could not stand the malaria that the ruined, neglected,
CHRISTENDOM AND THE CRUSADES 59
undrained country fostered. And in Rome, as well as in several
other of the cities of Italy, there smouldered a more ancient
tradition, the tradition of the aristocratic republic, hostile to both
Emperor and Pope.
§6
In spite of the fact that we have a life of him written by his
contemporary, Eginhard,1 the character and personality of Charle-
magne are difficult to visualize. Eginhard lacks vividness; he
tells many particulars, but not the particulars that make a man
live again in the record. Charlemagne, he says, was a tall man,
with a rather feeble voice ; and he had bright eyes and a long nose.
"The top of his head was round," whatever that may mean, and
his hair was "white." ,He had a thick, rather short neck, and
"his belly too prominent." He wore a tunic with a silver border,
and gartered hose. He had a blue cloak, and was always girt
with his sword, hilt and belt being of gold and silver. He was
evidently a man of great activity, one imagines him moving
quickly, and his numerous love affairs did not interfere at all with
his incessant military and political labours. He had numerous
wives and mistresses. He took much exercise, was fond of pomp
and religious ceremonies, and gave generously. He was a man
of very miscellaneous activity and great intellectual enterprise,
and with a self-confidence that is rather suggestive of William
II, the ex-German Emperor, the last, perhaps for ever, of this
series of imitation Caesars in Europe which Charlemagne began.
The mental life that Eginhard records of him is interesting,
because it not only gives glimpses of a curious character ,^but serves
as a sample of the intellectuality of the time. He could read
probably; at meals he "listened to music or reading," but we are
told that he had not acquired the art of writing ; "he used to keep
his writing-book and tablets under his pillow, that when he had
leisure he might practise his hand in forming letters, but he made
little progress in an art begun too late in life." He had, however,
a real respect for learning and a real desire for knowledge, and he
did his utmost to attract men of learning to his court. Among
others who came was Alcuin, a learned Englishman. All those
1 Eginhard's Life of Karl the Great. (Glaister.)
60 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
learned men were, of course, clergymen, there being no other
learned men, and naturally they gave a strongly clerical tinge to
the information they imparted to their master. At his court,
which was usually at Aix-la-Chapelle or Mayence, he maintained
in the winter months a curious institution called his "school," in
which he and his erudite associates affected to lay aside all thoughts
of worldly position, assumed names taken from the classical
writers or from Holy Writ, and discoursed upon theology and
literature. Charlemagne himself was "David." He developed a
considerable knowledge of theology, and it is to him that we must
ascribe the addition of the words filioque to the Nicene Creed (see
chap, xxx, § 8), an addition that finally split the Latin and Greek
Churches asunder. But it is more than doubtful if he had any
such separation in mind. He wanted to add a word or so to the
creed, just as the Emperor William II wanted to write operas and
paint pictures,1 and he took up what was originally a Spanish
innovation.
Of his organization of his empire there is little to be said here.
He was far too restless and busy to consider the quality of his
successor or the condition of political stability, and the most
noteworthy thing in this relationship is that he particularly
schooled his son and successor, Louis the Pious (814-840), to
take the crown from the altar and crown himself. But Louis
the Pious was too pious to adhere to those instructions when the
Pope made an objection.
The legislation of Charlemagne was greatly coloured by Bible
reading; he knew his Bible well, as the times went; and it is
characteristic of him that after he had been crowned emperor he
required every male subject above the age of twelve to renew his
oath of allegiance, and to undertake to be not simply a good sub-
ject, but a good Christian. To refuse baptism or to retract after
baptism was a crime punishable by death. He did much to en-
courage architecture, and imported many Italian architects,
chiefly from Ravenna, to whom we owe that pleasant Byzantine
style that still at Worms and Cologne and elsewhere delights the
JThe addition was discreetly opposed by Leo III. "In the correspondence
between them the Pope assumes the liberality of a statesman and the prince de-
scends to the prejudice and passions of a priest." — Gibbon, chap. Ix.
CHRISTENDOM AND THE CRUSADES 61
tourist in the Rhineland.1 He founded a number of cathedrals and
monastic schools, did much to encourage the study of classical
Latin, and was a distinguished amateur of church music. The
possibility of his talking Latin and understanding Greek is open to
discussion; probably he talked French-Latin. Frankish, how-
ever, was his habitual tongue. He made a collection of old
German songs and tales, but these were destroyed by his successor
Louis the Pious on account of their paganism.
He corresponded with Haroun-al-Raschid, the Abbasid Caliph
at Bagdad, who was not perhaps the less friendly to him on
account of his vigorous handling of the Omayyad Arabs in Spain.
Gibbon supposes that this " public correspondence was founded
on vanity," and that "their remote situation left no room for a
competition of interest." But with the Byzantine Empire be-
tween them in the East, and the independent caliphate of Spain
in the West, and a common danger in the Turks of the great
plains, they had three very excellent reasons for cordiality.
Haroun-al-Raschid, says Gibbon, sent Charlemagne by his am-
bassadors a splendid tent, a water clock, an elephant, and the
keys of the Holy Sepulchre. The last item suggests that Charle-
magne was to some extent regarded by the Saracen monarch as
the protector of the Christians and Christian properties in his
dominions. Some historians declare explicitly that there was a
treaty to that effect.2
§7
The Empire of Charlemagne did not outlive his son and suc-
cessor, Louis the Pious. It fell apart into its main constituents.
The Latinized Keltic and Frankish population of Gaul begins now
to be recognizable as France, though this France was broken up
into a number of dukedoms and principalities, often with no more
than a nominal unity; the German-speaking peoples between
the Rhine and the Slavs to the east similarly begin to develop an
even more fragmentary intimation of Germany. When at length
a real emperor reappears in Western Europe (962), he is not a
1 The Byzantine style in Gaul is, I fancy, much earlier than Charlemagne, and
goes back to the 4th century or earlier. See Rivoira's History of Lombard Archi-
tecture, or T. G. Jackson's History of Gothic Architecture. — E. B.
2 See L. Brechier, L'Eglise et VOrient au Moyen Age.
62 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
Frank, but a Saxon; the conquered in Germany have become
the masters.
It is impossible here to trace the events of the ninth and tenth
centuries in any detail, the alliances, the treacheries, the claims
and acquisitions. Everywhere there was lawlessness, war, and a
struggle for power. In 987 the nominal kingdom of France
passed from the hands of the Carlovingians, the last descendants of
Charlemagne, into the hands of Hugh Capet, who founded a new
dynasty. Most of his alleged subordinates were in fact independ-
ent, and willing to make war on the king at the slightest provo-
cation. The dominions of the Duke of Normandy, for example,
were more extensive and more powerful than the patrimony of
Hugh Capet. Almost the only unity of this France over which
the king exercised a nominal authority lay in the common resolu-
tion of its great provinces to resist incorporation in any empire
dominated either by a German ruler or by the Pope. Apart from
the simple organization dictated by that common will, France
was a mosaic of practically independent nobles. It was an era
of castle-building and fortification, and what was called " private
war" throughout all Europe.
The state of Rome in the tenth century is almost indescribable.
The decay of the Empire of Charlemagne left the Pope without
a protector, threatened by Byzantium and the Saracens (who had
taken Sicily), and face to face with the unruly nobles of Rome.
Among the most powerful of these were two women, Theodora and
Marozia, mother and daughter,1 who in succession held the Castle
of St. Angelo (§1), which Theophylact, the patrician husband of
Theodora, had seized with most of the temporal power of the
Pope ; these two women were as bold, unscrupulous, and dissolute
as any male prince of the time could have been, and they are abused
by historians as though they were ten times worse. Marozia
seized and imprisoned Pope John X (928), who speedily died under
her care. She subsequently made her illegitimate son pope, under
the title of John XI. After him her grandson, John XII, filled the
chair of St. Peter. Gibbon's account of the manners and morals
of John XII takes refuge at last beneath a veil of Latin footnotes.
This Pope, John XII, was finally degraded by the new German
1 Gibbon mentions a second Theodora, the sister of Marozia.
CHRISTENDOM AND THE CRUSADES 63
Emperor Otto, who came over the Alps and down into Italy to be
crowned in 962.1
This new line of Saxon emperors, which thus comes into prom-
inence, sprang from a certain Henry the Fowler, who was
elected King of* Germany by an assembly of German nobles,
princes, and prelates in 919. In 936 he was succeeded as King by
his son, Otto I, surnamed the Great, who was also elected to be his
successor at Aix-la-Chapelle, and who finally descended upon
Rome at the invitation of John XII, to be crowned emperor in
962. His subsequent degradation of John was forced upon him
by that Pope's treachery. With his assumption of the imperial
dignity, Otto I did not so much overcome Rome as restore the
ancient tussle of Pope and Emperor for ascendancy to something
like decency and dignity again. Otto I was followed by Otto II
(973-983), and he again by a third Otto (983-1002) .2
The struggle between the Emperor and the Pope for ascendancy
over the Holy Roman Empire plays a large part in the history of
the early Middle Ages, and we shall have presently to sketch its
chief phases. Though the Church never sank quite to the level
of John XII again, nevertheless the story fluctuates through phases
of great violence, confusion, and intrigue. Yet the outer history
of Christendom is not the whole history of Christendom. That
the Lateran was as cunning, foolish, and criminal as most other
contemporary courts has to be recorded; but, if we are to keep
due proportions in this history, it must not be unduly emphasized.
We must remember that through all those ages, leaving profound
consequences, but leaving no conspicuous records upon the his-
1 This period is a tangled one. The authority is Gregorovius, History of the
City of Rome in the Middle Ages (an excellent general book from A.D. 400 to 1527),
vol. iii of the Eng. trans., p. 249 seq. John X owed the tiara to his mistress, the
elder Theodora, but he was "the foremost statesman of his age" (Gregorovius,
p. 259). He fell in 928 owing to Marozia. John XI became Pope in 931 (after
two Popes had intervened in the period 928-931) ; he was Marozia's son, possibly
by Pope Sergius III. John XII did not come at once after John XI, who died
in 936 ; there were several Popes in between ; and he became Pope in 955. — E. B.
2 There were three dynasties of emperors in the early Middle Ages:
• Saxon : Otto I (962) to Henry II, ending 1024.
Salian : Conrad II to Henry V, ending about 1125.
Hohenstaufen : Conrad III to Frederic II, ending in 1250.
The Hohenstaufens were Swabian in origin. Then came the Habsburgs with
Kudolph I in 1273, who lasted until 1918.
64 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
torian's page, countless men and women were touched by that
Spirit of Jesus which still lived and lives still at the core of Chris-
tianity, that they led lives that were on the whole gracious and
helpful, and that they did unselfish and devoted deeds. Through
those ages such lives cleared the air and made a better world
possible. Just as in the Moslem world the Spirit of Islam gener-
ation by generation produced its crop of courage, integrity, and
kindliness.
§8
While the Holy Roman Empire and the kingdoms of France and
England were thus appearing amidst the extreme political frag-
mentation of the civilization of Western Europe, both that civil-
ization and the Byzantine Empire were being subjected to a three-
fold attack : from the Saracen powers, from the Northmen, and,
more slowly developed and most formidable of all, from a new west-
ward thrust of the Turkish peoples through South Russia, and
also by way of Armenia and the Empire of Bagdad from Central
Asia.
After the overthrow of the Omayyads by the Abbasid dynasty,
the strength of the Saracenic impulse against Europe diminished.
Islam was no longer united. Spain was under a separate Omayyad
Caliph, North Africa, though nominally subject to the Abbasids,
was really independent, and presently (969) Egypt became a
separate power with a Shiite Caliph of its own, a pretender claiming
descent from Ali and Fatima (the Fatimite Caliphate). These
Egyptian Fatimites, the green flag Moslems, were fanatics in
comparison with the Abbasids, and did much to embitter the
genial relations of Islam and Christianity. They took Jerusalem,
and interfered with the Christian access to the Holy Sepulchre.
On the other side of the shrunken Abbasid domain there was also a
Shiite kingdom in Persia. The chief Saracen conquest in the
ninth century was Sicily; but this was not overrun in the grand
old style in a year or so, but subjugated tediously through a long
century, and with many set-backs. The Spanish Saracens dis-
puted in Sicily with the Saracens from Africa. In Spain the Sara-
cens were giving ground before a renascent Christian effort.
Nevertheless, the Byzantine Empire and Western Christendom
CHRISTENDOM AND THE CRUSADES
65
were still so weak upon the Mediterranean Sea that the Saracen
raiders and pirates from North Africa were able to raid almost un-
challenged in South Italy and the Greek Islands.
But now a new force was appearing in the Mediterranean. We
have already remarked that the Roman Empire never extended
itself to the shores of the Baltic Sea, nor had ever the vigour to
push itself into Denmark. The Nordic Aryan peoples of these
neglected regions learnt much from the empire that was unable
66 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
to subdue them ; as we have already noted in § 4, they developed
the art of shipbuilding and became bold seamen; they spread
across the North Sea to the west, and across the Baltic and up the
Russian rivers into the very heart of what is now Russia. One of
their earliest settlements in Russia was Novgorod the Great.
There is the same trouble and confusion for the student of history
with these northern tribes as there is with the Scythians of classical
times, and with the Hunnish Turkish peoples of Eastern and Cen-
tral Asia. They appear under a great variety of names, they
change and intermingle. In the case of Britain, for example, the
Angles, the Saxons, and Jutes conquered most of what is now
England in the fifth and sixth centuries ; the Danes, a second wave
of practically the same people, followed in the eighth and ninth ;
and in 1013 a Danish King, Canute, reigned in England, and not
only over England, but over Denmark and Norway. For a time,
under Canute and his sons, it seemed possible that a great con-
federation of the Northmen might have established itself. Then
in 1066 a third wave of the same people flewed over England
from the "Norman" state in France, where the Northmen had
been settled since the days of Rolf the Ganger (912), and where
they had learnt to speak French. William, Duke of Normandy,
became the William the Conqueror (1066) of English history.
Practically, from the standpoint of universal history, all these
peoples were the same people, waves of one Nordic stock. These
waves were not only flowing westward, but eastward. Already
we have noted (chap, xxix, § 4), a very interesting earlier move-
ment of the same peoples under the name of Goths from the Baltic
to the Black Sea. We have traced the splitting of these Goths into
the Ostrogoths and the Visigoths, and the adventurous wanderings
that ended at last in the Ostrogoth kingdom in Italy and the Visigoth
states in Spain. In the ninth century a second movement of the
Northmen across Russia was going on at the same time that their
establishments in England and their dukedom of Normandy were
coming into existence. The populations of South Scotland, Eng-
land, East Ireland, Flanders, Normandy, and the Russias have
more elements in common than we are accustomed to recognize.
All are fundamentally Gothic and Nordic peoples. These "Rus-
sian" Norsemen travelled in the summer-time, using the river
CHRISTENDOM AND THE CRUSADES 67
routes that abounded in Russia ; they carried their ships by port-
ages from the northward-running rivers to those flowing southward.
They appeared as pirates, raiders, and traders both upon the
Caspian and the Black Sea. The Arabic chroniclers note their
apparition upon the Caspian, and give them the name of Russians.
They raided Persia, and threatened Constantinople with a great
fleet of small craft (in 865, 904, 941, and 1043).1 One of these
Northmen, Rurik (circa 850), established himself as the ruler of
Novgorod and Kief, and laid the foundations of modern Russia.
The fighting qualities of the Russian Vikings were speedily appre-
ciated at Constantinople ; the Greeks called them Varangians,
and an Imperial Varangian bodyguard was formed. After the
conquest of England by the Normans (1066), a number of Danes
and English were driven into exile and joined these Russian Varan-
gians, apparently finding few obstacles to intercourse in their
speech and habits.
Meanwhile the Normans from Normandy were also finding their
way into the Mediterranean from the West. They came first as
mercenaries, and later as independent invaders; and they came
mainly, not, it is to be noted, by sea, but in scattered bands by
land. They came through the Rhineland and Italy partly in tne
search for warlike employment and loot, partly as pilgrims. For
the ninth and tenth centuries saw a great development of pil-
grimage. These Normans, as they grew powerful, discovered
themselves such rapacious and vigorous robbers that they forced
the Eastern Emperor and the Pope into a feeble and ineffective
alliance against them (1053). They defeated and captured and
were pardoned by the Pope ; they established themselves in Cala-
bria and South Italy, conquered Sicily from the Saracens (1060-
1090), and under Robert Guiscard, who had entered Italy as a
pilgrim adventurer and began his career as a brigand in Calabria,
threatened the Byzantine Empire itself (1081). His army, which
contained a contingent of Sicilian Moslems, crossed from Brindisi
to Epirus in the reverse direction to that in which Pyrrhus had
crossed to attack the Roman Republic, thirteen centuries before
(275 B.C.). He laid siege to the Byzantine stronghold of Durazzo.
1 These dates are from Gibbon. Beazley gives 865, 904-7, 935, 944, 971-2.
(History of Russia, Clarendon Press.)
68
THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
CHRISTENDOM AND THE CRUSADES 69
Robert captured Durazzo (1082), but the pressure of affairs
in Italy recalled him, and ultimately put an end to this first Nor-
man attack upon the Empire of Byzantium leaving the way open
for the rule of a comparatively vigorous Comnenian dynasty (1081-
1204). In Italy, amidst conflicts too complex for us to tell here,
it fell to Robert Guiscard to besiege and sack Rome (1084) ; and
Gibbon notes with quiet satisfaction the presence of a large
contingent of Sicilian Moslems amongst the looters. There were
in the twelfth century three other Norman attacks upon the
Eastern power, one by the son of Robert Guiscard, and the two
others directly from Sicily by sea. . . .
But neither the Saracens nor the Normans pounded quite so
heavily against the old empire at Byzantium or against the Holy
Roman Empire, the vamped-up Roman Empire of the West,
as did the double thrust from the Turanian centres in Central
Asia, of which we must now tell. We have already noted (chap,
xxix, § 5) the westward movement of the Avars, and the Turkish
Magyars who followed in their track. From the days of Pepin I
onward, the Frankish power and its successors in Germany were
in conflict with these Eastern raiders along all the Eastern border-
lands. Charlemagne held and punished them, and established
some sort of overlordship as far east as the Carpathians; but
amidst the enfeeblement that followed his death, these peoples,
more or less blended now in the accounts under the name of Hun-
garians, led by the Magyars, re-established their complete free-
dom^ again, and raided yearly, often as far as the Rhine. They
destroyed, Gibbon notes, the monastery of St. Gall in Switzer-
land, and the town of Bremen. Their great raiding period was
between 900 and 950. Their biggest effort, through Germany
right into France, thence over the Alps and home again by North
Italy, was in 938-9.
Thrust southward by these disturbances, and by others to be
presently noted, the Bulgarians, as we have told in § 5, established
themselves under Krum, between the Danube and Constantinople.
Originally a Turkish people, the Bulgarians, since their first ap-
pearance in the east of Russia, had become by repeated admixture
almost entirely Slavonic in race and language. For some time
after their establishment in Bulgaria they remained pagan. Their
70
THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
king, Boris (852-884), entertained Moslem envoys, and seems to
have contemplated an adhesion to Islam, but finally he married a
Byzantine princess, and handed himself and .his people over to
the Christian faith.
The Hungarians were drubbed into a certain respect for civil-
ization by Henry the Fowler, the elected King of Germany, and
Otto the First, the first Saxon emperor, in the tenth century.
But they did not decide to adopt Christianity until about A.D.
1000. Though they were Christianized, they retained their own
Turko-Finnic language (Magyar), and they retain it to this day.
Bulgarians and Hungarians do not, however, exhaust the
catalogue of the peoples whose westward movements embodied
the Turkish thrust across South Russia. Behind the Hungarians
and Bulgarians thrust the Khazars, a Turkish people, with whom
were mingled a very considerable proportion of Jews who had been
expelled from Constantinople, and who had mixed with them and
CHRISTENDOM AND THE CRUSADES 71
made many proselytes. To these Jewish Khazars are to be
ascribed the great settlements of Jews in Poland and Russia.1
Behind the Khazars again, and overrunning them, were the
Petschenegs (or Patzinaks), a savage Turkish people who are
first heard of in the ninth century, and who were destined to
dissolve and vanish as the kindred Huns did five centuries before.
And while the trend of all these peoples was westward, we have,
when we are thinking of the present population of these South
Russian regions, to remember also the coming and going of the
Northmen between the Baltic and the Black Sea, who interwove
with the Turkish migrants like warp and woof, and bear in mind
also that there was a considerable Slavonic population, the heirs
and descendants of Scythians, Sarmatians, and the like, already
established in these restless, lawless, but fertile areas. All these
races mixed with and reacted upon one another. The universal
prevalence of Slavonic languages, except in Hungary, shows that
the population remained predominantly Slav. And in what is
now Roumania, for all the passage of peoples, and in spite of
conquest after conquest, the tradition and inheritance of the
Roman provinces of Dacia and Moesia Inferior still kept a Latin
speech and memory alive.
But this direct thrust of the Turkish peoples against Christen-
dom to the north of the Black Sea was, in the end, not nearly so
important as their indirect thrust south of it through the empire
of the Caliph. We cannot deal here with the tribes and dissen-
sions of the Turkish peoples of Turkestan, nor with the particular
causes that brought to the fore the tribes under the rule of the
Seljuk clan. In the eleventh century these Seljuk Turks broke
with irresistible force not in one army, but in a group of armies,
and under two brothers, into the decaying fragments of the
Moslem Empire. For Islam had long ceased to be one empire.
The orthodox Sunnite Abbasid rule had shrunken to what was
once Babylonia; and even in Bagdad the Caliph was the mere
creature of his Turkish palace guards. A sort of mayor of the
palace, a Turk, was the real ruler. East of the Caliph, in Persia,
and west of him in Palestine, Syria, and Egypt, were Shiite here-
tics. The Seljuk Turks were orthodox Sunnites ; they now swept
1 " A Turkish people whose leaders had adopted Judaism," says Harold Williams.
72 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
down upon and conquered the Shiite rulers and upstarts, and
established themselves as the protectors of the Bagdad Caliph,
taking over the temporal powers of the mayor of the palace. Very
early they conquered Armenia from the Greeks, and then, break-
ing the bounds that had restrained the power of Islam for four
centuries, they swept on to the conquest of Asia Minor, almost
to the gates of Constantinople. The mountain barrier of Cilicia
that had held the Moslem so long had been turned by the con-
quest of Armenia from the northeast. Under Alp Arslan, who had
united all the Seljuk power in his own hands, the Turks utterly
smashed the Byzantine army at the battle of Manzikert, or
Melasgird (1071). The effect of this battle upon people's imagi-
nations was very great. Islam, which had appeared far gone in
decay, which had been divided religiously and politically, was sud-
denly discovered to have risen again, and it was the secure old
Byzantine Empire that seemed on the brink of dissolution. The
loss of Asia Minor was very swift. The Seljuks established them-
selves at Iconium (Konia), in what is now Anatolia. In a little
while they were in possession of the fortress of Nicsea over against
the capital.
§9
We have already told of the attack of the Normans upon the
Byzantine Empire from the west, and of the battle of Durazzo
(1081) ; and we have noted that Constantinople had still vivid
memories of the Russian sea raids (1043). Bulgaria, it is true, had
been tamed, but there was heavy and uncertain warfare going
on with the Petschenegs. North and west, the emperor's hands
were full. This swift advance of the Turks into country that
had been so long securely Byzantine must have seemed like the
approach of final disaster. The Eastern Emperor, Michael VII,
under the pressure of these convergent dangers, took a step that
probably seemed both to himself and to Rome of the utmost
political significance. He appealed to the Pope, Gregory VII,
for assistance. His appeal was repeated still more urgently by
his successor, Alexius Comnenus, to Pope Urban II.
To the counsellors of Rome this must have presented itself as a
supreme opportunity for the assertion of the headship of the Pope
over the entire Christian world.
CHRISTENDOM AND THE CRUSADES 73
In this history we have traced the growth of this idea of a
religious government of Christendom — and through Christendom
of mankind — and we have shown how naturally and how neces-
sarily, because of the tradition of world empire, it found a centre
at Rome. The Pope of Rome was the only Western patriarch;
he was the religious head of a vast region in which the ruling tongue
was Latin; the other patriarchs of the Orthodox Church spoke
Greek, and so were inaudible throughout his domains; and the
two words Filioque, which had been added to the Latin creed' (see
chap, xxx, § 8, and chap, xxxiii, § 6), had split off the Byzantine Chris-
tians by one of those impalpable and elusive doctrinal points upon
which there is no reconciliation. (The final rupture was in 1054.)
The life of the Lateran changed in its quality with every occupant
of the chair of St. Peter : sometimes papal Rome was a den of
corruption and uncleanness, as it had been in the days of John
XII ; sometimes it was pervaded by the influence of widely think-
ing and nobly thinking men. But behind the Pope was the
assembly of the cardinals, priests, and a great number of highly
educated officials, who never, even in the darkest and wildest
days, lost sight altogether of the very grand idea of a divine world
dominion, of a peace of Christ throughout the earth that St.
Augustine had expressed. Through all the Middle Ages that idea
was the guiding influence in Rome. For a time, perhaps, mean
minds would prevail there, and in the affairs of the world Rome
would play the part of a greedy, treacherous, and insanely cunning
old woman; followed a phase of masculine and quite worldly
astuteness perhaps, or a phase of exaltation. Came an interlude
of fanaticism or pedantry, when all the pressure was upon exact
doctrine. Or there was a moral collapse, and the Lateran became
the throne of some sensuous or aesthetic autocrat, ready to sell
every hope or honour the Church could give for money to spend
upon pleasure or display. Yet, on the whole, the papal ship kept
its course, and came presently into the wind again.
In this period to which we have now come, the period of the
eleventh century, we discover a Rome dominated by the personal-
ity of an exceptionally great statesman, Hildebrand, who occupied
various official positions under a succession of Popes, and finally
became Pope himself under the name of Gregory VII (1073-1085).
74 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
We find that under his influence, vice, sloth, and corruption have
been swept out of the Church, that the method of electing the
Popes has been reformed, and that a great struggle has been waged
with the Emperor upon the manifestly vital question of "investi-
tures," the question whether Pope or temporal monarch should
have the decisive voice in the appointment of the bishops in their
domains. Hitherto the Roman clergy had been able to marry;
but now, to detach them effectually from the world and to make
them more completely the instruments of the church, celibacy
was imposed upon all priests. . . .*
Gregory VII had been prevented by his struggle over the in-
vestitures from any effectual answer to the first appeal from Byzan-
tium ; but he had left a worthy successor in Urban II (1087-1099) ;
and when the letter of Alexius came to hand, Urban seized at
once upon the opportunity it afforded for drawing together all the
thoughts and forces of Western Europe into one passion and pur-
pose. Thereby he might hope to end the private warfare that
prevailed, and find a proper outlet for the immense energy of the
Normans. He saw, too, an opportunity of thrusting the Byzantine
power and Church aside, and extending the influence of the Latin
Church over Syria, Palestine, and Egypt. The envoys of Alexius
were heard at a church council, hastily summoned at Piacenza
( = Placentia), and next year (1095), at Clermont, Urban held a
second great council, in which all the slowly gathered strength of
the Church was organized for a universal war propaganda against
the Moslems. Private war, all war among Christians, was to
cease until the infidel had been swept back and the site of the
Holy Sepulchre was again in Christian hands.
The fervour of the response enables us to understand the great
work of creative organization that had been done in Western
Europe in the previous five centuries. In the beginning of the
seventh century we saw Western Europe as a chaos of social and
political fragments, with no common idea nor hope, a system
shattered almost to a dust of self-seeking individuals. Now in
the dawn of the eleventh century there is everywhere a common
belief, a linking idea, to which men may devote themselves, and by
which they can co-operate together in a universal enterprise. We
1 For the development of the papacy, see H. W. C. Davis, Mediceval Europe.
CHRISTENDOM AND THE CRUSADES 75
realize that, in spite of much weakness and intellectual and moral
unsoundness, to this extent the Christian Church has worked.
We are able to measure the evil phases of tenth-century Rome, the
scandals, the filthiness, the murders and violence, at their proper
value by the scale of this fact. No doubt also all over Christendom
there had been many lazy, evil, and foolish priests; but it is
manifest that this task of teaching and co-ordination that had
been accomplished could have been accomplished only through a
great multitude of right-living priests and monks and nuns.
A new and greater amphictyony, the amphictyony of Christendom,
had come into the world, and it had been built by thousands of
anonymous, faithful lives.
And this response to the appeal of Urban the Second was not
confined only to what we should call educated people. It was
not simply knights and princes who were willing to go upon this
crusade. Side by side with the figure of Urban we must put the
figure of Peter the Hermit, a type novel to Europe, albeit a little
reminiscent of the Hebrew prophets. This man appeared preach-
ing the crusade to the common people. He told a story — whether
truthful or untruthful hardly matters in this connection — of his
pilgrimage to Jerusalem, of the wanton destruction at the Holy
Sepulchre by the Seljuk Turks, who took it in 1073, and of the
exactions, brutalities, and deliberate cruelties practised upon the
Christian pilgrims to the Holy Places. Barefooted, clad in a
coarse garment, riding on an ass, and bearing a huge cross, this
man travelled about France and Germany, and everywhere har-
angued vast crowds in church or street or market-place.
Here for the first time we discover Europe with an idea and a
soul ! Here is a universal response of indignation of the story of a
remote wrong, a swift understanding of a common cause for
rich and poor alike. You cannot imagine this thing happening
in the Empire of Augustus Caesar, or indeed in any previous state
in the world's history. Something of the kind might perhaps have
been possible in the far smaller world of Hellas, or in Arabia before
Islam. But this movement affected nations, kingdoms, tongues,
and peoples. It is clear that we are dealing with something new
that has come into the world, a new clear connection of the
common interest with the consciousness of the common man.
76 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
§10
From the very first this flaming enthusiasm was mixed with
baser elements. There was the cold and calculated scheme of the
free and ambitious Latin Church to subdue and replace the
emperor-ruled Byzantine Church; there was the freebooting
instinct of the Normans, who were tearing Italy to pieces, which
turned readily enough to a new and richer world of plunder ; and
there was something in the multitude who now turned their faces
east, something deeper than love in the human composition,
namely, fear-born hate, that the impassioned appeals of the propa-
gandists and the exaggeration of the horrors and cruelties of the
infidel had fanned into flame. And there were still other forces ;
the intolerant Seljuks and the intolerant Fatimites lay now an im-
passable barrier across the eastward trade of Genoa and Venice
that had hitherto flowed through Bagdad and Aleppo, or through
Egypt. They must force open these closed channels, unless
Constantinople and the Black Sea route were to monopolize
Eastern trade altogether. Moreover, in 1094 and 1095 there had
been a pestilence and famine from the Scheldt to Bohemia, and
there was great social disorganization. "No wonder," says Mr.
Ernest Barker, "that a stream of emigration set towards the
East, such as would in modern times flow towards a newly dis-
covered goldfield — a stream carrying in its turbid waters much
refuse, tramps and bankrupts, camp-followers and hucksters,
fugitive monks and escaped villeins, and marked by the same
motley grouping, the same fever of life, the same alternations of
affluence and beggary, which mark the rush for a goldfield to-day."
But these were secondary contributory causes. The fact of
predominant interest to the historian of mankind is this will to
crusade suddenly revealed as a new mass possibility in human
affairs.
The story of the crusades abounds in such romantic and pic-
turesque detail that the writer of an Outline of History must ride
his pen upon the curb through this alluring field. The first forces
to move eastward were great crowds of undisciplined people
rather than armies, and they sought to make their way by the
valley of the Danube, and thence southward to Constantinople.
CHRISTENDOM AND THE CRUSADES
77
This was the "people's crusade." Never before in the whole
history of the world had there been such a spectacle as these
masses of practically leaderless people moved by an idea. It was
a very crude idea. When they got among foreigners, they do not
seem to have realized that they were not already among the in-
fidel. Two great mobs, the advance guard of the expedition,
iStaias set up by the
Crusaders . .
Eastern .Empire . .
Sdjuks
Route, of Crusaders
committed such excesses in Hungary, where the language must
have been incomprehensible to them, as to provoke tbs Hun-
garians to destroy them. They were massacred. A tb i hnst
began with a great pogrom of the Jews in the Rhineland — rjr th?
Christian blood was up — and this multitude was also dispersed In
Hungary. Two other hosts under Peter got through and reached
Constantinople, to the astonishment and dismay of the Emperor
Alexius. They looted and committed outrages as they came,
78 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
and at last he shipped them across the Bosphorus, to be massacred
rather than defeated by the Seljuks (1096).
This first unhappy appearance of the " people" as people in
modern European history was followed in 1097 by the organized
forces of the First Crusade. They came by diverse routes from
France, Normandy, Flanders, England, Southern Italy, and Sicily,
and the will and power of them were the Normans. They crossed
the Bosphorus and captured Nicsea, which Alexius snatched away
from them before they could loot it. They then went on by much
the same route as Alexander the Great, through the Cilician Gates,
leaving the Turks in Konia unconquered, past the battle-fields of
the Issus, and so to Antioch, which they took after nearly a year's
siege. Then they defeated a great relieving army from Mosul.
A large part of the Crusaders remained in Antioch, a smaller
force under Godfrey of Bouillon (in Belgium) went on to Jeru-
salem. " After a little more than a month's siege, the city was
finally captured (July 15). The slaughter was terrible ; the blood
of the conquered ran down the streets, until men splashed in
blood as they rode. At nightfall, 'sobbing for excess of joy/ the
crusaders came to the Sepulchre from their treading of the wine-
press, and put their blood-stained hands together in prayer.
So, on that day of July, the First Crusade came to an end." l
The authority of the Patriarch of Jerusalem was at once seized
upon by the Latin clergy with the expedition, and the Orthodox
Christians found themselves in rather a worse case under Latin rule
than under the Turk. There were already Latin principalities
established at Antioch and Edessa, and there began a struggle for
ascendancy between these various courts and kings, and an un-
successful attempt to make Jerusalem a property of the Pope.
These are complications beyond our present scope.
Let us quote, however, a characteristic passage from Gibbon : —
"In a style less grave than that of history, I should perhaps
compare the Emperor Alexius to the jackal, who is said to follow
the steps and to devour the leavings of the lion. Whatever had
been his fears and toils in the passage of the First Crusade, they
were amply recompensed by the subsequent benefits which he
derived from the exploits of the Franks. His dexterity and
JE. Barker, art, "Crusades," Encyclopaedia Britannica.
CHRISTENDOM AND THE CRUSADES 79
vigilance secured their first conquest of Nicsea, and from this
threatening station the Turks were compelled to evacuate the
neighbourhood of Constantinople. While the Crusaders, with
blind valour, advanced into the midland countries of Asia, the
crafty Greek improved the favourable occasion when the emirs of
the sea coast were recalled to the standard of the Sultan. The
Turks were driven from the isles of Rhodes and Chios ; the cities
of Ephesus and Smyrna, of Sardes, Philadelphia, and Laodicea
were restored to the empire, which Alexius enlarged from the Helles-
pont to the banks of the Mseander and the rocky shores of Pam-
phylia. The churches resumed their splendour; the towns were
rebuilt and fortified; and the desert country was peopled with
colonies of Christians, who were gently removed from the more
distant and dangerous frontier. In these paternal cares we may
forgive Alexius, if we forget the deliverance of the Holy Sepulchre ;
but, by the Latins, he was stigmatized with the foul reproach of
treason and desertion. They had sworn fidelity and obedience to
his throne; but he had promised to assist their enterprise in
person, or at least, with his troops and treasures ; his base retreat
dissolved their obligations; and the sword, which had been the
instrument of their victory, was the pledge and title of their just
independence. It does not appear that the emperor attempted to
revive his obsolete claims over the kingdom of Jerusalem, but the
borders of Cilicia and Syria were more recent in his possession and
more accessible to his arms. The great army of the Crusaders
was annihilated or dispersed ; the principality of Antioch was left
without a head, by the surprise and captivity of Bohemond;
his ransom had oppressed him with a heavy debt ; and his Nor-
man followers were insufficient to repel the hostilities of the Greeks
and Turks. In this distress, Bohemond embraced a magnanimous
resolution, of leaving the defence of Antioch to his kinsman, the
faithful Tancred; of arming the West against the Byzantine
Empire, and of executing the design which he inherited from the
lessons and example of his father Guiscard. His embarkation was
clandestine ; and if we may credit a tale of the Princess Anna, he
passed the hostile sea closely secreted in a coffin. (Anna Comnena
adds, that to complete the imitation, he was shut up with a dead
cock ; and condescends to wonder how the barbarian could endure
80 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
the confinement and putrefaction. This absurd tale is unknown
to the Latins.) But his reception in France was dignified by the
public applause and his marriage with the king's daughter; his
return was glorious, since the bravest spirits of the age enlisted
under his veteran command ; and he repassed the Adriatic at the
head of five thousand horse and forty thousand foot, assembled
from the most remote climates of Europe. The strength of
Durazzo and prudence of Alexius, the progress of famine and
approach of winter, eluded his ambitious hopes; and the venal
confederates were seduced from his standard. A treaty of peace
suspended the fears of the Greeks."
We have dealt thus lengthily with the First Crusade, because
it displays completely the quality of all these expeditions. The
reality of the struggle between the Latin and the Byzantine system
became more and more nakedly apparent. In 1101 came rein-
forcements, in which the fleet of the mercantile republics of
Venice and Genoa played a prominent part, and the power of the
kingdom of Jerusalem was extended. The year 1147 saw a Second
Crusade, in which both the Emperor Conrad III and King Louis
of France participated. It was a much more stately and far less
successful and enthusiastic expedition than its predecessor. It
had been provoked by the fall of Edessa to the Moslems in 1144.
One large division of Germans, instead of going to the Holy Land,
attacked and subjugated the still pagan Wends east of the Elbe.
This, the Pope agreed, counted as crusading, and so did the cap-
ture of Lisbon, and the foundation of the Christian kingdom of
Portugal by the Flemish and English contingents.
In 1169 a Kurdish adventurer, named Saladin, became ruler of
Egypt, in which country the Shiite heresy had now fallen before a
Sunnite revival. This Saladin reunited the efforts of Egypt and
Bagdad, and preached a Jehad, a Holy War, a counter-crusade,
of all the Moslems against the Christians. This Jehad excited
almost as much feeling in Islam as the First Crusade had done in
Christendom. It was now a case of crusader against crusader;
and in 1187 Jerusalem was retaken. This provoked the Third
Crusade (1189). This also was a grand affair, planned jointly by
the Emperor Frederick I( known better as Frederick Barbarossa),
the King of France, and the King of England (who at that time
CHRISTENDOM AND THE CRUSADES 81
owned many of the fairest French provinces). The papacy played
a secondary part in this expedition ; it was in one of its phases of
enfeeblement ; and the crusade was the most courtly, chivalrous,
and romantic of all. Religious bitterness was mitigated by the
idea of knightly gallantry, which obsessed both Saladin and
Richard I (1189-1199) of England (Cceur-de-Lion), and the lover
of romance may very well turn to the romances about this period
for its flavour. The crusade saved the principality of Antioch for
a time, but failed to retake Jerusalem. The Christians, however,
remained in possession of the seacoast of Palestine.
By the time of the Third Crusade, the magic and wonder had
gone out of these movements altogether. The common people
had found them out. Men went, but only kings and nobles
straggled back; and that often only after heavy taxation for a
ransom. The idea of the crusades was cheapened by their too
frequent and trivial use. Whenever the Pope quarrelled with
anyone now, he called for a crusade, until the word ceased to mean
anything but an attempt to give flavour to an unpalatable civil
war. There was a crusade against the heretics in the south of
France, one against John (King of England), one against the
Emperor Frederick II. The Popes did not understand the necessity
of dignity to the papacy. They had achieved a moral ascendancy
in Christendom. Forthwith they began to fritter it away. They
not only cheapened the idea of the crusades, but they made their
tremendous power of excommunication, of putting people outside
all the sacraments, hopes, and comforts of religion, ridiculous by
using it in mere disputes of policy. Frederick II was not only
crusaded against, but excommunicated — without visible injury.
He was excommunicated again in 1239, and a third time in 1245.1
The bulk of the Fourth Crusade never reached the Holy Land
at all. It started from Venice (1202), captured Zara, encamped
at Constantinople (1203), and finally, in 1204, stormed the city.
It was frankly a combined attack on the Byzantine Empire. Venice
took much of the coasts and islands of the empire, and a Latin,
Baldwin of Flanders, was set up as emperor in Constantinople.
The Latin and Greek Churches were declared to be reunited, and
1 Technically only twice, the excommunication of 1245 was a renewal by Inno-
cent IV of that of 1239. — E. B.
Q
82 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
Latin emperors ruled as conquerors in Constantinople from 1204 to
1261.
In 1212 occurred a dreadful thing, a children's crusade. An
excitement that could no longer affect sane adults was spread
among the children in the south of France and in the Rhone Valley.
A crowd of many thousands of French boys marched to Marseilles ;
they were then lured on board ship by slave traders, who sold them
into slavery in Egypt. The Rhineland children tramped into
Italy, many perishing by the way, and there dispersed. Pope
Innocent III made great capital out of this strange business.
"The very children put us to shame," he said; and sought to
whip up enthusiasm for a Fifth Crusade. This crusade aimed at
the conquest of Egypt, because Jerusalem was now held by the
Egyptian Sultan; its remnants returned in 1221, after an in-
glorious evacuation of its one capture, Damietta, with the Jeru-
salem vestiges of the True Cross as a sort of consolation concession
on the part of the victor. We have already noted the earlier
adventures of this venerable relic before the days of Muhammad
in chap, xxxi, § 2, when it was carried off by Chosroes II to Ctesi-
phon, and recovered by the Emperor Heraclius. Fragments of
the True Cross, however, had always been in Rome at the church
of S. Croce-in-Gerusalemme, since the days of the Empress Helena
(the mother of Constantine the Great) to whom, says the legend,
its hiding-place had been revealed in a vision during her pilgrimage
to the Holy Land.1
The Sixth Crusade (1229) was a crusade bordering upon absurd-
ity. The Emperor Frederick II had promised to go upon a cru-
sade, and evaded his vow. He had made a false start and returned.
He was probably bored by the mere idea of a crusade. But
the vow had been part of the bargain by which he secured the
support of Pope Innocent III in his election as emperor. He
1 "The custody of the True Cross, which on Easter Sunday was solemnly exposed
to the people, was entrusted to the Bishop of Jerusalem ; and he alone might
gratify the curious devotion of the pilgrims, by the gift of small pieces, which they
encased in gold or gems, and carried away in triumph to their respective countries.
But, as this gainful branch of commerce must soon have been annihilated, it was
found convenient to suppose that the marvellous wood possessed a secret power
of vegetation, and that its substance, though continually diminished, still remained
entire and unimpaired." — Gibbon.
CHRISTENDOM AND THE CRUSADES 83
busied himself in reorganizing the government of his Sicilian
kingdom, though he had given the Pope to understand that he
would relinquish these possessions if he became emperor; and
the Pope was anxious to stop this process of consolidation by
sending him to the Holy Land. The Pope did not want Frederick
II, or any German emperor at all in Italy, because he himself
wished to rule Italy. As Frederick II remained evasive, Gregory
IX excommunicated him, proclaimed a crusade against him, and
invaded his dominions in Italy (1228). Whereupon the Emperor
sailed with an army to the Holy Land. There he had a meeting
with the Sultan of Egypt (the Emperor spoke six languages freely,
including Arabic) ; and it would seem these two gentlemen,
both of sceptical opinions, exchanged views of a congenial sort,
discussed the Pope in a worldly spirit, debated the Mongolian
rush westward, which threatened them both alike, and agreed
finally to a commercial convention, and the surrender of a part
of the kingdom of Jerusalem to Frederick. This indeed was a
new sort of crusade, a crusade by private treaty. As this astonish-
ing crusader had been excommunicated, he had to indulge in a
purely secular coronation in Jerusalem, taking the crown from the
altar with his own hand, in a church from which all the clergy
had gone. Probably there was no one to show him the Holy
Places ; indeed these were presently all put under an interdict by
the Patriarch of Jerusalem and locked up ; manifestly the affair
differed altogether in spirit from the red onslaught of the First
Crusade. It had not even the kindly sociability of the Caliph
Omar's visit six hundred years before. Frederick II rode out of
Jerusalem almost alone, returned from this unromantic success
to Italy, put his affairs there in order very rapidly, chased the
papal armies out of his possessions, and obliged the Pope to give
him absolution from his excommunication (1230). This Sixth
Crusade was indeed not only the reductio ad absurdum of crusades,
but of papal excommunications. Of this Frederick II we shall
tell more in a later section, because he was very typical of certain
new forces that were coming into European affairs.
The Christians lost Jerusalem again in 1244 ; it was taken from
them very, easily by the Sultan of Egypt when they attempted
an intrigue against him. This provoked the Seventh Crusade,
84 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
the Crusade of St. Louis, King of France (Louis IX), who was
taken prisoner in Egypt and ransomed in 1250. Not until 1918,
when it fell to a mixed force of French, British, and Indian troops,
did Jerusalem slip once more from the Moslem grasp. . . .
One more crusade remains to be noted, an expedition to Tunis
by this same Louis IX, who died of fever there.
§11
The essential interest of the crusades for the historian of man-
kind lies in the wave of emotion, of unifying feeling, that animated
the first. Thereafter these expeditions became more and more an
established process, and less and less vital events. The First
Crusade was an occurrence like the discovery of America; the
later ones were more and more like a trip across the Atlantic. In
the eleventh century, the idea of the crusade must have been
like a strange and wonderful light in the sky; in the thirteenth
one can imagine honest burghers saying in tones of protest,
" What ! another crusade !" The experience of St. Louis in Egypt
is not like a fresh experience for mankind ; it is much more like
a round of golf over some well-known links, a round that was
dogged by misfortune. It is an insignificant series of events.
The interest of life had shifted to other directions.
The beginning of the crusades displays all Europe saturated by
a naive Christianity, and ready to follow the leading of the Pope
trustfully and simply. The scandals of the Lateran during its
evil days, with which we are all so familiar now, were practically un-
known outside Rome. And Gregory VII and Urban II had re-
deemed all that. But intellectually and morally their successors at
the Lateran and the Vatican l were not equal to their opportunities.
The strength of the papacy lay in the faith men had in it, and it
used that faith so carelessly as to enfeeble it. Rome has always
had too much of the shrewdness of the priest and too little of the
power of the prophet. So that while the eleventh century was a
century of ignorant and confiding men, the thirteenth was an age
1 The Popes inhabited the palace of the Lateran until 1305, when a French Pope
set up the papal court at Avignon. When the Pope returned to Rome in 1377 the
Lateran was almost in ruins, and the palace of the Vatican became the seat of the
papal court. It was, among other advantages, much nearer to the papal strong-
hold, the Castle of San Angelo.
CHRISTENDOM AND THE CRUSADES 85
of knowing and disillusioned men. It was a far more civilized
and profoundly sceptical world.
The bishops, priests, and the monastic institutions of Latin
Christendom before the days of Gregory VII had been perhaps
rather loosely linked together and very variable in quality; but
it is clear that they were, as a rule, intensely intimate with the
people among whom they found themselves, and with much of
the spirit of Jesus still alive in them ; they were trusted, and they
had enormous power within the conscience of their followers. The
church, in comparison with its later state, was more in the hands
of local laymen and thelocal ruler ; it lacked its later universality.
The energetic bracing up of the church organization by Gregory
VII, which was designed to increase the central power of Rome,
broke many subtle filaments between priest and monastery on the
one hand, and the country-side about them on the other. Men
of faith and wisdom believe in growth and their fellow men ; but
priests, even such priests as Gregory VII, believe in the false
" efficiency" of an imposed discipline. The squabble over in-
vestitures made every prince in Christendom suspicious of the
bishops as agents of a foreign power ; this suspicion filtered down
to the parishes. The political enterprises of the papacy necessi-
tated an increasing demand for money. Already in the thirteenth
century it was being said everywhere that the priests were not
good men, that they were always hunting for money.
In the days of ignorance there had been an extraordinary willing-
ness to believe the Catholic priesthood good and wise. Relatively
it was better and wiser in those days. Great powers beyond her
spiritual functions had been entrusted to the church, and very
extraordinary freedoms. Of this confidence the fullest advantage
had been taken. In the Middle Ages the church had become a
state within the state. It had its own law courts. Cases in-
volving not merely priests, but monks, students, crusaders, widows,
orphans, and the helpless, were reserved for the clerical courts;
and whenever the rites or rules of the church were involved, there
the church claimed jurisdiction over such matters as wills, mar-
riages, oaths, and of course over heresy, sorcery, and blasphemy.
There were numerous clerical prisons in which offenders might
pine all their lives. The Pope was the supreme law-giver of
86 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
Christendom, and his court at Rome the final and decisive court
of appeal. And the church levied taxes; it had not only vast
properties and a great income from fees, but it imposed a tax
of a tenth, the tithe, upon its subjects. It did not call for
this as a pious benefaction; it demanded it as a right. The
clergy, on the other hand, were now claiming exemption from lay
taxation.
This attempt to trade upon their peculiar prestige and evade
their share in fiscal burdens was certainly one very considerable
factor in the growing dissatisfaction with the clergy. Apart from
any question of justice, it was impolitic. It made taxes seem ten
times more burthensome to those who had to pay. It made
everyone feel the immunities of the church. And a still more
extravagant and unwise claim made by the church was the claim
to the power of dispensation. The Pope might in many instances
set aside the laws of the church in individual cases ; he might allow
cousins to marry, permit a man to have two wives, or release
anyone from a vow. But to do such things is to admit that the
laws affected are not based upon necessity and an inherent
righteousness; that they are in fact restrictive and vexatious.
The law-giver, of all beings, most owes the law allegiance. He of
all men should behave as though the law compelled him. But
it is the universal weakness of mankind that what we are given to
administer we presently imagine we own.
§12
The Emperor Frederick II is a very convenient example of the
sort of doubter and rebel the thirteenth century could produce.
It may be interesting to tell a little of this intelligent and cynical
man. He was the son of the German Emperor, Henry VI, and
grandson of Frederick Barbarossa, and his mother was the daughter
of Roger I, the Norman King of Sicily. He inherited this kingdom
in 1198, when he was four years old ; his mother was his guardian
for six months, and when she died, Pope Innocent III (1198 to
1216) became regent and guardian. He seems to have had an
exceptionally good and remarkably mixed education, and his
accomplishments earned him the flattering title of Stupor mundi,
the amazement of the world. The result of getting an Arabic
CHRISTENDOM AND THE CRUSADES 87
view of Christianity, and a Christian view of Islam, was to make
him believe that all religions were impostures, a view held perhaps
by many a stifled observer in the Age of Faith. But he talked
about his views; his blasphemies and heresies are on record.
Growing up under the arrogant rule of Innocent III, who never
seems to have realized that his ward had come of age, he developed
a slightly humorous evasiveness. It was the papal policy to
prevent any fresh coalescence of the power of Germany and Italy,
and it was equally Frederick's determination to get whatever he
could. When presently opportunity offered him the imperial
crown of Germany, he secured the Pope's support by agreeing, if
he were elected, to relinquish his possessions in Sicily and South
Italy, and to put down heresy in Germany. For Innocent III
was one of the great persecuting Popes, an able, grasping, and
aggressive man. (For a Pope, he was exceptionally young. He
became Pope at thirty-seven.) It was Innocent who had preached
a cruel crusade against the heretics in the south of France, a
crusade that presently became a looting expedition beyond his
control. So soon as Frederick was elected emperor (121 1),1
Innocent pressed for the performance of the vows and promises
he had wrung from his dutiful ward. The clergy were to be freed
from lay jurisdiction and from taxation, and exemplary cruelties
were to be practised upon the heretics. None of which things
Frederick did. As we have already told, he would not even relin-
quish Sicily. He liked Sicily as a place of residence better than
he liked Germany.
Innocent III died baffled in 1216, and his successor, Honorius
III, effected nothing. Honorius was succeeded by Gregory IX
(1227), who evidently came to the papal throne with a nervous
resolution to master this perplexing young man. He excommuni-
cated him at once for failing to start upon his crusade, which was
now twelve years overdue ; and he denounced his vices, heresies,
and general offences in a public letter (1227). To this Frederick
replied in a far abler document addressed to all the princes of
Europe, a document of extreme importance in history, because it
is the first clear statement of the issue between the pretensions of
the Pope to be absolute ruler of all Christendom, and the claims of
1 He was crowned emperor in 1220 by Honorius III, the successor of Innocent.
88 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
the secular rulers.1 This conflict had always been smouldering;
it had broken out here in one form, and there in another ; but now
Frederick put it in clear general terms upon which men could
combine together.
Having delivered this blow, he departed upon the pacific crusade
of which we have already told. In 1239, Gregory IX was ex-
communicating him for a second time, and renewing that warfare
of public abuse in which the papacy had already suffered severely.
The controversy was revived after Gregory IX was dead, when
Innocent IV was Pope; and again a devastating letter, which
men were bound to remember, was written by Frederick against
the church. He denounced the pride and irreligion of the clergy,
and ascribed all the corruptions of the time to their pride and
wealth. He proposed to his fellow princes a general confiscation
of church property — for the good of the church. It was a
suggestion that never afterwards left the imagination of the Euro-
pean princes.
We will not go on to tell of his last years or of the disaster at
Parma, due to his carelessness, which cast a shadow of failure over
his end. The particular events of his life are far less significant
than its general atmosphere. It is possible to piece together some-
thing of his court life in Sicily. He is described towards the end
of his life as "red, bald, and short-sighted"; but his features
were good and pleasing. He was luxurious in his way of living,
and fond of beautiful things. He is described as licentious. But
it is clear that his mind was not satisfied by religious scepticism,
and that he was a man of very effectual curiosity and inquiry.
He gathered Jewish and Moslem as well as Christian philosophers
at his court, and he did much to irrigate the Italian mind with
Saracenic influences. Through him Arabic numerals and algebra
were introduced to Christian students, and among other philoso-
phers at his court was Michael Scott, who translated portions of
Aristotle and the commentaries thereon of the great Arab philoso-
pher Averroes (of Cordoba). In 1224 Frederick founded the
University of Naples, and he enlarged and enriched the great
medical school at Salerno University, the most ancient of uni-
1 Some authorities deny his authorship of this letter. See A. L. Smith's Church
and State in the Middle Ages.
CHRISTENDOM AND THE CRUSADES 89
versities. He also founded a zoological garden. He left a book
on hawking, which shows him to have been an acute observer
of the habits of birds, and he was one of the first Italians to write
Italian verse. Italian poetry was indeed born at his court. He
has been called by an able writer, "the first of the moderns,"
and the phrase expresses aptly the unprejudiced detachment of
his intellectual side. His was an all-round originality. During a
gold shortage he introduced and made a success of a coinage of
stamped leather, bearing his promise to pay in gold, a sort of
leather bank-note issue.1
In spite of the torrent of abuse and calumny in which Frederick
was drenched, he left a profound impression upon the popular
imagination. He is still remembered in South Italy almost as
vividly as is Napoleon I by the peasants of France ; he is the " Gran
Federigo." And German scholars declare 2 that, in spite of Fred-
erick's manifest dislike for Germany, it is he, and not Frederick
I, Frederick Barbarossa, to whom that German legend originally
attached — that legend which represents a great monarch slumber-
ing in a deep cavern, his beard grown round a stone table, against
a day of awakening when the world will be restored by him from
an extremity of disorder to peace. Afterwards, it seems, the
story was transferred to the Crusader Barbarossa, the grand-
father of Frederick II.
A difficult child was Frederick II for Mother Church, and he
was only the precursor of many such difficult children. The
princes and educated gentlemen throughout Europe read his
letters and discussed them. The more enterprising university
students found, marked, and digested the Arabic Aristotle he had
made accessible to them in Latin. Salerno cast a baleful light
upon Rome. All sorts of men must have been impressed by the
futility of the excommunications and interdicts that were levelled
at Frederick.
1 Perhaps parchment rather than leather. Such promises on parchment were
also used by the Carthaginians. Was Frederick's money an inheritance from an
old tradition living on in Sicily since Carthaginian times ? — E. B.
2 Encyclopaedia Britannica, art. "Frederick II."
90 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
§13*
We have said that Innocent III never seemed to realize that his
ward, Frederick II, was growing up. It is equally true that the
papacy never seemed to realize that Europe was growing up. It is
impossible for an intelligent modern student of history not to
sympathize with the underlying idea of the papal court, with the
idea of one universal rule of righteousness keeping the peace of
the earth, and not to recognize the many elements of nobility that
entered into the Lateran policy. Sooner or later mankind must
come to one universal peace, unless our race is to be destroyed by
the increasing power of its own destructive inventions ; and that
universal peace must needs take the form of a government, that
is to say a law-sustaining organization, in the best sense of the
word religious; a government ruling men through the educated
co-ordination of their minds in a common conception of human
history and human destiny.
The papacy we must now recognize as the first clearly con-
scious attempt to provide such a government in the world. We
cannot too earnestly examine its deficiencies and inadequacies,
for every lesson we can draw from them is necessarily of the
greatest value to us in forming our ideas of our own international
relationships. We have tried to suggest the main factors in the
breakdown of the Roman Republic, and it now behoves us to
attempt a diagnosis of the failure of the Roman Church to secure
and organize the good will of mankind.
The first thing that will strike the student is the intermittence
of the efforts of the church to establish the world City of God.
The policy of the church was not whole-heartedly and continuously
set upon that end. It was only now and then that some fine
personality or some group of fine personalities dominated it in
that direction. The kingdom of God that Jesus of Nazareth
had preached was overlaid, as we have explained, almost from
the beginning by the doctrines and ceremonial traditions of an
earlier age, and of an intellectually inferior type. Christianity
almost from its commencement ceased to be purely prophetic
1 In relation to this section, see the chapter on the "Unity of the Middle Ages"
in F. S. Marvin's Unity of Western Civilization.
CHRISTENDOM AND THE CRUSADES 91
and creative. It entangled itself with archaic traditions of human
sacrifice, with Mithraic blood-cleansing, with priestcraft as
ancient as human society, and with elaborate doctrines about the
structure of the divinity. The gory forefinger of the Etruscan
pontif ex maximus emphasized the teachings of Jesus of Nazareth ;
the mental complexity of the Alexandrian Greek entangled them.
In the inevitable jangle of these incompatibles the church had
become dogmatic. In despair of other solutions to its intellectual
discords it had resorted to arbitrary authority. Its priests and
bishops were more and more men moulded to creeds and dogmas
and set procedures ; by the time they became cardinals or popes
they were usually oldish men, habituated to a politic struggle for
immediate ends and no longer capable of world-wide views. They
no longer wanted to see the Kingdom of God established in the
hearts of men — they had forgotten about that ; they wanted to
see the power of the church, which was their own power, dominat-
ing men. They were prepared to bargain even with the hates and
fears and lusts in men's hearts to ensure that power. And it was
just because many of them probably doubted secretly of the entire
soundness of their vast and elaborate doctrinal fabric, that they
would brook no discussion of it. They were intolerant of ques-
tions or dissent, not because they were sure of their faith, but be-
cause they were not. They wanted conformity for reasons of
policy. By the thirteenth century the church was evidently al-
ready morbidly anxious about the gnawing doubts that might
presently lay the whole structure of its pretensions in ruins. It
had no serenity of soul. It was hunting everywhere for heretics
as timid old ladies are said to look under beds and in cupboards
for burglars before retiring for the night.
We have already mentioned (chap, xxxi, § 5) the Persian Mani
who was crucified and flayed in the year 277. His way of represent-
ing the struggle between good and evil was as a struggle between a
power of light which was, as it were, in rebellion against a power of
darkness inherent in the universe. All these profound mysteries
are necessarily represented by symbols and poetic expressions, and
the ideas of Mani still find a response in many intellectual tempera-
ments to-day. One may hear Manichsean doctrines from many
Christian pulpits. But the orthodox Catholic symbol was a dif-
92 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
ferent one. These Manichsean ideas had spread very widely in
Europe, and particularly in Bulgaria and the south of France. In
the south of France the people who held them were called the
Cathars or Albigenses. Their ideas jarred so little with the essentials
of Christianity that they believed themselves to be devout Chris-
tians. As a body they lived lives of conspicuous virtue and purity
in a violent, undisciplined, and vicious age. But they questioned
the doctrinal soundness of Rome and the orthodox interpretation
of the Bible. They thought Jesus was a rebel against the cruelty
of the God of the Old Testament, and not his harmonious son.
Closely associated with the Albigenses were the Waldenses, the
followers of a man called Waldo, who seems to have been quite
soundly Catholic in his theology, but equally offensive to the
church because he denounced the riches and luxury of the clergy.
This was enough for the Lateran, and so we have the spectacle of
Innocent III preaching a crusade against these unfortunate
sectaries, and permitting the enlistment of every wandering
scoundrel at loose ends to carry fire and sword and rape and every
conceivable outrage among the most peaceful subjects of the
King of France. The accounts of the cruelties and abominations
of this crusade are far more terrible to read than any account of
Christian martyrdoms by the pagans, and they have the added
horror of being indisputably true.
This black and pitiless intolerance was an evil spirit to be mixed
into the project of a rule of God on earth. This was a spirit en-
tirely counter to that of Jesus of Nazareth. We do not hear of
his smacking the faces or wringing the wrists of recalcitrant or un-
responsive disciples. But the Popes during their centuries of
power were always raging against the slightest reflection upon the
intellectual sufficiency of the church.
And the intolerance of the church was not confined to religious
matters. The shrewd, pompous, irascible, and rather malignant
old men who manifestly constituted a dominant majority in the
councils of the church, resented any knowledge but their own know-
ledge, and distrusted any thought at all that they did not correct
and control. They set themselves to restrain science, of which
they were evidently jealous. Any mental activity but their own
struck them as being insolent. Later on they were to have a
CHRISTENDOM AND THE CRUSADES 93
great struggle upon the question of the earth's position in space,
and whether it moved round the sun or not. This was really not
the business of the church at all. She might very well have left
to reason the things that are reason's, but she seems to have been
impelled by an inner necessity to estrange the intellectual con-
science in men.
Had this intolerance sprung from a real intensity of conviction
it would have been bad enough, but it was accompanied by a
scarcely disguised contempt for the intelligence and mental dig-
nity of the common man that makes it far less acceptable to our
modern judgments, and which no doubt made it far less acceptable
to the free spirits of the time. We have told quite dispassionately
the policy of the Roman church towards her troubled sister in the
East. Many of the tools and expedients she used were abominable.
In her treatment of her own people a streak of real cynicism is
visible. She destroyed her prestige by disregarding her own teach-
ing of righteousness. Of dispensations we have already spoken
(§ 11). Her crowning folly in the sixteenth century was the sale
of indulgences, whereby the sufferings of the soul in purgatory
could be commuted for a money payment. But the spirit that
led at last to this shameless and, as it proved, disastrous pro-
ceeding, was already very evident in the twelfth and thirteenth
centuries.
Long before the seed of criticism that Frederick II had sown had
germinated in men's minds and produced its inevitable crop of
rebellion, there was apparent a strong feeling in Christendom that
all was not well with the spiritual atmosphere. There began
movements, movements that nowadays we should call " revivalist,"
within the church, that implied rather than uttered a criticism of
the sufficiency of her existing methods and organization. Men
sought fresh forms of righteous living outside the monasteries and
priesthood. One notable figure is that of St. Francis of Assisi
(1181-1226). We cannot tell here in any detail of how this
pleasant young gentleman gave up all the amenities and ease of
his life and went forth to seek God ; the opening of the story is
not unlike the early experiences of Gautama Buddha. He had a
sudden conversion in the midst of a life of pleasure, and, taking a
vow of extreme poverty, he gave himself up to an imitation of the
94 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
life of Christ, and to the service of the sick and wretched, and more
particularly to the service of the lepers, who then abounded in
Italy. He was joined by great multitudes of disciples, and so the
first Friars of the Franciscan Order came into existence. An order
of women devotees was set up beside the original confraternity,
and in addition great numbers of men and women were brought
into less formal association. He preached, unmolested by the
Moslems, be it noted, in Egypt and Palestine, though the Fifth
Crusade was then in progress. His relations with the church
are still a matter for discussion.1 His work had been sanctioned by
Pope Innocent III, but while he was in the East there was a
reconstitution of his order, intensifying its discipline and sub-
stituting authority for responsive impulse, and as a consequence of
these changes he resigned its headship. To the end he clung
passionately to the ideal of poverty, but he was hardly dead before
the order was holding property through trustees and building a
great church and monastery to his memory at Assisi. The dis-
ciplines of the order that were applied after his death to his imme-
diate associates are scarcely to be distinguished from a persecu-
tion ; several of the more conspicuous zealots for simplicity were
scourged, others were imprisoned, one was killed while attempting
to escape, and Brother Bernard, the " first disciple," passed a
year in the woods and hills, hunted like a wild beast.
This struggle within the Franciscan Order is a very interesting
one, because it foreshadows the great troubles that were coming
to Christendom. All through the thirteenth century a section
of the Franciscans were straining at the rule of the church, and
in 1318 four of them were burnt alive at Marseilles as incorrigible
heretics. There seems to have been little difference between
the teaching and spirit of St. Francis and that of Waldo in the
twelfth century, the founder of the murdered sect of Waldenses.
Both were passionately enthusiastic for the spirit of Jesus of
Nazareth. But while Waldo rebelled against the church, St.
Francis did his best to be a good child of the church, and his
comment on the spirit of official Christianity was only implicit.
But both were instances of an outbreak of conscience against
authority and the ordinary procedure of the church. And it is
1 See Paul Sabatier's Vie de S. Francois d'Assise (English trans, by Houghton).
CHRISTENDOM AND THE CRUSADES 95
plain that in the second instance, as in the first, the church scented
rebellion.
A very different character to St. Francis was the Spaniard St.
Dominic (1170-1221), who was, of all things, orthodox. He had
a passion for the argumentative conversion of heretics, and he was
commissioned by Pope Innocent III to go and preach to the
Albigenses. His work went on side by side with the fighting and
massacres of the crusade; whom Dominic could not convert,
Innocent's crusader slew ; yet his very activities and the recogni-
tion and encouragement of his order by the Pope witness to the
rising tide of discussion, and to the persuasion even of the papacy
that force was no remedy. In several respects the development
of the Black Friars or Dominicans — the Franciscans were the
Grey Friars — shows the Roman church at the parting of the ways,
committing itself more and more deeply to organized dogma, and
so to a hopeless conflict with the quickening intelligence and cour-
age of mankind. She whose one duty was to lead, chose to compel.
The last discourse of St. Dominic to the heretics he had sought
to convert is preserved to us. It is a signpost in history. It
betrays the fatal exasperation of a man who has lost his faith in
the power of truth because his truth has not prevailed. "For
many years/' he said, "I have exhorted you in vain, with gentle-
ness, preaching, praying, and weeping. But according to the
proverb of my country, ' where blessing can accomplish nothing,
blows may avail/ We shall rouse against you princes and prel-
ates, who, alas ! will arm nations and kingdoms against this
land . . . and thus blows will avail where blessings and gentle-
ness have been powerless." l
The thirteenth century saw the development of a new institution
in the church, the papal Inquisition. Before this time it had been
customary for the Pope to make occasional inquests or inquiries
into heresy in this region or that, but now Innocent III saw in
the new order of the Dominicans a powerful instrument of sup-
pression. The Inquisition was organized as a standing inquiry
under their direction, and with fire and torment the church set
itself, through this instrument, to assail and weaken the human
conscience in which its sole hope of world dominion resided.
1 Encyclopedia Britannica, art. "Dominic."
96 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
Before the thirteenth century the penalty of death had been in-
flicted but rarely upon heretics and unbelievers. Now in a hundred
market-places in Europe the dignitaries of the church watched the
blackened bodies of its antagonists, for the most part poor and
insignificant people, burn and sink pitifully, and their own great
mission to mankind burn and sink with them into dust and ashes.
The beginnings of the Franciscans and the Dominicans were
but two among many of the new forces that were arising in
Christendom, either to help or shatter the church, as its own
wisdom might decide. Those two orders the church did assimilate
and use, though with a little violence in the case of the former.
But other forces were more frankly disobedient and critical. A
century and a half later came Wy cliff e (132Q-13S4). He was a
learned doctor at Oxford; for a time he was Master of Balliol;
and he held various livings in the church. Quite late in his life
he began a series of outspoken criticisms of the corruption of the
clergy and the unwisdom of the church. He organized a number
of poor priests, the Wycliffites, to spread his ideas throughout
England; and in order that people should judge between the
church and himself, he translated the Bible into English. He was
a more learned and far abler man than either St. Francis or St.
Dominic. He had supporters in high places and a great following
among the people; and though Rome raged against him, and
ordered his imprisonment, he died a free man, still administering
the Sacraments as parish priest of Lutterworth. But the black
and ancient spirit that was leading the Catholic church to its
destruction would not let his bones rest in his grave. By a decree
of the Council of Constance in 1415, his remains were ordered to
be dug up and burnt, an order which was carried out at the com-
mand of Pope Martin V by Bishop Fleming in 1428. This desecra-
tion was not the act of some isolated fanatic; it was the official
act of the church.
§14
The history of the papacy is confusing to the general reader
because of the multitude and abundance of the Popes. They
mostly began to reign as old men, and their reigns were short,
averaging less than two years each. But certain of the Popes
CHRISTENDOM AND THE CRUSADES 97
stand out and supply convenient handles for the student to grasp.
Such were Gregory I (590-604) the Great, the first monkish Pope,
the friend of Benedict, the sender of the English mission. Other
noteworthy Popes are Leo III (795-816), who crowned Charle-
magne, the scandalous Popes John XI (931-936) and John XII
(955-963), which latter was deposed by the Emperor Otto I,
and the great Hildebrand, who ended his days as Pope Gregory
VII (1073-1085), and who did so much by establishing the celi-
bacy of the clergy, and insisting upon the supremacy of the 'church
over kings and princes, to centralize the power of the church in
Rome. The next Pope but one after Gregory VII was Urban II
(1087-1099), the Pope of the First Crusade. The period from the
time of Gregory VII onward for a century and a half, was the
great period of ambition and effort for the church. There was a
real sustained attempt to unite all Christendom under a purified
and reorganized church.
The setting up of Latin kingdoms in Syria and the Holy Land,
in religious communion with Rome, after the First Crusade, marked
the opening stage of a conquest of Eastern Christianity by Rome
that reached its climax during the Latin rule in Constantinople
(1204-1261).
In 1176, at Venice, the Emperor Frederick Barbarossa (Frederick
I) knelt to the Pope Alexander III, recognized his spiritual suprem-
acy, and swore fealty to him. But after the death of Alexander
III, in 1181, the peculiar weakness of the papacy, its liability
to fall to old and enfeebled men, became manifest. Five Popes
tottered to the Lateran to die within the space of ten years.
Only with Innocent III (1198-1216) did another vigorous Pope
take up the great policy of the City of God.
Under Innocent III, the guardian of that Emperor Frederick
II, whose career we have already studied in §§ 10 and 12, and the
five Popes who followed him, the Pope of Rome came nearer to
being the monarch of a united Christendom than he had ever
been before, and was ever to be again. The empire was weakened
by internal dissensions, Constantinople was in Latin hands, from
Bulgaria to Ireland and from Norway to Sicily and Jerusalem the
Pope was supreme. Yet this supremacy was more apparent than
real. For, as we have seen, while in the time of Urban the power
H
98 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
of faith was strong in all Christian Europe, in the time of Innocent
III the papacy had lost its hold upon the hearts of princes, and the
faith and conscience of the common people was turning against a
merely political and aggressive church.
The church in the thirteenth century was extending its legal
power in the world, and losing its grip upon men's consciences.
It was becoming less persuasive and more violent. No intelligent
man can tell of this process or read of this process of failure with-
out very mingled feelings. The church had sheltered and formed
a new Europe throughout the long ages of European darkness and
chaos ; it had been the matrix in which the new civilization had
been cast. But this new-formed civilization was impelled to grow
by its own inherent vitality, and the church lacked sufficient power
of growth and accommodation. The time was fast approaching
when this matrix was to be broken.
The first striking intimation of the decay of the living and sus-
taining forces of the papacy appeared when presently the Popes
came into conflict with the growing power of the French king.
During the lifetime of the Emperor Frederick II, Germany fell
into disunion, and the French king began to play the role of
guard, supporter, and rival to the Pope that had hitherto fallen
to the Hohenstaufen emperors. A series of Popes pursued the
policy of supporting the French monarchs. French princes were
established in the kingdom of Sicily and Naples, with the support
and approval of Rome, and the French kings saw before them the
possibility of restoring and ruling the Empire of Charlemagne.
When, however, the German interregnum after the death of
Frederick II, the last of the Hohenstaufens, came to an end and
Rudolf of Habsburg was elected first Habsburg Emperor (1273),
the policy of the Lateran began to fluctuate between France and
Germany, veering about with the sympathies of each successive
Pope. In the East in 1261 the Greeks recaptured Constantinople
from the Latin emperors, and the founder of the new Greek dy-
nasty, Michael Palseologus, Michael VIII, after some unreal
tentatives of reconciliation with the Pope, broke away from the
Roman communion altogether, and with that, and the fall of the
Latin kingdoms in Asia, the eastward ascendancy of the Popes
came to an end.
CHRISTENDOM AND THE CRUSADES 99
In 1294 Boniface VIII became Pope. He was an Italian, hostile
to the French, and full of a sense of the great traditions and mission
of Rome. For a time he carried things with a high hand. In
1300 he held a jubilee, and a vast multitude of pilgrims assembled
in Rome. "So great was the influx of money into the papal
treasury, that two assistants were kept busy with rakes collecting
the offerings that were deposited at the tomb of St. Peter." l
But this festival was a delusive triumph. It is easier to raise a
host of excursionists than a band of crusaders. Boniface came
into conflict with the French king in 1302, and in 1303, as he was
about to pronounce sentence of excommunication against that
monarch, he was surprised and arrested in his own ancestral
palace, at Anagni, by Guillaume de Nogaret. This agent from
the French king forced an entrance into the palace, made his way
into the bedroom of the frightened Pope — he was lying in bed
with a cross in his hands — and heaped threats and insults upon
him. The Pope was liberated -a day or so later by the townspeople,
and returned to Rome ; but there he was seized upon and again
made prisoner by the Orsini family, and in a few weeks' time the
shocked and disillusioned old man died a prisoner in their hands.
The people of Anagni did resent the first outrage, and rose
against Nogaret to liberate Boniface, but then Anagni was the
Pope's native town. The important point to note is that the
French king, in this rough treatment of the head of Christendom,
was acting with the full approval of his people ; he had summoned
a council of the Three Estates of France (lords, church, and
commons) and gained their consent before proceeding to extrem-
ities. Neither in Italy, Germany, nor England was there the
slightest general manifestation of disapproval at this free handling
of the sovereign pontiff. The idea of Christendom had decayed
until its power over the minds of men had gone.
Throughout the fourteenth century the papacy did nothing to
recover its moral sway. The next Pope elected, Clement. .V, was
a Frenchman, the choice of King Philip of France. He never
came to Rome. He set up his court in the town of Avignon, which
then belonged not to France, but to the Papal See, though em-
bedded in French territory, and there his successors remained
1 J. H. Robinson.
100 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
until 1377, when Pope Gregory XI returned to the Vatican palace
in Rome. But Gregory XI did not take the sympathies of the
whole church with him. Many of the cardinals were of French
origin, and their habits and associations were rooted deep at Avi-
gnon. When in 1378 Gregory XI died, and an Italian, Urban VI,
was elected, these dissentient cardinals declared the election in-
valid, and elected another Pope, the anti-Pope, Clement VII.
This split is called the Great Schism. The Popes remained in
Rome, and all the anti-French powers, the Emperor, the King of
England, Hungary, Poland, and the North of Europe were loyal
to them. The anti-Popes, on the other hand, continued in Avi-
gnon, and were supported by the King of France, his ally the King
of Scotland, Spain, Portugal, and various German princes. Each
Pope excommunicated and cursed the adherents of his rival,
so that by one standard or another all Christendom was damned
during this time (1378-1417). The lamentable effect of this
split upon the solidarity of Christendom it is impossible to exag-
gerate. Is it any marvel that such men as Wycliffe began to teach
men to think on their own account when the fountain of truth
thus squirted against itself ? In 1417 the Great Schism was healed
at the Council of Constance, the same council that dug up and
burnt Wycliffe's bones, and which, as we shall tell later, caused
the burning of John Huss; at this council, Pope and anti-Pope
resigned or were swept aside, and Martin V became the sole Pope
of a formally reunited but spiritually very badly strained Christen-
dom.
How later on the Council of Basle (1437) led to a fresh schism,
and to further anti-Popes, we cannot relate here.
Such, briefly, is the story of the great centuries of papal ascend-
ancy and papal decline. It is the story of the failure to achieve
the very noble and splendid idea of a unified and religious world.
We have pointed out in the previous section how greatly the
inheritance of a complex dogmatic theology encumbered the
church in this its ambitious adventure. It had too much theology,
and not enough religion. But it may not be idle to point out
here how much the individual insufficiency of the Popes also con-
tributed to the collapse of its scheme and dignity. There was no
such level of education in the world as to provide a succession of
CHRISTENDOM AND THE CRUSADES 101
cardinals and popes with the breadth of knowledge and outlook
needed for the task they had undertaken; they were not suffi-
ciently educated for their task, and only a few, by sheer force of
genius, transcended that defect. And, as we have already pointed
out, they were, when at last they got to power, too old to use it.
Before they could grasp the situation they had to control, most
of them were dead. It would be interesting to speculate how far
it would have tilted the balance in favour of the church if the
cardinals had retired at fifty, and if no one could have been elected
Pope after fifty-five. This would have lengthened the average
reign of each Pope, and enormously increased the continuity of
the policy of the church. And it is perhaps possible that a more
perfect system of selecting the cardinals, who were the electors
and counsellors of the Pope, might have been devised. The rules
and ways by which men reach power are of very great importance
in human affairs. The psychology of the ruler is a science that
has still to be properly studied. We have seen the Roman Republic
wrecked, and here we see the church failing in its world mission
very largely through ineffective electoral methods.
BOOK VII
THE MONGOL EMPIRES OF THE LAND WAYS AND
THE NEW EMPIRES OF THE SEA WAYS
XXXIV
THE GREAT EMPIRE OF JENGIS KHAN AND HIS
SUCCESSORS
(THE AGE OP THE LAND WAYS)
§ 1. Asia at the end of the Twelfth Century. § 2. The Rise and
Victories of the Mongols. § 3. The Travels of Marco Polo.
§ 4. The Ottoman Turks and Constantinople. § 5. Why the
Mongols were not Christianized. § 5 A. Kublai Khan founds the
Yuan Dynasty. § SB. The Mongols Revert to Tribalism. § 5c.
The Kipchak Empire and the Tsar of Muscovy. § 5 D . Timurlane.
§ 5E. The Mongol Empire of India. § 5r. The Mongols and
the Gipsies.
§1
WE have to tell now of the last and greatest of all the raids
of nomadism upon the civilizations of the East and West.
We have traced in this history the development side by side of
these two ways of living, and we have pointed out that as the
civilizations grew more extensive and better organized, the arms,
the mobility, and the intelligence of the nomads also improved.
The nomad was not simply an uncivilized man, he was a man
specialized and specializing along his own line. From the very
beginning of history the nomad and the settled people have been
in reaction. We have told of the Semitic and Elamite raids
upon Sumeria ; we have seen the Western empire smashed by the
nomads of the great plains and Persia conquered and Byzantium
shaken by the nomads of Arabia. Whenever civilization seems
to be choking amidst its weeds of wealth and debt and servitude,
when its faiths seem rotting into cynicism and its powers of further
growth are hopelessly entangled in effete formulae, the nomad drives
in like a plough to break up the festering stagnation and release the
105
106 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
world to new beginnings. The Mongol aggression, which began
with the thirteenth century, was the greatest, and so far it has
been the last, of all these destructive reploughings of human
association.
From entire obscurity the Mongols came very suddenly into
history towards the close of the twelfth century. They appeared
in the country to the north of China, in the land of origin of the
Huns and Turks, and they were manifestly of the same strain as
these peoples. They were gathered together under a chief, with
whose name we will not tax the memory of the reader ; under his
son Jengis Khan their power grew with extraordinary swiftness.
The reader will already have an idea of the gradual breaking
up of the original unity of Islam. In the beginning of the thir-
teenth century there were a number of separate and discordant
Moslem states in Western Asia. There was Egypt (with Palestine
and much of Syria) under the successors of Saladin, there was the
Seljuk power in Asia Minor, there was still an Abbasid caliphate
in Bagdad, and to the east of this again there had grown up a very
considerable empire, the Kharismian empire, that of the Turkish
princes from Khiva who had conquered a number of fragmentary
Seljuk principalities and reigned from the Ganges Valley to the
Tigris. They had but an insecure hold on the Persian and Indian
populations.
The state of the Chinese civilization was equally inviting to an
enterprising invader. O^e last glimpse of China in this history
was in the seventh century during the opening years of the Tang
dynasty, when that shrewd and able emperor Tai-tsung was
weighing the respective merits of Nestorian Christianity, Islam,
Buddhism, and the teachings of Lao Tse, and on the whole inclining
to the opinion that Lao Tse was as good a teacher as any. We
have described his reception of the traveller Yuan Chwang.
Tai-tsung tolerated all religions, but several of his successors con-
ducted a pitiless persecution of the Buddhist faith ; it flourished
in spite of these persecutions, and its monasteries played a some-
what analogous part in at first sustaining learning and afterwards
retarding it, that the Christian monastic organization did in the
West. By the tenth century the great Tang dynasty was in an
• extreme state of decay ; the usual degenerative process through a
108 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
series of voluptuaries and incapables had gone on, and China
broke up again politically into a variable number of contending
states, "The age of the Ten States," an age of confusion that lasted
through the first half of the tenth century. Then arose a dynasty,
the Northern Sung (960-1127), which established a sort of unity,
but which was in constant struggle with a number of Hunnish
peoples from the north who were pressing down the eastern coast.
For a time one of these peoples, the Khitan, prevailed. In the
twelfth century these people had been subjugated and had given
place to another Hunnish empire, the empire of the Kin, with its
capital at Pekin and its southern boundary south of Hwangho.
The Sung empire shrank before this Kin empire. In 1138 the
capital was shifted from Nankin, which was now too close to the
northern frontier, to the city of Han Chau on the coast. From
1127 onward to 1295, the Sung dynasty is known as the Southern
Sung. To the northwest of its territories there was now the
Tartar empire of the Hsia; to the north, the Kin empire, both
states in which the Chinese population was under rulers in whom
nomadic traditions were still strong. So that here on the east
also the main masses of Asiatic mankind were under uncongenial
rulers and ready to accept, if not to welcome, the arrival of a
conqueror.
Northern India we have already noted was also a conquered
country at the opening of the thirteenth century. It was at first
a part of the Khivan empire, but in 1206 an adventurous ruler,
Kutub, who had been a slave and who had risen as a slave to be
governor of the Indian province, set up a separate Moslem state
of Hindustan in Delhi. Brahminism had long since ousted Bud-
dhism from India, but the converts to Islam were still but a small
ruling minority in the land.
Such was the political state of Asia when Jengis Khan began to
consolidate his power among the nomads in the country between
Lakes Balkash and Baikal in the beginning of the thirteenth
century.
§2
The career of conquest of Jengis Khan and his immediate
successors astounded the world, and probably astounded no one
more than these Mongol Khans themselves.
JENGIS KHAN AND HIS SUCCESSORS 109
The Mongols were in the twelfth century a tribe subject to those
Kin who had conquered Northeast China. They were a horde
of nomadic horsemen living in tents, and subsisting mainly upon
mare's milk products and meat. Their occupations were pas-
turage and hunting, varied by war. They drifted northward as
the snows melted for summer pasture, and southward to winter
pasture after the custom of the steppes. Their military education
began with a successful insurrection against the Kin. The empire
of Kin had the resources of half China behind it, and in the
struggle the Mongols learnt very much of the military science of
the Chinese. By the end of the twelfth century they were already
a fighting tribe of exceptional quality.
The opening years of the career of Jengis were spent in develop-
ing his military machine, in assimilating the Mongols and the
associated tribes about them into one organized army. His first
considerable extension of power was westward, when the Tartar
Kirghis and the Uigurs (who were the Tartar people of the Tarim
basin) were not so much conquered as induced to join his organ-
ization. He then attacked the Kin empire and took Pekin (1214).
The Khitan people, who had been so recently subdued by the Kin,
threw in their fortunes with his, and were of very great help
to him. The settled Chinese population went on sowing and reap-
ing and trading during this change of masters without lending its
weight to either side.
We have already mentioned the very recent Kharismian empire
of Turkestan, Persia, and North India. This empire extended
eastward to Kashgar, and it must have seemed one of the most
progressive and hopeful empires of the time. Jengis Khan, while
still engaged in this war with the Kin empire, sent envoys
to Kharismia. They were put to death, an almost incredible
stupidity. The Kharismian government, to use the political
jargon of to-day, had decided not to " recognize" Jengis Khan,
and took this spirited course with him. Thereupon (1218) the
great host of horsemen that Jengis Khan had consolidated and
disciplined swept over the Pamirs and down into Turkestan. It
was well armed, and probably it had some guns and gunpowder
for siege work — for the Chinese were certainly using gunpowder
at this time, and the Mongols learnt its use from them. Kashgar,
110 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
Khokand, Bokhara fell and then Samarkand, the capital of the
Kharismian empire. Thereafter nothing held the Mongols in
the Kharismian territories. They swept westward to the Caspian,
and southward as far as Lahore. To the north of the Caspian a
Mongol army encountered a Russian force from Kieff. There
was a series of battles, in which the Russian armies were finally
defeated and the Grand Duke of Kieff taken prisoner. So it was
the Mongols appeared on the northern shores of the Black Sea.
A panic swept Constantinople, which set itself to reconstruct its
fortifications. Meanwhile other armies were engaged in the con-
quest of the empire of the Hsia in China. This was annexed,
and only the southern part of the Kin empire remained unsubdued.
In 1227 Jengis Khan died in the midst of a career of triumph.
His empire reached already from the Pacific to the Dnieper. And
it was an empire still vigorously expanding.
Like all the empires founded by nomads, it was, to begin with,
purely a military and administrative empire, a framework rather
than a rule. It centred on the personality of the monarch, and
its relations with the mass of the populations over which it ruled
was simply one of taxation for the maintenance of the horde.
But Jengis Khan had called to his aid a very able and experienced
administrator of the Kin empire, who was learned in all the
traditions and science of the Chinese. This statesman, Yeliu
Chutsai, was able to carry on the affairs of the Mongols long after
the death of Jengis Khan, and there can be little doubt that he is
one of the great political heroes of history. He tempered the
barbaric ferocity of his masters, and saved innumerable cities and
works of art from destruction. He collected archives and inscrip-
tions, and when he was accused of corruption, his sole wealth
was found to consist of documents and a few musical instruments.
To him perhaps quite as much as to Jengis is the efficiency of the
Mongol military machine to be ascribed. Under Jengis, we may
note further, we find the completest religious toleration established
across the entire breadth of Asia.
At the death of Jengis the capital of the new empire was still in
the great barbaric town of Karakorum in Mongolia. There an
assembly of Mongol leaders elected Ogdai Khan, the son of Jengis,
as his successor. The war against the vestiges of the Kin empire
JENGIS KHAN AND HIS SUCCESSORS
111
112 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
was prosecuted until Kin was altogether subdued (1234). The
Chinese empire to the south under the Sung dynasty helped the
Mongols in this task, so destroying their own bulwark against the
universal conquerors. The Mongol hosts then swept right across
Asia to Russia (1235), an amazing march. Kieff was destroyed
in 1240, and nearly all Russia became tributary to the Mongols.
Poland was ravaged, and a mixed army of Poles and Germans was
annihilated at the battle of Liegnitz in Lower Silesia in 1241.
The Emperor Frederick II does not seem to have made any great
efforts to stay the advancing tide.
"It is only recently," says Bury, in his notes to Gibbon's Decline
and Fall of the Roman Empire, "that European history has begun
to understand that the successes of the Mongol army which
overran Poland and occupied Hungary in the spring of A.D. 1241
were won by consummate strategy and were not due to a mere
overwhelming superiority of numbers. But this fact has not yet
become a matter of common knowledge ; the vulgar opinion which
represents the Tartars as a wild horde carrying all before them
solely by their multitude, and galloping through Eastern Europe
without a ^strategic plan, rushing at all obstacles and overcoming
them by mere weight, still prevails. . . .
"It was wonderful how punctually and effectually the arrange-
ments of the commander were carried out in operations extending
from the Lower Vistula to Transylvania. Such a campaign was
quite beyond the power of any European army of the time, and it
was beyond the vision of any European commander. There
was no general in Europe, from Frederick II downward, who was
not a tyro in strategy compared to Subutai. It should also be
noticed that the Mongols embarked upon the enterprise with full
knowledge of the political situation of Hungary and the condition
of Poland — they had taken care to inform themselves by a well-
organized system of spies; on the other hand, the Hungarians
and Christian powers, like childish barbarians, knew hardly any-
thing about their enemies."
But though the Mongols were victorious at Liegnitz, they did
not continue their drive westward. They were getting into wood-
lands and hilly country, which did not suit their tactics ; and so
they turned southward and prepared to settle in Hungary, massa-
JENGIS KHAN AND HIS SUCCESSORS 113
cring or assimilating the kindred Magyar, even as these had
previously massacred and assimilated the mixed Scythians and
Avars and Huns before them. From the Hungarian plain they
would probably have made raids west and south as the Hungarians
had done in the ninth century, the Avars in the seventh and eighth,
and the Huns in the fifth. But in Asia the Mongols were fighting
a stiff war of conquest against the Sung, and they were also
raiding Persia and Asia Minor ; Ogdai died suddenly, and in 1242
there was trouble about the succession, and recalled by this, the
undefeated hosts of Mongols began to pour back across Hungary
and Rumania towards the east.
To the great relief of Europe the dynastic troubles at Karakorum
lasted for some years, and this vast new empire showed signs of
splitting up. Mangu Khan became the Great Khan in 1251, and
he nominated his brother Kublai Khan as Governor-General of
China. Slowly but surely the entire Sung empire was subjugated,
and as it was subjugated the eastern Mongols became more and
more Chinese in their culture and methods. Tibet was invaded
and devastated by Mangu, and Persia and Syria invaded in good
earnest. Another brother of Mangu, Hulagu, was in command of
this latter war. He turned his arms against the caliphate and
captured Bagdad, in which city he perpetrated a massacre of the
entire population. Bagdad was still the religious capital of
Islam, and the Mongols had become bitterly hostile to the Moslems.
This hostility exacerbated the natural discord of nomad and towns-
man. In 1259 Mangu died, and in 1260 — for it took the
best part of a year for the Mongol leaders to gather from the
extremities of this vast empire, from Hungary and Syria and Scind
and China — Kublai was elected Great Khan. He was already
deeply interested in Chinese affairs; he made his capital Pekin
instead of Karakorum, and Persia, Syria, and Asia Minor became
virtually independent under his brother Hulagu, while the hordes
of Mongols in Russia and Asia next to Russia, and various smaller
Mongol groups in Turkestan became also practically separate.
Kublai died in 1294, and with his death even the titular supremacy
of the Great Khan disappeared.
At the death of Kublai there was a main Mongol empire, with
Pekin as its capital, including all China and Mongolia ; there was
114 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
a second great Mongol empire, that of Kipchak in Russia ; there
was a third in Persia, that founded by Hulagu, the Ilkhan empire,
to which the Seljuk Turks in Asia Minor were tributary; there
was a Siberian state between Kipchak and Mongolia ; and another
separate state " Great Turkey" in Turkestan. It is particularly
remarkable that India beyond the Punjab was never invaded by
the Mongols during this period, and that an army under the
Sultan of Egypt completely defeated Ketboga, Hulagu's general,
in Palestine (1260), and stopped them from entering Africa. By
1260 the impulse of Mongol conquest had already passed its
zenith. Thereafter the Mongol story is one of division and decay.
The Mongol dynasty that Kublai Khan had founded in China,
the Yuan dynasty, lasted from 1280 until 1368. Later on a recru-
descence of Mongolian energy in Western Asia was destined to
create a still more enduring monarchy in India.
§3
Now this story of Mongolian conquests is surely the most
remarkable in all history. The conquests of Alexander the
Great cannot compare with them in extent. And their effect in
diffusing and broadening men's ideas, though such things are
more difficult to estimate, is at least comparable to the spread of
the Hellenic civilization which is associated with Alexander's
adventure. For a time all Asia and Western Europe enjoyed an
open intercourse ; all the roads were temporarily open, and repre-
sentatives of every nation appeared at the court of Karakorum.
The barriers between Europe and Asia set up by the religious feud
of Christianity and Islam were lowered. Great hopes were enter-
tained by the papacy for the conversion of the Mongols to Chris-
tianity. Their only religion so far had been Shamanism, a
primitive paganism. Envoys of the Pope, Buddhist priests from
India, Parisian and Italian and Chinese artificers, Byzantine and
Armenian merchants, mingled with Arab officials and Persian
and Indian astronomers and mathematicians at the Mongol
court. We hear too much in history of the campaigns and
massacres of the Mongols, and not enough of their indubitable
curiosity and zest for learning. Not perhaps as an originative
people, but as transmitters of knowledge and method their in-
JENGIS KHAN AND HIS SUCCESSORS
115
J#*
ZM -^*i vJ
116 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
fluence upon the world's history has been enormous. And every-
thing one can learn of the vague and romantic personalities of
Jengis or Kublai tends to confirm the impression that these men
were built upon a larger scale, and were at least as understanding
and creative monarchs as either that flamboyant but egotistical
figure Alexander the Great, or that raiser of political ghosts, that
energetic but illiterate theologian, Charlemagne.
The missionary enterprises of the papacy in Mongolia ended in
failure. Christianity was losing its persuasive power. The
Mongols had no prejudice against Christianity; they evidently
preferred it at first to Islam; but the missions that came to
them were manifestly using the power in the great teachings of
Jesus to advance the vast claims of the Pope to world dominion.
Christianity so vitiated was not good enough for the Mongol
mind. To make the empire of the Mongols part of the kingdom of
God might have appealed to them; but not to make it a fief
of a group of French and Italian priests, whose claims were as
gigantic as their powers and outlook were feeble, who were now the
creatures of the Emperor of Germany, now the nominees of the
King of France, and now the victims of their own petty spites and
vanities. In 1269 Kublai Khan sent a mission to the Pope with
the evident intention of finding some common mode of action with
Western Christendom. He asked that a hundred men of learning
and ability should be sent to his court to establish an understand-
ing. His mission found the Western world popeless, and engaged
in one of those disputes about the succession that are so frequent
in the history of the papacy. For two years there was no pope
at all. When at last a pope was appointed, he despatched two
Dominican friars to convert the greatest power in Asia to his
rule ! Those worthy men were appalled by the length and hard-
ship of the journey before them, and found an early excuse for
abandoning the expedition.
But this abortive mission was only one of a number of attempts
to communicate, and always they were feeble and feeble-spirited
attempts, with nothing of the conquering fire of the earlier Chris-
tian missions. Innocent IV had already sent some Dominicans
to Karakorum, and Saint Louis of France had also despatched
missionaries and relics, by way of Persia; Mangu Khan had
JENGIS KHAN AND HIS SUCCESSORS 117
numerous Nestorian Christians at his court, and subsequent papal
envoys actually reached Pekin. We hear of the appointment of
various legates and bishops to the East, but many of these seem
to have lost themselves and perhaps their lives before they reached
China. There was a papal legate in Pekin in 1346, but he seems to
have been a mere papal diplomatist. With the downfall of the
Mongolian (Yuan) dynasty (1368), the dwindling opportunity of
the Christian missions passed altogether. The house of Yuan
was followed by that of Ming, a strongly nationalist Chinese dy-
nasty, at first very hostile to all foreigners. There may have
been a massacre of the Christian missions. Until the later days
of the Mings (1644) little more is heard of Christianity, whether
Nestorian or Catholic, in China. Then a fresh and rather more
successful attempt to propagate Catholic Christianity in China
was made by the Jesuits, but this second missionary wave reached
China by the sea.
In the year 1298 a naval battle occurred between the Genoese
and the Venetians, in which the latter were defeated. Among the
7000 prisoners taken by the Genoese was a Venetian gentleman
named Marco Polo, who had been a great traveller, and who was
very generally believed by his neighbours to be given to exag-
geration. He had taken part in that first mission to Kublai
Khan, and had gone on when the two Dominicans turned back.
While this Marco Polo was a prisoner in Genoa, he beguiled his
tedium by talking of his travels to a certain writer named Rusti-
ciano, who wrote them down. We will not enter here into the
vexed question of the exact authenticity of Rusticiano's story —
we do not certainly know in what language it was written — but
there can be no doubt of the general truth of this remarkable
narrative, which became enormously popular in the fourteenth
and fifteenth centuries with all men of active intelligence. The
Travels of Marco Polo is one of the great books of history. It
opens this world of the thirteenth century, this century which saw
the reign of Frederick II and the beginnings of the Inquisition,
to our imaginations as no mere historian's chronicle can do.
It led directly to the discovery of America.
It begins by telling of the journey of Marco's father, Nicolo
Polo, and uncle, Maffeo Polo, to China. These two were Venetian
118 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
merchants of standing, living in Constantinople, and somewhen
about 1260 they went to the Crimea and thence to Kazan ; from
that place they journeyed to Bokhara, and at Bokhara they fell
in with a party of envoys from Kublai Khan in China to his brother
Hulagu in Persia. These envoys pressed them to come on to the
Great Khan, who at that time had never seen men of the " Latin''
peoples. They went on ; and it is clear they made a very favour-
able impression upon Kublai, and interested him greatly in the
civilization of Christendom. They were made the bearers of
that request for a hundred teachers and learned men, " intelligent
men acquainted with the Seven Arts, able to enter into controversy
and able clearly to prove to idolators and other kinds of folk that
the Law of Christ was best," to which we have just alluded. But
when they returned Christendom was in a phase of confusion, and
it was only after a delay of two years that they got their author-
ization to start for China again in the company of those two faint-
hearted Dominicans. They took with them young Marco, and
it is due to his presence and the boredom of his subsequent cap-
tivity at Genoa that this most interesting experience has been
preserved to us.
The three Polos started by way of Palestine and not by the
Crimea, as in the previous expedition. They had with them a gold
tablet and other indications from the Great Khan that must have
greatly facilitated their journey. The Great Khan had asked for
some oil from the lamp that burns in the Holy Sepulchre at Jeru-
salem ; and so thither they first went, and then by way of Cilicia
into Armenia. They went thus far north because the Sultan of
Egypt was raiding the Ilkhan domains at this time. Thence they
came by way of Mesopotamia to Ormuz on the Persian Gulf, as
if they contemplated a sea voyage. At Ormuz they met merchants
from India. For some reason they did not take ship, but instead
turned northward through the Persian deserts, and so by way of
Balkh over the Pamir to Kashgar, and by way of Kotan and the
Lob Nor (so following in the footsteps of Yuan Chwang) into the
Hwangho Valley and on to Pekin. Pekin Polo calls " Cambulac " ;
Northern China, " Cathay" ( = Khitan) ; and Southern China of
the former Sung dynasty, "Manzi." At Pekin was the Great
Khan, and they were hospitably entertained. Marco particularly
JENGIS KHAN AND HIS SUCCESSORS 119
pleased Kublai ; he was young and clever, and it is clear he had
mastered the Tartar language very thoroughly. He was given
an official position and sent on several missions, chiefly in South-
west China. The tale he had to tell of vast stretches of smiling
and prosperous country, "all the way excellent hostelries for
travellers," and "fine vineyards, fields, and gardens," of "many
abbeys" of Buddhist monks, of manufactures of "cloth of silk
and gold and many fine taffetas," a "constant succession of cities
and boroughs," and so on, first roused the incredulity and then
fired the imagination of all Europe. He told of Burmah, and of
its great armies with hundreds of elephants, and how these animals
were defeated by the Mongol bowmen, and also of the Mongol
conquest of Pegu. He told of Japan, and greatly exaggerated
the amount of gold in that country. And, still more wonderful,
he told of Christians and Christian rulers in China, and of a
certain "Prester John," John the Priest, who was the "king" of a
Christian people. Those people he had not seen. Apparently
they were a tribe of Nestorian Tartars in Mongolia. An under-
standable excitement probably made Rusticiano over-emphasize
what must have seemed to him the greatest marvel of the whole
story, and Prester John became one of the most stimulating legends
of the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries. It encouraged Euro-
pean enterprise enormously to think that far away in China was a
community of their co-religionists, presumably ready to welcome
and assist them. For three years Marco ruled the city of Yang-
chow as governor, and he probably impressed the Chinese in-
habitants as being very little more of a foreigner than any Tartar
would have been. He may also have been sent on a mission to
India. Chinese records mention a certain Polo attached to the
imperial council in 1277, a very valuable confirmation of the
general truth of the Polo story.
The Polos had taken about three and a half years to get to
China. They stayed there upwards of sixteen. Then they began
to feel homesick. They were the prote'ge's of Kublai, and possibly
they felt that his favours roused a certain envy that might have
disagreeable results after his death. They sought his permission
to return. For a time he refused it, and then an opportunity
occurred. Argon, the Ilkhan monarch of Persia, the grandson of
120 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
Hulagu, Kublai's brother, had lost his Mongol wife, and on her
deathbed had promised not to wed any other woman but a Mongol
of her own tribe. He sent ambassadors to Pekin, and a suitable
princess was selected, a girl of seventeen. To spare her the fatigues
of the caravan route, it was decided to send her by sea with a
suitable escort. The " Barons" in charge of her asked for the
company of the Polos because these latter were experienced
travellers and sage men, and the Polos snatched at this opportunity
of getting homeward. The expedition sailed from some port on
the east of South China ; they stayed long in Sumatra and South
India, and they reached Persia after a voyage of two years. They
delivered the young lady safely to Argon's successor — for Argon
was dead — and she married Argon's son. The Polos then went
by Tabriz to Trebizond, sailed to Constantinople, and got back to
Venice about 1295. It is related that the returned travellers,
dressed in Tartar garb, were refused admission to their own
house. It was some time before they could establish their identity.
Many people who admitted that, were still inclined to look askance
at them as shabby wanderers ; and, in order to dispel such doubts,
they gave a great feast, and when it was at its height they had their
old padded suits brought to them, dismissed the servants, and then
ripped open these garments, whereupon an incredible display of
" rubies, sapphires, carbuncles, emeralds, and diamonds" poured
out before the dazzled company. Even after this, Marco's
accounts of the size and population of China were received with
much furtive mockery. The wits nicknamed him II Milione,
because he was always talking of millions of people and millions
of ducats.
Such was the story that raised eyebrows first in Venice and then
throughout the Western world. The European literature, and
especially the European romance of the fifteenth century, echoes
with the names in Marco Polo's story, with Cathay and Cambulac
and the like.
§4
These travels of Marco Polo were only the beginning of a very
considerable intercourse. That intercourse was to bring many
revolutionary ideas and many revolutionary things to Europe,
JENGIS KHAN AND HIS SUCCESSORS 121
including a greatly extended use of paper and printing from
blocks, the almost equally revolutionary use of gunpowder in
warfare, and the mariner's compass which was to release the
European shipping from navigation by coasting. The popular
imagination has always been disposed to ascribe every such
striking result to Marco Polo. He has become the type and symbol
for all such interchanges. As a matter of fact, there is no evidence
that he had any share in these three importations. There were
many mute Marco Polos who never met their Rusticianos, and
history has not preserved their names. Before we go on, however,
to describe the great widening of the mental horizons of Europe
that was now beginning, and to which this book of travels was to
contribute very materially, it will be convenient first to note a
curious side consequence of the great Mongol conquests, the
appearance of the Ottoman Turks upon the Dardanelles, and
next to state in general terms the breaking up and development of
the several parts of the empire of Jengis Khan.
The Ottoman Turks were a little band of fugitives who fled
southwesterly before the first invasion of Western Turkestan by
Jengis. They made their long way from Central Asia, over deserts
and mountains and through alien populations, seeking some new
lands in which they might settle. "A small band of alien herds-
men," says Sir Mark Sykes, " wandering unchecked through
crusades and counter-crusades, principalities, empires, and states.
Where they camped, how they moved and preserved their flocks
and herds, where they found pasture, how they made their peace
with the various chiefs through whose territories they passed, are
questions which one may well ask in wonder."
They found a resting-place at last and kindred and congenial
neighbours on the tablelands of Asia Minor among the Seljuk
Turks. Most of this country, the modern Anatolia, was now
largely Turkish in speech and Moslem in religion, except that there
was a considerable proportion of Greeks, Jews, and Armenians
in the town populations. No doubt the various strains of Hittite,
Phrygian, Trojan, Lydian, Ionian Greek, Cimmerian, Galatian,
and Italian (from the Pergamus times) still flowed in the blood of
the people, but they had long since forgotten these ancestral
elements. They were indeed much the same blend of ancient
122 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
Mediterranean dark-whites, Nordic Aryans, Semites and Mon-
golians as were the inhabitants of the Balkan peninsula, but
they believed themselves to be a pure Turanian race, and al-
together superior to the Christians on the other side of the
Bosphorus.
Gradually the Ottoman Turks became important, and at last
dominant among the small principalities into which the Seljuk
empire, the empire of "Roum," had fallen. Their relations with
the dwindling empire of Constantinople remained for some cen-
turies tolerantly hostile. They made no attack upon the Bos-
phorus, but they got a footing in Europe at the Dardanelles, and,
using this route, the route of Xerxes and not the route of Darius,
they pushed their way steadily into Macedonia, Epirus, Illyria,
Yugo-Slavia, and Bulgaria. In the Serbs (Yugo-Slavs) and
Bulgarians the Turks found people very like themselves in culture
and, though neither side recognized it, probably very similar in
racial admixture, with a little less of the dark Mediterranean and
Mongolian strains than the Turks and a trifle more of the Nordic
element. But these Balkan peoples were Christians, and bitterly
divided among themselves. The Turks on the other hand spoke
one language; they had a greater sense of unity, they had the
Moslem habits of temperance and frugality, and they were on the
whole better soldiers. They converted what they could of the
conquered people to Islam; the Christians they disarmed, and
conferred upon them the monopoly of tax-paying. Gradually
the Ottoman princes consolidated an empire that reached from
the Taurus mountains in the east to Hungary and Roumania in
the west. Adrianople became their chief city. They surrounded
the shrunken empire of Constantinople on every side.
The Ottomans organized a standing military force, the Janis-
saries, rather on the lines of the Mamelukes who dominated Egypt.
" These troops were formed of levies of Christian youths to the
extent of one thousand per annum, who were affiliated to the Bek-
tashi order of dervishes, and though at first not obliged to embrace
Islam, were one and all strongly imbued with the mystic and frater-
nal ideas of the confraternity to which they were attached. Highly
paid, well disciplined, a close and jealous secret society, the Janis-
saries provided the newly formed Ottoman state with a patriotic
JENGIS KHAN AND HIS SUCCESSORS
123
force of trained infantry soldiers, which, in an age of light cavalry
and hired companies of mercenaries, was an invaluable asset. . . ,l
"The relations between the Ottoman Sultans and the Emperors
has been singular in the annals of Moslem and Christian states.
The Turks had been involved in the family and dynastic quarrels
of the Imperial City, were bound by ties of blood to the ruling
<*£* OTTOMAN EMPIRE
1453.
J.KH.
families, frequently supplied troops for the defence of Con-
stantinople, and on occasion hired parts of its garrison to assist
them in their various campaigns ; the sons of the Emperors and
Byzantine statesmen even accompanied the Turkish forces in the
field, yet the Ottomans never ceased to annex Imperial territories
and cities both in Asia and Thrace. This curious intercourse
between the House of Osman and the Imperial government had a
profound effect on both institutions; the Greeks grew more and
more debased and demoralized by the shifts and tricks that their
military weakness obliged them to adopt towards their neighbours,
the Turks were corrupted by the alien atmosphere of intrigue and
1 Sir Mark Sykes, The Caliphs' Last Heritage.
124 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
treachery which crept into their domestic life. Fratricide and
parricide, the two crimes which most frequently stained the annals
of the Imperial Palace, eventually formed a part of the policy of
the Ottoman dynasty. One of the sons of Murad I embarked on
an intrigue with Andronicus, the son of the Greek Emperor, to
murder their respective fathers. . . .
"The Byzantine found it more easy to negotiate with the Otto-
man Pasha than with the Pope. For years the Turks and Byzan-
tines had intermarried, and hunted in couples in strange by-paths
of diplomacy. The Ottoman had played the Bulgar and the Serb
of Europe against the Emperor, just as the Emperor had played
the Asiatic Amir against the Sultan; the Greek and Turkish
Royal Princes had mutually agreed to hold each other's rivals as
prisoners and hostages ; in fact, Turk and Byzantine policy had
so intertwined that it is difficult to say whether the Turks regarded
the Greeks as their allies, enemies, or subjects, or whether the
Greeks looked upon the Turks as their tyrants, destroyers, or
protectors. . . .';i
It was in 1453, under the Ottoman Sultan, Muhammad II, that
Constantinople at last fell to the Moslems. He attacked it from
the European side, and with a great power of artillery. The Greek
Emperor was killed, and there was much looting and massacre.
The great church of Saint Sophia which Justinian the Great had
built (532) was plundered of its treasures and turned at once into
a mosque. This event sent a wave of excitement throughout
Europe, and an attempt was made to organize a crusade, but the
days of the crusades were past.
Says Sir Mark Sykes: "To the Turks the capture of Con-
stantinople was a crowning mercy and yet a fatal blow. Con-
stantinople had been the tutor and polisher of the Turks. So long
as the Ottomans could draw science, learning, philosophy, art,
and tolerance from a living fountain of civilization in the heart
of their dominions, so long had the Ottomans not only brute force,
but intellectual power. So long as the Ottoman Empire had in
Constantinople a free port, a market, a centre of world finance,
a pool of gold, an exchange, so long did the Ottomans never lack
for money and financial support. Muhammad was a great
1 Sir Mark Sykes, The Caliphs1 Last Heritage.
JENGIS KHAN AND HIS SUCCESSORS
125
126 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
statesman, the moment he entered Constantinople he endeavoured
to stay the damage his ambition had done; he supported the
patriarch, he conciliated the Greeks, he did all he could to con-
tinue Constantinople the city of the Emperors . . . but the fatal
step had been taken ; Constantinople as the city of the Sultans
was Constantinople no more ; the markets died away, the culture
and civilization fled, the complex finance faded from sight; and
the Turks had lost their governors and their support. On the
other hand, the corruptions of Byzantium remained, the bureau-
cracy, the eunuchs, the palace guards, the spies, the bribers, go-
betweens — all these the Ottomans took over, and all these sur-
vived in luxuriant life. The Turks, in taking Stambul, let slip
a treasure and gained a pestilence. . . ."
Muhammad's ambition was not sated by the capture of Con-
stantinople. He set his eyes also upon Rome. He captured and
looted the Italian town of Otranto, and it is probable that a very
vigorous and perhaps successful attempt to conquer Italy — for
the peninsula was divided against itself — was averted only by
his death (1481). His sons engaged in fratricidal strife. Under
Bayezid II (1481-1512), his successor, war was carried into
Poland, and most of Greece was conquered. Selim (1512-1520),
the son of Bayezid, extended the Ottoman power over Armenia
and conquered Egypt. In Egypt, the last Abbasid Caliph was
living under the protection of the Mameluke Sultan — for the
Fatimite caliphate was a thing of the past. Selim bought the
title of Caliph from this last degenerate Abbasid, and acquired the
sacred banner and other relics of the Prophet. So the Ottoman
Sultan became also Caliph of all Islam. Selim was followed by
Suleiman the Magnificent (1520-1566), who conquered Bagdad in
the east and the greater part of Hungary in the west, and very
nearly captured Vienna. His fleets also took Algiers, and in-
flicted a number of reverses upon the Venetians. In most of his
warfare with the empire he was in alliance with the French.
Under him the Ottoman power reached its zenith.
§5
Let us now very briefly run over the subsequent development of
the main masses of the empire of the Great Khan. In no case
JENGIS KHAN AND HIS SUCCESSORS 127
did Christianity succeed in capturing the imagination of these
Mongol states. Christianity was in a phase of moral and in-
tellectual insolvency, without any collective faith, energy, or
honour ; we have told of the wretched brace of timid Dominicans
which was the Pope's reply to the appeal of Kublai Khan, and we
have noted the general failure of the overland mission of the
thirteenth and fourteenth centuries. That apostolic passion
that could win whole nations to the Kingdom of Heaven was
dead in the church.
In 1305, as we have told, the Pope became the kept pontiff of the
French king. All the craft and policy of the Popes of the thirteenth
century to oust the Emperor from Italy had only served to let in
the French to replace him. From 1305 to 1377 the Popes re-
mained at Avignon; and such slight missionary effort as they
made was merely a part of the strategy of Western European
politics.1 In 1377 the Pope Gregory XI did indeed re-enter Rome
and die there, but the French cardinals split off from the others
at the election of his successor, and two Popes were elected, one at
Avignon and one at Rome. This split, the Great Schism, lasted
from 1378 to 1418. Each Pope cursed the other, and put all his
supporters under an interdict. Such was the state of Christianity,
and such were now the custodians of the teachings of Jesus of
Nazareth. All Asia was white unto harvest, but there was no
effort to reap it.
When at last the church was reunited and missionary energy
returned with the foundation of the order of the Jesuits, the days
of opportunity were over. The possibility of a world-wide moral
unification of East and West through Christianity had passed
away. The Mongols in China and Central Asia turned to Bud-
dhism ; in South Russia, Western Turkestan, andthellkhan Empire
they embraced Islam.
§5A
In China the Mongols were already saturated with Chinese
civilization by the time of Kublai. After 1280 the Chinese annals
treat Kublai as a Chinese monarch, the founder of the Yuan
dynasty (1280-1368). This Mongol dynasty was finally over-
1 But see Pastor, History of the Popes, Vol. I.
128 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
thrown by a Chinese nationalist movement which set up the
Ming dynasty (1368-1644), a cultivated and artistic line of
emperors, ruling until a northern people, the Manchus, who were
the same as the Kin whom Jengis had overthrown, conquered
China and established a dynasty which gave way only to a native
republican form of government in 1912.
It was the Manchus who obliged the Chinese to wear pig-tails
as a mark of submission. The pigt ailed Chinaman is quite a
recent, and now a vanished figure in history.
§5B
In the Pamirs, in much of Eastern and Western Turkestan,
and to the north, the Mongols dropped back towards the tribal
conditions from which they had been lifted by Jengis. It is
possible to trace the dwindling succession of many of the small
Kans who became independent during this period, almost down
to the present time. The Kalmuks in the seventeenth and eight-
eenth centuries founded a considerable empire, but dynastic
troubles broke it up before it had extended its power beyond
Central Asia. The Chinese recovered Eastern Turkestan from
them about 1757.
Tibet was more and more closely linked with China, and became
the great home of Buddhism and Buddhist monasticism.
Over most of the area of Western Central Asia and Persia and
Mesopotamia, the ancient distinction of nomad and settled popu-
lation remains to this day. The townsmen despise and cheat the
nomads, the nomads ill-treat and despise the townsfolk.
§5c
The Mongols of the great realm of Kipchak remained nomadic,
and grazed their stock across the wide plains of South Russia and
Western Asia adjacent to Russia. They became not very devout
Moslems, retaining many traces of their earlier barbaric Shaman-
ism. Their chief Khan was the Khan of the Golden Horde. To
the west, over large tracts of open country, and more particularly
in what is now known as Ukrainia, the old Scythian population,
Slavs with a Mongol admixture, reverted to a similar nomadic
JENGIS KHAN AND HIS SUCCESSORS 129
life. These Christian nomads, the Cossacks, formed a sort of
frontier screen against the Tartars, and their free and adventurous
life was so attractive to the peasants of Poland and Lithuania that
severe laws had to be passed to prevent a vast migration from the
ploughlands to the steppes. The serf-owning landlords of Poland
regarded the Cossacks with considerable hostility on this account,
and war was as frequent between the Polish chivalry and the
Cossacks as it was between the latter and the Tartars.1
In the empire of Kipchak, as in Turkestan almost up to the
present time, while the nomads roamed over wide areas, a number
of towns and cultivated regions sustained a settled population
which usually paid tribute to the nomad Khan. In such towns as
Kieff, Moscow, and the like, the pre-Mongol, Christian town life
went on under Russian dukes or Tartar governors, who collected
the tribute for the Khan of the Golden Horde. The Grand Duke
of Moscow gained the confidence of the Khan, and gradually,
under his authority, obtained an ascendancy over many of his
fellow tributaries. In the fifteenth century, under its grand duke,
Ivan III, Ivan the Great (1462-1505), Moscow threw off its
Mongol allegiance and refused to pay tribute any longer (1480).
The successors of Constantine no longer reigned in Constantinople,
and Ivan took possession of the Byzantine double-headed eagle
for his arms. He claimed to be the heir to Byzantium because of
his marriage (1472) with Zoe Palseologus of the imperial line.
This ambitious grand dukedom of Moscow assailed and subjugated
the ancient Northman trading republic of Novgorod to the north,
and so the foundations of the modern Russian Empire were laid
and a link with the mercantile life of the Baltic established. Ivan
III did not, however, carry his claim to be the heir of the Christian
rulers of Constantinople to the extent of assuming the imperial
title. This step was taken by his grandson, Ivan IV (Ivan the
Terrible, because of his insane cruelties; 1533-1584). Although
the ruler of Moscow thus came to be called Tsar (Caesar), his
tradition was in many respects Tartar rather than European ; he
was autocratic after the unlimited Asiatic pattern, and the form
of Christianity he affected was the Eastern, court-ruled, "ortho-
1 See Beazley, Forbes and Birkett's Russia for a fuller account of the Cossacks
and also see later chap, xxxvi, § 10.
K
130 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
dox" form, which had reached Russia long before the Mongol
conquest, by means of Bulgarian missionaries from Constantinople.
To the west of the domains of Kipchak, outside the range of
Mongol rule, a second centre of Slav consolidation had been set
up during the tenth and eleventh centuries in Poland. The
Mongol wave had washed over Poland, but had never subjugated
it. Poland was not " orthodox," but Roman Catholic in religion;
it used the Latin alphabet instead of the strange Russian letters,
and its monarch never assumed an absolute independence of the
Emperor. Poland was in fact in its origins an outlying part of
Christendom and of the Holy Empire ; Russia never was anything
of the sort.
§5D
The nature and development of the empire of the Ilkhans in
Persia, Mesopotamia, and Syria is perhaps the most interesting
of all the stories of these Mongol powers, because in this region
nomadism really did attempt, and really did to a very considerable
degree succeed in its attempt to stamp a settled civilized system
out of existence. When Jengis Khan first invaded China, we are
told that there was a serious discussion among the Mongol chiefs
whether all the towns and settled populations should not be
destroyed. To these simple practitioners of the open-air life the
settled populations seemed corrupt, crowded, vicious, effeminate,
dangerous, and incomprehensible; a detestable human efflor-
escence upon what would otherwise have been good pasture.
They had no use whatever for the towns. The early Franks and
the Anglo-Saxon conquerors of South Britain had much the same
feeling towards townsmen. But it was only under Hulagu in
Mesopotamia that these ideas seem to have been embodied in a
deliberate policy. The Mongols here did not only burn and
massacre ; they destroyed the irrigation system that had endured
for at least eight thousand years, and with that the mother
civilization of all the Western world came to an end. Since the
days of the priest-kings of Sumeria there had been a continuous
cultivation in these fertile regions, an accumulation of tradition, a
great population, a succession of busy cities, Eridu, Nippur, Baby-
lon, Nineveh, Ctesiphon, Bagdad. Now the fertility ceased.
JENGIS KHAN AND HIS SUCCESSORS
131
132 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
Mesopotamia became a land of ruins and desolation, through which
great waters ran to waste, or overflowed their banks to make
malarious swamps. Later on Mosul and Bagdad revived feebly
as second-rate towns. . . .
But for the defeat and death of Hulagu's general Kitboga in
Palestine (1260), the same fate might have overtaken Egypt.
But Egypt was now a Turkish sultanate ; it was dominated by a
body of soldiers, the Mamelukes, whose ranks, like those of their
imitators, the Janissaries of the Ottoman Empire, were recruited
and kept vigorous by the purchase and training of boy slaves.
A capable Sultan such men would obey ; a weak or evil one they
would replace. Under this ascendancy Egypt remained an in-
dependent power until 1517, when it fell to the Ottoman
Turks.
The first destructive vigour of Hulagu's Mongols soon sub-
sided, but in the fifteenth century a last tornado of nomadism arose
in Western Turkestan under the leadership of a certain Timur
the Lame, or Timurlane. He was descended in the female line
from Jengis Khan. He established himself in Samarkand, and
spread his authority over Kipchak (Turkestan to South Russia),
Siberia, and southward as far as the Indus. He assumed the
title of Great Khan in 1369. He was a nomad of the savage
school, and he created an empire of desolation from North India
to Syria. Pyramids of skulls were his particular architectural
fancy ; after the storming of Ispahan he made one of 70,000. His
ambition was to restore the empire of Jengis Khan as he conceived
it, a project in which he completely failed. He spread destruction
far and wide ; the Ottoman Turks — it was before the taking of
Constantinople and their days of greatness — and Egypt paid
him tribute; the Punjab he devastated; and Delhi surrendered
to him. After Delhi had surrendered, however, he made a
frightful massacre of its inhabitants. At the time of his death
(1405) very little remained to witness to his power but a name of
horror, ruins, and desolated countries, and a shrunken and im-
poverished domain in Persia.
The dynasty founded by Timur in Persia was extinguished by
another Turkoman horde fifty years later.
JENGIS KHAN AND HIS SUCCESSORS 133
§5E1
In 1505 a small Turkoman chieftain, Baber, a descendant of
Timur and therefore of Jengis, was forced after some years of
warfare and some temporary successes — for a time he held
Samarkand — to fly with a few followers over the Hindu Kush to
Afghanistan. There his band increased, and he made himself
master of Cabul. He assembled an army, accumulated guns, and
then laid claim to the Punjab, because Timur had conquered it a
hundred and seven years before. He pushed his successes beyond
the Punjab. India was in a state of division, and quite ready to
welcome any capable invader who promised peace and order.
After various fluctuations of fortune Baber met the Sultan of Delhi
at Panipat (1525), ten miles north of that town, and though he
had but 25,000 men, provided, however, with guns, against a
thousand elephants and four times as many men — the numbers,
by the by, are his own estimate — he gained a complete victory.
He ceased to call himself King of Cabul, and assumed the title of
Emperor of Hindustan. "This," he wrote, "is quite a different
world from our countries." It was finer, more fertile, altogether
richer. He conquered as far as Bengal, but his untimely death in
1530 checked the tide of Mongol conquest for a quarter of a
century, and it was only after the accession of his grandson Akbar
that it flowed again. Akbar subjugated all India as far as Berar,
and his great-grandson Aurungzeb (1658-1707) was practically
master of the entire peninsula. This great dynasty of Baber
(1526-1530), Humayun (1530-1556), Akbar (1556-1605), Jehangir
(1605-1628), Shah Jehan (1628-1658), and Aurungzeb (1658-
1707), in which son succeeded father for six generations, this
"Mogul (= Mongol) dynasty,"2 marks the most splendid age
that had hitherto dawned upon India. Akbar next perhaps to
Asoka, was one of the greatest of Indian monarchs, and one of the
few royal figures that approach the stature of great men.
To Akbar it is necessary to give the same distinctive attention
that we have shown to Charlemagne or Constantine the Great.
1 See Malleson's Akbar, in the Rulers of India series.
'"Mogul" is our crude rendering of the Arabic spelling Mughal, which it-
self was a corruption of Mongol, the Arabic alphabet having no symbol for ng.
— H. H. J.
134 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
He is one of the hinges of history. Much of his work of con-
solidation and organization in India survives to this day. It was
taken over and continued by the British when they became the
successors of the Mogul emperors. The British monarch, indeed,
now uses as his Indian title the title of the Mogul emperors,
Kaisar-i-Hind. All the other great administrations of the de-
scendants of Jengis Khan, in Russia, throughout Western and Cen-
tral Asia and in China, have long since dissolved away and given
place to other forms of government. Their governments were
indeed little more than taxing governments ; a system of revenue-
collecting to feed the central establishment of the ruler, like the
Golden Horde in South Russia or the imperial city at Karakorum
or Pekin. The life and ideas of the people they left alone, careless
how they lived — so long as they paid. So it was that after
centuries of subjugation, a Christian Moscow and Kieff, a Shiite
Persia, and a thoroughly Chinese China rose again from their
Mongol submergence. But Akbar made a new India. He gave
the princes and ruling classes of India some inklings at least of a
common interest. If India is now anything more than a sort of
rag-bag of incoherent states and races, a prey to every casual
raider from the north, it is very largely due to him.
His distinctive quality was his openness of mind. He set him-
self to make every sort of able man in India, whatever his race or
religion, available for the public work of Indian life. His instinct
was the true stateman's instinct for synthesis. His empire was
to be neither a Moslem nor a Mongol one, nor was it to be Rajput
or Aryan, or Dravidian, or Hindu, or high or low caste ; it was to
be Indian. " During the years of his training he enjoyed many
opportunities of noting the good qualities, the fidelity, the devo-
tion, often the nobility of soul, of those Hindu princes, whom,
because they were followers of Brahma, his Moslem courtiers
devoted mentally to eternal torments. He noted that these men,
and men who thought like them, constituted the vast majority of
his subjects. He noted, further, of many of them, and those the
most trustworthy, that though they had apparently much to gain
from a worldly point of view by embracing the religion of the court,
they held fast to their own. His reflective mind, therefore, was
unwilling from the outset to accept the theory that because he,
JENGIS KHAN AND HIS SUCCESSORS 135
the conqueror, the ruler, happened to be born a Muhammadan,
therefore Muhammadanism was true for all mankind. Gradually
his thoughts found words in the utterance : ' Why should I claim
to guide men before I myself am guided?' and, as he listened to
other doctrines and other creeds, his honest doubts became
confirmed, and, noting daily the bitter narrowness of sectarianism,
no matter of what form of religion, he became more and more
wedded to the principle of toleration for all."
"The son of a fugitive emperor," says Dr. Emil Schmit, "born
in the desert, brought up in nominal confinement, he had known
the bitter side of life from his youth up. Fortune had given him a
powerful frame, which he trained to support the extremities of
exertion. Physical exercise was with him a passion; he was
devoted to the chase and especially to the fierce excitement of
catching the wild horse or elephant or slaying the dangerous
tiger. On one occasion, when it was necessary to dissuade the
Raja of Jodhpore to abandon his intention of forcing the widow
of his deceased son to mount the funeral pyre, Akbar rode two
hundred and twenty miles in two days. In battle he displayed
the utmost bravery. He led his troops in person during the
dangerous part of a campaign, leaving to his generals the lighter
task of finishing the war. In every victory he displayed humanity
to the conquered, and decisively opposed any exhibition of cruelty.
Free from all these prejudices which separate society and create
dissension, tolerant to men of other beliefs, impartial to men of
other races, whether Hindu or Dravidian, he was a man obviously
marked out to weld the conflicting elements of his kingdom into a
strong and prosperous whole.
"In all seriousness he devoted himself to the work of peace.
Moderate in all pleasures, needing but little sleep and accustomed
to divide his time with the utmost accuracy, he found leisure to
devote himself to science and art after the completion of his State
duties. The famous personages and scholars who adorned the
capital he had built for himself at Fatehpur-Sikri were at the same
time his friends; every Thursday evening a circle of these was
collected for intellectual conversation and philosophical dis-
cussion. His closest friends were two highly talented brothers,
Faizi and Abul Fazl, the sons of a learned free-thinker. The elder
136 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
of these was a famous scholar in Hindu literature; with his
help, and under his direction, Akbar had the most important of the
Sanskrit works translated into Persian. Fazl, on the other hand,
who was an especially close friend of Akbar, was a general, a
statesman, and an organizer, and to his activity Akbar's kingdom
chiefly owed the solidarity of its internal organization." 1
(Such was the quality of the circle that used to meet in the
palaces of Fatehpur-Sikri, buildings which still stand in the Indian
sunlight — but empty now and desolate. Fatehpur-Sikri, like
the city of Ambar, is now a dead city. A few years ago the child
of a British official was killed by a panther in one of its silent
streets.)
All this that we have quoted reveals a pre-eminent monarch.
But Akbar, like all men, great or petty, lived within the limitations
of his period and its circles of ideas. And a Turkoman, ruling in
India, was necessarily ignorant of much that Europe had been
painfully learning for a thousand years. He knew nothing of the
growth of a popular consciousness in Europe, and little or nothing
of the wide educational possibilities that the church had been
working out in the West. His upbringing in Islam and his native
genius made it plain to him that a great nation in India could only
be cemented by common ideas upon a religious basis, but the
knowledge of how such a solidarity could be created and sustained
by universal schools, cheap books, and a university system at
once organized and free to think, to which the modern state is
still feeling its way, was as impossible to him as a knowledge of
steamboats or aeroplanes. The form of Islam he knew best was
the narrow and fiercely intolerant form of the Turkish Sunnites.
The Moslems were only a minority of the population. The prob-
lem he faced was indeed very parallel to the problem of Con-
stantine the Great. But it had peculiar difficulties of its own.
He never got beyond an attempt to adapt Islam to a wider appeal
by substituting for "There is one God, and Muhammad is his
prophet," the declaration, "There is one God, and the Emperor is
his vice-regent." This he thought might form a common plat-
form for every variety of faith in India, that kaleidoscope of
religions. With this faith he associated a simple ritual borrowed
1 Dr. Schmit in Helmolt's History of the World.
JENGIS KHAN AND HIS SUCCESSORS 137
from the Persian Zoroastrians (the Parsees) who still survived,
and survive to-day, in India. This new state religion, however,
died with him, because it had no roots in the minds of the people
about him.
The essential factor in the organization of a living state, the
world is coming to realize, is the organization of an education.
This Akbar never understood. And he had no class of men avail-
able who would suggest such an idea to him or help him to carry it
out. The Moslem teachers in India were not so much teachers as
conservators of an intense bigotry ; they did not want a common
mind in India, but only a common intolerance in Islam. The
Brahmins, who had the monopoly of teaching among the Hindus,
had all the conceit and slackness of hereditary privilege. Yet
though Akbar made no general educational scheme for India, he
set up a number of Moslem and Hindu schools. He knew less and
he did more for India in these matters than the British who suc-
ceeded him. Some of the British viceroys have aped his magnifi-
cence, his costly tents and awnings, his palatial buildings and his
elephants of state, but none have gone far enough beyond the
political outlook of this mediaeval Turkoman to attempt that
popular education which is an absolute necessity to India before
she can play her fitting part in the commonweal of mankind.1
§5F
A curious side result of these later Mongol perturbations, those
of the fourteenth century of which Timurlane was the head and
centre, was the appearance of drifting batches of a strange refugee
Eastern people in Europe, the Gipsies. They appeared some when
about the end of the fourteenth and early fifteenth centuries in
Greece, where they were believed to be Egyptians (hence Gipsy),
a very general persuasion which they themselves accepted and
disseminated. Their leaders, however, styled themselves "Counts
of Asia Minor. " They had probably been drifting about Western
Asia for some centuries before the massacres of Timurlane drove
them over the Hellespont. They may have been dislodged from
1 1 do not think this is fair. See Edinburgh Review for January, 1920, article on
Calcutta University Commission. — E. B.
But popular education ! — H. G. W.
138 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
their original homeland — as the Ottoman Turks were — by the
great cataclysm of Jengis or even earlier. They had drifted
about as the Ottoman Turks had drifted about, but with less good
fortune. They spread slowly westward across Europe, strange
fragments of nomadism in a world of plough and city, driven off
their ancient habitat of the Bactrian steppes to harbour upon
European commons and by hedgerows and in wild woodlands and
neglected patches. The Germans called them " Hungarians"
and " Tartars," the French, " Bohemians." They do not seem
to have kept the true tradition of their origin, but they have a
distinctive language which indicates their lost history ; it contains
many North Indian words, and is probably in its origin North
India. There are also considerable Armenian and Persian ele-
ments in their speech. They are found in all European countries
to-day ; they are tinkers, pedlars, horse-dealers, showmen, fortune-
tellers, and beggars. To many imaginative minds their wayside
encampments, with their smoking fires, their rounded tents, their
hobbled horses, and their brawl of sunburnt children, have a
very strong appeal. Civilization is so new a thing in history, and
has been for most of the time so very local a thing, that it has still
to conquer and assimilate most of our instincts to its needs. In
most of us, irked by its conventions and complexities, there stirs
the nomad strain. We are but half-hearted home-keepers. The
blood in our veins was brewed on the steppes as well as on the
ploughlands.
XXXV
THE RENASCENCE OF WESTERN CIVILIZATION1
(LAND WAYS GIVE PLACE TO SEA WAYS)
1. Christianity and Popular Education. § 2. Europe begins
to Think for Itself. § 3. The Great Plague and the Dawn of
Communism. § 4. How Paper Liberated the Human Mind.
§ 5. Protestantism of the Princes and Protestantism of the Peoples.
§ 6. The Reawakening of Science. § 7. The New Growth of
European Towns. § 8. America Comes into History. § 9. What
Machiavelli Thought of the World. § 10. The Republic of Switzer-
land. § 11 A. The Life of the Emperor Charles V. § HB. Prot-
estants if the Prince Wills it. § 11 c. The Intellectual Under-low.
JUDGED by the map, the three centuries from the beginning
of the thirteenth to the end of the fifteenth century were
an age of recession for Christendom. These centuries were the
Age of the Mongolian peoples. Nomadism from Central Asia
dominated the known world. At the crest of this period there
were rulers of Mongol or the kindred Turkish race and nomadic
tradition in China, India, Persia, Egypt, North Africa, the Balkan
Peninsula, Hungary, and Russia. The Ottoman Turk had even
taken to the sea, and fought the Venetian upon his own Mediter-
1 Renascence here means rebirth, and it is applied to the recovery of the entire
Western world. It is not to be confused with "the Renaissance," an educational,
literary, and artistic revival tjh^t went on in Italy and the Western world affected
by Italy during the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries. The Renaissance was only
a part of the Renascence of Europe. The Renaissance was a revival due to the
exhumation of classical art and learning ; it was but one factor in the very much
larger and more complicated resurrection of European capacity and .vigour, with
which we are dealing in this chapter.
139
140 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
ranean waters. In 1529 the Turks besieged Vienna, and were
defeated rather by the weather than by the defenders. The
Habsburg empire of Charles V paid the Sultan tribute. It was
not until the battle of Lepanto in 1571, the battle in which Cer-
vantes, the author of Don Quixote, lost his left arm, that Chris-
tendom, to use his words, "broke the pride of the Osmans and
undeceived the world which had regarded the Turkish fleet as
invincible." The sole region of Christian advance was Spain.
A man of foresight surveying the world in the early sixteenth
century might well have concluded that it was only a matter of a
few generations before the whole world became Mongolian —
and probably Moslem. Just as to-day most people seem to take
it for granted that European rule and a sort of liberal Christianity
are destined to spread over the whole world. Few people seem to
realize how recent a thing is this European ascendancy. It was
only as the fifteenth century drew to its close that any indications
of the real vitality of Western Europe became clearly apparent.
Our history is now approaching our own times, and our study
becomes more and more a study of the existing state of affairs.
The European or Europeanized system in which the reader is
living is the same system that we see developing in the
crumpled-up, Mongol-threatened Europe of the early fifteenth
century. Its problems then were the embryonic form of the
problems of to-day. It is impossible to discuss that time with-
out discussing our own time. We become political in spite of our-
selves. "Politics without history has no root," said Sir J. R.
Seeley ; " history without politics has no fruit."
Let us try, with as much detachment as we can achieve, to
discover what the forces were that were dividing and holding back
the energies of Europe during this tremendous outbreak of the
Mongol peoples, and how we are to explain the accumulation of
mental and physical energy that undoubtedly went on during
this phase of apparent retrocession, and which broke out so im-
pressively at its close.
Now, just as in the Mesozoic Age, while the great reptiles lorded
it over the earth, there were developing in odd out-of-the-way
corners those hairy mammals and feathered birds who were finally
to supersede that tremendous fauna altogether by another far
RENASCENCE OF WESTERN CIVILIZATION
141
142 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
more versatile and capable, so in the limited territories of Western
Europe of the Middle Ages, while the Mongolian monarchies
dominated the world from the Danube to the Pacific and from the
Arctic seas to Madras and Morocco and the Nile, the fundamental
lines of a new and harder and more efficient type of human com-
munity were being laid down. This type of community, which
is still only in the phase of formation, which is still growing and
experimental, we may perhaps speak of as the ." modern state."
This is, we must recognize, a vague expression, but we shall en-
deavour to get meaning into it as we proceed. We have noted
the appearance of its main root ideas in the Greek republics and
especially in Athens, in the great Roman republic, in Judaism, in
Islam, and in the story of Western Catholicism. Essentially
this modern state, as we see it growing under our eyes to-day, is
a tentative combination of two apparently contradictory ideas,
the idea of a community of faith and obedience, such as the earliest
civilizations undoubtedly were, and the idea of a community 0}
will, such as were the primitive political groupings of the Nordic
and Hunnish peoples. For thousands of years the settled civilized
peoples, who were originally in most cases dark-white Cauca-
sians, or Dravidian or Southern Mongolian peoples, seem to
have developed their ideas and habits along the line of worship
and personal subjection, and the nomadic peoples theirs along the
line of personal self-reliance and self-assertion. Naturally enough
under the circumstances the nomadic peoples were always supply-
ing the civilizations with fresh rulers and new aristocracies.
That is the rhythm of all early history. It was only after thou-
sands of years of cyclic changes between refreshment by nomadic
conquest, civilization, decadence, and fresh conquest that the
present process of a mutual blending of " civilized" and "free"
tendencies into a new type of community, that now demands
our attention and which is the substance of contemporary history,
began.
We have traced in this history the slow development of larger
and larger "civilized" human communities from the days of such
a Palaeolithic family tribe as that described in Chapter IX. We
have seen how the advantages and necessities of cultivation, the fear
of tribal gods, the ideas of the priest-king and the god-king, played
RENASCENCE OF WESTERN CIVILIZATION 143
their part in consolidating continually larger and more powerful
societies in regions of maximum fertility. We have watched the
interplay of priest, who was usually native, and monarch, who
was usually a conqueror, in these early civilizations, the develop-
ment of a written tradition and its escape from priestly control,
and the appearance of novel forces, at first apparently incidental
and secondary, which we have called the free intelligence and the
free conscience of mankind. We have seen the rulers of the
primitive civilizations of the river valleys widening their area
and extending their sway, and simultaneously over the less fer-
tile areas of the earth we have seen mere tribal savagery develop
into a more and more united and politically competent nomadism.
Steadily and divergently mankind pursued one or other of these
two lines. For long ages all the civilizations grew and developed
along monarchist lines, upon lines of absolute monarchy, and in
every monarchy and dynasty we have watched, as if it were a
necessary process, efficiency and energy give way to pomp, in-
dolence, and decay, and finally succumb to some fresher lineage
from the desert or the steppe. The story of the early cultivat-
ing civilizations and their temples and courts and cities bulks
large in human history, but it is well to remember that the scene
of that story was never more than a very small part of the land
surface of the globe. Over the greater part of the earth until
quite recently, until the last two thousand years, the hardier,
less numerous tribal peoples of forest and parkland and the no-
madic peoples of the seasonal grasslands maintained and de-
veloped their own ways of life.
The primitive civilizations were, we may say, " communities
of obedience"; obedience to god-kings or kings under gods was
their cement; the nomadic tendency on the other hand has al-
ways been towards a different type of association which we shall
here call a "community of will." In a wandering, fighting com-
munity the individual must be at once self-reliant and disciplined.
The chiefs of such communities must be chiefs who are followed,
not masters who compel. This community of will is traceable
throughout the entire history of mankind; everywhere we find
the original disposition of all the nomads alike, Nordic, Semitic,
or Mongolian, was individually more willing and more erect than
144 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
that of the settled folk. The Nordic peoples came into Italy and
Greece under leader kings; they did not bring any systematic
temple cults with them, they found such things in the conquered
lands and adapted as they adopted them. The Greeks and
Latins lapsed very easily again into republics, and so did the
Aryans in India. There was a tradition of election also in the
early Frankish and German kingdoms.1 The early Caliphs were
elected, the Judges of Israel and the " kings" of Carthage and
Tyre were elected, and so was the Great Khan of the Mongols
until Kublai became a Chinese monarch. . . . Equally con-
stant in the settled lands do we find the opposite idea, the idea
of a non-elective divinity in kings and of their natural and in-
herent right to rule. ... As our history has developed we have
noted the appearance of new and complicating elements in the
story of human societies; we have seen that nomad turned go-
between, the trader, appear, and we have noted the growing
importance of shipping in the world. It seems as inevitable
that voyaging should make men free in their minds as that settle-
ment within a narrow horizon should make men timid and ser-
vile. . . . But in spite of all such complications, the broad antag-
onism between the method of obedience and the method of will
runs through history down into our own times. To this day their
reconciliation is incomplete.
Civilization even in its most servile forms has always offered
much that is enormously attractive, convenient, and congenial
to mankind; but something restless and untamed in our race
has striven continually to convert civilization from its original
reliance upon unparticipating obedience into a community of
participating wills. And to the lurking nomadism in our blood,
and particularly in the blood of monarchs and aristocracies, we
must ascribe also that incessant urgency towards a wider range
1 The early Frankish and other German kings were not elective. They were
hereditary ; but as there was no primogeniture, there was either partition among the
sons, or a struggle to decide which son or relative should succeed. In such a
struggle the nobles might take part, and this might mean some form of election.
But heredity is the thing : reges ex nobilitate sumunt, says Tacitus : the king must
have the nobility of being Woden-born, or he cannot be king. The genealogies
of our early Saxon kings all go back to Woden, and George V is Woden-born.
— E. B.
RENASCENCE OF WESTERN CIVILIZATION 145
that forces every state to extend its boundaries if it can, and to
spread its interests to the ends of the earth. The power of no-
madic restlessness that tends to bring all the earth under one rule,
seems to be identical with the spirit that makes most of us chafe
under direction and restraint, and seek to participate in what-
ever government we tolerate. And this natural, this tempera-
mental struggle of mankind to reconcile civilization with free-
dom has been kept alive age after age by the military and
political impotence of every "community of obedience" that
has ever existed. Obedience, once men are broken to it, can
be easily captured and transferred; witness the passive role
of Egypt, Mesopotamia, and India, the original and typical
lands of submission, the "cradles of civilization, " as they have
passed from one lordship to another. A servile civilization is
a standing invitation to predatory free men. But on the other
hand a "community of will" necessitates a fusion of intract-
able materials; it is a far harder community to bring about,
and still more difficult to maintain. The story of Alexander
the Great displays the community of will of the Macedonian
captains gradually dissolving before his demand that they should
worship him. The incident of the murder of Clitus is quite
typical of the struggle between the free and the servile tradi-
tion that went on whenever a new conqueror from the open
lands and the open air found himself installed in the palace of
an ancient monarchy.
In the case of the Roman Republic, history tells of the first
big community of will in the world's history, the first free com-
munity much larger than a city, and how it weakened with growth
and spent itself upon success until at last it gave way to a mon-
archy of the ancient type, and decayed swiftly into one of the
feeblest communities of servitude that ever collapsed before a
handful of invaders. We have given some attention in this book
to the factors in that decay, because they are of primary im-
portance in human history. One of the most evident was the
want of any wide organization of education to base the ordinary-
citizens' minds upon the idea of service and obligation to the
republic, to keep them willing, that is ; another was the absence
of any medium of general information to keep their activities in
146 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
harmony, to enable them to will as one body. The community
of will is limited in size by the limitations set upon the possi-
bilities of a community of knowledge. The concentration of
property in a few hands and the replacement of free workers by
slaves were rendered possible by the decay of public spirit and the
confusion of the public intelligence that resulted from these limi-
tations. There was, moreover, no efficient religious idea behind
the Roman state; the dark Etruscan liver-peering cult of Rome
was as little adapted to the political needs of a great community
as the very similar Shamanism of the Mongols. It is in the fact
that both Christianity and Islam, in their distinctive ways, did
at least promise to supply, for the first time in human experience,
this patent gap in the Roman republican system as well as in the
nomadic system, to give a common moral education for a mass
of people, and to supply them with a common history of the past
and a common idea of a human purpose and destiny, that their
enormous historical importance lies. Aristotle, as we have noted,
had set a limit to the ideal community of a few thousand citizens,
because he could not conceive how a larger multitude could be
held together by a common idea. He had had no experience of
any sort of education beyond the tutorial methods of his time.
Greek education was almost purely viva-voce education; it could
reach therefore only to a limited aristocracy. Both the Chris-
tian church and Islam demonstrated the unsoundness of Aris-
totle's limitation. We may think they did their task of educa-
tion in their vast fields of opportunity crudely or badly, but the
point of interest to us is that they did it at all. Both sustained
almost world-wide propagandas of idea and inspiration. Both
relied successfully upon the power of the written word to link
great multitudes of diverse men together in common enterprises.
By the eleventh century, as we have seen, the idea of Christen-
dom had been imposed upon all the vast warring miscellany of
the smashed and pulverized Western empire, and upon Europe
far beyond its limits, as a uniting and inspiring idea. It had
made a shallow but effective community of will over an unprece-
dented area and out of an unprecedented multitude of human
beings. Only one other thing at all like this had ever happened
to any great section of mankind before, and that was the idea of a
RENASCENCE OF WESTERN CIVILIZATION 147
community of good behaviour that the literati had spread through-
out China.1
The Catholic Church provided what the Roman Republic
had lacked, a system of popular teaching, a number of univer-
sities and methods of intellectual inter-communication. By this
achievement it opened the way to the new possibilities of human
government that now become apparent in this Outline, possi-
bilities that are still being apprehended and worked out in the
world in which we are living. Hitherto the government of states
had been either authoritative, under some uncriticized and un-
challenged combination of priest and monarch, or it had been a
democracy, uneducated and uninformed, degenerating with any
considerable increase of size, as Rome and Athens did, into a
mere rule by mob and politician. But by the thirteenth century
the first intimations had already dawned of an ideal of govern-
ment which is still making its way to realization, the modern
ideal, the ideal of a world-wide educational government, in which
the ordinary man is neither the slave of an absolute monarch nor
of a demagogue-ruled state, but an informed, inspired, and con-
sulted part of his community. It is upon the word educational
that stress must be laid, and upon the idea that information must
precede consultation. It is in the practical realization of this
idea 2 that education is a collective function and not a private
affair that one essential distinction of the " modern state " from
any of its precursors lies. The modern citizen, men are coming
to realize, must be informed first and then consulted. Before
he can vote he must hear the evidence ; before he can decide he
must know. It is not by setting up polling booths, but by setting
UP schools and making literature, and knowledge and news uni-
versally accessible that the way is opened from servitude and con-
fusion to that willingly co-operative state which is the modern ideal. /
Votes in themselves are worthless things. Men had votes in Italy
in the time of the Gracchi. Their votes did not help them. Until /
a man has education, a vote is a useless and dangerous thing for I
him to possess. The ideal community towards which we move
1 But the Jews were already holding their community together by systematic
education at least *as early as the beginning of the Christian era.
2 The Greeks had this idea. — E. B.
148 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
is not a community of will simply ; it is a community of know-
ledge and will, replacing a community of faith and obedience. Educa-
tion is the adapter which will make the nomadic spirit of freedom
and self-reliance compatible with the co-operations and wealth
and security of civilization.
§2
But though it is certain that the Catholic Church, through
its propagandas, its popular appeals, its schools and universities,
opened up the prospect of the modern educational state in Europe,
it is equally certain that the Catholic Church never intended to
do anything of the sort. It did not send out knowledge with
its blessing ; it let it loose inadvertently. It was not the Roman
Republic whose heir the Church esteemed itself, but the Roman
Emperor. Its conception of education was not release, not an
invitation to participate, but the subjugation of minds. Two
of the greatest educators of the Middle Ages were indeed not
churchmen at all, but monarchs and statesmen, Charlemagne
and Alfred the Great of England, who made use of the church
organization. But it was the church that had provided the
organization. Church and monarchs in their mutual grapple
for power were both calling to their aid the thoughts of the com-
mon man. In response to these conflicting appeals appeared the
common man, the unofficial outside independent man, thinking
for himself.
Already in the thirteenth century we have seen Pope Gregory
IX and the Emperor Frederick II engaging in a violent public
controversy. Already then there was a sense that a new arbi-
trator greater than pope or monarchy had come into the world,
that there were readers and a public opinion. The exodus of the
Popes to Avignon, and the divisions and disorders of the Papacy
during the fourteenth century, stimulated this free judgment upon
authority throughout Europe enormously.
At first the current criticism upon the church concerned only
moral and material things. The wealth and luxury of the higher
clergy and the heavy papal taxation were the chief grounds of
complaint. And the earlier attempts to restore Christian sim-
plicity, the foundation of the Franciscans for example, were not
movements of separation, but movements of revival. Only later
RENASCENCE OF WESTERN CIVILIZATION 149
did a deeper and more distinctive criticism develop which at-
tacked the central fact of the church's teaching and the justifica-
tion of priestly importance, namely, the sacrifice of the mass.
We have sketched in broad outlines the early beginnings of
Christianity, and we have shown how rapidly that difficult and
austere conception of the Kingdom of God, which was the central
idea of the teachings of Jesus of Nazareth, was overlaid by a re-
vival of the ancient sacrificial idea, a doctrine more difficult indeed
to grasp, but easier to reconcile with the habits and dispositions
and acquiescences of everyday life in the Near East. We have
noted how a sort of theocrasia went on between Christianity and
Judaism and the cult of the Serapeum and Mithraism and other
competing cults, by which the Mithraist Sun-day, the Jewish
idea of blood as a religious essential, the Alexandrian importance
of the Mother of God, the shaven and fasting priest, self -torment-
ing asceticism, and many other matters of belief and ritual and
practice, became grafted upon the developing religion. These
adaptations, no doubt, made the new teaching much more under-
standable and acceptable in Egypt and Syria and the like. There
were things in the way of thought of the dark-white Mediter-
ranean race ; they were congenial to that type. But as we have
shown in our story of Muhammad, these acquisitions did not
make Christianity more acceptable to the Arab nomads ; to them
these features made it disgusting. And so, too, the robed and
shaven monk and nun and priest seem to have roused something
like an instinctive hostility in the Nordic barbarians of the North
and West. We have noted the peculiar bias of the early Anglo-
Saxons and Northmen against the monks and nuns. They seem
to have felt that the lives and habits of these devotees were queer
and unnatural.
The clash between what we may call the " dark- white" factors
and the newer elements in Christianity was no doubt intensified
by Pope Gregory VIFs imposition of celibacy upon the Catholic
priests in the eleventh century. The East had known religious
celibates for thousands of years ; in the West they were regarded
with the profoundest scepticism and suspicion.1
1 1 do not think this is just. The Anglo-Saxons were not anti-monastic. They
were converted by Benedictine monks in 600 ; just after 700 they sent out monks to
150 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
And now in the thirteenth and fourteenth centuries, as the lay
mind of the Nordic peoples began to acquire learning, to read
and write and express itself, and as it came into touch with the
stimulating activities of the Arab mind, we find a much more
formidable criticism of Catholicism beginning, an intellectual
attack upon the priest as priest, and upon the ceremony of the
mass as the central fact of the religious life, coupled with a demand
for a return to the personal teachings of Jesus as recorded in the
Gospels.
We have already mentioned the career of the Englishman Wyc-
liffe (c. 1320-1384), and how he translated the Bible into Eng-
lish in order to set up a counter authority to that of the Pope.
He denounced the doctrines of the church about the mass as
disastrous error, and particularly the teaching that the conse-
crated bread eaten in that ceremony becomes in some magical
way the actual body of Christ. We will not pursue the question
of transubstantiation, as this process of the mystical change of
the elements in the sacrament is called, into its intricacies. These
are matters for the theological specialist. But it will be obvious
that any doctrine, such as the Catholic doctrine, which makes
the consecration of the elements in the sacrament a miraculous
process performed by the priest, and only to be performed by the
priest, and which makes the sacrament the central necessity of
the religious system, enhances the importance of the priestly order
enormously. On the other hand, the view, which was the typical
" Protestant" view, that this sacrament is a mere eating of bread
and drinking of wine as a personal remembrance of Jesus of Naza-
reth, does away at last with any particular need for a consecrated
priest at all. Wycliffe himself did not go to this extremity; he
was a priest, and he remained a priest to the end of his life, but
his doctrine raised a question that carried men far beyond his
positions. From the point of view of the historian the struggle
convert Germany ; about 960, under Dunstan and Edgar, they experienced a mo-
nastic revival. The Normans after 1066 introduced the Cluniac and Cistercian
orders, and spread monasticism, while the earlier Northmen, after 900, were quite
favourable to the Church in England.
Note that Gregory's imposition of celibacy on the clergy was accepted, and will-
ingly accepted, by the contemporary lay world. William the Conqueror, through
Archbishop Lanfranc, enforced celibacy in England. — E. B.
RENASCENCE OF WESTERN CIVILIZATION 151
against Rome that Wycliffe opened became very speedily a
struggle of what one may call rational or layman's religion making
its appeal to the free intelligence and the free conscience in man-
kind, against authoritative, traditional, ceremonial, and priestly
religion. The ultimate tendency of this complicated struggle was
to strip Christianity as bare as Islam of every vestige of ancient
priestcraft, to revert to the Bible documents as authority, and to
recover, if possible, the primordial teachings of Jesus. Most of
its issues are still undecided among Christians to this day.1
WyclifiVs writings had nowhere more influence than in Bo-
hemia. About 1396 a learned Czech, John Huss, delivered a series
of lectures in the university of Prague based upon the doctrines
of the great Oxford teacher. Huss became rector of the univer-
sity, and rns teachings roused the church to excommunicate him
(1412). This was at the time of the Great Schism, just before
the Council of Constance (1414-1418) gathered to discuss the
scandalous disorder of the church. We have already told (chap,
xxxiii, § 13) how the schism was ended by the election of Martin
V. The council aspired to reunite Christendom completely.
But the methods by which it sought this reunion jar with our
modern consciences. Wycliffe's bones were condemned to be
burnt. Huss was decoyed to Constance under promise of a
safe conduct, and he was then put upon his trial for heresy. He
was ordered to recant certain of his opinions. He replied that
he could not recant until he was convinced of his error. He
was told that it was his duty to recant if his superiors required
it of him, whether he was convinced or not. He refused to ac-
cept this view. In spite of the Emperor's safe conduct, he was
burnt alive (1415), a martyr not for any specific doctrine, but
for the free intelligence and free conscience of mankind.
It would be impossible to put the issue between priest and anti-
priest more clearly than it was put at this trial of John Huss,
or to demonstrate more completely the evil spirit in priestcraft.
A colleague of Huss, Jerome of Prague, was burnt in the following
year.
1 Wycliffe believed in a real presence — but he held that it was spiritual and not
substantial. The host was two things — bread, and at the same time a spiritual
Christ. This is not the "memorial" view. — E. B.
152 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
These outrages were followed by an insurrection of the Hus-
sites in Bohemia (1419), the first of a series of religious wars that
marked the breaking-up of Christendom. In 1420, the Pope,
Martin V, issued a bull proclaiming a crusade "for the destruc-
tion of the Wycliffites, Hussites, and all other heretics in Bo-
hemia," and attracted by this invitation the unemployed soldiers
of fortune, and all the drifting blackguardism of Europe con-
verged upon that valiant country. They found in Bohemia,
under its great leader Ziska, more hardship and less loot than
crusaders were disposed to face. The Hussites were conducting
their affairs upon extreme democratic lines, and the whole coun-
try was aflame with enthusiasm. The crusaders beleaguered
Prague, but failed to take it, and they experienced a series of re-
verses that ended in their retreat from Bohemia. A second
crusade (1421) was no more successful. Two other crusades failed.
Then unhappily the Hussites fell into internal dissensions. En-
couraged by this, a fifth crusade (1431) crossed the frontier under
Frederick, Margrave of Brandenburg.
The army of these crusaders, according to the lowest esti-
mates, consisted of 90,000 infantry and 40,000 horsemen. At-
tacking Bohemia from the west, they first laid siege to the town
of Tachov, but failing to capture the strongly fortified city, they
stormed the little town of Most, and here, as well as in the sur-
rounding country, committed the most horrible atrocities on a
population a large part of which was entirely innocent of any form
of theology whatever. The crusaders, advancing by slow marches,
penetrated further into Bohemia, till they reached the neighbour-
hood of the town of Domazlice (Tauss). "It was at three o'clock
on August 14th, 1431, that the crusaders, who were encamped
in the plain between Domazlice and Horsuv Tyn, received the
news that the Hussites, under the leadership of Prokop the Great,
were approaching. Though the Bohemians were still four miles
off, the rattle of their war-wagons and the song, ' All ye warriors
of God/ which their whole host was chanting, could already be
heard." The enthusiasm of the crusaders evaporated with as-
tounding rapidity. Liitzow l describes how the papal representa-
tive and the Duke of Saxony ascended a convenient hill to inspect
1 Liitzow's Bohemia.
N
RENASCENCE OF WESTERN CIVILIZATION 153
the battlefield. It was, they discovered, not going to be a battle-
field. The German camp was in utter confusion. Horsemen
were streaming off in every direction, and the clatter of empty
wagons being driven off almost drowned the sound of that terrible
singing. The crusaders were abandoning even their loot. Came
a message from the Margrave of Brandenburg advising flight;
there was no holding any of their troops. They were dangerous
now only to their own side, and the papal representative spent
an unpleasant night hiding from them in the forest. ... So
ended the Bohemian crusade.
In 1434 civil war again broke out among the Hussites, in which
the extreme and most valiant section was defeated, and in 1436
an agreement was patched up between the Council of Basle and
the moderate Hussites, in which the Bohemian church was al-
lowed to retain certain distinctions from the general Catholic
practice, which held good until the German Reformation in the
sixteenth century.
§3
The split among the Hussites was largely due to the drift of the
extremer section towards a primitive communism, which alarmed
the wealthier and more influential Czech noblemen. Similar
tendencies had already appeared among the English Wycliff-
ites. They seem to follow naturally enough upon the doctrines
of equal human brotherhood that emerge whenever there is an
attempt to reach back to the fundamentals of Christianity.
The development of such ideas had been greatly stimulated by
a stupendous misfortune that had swept the world and laid bare
the foundations of society, a pestilence of unheard-of virulence.
It was called the Black Death, and it came nearer to the extirpa-
tion of mankind than any other evil has ever done. It was far
more deadly than the plague of Pericles, or the plague of Marcus
Aurelius, or the plague waves of the time of Justinian and Gregory
the Great that paved the way for the Lombards in Italy. It arose
in South Russia or Central Asia, and came by way of the Crimea
and a Genoese ship to Genoa and Western Europe. It passed
by Armenia to Asia Minor, Egypt, and North Africa. It reached
England in 1348. Two thirds of the students at Oxford died,
154 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
we are told; it is estimated that between a quarter and a half
of the whole population of England perished at this time.
Throughout all Europe there was as great a mortality. Hecker
estimates the total as twenty-five million dead. It spread east-
ward to China, where, the Chinese records say, thirteen million
people perished. In China the social disorganization led to a
neglect of the river embankments, and as a consequence great
floods devastated the crowded agricultural lands.1
Never was there so clear a warning to mankind to seek know-
ledge and cease from bickering, to unite against the dark powers
of nature. All the massacres of Hulagu and Timurlane were
as nothing to this. " Its ravages/' says J. R. Green, " were fiercest
in the greater towns, where filthy and undrained streets afforded
a constant haunt to leprosy and fever. In the burial-ground
which the piety of Sir Walter Manny purchased for the citizens
of London, a spot whose site was afterwards marked by the Charter
House, more than fifty thousand corpses are said to have been
interred. Thousands of people perished at Norwich, while in
Bristol the living were hardly able to bury the dead. But the
Black Death fell on the villages almost as fiercely as on the towns.
More than one half of the priests of Yorkshire are known to have
perished ; in the diocese of Norwich two thirds of the parishes
changed their incumbents. The whole organization of labour
was thrown out of gear. The scarcity of hands made it difficult
for the minor tenants to perform the services due for their lands,
and only a temporary abandonment of half the rent by the land-
owners induced the farmers to refrain from the abandonment of
their farms. For a time cultivation became impossible. 'The
sheep and cattle strayed through the fields and corn/ says a con-
temporary, 'and there were none left who could drive them.'"
It was from these distresses that the peasant wars of the four-
teenth century sprang. There was a great shortage of labour
and a great shortage of goods, and the rich abbots and monastic
cultivators who owned so much of the land, and the nobles
1 Dr. C. O. Stallybrass says that this plague reached China thirty or forty years
after its first appearance in Europe. Ibn Batuta, the Arab traveller, who was
in China from 1342 to 1346, first met with it on his return to Damascus. The
Black Death is the human form of a disease endemic among the jerboas and other
small rodents in thejdistricts round the head of the Caspian Sea.
RENASCENCE OF WESTERN CIVILIZATION
155
and rich merchants, were too ignorant of economic laws to
understand that they must not press upon the toilers in this
time of general distress. They saw their
property deteriorating, their lands going out
of cultivation, and they made violent stat-
utes to compel men to work without any
rise in wages, and to prevent their straying
in search of better employment. Naturally
enough this provoked "a new revolt against
the whole system of social inequality which
had till then passed unquestioned as the di-
vine order of the world. The cry of the poor
found a terrible utterance in the words of 'a
mad priest of Kent,' as the courtly Froissart
calls him, who for twenty years (1360-1381)
found audience for his sermons, in defiance of
interdict and imprisonment, in the stout yeo-
men who gathered in the Kentish church-
yards. ' Mad, ' as the landowners called him,
it was in the preaching of John Ball that
England first listened to a declaration of
natural equality and the rights of man.
'Good people/ cried the preacher, 'things
will never go well in England so long as goods
be not in common, and so long as there be
villeins and gentlemen. By what right are
they whom we call lords greater folk than
we? On what grounds have they deserved
it ? Why do they hold us in serfage ? If we
all came of the same father and mother, of
Adam and Eve, how can they say or prove
that they are better than we, if it be not that
they make us gain for them by our toil what
they spend in their pride? They are clothed
in velvet and warm in their furs and their
ermines, while we are covered with rags. They have wine and
spices and fair bread ; and we oat-cake and straw, and water to
drink. They have leisure and fine houses; we have pain and
156 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
labour, the rain and the wind in the fields. And yet it is of us
and of our toil that these men hold their state.' A spirit fatal to
the whole system of the Middle Ages breathed in the popular
rhyme which condensed the levelling doctrine of John Ball : ' When
Adam delved and Eve span, who was then the gentleman? '" 1
Wat Tyler, the leader of the English insurgents, was assassi-
nated by the Mayor of London in the presence of the young
King Richard II (1381), and his movement collapsed. The
communist side of the Hussite movement was a part of the same
system of disturbance. A little earlier than the English out-
break had occurred the French ''Jacquerie" (1358), in which
the French peasants had risen, burnt chateaux, and devastated
the country-side. A century later the same urgency was to
sweep Germany into a series of bloody Peasant Wars. These
began late in the fifteenth century. Economic and religious
disturbance mingled in the case of Germany even more plainly
than in England. One conspicuous phase of these German troubles
was the Anabaptist outbreak. The sect of the Anabaptists ap-
peared in Wittenberg in 1521 under three "prophets," and broke
out into insurrection in 1525. Between 1532 and 1535 the in-
surgents held the town of Miinster in Westphalia, and did their ut-
most to realize their ideas of a religious communism. They were
besieged by the Bishop of Munster, and under the distresses of
the siege a sort of insanity ran rife in the town; cannibalism is
said to have occurred, and a certain John of Leyden seized power,
proclaimed himself the successor of King David, and followed
1 The seeds of conflict which grew up into the Peasants' Revolt of 1381 were
sown upon ground which is strangely familiar to any writer in 1920. A European
catastrophe had reduced production and consequently increased the earnings of
workers and traders. Rural wages had risen by 48 per cent in England, when an
unwise executive endeavored to enforce in the Ordinance and Statute of Labourers
(1350-51) a return to the pre-plague wages and prices of 1346, and aimed a blow
in the Statute of 1378 against labour combinations. The villeins were driven to '
desperation by the loss of their recent increase of comfort, and the outbreak came,
as Froissart saw it from the angle of the Court, "all through the too great comfort
of the commonalty." Other ingredients which entered into the outbreak were the
resentment felt by the new working class at the restrictions imposed on its right to
combine, the objection of the lower clergy to papal taxes, and a frank dislike of
foreigners and landlords. There was no touch of Wycliffe's influence in the rising.
It was at its feeblest in Leicestershire, and it murdered one of the only other Liberal
churchmen in England. — P. G.
RENASCENCE OF WESTERN CIVILIZATION 157
that monarch's evil example by practising polygamy. After
the surrender of the city the victorious bishop had the Ana-
baptist leaders tortured very horribly and executed in the market-
place, their mutilated bodies being hung in cages from a church
tower to witness to all the world that decency and order were
now restored in Miinster. . . .
These upheavals of the common labouring men of the Western
European countries in the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries
were more serious and sustained than anything that had ever hap-
pened in history before. The nearest previous approach to them
were certain communistic Muhammadan movements in Persia.
There was a peasant revolt in Normandy about A.D. 1000, and
there were revolts of peasants (Bagaudse) in the later Roman Em-
pire, but these were not nearly so formidable. They show a new
spirit growing in human affairs, a spirit altogether different from
the unquestioning apathy of the serfs and peasants in the original
regions of civilization or from the anarchist hopelessness of the
serf and slave labour of the Roman capitalists. All these early
insurrections of the workers that we have mentioned were sup-
pressed with much cruelty, but the movement itself was never
completely stamped out. From that time to this there has been
a spirit of revolt in the lower levels of the pyramid of civiliza-
tion. There have been phases of insurrection, phases of repres-
sion, phases of compromise and comparative pacification; but
from that time until this, the struggle has never wholly ceased.
We shall see it flaring out during the French Revolution at the
end of the eighteenth century, insurgent again in the middle and
at the opening of the last quarter of the nineteenth century, and
achieving vast proportions in the world of to-day. The social-
ist movement of the nineteenth century was only one version of
that continuing revolt.
In many countries, in France and Germany and Russia, for
example, this labour movement has assumed at times an atti-
tude hostile to Christianity, but there can be little doubt that
this steady and, on the whole, growing pressure of the common
man in the West against a life of toil and subservience is closely
associated with Christian teaching. The church and the Chris-
tian missionary may not have intended to spread equalitarian
158 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
doctrines, but behind the church was the unquenchable personality
of Jesus of Nazareth, and even in spite of himself the Christian
preacher brought the seeds of freedom and responsibility with
him, and sooner or later they shot up where he had been.
This steady and growing upheaval of "Labour/' its develop-
ment of a consciousness of itself as a class and of a definite claim
upon the world at large, quite as much as the presence of schools
and universities, quite as much as abundant printed books and a
developing and expanding process of scientific research, mark
off our present type of civilization, the " modern civilization,"
from any pre-existing state of human society, and mark it, for
all its incidental successes, as a thing unfinished and transitory.
It is an embryo or it is something doomed to die. It may be
able to solve this complex problem of co-ordinated toil and happi-
ness, and so adjust itself to the needs of the human soul, or it may
fail and end in a catastrophe as the Roman system did. It may
be the opening phase of some more balanced and satisfying order
of society, or it may be a system destined to disruption and re-
placement by some differently conceived method of human as-
sociation. Like its predecessor, our present civilization may be
no more than one of those crops farmers sow to improve their
land by the fixation of nitrogen from the air ; it may have grown
only that, accumulating certain traditions, it may be ploughed
into the soil again for better things to follow. Such questions as
these are the practical realities of history, and in all that follows
we shall find them becoming clearer and more important, until
in our last chapter we shall end, as all our days and years end,
with a recapitulation of our hopes and fears — and a note of in-
terrogation.
§4
The development of free discussion in Europe during this age
of fermentation was enormously stimulated by the appearance of
printed books. It was the introduction of paper from the East
that made practicable the long latent method of printing. It is
still difficult to assign the honour of priority in the use of the
simple expedient of printing for multiplying books. It is a trivial
question that has been preposterously debated.1 Apparently
1 See article "Typography" in the Encyclo. Brit.
RENASCENCE OF WESTERN CIVILIZATION 159
the glory, such as it is, belongs to Holland. In Haarlem, one
Coster was printing from movable type somewhen before 1446.
Gutenberg was printing at Mainz about the same time. There
were printers in Italy by 1465, and Caxton set up his press in West-
minster in 1477. But long before this time there had been a partial
use of printing. Manuscripts as early as the twelfth century
display initial letters that may have been printed from wooden
stamps.
Far more important is the question of the manufacture of paper.
It is scarcely too much to say that paper made the revival of Europe
possible. Paper originated in China, where its use probably
goes back to the second century B.C. In 751 the Chinese made an
attack upon the Arab Moslems in Samarkand; they were re-
pulsed, and among the prisoners taken from them were some
skilled paper-makers, from whom the art was learnt. Arabic
paper manuscripts from the ninth century onward still exist.
The manufacture entered Christendom either through Greece
or by the capture of Moorish paper-mills during the Christian
reconquest of Spain. But under the Christian Spanish the
product deteriorated sadly. Good paper was not made in Chris-
tian Europe until near the end of the thirteenth century, and then
it was Italy which led the world. Only by the fourteenth cen-
tury did the manufacture reach Germany, and not until the end
of that century was it abundant and cheap enough for the print-
ing of books to be a practicable business proposition. There-
upon printing followed naturally and necessarily, and the in-
tellectual life of the world entered upon a new and far more vig-
orous phase. It ceased to be a little trickle from mind to mind ;
it became a broad flood, in which thousands and presently scores
and hundreds of thousands of minds participated.
One immediate result of this achievement of printing was the
appearance of an abundance of Bibles in the world. Another was
a cheapening of school-books. The knowledge of reading spread
swiftly. There was not only a great increase of books in the
world, but the books that were now made were plainer to read
and so easier to understand. Instead of toiling at a crabbed
text and then thinking over its significance, readers now could
think unimpeded as they read. With this increase in the facility
160 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
of reading, the reading public grew. The book ceased to be a
highly decorated toy or a scholar's mystery. People began to
write books to be read as well as looked at by ordinary people.
With the fourteenth century the real history of the European
literatures begins. We find a rapid development of standard
Italian, standard English, standard French, standard Spanish,
and standard German.1 These languages became literary lan-
guages; they were tried over, polished by use, and made exact
and vigorous. They became at last as capable of the burden of
philosophical discussion as Greek or Latin.
§5
Here we devote a section to certain elementary statements
about the movement in men's religious ideas during the fifteenth
and sixteenth centuries. They are a necessary introduction
to the political history of the seventeenth and eighteenth cen-
turies that follows in Chapter XXXVI.
We have to distinguish clearly between two entirely different
systems of opposition to the Catholic church. They intermingled
very confusingly. The church was losing its hold upon the con-
sciences of princes and rich and able people ; it was also losing the
faith and confidence of common people. The effect of its decline
of spiritual power upon the former class was to make them resent
its interference, its moral restrictions, its claims to overlordship,
its claim to tax, and to dissolve allegiances. They ceased to re-
spect its power and its property. This insubordination of princes
and rulers was going on throughout the Middle Ages, but it was
only when in the sixteenth century the church began to side openly
with its old antagonist the Emperor, when it offered him its sup-
port and accepted his help in its campaign against heresy, that
princes began to think seriously of breaking away from the Roman
communion and setting up fragments of a church. And they
would never have done so if they had not perceived that the hold
of the church upon the masses of mankind had relaxed.
The revolt of the princes was essentially an irreligious revolt
against the world-rule of the church. The Emperor Frederick
1 Standard Italian dates from Dante (1300) ; standard English from Chaucer
and Wycliffe (1380) ; standard German from Luther (1520). — E. B.
RENASCENCE OF WESTERN CIVILIZATION 161
II, with his epistles to his fellow princes, was its forerunner. The
revolt of the people against the church, on the other hand, was
as essentially religious. They objected not to the church's power,
but to its weaknesses. They wanted a deeply righteous and
fearless church to help them and organize them against the wicked-
ness of powerful men. Their movements against the church, within
it and without, were movements not for release from a religious
control, but for a fuller and more abundant religious control.
They did not want less religious control, but more — but they
wanted to be assured that it was religious. They objected to
the Pope not because he was the religious head of the world, but
because he was not; because he was a wealthy earthly prince
when he ought to have been their spiritual leader.
The contest in Europe from the fourteenth century onward
therefore was a three-cornered contest. The princes wanted to
use the popular forces against the Pope, but not to let those forces
grow too powerful for their own power and glory. For a long
time the church went from prince to prince for an ally without
realizing that the lost ally it needed to recover was popular venera-
tion.
Because of this triple aspect of the mental and moral con-
flicts that were going on in the fourteenth and fifteenth and six-
teenth centuries, the series of ensuing changes, those changes
that are known collectively in history as the Reformation, took
on a threefold aspect. There was the Reformation according
to the princes, who wanted to stop the flow of money to Rome
and to seize the moral authority, the educational power, and the
material possessions of the church within their dominions. There
was the Reformation according to the people, who sought to make
Christianity a power against unrighteousness, and particularly
against the unrighteousness of the rich and powerful. And finally
there was the Reformation within the church, of which St. Francis
of Assisi was the precursor, which sought to restore the good-
ness of the church and, through its goodness, to restore its power.
The Reformation according to the princes took the form of a
replacement of the Pope by the prince as the head of the religion
and the controller of the consciences of his people. The princes
had no idea and no intention of letting free the judgments of their
162 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
subjects more particularly with the object-lessons of the Hus-
sites and the Anabaptists before their eyes; they sought to es-
tablish national churches dependent upon the throne. As Eng-
land, Scotland, Sweden, Norway, Denmark, North Germany,
and Bohemia broke away from the Roman communion, the princes
and other ministers showed the utmost solicitude to keep the
movement well under control. Just as much reformation as would
sever the link with Rome they permitted ; anything beyond that,
any dangerous break towards the primitive teachings of Jesus
or the crude direct interpretation of the Bible, they resisted.
The Established Church of England is one of the most typical
and successful of the resulting compromises. It is still sacramental
and sacerdotal ; but its organization centres in the Court and the
Lord Chancellor, and though subversive views may, and do,
break out in the lower and less prosperous ranks of its priesthood,
it is impossible for them to struggle up to any position of in-
fluence and authority.
The Reformation according to the common man was very
different in spirit from the Princely Reformation. We have al-
ready told something of the popular attempts at Reformation
in Bohemia and Germany. The wide spiritual upheavals of the
time were at once more honest, more confused, more enduring,
and less immediately successful than the reforms of the princes.
Very few religious-spirited men had the daring to break away
or the effrontery to confess that they had broken away from all
authoritative teaching, and that they were now relying entirely
upon their own minds and consciences. That required a very
high intellectual courage. The general drift of the common
man in this period in Europe was to set up his new acquisition,
the Bible, as a counter authority to the church. This was par-
ticularly the case with the great leader of German Protestantism,
Martin Luther (1483-1546). All over Germany, and indeed all
over Western Europe, there were now men spelling over the black-
letter pages of the newly translated and printed Bible, over the
Book of Leviticus and the Song of Solomon and the Revelation
of St. John the Divine — strange and perplexing books — quite
as much as over the simple and inspiring record of Jesus in the
Gospels. Naturally they produced strange views and grotesque
RENASCENCE OF WESTERN CIVILIZATION 163
interpretations. It is surprising that they were not stranger and
grotesquer. But the human reason is an obstinate thing, and will
criticize and select in spite of its own resolutions. The bulk of
these new Bible students took what their consciences approved
from the Bible and ignored its riddles and contradictions. All
over Europe, wherever the new Protestant churches of the princes
were set up, a living and very active residuum of Protestants re-
mained who declined to have their religion made over for them in
this fashion. These were the Nonconformists, a medley of sects,
having nothing in common but their resistance to authoritative
religion, whether of the Pope or the State.1 Most but not all
of these Nonconformists held to the Bible as a divinely inspired
and authoritative guide. This was a strategic rather than an
abiding position, and the modern drift of Nonconformity has
been onward away from this original Bibliolatry towards a miti-
gated and sentimentalized recognition of the bare teachings of
Jesus of Nazareth. Beyond the range of Nonconformity, be-
yond the range of professed Christianity at all, there is also now a
great and growing mass of equalitarian belief and altruistic im-
pulse in the modern civilizations, which certainly owes, as we
have already asserted, its spirit to Christianity, which began to
appear in Europe as the church lost its grip upon the general
mind.2
1 But Nonconformity was stamped out in Germany. See § 11 B of this chapter.
2 "If I were writing a history of democracy," comments E. B., "I should deal
first with democracy in religion, which is Calvinism, founded by a great Frenchman
at Geneva, and then with democracy in politics, which is the French Revolution,
inaugurated by another great Frenchman at Geneva, Rousseau. (The parallel of
these two is striking — both typical exponents of the French genius, in its ardent
logic and its apostolic fervour which gives in a burning lava to the world the findings
of its logic.) It is noticeable in England how democracy in religion (Presby-
terianism, which is simply Calvinism, plus Independency or Congregationalism)
leads straight under the Stuarts to the English democratic ideas of the seventeenth
century. I do not think the democratic element in Protestantism is sufficiently
appreciated in the text. Even Luther, in the early days of 1520, could write The
Freedom of a Christian Man and champion the priesthood of each believer and his
direct access to his Maker. Luther, it is true, changed by 1525, and became a
monarchist, the apostle of a state religion, under a godly prince who was summus
episcopus. Anglicanism was from the first a monarchist religion, under a Henry
VIII who was supremum caput. But if Lutheranism became, and Anglicanism was
from the first, a religion of the State, Calvinism was always the religion of resistance
to the State — in Holland and in Scotland most especially. The Reformation thus
164
THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
Let us say a word now of the third phase of the Reformation
process, the Reformation within the church. This was already
beginning in the twelfth and thirteenth centuries with the ap-
pearance of the Black and Grey Friars (chap, xxxiii, § 13). In
the sixteenth century, and when it was most needed, came a
fresh impetus of the same kind. This was the foundation of the
Society of the Jesuits by
Inigo Lopez de Recalde, better
known to the world of to-day
as Saint Ignatius of Loyola.
Ignatius began his career
as a very tough and gal-
lant young Spaniard. He was
clever and dexterous and in-
spired by a passion for pluck,
hardihood, and rather showy
glory. His love affairs were
free and picturesque. In 1521
the French took the town of
Pampeluna in Spain from the
Emperor Charles V, and Ig-
natius was one of the defenders. His legs were smashed by a
cannon-ball, and he was taken prisoner. One leg was badly set
and had to be broken again, and these painful and complex oper-
ations nearly cost him his life. He received the last sacraments.
In the night, thereafter, he began to mend, and presently he was
convalescent and facing the prospect of a life in which he would
perhaps always be a cripple. His thoughts turned to the adven-
produced two opposite effects in politics ; so far as it was Lutheran and Anglican it
was monarchist ; so far as it was Calvinistic, it was democratic. It is at first sight
curious, but it is really quite natural, that the Catholics of the counter-reformation
should also have been democratic. The Catholics could not admit the control
of the monarch in the sphere of religion any more than the Calvinist ; and here, as
in other things (e.g. in the claim to possession of infallible truth), the Catholic
priest and the Calvinistic presbyter were agreed. Filmer, an exponent of Anglican
monarchism, expresses this well when he says, in speaking of the doctrine of a
social contract, that ' Cardinal Bellarmine and Calvin both look asquint this way.'
For the doctrine of a social contract was the democratic doctrine put forward by
Catholics and Calvinists in opposition to the Lutheran and Anglican doctrine of
divine right."
RENASCENCE OF WESTERN CIVILIZATION 165
ture of religion. Sometimes he would think of a certain great lady,
and how, in spite of his broken state, he might yet win her ad-
miration by some amazing deed ; and sometimes he would think
of being in some especial and personal way the Knight of Christ.
In the midst of these confusions, one night as he lay awake, he
tells us, a new great lady claimed his attention ; he had a vision
of the Blessed Virgin Mary carrying the Infant Christ in her
arms. " Immediately a loathing seized him for the former deeds
of his life." He resolved to give up all further thoughts of earthly
women, and to lead a life of absolute chastity and devotion to the
Mother of God. He projected great pilgrimages and a monastic
life.
His final method of taking his vows marks him the country-
man of Don Quixote. He had regained his strength, and he was
riding out into the world rather aimlessly, a penniless soldier of
fortune with little but his arms and the mule on which he rode,
when he fell into company with a Moor. They went on together
and talked, and presently disputed about religion. The Moor
was the better educated man ; he had the best of the argument,
he said offensive things about the Virgin Mary that were diffi-
cult to answer, and he parted triumphantly from Ignatius. The
young Knight of our Lady was boiling with shame and indigna-
tion. He hesitated whether he should go after the Moor and
kill him or pursue the pilgrimage he had in mind. At a fork
in the road he left things to his mule, which spared the Moor.
He came to the Benedictine Abbey of Manresa near Montserrat,
and here he imitated that peerless hero of the mediaeval romance,
Amadis de Gaul, and kept an all-night vigil before the Altar of
the Blessed Virgin. He presented his mule to the abbey, he gave
his worldly clothes to a beggar, he laid his sword and dagger upon
the altar, and clothed himself in a rough sackcloth garment and
hempen shoes. He then took himself to a neighbouring hospice
and gave himself up to scour gings and austerities. For a whole
week he fasted absolutely. Thence he went on a pilgrimage to
the Holy Land.
For some years he wandered, consumed with the idea of found-
ing a new order of religious knighthood, but not knowing clearly
how to set about this enterprise. He became more and more
166 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
aware of his own illiteracy, and the Inquisition, which was be-
ginning to take an interest in his proceedings, forbade him to
attempt to teach others until he had spent at least four years in
study. So much cruelty and intolerance is laid at the door of
the Inquisition that it is pleasant to record that in its handling
of this heady, imaginative young enthusiast it showed itself both
sympathetic and sane. It recognized his vigour and possible
uses ; it saw the dangers of his ignorance. He studied at Sala-
manca and Paris, among other places. He was ordained a priest
in 1538, and a year later his long-dreamt-of order was founded
under the military title of the " Company of Jesus." Like the
Salvation Army of modern England, it made the most direct
attempt to bring the generous tradition of military organization
and discipline to the service of religion.
This Ignatius of Loyola who founded the Order of Jesuits was
a man of forty-seven ; he was a very different man, much wiser
and steadier, than the rather absurd young man who had aped
Amadis de Gaul and kept vigil in the abbey of Manresa ; and the
missionary and educational organization he now created and
placed at the disposal of the Pope was one of the most powerful
instruments the church had ever handled. These men gave
themselves freely and wholly to be used by the church. It was
the Order of the Jesuits which carried Christianity to China again
after the downfall of the Ming Dynasty, and Jesuits were the chief
Christian missionaries in India and North America. To their
civilizing work among the Indians in South America we shall
presently allude. But their main achievement lay in raising
the standard of Catholic education. Their schools became
and remained for a long time the best schools in Christendom.
Says Lord Verulam ( = Sir Francis Bacon): "As for the peda-
gogic part . . . consult the schools of the Jesuits, for nothing better
has been put in practice." They raised the level of intelligence,
they quickened the conscience of all Catholic Europe, they stimu-
lated Protestant Europe to competitive educational efforts. . . .
Some day it may be we shall see a new order of Jesuits, vowed
not to the service of the Pope, but to the service of mankind.
And concurrently with this great wave of educational effort,
the tone and quality of the church was also greatly improved by
RENASCENCE OF WESTERN CIVILIZATION 167
the clarification of doctrine and the reforms in organization and
discipline that were made by the Council of Trent. This council
met intermittently either at Trent or Bologna between the years
1545 and 1563, and its work was at least as important as the
energy of the Jesuits in arresting the crimes and blunders that
were causing state after state to fall away from the Roman com-
munion. The change wrought by the Reformation within the
Church of Rome was as great as the change wrought in the Prot-
estant churches that detached themselves from the mother body.
There are henceforth no more open scandals or schisms to record.
But if anything, there has been an intensification of doctrinal
narrowness, and such phases of imaginative vigour as are repre-
sented by Gregory the Great, or by the group of Popes associated
with Gregory VII and Urban II, or by the group that began with
Innocent III, no longer enliven the sober and pedestrian narrative.
The world war of 1914-1918 was a unique opportunity for the
Papacy; the occasion was manifest for some clear strong voice
proclaiming the universal obligation to righteousness, the brother-
hood of men, the claims of human welfare over patriotic passion.
No such moral lead was given. The Papacy seemed to be bal-
ancing its traditional reliance upon the faithful Habsburgs against
its quarrel with republican France.
§6
The reader must not suppose that the destructive criticism of
the Catholic Church and of Catholic Christianity, and the print-
ing and study of the Bible, were the only or even the most im-
portant of the intellectual activities of the fourteenth and fifteenth
centuries. That was merely the popular and most conspicuous
aspect of the intellectual revival of the time. Behind this con-
spicuous and popular awakening to thought and discussion, other
less immediately striking but ultimately more important mental
developments were in progress. Of the trend of these develop-
ments we must now give some brief indications. They had be-
gun long before books were printed, but it was printing that re-
leased them from obscurity.
We have already told something of the first appearance of the
free intelligence, the spirit of inquiry and plain statement, in
168 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
human affairs. One name is central in the record of that first
attempt at systematic knowledge, the name of Aristotle. We
have noted also the brief phase of scientific work at Alexandria.
From that time onward the complicated economic and political
and religious conflicts of Europe and Western Asia impeded further
intellectual progress. These regions, as we have seen, fell for long
ages under the sway of the Oriental type of monarchy and of
Oriental religious traditions. Rome tried and abandoned a
slave-system of industry. The first great capitalistic system
developed and fell into chaos through its own inherent rotten-
ness. Europe relapsed into universal insecurity. The Semite
rose against the Aryan, and replaced Hellenic civilization through-
out Western Asia and Egypt by an Arabic culture. All Western
Asia and half of Europe fell under Mongolian rule. It is only in
the twelfth and thirteenth centuries that we find the Nordic
intelligence struggling through again to expression.
We then find in the growing universities of Paris, Oxford, and
Bologna an increasing amount of philosophical discussion going
on. In form it is chiefly a discussion of logical questions. As
the basis of this discussion we find part of the teachings of Aris-
totle, not the whole mass of writings he left behind him, but his
logic only. Later on his work became better known through the
Latin translations of the Arabic edition annotated by Averroes.1
1 Aristotle's Organon, or logic, had always been in part known to the West and
was known as a whole after about 1130. In the thirteenth century the rest of
his writings became known, in two ways. One way was that of direct translation
from the Greek into Latin : it was in this way that St. Thomas Aquinas knew the
Ethics and the Politics (the latter translated about 1260 by William of Moerbeke,
Archbishop of Corinth in the Latin Empire of Constantinople started under Baldwin
of Flanders in 1204, and a Fleming himself). The other way was that of indirect
translation, that is to say, of translations of Arabic paraphrases of, or commentaries
on, the works of Aristotle, such as had been made by Averroes and by Avicenna
before him. It was Aristotle's Physics and (I think) Metaphysics that first became
known in this way. In this latter way the West received a version of Aristotle
which, like Bottom the Weaver, was strangely "translated." Sometimes trans-
lations were made direct from Arabic into Latin ; sometimes they were made first
into Hebrew, and then new translations were made from Hebrew into Latin. As
the Arabic version of Aristotle was not always itself direct, but sometimes made
from Syriac versions of the Greek, confusion became confounded. The Latin
translations of the Arabic Aristotle sometimes contained not translation, but
transliteration of Arabic words or sentences ; and Roger Bacon very naturally
objected to their unintelligibility. What is more, Aristotle's views, as well as his
RENASCENCE OF WESTERN CIVILIZATION 169
Except for these translations of Aristotle, very little of the Greek
philosophical literature was read in Western Europe until the
fifteenth century. The creative Plato — as distinguished from
the scientific Aristotle — was almost unknown. Some neo-
Platonic writers were known, but neo-Platonism had much the
same relation to Plato that Christian Science has to Christ.
It has been the practice of recent writers to decry the philosoph-
ical discussion of the mediaeval "schoolmen" as tedious and
futile. It was nothing of the sort. It had to assume a severely
technical form because the dignitaries of the church, ignorant
and intolerant, were on the watch for heresy. It lacked the
sweet clearness, therefore, of fearless thought. It often hinted
what it dared not say. But it dealt with fundamentally important
things, it was a long and necessary struggle to clear up and cor-
rect certain inherent defects of the human mind, and many people
to-day blunder dangerously through their neglect of the issues the
schoolmen discussed.
There is a natural tendency in the human mind to exaggerate
the differences and resemblances upon which classification is
based, to suppose that things called by different names are alto-
gether different, and that things called by the same name are
practically identical. This tendency to exaggerate classification
produces a thousand evils and injustices. In the sphere of race
or nationality, for example, a "European" will often treat an
"Asiatic" almost as if he were a different animal, while he will
be disposed to regard another "European" as necessarily as
virtuous and charming as himself. He will, as a matter of course,
take sides with Europeans against Asiatics. But, as the reader
of this history must realize, there is no such difference as the op-
position of these names implies. It is a phantom difference created
by two names. . . .
The main mediaeval controversy was between the "Realists"
and the "Nominalists," and it is necessary to warn the reader
that the word "Realist" in mediaeval discussion has a meaning
words, were transmogrified in the process. But the important thing is that for
Aristotle's Organon, Ethics, and Politics there were direct translations from the
Greek. (See Sandys' History of Classical Scholarship and Kenan's Averroes et
I'AverToisme.) — E. B.
170 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
almost diametrically opposed to "Realist" as it is used in the
jargon of modern criticism. The modern " Realist" is one who
insists on materialist details; the mediaeval "Realist" was far
nearer what nowadays we should call an Idealist, and his con-
tempt for incidental detail was profound. The Realists outdid
the vulgar tendency to exaggerate the significance of class. They
held that there was something in a name, in a common noun
that is, that was essentially real. For example, they held there
was a typical "European," an ideal European, who was far more
real than any individual European. Every European was, as
it were, a failure, a departure, a flawed specimen of this prof ounder
reality. On the other hand the Nominalist held that the only
realities in the case were the individual Europeans, that the name
"European" was merely a name and nothing more than a name
applied to all these instances.
Nothing is quite so difficult as the compression of philosophical
controversies, which are by their nature voluminous and various
and tinted by the mental colours of a variety of minds. With
the difference of Realist and Nominalist stated baldly, as we
have stated it here, the modern reader unaccustomed to philo-
sophical discussion may be disposed to leap at once to the side
of the Nominalist. But the matter is not so simple that it can
be covered by one instance, and here we have purposely chosen
an extreme instance. Names and classifications differ in their
value and reality. While it is absurd to suppose that there can
be much depth of class difference between men called Thomas
and men called William, or that there is an ideal and quintes-
sential Thomas or William, yet on the other hand there may be
much profounder differences between a white man and a Hotten-
tot, and still more between Homo sapiens and Homo neander-
thalensis. While again the distinction between the class of pets
and the class of useful animals is dependent upon very slight
differences of habit and application, the difference of a cat and
dog is so profound that the microscope can trace it in a drop of
blood or a single hair. When this aspect of the question is con-
sidered, it becomes understandable how Nominalism had ulti-
mately to abandon the idea that names were as insignificant as
labels, and how, out of a revised and amended Nominalism, there
RENASCENCE OF WESTERN CIVILIZATION 171
grew up that systematic attempt to find the true — the most
significant and fruitful — classification of things and substances
which is called Scientific Research.
And it will be almost as evident that while the tendency of
Realism, which is the natural tendency of every untutored mind,
was towards dogma, harsh divisions, harsh judgments, and un-
compromising attitudes, the tendency of earlier and later Nominal-
ism was towards qualified statements, towards an examination of
individual instances, and towards inquiry and experiment and
scepticism. And it may not surprise the reader to learn that
the philosophy of the Catholic Church was essentially a Realist
philosophy.1
So while in the market-place and the ways of the common life
men were questioning the morals and righteousness of the clergy,
the good faith and propriety of their celibacy, and the justice
of papal taxation; while in theological circles their minds were
set upon the question of transubstantiation, the question of the
divinity or not of the bread and wine in the mass, in studies and
lecture-rooms a wider-reaching criticism of the methods of thought
upon which the very fundamentals of Catholic teaching rested
was in progress. We cannot attempt here to gauge the signifi-
cance in this process of such names as Peter Abelard (1079-1142),
Albertus Magnus (1193-1280), and Thomas Aquinas (1225-
1274). These men sought to reconstruct Catholicism on a sounder
system of reasoning. Chief among their critics and successors
were Duns Scotus (?-1308), an Oxford Franciscan and, to judge
by his sedulous thought and deliberate subtleties, a Scotchman,
and Occam, an Englishman (7-1347). Both these latter, like
Averroes (see chap, xxxii, § 8), made a definite distinction be-
tween theological and philosophical truth; they placed theology
on a pinnacle, but they placed it where it could no longer obstruct
research. Duns Scotus declared that it was impossible to prove
by reasoning the existence of God or of the Trinity or the credi-
1 1 do not agree with this paragraph. In the first sentence things are alleged
about Realism which are not justified. It was the philosophy of the priests and
most humane thinkers of the Middle Ages, of St. Anselm and of John Wycliffe.
Nor is it true that Realism was the philosophy of the church. It was, in the early
Middle Ages ; but after Occam (1330) Nominalism triumphed, and was the philos-
ophy of the church till the Reformation. Luther denounced Nominalism. — E. B.
172 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
bility of the Act of Creation; Occam was still more insistent
upon this separation — which manifestly released scientific in-
quiry from dogmatic control. A later generation, benefiting
by the freedoms towards which these pioneers worked, and know-
ing not the sources of its freedom, had the ingratitude to use the
name of Scotus as a term for stupidity, and so we have our English
word "Dunce." Says Professor Pringle Pattison,1 "Occam, who
is still a Scholastic, gives us the Scholastic justification of the spirit
which had already taken hold upon Roger Bacon, and which was
to enter upon its rights in the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries."
Standing apart by himself because of his distinctive genius
is this Roger Bacon (about 1210 to about 1293), who was also
English. He was a Franciscan of Oxford, and a very typical
Englishman indeed, irritable, hasty, honest, and shrewd. He
was two centuries ahead of his world. Says H. 0. Taylor of
him:2
"The career of Bacon was an intellectual tragedy, conform-
ing to the old principles of tragic art : that the hero's character
shall be large and noble, but not flawless, inasmuch as the fatal
consummation must issue from character, and not happen through
chance. He died an old man, as in his youth, so in his age, a
devotee of tangible knowledge. His pursuit of a knowledge which
was not altogether learning had been obstructed by the Order
of which he was an unhappy and rebellious member; quite as
fatally his achievement was deformed from within by the prin-
ciples which he accepted from his time. But he was responsible
for his acceptance of current opinions; and as his views roused
the distrust of his brother Friars, his intractable temper drew
their hostility (of which we know very little) on his head. Per-
suasiveness and tact were needed by one who would impress
such novel views as his upon his fellows or, in the thirteenth cen-
tury, escape persecution for their divulgence. Bacon attacked
dead and living worthies, tactlessly, fatuously, and unfairly.
Of his life scarcely anything is known, save from his allusions to
himself and others ; and these are insufficient for the construction
of even a slight consecutive narrative. Born; studied at Ox-
1 Encyclopedia Britannica, article "Scholasticism."
« The Medieval Mind, by Henry Osborn Taylor.
RENASCENCE OF WESTERN CIVILIZATION 173
ford ; went to Paris, studied, experimented ; is at Oxford again,
and a Franciscan ; studies, teaches, becomes suspect to his Order,
is sent back to Paris, kept under surveillance, receives a letter
from the Pope, writes, writes, writes — his three best-known
works; is again in trouble, confined for many years, released,
and dead, so very dead, body and frame alike, until partly un-
earthed after five centuries."
The bulk of these " three best-known works" is a hotly phrased
and sometimes quite abusive, but entirely just attack on the ig-
norance of the times, combined with a wealth of suggestions for
the increase of knowledge. In his passionate insistence upon
the need of experiment and of collecting knowledge, the spirit
of Aristotle lives again in him. " Experiment, experiment,"
that is the burthen of Roger Bacon. Yet of Aristotle himself
Roger Bacon fell foul. He fell foul of him because men, instead
of facing facts boldly, sat in rooms and pored over bad Latin
translations of the master. "If I had my way," he wrote, in his
intemperate fashion, "I should burn all the books of Aristotle*
for the study of them can only lead to a loss of time, produce error,
and increase ignorance," a sentiment that Aristotle would prob-
ably have echoed could he have returned to a world in which his
works were not so much read as worshipped — and that, as Roger
Bacon showed, in the most abominable translations.
Throughout his books, a little disguised by the necessity of
seeming to square it all with orthodoxy for fear of the prison and
worse, Roger Bacon shouted to mankind, " Cease to be ruled
by dogmas and authorities ; look at the world /" , Four chief sources
of ignorance he denounced: respect for authority, custom, the
sense of the ignorant crowd, and the vain proud unteachableness
of our dispositions. Overcome but these, and a world of power
would open to men : —
"Machines for navigating are possible without rowers, so that
great ships suited to river or ocean, guided by one man, may be
borne with greater speed than if they were full of men. Like-
wise cars may be made so that without a draught animal they
may be moved cum impetu incestimabili, as we deem the scythed
chariots to have been from which antiquity fought. And flying
machines are possible, so that a man may sit in the middle turn-
174 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
ing some device by which artificial wings may beat the air in the
manner of a flying bird."
Occam, Roger Bacon, these are the early precursors of a great
movement in Europe away from "Realism" towards reality.
For a time the older influences fought against the naturalism of
the new Nominalists. In 1339 Occam's books were put under a
ban and Nominalism solemnly condemned. As late as 1473
an attempt was made to bind teachers of Paris by an oath to teach
Realism.1 It was only in the sixteenth century with the print-
ing of books and the increase of intelligence that the movement
from absolutism towards experiment became massive, and that
one investigator began to co-operate with another.
Throughout the thirteenth and fourteenth centuries experi-
menting with material things was on the increase, items of know-
ledge were being won by men, but there was no inter-related ad-
vance. The work was done in a detached, furtive, and inglorious
manner. A tradition of isolated investigation came into Europe
from the Arabs and a considerable amount of private and se-
cretive research was carried on by the alchemists, for whom mod-
ern writers are a little too apt with their contempt. These al-
chemists were in close touch with the glass and metal workers and
with the herbalists and medicine-makers of the times; they
pried into many secrets of nature, but they were obsessed by
"practical" ideas; they sought not knowledge, but power;
they wanted to find out how to manufacture gold from cheaper
materials, how to make men immortal by the elixir of life, and
such-like vulgar dreams. Incidentally in their researches they
1 This gives a wrong impression about Nominalism, that it was banned in the
fourteenth and fifteenth centuries. The contrary is the case. The attempt of
1339 came to nothing ; that of 1473 was belated and unsuccessful. Except
Wycliffe, there is no considerable thinker of these centuries, so far as I know, who
is not Nominalist. The triumph of Nominalism was no unmixed benefit. Its
insistence on study of the individual was indeed favourable to natural science ;
and Harnack says that it led to good work in psychology. But its nescience about
Universals led to obscurantism in theology. Wycliffe as a Realist could hold that
God acted secundum rationes exemplar es, by certain and known universal rules ; the
Nominalists reduced God to inscrutable omnipotence. They went on to add
that He could therefore only be known at all by the miraculous intervention of the
mass through the priesthood. Their scepticism about Universals thus overleapt
itself, and fell on the other side, into obscurantist ecclesiasticism. — E. B.
RENASCENCE OF WESTERN CIVILIZATION 175
learnt much about poisons, dyes, metallurgy, and the like ; they
discovered various refractory substances, and worked their way
towards clear glass and so to lenses and optical instruments;
but as scientific men tell us continually, and as " practical" men
still refuse to learn, it is only when knowledge is sought for her
own sake that she gives rich and unexpected gifts in any abun-
dance to her servants. The world of to-day is still much more
disposed to spend money on technical research than on pure science.
Half the men in our scientific laboratories still dream of patents
and secret processes. We live to-day largely in the age of al-
chemists, for all our sneers at their memory. The " business
man" of to-day still thinks of research as a sort of alchemy.
Closely associated with the alchemists were the astrologers,
who were also a " practical" race. They studied the stars — to
tell fortunes. They lacked that broader faith and understanding
which induces men simply to study the stars.
Not until the fifteenth century did the ideas which Roger Bacon
first expressed begin to produce their first-fruits in new know-
ledge and a widening outlook. Then suddenly, as the sixteenth
century dawned, and as the world recovered from the storm of
social trouble that had followed the pestilences of the fourteenth
century, Western Europe broke out into a galaxy of names that
outshine the utmost scientific reputations of the best age of
Greece. Nearly every nation contributed, the reader will note,
for science knows no nationality.
One of the earliest and most splendid in this constellation is
the Florentine, Leonardo da Vinci (1452-1519), a man with an
almost miraculous vision for reality. He was a naturalist, an
anatomist, an engineer, as well as a very great artist. He was
the first modern to realize the true nature of fossils,1 he made
note-books of observations that still amaze us, he was convinced
of the practicability of mechanical flight. Another great name
is that of Cpj^xnicu&r a Pole (1473-1543), who made the first
clear analysis of the movements of the heavenly bodies and showed
that the earth moves round the sun. Tycho Brahe (1546-1601), a
Dane working at the university of Prague, rejected this latter belief,
but his observations of celestial movements were of the utmost
1 Cp. chap, ii, § 1, towards the end.
176 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
value to his successors, and especially to the German, Kepler (1571-
1630). Galileo Galilei (1564-1642) was the founder of the science
of dynamics. Before his time it was believed that a weight a hun-
dred times greater than another would fall a hundred times as fast.
Galileo denied this. Instead of arguing about it like a scholar and
a gentleman, he put it to the coarse test of experiment by dropping
two unequal weights from an upper gallery of the leaning tower of
Pisa — to the horror of all erudite men. He made what was
almost the first telescope, and he developed the astronomical
views of Copernicus; but the church, still struggling gallantly
against .the light, decided that to believe that the earth was smaller
and inferior to the sun made man and Christianity of no account,
and diminished the importance of the Pope; so Galileo, under
threats of dire punishment, when he was an old man of sixty-
nine, was made to recant this view and put the earth back in its
place as the immovable centre of the universe. He knelt before
ten cardinals in scarlet, an assembly august enough to overawe
truth itself, while he amended the creation he had disarranged.
The story has it that as he rose from his knees, after repeating
his recantation, he muttered, "Eppur si muove" — "it moves
nevertheless."
Newton (1642-1727) was born in the year of Galileo's death.
By his discovery of the law of gravitation he completed the clear
vision of the starry universe that we have to-day. But Newton
carries us into the eighteenth century. He carries us too far
for the present chapter. Among the earlier names, that of Dr.
Gilbert (1540-1603), of Colchester, is pre-eminent. Roger
Bacon had preached experiment, Gilbert was one of the first
to practise it. There can be little doubt that his work, which
was chiefly upon magnetism, helped to form the ideas of Francis
Bacon, Lord Verulam (1561-1626), Lord Chancellor to James
I of England. This Francis Bacon has been called the " Father
of Experimental Philosophy," but of his share in the develop-
ment of scientific work far too much has been made.1 He was,
says Sir R. A. Gregory, "not the founder but the apostle" of the
scientific method. His greatest service to science was a fantastic
book, The New Atlantis. "In his New Atlantis, Francis Bacon
1 See Gregory's Discovery, chap. vi.
RENASCENCE OF WESTERN CIVILIZATION 177
planned in somewhat fanciful language a palace of invention, a
great temple of science, where the pursuit of knowledge in all its
branches was to be organized on principles of the highest effi-
ciency."
From this Utopian dream arose the Royal Society of London,
which received a Royal Charter from Charles II of England in
1662. The essential use and virtue of this society was and is
publication. Its formation marks a definite step from isolated
inquiry towards co-operative work, from the secret and solitary
investigations of the alchemist to the frank report and open dis-
cussion which is the life of the modern scientific process. For
the true scientific method is this : to trust no statements without
verification, to test all things as rigorously as possible, to keep no
secrets, to attempt no monopolies, to give out one's best modestly
and plainly, serving no other end but knowledge.
The long-slumbering science of anatomy was revived by Har-
vey (1578-1657), who demonstrated the circulation of the blood.
. . . Presently the Dutchman, Leeuwenhoek (1632-1723) brought
the first crude microscope to bear upon the hidden minutiae of
life.
These are but some of the brightest stars amidst that increas-
ing multitude of men who have from the fifteenth century to our
own time, with more and more collective energy and vigour, lit
up our vision of the universe, and increased our power over the
conditions of our lives.
§7
We have dealt thus fully with the beginnings of science in the
Middle Ages because of its ultimate importance in human affairs.
In the long run, Roger Bacon is of more significance to mankind
than any monarch of his time. But the contemporary world,
for the most part, knew nothing of this smouldering activity
in studies and lecture-rooms and alchemist's laboratories that was
presently to alter all the conditions of life. The church did in-
deed take notice of what was afoot, but only because of the dis-
regard of her conclusive decisions. She had decided that the
earth was the very centre of God's creation, and that the f'ope
was the divinely appointed ruler of the earth. Men's ideas on
178 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
these essential points, she insisted, must not be disturbed by any
contrary teaching. So soon, however, as she had compelled
Galileo to say that the world did not move she was satisfied;
she does not seem to have realized how ominous it was for her
that, after all, the earth did move.
Very great social as well as intellectual developments were in
progress in Western Europe throughout this period of the later
Middle Ages. But the human mind apprehends events far
more vividly than changes ; and men for the most part, then as
now, kept on in their own traditions in spite of the shifting scene
about them.
In an outline such as this it is impossible to crowd in the cluster-
ing events of history that do not clearly show the main process
of human development, however bright and picturesque they
may be. We have to record the steady growth of towns and
cities, the reviving power of trade and money, the gradual re-
establishment of law and custom, the extension of security, the
supersession of private warfare that went on in Western Europe
in the period between the First Crusade and the sixteenth century.
Of much that looms large in our national histories we cannot tell
anything. We have no space for the story of the repeated attempts
of the English kings to conquer Scotland and set themselves up
as kings of France, nor of how the Norman English established
themselves insecurely in Ireland (twelfth century), and how Wales
was linked to the English crown (1282). All through the Middle
Ages the struggle of England with Scotland and France was in
progress; there were times when it seemed that Scotland was
finally subjugated and when the English king held far more land
in France than its titular sovereign. In the English histories
this struggle with France is too often represented as a single-
handed and almost successful attempt to conquer France. In
reality it was a joint enterprise undertaken in concert with the
powerful French vassal state of Burgundy to conquer and divide
the patrimony of Hugh Capet.1 Of the English rout by the
Scotch at Bannockburn (1314), and of William Wallace and
1 Not from 1340-1360, under Edward III, but later under Henry V, 1413-1422.
— E. B.
Edward had Flemish and Bavarian allies. — H. G. W.
RENASCENCE OF WESTERN CIVILIZATION 179
Robert the Bruce, the Scottish national heroes, of the battles of
Crecy (1346) and Poitiers (1356) and Agincourt (1415) in France,
which shine like stars in the English imagination, little battles
in which sturdy bowmen through some sunny hours made a great
havoc among French knights in armour, of the Black Prince and-
Henry V of England, and of how a peasant girl, Joan of Arc,
the Maid of Orleans, drove the English out of her country again
(1429-1430), this history relates nothing. For every country
has such cherished national events. They are the ornamental
tapestry of history, and no part of the building. Rajputana or
Poland, Russia, Spain, Persia, and China can all match or outdo
the utmost romance of western Europe, with equally adventurous
knights and equally valiant princesses and equally stout fights
against the odds. Nor can we tell how Louis XI of France (1461-
1483), the son of Joan of Arc's Charles VII, brought Burgundy
to heel and laid the foundations of a centralized French mon-
archy. It signifies more that in the thirteenth and fourteenth
centuries, gunpowder, that Mongol gift, came to Europe so that
the kings (Louis XI included) and the law, relying upon the sup-
port of the growing towns, were able to batter down the castles
of the half-independent robber knights and barons of the earlier
Middle Ages and consolidate a more centralized power. The
fighting nobles and knights of the barbaric period disappear slowly
from history during these centuries; the Crusades consumed
them, such dynastic wars as the English Wars of the Roses killed
them off, the arrows from the English long-bow pierced them and
stuck out a yard behind, infantry so armed swept them from
the stricken field ; they became reconciled to trade and changed
their nature. They disappeared in everything but a titular
sense from the west and south of Europe before they disappeared
from Germany., The knight in Germany remained a professional
fighting man into the sixteenth century.
Between the eleventh and the fifteenth centuries in western
Europe, and particularly in France and England, there sprang
up like flowers a multitude of very distinctive and beautiful build-
ings, cathedrals, abbeys, and the like, the Gothic architecture.
This lovely efflorescence marks the appearance of a body of
craftsmen closely linked in its beginnings to the church. In Italy
180 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
and Spain too the world was beginning to build freely and beauti-
fully again. At first it was the wealth of the church that provided
most of these buildings ; then kings and merchants also began to
build.
From the twelfth century onward, with the increase of trade,
there was a great revival of town life throughout Europe. Promi-
nent among these towns were Venice, with its dependents Ragusa
and Corfu, Genoa, Verona, Bologna, Pisa, Florence, Naples,
Milan, Marseilles, Lisbon, Barcelona, Narbonne, Tours, Orleans,
Bordeaux, Paris, Ghent, Bruges, Boulogne, London, Oxford, Cam-
bridge, Southampton, Dover, Antwerp, Hamburg, Bremen,
Cologne, Mayence, Nuremberg, Munich, Leipzig, Magdeburg,
Breslau, Stettin, Dantzig, Konigsberg, Riga, Pskof, Novgorod,
Wisby, and Bergen.
"A West German town, between 1400 and 1500,1 embodied
all the achievements of progress at that time, although from a
modern standpoint much seems wanting. . . . The streets
were mostly narrow and irregularly built, the houses chiefly of
wood, while almost every burgher kept his cattle in the house,
and the herd of swine which was driven every morning by the
town herdsman to the pasture-ground formed an inevitable part
of city life.2 In Frankfort-on-Main it was unlawful after 1481
to keep swine in the Altstadt, but in the Neustadt and in Sachsen-
hausen this custom remained as a matter of course. It was only
in 1645, after a corresponding attempt in 1556 had failed, that
the swine-pens in the inner town were pulled down at Leipzig.
The rich burghers, who occasionally took part in the great trading
companies, were conspicuously wealthy landowners and had
extensive courtyards with large barns inside the town walls. The
most opulent of them owned those splendid patrician houses
which we still admire even to-day. But even in the older towns
most houses of the fifteenth century have disappeared; only
here and there a building with open timber-work and over-hang-
ing storeys, as in Bacharach or Miltenburg, reminds us of the style
of architecture then customary in the houses of burghers. The
1 From Dr. Tille in Helmolt's History of the World.
2 Charles Dickens in his American Notes mentions swine in Broadway, New York,
in the middle nineteenth century.
RENASCENCE OF WESTERN CIVILIZATION 181
great bulk of the inferior population, who lived on mendicancy,
or got a livelihood by the exercise of the inferior industries, in-
habited squalid hovels outside the town; the town wall was
often the only support for these wretched buildings. The in-
ternal fittings of the houses, even amongst the wealthy popula-
tion, were very defective according to modern ideas ; the Gothic
style was as little suitable for the petty details of objects of luxury
as it was splendidly adapted for the building of churches and
town halls. The influence of the Renaissance added much to the
comfort of the house.
"The fourteenth and fifteenth century saw the building of nu-
merous Gothic town churches and town halls throughout Europe
which still in many cases serve their original purpose. The
power and prosperity of the towns find their best expression in
these and in the fortifications with their strong towers and gate-
ways. Every picture of a town of the sixteenth or later centuries
shows conspicuously these latter erections for the protection and
honour of the town. The town did many things which in our
time are done by the State. Social problems were taken up
by town administration or the corresponding municipal organiza-
tion. The regulation of trade was the concern of the guilds in
agreement with the council, the care of the poor belonged to the
church, while the council looked after the protection of the town
walls and the very necessary fire brigades. The council, mind-
ful of its social duties, superintended the filling of the municipal
granaries, in order to have supplies in years of scarcity. Such
store-houses were erected in almost every town during the fif-
teenth century. Tariffs of prices for the sale of all wares, high
enough to enable every artisan to make a good livelihood, and to
give the purchaser a guarantee for the quality of the wares, were
maintained. The town was also the chief capitalist; as a seller
of annuities on lives and inheritances it was a banker and en-
joyed unlimited credit. In return it obtained means for the
construction of fortifications or for such occasions as the ac-
quisition of sovereign rights from the hand of an impecunious
prince."
For the most part these European towns were independent
or quasi-independent aristocratic republics. Most admitted a
to
all
un
\
182 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
vague overlordship on the part of the church, or of the emperor
or of a king. Others were parts of kingdoms, or even the capitals
of dukes or kings. In such cases their internal freedom was
maintained by a royal or imperial charter. In England the Royal
City of Westminster on the Thames stood cheek by jowl with the
walled city of London, into which the King came only with cere-
mony and permission. The entirely free Venetian republic ruled
an empire of dependent islands and trading ports, rather after
the fashion of the Athenian republic. Genoa also stood alone.
The Germanic towns of the Baltic and North Sea from Riga
to Middelburg in Holland, Dortmund, and Cologne were loosely
allied in a confederation, the confederation of the Hansa towns,
der the leadership of Hamburg, Bremen, and Lubeck, a con-
federation which was still more loosely attached to the empire.
This confederation, which included over seventy towns in all,
and which had depots in Novgorod, Bergen, London, and Bruges,
did much to keep the northern seas clean of piracy, that curse
of the Mediterranean and of the Eastern seas. The Eastern
Empire throughout its last phase, from the Ottoman conquest
of its European hinterland in the fourteenth and early fifteenth
century until its fall in 1453, was practically only the trading
town of Constantinople, a town state like Genoa or Venice, ex-
cept that it was encumbered by a corrupt imperial court.
The fullest and most splendid developments of this city life
of the later Middle Ages occurred in Italy. After the end of the
Hohenstaufen line in the thirteenth century, the hold of the
Holy Roman Empire upon North and Central Italy weakened,
although, as we shall tell, German Emperors were still crowned
as kings and emperors in Italy up to the time of Charles V (circ.
1530). There arose a number of quasi-independent city states
to the north of Rome, the papal capital. South Italy and Sicily,
however, remained under foreign dominion. Genoa and her
rival, Venice, were the great trading seaports of this time; their
noble palaces, their lordly paintings, still win our admiration.
Milan, at the foot of the St. Gothard pass, revived to wealth and
power. Inland was Florence, a trading and financial centre
which, under the almost monarchical rule of the Medici family
in the fifteenth century, enjoyed a second "Periclean age." But
RENASCENCE OF WESTERN CIVILIZATION 183
184 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
already before the time of these cultivated Medici "bosses,"
Florence had produced much beautiful art. Giotto's tower
(Giotto, born 1266, died 1337) and the glorious Duomo (by Bru-
nellesco, born 1377, died 1446) already existed. Towards the
end of the fourteenth century Florence became the centre of the
rediscovery, restoration, and imitation of antique art (the " Ren-
aissance" in its narrower sense). Artistic productions, unlike
philosophical thought and scientific discovery, are the ornaments
and expression rather than the creative substance of history,
and here we cannot attempt to trace the development of the art
of Filippo Lippi, Botticelli, Donatello (died 1466), Leonardo da
Vinci (died 1519), Michelangelo (1475-1564), and Raphael' (died
1520). Of the scientific speculation of Leonardo we have al-
ready had occasion to speak.
§8
In 1453, as we have related, Constantinople fell. Throughout
the next century the Turkish pressure upon Europe was heavy
and continuous. The boundary line between Mongol and Aryan,
which had lain somewhere east of the Pamirs in the days of Pericles,
had receded now to Hungary. Constantinople had long been a
mere island of Christians in a Turk-ruled Balkan Peninsula. Its
fall did much to interrupt the trade with the East.
Of the two rival cities of the Mediterranean, Venice was gen-
erally on much better terms with the Turks than Genoa. Every
intelligent Genoese sailor fretted at the trading monopoly of
Venice, and tried to invent some way of getting through it or
round it. And there were now new peoples taking to the sea
trade, and disposed to look for new ways to the old markets be-
cause the ancient routes were closed to them. The Portuguese,
for example, were developing an Atlantic coasting trade. The
Atlantic was waking up again after a vast period of neglect that
dated from the Roman murder of Carthage. It is rather a deli-
cate matter to decide whether the western European was pushing
out into the Atlantic or whether he was being pushed out into it
by the Turk, who lorded it in the Mediterranean until the Battle
of Lepanto (1571). The Venetian and Genoese ships were creep-
ing round to Antwerp, and the Hansa town seamen were coming
RENASCENCE OF WESTERN CIVILIZATION 185
south and extending their range. And there were considerable
developments of seamanship and shipbuilding in progress. The
Mediterranean, as we have noted (chapter xvii) is a sea for gal-
leys and coasting. But upon the Atlantic Ocean and the North
Sea winds are more prevalent, seas run higher, the shore is often
a danger rather than a refuge. The high seas called for the sail-
ing ship, and in the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries it appears,
keeping its course by the compass and the stars.
By the thirteenth century the Hansa merchants were already
sailing regularly from Bergen across the grey cold seas to the
Northmen in Iceland. In Iceland men knew of Greenland, and
adventurous voyagers had long ago foiled a further land beyond,
Vinland, where the climate was pleasant and where men could
settle if they chose to cut themselves off from the rest of human
kind. This Vinland was either Nova Scotia or, what is more
probable, New England.
All over Europe in the fifteenth century merchants and sailors
were speculating about new ways to the East. The Portuguese,
unaware that Pharaoh Necho had solved the problem ages ago,
were asking whether it was not possible to go round to India by
the coast of ALfrica. Their ships followed in the course that
Haimo took to Cape Verde (1445). They put out to sea to the
west and found the Canary Isles, Madeira, and the Azores.1 That
was a fairly long stride across the Atlantic. In 1486 a Portuguese,
Diaz, reported that he had rounded the south of Africa. . . .
A certain Genoese, Christopher Columbus, began to think more
and more of what is to us a very 6bvious and natural enterprise,
but which strained the imagination of the fifteenth century to the
utmost, a voyage due west across the Atlantic. At that time
nobody knew of the existence of America as a separate continent.
Columbus knew that the world was a sphere, but he under-esti-
mated its size ; the travels of Marco Polo had given him an
exaggerated idea of the extent of Asia, and he supposed therefore
that Japan, with its reputation for a great wealth of gold, lay across
1 In these maritime adventures in the eastern Atlantic and the west African
coast the Portuguese were preceded in the thirteenth, fourteenth, and early fifteenth
centuries by Normans, Catalonians, and Genoese. See Raymond Beazley, History
of Exploration in the Middle Ages. — H. H. J.
186 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
the Atlantic in about the position of Mexico. He had made
various voyages in the Atlantic ; he had been to Iceland and per-
haps heard of Vinland, which must have greatly encouraged
these ideas of his, and this project of sailing into the sunset be-
came the ruling purpose of his life. He was a penniless man,
some accounts say he was a bankrupt, and his only way of secur-
ing a ship was to get someone to entrust him with a command.
He went first to King John II of Portugal, who listened to him,
made difficulties, and then arranged for an expedition to start with-
out his knowledge, a purely Portuguese expedition. This highly
diplomatic attempt to steal a march on an original man failed,
as it deserved to fail ; the crew became mutinous, the captain lost
heart and returned (1483). Columbus then went to the Court
of Spain.
At first he could get no ship and no powers. Spain was as-
sailing Granada, the last foothold of the Moslems in western
Europe. Most of Spain had been recovered by the Christians
between the eleventh and the thirteenth century ; then had come
a pause ; and now all Spain, united by the marriage of Ferdinand
of Aragon and Isabella of Castile, was setting itself to the com-
pletion of the Christian conquest. Despairing of Spanish help,
Columbus sent his brother Bartholomew to Henry VII of Eng-
land, but the adventure did not attract that canny monarch.
Finally in 1492 Granada fell, and then, helped by some merchants
of the town of Palos, Columbus got his ships, three ships, of which
only one, the Santa Maria, of 100 tons burthen, was decked.
The two other were open boats of half that tonnage.
The little expedition — it numbered altogether eighty-eight
men ! — went south to the Canaries, and then stood out across
the unknown seas, in beautiful weather and with a helpful wind.
The story of that momentous voyage of two months and nine
days must be read in detail to be appreciated. The crew was
full of doubts and fears ; they might, they feared, sail on for ever.
They were comforted by seeing some birds, and later on by find-
ing a pole worked with tools, and a branch with strange berries.
At ten o'clock, on the night of October llth, 1492, Columbus
saw a light ahead ; the next morning land was sighted, and, while
the day was still young, Columbus landed on the shores of the
RENASCENCE OF WESTERN CIVILIZATION 187
new world, richly apparelled and bearing the royal banner of
Spain. . . .
Early in 1493 Columbus returned to Europe. He brought
gold, cotton, strange beasts and birds, and two wild-eyed painted
Indians to be baptized. He had not found Japan, it was thought,
but India. The islands he had found were called therefore the
West Indies. The same year he sailed again with a great expe-
dition of seventeen ships and fifteen thousand men, with the ex-
press permission of the Pope to take possession of these new lands
for the Spanish crown. . . .
We cannot tell of his experiences as Governor of this Spanish
colony, nor how he was superseded and put in chains. In a little
while a swarm of Spanish adventurers were exploring the new
lands. But it is interesting to note that Columbus died ignorant
of the fact that he had discovered a new continent. He be-
lieved to the day of his death that he had sailed round the world
to Asia.
The news of his discoveries caused a great excitement through-
out western Europe. It spurred the Portuguese to fresh attempts
to reach India by the South African route. In 1497, Vasco da
Gama sailed from Lisbon to Zanzibar, and thence, with an Arab
pilot, he struck across the Indian Ocean to Calicut in India. In
1515 there were Portuguese ships in Java and the Moluccas.
In 1519 a Portuguese sailor, Magellan, in the employment of the
Spanish King, coasted to the south of South America, passed
through the dark and forbidding "Strait of Magellan," and so
came into the Pacific Ocean, which had already been sighted by
Spanish explorers who had crossed the Isthmus of Panama.
Magellan's expedition continued across the Pacific Ocean west-
ward. This was a far more heroic voyage than that of Colum-
bus ; for eight and ninety days Magellan sailed unflinchingly over
that vast, empty ocean, sighting nothing but two little desert
islands. The crews were rotten with scurvy; there was little
water and that bad, and putrid biscuit to eat. Rats were hunted
eagerly ; cowhide was gnawed and sawdust devoured to stay the
pangs of hunger. In this state the expedition reached the La-
drones. They discovered the Philippines, and here Magellan
was killed in a fight with the natives. Several other captains
188 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
were murdered. Five ships had started with Magellan in August,
1519, and two hundred and eighty men ; in July, 1522, the Vit-
toria, with a remnant of one and thirty men aboard, returned up
the Atlantic to her anchorage near the Mole of Seville, in the river
Guadalquivir • — the first ship that ever circumnavigated this
planet.1
The English and French and Dutch and the sailors of the Hansa
towns came rather later into this new adventure of exploration.
They had not the same keen interest in the eastern trade. And
when they did come in, their first efforts were directed to sailing
round the north of America as Magellan had sailed round the
south, and to sailing round the north of Asia as Vasco da Gama
had sailed round the south of Africa. Both these enterprises were
doomed to failure by the nature of things. Both in America and
the East, Spain and Portugal had half a century's start of England
and France and Holland. And Germany never started. The
King of Spain was Emperor of Germany in those crucial years,
and the Pope had given the monopoly of America to Spain, and
not simply to Spain, but to the kingdom of Castile. This must
have restrained both Germany and Holland at first from Ameri-
can . adventures. The Hansa towns were quasi-independent ;
they had no monarch behind them to support them, and no unity
among themselves for so big an enterprise as oceanic exploration.
It was the misfortune of Germany, and perhaps of the world, that,
as we will presently tell, a storm of warfare exhausted her when
all the Western powers were going to this newly opened school
of trade and administration upon the high seas.
Slowly throughout the sixteenth century the immense good
fortune of Castile unfolded itself before the dazzled eyes of
Europe. She had found a new world, abounding in gold and
silver and wonderful possibilities of settlement. It was all hers,
because the Pope had said so. The Court of Rome, in an access
of magnificence, had divided this new world of strange lands,
which was now opening out to the European imagination, between
the Spanish, who were to have everything west of a line 370
leagues west of the Cape Verde islands, and the Portuguese, to
whom everything east of this line was given.
1 See Guillemard's Ferdinand Magellan.
RENASCENCE OF WESTERN CIVILIZATION 189
At first the only people encountered by the Spaniards
in America were savages of a Mongoloid type. Many of these
savages were cannibals. It is a misfortune for science that the
first Europeans to reach America were these rather incurious
Spaniards, without any scientific passion, thirsty for gold, and
full of the blind bigotry of a recent religious war. They made
few intelligent observations of the native methods and ideas of
these primordial people. They slaughtered them, they robbed
them, they enslaved them, and baptized them; but they made
small note of the customs and motives that changed and van-
ished under their assault. They were as destructive and reck-
less as the British in Tasmania, who shot the last Palaeolithic
men at sight, and put out poisoned meat for them to find.
Great areas of the American interior were prairie land, whose
nomadic tribes subsisted upon vast herds of the now practically
extinct bison. In their manner of life, in their painted garments
and their free use of paint, in their general physical characters,
these prairie Indians showed remarkable resemblances to the
Later Palaeolithic men of the Solutrian age in Europe. But
they had no horses. They seem to have made no very great ad-
vance from that primordial state, which was probably the state
in which their ancestors had reached America. They had, how-
ever, a knowledge of metals, and most notably a free use of native
copper, but no knowledge of iron. As the Spaniards penetrated
into the continent, they found and they attacked, plundered,
and destroyed two separate civilized systems that had developed
in America, perhaps quite independently of the civilized systems of
the old world. One of them was the Aztec civilization of Mexico ;
the other, that of Peru. They had arisen out of the heliolithic
sub-civilization that had drifted across the Pacific from its region
of origin round and about the Mediterranean. We have already
noted one or two points of interest in these unique developments.
Along their own lines these civilized peoples had reached to a state
of affairs roughly parallel with the culture of pre-dynastic Egypt
or the early Sumerian cities. Before the Aztecs and the Peru-
vians there had been still earlier civilized beginnings which had
either been destroyed by their successors, or which had failed and
relapsed of their own accord.
190 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
The Aztecs seem to have been a conquering, less civilized people,
dominating a more civilized community, as the Aryans domi-
nated Greece and North India. Their religion was a primitive,
complex, and cruel system, in which human sacrifices and cere-
monial cannibalism played a large part. Their minds were
haunted by the idea of sin and the need for bloody propitiations.1
The Aztec civilization was destroyed by an expedition under
Cortez. He had eleven ships, four hundred Europeans, two
hundred Indians, sixteen horses, and fourteen guns. But in
Yucatan he picked up a stray Spaniard who had been a captive
with the Indians for some years, and who had more or less learnt
various Indian languages, and knew that the Aztec rule was deeply
resented by many of its subjects. It was in alliance with these
that Cortez advanced over the mountains into the valley of Mexico,
(15 19)2. How he entered Mexico, how its monarch, Montezuma,
was killed by his own people for favouring the Spaniards, how
Cortez was besieged in Mexico, and escaped with the loss of
his guns and horses, and how after a terrible retreat to the coast
he was able to return and subjugate the whole land, is a romantic
and picturesque story which we cannot even attempt to tell
here. The population of Mexico to this day is largely of native
blood, but Spanish has replaced the native languages, and such
culture as exists is Catholic and Spanish.
The still more curious Peruvian state fell a victim to another
adventurer, Pizarro. He sailed from the Isthmus of Panama
in 1530, with an expedition of a hundred and sixty-eight Span-
iards. Like Cortez in Mexico, he availed himself of the native
dissensions to secure possession of the doomed state. Like Cortez,
too, who had made a captive and tool of Montezuma, he seized
the Inca of Peru by treachery, and attempted to rule in his name.
Here again we cannot do justice to the tangle of subsequent events,
the ill-planned insurrections of the natives, the arrival of Spanish
reinforcements from Mexico, and the reduction of the state to a
Spanish province. Nor can we tell much more of the swift spread
1 For an interesting account of these American civilizations, see L. Spence, The
Civilization of Ancient Mexico and Myths of Mexico and Peru.
2 See Prescott's History of the Conquest of Mexico and his History of the Conquest
of Peru.
RENASCENCE OF WESTERN CIVILIZATION 191
192
THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
of Spanish adventurers over the rest of America, outside the Portu-
guese reservation of Brazil. To begin with, each story is nearly
always a story of adventurers and of cruelty and loot. The
Spaniards ill-treated the natives, they quarrelled among them-
Tvf EXJCO W. 7ERXI
selves, the law and order of Spain were months and years away
from them; it was only very slowly that the phase of violence
and conquest passed into a phase of government and settlement.
But long before there was much order in America, a steady stream
of gold and silver began to flow across the Atlantic to the Span-
ish government and people.
RENASCENCE OF WESTERN CIVILIZATION 193
After the first violent treasure hunt came plantation and the
working of mines. With that arose the earliest labour difficulty
in the new world. At first the Indians were enslaved with much
brutality and injustice ; but to the honour of the Spaniards this
did not go uncriticized. The natives found champions, and
very valiant champions, in the Dominican Order and in a secular
priest Las Casas, who was for a time a planter and slave-owner
in Cuba until his conscience smote him. An importation of negro
slaves from West Africa also began quite early in the sixteenth
century. After some retrogression, Mexico, Brazil, and Spanish
South America began to develop into great slave-holding, wealth-
producing lands. . . .
We cannot tell here, as we would like to do, of the fine civiliz-
ing work done in South America, and more especially among the
natives, by the Franciscans, and presently by the Jesuits, who
came into America in the latter half of the sixteenth century
(after 1549). . . .*
So it was that Spain rose to a temporary power and promi-
nence in the world's affairs. It was a very sudden and very
memorable rise. From the eleventh century this infertile and
corrugated peninsula had been divided against itself, its Chris-
tian population had sustained a perpetual conflict with the Moors ;
then by what seems like an accident it achieved unity just in
time to reap the first harvest of benefit from the discovery of
America. Before that time Spain had always been a poor coun-
try ; it is a poor country to-day, almost its only wealth lies in its
mines. For a century, however, through its monopoly of the
gold and silver of America, it dominated the world. The east
and centre of Europe were still overshadowed by the Turk and
Mongol; the discovery of America was itself a consequence of
the Turkish conquests; very largely through the Mongolian
inventions of compass and paper, and under the stimulus of travel
in Asia and of the growing knowledge of eastern Asiatic wealth
and civilization, came this astonishing blazing up of the mental,
physical, and social energies of the " Atlantic fringe." For close
in the wake of Portugal and Spain came France and England,
and presently Holland, each in its turn taking up the role of ex-
1 See Cunninghame Graham's A Vanished Arcadia.
o
194 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
pansion and empire overseas. The centre of interest for Euro-
pean history which once lay in the Levant shifts now from the
Alps and the Mediterranean Sea to the Atlantic. For some
centuries the Turkish Empire and Central Asia and China are
relatively neglected by the limelight of the European historian.
Nevertheless, these central regions of the world remain central,
and their welfare and participation is necessary to the permanent
peace of mankind.
§9
And now let us consider the political consequences of this vast
release and expansion of European ideas in the fourteenth and
fifteenth centuries with the new development of science, the
exploration of the world, the great dissemination of knowledge
through paper and printing, and the spread of a new craving
for freedom and equality. How was it affecting the mentality
of the courts and kings that directed the formal affairs of man-
kind? We have already shown how the hold of the Catholic
church upon the consciences of men was weakening at this time.
Only the Spaniards, fresh from a long and finally successful re-
ligious war against Islam, had any great enthusiasm left for the
church. The Turkish conquests and the expansion of the known
world robbed the Roman Empire of its former prestige of uni-
versality. The old mental and moral framework of Europe
was breaking up. What~"was happening to the dukes, princes,
and kings of the old dispensation during this age of change ?
In England, as we shall tell later, very subtle and interesting
tendencies were leading towards a new method in government,
the method of parliament, that was to spread later on over nearly
all the world. But of these tendencies the world at large was as
yet practically unconscious in the sixteenth century.
Few monarchs have left us intimate diaries ; to be a monarch
and to be frank are incompatible feats ; monarchy is itself neces-
sarily a pose. The historian is obliged to speculate about the
contents of the head that wears a crown as best he can. No
doubt regal psychology has varied with the ages. We have,
however, the writings of a very able man of this period who set
himself to study and expound the arts of kingcraft as they were
RENASCENCE OF WESTERN CIVILIZATION 195
understood in the later fifteenth century. This was the celebrated
Florentine, Niccolo Machiavelli (1469-1527). He was of good
birth and reasonable fortune, and he had entered the public em-
ployment of the republic by the time he was twenty-five. For
eighteen years he was in the Florentine diplomatic service; he
was engaged upon a number of embassies, and in 1500 he was sent
to France to deal with the French king. From 1502 to 1512 he
was the right-hand man of the gonfalonier (the life president)
of Florence, Soderini. Machiavelli reorganized the Florentine
army, wrote speeches for the gonfalonier, was indeed the ruling
intelligence in Florentine affairs. When Soderini, who had leant
upon the French, was overthrown by the Medici family whom
the Spanish supported, Machiavelli, though he tried to transfer
his services to the victors, was tortured on the rack and expelled.
He took up his quarters in a villa near San Casciano, twelve miles
or so from Florence, and there entertained himself partly by col-
lecting and writing salacious stories to a friend in Rome, and partly
by writing books about Italian politics in which he could no longer
play a part. Just as we owe Marco Polo's book of travels to his
imprisonment, so we owe Machiavelli's Prince, his Florentine
History, and The Art of War to his downfall and the boredom of
San Casciano.
The enduring value of these books lies in the clear idea they
give us of the quality and limitations of the ruling minds of this
age. Their atmosphere was his atmosphere. If he brought an
exceptionally keen intelligence to their business, that merely throws
it into a brighter light.
His susceptible mind had been greatly impressed by the cun-
ning, cruelty, audacity, and ambition of Caesar Borgia, the Duke
of Valentino, in whose camp he had spent some months as an
envoy. In his Prince he idealized this dazzling person. Caesar
Borgia (1476-1507), the reader must understand, was the son of
Pope Alexander VI, Rodrigo Borgia (1492-1503). The reader
will perhaps be startled at the idea of a Pope having a son, but
this, we must remember, was a pre-reformation Pope. The
Papacy at this time was in a mood of moral relaxation, and though
Alexander was, as a priest, pledged to live unmarried, this did
not hinder him from living openly with a sort of unmarried wife,
196 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
and devoting the resources of Christendom to the advancement
of his family. Caesar was a youth of spirit even for the times in
which he lived ; he had early caused his elder brother to be mur-
dered, and also the husband of his sister, Lucrezia. He had in-
deed betrayed and murdered a number of people. With his
father's assistance he had become duke of a wide area of Central
Italy when Machiavelli visited him. He had shown little or no
military ability, but considerable dexterity and administrative
power. His magnificence was of the most temporary sort. When
presently his father died, it collapsed like a pricked bladder.
Its unsoundness was not evident to Machiavelli.1 Our chief in-
terest in Csesar Borgia is that he realized Machiavelli's highest
ideals of a superb and successful prince.
Much has been written to show that Machiavelli had wide
and noble intentions behind his political writings, but all such
attempts to ennoble him will leave the sceptical reader who in-
sists on reading the lines instead of reading imaginary things be-
tween the lines of Machiavelli's work, cold towards him. This
man manifestly had no belief in any righteousness at all, no be-
lief in a God ruling over the world or in a God in men's hearts,
no understanding of the power of conscience in men. Not for
him were Utopian visions of world-wide human order, or at-
tempts to realize the City of God. Such things he did not want.
It seemed to him that to get power, to gratify one's desires and
sensibilities and hates, to swagger triumphantly in the world,
must be the crown of human desire. Only a prince could fully
realize such a life. Some streak of timidity or his sense of the
poorness of his personal claims had evidently made him abandon
such dreams for himself; but at least he might hope to serve a
prince, to live close to the glory, to share the plunder and the lust
and the gratified malice. He might even make himself indispen-
sable ! He set himself, therefore, to become an "expert " in prince-
craft. He assisted Soderini to fail. When he was racked and re-
jected by the Medicis, and had no further hopes of being even a
successful court parasite, he wrote these handbooks of cunning
to show what a clever servant some prince had lost. His ruling
1 Machiavelli examines the causes of Caesar's collapse, but he holds that it was
due to fortuna, against which Caesar's mrtti could not prevail. — E. B.
RENASCENCE OF WESTERN CIVILIZATION 197
thought, his great contribution to political literature, was that
the moral obligations upon ordinary men cannot bind princes.1
There is a disposition to ascribe the virtue of patriotism to
Machiavelli because he suggested that Italy, which was weak and
divided — she had been invaded by the Turks and saved from
conquest only by the death of the Sultan Muhammad, and she
was being fought over by the Frencji and Spanish as though she
was something inanimate — might be united and strong ; but
he saw in that possibility only a great opportunity for a prince.
And he advocated a national army only because he saw the
Italian method of carrying on war by hiring bands of foreign
mercenaries was a hopeless one. At any time such troops might
go over to a better paymaster or decide to plunder the state they
protected. He had been deeply impressed by the victories of the
Swiss over the Milanese, but he never fathomed the secret of the
free spirit that made those victories possible. The Florentine
militia he created was a complete failure. He was a man born
blind to the qualities that make peoples free and nations great.
Yet this morally blind man was living in a little world of mor-
ally blind men. It is clear that his style of thought was the style
of thought of the court of his time. Behind the princes of the new
states that had grown up out of the wreckage of the empire and the
failure of the Church, there were everywhere chancellors and
secretaries and trusted ministers of the Machiavellian type.
Cromwell, for instance, the minister of Henry VIII of England
after his breach with Rome, regarded Machiavelli's Prince as
JE. B. writes as follows: "I think better of Machiavelli than you do, and
especially on two points. (1) He raises a real issue — whether, when a crisis
besets the State, the ruler is not bound to abandon the rules of private morality,
if by doing so he can preserve the State. If he abandons those rules, he does
wrong — and Machiavelli admits that — but, at the same time, as the agent and
organ of the State, he does right by preserving it, so far, at any rate, as it is right
that it should be preserved. This is a real issue, which one cannot simply dismiss.
E.g., all war is wrong, by the rules of private morality, because it is killing; but
it may have a qualified and conditioned Tightness if it is necessary to preserve the
State, and if the State, as a scheme of good life, ought to be preserved. (2) Machia-
velli did believe in the people. He only exalts the new prince, who arises to restore
order and security in a troubled State. In normal times he believes that the people
is a good judge of men: that 'better than many fortresses is not to be hated by
the people' ; that the trite proverb, 'He who founds himself on the people founds
himself on mud,' is untrue, except as applied to demagogues."
198
THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
the quintessence of political wisdom. When the princes were
themselves sufficiently clever they too were Machiavellian.
They were scheming to outdo one another, to rob weaker con-
temporaries, to destroy rivals, so that they might for a brief in-
terval swagger. They had little or no vision of any scheme of
, shewing principal
human destinies greater than this game they played against one
another.
" § 10
It is interesting to note that this Swiss infantry which had so im-
pressed Machiavelli was no part of the princely system of Europe.
At the very centre of the European system there had arisen a little
confederation of free states, the Swiss Confederation, which after
some centuries of nominal adhesion to the Holy Roman Empire be-
came frankly republican in 1499. As early as the thirteenth cen-
tury, the peasant farmers of three valleys round about the Lake of
Lucerne took it into their heads that they would dispense with an
RENASCENCE OF WESTERN CIVILIZATION 199
overlord and manage their own affairs in their own fashion. Their
chief trouble came from the claims of a noble family of the Aar
Valley, the Habsburg family. In 1245 the men of Schwyz burnt the
castle of New Habsburg which had been set up near Lucerne to
overawe them ; its ruins are still to be seen there.
This Habsburg family was a growing and acquisitive one;
it had lands and possessions throughout Germany ; and^jn^J.273,
after the extinction of the Hohenstaufen house, Rudolf of Habs-
burg was elected Emperor of Germany, a distinction that became
at last practically hereditary in his family. None the less, the
men of Uri, Schwyz, and Unterwalden did not mean to be ruled
by any Habsburg ; they formed an Everlasting League in 1291, and
they held their own among the mountains from that time onward
to this day, first as free members of the empire and then as an
absolutely independent confederation. Of the heroic legend of
William Tell we have no space to tell here, nor have we room in
which to trace the gradual extension of the confederation to its
present boundaries. Romansh, Italian, and French-speaking
valleys were presently added to this valiant little republican group.
The red cross flag of Geneva has become the symbol of inter-
national humanity in the midst of warfare. The bright and
thriving cities of Switzerland have been a refuge for free men
from a score of tyrannies.
§11 A
Most of the figures that stand out in history, do so through
some exceptional personal quality, good or bad, that makes them
more significant than their fellows. But there was born at Ghent
in Belgium in 1500 a man of commonplace abilities and melan-
choly temperament, the son of a mentally defective mother who
had been married for reasons of state, who was, through no fault
of his own, to become the focus of the accumulating stresses of
Europe. The historian must give him a quite unmerited and
accidental prominence side by side with such marked individualities
as Alexander and Charlemagne and Frederick II. This.- was the
Emperor Charles V. For a time he had an air of being the great-
est monarch in Europe since Charlemagne. Both he and his
illusory greatness were the results of the matrimonial statecraft
200 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
of his grandfather, the Emperor Maximilian I (born 1459, died
1519).
Some families have fought, others have intrigued their way
to world power; the Habsburgs married their way. Maxi-
milian began his career with the inheritance of the Habsburgs,
Austria, Styria, part of Alsace and other districts; he married
— the lady's name scarcely matters to us — the Netherlands
and Burgundy. Most of Burgundy slipped from him after his
first wife's death, but the Netherlands he held. Then he tried
unsuccessfully to marry Brittany. He became Emperor in suc-
cession to his father, Frederick III, in 1493, and married the
duchy of Milan. Finally he married his son to the weak-minded
daughter of Ferdinand and Isabella, the Ferdinand and Isabella
of Columbus, who not only reigned over a freshly united Spain,
and over Sardinia and the kingdom of the Two Sicilies, but by
virtue of the papal gifts to Castile, over all America west of Brazil.
So it was that Charles, his grandson, inherited most of the Ameri-
can continent and between a third and a half of what the Turks
had left of Europe. The father of Charles died in 1506, and Maxi-
milian did his best to secure his grandson's election to the im-
perial throne.
; Charles succeeded to the Netherlands in 1506; he became
practically king of the Spanish dominions, his mother being im-
becile, when his grandfather Ferdinand died in 1516; and his
grandfather Maximilian dying in 1519, he was in 1520 elected
Emperor at the still comparatively tender age of twenty.
His election as Emperor was opposed by the young and bril-
liant French King, Francis I, who had succeeded to the French
throne in 1515 at the age of twenty-one. The candidature of
Francis was supported by Leo X (1513), who also requires from us
the epithet brilliant. It was indeed an age of brilliant monarchs.
It was the age of Baber in India (1526-1530) and Suleiman
in Turkey (1520). Both Leo and Francis dreaded the con-
centration of so much power in the hands of one man as the elec-
tion of Charles threatened. The only other monarch who seemed
to matter in Europe was Henry VIII, who had become King of
England in 1509 at the age of eighteen. He also offered him-
self as a candidate for the empire, and the imaginative English
RENASCENCE OF WESTERN CIVILIZATION 201
202 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
reader may amuse himself by working out the possible conse-
quences of such an election. There was much scope for diplomacy
in this triangle of kings. Charles on his way from Spain to Ger-
many visited England and secured the support of Henry against
Francis by bribing his minister, Cardinal Wolsey. Henry also
made a great parade of friendship with Francis, there was feast-
ing, tournaments, and suchlike antiquated gallantries in France,
in a courtly picnic known to historians as the Field of the Cloth
of Gold (1520). Knighthood was becoming a picturesque af-
fectation in the sixteenth century. The Emperor Maximilian I
is still called "the last of the knights" ; by German historians.
The election of Charles was secured, it is to be noted, by a vast
amount of bribery. He had as his chief supporters and creditors
the great German business house of the Fuggers. That large
treatment of money and credit which we call finance, which had
gone out of European political life with the collapse of the Roman
Empire, was now coming back to power. This appearance of the
Fuggers, whose houses and palaces outshone those of the em-
perors, marks the upward movement of forces that had begun
two or three centuries earlier in Cahors in France and in Florence
and other Italian towns. Money, public debts, and social un-
rest and discontent, re-enter upon the miniature stage of this
Outline. Charles V was not so much a Habsburg as a Fugger
emperor.
For a time this fair, not very intelligent-looking young man
i with the thick upper lip and long, clumsy chin — features which
still afflict his descendants — was largely a puppet in the hands
of his ministers. Able servants after the order of Machiavelli
\ guided him at first in the arts of kingship. Then in a slow but
\ effectual way he began to assert himself. He was confronted at
\ the very outset of his reign in Germany with the perplexing dis-
tensions of Christendom. The revolt against the papal rule
which had been going on since the days of Huss and Wycliffe had
|)een recently exasperated by a new and unusually cynical sell-
ing of indulgences to raise money for the completion of St. Peter's
at Rome. A monk named Luther, who had been consecrated
as a priest, who had taken to reading the Bible, and who, while
visiting Rome on the business of his order, had been much shocked
RENASCENCE OF WESTERN CIVILIZATION
203
by the levity and worldly splendour of the Papacy, had come for-
ward against these papal expedients at Wittenberg (1517), offer-
ing disputation and propounding certain theses. An important
controversy ensued. At first Luther carried on this controversy
in Latin, but presently took
to German, and speedily had
the people in a ferment.
Charles found this dispute
raging when he came from
Spain to Germany. He sum-
moned an assembly or "diet"
of the empire at Worms on
the Rhine. To this, Luther,
who had been asked to recant
his views by Pope Leo X, and
who had refused to do so, was
summoned. He came, and,
entirely in the spirit of Huss,
refused to recant unless he
was convinced of his error by
logical argument or the authority of Scripture. But his protec-
tors among the princes were too powerful for him to suffer the
fate of John Huss.
Here was a perplexing situation for the young Emperor. There
is reason to suppose that he was inclined at first to support Luther
against the Pope. Leo X had opposed the election of Charles,
and was friendly with his rival, Francis I. But Charles V was
not a good Machiavellian, and he had acquired in Spain a con-
siderable religious sincerity. He decided against Luther. Many
of the German princes, and especially the Elector of Saxony,
sided with the reformer. Luther went into hiding under the pro-
tection of the Saxon Elector, and Charles found himself in the
presence of the opening rift that was to split Christendom into
two contending camps.
Close upon these disturbances, and probably connected with
them, came a widespread peasants' revolt throughout Germany.
This outbreak frightened Luther very effectually. He was
shocked by its excesses, and from that time forth the Reforma-
tuthcr
(after
204
THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
tion he advocated ceased to be a Reformation according to the
people and became a Reformation according to the princes. He
lost his confidence in that free judgment for which he had stood
up so manfully.
Meanwhile Charles realized that his great empire was in very
serious danger both from the west and from the east. On the
west of him was his spirited rival, Francis I ; to the east was the
Turk in Hungary, in alliance with Francis and clamouring for
certain arrears of tribute from the Austrian dominions. Charles
had the money and army of Spain at his disposal, but it was ex-
tremely difficult to get any effec-
tive support in money from Ger-
many. His grandfather had de-
veloped a German infantry on the
Swiss model, very much upon the
lines expounded in Machiavelli's
Art of War, but these troops had
to be paid and his imperial sub-
sidies had to be supplemented
by unsecured borrowings, which
were finally to bring his sup-
porters, the Fuggers, to ruin, j
On the whole, Charles, in alliance with Henry VIII, was suc-
cessful against Francis I and the Turk. Their chief battlefield
was north Italy ; the generalship was dull on both sides ; their ad-
vances and retreats depended chiefly on the arrival of reinforce-
ments. The German army invaded France, failed to take Mar-
seilles, fell back into Italy, lost Milan, and was besieged in Pavia.
Francis I made a long and unsuccessful siege of Pavia, was caught
by fresh German forces, defeated, wounded, and taken prisoner.
He sent back a message to his queen that all was "lost but honour,"
made a humiliating peace, and broke it as soon as he was liberated
so that even the salvage of honour was but temporary. Henry
VIII and the Pope, in obedience to the rules of Machiavellian
strategy, now went over to the side of France in order to prevent
Charles becoming too powerful. The German troops in Milan,
under the Constable of Bourbon, being unpaid, forced rather
than followed their commander into a raid upon Rome. They
RENASCENCE OF WESTERN CIVILIZATION 205
stormed the city and pillaged it (1527). The Pope took refuge
in the Castle of St. Angelo while the looting and slaughter went
on. He bought off the German troops at last by the payment
of four hundred thousand ducats. Ten years of such stupid and
confused fighting impoverished all Europe and left the Emperor
in possession of Milan. In 1530 he was crowned by the Pope
— he was the last German Emperor to be crowned by the Pope —
at Bologna. One thinks of the rather dull-looking blonde face,
with its long lip and chin, bearing the solemn expression of one
who endures a doubtful though probably honourable ceremony.
Meanwhile the Turks were making great headway in Hungary.
They had defeated and killed the King of Hungary in 1526, they
held Buda-Pesth, and in 1529, as we have already noted, Sulei-
man the Magnificent very nearly took Vienna. The Emperor
was greatly concerned by these advances, and did his utmost
to drive back the Turks, but he found the greatest difficulty in
getting the German princes to unite, even with this formidable
enemy upon their very borders. Francis I remained implacable
for a time, and there was a new French war ; but in 1538 Charles
won his rival over to a more friendly attitude by ravaging the south
of France. Francis and Charles then formed an alliance against
the Turk, but the Protestant princes, the German princes who
were resolved to break away from Rome, had formed a league,
the Schmalkaldic League (named after the little town of
Schmalkalden in Hesse, at which its constitution was arranged),
against the Emperor, and in the place of a great campaign to re-
cover Hungary for Christendom Charles had to turn his mind
to the gathering internal struggle in Germany. Of that struggle
he saw only the opening war. It was a struggle, a sanguinary
irrational bickering of princes for ascendancy, now flaming into
war and destruction, now sinking back to intrigues and diplo-
macies ; it was a snake's sack of Machiavellian policies, that was
to go on writhing incurably right into the nineteenth century,
and to waste and desolate Central Europe again and again.
The Emperor never seems to have grasped the true forces at
work in these gathering troubles. He was for his time and sta-
tion an exceptionally worthy man, and he seems to have taken
the religious dissensions* that were tearing Europe into warring
206
THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
fragments as genuine theological differences. He gathered diets
and councils in futile attempts at reconciliation. Formulae and
confessions were tried over. The student of German history
must struggle with the details of the Religious Peace of Nurem-
berg, the settlement at the diet of Ratisbon, the Interim of
Augsburg, and the like. Here we do but mention them as details
in the worried life of this culminating emperor. As a matter of
fact, hardly one of the multifarious princes and rulers in Europe
seems to have been acting in
good faith. The widespread re-
ligious trouble of the world, the
desire of the common people for
truth and social righteousness,
the spreading knowledge of the
time, all those things were merely
counters in the imaginations of
princely diplomacy. Henry VIII
of England, who had begun his
career with a book written
against heresy, and who had been
rewarded by the Pope with the title of "Defender of the Faith,"
being anxious to divorce his first wife in favour of an animated
young lady named Anne Boleyn,1 and wishing also to turn against
the Emperor in favour of Francis I and to loot the vast wealth of
the church in England, joined the company of Protestant princes
in 1530. Sweden, Denmark, and Norway had already gone over
to the Protestant side.
The German religious war began in 1546, a few months after
the death of Martin Luther. We need not trouble about the
incidents of the campaign. The Protestant Saxon army was
badly beaten at Lochau. By something very like a breach of faith
Philip of Hesse, the Emperor's chief remaining antagonist, was
caught and imprisoned, and the Turks were bought off by the pay-
ment of ^n annual tribute. In 1547, to the great relief of the Em-
peror, Francis I died. So by 1547 Charles got to a kind of settle-
1 But he had a better reason for doing this in the fact that there was no heir to
the throne. The Wars of the Roses, a bitter dynastic war, were still very vivid in
the minds of English people. — F. H. H.
RENASCENCE OF WESTERN CIVILIZATION 207
ment, and made his last efforts to effect peace where there was no
peace. In 1552 all Germany was at war again, only a precipitate
flight from Innsbruck saved Charles from capture, and in 1552,
with the treaty of Passau, came another unstable equilibrium.
Charles was now utterly weary of the cares and splendours of
empire ; he had never had a very sound constitution, he was nat-
urally indolent, and he was suffering greatly from gout. He
abdicated. He made over all his sovereign rights in Germany
to his brother Ferdinand, and Spain and the Netherlands he re-
signed to his son Philip. He then retired to a monastery at Yuste,
among the oak and chestnut forests in the hills to the north of the
Tagus valley, and there he died in 1558.
Much has been written in a sentimental vein of this retire-
ment, this renunciation of the world by this tired majestic Titan,
world-weary, seeking in an austere solitude his peace with God.
But his retreat was neither solitary nor austere ; he had with him
nearly a hundred and fifty attendants; his establishment had
all the indulgences without the fatigues of a court, and Philip II
was a dutiful son to whom his
father's advice was a command.
As for his austerities, let Prescott
witness: "In the almost daily
correspondence between Quixada,
or Gaztelu, and the Secretary
of State at Valladolid, there is
scarcely a letter that does not
turn more or less on the Em-
peror's eating or his illness. The
one seems naturally to follow,
like a running commentary, on the
other. It is rare that such topics have formed the burden of
communications with the department of state. It must have
been no easy matter for the secretary to preserve his gravity in
the perusal of despatches in which politics and gastronomy were
so strangely mixed together. The courier from Valladolid to
Lisbon was ordered to make a detour, so as to take Jarandilla in
his route, and bring supplies for the royal table. On Thursdays
he was to bring fish to serve for the jour maigre that was to follow.
208 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
The trout in the neighbourhood Charles thought too small ; so
others, of a larger size, were to be sent from Valladolid. Fish
of every kind was to his taste, as, indeed, was anything that in
its nature or habits at all approached to fish. Eels, frogs, oysters,
occupied an important place in the royal bill of fare. Potted
fish, especially anchovies, found great favour with him ; and he
regretted that he had not brought a better supply of these from
the Low Countries. On an eel-pasty he particularly doted." . . .*
In 1554 Charles had obtained a bull from Pope Julius III grant-
ing him a dispensation from fasting, and allowing him to break
his fast early in the morning even when he was to take the sacra-
ment.
"That Charles was not altogether unmindful of his wearing
apparel in Yuste, may be inferred from the fact that his ward-
robe contained no less than sixteen robes of silk and velvet, lined
with ermine, or eider down, or the soft hair of the Barbary goat.
As to the furniture and upholstery of his apartments, how little
reliance is to be placed on the reports so carelessly circulated
about these may be gathered from a single glance at the inventory
of his effects, prepared by Quixada and Gaztelu soon after their
master's death. Among the items we find carpets from Turkey
and Alcarez, canopies of velvet and other stuffs, hangings of fine
black cloth, which since his mother's death he had always chosen
for his own bedroom ; while the remaining apartments were pro-
vided with no less than twenty-five suits of tapestry, from the
looms of Flanders, richly embroidered with figures of animals
and with landscapes. . . . Among the different pieces of plate
we find some of pure gold, and others especially noted for their
curious workmanship; and as this was an age in which the art
of working the precious metals was carried to the highest perfec-
tion, we cannot doubt that some of the finest specimens had come
into the Emperor's possession. The whole amount of plate was
estimated at between twelve and thirteen thousand ounces in
weight." . . .2
Charles had never acquired the habit of reading, but he would
be read aloud to at meals after the fashion of Charlemagne, and
1 Prescott's Appendix to Robertson's History of Charles V.
3 Preicott.
RENASCENCE OF WESTERN CIVILIZATION 209
would make what one narrator describes as a "sweet and heavenly
commentary." He also amused himself with technical toys,
by listening to music or sermons, and by attending to the imperial
business ^that still came drifting in to him. The death of the
Empress, to whom he was greatly attached, had turned his mind
towards religion, which in his case took a punctilious and cere-
monial form ; every Friday in Lent he scourged himself with the
rest of the monks with such good will as to draw blood. These
exercises and the gout released a bigotry in Charles that had been
hitherto restrained by considerations of policy. The appear-
ance of Protestant teaching close at hand in Valladolid roused
him to fury. "Tell the grand inquisitor and his council from me
to be at their posts, and to lay the axe at the root of the evil before
it spreads further." . . . He expressed a doubt whether it would
not be well, in so black an affair, to dispense with the ordinary
course of justice, and to show no mercy; "lest the criminal, if
pardoned, should have the opportunity of repeating his crime."
He recommended, as an example, his own mode of proceeding
in the Netherlands, "where all who remained obstinate in their
errors were burned alive, and those who were admitted to peni-
tence were beheaded."
Among the chief pleasures of the Catholic monarch between
meals during this time of retirement were funeral services. He
not only attended every actual funeral that was celebrated at
Yuste, but he had services conducted for the absent dead, he held
a funeral service in memory of his wife on the anniversary of her
death, and finally he celebrated his own obsequies. "The chapel
was hung with black, and the blaze of hundreds of wax-lights was
scarcely sufficient to dispel the darkness. The brethren in their
conventual dress, and all the Emperor's household clad in deep
mourning, gathered round a huge catafalque, shrouded also in
black, which had been raised in the centre of the chapel. The
service for the burial of the dead was then performed ; and,
amidst the dismal wail of the monks, the prayers ascended for the
departed spirit, that it might be received into the mansions of the
blessed. The sorrowful attendants were melted to tears, as the
image of their master's death was presented to their minds — or
they were touched, it may be, with compassion by this pitiable
210 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
display of weakness. Charles, muffled in a dark mantle, and bear-
ing a lighted candle in his hand, mingled with his household, the
spectator of his own obsequies; and the doleful ceremony was
concluded by his placing the taper in the hands of the priest, in
sign of his surrendering up his soul to the Almighty."
Other accounts make Charles wear a shroud and lie in the
coffin, remaining there alone until the last mourner had left the
chapel.
Within two months of this masquerade he was dead. And the
greatness of the Holy Roman Empire died with him. The Holy
Roman Empire struggled on indeed to the days of Napoleon,
but as an invalid and dying thing.
§HB
Ferdinand, the brother of Charles V, took over his abandoned
work and met the German princes at the diet of Augsburg in
1555. Again there was an attempt to establish a religious peace.
Nothing could better show the quality of that attempted settle-
ment and the blindness of the princes and statesmen concerned
in it, to the deeper and broader processes of the time, than the
form that settlement took. The recognition of religious free-
dom was to apply to the states and not to individual citizens;
cujus regio ejus religio, t(the confession of the subject was to be de-
pendent on that of the territorial lord."
§llc
We have given as much attention as we have done to the writ-
ings of Machiavelli and to the personality of Charles V because
they throw a flood of light upon the antagonisms of the next
period in our history. This present chapter has told the story
of a vast expansion of human horizons and of a great increase
and distribution of knowledge ; we have seen the conscience of
common men awakening and intimations of a new and profounder
social justice spreading throughout the general body of the West-
ern civilization. But this process of light and thought was leav-
ing courts and the political life of the world untouched. There
is little in Machiavelli that might not have been written by some
RENASCENCE OF WESTERN CIVILIZATION 211
clever secretary in the court of Chosroes I or Shi-Hwang-ti — or
even of Sargon I or Pepi. While the world in everything else was
moving forward, in political ideas, in ideas about the relationship
of state to state and of sovereign to citizen, it was standing still.
Nay, it was falling back. For the great idea of the Catholic !
Church as the world city of God had been destroyed in men's
minds by the church itself, andvthe dream of a world^imperialism
had, in the person of Charles V, been carried in effigy through
Europe to limbo. Politically the world seemed falling back
towards personal monarchy of the Assyrian or Macedonian pat-
tern.
It is not that the newly awakened intellectual energies of west-
ern European men were too absorbed in theological restatement,
in scientific investigations, in exploration and mercantile develop-
ment, to give a thought to the claims and responsibilities of rulers.
Not only were common men drawing ideas of a theocratic or re-
publican or communistic character from the now accessible Bible,
but the renewed study of the Greek classics was bringing the
creative and fertilizing spirit of Plato to bear upon the Western
mind. In England Sir Thomas More produced a quaint imita-
tion of Plato's Republic in his Utopia, setting out a sort of auto-
cratic communism. In Naples, a century later, a certain friar
Campanella was equally bold in his City of the Sun. But such
discussions were having no immediate effect upon political ar-
rangements. Compared with the massiveness of the task, these
books do indeed seem poetical and scholarly and flimsy. (Yet
later on the Utopia was to bear fruit in the English Poor Laws.)
The intellectual and moral development of the Western mind
and this drift towards Machiavellian monarchy in Europe were
for a time going on concurrently in the same world, but they
were going on almost independently. The statesmen still schemed
and manoeuvred as if nothing grew but the power of wary and
fortunate kings. It was only in the seventeenth and eighteenth
centuries that these two streams of tendency, the stream of gen-
eral ideas and the drift of traditional and egoistic monarchical
diplomacy, interfered and came into conflict.
BOOK VIII
THE AGE OF THE GREAT POWERS
XXXVI
PRINCES, PARLIAMENTS, AND POWERS
§ 1. Princes and Foreign Policy. § 2. The English Republic.
§ 3. The Dutch Republic. § 4. The Break-up and Disorder of
Germany. § 5. The Splendours of Grand Monarchy in Europe.
§ 6. The Growth of the Idea of Great Powers. § 7. The Crowned
Republic of Poland and Its Fate. § 8. The First Scramble for
Empire Overseas. § 9. Britain Dominates India. § 10. Rus-
sia's Ride to the Pacific. §11. What Gibbon Thought of the World
in 1780. § 12. The Social Truce Draws to an End.
§1
IN the preceding chapter we have traced the beginnings of a new
civilization, the civilization of the " modern" type which
becomes at the present time world-wide. It is still a vast unformed
thing, still only in the opening phases of growth and develop-
ment to-day. We have seen the mediaeval ideas of the Holy
Roman Empire and of the Roman Church, as forms of universal
law and order, fade in its dawn. They fade out, as if it were neces-
sary in order that these ideas of one law and one order for all
men should be redrawn on world-wide lines. And while in nearly
every other field of human interest there was advance, the efface-
ment of these general political ideas of the Church and Empire
led back for a time in things political towards merely personal
monarchy and monarchist nationalism of the Macedonian type.
There came an interregnum, as it were, in the consolidation of
human affairs, a phase of the type the Chinese annalists would
call an "Age of Confusion." This interregnum has lasted as
long as that between the fall of the Western Empire and the
crowning of Charlemagne in Rome. We are living in it to-day.
215
216 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
It may be drawing to its close ; we cannot tell yet. The old lead-
ing ideas had broken down, a medley of new and untried pro-
jects and suggestions perplexed men's minds and actions, and
meanwhile the world at large had to fall back for leadership upon
the ancient tradition of an individual prince. There was no new
way clearly apparent for men to follow, and the prince was there.
All over the world the close of the sixteenth century saw mon-
archy prevailing and tending towards absolutism. Germany
and Italy were patchworks of autocratic princely dominions,
Spain was practically autocratic, the throne had never been so
powerful in England, and as the seventeenth century drew on,
the French monarchy gradually became the greatest and most
consolidated power in Europe. The phases and fluctuations of
its ascent we cannot record here.
vAt every court there were groups of ministers and secretaries
who played a Machiavellian game against their foreign rivals.
Foreign policy is the natural employment of courts and mon-
archies. Foreign offices are, so to speak, the leading characters
in all the histories of the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries.
They kept Europe in a fever of wars. And wars were becoming
expensive. Armies were no longer untrained levies, no longer
assemblies of feudal knights who brought their own horses and
weapons and retainers with them; they needed more and more
artillery ; they consisted of paid troops who insisted on their pay ;
they were professional and slow and elaborate, conducting long
sieges, necessitating elaborate fortifications. War expenditure
increased everywhere and called for more and more taxation.
And here it was that these monarchies of the sixteenth and seven-
teenth centuries came into conflict with new and shapeless forces
of freedom in the community. In practice the princes found they
were not masters of their subjects' lives or property. They
found an inconvenient resistance to the taxation that was neces-
sary if their diplomatic aggressions and alliances were to continue.
Finance became an unpleasant spectre in every council chamber.
In theory the monarch owned his country. James I of England
(1603) declared that "As it is atheism and blasphemy to dispute
what God can do; so it is presumption and high contempt in a
subject to dispute what a king can do, or say that a king cannot
PRINCES, PARLIAMENTS, AND POWERS 217
do this or that." In practice, however, he found, and his son
Charles I (1625) was to find still more effectually, that there
were in his dominions a great number of landlords and mer-
chants, substantial and intelligent persons, who set a very definite
limit to the calls and occasions of the monarch and his ministers.
They were prepared to tolerate his rule if they themselves might
also be monarchs of their lands and businesses and trades and
what not. But not otherwise.
Everywhere in Europe there was a parallel development. Be-
neath the kings and princes there were these lesser monarchs,
the private owners, noblemen, wealthy citizens, and the like,
who were now offering the sovereign prince much the same re-
sistance that the kings and princes of Germany had offered the
Emperor. They wanted to limit taxation so far as it pressed upon
themselves, and to be free in their own houses and estates. And
the spread of books and reading and inter-communication was
enabling these smaller monarchs, these monarchs of ownership,
to develop such a community of ideas and such a solidarity of
resistance as had been possible at no previous stage in the world's
history. Everywhere they were disposed to resist the prince,
but it was not everywhere that they found the same faculties
for an organized resistance. The economic circumstances and
the political traditions of the Netherlands and England made
those countries the first to bring this antagonism of monarchy
and private ownership to an issue.1
At first this seventeenth-century "public/' this public of prop-
erty owners, cared very little for foreign policy. They did not
perceive at first how it affected them. They did not want to be
1 It was private conscience, rather than private property, that quarrelled with
and limited princes. The Puritan Revolution in England (1640-1660) was a
puritan revolution — it sprang from the religious motive first and foremost. The
economic motive was secondary. The "economic interpretation of history" is
always tempting, but men's souls have always mattered more than their pockets.
Englishmen fought Charles I for the sake of free consciences rather than for the
sake of free pockets. This is a large issue, on which much could be written ; but
I feel sure that religion came first in our Civil War. — E. B.
I do not agree. Loath as I am to differ from E. B., I can find no evidence of any
religious issue as important as the issue of taxation either in the English Civil War
or the American War of Independence. — H. G. W.
I did not mention the Americans. I will surrender them to H. G. W. — E. B.
218 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
bothered with it ; it was, they conceded, the affairs of kings and
princes.1 They made no attempts therefore to control foreign
entanglements. But it was with the direct consequences of these
entanglements that they quarrelled; they objected to heavy
taxation, to interference with trade, to arbitrary imprisonment,
and to the control of consciences by the monarch. It was upon
these questions that they joined issue with the Crown.
§2
The open struggle of the private property owner against the
aggressions of the " Prince" begins in England far back in the
twelfth century.2 The phase in this struggle that we have to
study now is the phase that opened with the attempts of Henry
VII and VIII and their successors, Edward VI, Mary and Eliza-
beth, to make the government of England a " personal monarchy"
of the continental type. It became more acute when, by dy-
nastic accidents, James, King of Scotland, became James I, King
of both Scotland and England (1603), and began to talk in the
manner we have already quoted of his "divine right" to do as he
pleased. But never had the path of English monarchy been a
smooth one. In all the monarchies of the Northmen and Ger-
manic invaders of the empire there had been a tradition of a
popular assembly of influential and representative men to pre-
serve their general liberties, and in none was it more living than
in England. France had her tradition of the assembly of the
Three Estates, Spain her Cortes, but the English assembly was
peculiar in two respects: that it had behind it a documentary
declaration of certain elementary and universal rights, and that
it contained elected "Knights of the Shire," as well as elected
burghers from the towns. The French and Spanish assemblies
had the latter, but not the former element.
1 Englishmen did try to control the foreign policy of James I, because it involved
questions of religion, and because their primary concern was religious. They
wanted foreign policy to be directed to the militant defence of Protestantism.
James I, a good internationalist (in his way), and at any rate a lover of peace,
wanted to secure European peace by diplomacy — and failed to do so. Hia
parliaments, and all seventeenth-century parliaments, were vitally interested in
foreign policy. — E. B.
2 A very good general history of Great Britain, too little known as yet, is A. D.
Innes' History of the British Nation (1912),
PRINCES, PARLIAMENTS, AND POWERS 219
These two features gave the English Parliament a peculiar
strength in its struggle with the Throne. The document in ques-
tion was Magna Carta, the Great Charter, a declaration which was
forced from King John (1199-1216), the brother and successor of
Richard Cceur de Lion (1189-99) after a revolt of the Barons
in 1215. It rehearsed a number of fundamental rights that made
England a legal and not a regal state. It rejected the power of
the king to control the personal property and liberty of every
sort of citizen — save with the consent of that man's equals.
The presence of the elected shire representatives in the Eng-
lish Parliament, the second peculiarity of the British situation,
came about from very simple and apparently innocuous be-
ginnings. From the shires, or county divisions, knights seem to
have been summoned to the national council to testify to the
taxable capacity of their districts. They were sent up by the
minor gentry, freeholders and village elders of their districts as
early as 1254, two knights from each shire. This idea inspired
Simon de Montfort,1 who was in rebellion against Henry III,
the successor of John, to summon to the national council two
knights from each shire and two citizens from each city or bor-
ough. Edward I, the successor to Henry III, continued this
practice because it seemed a convenient way of getting into
financial touch with the growing towns. At first there was con-
siderable reluctance on the parts of the knights and townsmen to
attend Parliament, but gradually the power they possessed of
linking the redress of grievances with the granting of subsidies
was realized. Quite early, if not from the first, these representa-
tives of the general property owners in town and country, the
Commons, sat and debated apart from the great Lords and Bish-
ops. So there grew up in England a representative assembly,
the Commons, beside an episcopal and patrician one, the Lords.
There was no profound and fundamental difference between the
personnel of the two assemblies ; many of the knights of the shire
were substantial men who might be as wealthy and influential
as peers and also the sons and brothers of peers, but on the whole
the Commons was the more plebeian assembly. From the first
1 This is not the same Simon de Montfort as the leader of the crusades against
the Albigenses, but his son.
220 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
these two assemblies, and especially the Commons, displayed a
disposition to claim the entire power of taxation in the land.
Gradually they extended their purview of grievances to a criti-
cism of all the affairs of the realm. We will not follow the fluctua-
tions of the power and prestige of the English Parliament through
the time of the Tudor monarchs (i.e., Henry VII and VIII, Ed-
ward VI, Mary, and Elizabeth), but it will be manifest from what
has been said that when at last James Stuart made his open claim
to autocracy, the English merchants, peers, and private gentle-
men found themselves with a tried and honoured traditional means
of resisting him such as no other people in Europe possessed.
Another peculiarity of the English political conflict was its com-
parative detachment from the great struggle between Catholic
and Protestant that was now being waged all over Europe. There
were, it is true, very distinct religious issues mixed up in the Eng-
lish struggle, but upon its main lines it was a political struggle
of King against the Parliament embodying the class of private-
property-owning citizens. Both Crown and people were formally
reformed and Protestant. It is true that many people on the latter
side were Protestants of a Bible-respecting, non-sacerdotal type,
representing the reformation according to the peoples, and that
the king was the nominal head of a special sacerdotal and sacra-
mental church, the established Church of England, represent-
ing the reformation according to the princes, but this antagonism
never completely obscured the essentials of the conflict.
The struggle of King and Parliament had already reached an
acute phase before the death of James I (1625), but only in the reign
of his son Charles I did it culminate in civil war. Charles did ex-
actly what one might have expected a king to do in such a
position, in view of the lack of Parliamentary control over foreign
policy ; he embroiled the country in a conflict with both Spain and
France, and then came to the country for supplies in the hope that
patriotic feeling would override the normal dislike to giving him
money. When Parliament refused supplies, he demanded loans
from various subjects, and attempted similar illegal exactions. This
produced from Parliament in 1628 a very memorable document, the
Petition of Right, citing the Great Charter and rehearsing the legal
limitations upon the power of the English king, denying his right to
PRINCES, PARLIAMENTS, AND POWERS 221
levy charges upon, or to imprison, or punish anyone, or to quarter
soldiers on the people, without due process of law. The Peti-
tion of Right stated the case of the English Parliament. The
disposition to " state a case" has always been a very marked
English characteristic. When President Wilson, during the Great
War of 1914-18, prefaced each step in his policy by a "Note,"
he was walking in the most respectable traditions of the English.
Charles dealt with this Parliament with a high hand, he dismissed
it in 1629, and for eleven years he summoned no Parliament. He
levied money illegally, but not enough for his purpose; and
realizing that the church could be used as an instrument of obe-
dience, he made Laud, an aggressive high churchman, very much
of a priest and a very strong believer in "divine right," Arch-
bishop of Canterbury, and so head of the Church of England.
In 1638 Charles tried to extend the half -Protestant, half-Catholic
characteristics of the Church of England to his other kingdom
of Scotland, where the secession from Catholicism had been more
complete, and where a non-sacerdotal, non-sacramental form of
Christianity, Presbyterianism, had been established as the na-
tional church. The Scotch revolted, and the English levies
Charles raised to fight them mutinied. Insolvency, at all times
the natural result of a "spirited" foreign policy, was close at hand.
Charles, without money or trustworthy troops, had to summon a
Parliament at last in 1640. This Parliament, the Short Parlia-
ment, he dismissed in the same year ; he tried a Council of Peers
at York (1640), and then, in the November of that year, sum-
moned his last Parliament.
This body, the Long Parliament, assembled in the mood for
conflict. It seized Laud, the Archbishop of Canterbury, and
charged him with treason. It published a " Grand Remonstrance,"
which was a long and full statement of its case against Charles.
It provided by a bill for a meeting of Parliament at least once
in three years, whether the King summoned it or ho. It prose-
cuted the King's chief ministers who had helped him to reign for
so long without Parliament, and in particular the Earl of Straf-
ford. To save Strafford the King plotted for a sudden seizure of
London by the army. This was discovered, and the Bill for Straf-
ford's condemnation was hurried on in the midst of a vast popular
222 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
excitement. Charles I, who was probably one of the meanest
and most treacherous occupants the English throne has ever
known, was frightened by the London crowds. Before Straf-
ford could die by due legal process, it was necessary for the King
to give his assent. Charles gave it — and Straff ord was be-
headed. Meanwhile the King was plotting and looking for help
in strange quarters — from the Catholic Irish, from treasonable
Scotchmen. Finally he resorted to a forcible-feeble display of
violence. He went down to the Houses of Parliament to arrest
five of his most active opponents. He entered the House of
Commons and took the Speaker's chair. He was prepared with
some bold speech about treason, but when he saw the places
of his five antagonists vacant, he was baffled, confused, and
spoke in broken sentences. He learnt that they had departed
from his royal city of Westminster and taken refuge in the city
of London (see chap, xxv, § 7). London defied him. A week
later the Five Members were escorted back in triumph to the Par-
liament House in Westminster by the Trained Bands of London,
and the King, to avoid the noise and hostility of the occasion,
left Whitehall for Windsor.
Both parties then prepared openly for war.
The King was the traditional head of the army, and the habit
of obedience in soldiers is to the King. The Parliament had the
greater resources. The King set up his standard at Notting-
ham on the eve of a dark and stormy August day in 1642. There
followed a long and obstinate civil war, the King holding Ox-
ford, the Parliament, London. Success swayed from side to side
but the King could never close on London nor Parliament take
Oxford. Each antagonist was weakened by moderate adherents
who "did not want to go too far." There emerged among the
Parliamentary commanders a certain Oliver Cromwell, who had
raised a small troop of horse and who rose to the position of gen-
eral. Lord Warwick, his contemporary, describes him as a plain
man, in a cloth suit "made by an ill country tailor." He was
no mere fighting soldier, but a military organizer; he realized
the inferior quality of many of the Parliamentary forces, and set
himself to remedy it. The Cavaliers of the King had the pic-
turesque tradition of chivalry and loyalty on their side ; Parlia-
PRINCES, PARLIAMENTS, AND POWERS 223
ment was something new and difficult — without any comparable
traditions. "Your troops are most of them old decayed serving
men and tapsters," said Cromwell. " Do you think that the spirits
of such base and mean fellows will ever be able to encounter
gentlemen that have honour and courage and resolution in them?"
But there is something better and stronger than picturesque
chivalry in the world, religious enthusiasm. He set himself to
get together a ' 'godly" regiment. They were to be earnest, sober-
living men. Above all, they were to be men of strong convictions.
He disregarded all social traditions, and drew his officers from
every class. "I had rather have a plain, russet-coated captain
that knows what he fights for and loves what he knows, than what
you call a gentleman and is nothing else." England discovered
a new force, the Ironsides, in its midst, in which footmen, dray-
men, and ships' captains held high command, side by side with men
of family. They became the type on which the Parliament sought
to reconstruct its entire army. The Ironsides were the backbone
of this "New Model." From Marston Moor to Naseby these
men swept the Cavaliers before them. The King was at last a
captive in the hands of Parliament.
There were still attempts at settlement that would have left
the King a sort of king, but Charles was a man doomed to tragic
issues, incessantly scheming, "so false a man that he is not to be
trusted." The English were drifting towards a situation new in
the world's history, in which a monarch should be formally tried
for treason to his people and condemned.
Most revolutions are precipitated, as this English one was,
by the excesses of the ruler, and by attempts at strength and
firmness beyond the compass of the law; and most revolutions
swing by a kind of necessity towards an extremer conclusion
than is warranted by the original quarrel. The English revo-
lution was no exception. The English are by nature a compromis-
ing and even a vacillating people, and probably the great ma-
jority of them still wanted the King to be King and the people
to be free, and all the lions and lambs to lie down together in
peace and liberty. But the army of the New Model could not go
back. There would have been scant mercy for these draymen
and footmen who had ridden down the King's gentlemen if the
224 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
King came back. When Parliament began to treat again with
this regal trickster, the New Model intervened; Colonel Pride
turned out eighty members from the House of Commons who
favoured the King, and the illegal residue, the Rump Parliament,
then put the King on trial.
! But indeed the King was already doomed. The House of Lords
rejected the ordinance for the trial, and the Rump then pro-
claimed "that the People are under God, the original of all just
power," and that "the Commons of England . . . have the su-
preme power in this nation," and — assuming that it was itself
the Commons — proceeded with the trial. The King was con-
demned as a "tyrant, traitor, murderer, and enemy of his coun-
try." He was taken one January morning in 1649 to a scaffold
erected outside the windows of his own banqueting-room at
Whitehall. There he was beheaded. He died with piety and a
certain noble self-pity — eight years after the execution of Straf-
ford, and after six and a half years of a destructive civil war which
had been caused almost entirely by his own lawlessness.
This was indeed a great and terrifying thing that Parliament
had done. The like of it had never been heard of in the world
before. Kings had killed each other times enough; parricide,
fratricide, assassination, those are the privileged expedients of
princes; but that a section of the people should rise up, try its
king solemnly and deliberately for disloyalty, mischief, and
treachery, and condemn and kill him, sent horror through every
court in Europe. The .Rump Parliament had gone beyond the
ideas and conscience of its time. It was as if a committee of
jungle deer had taken and killed a tiger — a crime against nature.
The Tsar of Russia chased the English envoy from his court.
France and Holland committed acts of open hostility. England,
confused and conscience-stricken at her own sacrilege, stood
isolated before the world.
But for a time the personal quality of Oliver Cromwell and the
discipline and strength of the army he had created maintained
England in the republican course she had taken. The Irish
Catholics had made a massacre of the Protestant English in Ire-
land, and now Cromwell suppressed the Irish insurrection with
great vigour. Except for certain friars at the storm of Drogheda,
PRINCES, PARLIAMENTS, AND POWERS 225
none but men with arms in their hands were killed by his troops ;
but the atrocities of the massacre were fresh in his mind, no quarter
was given in battle, and so his memory still rankles in the minds
of the Irish, who have a long memory for their own wrongs. After
Ireland came Scotland, where Cromwell shattered a Royalist
army at the Battle of Dunbar (1650). Then he turned his at-
tention to Holland, which country had rashly seized upon the
divisions among the English as an excuse for the injury of a trade
rival. The Dutch were then the rulers of the sea, and the Eng-
lish fleet fought against odds ; but after a series of obstinate sea
fights the Dutch were driven from the British seas and the Eng-
lish took their place as the ascendant naval power. Dutch and
French ships must dip their flags to them. An English fleet
went into the Mediterranean — the first English naval force to
enter those waters; it put right various grievances of the Eng-
lish shippers with Tuscany and Malta, and bombarded the pirate
nest of Algiers and destroyed the pirate fleet — which in the lax
days of Charles had been wont to come right up to the coast
of Cornwall and Devon to intercept ships and carry off slaves to
Africa. The strong arm of England also intervened to protect
the Protestants in the south of France, who were being hunted
to death by the Duke of Savoy. France, Sweden, Denmark,
all found it wiser to overcome their first distaste for regicide and
allied themselves with England. Came a war with Spain, and
the great English Admiral Blake destroyed the Spanish Plate
Fleet at Teneriffe in an action of almost incredible daring. He
engaged land batteries. He was the first man ''that brought ships
to contemn castles on the shore." (He died in 1657, and was
buried in Westminster Abbey, but after the restoration of the
monarchy his bones were dug out by the order of Charles II,
and removed to St. Margaret's, Westminster.) Such was the
figure that England cut in the eyes of the world during her brief
republican days.
On September 3rd, 1658, Cromwell died in the midst of a great
storm that did not fail to impress the superstitious. Once his
strong hand lay still, England fell away from this premature at-
tempt to realize a righteous commonweal of free men. In 1660
Charles II, the son of Charles the "Martyr," was welcomed back
Q
226 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
to England with all those manifestations of personal loyalty dear
to the English heart, and the country relaxed from its military
and naval efficiency as a sleeper might wake and stretch and yawn
after too intense a dream. The Puritans were done with.
"Merrie England" was herself again, and in 1667 the Dutch,
once more masters of the sea, sailed up the Thames to Gravesend
and burnt an English fleet in the Medway. " On the night when
our ships were burnt by the Dutch," says Pepys, in his diary,
"the King did sup with my Lady Castelmaine, and there they
were all mad, hunting a poor moth." Charles, from the date of
his return, 1660, took control of the foreign affairs of the state,
and in 1670 concluded a secret treaty with Louis XIV of France
by which he undertook to subordinate entirely English foreign
policy to that of France for an annual pension of £100,000. Dun-
kirk, which Cromwell had taken, had already been sold back to
France. The King was a great sportsman; he had the true
English love for watching horse races, and the racing centre at
Newmarket is perhaps his most characteristic monument.
While Charles lived, his easy humour enabled him to retain the
British crown, but he did so by wariness and compromise, and
when in 1685 he was succeeded by his brother James II, who
was a devout Catholic, and too dull to recognize the hidden limita-
tion of the monarchy in Britain, the old issue between Parliament
and Crown became acute. James set himself to force his coun-
try into a religious reunion with Rome. In 1688 he was in flight
to France. But this time the great lords and merchants and
gentlemen were too circumspect to let this revolt against the King
fling them into the hands of a second Pride or a second Crom-
well. They had already called in another king, William, Prince
of Orange, to replace James. The change was made rapidly.
There was no civil war — except in Ireland — and no release
of the deeper revolutionary forces of the country.
Of William's claim to the throne, or rather of his wife Mary's
claim, we cannot tell here, its interest is purely technical, nor
how William III and Mary ruled, nor how, after the widower
William had reigned alone for a time, the throne passed on to
Mary's sister Anne (1702-14). Anne seems to have thought
favourably of a restoration of the Stuart line, but the Lords and
PRINCES, PARLIAMENTS, AND POWERS 227
the Commons, who now dominated English affairs, preferred a
less competent king. Some sort of claim could be made out for
the Elector of Hanover, who became King of England as George
I (1714-27). He was entirely German, he could speak no Eng-
lish, and he brought a swarm of German women and German at-
tendants to the English court; a dullness, a tarnish, came over
the intellectual life of the land with his coming, the poetry, paint-
ing, architecture, and imaginative literature of later eighteenth-
century England is immeasurably below that of the seventeenth
century,1 but this isolation of the court from English life was his
conclusive recommendation to the great landowners and the
commercial interests who chiefly brought him over. England
entered upon a phase which Lord Beaconsfield has called the
"Venetian oligarchy" stage ; the supreme power resided in Parlia-
ment, dominated now by the Lords, for the art of bribery and a
study of the methods of working elections carried to a high pitch
by Sir Robert Walpole had robbed the House of Commons of its
original freedom and vigour. By ingenious devices the parlia-
mentary vote was restricted to a shrinking number of electors,
old towns with little or no population would return one or two
members (old Sarum had one non-resident voter, no population,
and two members), while newer populous centres had no repre-
sentation at all. And by insisting upon a high property quali-
fication for members, the chance of the Commons speaking in
common accents of vulgar needs was still more restricted. George
I was followed by the very similar George II (1727-60), and it
was only at his death that England had again a king who had been
born in England, and one who could speak English fairly well,
his grandson George III. On this monarch's attempt to recover
some of the larger powers of monarchy we shall have something
to say in a later section.
Such briefly is the story of the struggle in England during the
seventeenth and eighteenth centuries between the three main
factors in the problem of the "modern state"; between the
1 But Sir Joshua Reynolds, Hogarth, Gray, Gibbon, for instance! — G. M.
And the golden age of the great cabinet-makers ! — P. G.
Exactly! Culture taking refuge in the portraits, libraries, and households of
a few rich people. No national culture in the court, nor among the commonalty ;
a steady decay. — H. G. W.
228 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
crown, the private property owners, and that vague power, still
blind and ignorant, the power of the quite common people. This
latter factor appears as yet only at moments when the country is
most deeply stirred ; then it sinks back into the depths. But the
end of the story, thus far, is a very complete triumph of the
British private property owner over the dreams and schemes
of Machiavellian absolutism. With the Hanoverian Dynasty
England became — as the Times recently styled her — a " crowned
republic." She had worked, out^a new method of government,
Parliamentary government, recalling in many ways the Senate
and Popular Assembly of Rome, but more steadfast and efficient
because of its use, however restricted, of the representative method.
Her assembly at Westminster was to become the " Mother of
Parliaments" throughout the world. Towards the crown the
English Parliament has held and still holds much the relation
of the mayor of the palace to the Merovingian kings. The king
is conceived of as ceremonial and irresponsible, a living symbol
of the royal and imperial system. But much power remains
latent in the tradition and prestige of the crown, and the succession
of the four Hanoverian Georges, William IV (1830), Victoria
(1837), Edward VII (1901), and the present king, George V (1910),
is of a quite different strain from the feeble and short-lived|Mero-
vingian monarchs. In the affairs of the church, the military and
naval organizations, and the foreign office, these sovereigns have
all in various degrees exercised an influence ^which is none the
less important because it is indefinable.
§3
The breaking away of the Netherlands from absolutist mon-
archy was on the face of it much more of a religious and national
affair and much less economic and social than the English parlia-
mentary revolution. In the twelfth century all the lower Rhine
country was divided up among a number of small rulers, and the
population was a Low German one on a Keltic basis, mixed with
subsequent Danish ingredients very similar to the English ad-
mixture. The southeastern fringe of it spoke French dialects;
the bulk, Frisian, Dutch, and other Low German languages. The
Netherlands figured largely in the crusades. Godfrey of Bouillon,
PRINCES, PARLIAMENTS, AND POWERS 229
who took Jerusalem (First Crusade), was a Belgian; and the
founder of the so-called Latin Dynasty of emperors in Constanti-
nople (Fourth Crusade) was Baldwin of Flanders. (They were
called Latin emperors because they were on the side of the Latin
church.) In the thirteenth and fourteenth centuries consider-
able towns grew up in the Netherlands : Ghent, Bruges, Ypres,
Utrecht, Leyden, Haarlem, and so forth; and these towns de-
veloped quasi-independent municipal governments and a class
of educated townsmen. We will not trouble the reader with the
dynastic accidents that linked the affairs of the Netherlands with
Burgundy (Eastern France), and which finally made their over-
lordship the inheritance of the Emperor Charles V.
It was under Charles that the Protestant doctrines that now
prevailed in Germany spread into the Netherlands. Charles
persecuted with some vigour, but in 1556, as we have told, he
handed over the task to his son Philip (Philip II). Philip's
spirited foreign policy — he was carrying on a war with France
- presently became a second source of trouble between him-
self and the Netherlandish noblemen and townsmen, because he
had to come to them for supplies. The great nobles, led by Wil-
liam the Silent, Prince of Orange, and the Counts of Egmont
and Horn, made themselves the heads of a popular resistance,
in which it is now impossible to disentangle the objection to taxa-
tion from the objection to religious persecution. The great
nobles were not at first Protestants. They became Protestants
as the struggle grew in bitterness. The people were often bitterly
Protestant.
Philip was resolved to rule both the property and consciences
of his Netherlanders. He sent picked Spanish troops into the
country, and he made governor-general a nobleman named
Alva, one of those ruthless "strong" men who wreck govern-
ments and monarchies. For a time he ruled the land with a hand
of iron, but the hand of iron begets a soul of iron in the body it grips,
and in 1567 — about eighty years, that is, before the English
civil war — the Netherlands were in open revolt. Alva murdered,
sacked, and massacred — in vain. Counts Egmont and Horn
were executed. William the Silent became the great leader of
the Dutch, a king de facto. For a long time, and with many com-
230 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
plications, the struggle for liberty continued, and through it all
it is noteworthy that the rebels continued to cling to the plea
that Philip II was their king — if only he would be a reasonable
and limited king. But the idea of limited monarchy was dis-
tasteful to the crowned heads of Europe at that time, and at last
Philip drove the United Provinces, for which we now use the
name of Holland, to the republican form of government. Hol-
land, be it noted — not all the Netherlands ; the southern Nether-
lands, Belgium as we now call that country, remained at the end
of the struggle a Spanish possession and Catholic.
The siege of Alkmaar (1573), as Motley l describes it, may be
taken as a sample of that long and hideous conflict between the
little Dutch people and the still vast resources of Catholic Im-
perialism.
"'If I take Alkmaar,' Alva wrote to Philip, 'I am resolved
not to leave a single creature alive ; the knife shall be put to every
throat.' . . .
"And now, with the dismantled and desolate Haarlem before
their eyes, a prophetic phantom, perhaps, of their own immi-
nent fate, did the handful of people shut up within Alkmaar pre-
pare for the worst. Their main hope lay in the friendly sea.
The vast sluices called the Zyp, through which the inundation
of the whole northern province could be very soon effected, were
but a few miles distant. By opening these gates, and by pierc-
ing a few dykes, the ocean might be made to fight for them. To
obtain this result, however, the consent of the inhabitants was
requisite, as the destruction of all the standing crops would be
inevitable. The city was so closely invested, that it was a matter
of life and death to venture forth, and it was difficult, therefore,
to find an envoy for this hazardous mission. At last, a carpenter
in the city, Peter Van der Mey by name, undertook the adventure.
" Affairs soon approached a crisis within the beleaguered city.
Daily skirmishes, without decisive results, had taken place out-
side the walls. At last, on the 18th of September, after a steady
cannonade of nearly twelve hours, Don Frederick, at three in the
afternoon, ordered an assault. Notwithstanding his seven months'
1 Rise of the Dutch Republic.
PRINCES, PARLIAMENTS, AND POWERS 231
experience at Haarlem, he still believed it certain that he should
carry Alkmaar by storm. The attack took place at once upon
the Frisian gate and upon the red tower on the opposite side.
Two choice regiments, recently arrived from Lombardy, led the
onset, rending the air with their shouts and confident of an easy
victory. They were sustained by what seemed an overwhelming
force of disciplined troops. Yet never, even in the recent history
of Haarlem, had an attack been received by more dauntless breasts.
Every living man was on the walls. The storming parties were
assailed with cannon, with musketry, with pistols. Boiling
water, pitch and oil, molten lead, and unslaked lime were poured
upon them every moment. Hundreds of tarred and burning
hoops were skilfully quoited around the necks of the soldiers,
who struggled in vain to extricate themselves from these fiery
ruffs, while as fast as any of the invaders planted foot upon the
breach, they were confronted face to face with sword and dagger
by the burghers, who hurled them headlong into the moat below.
" Thrice was the attack renewed with ever-increasing rage —
thrice repulsed with unflinching fortitude. The storm con-
tinued four hours long. During all that period not one of
the defenders left his post, till he dropped from it dead or
wounded. . . . The trumpet of recall was sounded, and the Span-
iards, utterly discomfited, retired from the walls, leaving at least
one thousand dead in the trenches, while only thirteen burghers
and twenty-four of the garrison lost their lives. . . . Ensign
Solis, who had mounted the breach for an instant, and miracu-
lously escaped with life, after having been hurled from the battle-
ments, reported that he had seen ' neither helmet nor harness'
as he looked down into the city : only some plain-looking people,
generally dressed like fishermen. Yet these plain-looking fisher-
men had defeated the veterans of Alva. . . .
" Meantime, as Governor Sonoy had opened many of the dykes,
the land in the neighbourhood of the camp was becoming plashy,
although as yet the threatened inundation had not taken place.
The soldiers were already very uncomfortable and very refractory.
The carpenter-envoy had not been idle. ..."
He returned with despatches for the city. By accident or con-
trivance he lost these despatches as he made his way into the
232 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
town, so that they fell into Alva's hands. They contained a
definite ^promise from the Duke of Orange to flood the country
so as to drown the whole Spanish army. Incidentally this would
also have drowned most of the Dutch harvest and cattle. But
Alva, when he had read these documents, did not wait for the
opening of any more sluices. Presently the stout men of Alk-
maar, cheering and jeering, watched the Spaniards breaking
camp. . . .
The form assumed by the government of Holland was a pa-
trician republic under the headship of the house of Orange. The
States-General was far less representative of the whole body of
citizens than was the English Parliament even in its " Venetian"
days. Though the worst of the struggle was over after Alkmaar,
Holland was not effectively independent until 1609, and its inde-
pendence was only fully and completely recognized by the treaty
of Westphalia in 1648. We have given fthis account of the origin
of free Holland after OUT account of the English revolution because
it was less representative of the essential triangle of forces in the
developing modern state, and because it was complicated by the
merely patriotic element of insurrection against the Spanish
foreigner. But though we have told of it later, the reader must
remember it came to ils climax in the time of Queen Elizabeth
of England, half a century earlier than the English civil war.
As Motley says, the Dutch, the English, and the American revo-
lution, of which latter we have presently to tell, "form but a single
chapter in the great volume of human fate."
§4
Upon no part of Europe did the collapse of the idea of a unified
Christendom bring more disastrous consequences than to Ger-
many. Naturally one would have supposed that the Emperor,
being by origin a German, both in the case of the earlier lines
and in the case of the Habsburgs, would have developed into the
national monarch of a united German-speaking state. It was
the accidental misfortune of Germany that her Emperors never
remained German. Frederick II, the last Hohenstaufen, was,
as we have seen, a half-Orientalized Sicilian; the Habsburgs,
by marriage and inclination, became in the person of Charles V,
PRINCES, PARLIAMENTS, AND POWERS
233
first Burgundian and then Spanish in spirit. After the death of
Charles V, his brother Ferdinand took Austria and the empire,
and his son Philip II took Spain, the Netherlands, and South
Italy; but the Austrian line, obstinately Catholic, holding its
patrimony mostly on the eastern frontiers, deeply entangled
Onfeai EUROP afler
Cffh& free. Towns, -Hate: jSwecttkh.
Empire ***** «C»lognc French,
therefore with Hungarian affairs and paying tribute, as Ferdi-
nand and his two successors did, to the Turk, retained no grip
upon the north Germans with their disposition towards Protes-
tantism, their Baltic and westward affinities, and their ignorance
of or indifference to the Turkish danger.
The sovereign princes, dukes, electors, prince bishops, and the
like, whose domains cut up the map of the Germany of the Middle
234 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
Ages into a crazy patchwork, were really not the equivalents of
the kings of England and France. They were rather on the level
of the great land-owning dukes and peers of France and England.
Until 1701 none of them had the title of "King." Many of their
dominions were less both in size and value than the larger estates
of the British nobility. The German Diet was like the States-
General or like a parliament without the presence of elected
representatives. So that the great civil war in Germany that
presently broke out, the Thirty Years' War (1618-48), was in its
essential nature much more closely akin to the civil war in Eng-
land (1643^9) and to the war of the Fronde (1648-53), the league
of feudal nobles against the Crown in France, than appears upon
the surface. In all these cases the Crown was either Catholic
or disposed to become Catholic, and the recalcitrant nobles found
their individualistic disposition tending to a Protestant formula.
But while in England and Holland the Protestant nobles and rich
merchants ultimately triumphed and in France the success of the
Crown was even more complete, in Germany neither was the Em-
peror strong enough, nor had the Protestant princes a sufficient
unity and organization among themselves to secure a conclusive
triumph. It ended there in a torn-up Germany. Moreover,
the German issue was complicated by the fact that various non-
German peoples, the Protestant Bohemians and the Protestant
Swedes (who had a new Protestant monarchy which had arisen
under Gustava Vasa as a direct result of the Reformation) were
entangled in the struggle. Finally, the French monarchy, trium-
phant now over its own nobles, although it was Catholic, came in
on the Protestant side with the evident intention of taking the
place of the Habsburgs as the imperial line.
The prolongation of the war, and the fact that it was not fought
along a determined frontier, but all over an empire of patches,
Protestant here, Catholic there, made it one of the most cruel
and destructive that Europe had known since the days of the
barbarian raids. Its peculiar mischief lay not in the fighting,
but in the concomitants of the fighting. It came at a time when
military tactics had developed to a point that rendered ordinary
levies useless against trained professional infantry. Volley fir-
ing with muskets at a range of a few score yards had abolished the
PRINCES, PARLIAMENTS, AND POWERS 235
individualistic knight in armour, but the charge of disciplined
masses of cavalry could still disperse any infantry that had not
been drilled into a mechanical rigidity. The infantry with their
muzzle-loading muskets could not keep up a steady enough fire
to wither determined cavalry before it charged home. They had,
therefore, to meet the shock standing or kneeling behind a bris-
tling wall of pikes or bayonets. For this they needed great dis-
cipline and experience. Iron cannon were still of small size and
not very abundant, and they did not play a decisive part as yet
in warfare. They could "plough lanes" in infantry, but they
could not easily smash and scatter it if it was sturdy and well
drilled. War under these conditions was entirely in the hands of
seasoned professional soldiers, and the question of their pay was
as important a one to the generals of that time as the question of
food or munitions. As the long struggle dragged on from phase
to phase, and the financial distress of the land increased, the
commanders of both sides were forced to fall back upon the
looting of towns and villages, both for supply and to make up the
arrears of their soldiers' pay. The soldiers became, therefore,
more and more mere brigands living on the country, and the
Thirty Years' War set up a tradition of looting as a legitimate op-
eration in warfare and of outrage as a soldiers' privilege that has
tainted the good name of Germany right down to the Great War
of 1914. The earlier chapters of Defoe's Memoirs of a Cavalier,
with its vivid description of the massacre and burning of Magde-
burg, will give the reader a far better idea of the warfare of this
time than any formal history. So harried was the land that the
farmers ceased from cultivation, what snatch crops could be har-
vested were hidden away, and great crowds of starving women
and children became camp followers of the armies, and supplied
a thievish tail to the rougher plundering. At the close of the
struggle all Germany was ruined and desolate. Central Europe
did not fully recover from these robberies and devastations for a
century.
Here we can but name Tilly and Wallenstein, the great plunder
captains on the Habsburg side, and Gustavus Adolphus, the
King of Sweden, the Lion of the North, the champion of the Prot-
estants, whose dream was to make the Baltic Sea a "Swedish
236 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
Lake." Gustavus Adolphus was killed in his decisive victory
over Wallenstein at Liitzen (1632), and Wallenstein was mur-
dered in 1634. In 1648 the princes and diplomatists gathered
amidst the havoc they had made to patch up the affairs of Cen-
tral Europe at the Peace of Westphalia. By that peace the
power of the Emperor was reduced to a shadow, and the acquisi-
tion of Alsace brought France up to the Rhine. And one Ger-
man prince, the Hohenzollern Elector of Brandenburg, acquired
so much territory as to become the greatest German power next
to the Emperor, a power that presently (1701) became the king-
dom of Prussia. The Treaty also recognized two long accom-
plished facts, the separation from the empire and the complete
independence of both Holland and Switzerland.
§5
We have opened this chapter with the stories of two countries.
Britain and the Netherlands, in which the resistance of the pri-
vate citizen to this new type of monarchy, the Machiavellian
monarchy, that was arising out of the moral collapse of Christen-
dom, succeeded. But in France, Russia, in many states of Ger-
many and of Italy — Saxony and Tuscany e. g. — personal mon-
archy was not so restrained and overthrown; it established it-
self indeed as the ruling European system during the seventeenth
and eighteenth centuries.
(In Poland conditions were peculiar, and they will be dealt
with in a later section.)
In France there had been no Magna Carta, and there was no
tradition of parliamentary rule. There was the same opposi-
tion of interests between the crown on the one hand and the land-
lords and merchants on the other, but the latter had no recognized
and traditional gathering-place, and no dignified method of unity.
They formed oppositions to the crown, they made leagues of
resistance — such was the "Fronde," which was struggling against
the young King Louis XIV and his great minister Mazarin, while
Charles I was fighting for his life in England — but ultimately
(1652), after a civil war, they were conclusively defeated ; and
while in England after the establishment of the Hanoverians the
House of Lords and their subservient Commons ruled the country,
PRINCES, PARLIAMENTS, AND POWERS
237
in France, after 1652, the court entirely dominated the aristocracy.
Cardinal Mazarin was himself building upon a foundation that
Cardinal Richelieu, the contemporary of King James I of England,
had prepared for him. After the time of Mazarin we hear of no
great French nobles unless they are at court as court servants
and officials. They have
been tamed — but at a
price, the price of throw-
ing the burthen of taxa-
tion upon the voiceless
mass of the common
people. From many taxes
both the clergy and the
nobility — everyone in-
deed who bore a title —
were exempt. In the end
this injustice became in-
tolerable, but for a while
the French monarchy
flourished like the Psalm-
ist's green bay tree. By
the opening of the eight-
eenth century English
writers are already calling
attention to the misery of
the French lower classes
and the comparative pros-
perity, at that time, of the
English poor.
On such terms of un-
righteousness what we
may call " Grand Monarchy" established itself in France. Louis
XIV, styled the Grand Monarque, reigned for the unparalleled length
of seventy-two years (1643-1715), and set a pattern for all the kings
of Europe. At first he was guided by his Machiavellian minister,
Cardinal Mazarin ; after the death of the Cardinal he himself in his
own proper person became the ideal "Prince." He was, within his
limitations, an exceptionally capable king; his ambition was
238 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
stronger than his baser passions, and he guided his country towards
bankruptcy through the complication of a spirited foreign policy,
with an elaborate dignity that still extorts our admiration. His
immediate desire was to consolidate and extend France to the
Rhine and Pyrenees, and to absorb the Spanish Netherlands;
his remoter view saw the French kings as the possible successors
of Charlemagne in a recast Holy Roman Empire. He made
bribery a state method almost more important than warfare.
Charles II of England was in his pay, and so were most of the
Polish nobility, presently to be described. His money, or rather
the money of the tax-paying classes in France, went everywhere.
But his prevailing occupation was splendour. His great palace
at Versailles, with its salons, its corridors, its mirrors, its terraces
and fountains and parks and prospects, was the envy and ad-
miration of the world. He provoked a universal imitation. Every
king and princelet in Europe was building his own Versailles as
much beyond his means as his subjects and credits would per-
mit. Everywhere the nobility rebuilt or extended their chateaux
to the new pattern. A great industry of beautiful and elaborate
fabrics and furnishings developed. The luxurious arts flour-
ished everywhere; sculpture in alabaster, faience, gilt wood-
I work, metal work, stamped leather, much music, magnificent
painting, beautiful printing and bindings, fine cookery, fine vin-
tages. Amidst the mirrors and fine furniture went a strange race
;of " gentlemen" in vast powdered wigs, silks and laces, poised
upon high red heels, supported by amazing canes ; and still more
wonderful "ladies," under towers of powdered hair and wearing
vast expansions of silk and satin sustained on wire. Through
it all postured the great Louis, the sun of his world, unaware of
the meagre and sulky and bitter faces that watched him from
those lower darknesses to which his sunshine did not penetrate.
We cannot give here at any length the story of the wars and do-
ings of this monarch. In many ways Voltaire's Siecle de Louis
XIV is still the best and most wholesome account. He created
a French navy fit to face the English and Dutch ; a very con-
siderable achievement. But because his intelligence did not
rise above the lure of that Fata Morgana, that crack in the po-
litical wits of Europe, the dream of a world-wide Holy Roman
PRINCES, PARLIAMENTS, AND POWERS 239
Empire, he drifted in his later years to the propitiation of the
Papacy, which had hitherto been hostile to him. He set himself
against those spirits of independence and disunion, the Protes-
tant princes, and he made war against Protestantism in France.
Great numbers of his most sober and valuable subjects were driven
abroad by his religious persecutions, taking arts and industries
with them. The English silk manufacture, for instance, was
founded by French Protestants. Under his rule were carried out
the "dragonnades," a peculiarly malignant and effectual form of
persecution. Rough soldiers were quartered in the houses of the
Protestants, and were free to disorder the life of their hosts and
insult their womankind as they thought fit. Men yielded to that
sort of pressure who would not have yielded to rack and fire.
The education of the next generation of Protestants was broken
up, and the parents had to give Catholic instruction or none.
They gave it, no doubt, with a sneer and an intonation that
destroyed all faith in it. While more tolerant countries became
mainly sincerely Catholic or sincerely Protestant, the persecut-
ing countries, like France and Spain and Italy, so destroyed hon-
est Protestant teaching that these peoples became mainly Cath-
olic believers or Catholic atheists, ready to break out into blank
atheism whenever the opportunity offered. The next reign,
that of Louis XV, was the age of that supreme mocker, Voltaire
(1694-1778), an age in which everybody in French society con-
formed to the Roman church and hardly anyone believed in it.
It was part — and an excellent part — of the pose of Grand
Monarchy to patronize literature and the sciences. Louis XIV
set up an academy of sciences in rivalry with the English Royal
Society of Charles II and the similar association at Florence.
He decorated his court with poets, playwrights, philosophers,
and scientific men. If the scientific process got little inspiration
from this patronage, it did at any rate acquire resources for ex-
periment and publication, and a certain prestige in the eyes of the
vulgar.
Louis XV was the great-grandson of Louis XIV, and an incom-
petent imitator of his predecessor's magnificence. He posed as a
king, but his ruling passion was that common obsession of our
kind, the pursuit of women, tempered by a superstitious fear
240 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
of hell. How such women as the Duchess of Chateauroux, Ma-
dame de Pompadour, and Madame du Barry dominated the pleas-
ures of the king, and how wars and alliances were made, provinces
devastated, thousands of people killed, because of the vanities
and spites of these creatures, and how all the public life of France
and Europe was tainted with intrigue and prostitution and im-
posture because of them, the reader must learn from the me-
moirs of the time. The spirited foreign policy went on steadily
under Louis XV towards its final smash. In 1774 this Louis,
Louis the Well-Beloved, as his flatterers called him, died of small-
pox, and was succeeded by his grandson, Louis XVI (1774-93),
a dull, well-meaning man, an excellent shot, and an amateur lock-
smith of some ingenuity. Of how he came to follow Charles I to
the scaffold we shall tell in a later section. Our present concern
is with Grand Monarchy in the days of its glory.
Among the chief practitioners of Grand Monarchy outside France
we may note first the Prussian kings, Frederick William I (1713-
40), and his son and successor, Frederick II, Frederick the Great
(1740-86). The story of the slow rise of the Hohenzollern family,
which ruled the kingdom of Prussia, from inconspicuous begin-
nings is too tedious and unimportant for us to follow here. It
is a story of luck and violence, of bold claims and sudden be-
trayals. It is told with great appreciation in Carlyle's Frederick
the Great. By the eighteenth century the Prussian kingdom
was important enough to threaten the empire ; it had a strong,
well-drilled army, and its king was an attentive and worthy stu-
dent of Machiavelli. Frederick the Great perfected his Ver-
sailles at Potsdam. There the park of Sans Souci, with its foun-
tains, avenues, statuary, aped its model ; there also was the New
Palace, a vast brick building erected at enormous expense, the
Orangery in the Italian style, with a collection of pictures, a Marble
Palace, and so on. Frederick carried culture to the pitch of
authorship, and corresponded with and entertained Voltaire,
to their mutual exasperation. The Austrian dominions were
kept too busy between the hammer of the French and the anvil
of the Turks to develop the real Grand Monarch style until the
reign of MariarTheresa (who, being a woman, did not bear the
title of Empress) (1740-80). Joseph II, who was Emperor from
PRINCES, PARLIAMENTS, AND POWERS 241
242 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
1765-92, succeeded to her palaces in 1780. With Peter the
Great (1682-1725) the empire of Muscovy broke away from her
Tartar traditions and entered the sphere of French attraction.
Peter shaved the Oriental beards of his nobles and introduced
Western costume. These were but the outward and visible
symbols of his westering tendencies. To release himself from
the Asiatic feeling and traditions of Moscow, which, like Pekin,
has a sacred inner city, the Kremlin, he built himself a new capi-
tal, Petrograd, upon the swamp of the Neva. And of course
he built his Versailles, the Peterhof, about eighteen miles from
this new Paris, employing a French architect and having a terrace,
fountains, cascades, picture gallery, park, and all the recognized
features. His more distinguished successors were Elizabeth
(1741-62) and Catherine the Great, a German princess, who,
after obtaining the crown in sound Oriental fashion through the
murder of her husband, the legitimate Tsar, reverted to advanced
Western ideals and ruled with great vigour from 1762 to 1796.
She set up an academy, and corresponded with Voltaire. And
she lived to witness the end of the system of Grand Monarchy in
Europe and the execution of Louis XVI.
We cannot even catalogue here the minor Grand Monarchs
of the time in Florence (Tuscany) and Savoy and Saxony and Den-
mark and Sweden. Versailles, under a score of names, is starred
in every volume of Baedeker, and the tourist gapes in their pal-
aces. Nor can we deal with the war of the Spanish Succession.
Spain, overstrained by the imperial enterprises of Charles V and
Philip II, and enfeebled by a bigoted persecution of Protestants,
Moslems, and Jews, was throughout the seventeenth and eight-
eenth centuries sinking down from her temporary importance in
European affairs to the level of a secondary power again.
These European monarchs ruled their kingdoms as their noble-
men ruled their estates: they plotted against one another, they
were politic and far-seeing in an unreal fashion, they made wars,
they spent the substance of Europe upon absurd " policies " of
aggression and resistance. At last there burst upon them a great
storm out of the depths. That storm, the First French Revo-
lution, the indignation of the common man in Europe, took their
system unawares. It was but the opening outbreak of a great
PRINCES, PARLIAMENTS, AND POWERS 243
cycle of political and social storms that still continue, that will
perhaps continue until every vestige of nationalist monarchy
has been swept out of the world and the skies clear again for the
great peace of the federation of mankind.
§6
We have seen how the idea of a world-rule and a community
of mankind first came into human affairs, and we have traced
how the failure of the Christian churches to sustain and establish
those conceptions of its founder, led to a moral collapse in polit-
ical affairs and a reversion to egotism and want of faith. We
have seen how Machiavellian monarchy set itself up against the
spirit of brotherhood in Christendom, and how Machiavellian
monarchy developed throughout a large part of Europe into the
Grand Monarchies and Parliamentary Monarchies of the seven-
teenth and eighteenth centuries. But the mind and imagina-
tion of man is incessantly active, and beneath the sway of the
grand monarchs, a complex of notions and traditions was being
woven as a net is woven, to catch and entangle men's minds, the
conception of international politics not as a matter of dealings
between princes, but as a matter of dealings between a kind of
immortal Beings, the Powers. The Princes came and went; a
Louis XIV would be followed by a petticoat-hunting Louis XV,
and he again by that dull-witted amateur locksmith, Louis XVI.
Peter the Great gave place to a succession of empresses ; the chief
continuity of the Habsburgs after Charles V, either in Austria
or Spain, was a continuity of thick lips, clumsy chins, and super-
stition ; the amiable scoundrelism of a Charles II would make a
mock of his own pretensions. But what remained much more
steadfast were the secretariats of the foreign ministeries and the
ideas of people who wrote of state concerns. The ministers main-
tained a continuity of policy during the "off days" of their mon-
archs, and between one monarch and another.
So we find that the prince gradually became less important in
men's minds than the "Power" of which he was the head. We
begin to read less and less of the schemes and ambitions of King
This or That, and' more of the "Designs of France" or the "Am-
bitions of Prussia." In an age when religious faith was declin-
244 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
ing, we find men displaying a new and vivid belief in the reality
of these personifications. These vast vague phantoms, the
"Powers," crept insensibly into European political thought, until
in the later eighteenth and in the nineteenth centuries they domi-
nated it entirely. To this day they dominate it. European
life remained nominally Christian, but to worship one God in
spirit and in truth is to belong to one community with all one's
fellow worshippers. In practical reality Europe does not do this,
she has given herself up altogether to the worship of this strange
state mythology. To these sovereign deities, to the unity of
"Italy," to the hegemony of " Prussia," to the glory of "France,"
and the destinies of "Russia," she has sacrificed many genera-
tions of possible unity, peace, and prosperity and the lives of mil-
lions of men.
To regard a tribe or a state as a sort of personality is a very
old disposition of the human mind. The Bible abounds in such
personifications. Judah, Edom, Moab, Assyria figure in the
Hebrew Scriptures as if they were individuals; it is sometimes
impossible to say whether the Hebrew writer is dealing with a
person or with a nation. It is manifestly a primitive and natural
tendency. But in the case of modern Europe it is a retrocession.
Europe, under the idea of Christendom, had gone far towards
unification. And while such tribal persons as "Israel" or "Tyre"
did represent a certain community of blood, a certain uniformity
of type, and a homogeneity of interest, the European powers
which arose in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries were
entirely fictitious unities. Russia was in truth an assembly of
the most incongruous elements, Cossacks, Tartars, Ukrainians,
Muscovites, and, after the time of Peter, Esthonians and Lithu-
anians; the France of Louis XV comprehended German Alsace
and freshly assimilated regions of Burgundy; it was a prison
of suppressed Huguenots and a sweating-house for peasants. In
"Britain," England carried on her back the Hanoverian do-
minions in Germany, Scotland, the profoundly alien Welsh and
the hostile and Catholic Irish. Such powers as Sweden, Prussia,
and still more so Poland and Austria, if we watch them in a series of
historical maps, contract, expand, thrust out extensions, and wander
over the map of Europe like amoebae under the microscope. . . .
PRINCES, PARLIAMENTS, AND POWERS 245
If we consider the psychology of international relationship as
we see it manifested in the world about us, and as it is shown by
the development of the "Power" idea in modern Europe, we shall
realize certain historically very important facts about the nature
of man. Aristotle said that man is a political animal, but in our
modern sense of the word politics, which now covers world-pol-
itics, he is nothing of the sort. He has still the instincts of the
family tribe, and beyond that he has a disposition to attach him-
self and his family to something larger, to a tribe, a city, a na-
tion, or a state. But that disposition, left to itself, is a vague and
very uncritical disposition. If anything, he is inclined to fear
and dislike criticism of this something larger that encloses his life
and to which he has given himself, and to avoid such criticism.
Perhaps he has a subconscious fear of the isolation that may
ensue if the system is broken or discredited. He takes the milieu
in which he finds himself for granted ; he accepts his city or his
government, just as he accepts the nose or the digestion which
fortune has bestowed upon him. But men's loyalties, the sides
they take in political things, are not innate, they are educational
results. For most men their education in these matters is the
silent, continuous education of things about them. Men find
themselves a part of Merry England or Holy Russia ; they grow
up into these devotions; they accept them as a part of their
nature.
It is only slowly that the world is beginning to realize how
profoundly the tacit education of circumstances can be supple-
mented, modified, or corrected by positive teaching, by literature,
discussion, and properly criticized experience. The real life of
the ordinary man is his everyday life, his little circle of affections,
fears, hungers, lusts, and imaginative impulses. It is only when
his attention is directed to political affairs as something vitally
affecting this personal circle, that he brings his reluctant mind to
bear upon them. It is scarcely too much to say that the ordinary
man thinks as little about political matters as he can, and stops
thinking about them as soon as possible. It is still only very
curious and exceptional minds, or minds that have by example
or good education acquired the scientific habit of wanting to
know why, or minds shocked and distressed by some public ca-
246 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
tastrophe and roused to wide apprehensions of danger, that will
not accept governments and institutions, however preposterous,
that do not directly annoy them, as satisfactory. The ordinary
human being, until he is so aroused, will acquiesce in any col-
lective activities that are going on in this world in which he finds
himself, and any phrasing or symbolization that meets his vague
need for something greater to which his personal affairs, his indi-
vidual circle, can be anchored. ,
If we keep these manifest limitations of our nature in mind,
it no longer becomes a mystery how, as the idea of Christianity
as a world brotherhood of men sank into discredit because of its
fatal entanglement with priestcraft and the Papacy on the one
hand and with the authority of princes on the other, and the age
of faith passed into our present age of doubt and disbelief, men
shifted the reference of their lives from the kingdom of God and the
brotherhood of mankind to these apparently more living realities,
France and England, Holy Russia, Spain, Prussia, which were at
least embodied in active courts, which maintained laws, exerted
power through armies and navies, waved flags with a compell-
ing solemnity, and were self-assertive and insatiably greedy in an
entirely human and understandable fashion. Certainly such
men as Cardinal Richelieu and Cardinal Mazarin thought of them-
selves as serving greater ends than their own or their monarch's ;
they served the quasi-divine France of their imaginations. And
as certainly these habits of mind percolated down from them to
their subordinates and to the general body of the population.
In the thirteenth and fourteenth centuries the general population
of Europe was religious and only vaguely patriotic ; by the nine-
teenth it had become wholly patriotic. In a crowded English
or French or German railway carriage of the later nineteenth cen-
tury it would have aroused far less hostility to have jeered at God
than to have jeered at one of those strange beings, England or
France or Germany. To these things men's minds clung, and they
clung to them because in all the world there appeared nothing else
so satisfying to cling to. They were the real and living gods of
Europe.
(Yet in the background of the consciousness of the world, wait-
ing as the silence and moonlight wait above the flares and shouts,
PRINCES, PARLIAMENTS, AND POWERS 247
the hurdy-gurdys and quarrels of a village fair, is the knowledge
that all mankind is one brotherhood, that God is the universal
and impartial Father of mankind, and that only in that univer-
sal service can mankind find peace, or peace be found for the
troubles of the individual soul. . . .)
This idealization of governments and foreign offices, this
mythology of " Powers" and their loves and hates and conflicts,
has so obsessed the imaginations of Europe and Western Asia
as to provide it with its "forms of thought." Nearly all the
histories, nearly all the political literature of the last two cen-
turies in Europe, have been written in its phraseology. Yet a
time is coming when a clearer-sighted generation will read with
perplexity how in the community of western Europe, consisting
everywhere of very slight variations of a common racial mixture
of Nordic and Iberian peoples and immigrant Semitic and Mon-
golian elements, speaking nearly everywhere modifications of the
same Aryan speech, having a common past in the Roman Empire,
common religious forms, common social usages, and a common
art and science, and intermarrying so freely that no one could
tell with certainty the "nationality" of any of his great-grand-
children, men could be moved to the wildest excitement upon the
question of the ascendancy of "France," the rise and unification
of "Germany," the rival claims of "Russia" and "Greece" to
possess Constantinople. These conflicts will seem then as reason-
less and insane as those dead, now incomprehensible feuds of the
"greens" and "blues" that once filled the streets of Byzantium
with shouting and bloodshed.
Tremendously as these phantoms, the Powers, rule our minds
and lives to-day, they are, as this history shows clearly, things
only of the last few centuries, a mere hour, an incidental phase,
in the vast deliberate history of our kind. They mark a phase of
relapse, a backwater, as the rise of Machiavellian monarchy marks
a backwater; they are part of the same eddy of faltering faith,
in a process altogether greater and altogether different in its
general tendency, the process of the moral and intellectual re-
union of mankind. For a time men have relapsed upon these
national or imperial gods of theirs ; it is but for a time. The idea
of the world state, the universal kingdom of righteousness of
248 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
which every living soul shall be a citizen, was already in the
world two thousand years ago never more to leave it. Men
know that it is present even when they refuse to recognize it.
In the writings and talk of men about international affairs to-day,
in the current discussions of historians and political journalists,
there is an effect of drunken men growing sober, and terribly
afraid of growing sober. They still talk loudly of their "love"
for France, of their "hatred" of Germany, of the "traditional
ascendancy of Britain at sea/7 and so on and so on, like those who
sing of their cups in spite of the steadfast onset of sobriety and a
headache. These are dead gods they serve. By sea or land men
want no Powers ascendant, but only law and service. That silent
unavoidable challenge is in all our minds like dawn breaking
slowly, shining between the shutters of a disordered room.
§7
The seventeenth century in Europe was the century of Louis
XIV; he and French ascendancy and Versailles are the central
motif of the story. The eighteenth century was equally the
century of the "rise of Prussia as a great power," and the chief
figure in the story is Frederick II, Frederick the Great. Inter-
woven with his history is the story of Poland.
The condition of affairs in Poland was peculiar. Unlike its
three neighbours, Prussia, Russia, and the Austro-Hungarian
monarchy of the Habsburgs, Poland had not developed a Grand
Monarchy. Its system of government may be best described as
republican with a king, an elected life-president. Each king was
separately elected. It was in fact rather more republican than
Britain, but its republicanism was more aristocratic in form. Po-
land had little trade and few manufactures ; she was agricultural
and still with great areas of grazing, forest, and waste ; she was a
poor country, and her landowners were poor aristocrats. The
mass of her population was a downtrodden and savagely ignorant
peasantry, and she also harboured great masses of very poor
Jews. She had remained Catholic. She was, so to speak, a
poor Catholic inland Britain, entirely surrounded by enemies
instead of by the sea. She had no definite boundaries at all,
neither sea nor mountain. And it added to her misfortunes that
PRINCES, PARLIAMENTS, AND POWERS 249
some of her elected kings had been brilliant and aggressive rulers.
Eastward her power extended weakly into regions inhabited
almost entirely by Russians ; westward she overlapped a German
subject population.
Because she had no great trade, she had no great towns to com-
pare with those of western Europe, and no vigorous universities
to hold her mind together. Her noble class lived on their estates,
without much intellectual intercourse. They were patriotic,
they had an aristocratic sense of freedom — which was entirely
compatible with the systematic impoverishment of their serfs —
but their patriotism and freedom were incapable of effective
co-operation. While warfare was a matter of levies of men and
horses, Poland was a comparatively strong power; but it was
quite unable to keep pace with the development of military art
that was making standing forces of professional soldiers the
necessary weapon in warfare. Yet divided and disabled as she
was, she could yet count some notable victories to her credit.
The last Turkish attack upon Vienna (1683) was defeated by the
Polish cavalry under King John Sobiesky, King John III. (This
same Sobiesky, before he was elected king, had been in the pay
of Louis XIV, and had also fought for the Swedes against his
native country.) Needless to say, this weak aristocratic republic,
with its recurrent royal elections, invited aggression from all
three of its neighbours. "Foreign money," and every sort of
exterior interference, came into the country at each election.
And like the Greeks of old, every disgruntled Polish patriot flew
off to some foreign enemy to wreak his indignation upon his un-
grateful country.
Even when the King of Poland was elected, he had very little
power because of the mutual jealousy of the nobles. Like the
English peers, they preferred a foreigner, and for much the same
reason, because he had no roots of power in the land ; but, un-
like the British, their own government had not the solidarity
which the periodic assembling of Parliament in London, the
"coming up to town," gave the British peers. In London there
was "Society," a continuous intermingling of influential persons
and ideas. Poland had no London and no "Society." So
practically Poland had no central government at all. The King
250
THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
of Poland could not make war nor peace, levy a tax nor alter
the law, without the consent of the Diet, and any single member
of the Diet had the power of putting a veto upon any proposal be-
fore it. He had merely to rise and say, "I disapprove," and the
PATH 'IONS oT POLAND
matter dropped. He could even carry his free veto, his liberum
veto, further. He could object to the assembly of the Diet, and the
Diet was thereby dissolved. Poland was not simply a crowned
aristocratic republic like the British, it was a paralyzed crowned
aristocratic republic.
To Frederick the Great the existence of Poland was partic-
PRINCES, PARLIAMENTS, AND POWERS 251
ularly provocative because of the way in which an arm of Poland
reached out to the Baltic at Dantzig and separated his ancestral
dominions in East Prussia from his territories within the empire.
It was he who incited Catherine the Second of Russia and Maria /
Theresa of Austria, whose respect he had earned by depriving :
her of Silesia, to a joint attack upon Poland.
Let four maps of Poland tell the tale.
After this first outrage of 1772 Poland underwent a great change
of heart. Poland was indeed born as a nation on the eve of her
dissolution. There was a hasty but very considerable develop-
ment of education, literature, and art; historians and poets
sprang up, and the impossible constitution that had made Poland
impotent was swept aside. The free veto was abolished, the
crown was made hereditary to save Poland from the foreign in-
trigues that attended every election, and a Parliament in imita-
tion of the British was set up. There were, however, lovers of
the old order in Poland who resented these necessary changes,
and these obstructives were naturally supported by Prussia and
Russia, who wanted no Polish revival. Came the second parti-
tion, and, after a fierce patriotic struggle that began in the region
annexed by Prussia and found a leader and national hero in
Kosciusko, the final obliteration of Poland from the map. So
for a time ended this Parliamentary threat to Grand Monarchy
in Eastern Europe. But the patriotism and republican passion
of the Poles grew stronger and clearer with suppression. For a
hundred and twenty years Poland grew in spirit, and struggled
like a submerged creature beneath the political and military net
that held her down. She rose again in 1918, at the end of the
Great War.
§8
We have given some account of the ascendancy of France in
Europe, the swift decay of the sappy growth of Spanish power
and its separation from Austria, and the rise of Prussia. So
far as Portugal, Spain, France, Britain, and Holland were con-
cerned, their competition for ascendancy in Europe was extended
and complicated by a struggle for dominion overseas.
The discovery of the huge continent of America, thinly in-
252 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
habited, undeveloped, and admirably adapted for European
settlement and exploitation, the simultaneous discovery of great
areas of unworked country south of the torrid equatorial regions
of Africa that had hitherto limited European knowledge, and
the gradual realization of vast island regions in the Eastern seas,
as yet untouched by Western civilization, was a presentation of
opportunity to mankind unprecedented in all history. It was
as if the peoples of Europe had come into some splendid legacy.
Their world had suddenly quadrupled. There was more than
enough for all; they had only to take these lands and continue
to do well by them, and their crowded poverty would vanish
like a dream. And they received this glorious legacy like ill-
bred heirs ; it meant no more to them than a fresh occasion for
atrocious disputes. But what community of human beings has
ever yet preferred creation to conspiracy? What nation in all
our story has ever worked with another when, at any cost to
itself, it could contrive to do that other an injury? The Powers
of Europe began by a frantic " claiming" of the new realms.
They went on to exhausting conflicts. Spain, who claimed first
and most, and who was for a time "mistress" of two-thirds of
America, made no better use of her possession than to bleed her-
self nearly to death therein.
We have told how the Papacy in its last assertion of world do-
minion, instead of maintaining the common duty of all Christen-
dom to make a great common civilization in the new lands, di-
vided the American continent between Spain and Portugal. This
naturally roused the hostility of the excluded nations. The sea-
men of England showed no respect for either claim, and set them-
selves particularly against the Spanish ; the Swedes turned their
Protestantism to a similar account. The Hollanders, so soon
as they had shaken off their Spanish masters, also set their sails
westward to flout the Pope and share in the good things of the
new world. His Most Catholic Majesty of France hesitated as
little as any Protestant. All these powers were soon busy pegging
out claims in North America and the West Indies.
Neither the Danish kingdom (which at that time included Nor-
way and Iceland) nor the Swedes secured very much in the
scramble. The Danes annexed some of the West Indian islands.
PRINCES, PARLIAMENTS, AND POWERS 253
Sweden got nothing. Both Denmark and Sweden at this time
were deep in the affairs of Germany. We have already named
Gustavus Adolphus, the Protestant "Lion of the North," and
mentioned his campaigns in Germany, Poland, and Russia.
These Eastern European regions are great absorbents of energy,
and the strength that might have given Sweden a large share in
the new world reaped a barren harvest of glory in Europe. Such
small settlements as the Swedes made in America presently
fell to the Dutch.
The Hollanders too, with the French monarchy under Cardinal
Richelieu and under Louis XIV eating its way across the Spanish
Netherlands towards their frontier, had not the undistracted re-
sources that Britain, behind her " silver streak " of sea, could put
into overseas adventures.
Moreover, the absolutist efforts of James I and Charles I, and
the restoration of Charles II, had the effect of driving out from
England a great number of sturdy-minded, republican-spirited
Protestants, men of substance and character, who set up in
America, and particularly in New England, out of reach, as they
supposed, of the king and his taxes. The Mayflower was only
one of the pioneer vessels of a stream of emigrants. It was the
luck of Britain that they remained, though dissentient in spirit,
under the British flag. The Dutch never sent out settlers of the
same quantity and quality, first because their Spanish rulers
would not let them, and then because they had got possession of
their own country. And though there was a great emigration of
Protestant Huguenots from the dragonnades and persecution of
Louis XIV, they had Holland and England close at hand as refuges,
and their industry, skill, and sobriety went mainly to strengthen
those countries, and particularly England. A few of them founded
settlements in Carolina, but these did not remain French ; they
fell first to the Spanish and finally to the English.
The Dutch settlements, with the Swedish, also succumbed to
Britain ; Nieuw Amsterdam became British in 1674, and its name
was changed to New York, as the reader may learn very cheer-
fully in Washington Irving's Knickerbocker's History of New York.
The state of affairs in North America in 1750 is indicated very
clearly by a map we have adapted from one in Robinson's Medieval
254 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
and Modern Times. The British power was established along the
east coast from Savannah to the St. Lawrence River, and Newfound-
land and considerable northern areas, the Hudson Bay Company
territories, had been acquired by treaty from the French. The
British occupied Barbados (almost our oldest possession) in 1605,
and acquired Jamaica, the Bahamas, and British Honduras from
the Spaniards. But France was pursuing a very dangerous and
alarming game, a game even more dangerous and alarming on the
map than in reality. She had made real settlements in Quebec
and Montreal to the north and at New Orleans in the south, and
her explorers and agents had pushed south and north, making
treaties with the American Indians of the great plains and setting
up claims — without setting up towns — right across the conti-
nent behind the British. But the realities of the case are not
adequately represented in this way. The British colonies were
being very solidly settled by a good class of people ; they already
numbered a population of over a million; the French at that
time hardly counted a tenth of that. They had a number of
brilliant travellers and missionaries at work, but no substance of
population behind them.
Many old maps of America in this period are still to be found,
maps designed to scare and "rouse" the British to a sense of the
"designs of France" in America. War broke out in 1754, and in
1759 the British and Colonial forces under General Wolfe took
Quebec and completed the conquest of Canada in the next year.
In 1763 Canada was finally ceded to Britain. (But the western
part of the rather indefinite region of Louisiana in the south,
named after Louis XIV, remained outside the British sphere.
It was taken over by Spain; and in 1800 it was recovered by
France. Finally, in 1803, it was bought from France by the
United States government.) In this Canadian war the Ameri-
can colonists gained a considerable experience of the military
art, and a knowledge of British military organization that was to
be of great use to them a little later.
§9
It was not only in America that the French and British powers
clashed. The condition of India at this time was one very inter-
PRINCES, PARLIAMENTS, AND POWERS 255
v tn America, 1750*
not indicate
areas actually settled (cf. later
al extent of
claimed.
256
THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
esting and attractive to European adventurers. The great Mon-
gol Empire of Baber, Akbar, and Aurangzeb was now far gone
in decay. What had happened to India was very parallel to what
had happened to Germany. The Great Mogul at Delhi in India,
like the Holy Roman Emperor in Germany, was still legally over-
lord, but after the death of Aurangzeb he exerted only a nominal
authority except in the immediate neighbourhood of his capital.
In the southwest a Hindu people, the Mahrattas, had risen
against Islam, restored Brahminism as the ruling religion, and for
a time extended their power over the whole southern triangle of
India. In Rajputana also the rule of Islam was replaced by Brah-
minism, and at Bhurtpur and Jaipur there ruled powerful Rajput
princes. In Oudh there was a Shiite kingdom, with its capital at
FRINGES, PARLIAMENTS, AND POWERS 257
Lucknow, and Bengal was also a separate (Moslem) kingdom.
Away in the Punjab to the north had arisen a very interesting
religious body, the Sikhs, proclaiming the universal rule of one
God and assailing both the Hindu Vedas and the Moslem Koran.
Originally a pacific sect, the Sikhs presently followed the example
of Islam, and sought — at first very disastrously to themselves
— to establish the kingdom of God by the sword. And into this
confused and disordered India there presently (1738) came an
invader from the north, Nadir Shah (1736-47), the Turcoman
ruler of Persia, who swept down through the Khyber pass, broke
every army that stood in his way, and captured and sacked Delhi,
carrying off an enormous booty. He left the north of India so
utterly broken, that in the next twenty years there were no less
than six other successful plundering raids into North India from
Afghanistan, which had become an independent state at the death
of Nadir Shah. For a time Mahrattas fought with Afghans for
the rule of North India ; then the Mahratta power broke up into
a series of principalities, Indore, Gwalior, Baroda, and others. . . .
This was the India into which the French and English were
thrusting during the eighteenth century. A succession of other
European powers had been struggling for a commercial and po-
litical footing in India and the east ever since Vasco da Gama
had made his memorable voyage round the Cape to Calicut. The
sea trade of India had previously been in the hands of the Red
Sea Arabs,^and the Portuguese won it from them in a series of sea
fights. The Portuguese ships were the bigger, and carried a
heavier armament. For a time the Portuguese held the Indian
trade as their own, and Lisbon outshone Venice as a mart for
oriental spices ; the seventeenth century, however, saw the Dutch
grasping at this monopoly. At the crest of their power the Dutch
had settlements at the Cape of Good Hope, they held Mauritius,
they had two establishments in Persia, twelve in India, six in
Ceylon, and all over the East Indies they had dotted their forti-
fied stations. But their selfish resolution to exclude traders of
any other European nationality forced the Swedes, Danes, French,
and English into hostile competition. The first effectual blows
at their overseas monopoly were struck in European waters by
the victories of Blake, the English republican admiral; and by
258 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
the opening of the eighteenth century both the English and French
were in vigorous competition with the Dutch for trade and privi-
leges throughout India. At Madras, Bombay, and Calcutta the
English established their headquarters; Pondicherry and Chan-
dernagore were the chief French settlements.
At first all these European powers came merely as traders,
and the only establishments they attempted were warehouses;
but the unsettled state of the country, and the unscrupulous
methods of their rivals, made it natural for them to fortify and
arm their settlements, and this armament made them attractive
allies of the various warring princes who now divided India.
And it was entirely in the spirit of the new European nationalist
politics that when the French took one side, the British should
take another. The great leader upon the English side was Robert
Clive, who was born in 1725, and went to India in 1743. His
chief antagonist was Dupleix. The story of this struggle through-
out the first half of the eighteenth century is too long and intricate
to be told here. By 1761 the British found themselves completely
dominant in the Indian peninsula. At Plassey (1757) and at Buxar
(1764) their armies gained striking and conclusive victories over
the army of Bengal and the army of Oudh. The great Mogul,
nominally their overlord, became in effect their puppet. They
levied taxes over great areas; they exacted indemnities for real
or fancied opposition.
These successes were not gained directly by the forces of the
King of England; they were gained by the East India Trading
Company, which had been originally, at the time of its incorpora-
tion under Queen Elizabeth, no more than a company of sea ad-
venturers. Step by step they had been forced to raise troops
and arm their ships. And now this trading company, with its
tradition of gain, found itself dealing not merely in spices and
dyes and tea and jewels, but in the revenues and territories of
princes and the destinies of India. It had come to buy and sell,
and it found itself achieving a tremendous piracy. There was
no one to challenge its proceedings. Is it any wonder that its
captains and commanders and officials, nay, even its clerks
and common soldiers, came back to England loaded with spoils?
Men under such circumstances, with a great and wealthy land at
PRINCES, PARLIAMENTS, AND POWERS 259
their mercy, could not determine what they might or might not
do. It was a strange land to them, with a strange sunlight ; its
brown people were a different race, outside their range of sym-
pathy; its temples and buildings seemed to sustain fantastic
standards of behaviour. Englishmen at home were perplexed
when presently these generals and officials came back to make dark
accusations against each other of extortions and cruelties. Upon
Clive Parliament passed a vote of censure. He committed sui-
cide in 1774. In 1788 Warren Hastings, a second great Indian
administrator, was impeached and acquitted (1792). It was a
strange and unprecedented situation in the world's history.
The English Parliament found itself ruling over a London trading
company, which in its turn was dominating an empire far greater
and more populous than all the domains of the British crown.
To the bulk of the English people India was a remote, fantastic,
almost inaccessible land, to which adventurous poor young men
went out, to return after many years very rich and very choleric
old gentlemen. It was difficult for the English to conceive what
the life of these countless brown millions in the eastern sunshine
could be. Their imaginations declined the task. India re-
mained romantically unreal. It was impossible for the Eng-
lish, therefore, to exert any effective supervision and control over
the company's proceedings.
§10
And while the great peninsula of the south of Asia was thus
falling under the dominion of the English sea traders, an equally
remarkable reaction of Europe upon Asia was going on in the
north. We have told in chap, xxxiv, § 5c, how the Christian
states of Russia recovered their independence from the Golden
Horde, and how the Tsar of Moscow became master of the re-
public of Novgorod ; and in § 5 of this chapter we have told of
Peter the Great joining the circle of Grand Monarchs and, as it
were, dragging Russia into Europe. The rise of this great cen-
tral power of the old world, which is neither altogether of the
East nor altogether of the West, is one of the utmost importance
to our human destiny. We have also told in the same chapter
of the appearance of a Christian steppe people, the Cossacks,
260
THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
who formed a barrier between the feudal agriculture of Poland and
Hungary to the west and the Tartar to the east. The Cos-
sacks were the wild east of Europe, and in many ways not unlike
the wild west of the United States in the middle nineteenth cen-
tury. All who had made Russia too hot to hold them, criminals
South of unnramn subject to
Mafcratta Tribute.
E&stnn Sphere cf 'French
influence
J^rench, sstfbzmeitts vndei'lizieB.
British, •*
as well as the persecuted innocent, rebellious serfs, religious sec-
taries, thieves, vagabonds, murderers, sought asylum in the
southern steppes, and there made a fresh start and fought for life
and freedom against Pole, Russian, and Tartar alike. Doubt-
less fugitives from the Tartars to the east also contributed to the
Cossack mixture. Chief among these new nomad tribes were
the Ukraine Cossacks on the Dnieper and the Don Cossacks on the
PRINCES, PARLIAMENTS, AND POWERS 261
Don. Slowly these border folk were incorporated in the Rus-
sian imperial service, much as the Highland clans of Scotland
were converted into regiments by the British government. New
lands were offered them in Asia. They became a weapon against
the dwindling power of the Mongolian nomads, first in Turkes-
tan and then across Siberia as far as the Amur.
The decay of Mongol energy in the seventeenth and eighteenth
centuries is very difficult to explain. Within two or three cen-
turies from the days of Jengis and Timurlane, Central Asia had
relapsed from a period of world ascendancy to extreme political
impotence. Changes of climate, unrecorded pestilences, infec-
tions of a malarial type, may have played their part in this reces-
sion — which may be only a temporary recession measured by the
scale of universal history — of the Central Asian peoples. Some
authorities think that the spread of Buddhist teaching from
China also had a pacifying influence upon them. At any rate,
by the sixteenth century the Mongol Tartar and Turkish peoples
were no longer pressing outward, but were being invaded, sub-
jugated, and pushed back both by Christian Russia in the west
and by China in the east.
All through the seventeenth century the Cossacks were spread-
ing eastward from European Russia, and settling wherever they
found agricultural conditions. Cordons of forts and stations
formed a moving frontier to these settlements to the south, where
the Turkomans were still strong and active; to the north-east,
however, Russia had no frontier until she reached right to the
Pacific. . . .
At the same time China was in a phase of expansion. In 1644
the Ming Dynasty, in a state of artistic decay and greatly weak-
ened by a Japanese invasion, fell to Manchu conquerors, a people
apparently identical with the former Kin Dynasty, which had ruled
at Pekin over North China until the days of Jengis. It was the
Manchus who imposed the pigtail as a mark of political loyalty
upon the Chinese population. They brought a new energy into
Chinese affairs, and their northern interests led to a considerable
northward expansion of the Chinese civilization and influence
into Manchuria and Mongolia. So it was that by the middle of
the eighteenth century the Russians and Chinese were in contact
262 THE OUTLINE Otf HISTO&Y
in Mongolia. At this period China ruled eastern Turkestan,
*Tibet, Nepal, Burmah, and Annam. . . .
We have mentioned a Japanese invasion of China (or rather of
Korea). Except for this aggression upon China, Japan plays no
part in our history before the nineteenth century. Like China
under the Mings, Japan had set her face resolutely against the in-
terference of foreigners in her affairs. She was a country leading
her own civilized life, magically sealed against intruders. We
have told little of her hitherto because there was little to tell.
Her picturesque and romantic history stands apart from the gen-
eral drama of human affairs. Her population was chiefly a Mon-
golian population, with some very interesting white people of a
Nordic type, the Hairy Ainu, in the northern islands. Her civili-
zation seems to have been derived almost entirely from Korea and
China ; her art is a special development of Chinese art, her writ-
ing an adaptation of the Chinese script.
In these preceding ten sections we have been dealing with an
age of division, of separated nationalities. We have already
described this period of the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries
as an interregnum in the progress of mankind towards a world-
wide unity. Throughout this period there was no ruling unify-
ing idea in men's minds. The impulse of the empire had failed
until the Emperor was no more than one of a number of com-
peting princes, and the dream of Christendom also was a fading
dream. The developing "powers" jostled one another through-
out the world; but for a time it seemed that they might jostle
one another indefinitely without any great catastrophe to man-
kind. The great geographical discoveries of the sixteenth cen-
tury had so enlarged human resources that, for all their divisions,
for all the waste of their wars and policies, the people of Europe
enjoyed a considerable and increasing prosperity. Central
Europe recovered steadily from the devastation of the Thirty
Years War.
Looking back upon this period, which came to its climax in the
eighteenth century, looking back, as we can begin to do nowa-
days, and seeing its events in relation to the centuries that came
PRINCES, PARLIAMENTS, AND POWERS 263
before it and to the great movements of the present time, we are
able to realize how transitory and provisional were its political
forms and how unstable its securities. Provisional it was as no
other age has been provisional, an age of assimilation and recupera-
tion, a political pause, a gathering up of the ideas of men and the
resources of science for a wider human effort. But the contem-
porary mind did not see it in that light. The failure of the great
creative ideas as they had been formulated in the Middle Ages,
had left human thought for a time destitute of the guidance of
creative ideas ; even educated and imaginative men saw the world
undramatically ; no longer as an interplay of effort and destiny,
but as the scene in which a trite happiness was sought and the
milder virtues were rewarded. It was not simply the contented
and conservative-minded who, in a world of rapid changes, were
under the sway of this assurance of an achieved fixity of human
conditions. Even highly critical and insurgent intelligences,
in default of any sustaining movements in the soul of the com-
munity, betrayed the same disposition. Political life, they felt,
had ceased to be the urgent and tragic thing it had once been;
it had become a polite comedy. The eighteenth was a century
of comedy — which at the end grew grim. It is inconceivable
that that world of the middle eighteenth century could have
produced a Jesus of Nazareth, a Gautama, a Francis of Assisi,
an Ignatius of Loyola. If one may imagine an eighteenth-cen-
tury John Huss, it is impossible to imagine anyone with suffi-
cient passion to burn him. Until the stirrings of conscience in
Britain that developed into the Methodist revival began, we can
detect scarcely a suspicion that there still remained great tasks
in hand for our race to do, that enormous disturbances were close
at hand, or that the path of man through space and time was dark
with countless dangers, and must to the end remain a high and
terrible enterprise.
We have quoted again and again in this history from Gibbon's
Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire. Now we shall quote
from it for the last time and bid it farewell, for we have come
to the age in which it was written. Gibbon was born in 1737,1
1 See his fragment of autobiography (The Autobiography of Edward Gibbon,
edited by John Murray).
264 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
and the last volume of his history was published in 1787, but the
passage we shall quote was probably written in the year 1780.
Gibbon was a young man of delicate health and fairly good for-
tune ; he had a partial and interrupted education at Oxford, and
then he completed his studies in Geneva ; on the whole his out-
look was French and cosmopolitan rather than British, and he
was much under the intellectual influence of that great French-
man who is best known under the name of Voltaire (Frangois Marie
Arouet de Voltaire, 1694-1778). Voltaire was an author of enor-
mous industry ; seventy volumes of him adorn the present writer's
shelves, and another edition of Voltaire's works runs to ninety-
four; he dealt largely with history and public affairs, and he
corresponded with Catherine the Great of Russia, Frederick the
Great of Prussia, Louis XV, and most of the prominent people
of the time. Both Voltaire and Gibbon had the sense of history
strong in them; both have set out very plainly and fully their
visions of human life; and it is clear that to both of them the
system in which they lived, the system of monarchy, of leisurely and
privileged gentlefolks, of rather despised industrial and trading
people and of down-trodden and negligible labourers and poor and
common people, seemed the most stably established way of living
that the world has ever seen. They postured a little as republicans,
and sneered at the divine pretensions of monarchy ; but the repub-
licanism that appealed to Voltaire was the crowned republicanism
of the Britain of those days, in which the king was simply the offi-
cial head, the first and greatest of the gentlemen.
The ideal they sustained was the ideal of a polite and polished
world in which men — men of quality that is, for no others counted
- would be ashamed to be cruel or gross or enthusiastic, in which
the appointments of life would be spacious and elegant, and the
fear of ridicule the potent auxiliary of the law in maintaining the
decorum and harmonies of life. Voltaire had in him the possi-
bility of a passionate hatred of injustice, and his interventions
on behalf of persecuted or ill-used men are the high lights of his
long and complicated life-story. And this being the mental dis-
position of Gibbon and Voltaire, and of the age in which they
lived, it is natural that they should find the existence of religion
in the world, and in particular the existence of Christianity, a
PRINCES, PARLIAMENTS, AND POWERS 265
perplexing and rather unaccountable phenomenon. The whole
of that side of life seemed to them a kind of craziness in the human
make-up. Gibbon's great history is essentially an attack upon
Christianity as the operating cause of the decline and fall. He
idealized the crude and gross plutocracy of Rome into a world
of fine gentlemen upon the eighteenth-century model, and told
how it fell before the Barbarian from without because of the de-
cay through Christianity within. In our history here we have
tried to set that story in a better light. To Voltaire official
Christianity was "Vinf&tne" } something that limited people's
lives, interfered with their thoughts, persecuted harmless dis-
sentients. And indeed in that period of the interregnum there
was very little life or light in either the orthodox Christianity
of Rome or in the orthodox tame churches of Russia and of the
Protestant princes. In an interregnum incommoded with an
abundance of sleek parsons and sly priests it was hard to realize
what fires had once blazed in the heart of Christianity, and what
fires of political and religious passion might still blaze in the
hearts of men.
At the end of his third volume Gibbon completed his account
of the breaking up of the Western Empire. He then raised the
question whether civilization might ever undergo again a similar
collapse. This led him to review the existing state of affairs
(1780) and to compare it with the state of affairs during the de-
cline of imperial Rome. It will be very convenient to our general
design to quote some passages from that comparison here, for
nothing could better illustrate the state of mind of the liberal
thinkers of Europe at the crest of the political interregnum of
the age of the Great Powers, before the first intimations of
those profound political and social forces of disintegration that
have produced at length the dramatic interrogations of our own
times.
"This awful revolution," wrote Gibbon of the Western col-
lapse, "may be usefully applied to the useful instruction of the
present age. It is the duty of a patriot to prefer and promote
the exclusive interest and glory of his native country; but a
philosopher may be permitted to enlarge his views, and to con-
sider Europe as one great republic, whose various inhabitants
266 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
have attained almost the same level of politeness and cultiva-
tion. The balance of power will continue to fluctuate, and the
prosperity of our own or the neighbouring kingdoms may be al-
ternately exalted or depressed; but these partial events cannot
essentially injure our general state of happiness, the system of
arts, and laws, and manners, which so advantageously distin-
guish, above the rest of mankind, the Europeans and their colonies.
The savage nations of the globe are the common enemies of civilized
society ; and we may enquire with anxious curiosity whether
Europe is still threatened with a repetition of those calamities
which formerly oppressed the arms and institutions of Rome.
Perhaps the same reflections will illustrate the fall of that mighty
empire and explain the probable causes of our actual security.
"The Romans were ignorant of the extent of their danger, and
the number of their enemies. Beyond the Rhine and Danube,
the northern countries of Europe and Asia were filled with in-
numerable tribes of hunters and shepherds, poor, voracious, and
turbulent; bold in arms, and impatient to ravish the fruits of
industry. The Barbarian world was agitated by the rapid im-
pulse of war ; and the peace of Gaul or Italy was shaken by the
distant revolutions of China. The Huns, who fled before a vic-
torious enemy, directed their march towards the west; and the
torrent was swelled by the gradual accession of captives and allies.
The flying tribes who yielded to the Huns assumed in their turn
the spirit of conquest ; the endless column of barbarians pressed
on the Roman Empire with accumulated weight and, if the fore-
most were destroyed, the vacant space was instantly replenished
by new assailants. Such formidable emigrations can no longer
issue from the North ; and the long repose, which has been imputed
to the decrease of population, is the happy consequence of the
progress of arts and agriculture. Instead of some rude villages,
thinly scattered among its woods and morasses, Germany now
produces a list of two thousand three hundred walled towns;
the Christian kingdoms of Denmark, Sweden, and Poland have
been successively established; and the Hanse merchants, with
the Teutonic knights, have extended their colonies along the
coast of the Baltic, as far as the Gulf of Finland. From the Gulf
of Finland to the Eastern Ocean, Russia now assumes the form
PRINCES, PARLIAMENTS, AND POWERS 267
of a powerful and civilized empire. The plough, the loom, and the
forge are introduced on the banks of the Volga, the Oby, and the
Lena ; and the fiercest of the Tartar hordes have been taught to
tremble and obey. . . .
"The Empire of Rome was firmly established by the singular
and perfect coalition of its members. . . . But this union was
purchased by the loss of national freedom and military spirit;
and the servile provinces, destitute of life and motion, expected
their safety from the mercenary troops and governors, who were
directed by the orders of a distant court. The happiness of a
hundred millions depended on the personal merit of one or two
men, perhaps children, whose minds were corrupted by educa-
tion, luxury, and despotic power. Europe is now divided into
twelve powerful, though unequal kingdoms, three respectable
commonwealths, and a variety of smaller, though independent,
states ; the chances of royal and ministerial talents are multiplied,
at least with the number of its rulers ; and a Julian l or Semi-
ramis 2 may reign in the north, while Arcadius and Honorius 3
again slumber on the thrones of the House of Bourbon. The
abuses of tyranny are restrained by the mutual influence of fear
and shame; republics have acquired order and stability; mon-
archies have imbibed the principles of freedom, or, at least, of
moderation ; and some sense of honour and justice is introduced
into the most defective constitutions by the general manners of
the times. In peace, the progress of knowledge and industry is
accelerated by the emulation of so many active rivals: in war,
the European forces are exercised by temperate and undecisive
contests. If a savage conqueror should issue from the deserts
of Tartary, he must repeatedly vanquish the robust peasants
of Russia, the numerous armies of Germany, the gallant nobles
of France, and the intrepid freemen of Britain; who, perhaps,
might confederate for their common defence. Should the vic-
torious Barbarians carry slavery and desolation as far as the At-
lantic Ocean, ten thousand vessels would transport beyond their
pursuit the remains of civilized society; and Europe would re-
1 Frederick the Great of Prussia.
8 Catherine the Great of Russia.
« Louis XVI of France and Charles III of Spain.
268 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
vive and flourish in the American world which is already filled
with her colonies and institutions.
"Cold, poverty, and a life of danger and fatigue fortify the
strength and courage of Barbarians. In every age they have op-
pressed the polite and peaceful nations of China, India, and
Persia, who neglected, and still neglect, to counterbalance these
natural powers by the resources of military art. The warlike
states of antiquity, Greece, Macedonia, and Rome, educated a
race of soldiers ; exercised their bodies, disciplined their courage,
multiplied their forces by regular evolutions, and converted the
iron which they possessed into strong and serviceable weapons.
But this superiority insensibly declined with their laws and
manners ; and the feeble policy of Constantine and his successors
armed and instructed, for the ruin of the empire, the rude valour
of the Barbarian mercenaries. The military art has been changed
by the invention of gunpowder ; which enables man to command
the two most powerful agents of nature, air and fire. Mathe-
matics, chemistry, mechanics, architecture, have been applied
to the service of war; and the adverse parties oppose to each
other the most elaborate modes of attack and of defence. His-
torians may indignantly observe that the preparations of a siege
would found and maintain a flourishing colony; yet we cannot
be displeased that the subversion of a city should be a work of
cost and difficulty, or that an industrious people should be pro-
tected by those arts, which survive and supply the decay of mili-
tary virtue. Cannon and fortifications now form an impregnable
barrier against the Tartar horse ; 1 and Europe is secure from any
future irruption of Barbarians; since, before they can conquer,
they must cease to be barbarous. . . .
"Should these speculations be found doubtful or fallacious,
there still remains a more humble source of comfort and hope.
The discoveries of ancient and modern navigators, and the do-
mestic history, or tradition, of the most enlightened nations, repre-
sent the human savage, naked both in mind and body, and desti-
tute of laws, of arts, of ideas, and almost of language. From this
abject condition, perhaps the primitive and universal state of man,
1 Gibbon forgets here that cannon and the fundamentals of modern military
method came to Europe with the Mongols.
PRINCES, PARLIAMENTS, AND POWERS 269
he has gradually arisen to command the animals, to fertilize the
earth, to traverse the ocean, and to measure the heavens. His
progress in the improvement and exercise of his mental and cor-
poreal faculties has been irregular and various, infinitely slow in
the beginning, and increasing by degrees with redoubled velocity ;
ages of laborious ascent have been followed by a moment of rapid
downfall ; and the several climates of the globe have felt the vicissi-
tudes of light and darkness. Yet the experience of four thousand
years should enlarge our hopes, and diminish our apprehensions ;
we cannot determine to what height the human species may as-
pire in their advances towards perfection ; but it may safely be
presumed that no people, unless the face of nature is changed, will
relapse into their original barbarism.
" Since the first discovery of the arts, war, commerce, and
religious zeal have diffused, among the savages of the Old and New
World, those inestimable gifts, they have been successively
propagated ; they can never be lost. We may therefore acquiesce
in the pleasing conclusion that every age of the world has in-
creased, and still increases, the real wealth, the happiness, the
knowledge, and perhaps the virtue, of the human race."
§12*
One of the most interesting aspects of this story of Europe in
the seventeenth and earlier eighteenth century during the phase
of the Grand and Parliamentary Monarchies, is the comparative
quiescence of the peasants and workers. The insurrectionary fires
of the fourteenth and fifteenth and sixteenth centuries seem to have
died down. The acute economic clashes of the earlier period had
been mitigated by rough adjustments. The discovery of America
had revolutionized and changed the scale of business and industry,
had brought a vast volume of precious metal for money into
Europe, had increased and varied employment. For a time life
and work ceased to be intolerable to the masses of the poor. This
did not, of course, prevent much individual misery and discontent ;
1 See for the expansion of the topics of this section, Hammond's Town Labourer,
Village Labourer, and Skilled Labourer. These three books are too little known to
the general reader. They are not dry-as-dust compilations of statistics, but full
of interesting matter and delightfully well written,
270 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
the poor we have always had with us, but this misery and dis-
content was divided and scattered. It became inaudible.
In the earlier period the common people had had an idea to crys-
tallize upon, the idea of Christian communism. They had found
an educated leadership in the dissentient priests and doctors of the
Wycliffe type. As the movement for a revival in Christianity
spent its force, as Lutheranism fell back for leadership from Jesus
upon the Protestant Princes, this contact and reaction of the
fresher minds of the educated class upon the illiterate mass was in-
terrupted. However numerous a downtrodden class may be, and
however extreme its miseries, it will never be able to make an effec-
tive protest until it achieves solidarity by the development of some
common general idea. Educated men and men of ideas are more
necessary to a popular political movement than to any other polit-
ical process. A monarchy learns by ruling, and an oligarchy of
any type has the education of affairs ; but the common man, the
peasant or toiler, has no experience in large matters, and can
exist politically only through the services, devotion, and guidance
of educated men. The Reformation, the Reformation that suc-
ceeded, the Reformation that is of the Princes, by breaking up
educational facilities, largely destroyed the poor scholar and priest
class whose persuasion of the crowd had rendered the Reformation
possible.
The Princes of the Protestant countries when they seized upon
the national churches early apprehended the necessity of gripping
the universities also. Their idea of education was the idea of
capturing young clever people for the service of their betters.
Beyond that they were disposed to regard education as a mischiev-
ous thing. The only way to an education, therefore, for a poor
man was through patronage. Of course there was a parade of
encouragement towards learning in all the Grand Monarchies, a
setting up of Academies and Royal Societies, but these benefited
only a small class of subservient scholars. The church also had
learnt to distrust the educated poor man. In the great aristocratic
" crowned republic" of Britain there was the same shrinkage of
educational opportunity. "Both the ancient universities," says
Hammond, in his account of the eighteenth century, "were the
universities of the rich, There is a passage in Macaulay describing
PRINCES, PARLIAMENTS, AND POWERS 271
the state and pomp of Oxford at the end of the seventeenth cen-
tury, 'when her Chancellor, the Venerable Duke of Ormonde,
sat in his embroidered mantle on his throne under the painted
ceiling of the Sheldonian theatre, surrounded by hundreds of grad-
uates robed according to their rank, while the noblest youths of
England were solemnly presented to him as candidates for academ-
ical honours/ The university was a power, not in the sense in
which that could be said of a university like the old university of
Paris, whose learning could make Popes tremble, but in the sense
that the university was part of the recognized machinery of aris-
tocracy. What was true of the universities was true of the public
schools. Education in England was the nursery not of a society,
but of an order ; not of a state, but of a race of owner-rulers."
The missionary spirit had departed from education throughout
Europe. To that quite as much as to the amelioration of things
by a diffused prosperity, this phase of quiescence among the lower
classes is to be ascribed. They had lost brains and speech, and
they were fed. The community was like a pithed animal in the
hands of the governing class.1
Moreover, there had been considerable changes in the proportions
of class to class. One of the most difficult things for the historian
to trace is the relative amount of the total property of the com-
munity held at any time by any particular class in that com-
munity. These things fluctuate very rapidly. The peasant wars
of Europe indicate a phase of comparatively concentrated property
when large masses of people could feel themselves expropriated
and at a common disadvantage, and so take mass action. This
was the time of the rise and prosperity of the Fuggers and their
like, a time of international finance. Then with the vast importa-
tion of silver and gold and commodities into Europe from America,
there seems to have been a restoration of a more diffused state of
wealth. The poor were just as miserable as ever, but there were
perhaps not so many poor relatively, and they were broken up into
1 "Our present public school system is candidly based on training a dominant
master class. But the uprising of the workers and modern conditions are rapidly
making the dominant method unworkable. . . . The change in the aim of schools
will transform all the organizations and methods of schools, and my belief is that
this change will make the new era." — F. W. Sanderson, Head Master of Oundle,
in an address at Leeds, February 16, 1920.
272 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
a variety of types without any ideas in common. In Great Britain
the agricultural life which had been dislocated by the confiscations
of the Reformation had settled down again into a system of tenant
farming under great landowners. Side by side with the large
estates there was still, however, much common land for pasturing
the beasts of the poorer villagers, and much land cultivated in strips
upon communal lines. The middling sort of man, and even the
poorer sort of man upon the land, were leading an endurable exist-
ence in 1700. The standard of life, the idea, that is, of what is an
endurable existence, was, however, rising during the opening phase
of Grand Monarchy ; after a time the process of the upward con-
centration of wealth seems to have been resumed, the larger land-
owners began to acquire and crowd out the poorer free cultivators,
and the proportion of poor people and of people who felt they
were leading impoverished lives increased again. The bigger men
were unchallenged rulers of Great Britain, and they set themselves
to enact laws, the Enclosure Acts, that practically confiscated the
unenclosed and common lands, mainly for the benefit of the larger
landowners. The smaller men sank to the level of wage workers
upon the land over which they had once possessed rights of culti-
vation and pasture.
The peasant in France and upon the Continent generally was not
so expropriated; his enemy was not the landlord, but the tax-
gatherer ; he was squeezed on his land instead of being squeezed
off it.
As the eighteenth century progressed, it is apparent in the litera-
ture of the time that what to do with "the poor" was again exer-
cising men's thoughts. We find such active-minded English
writers as Defoe (1659-1731) and Fielding (1707-54) deeply exer-
cised by this problem. But as yet there is no such revival of the
communistic and equalitarian ideas of primitive Christianity as
distinguished the time of Wycliffe and John Huss. Protestantism
in breaking up the universal church had for a time broken up the
idea of a universal human solidarity. Even if the universal church
of the Middle Ages had failed altogether to realize that idea, it
had at any rate been the symbol of that idea.
Defoe and Fielding were men of a livelier practical imagination
than Gibbon, and they realized something of the economic processes
FRINGES, PARLIAMENTS, AND POWERS 273
that were afoot in their time. So did Oliver Goldsmith (1728-74) ;
his Deserted Village (1770) is a pamphlet on enclosures disguised
as a poem.1 But Gibbon's circumstances had never brought eco-
nomic facts very vividly before his eyes ; he saw the world as a
struggle between barbarism and civilization, but he perceived
nothing of that other struggle over which he floated, the mute,
unconscious struggle of the commonalty against able, powerful,
rich, and selfish men. He did not perceive the accumulation of
stresses that were presently to strain and break up all the balance
of his " twelve powerful, though unequal, kingdoms/' his "three
respectable commonwealths," and their rag, tag, and bobtail of
independent minor princes, reigning dukes, and so forth. Even
the civil war that had begun in the British colonies in America
did not rouse hmrto the nearness of what we now call "Democ-
racy."
From what we have been saying hitherto, the reader may suppose
that the squeezing of the small farmer and the peasant off the land
by the great landowners, the mere grabbing of commons and the
concentration of property in the hands of a powerful privileged
and greedy class, was all that was happening to the English land in
the eighteenth century. So we do but state the worse side of the
change. Concurrently with this change of ownership there was
going on a great improvement in agriculture. There can be little
doubt that the methods of cultivation pursued by the peasants,
squatters, and small farmers were antiquated, wasteful, and com-
paratively unproductive, and that the larger private holdings and
estates created by the Enclosure Acts were much more productive
(one authority says twenty times more productive) than the old
ways. The change was perhaps a necessary one and the evil of it
was not that it was brought about, but that it was brought about
so as to increase both wealth and the numbers of the poor. Its
benefits were intercepted by the bigger private owners. The
community was injured to the great profit of this class.
And here we come upon one of the chief problems of our lives
1 The student who looks up the Encyclopaedia Britannica," article "Goldsmith,"
instead of going to the poem itself, will find some hostile comments thereon which
are themselves now literature and history ; they were written by Lord Macaulay
(1800-59).
T
274 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
at the present time, the problem of the deflection of the profits
of progress. For two hundred years there has been, mainly under
the influence of the spirit of science and enquiry, a steady improve-
ment in the methods of production of almost everything that
humanity requires. If our sense of community and our social
science were equal to the tasks required of them, there can be little
question that this great increment in production would have bene-
fited the whole community, would have given everyone an amount
of education, leisure and freedom such as mankind had never
dreamt of before. But though the common standard of living has
risen, the rise has been on a scale disproportionately small. The
rich have developed a freedom and luxury unknown in the world
hitherto, and there has been an increase in the proportion of rich
people and stagnantly prosperous and unproductive people in the
community; but that also fails to account for the full benefit.
There has been much sheer waste. Vast accumulations of mate-
rial and energy have gone into warlike preparations and warfare.
Much has been devoted to the futile efforts of unsuccessful
business competition. Huge possibilities have remained unde-
veloped because of the opposition of owners, forestallers, and
speculators to their economical exploitation. The good things
that science and organization have been bringing within the reach
of mankind have not been taken methodically and used to their
utmost, but they have been scrambled for, snatched at, seized upon
by gambling adventurers and employed upon selfish and vain ends.
The eighteenth century in Europe, and more particularly in
Great Britain and Poland, was the age of private ownership.
"Private enterprise," which meant in practice that everyone was
entitled to get everything he could out of the business of the com-
munity, reigned supreme. No sense of obligation to the state in
business matters is to be found in the ordinary novels, plays, and
such like representative literature of the time. Everyone is out
"to make his fortune," there is no recognition that it is wrong to
be an unproductive parasite on the community, and still less that
a financier or merchant or manufacturer can ever be overpaid for
his services to mankind. This was the moral atmosphere of the
time, and those lords and gentlemen who grabbed the people's
commons, assumed possession of the mines under their lands,
PRINCES, PARLIAMENTS, AND POWERS 275
and crushed down the yeoman farmers and peasants to the status
of pauper labourers, had no idea that they were living anything
but highly meritorious lives.
Concurrently with this change in Great Britain from traditional
patch agriculture and common pasture to large and more scientific
agriculture, very great changes were going on in the manufacture
of commodities. In these changes Great Britain was, in the
eighteenth century, leading the world. Hitherto, throughout the
whole course of history from the beginnings of civilization, manu-
factures, building, and industries generally had been in the hands
of craftsmen and small masters who worked in their own houses.
They had been organized in guilds, and were mostly their own
employers. They formed an essential and permanent middle
class. There were capitalists among them, who let out looms and
the like, supplied material, and took the finished product, but they
were not big capitalists. There had been no rich manufacturers.
The rich men of the world before this time had been great land-
owners or money-lenders and money manipulators or merchants.
But in the eighteenth century, workers in certain industries began
to be collected together into factories in order to produce things in
larger quantities through a systematic division of labour, and the
employer, as distinguished from the master worker, began to be a
person of importance. Moreover, mechanical invention was pro-
ducing machines that simplified the manual work of production,
and were capable of being driven by water power and presently
by steam. In 1765 Watt's steam engine was constructed, a very
important date in the history of industrialism.
The cotton industry was one of the first to pass into factory
production (originally with water-driven machinery) . The woollen
industry followed. At the same time iron smelting, which had
been restrained hitherto to small methods by the use of charcoal,
resorted to coke made from coal, and the coal and iron industries
also began to expand. The iron industry shifted from the wooded
country of Sussex and Surrey to the coal districts. By 1800 this
change-over of industry from a small scale business with small
employers to a large scale production under big employers was well
in progress. Everywhere there sprang up factories using first
water then steam power. It was a change of fundamental im-
276 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
portance in human economy. From the dawn of history the manu-
facturer and craftsman had been, as we have said, a sort of middle-
class townsman. The machine and the employer now superseded
his skill, and he either became an employer of his fellows, and grew
towards wealth and equality with the other rich classes, or he re-
mained a worker and sank very rapidly to the level of a mere
labourer. This great change in human affairs is known as the
Industrial Revolution. Beginning in Great Britain, it spread dur-
ing the nineteenth century throughout the world.
As the Industrial Revolution went on, a great gulf opened
between employer and employed. In the past every manufactur-
ing worker had the hope of becoming an independent master.
Even the slave craftsmen of Babylon and Rome were protected by
laws that enabled them to save and buy their freedom and to set
up for themselves. But now a factory and its engines and machines
became a vast and costly thing, measured by the scale of the work-
er's pocket. Wealthy men had to come together to create an
enterprise; credit and plant, that is to say, "Capital," were re-
quired. "Setting up for oneself" ceased to be a normal hope for
an artisan. The Vorker was henceforth a worker from the cradle
to the grave. Besides the landlords and merchants and the money-
dealers who financed trading companies and lent their money to
the merchants and the state, there arose now this new wealth of
industrial capital — a new sort of power in the state.
Of the working out of these beginnings we shall tell later. The
immediate effect of the industrial revolution upon the countries
to which it came was to cause a vast, distressful shifting and stir-
ring of the mute, uneducated, leaderless, and now more and more
propertyless common population. The small cultivators and
peasants, ruined and dislodged by the Enclosure Acts, drifted
towards the new manufacturing regions, and there they joined the
families of the impoverished and degraded craftsmen in the fac-
tories. Great towns of squalid houses came into existence. No-
body seems to have noted clearly what was going on at the time.
It is the keynote of "private enterprise" to mind one's own busi-
ness, secure the utmost profit, and disregard any other conse-
quences. Ugly great factories grew up, built as cheaply as pos-
sible, to hold as many machines and workers as possible. Around
PRINCES, PARLIAMENTS, AND POWERS 277
them gathered the streets of workers' homes, built at the cheapest
rate, without space, without privacy, barely decent, and let at the
utmost rent that could be exacted. These new industrial centres
were at first without schools, without churches. . . . The English
gentleman of the closing decades of the eighteenth century read
Gibbon's third volume and congratulated himself that there was
henceforth no serious fear of the Barbarians, with this new bar-
barism growing up, with this metamorphosis of his countrymen
into something dark and desperate, in full progress, within an easy
walk perhaps of his door.
XXXVII
THE NEW DEMOCRATIC REPUBLICS OF AMERICA
AND FRANCE
1. Inconveniences of the Great Power System. § 2. The Thirteen
Colonies before Their Revolt. § 3. Civil War is Forced upon the
Colonies. § 4. The War of Independence. § 5. The Constitu-
tion of the United States. § 6. Primitive Features of the United
States Constitution. § 7. Revolutionary Ideas in France. § 8.
The Revolution of the Year 1789. § 9. The French "Crowned
Republic" of '89-91. § 10. The Revolutions of the Jacobins.
§ 11. The Jacobin Republic, 1792-94. § 12. The Directory.
§ 13. The Pause in Reconstruction and the Dawn of Modern
Socialism.
X Tl THEN Gibbon, nearly a century and a half ago, was con-
V V gratulating the world of refined and educated people
that the age of great political and social catastrophes was past,
he was neglecting many signs which we — in the wisdom of ac-
complished facts — could have told him portended far heavier
jolts and dislocations than any he foresaw. We have told how the
struggle of the sixteenth and seventeenth-century princes for
ascendancies and advantages developed into a more cunning and
complicated struggle of foreign offices, masquerading as idealized
" Great Powers, " as the eighteenth century wore on. The intricate
and pretentious art of diplomacy developed. The " Prince"
ceased to be a single and secretive Machiavellian schemer, and
became merely the crowned symbol of a Machiavellian scheme.
Prussia, Russia, and Austria fell upon and divided Poland. France
1 Charming' s excellent new History of the United States to vol. iv. has been our
handbook here.
278
REPUBLICS OF AMERICA AND FRANCE 279
was baffled in profound schemes against Spain. Britain circum-
vented the ''designs of France" in America and acquired Canada,
and got the better of France in India. And then a remarkable
thing occurred, a thing very shocking to European diplomacy.
The British colonies in America flatly refused to have further part
or lot in this game of " Great Powers." They objected that they
had no voice and no great interest in these European schemes
and conflicts, and they refused to bear any portion of the burthen
of taxation these foreign policies entailed.
Of course this decision did not flash out complete and finished
from the American mind at the beginning of these troubles. In
America in the eighteenth century, just as in England in the
seventeenth, there was an entire willingness, indeed a desire on the
part of ordinary men, to leave foreign affairs in the hands of the
king and his ministers. But there was an equally strong desire on
the part of ordinary men to be neither taxed nor interfered with in
their ordinary pursuits. These are incompatible wishes. Com-
mon men cannot shirk world politics and at the same time enjoy
private freedom ; but it has taken them countless generations to
learn this. The first impulse in the American revolt against the
government in Great Britain was therefore simply a resentment
against the taxation and interference that followed necessarily
from "foreign policy" without any clear recognition of what was
involved in that objection. It was only when the revolt was con-
summated that the people of the American colonies recognized
at all clearly that they had repudiated the Great Power view of
life. The sentence in which that repudiation was expressed was
Washington's injunction to " avoid entangling alliances." From
his time until the year 1917 the united colonies of Great Britain
in North America, liberated and independent as the United States
of America, stood apart altogether from the blood-stained intrigues
and conflicts of the European foreign offices. Soon after (1810-
1823) they were able to extend their principle of detachment
to the rest of the continent, and to make all the New World
" out of bounds " for the scheming expansionists of the old. When
at length, in 1917, they were obliged to re-enter the arena of world
politics, it was to bring the new spirit and new aims their aloofness
had enabled them to develop into the tangle of international re-
280 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
lationships. They were not, however, the first to stand aloof.
Since the treaty of Westphalia (1648), the confederated states of
Switzerland, in their mountain fastnesses, had sustained their right-
to exclusion from the schemes of kings and empires.
But since the North American peoples are now to play an in-
creasingly important part in our history, it will be well to devote
a little more attention than we have hitherto given to their de-
velopment. We have already glanced at this story in § 8 of the
preceding chapter. We will now tell a little more fully — though
still in the barest outline — what these colonies were, whose re-
calcitrance was so disconcerting to the king and ministers of Great
Britain in their diplomatic game against the rest of mankind.1
§2
The extent of the British colonies in America in the early half
of the eighteenth century is shown in the accompanying map.2
The darker shading represents the districts settled in 1700, the
lighter the growth of the settlements up to 1760. It will be seen
that the colonies were a mere fringe of population along the coast,
spreading gradually inland and finding in the Alleghany and Blue
Mountains a very serious barrier. Among the oldest of these
settlements was the colony of Virginia, the name of which commem-
orates Queen Elizabeth, the Virgin Queen of England. The first
expedition to found a colony in Virginia was made by Sir Walter
Raleigh in 1584, but there was no permanent settlement at that
time ; and the real beginnings of Virginia date from the foundation
of the Virginia Company in 1606 in the reign of James I (1603-25).
The story of John Smith and the early founders of Virginia, and
of how the Indian "princess" Pocahontas married one of his gentle-
1 You are, I think, unjust to Great Britain and her "great power game." She
was not playing that game — or, so far as she was, she was acting against "France "
to liberate the colonies from the French menace in the hinterland which alarmed
them. Once liberated, they broke loose, 'somewhat selfishly, refusing to pay the
piper, though they had enjoyed, and done much to call, the tune. Great Britain
was indeed to blame, not on the "great power" ground, but on the "sovereignty"
ground, which made her stickle for the "sovereignty" of the British parliament
over colonial legislature. It wasn't diplomatists, it was lawyers in both countries,
who precipitated the struggle of 1776. — E. B.
But see §§ 2 and 3. — H. G. W.
2 See Channing's History of the United States, vol. ii.
REPUBLICS OF AMERICA AND FRANCE 281
men, is an English classic.1 In growing tobacco the Virginians
found the beginning of prosperity. At the •' same time that the
Virginian Company was founded, the PlymouiJh Company obtained
a charter for the settlement of the country to the north of Long
Island Sound, to which the English laid claim. But it was only
in 1620 that the northern region began to be settled, and that under
fresh charters. The settlers of the northern region (New England),
which became Connecticut, New Hampshire, Rhode Island, and
Massachusetts, were men of a different stamp to the Virginia
people. They were Protestants discontented with the Anglican
Church compromise, and republican-spirited men hopeless of
resistance to the Grand Monarchy of James I and Charles I.
Their pioneer ship was the Mayflower, which founded New Plym-
outh in 1620. The dominant northern colony was Massachu-
setts. Differences in religious method and in ideas of toleration
led to the separation of the three other Puritan colonies from Massa-
chusetts. It illustrates the scale upon which things were done in
those days that the whole state of New Hampshire was claimed as
belonging to a certain Captain John Mason, and that he offered
to sell it to the king (King Charles II in 1671) in exchange for the
right to import 300 tons of French wine free of duty — an offer
which was refused. The present state of Maine was bought by
Massachusetts from its alleged owner for twelve hundred and
fifty pounds.
In the Civil War that ended with the decapitation of Charles I
the sympathies of New England were for the Parliament, and
Virginia was Cavalier ; but two hundred and fifty miles separated
these settlements, and there were no serious hostilities. With
the return of the monarchy in 1660, there was a vigorous develop-
ment of British colonization in America. Charles II and his asso-
ciates were greedy for gain, and the British crown had no wish to
make any further experiments in illegal taxation at home. But
the undefined relations of the colonies to the crown and the British
government seemed to afford promise of financial adventure across
the Atlantic. There was a rapid development of plantations and
proprietary colonies. Lord Baltimore had already in 1632 set up a
colony that was to be a home of religious freedom for Catholics
1 John Smith's Travels.
282 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
under the attractive name of Maryland, to the north and east of
Virginia ; and now the Quaker Penn (who was nevertheless a very
good friend of Charles II) established himself to the north at Phila-
delphia and founded the colony of Pennsylvania. Its main bound-
ary with Maryland and Virginia was delimited by two men, Mason
and Dixon, whose " Mason and Dixon line" was destined to become
a very important line indeed in the later affairs of the United States.
Carolina, which was originally an unsuccessful French Protestant
establishment, and which owed its name not to Charles (Carolus) II
of England, but to Charles IX of France, had fallen into English
hands and was settled at several points.1 Between Maryland
and New England stretched a number of small Dutch and Swedish
settlements, of which the chief town was New Amsterdam. These
settlements were captured from the Dutch by the British in 1664,
lost again in 1673, and restored by treaty when Holland and Eng-
land made peace in 1674. Thereby the whole coast from Maine
to Carolina became in some form or other a British possession.
To the south the Spanish were established; their headquarters
were at Fort St. Augustine in Florida, and in 1732 the town of
Savannah 2 was settled by a philanthropist Oglethorpe from Eng-
land, who had taken pity on the miserable people imprisoned for
debt in England, and rescued a number of them from prison to
become the founders of a new colony, Georgia, which was to be a
bulwark against the Spanish. So by the middle of the eighteenth
century we have these settlements along the American coastline :
the New England group of Puritans and free Protestants, Maine
(belonging to Massachusetts), New Hampshire, Connecticut,
Rhode Island, and Massachusetts; the captured Dutch group,
1 There is some doubt about the name of Carolina. Channing, in his short history,
says it was named in honour of Charles II. Bassett says it was named originally
Carolana, in honour of Charles I, in 1629, and kept the name, under the new form
of Carolina in honour of Charles II. Fiske, Old Virginia and Her Neighbors, vol. i.
p. 265, speaks of Carolina, in 1629, as named "either in honour of Charles I or
because the name had been given by Huguenots in 1562 in honour of Charles IX
of France." Another authority speaks of the name as used before, and now no
doubt retained in honour of the English king ; but, according to him, the name had
not been used for the country (called, by the French, Florida), but for a fort in it,
the arx Carolana. He adds that in 1629 the name Carolana is used, but Carolina
appears afterwards, and becomes normal after 1662. — E. B.
2 From the Spanish word Sabana = "meadow." — H. H. J.
REPUBLICS OF AMERICA AND FRANCE
283
which was now divided up into New York (New Amsterdam re-
christened), New Jersey, and Delaware (Swedish before it was
Dutch, and in its earliest British phase attached to Pennsylvania) ;
British. setfLz-
mmts to l/OO
dfao to 176O
• French settkmenb
» forts
XHfNEwHAMPSHIRE
MASSACHUSETTS
C. = CONNECTICUT
R.I.= RHODE Is.
Txfew JERSEY
MARYLAND
D. * DELAWARE
then came catholic Maryland ; Cavalier Virginia ; Carolina (which
was presently divided into North and South), and Oglethorpe's
Georgia. Later on a number of Tyrolese Protestants took refuge
in Georgia, and there was a considerable immigration of a good
class of German cultivators into Pennsylvania.
284 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
Such were the miscellaneous origins of the citizens of the Thirteen
Colonies.1 The possibility of their ever becoming closely united
would have struck an impartial observer in 1760 as being very
slight. Superadded to the initial differences of origin, fresh dif-
ferences were created by climate. North of the Mason and Dixon
line farming was practised mainly upon British or Central Euro-
pean lines by free white cultivators. The settled country of New
England took on a likeness to the English countryside; con-
siderable areas of Pennsylvania developed fields and farmhouses
like those of South Germany. The distinctive conditions in the
north had, socially, important effects. Masters and men had to
labour together as backwoodsmen, and were equalized in the pro-
cess. They did not start equally ; many " servants " are mentioned
in the roster of the Mayflower. But they rapidly became equal
under colonial conditions ; there was, for instance, a vast tract of
land to be had for the taking, and the "servant" went off and took
land like his master. The English class system disappeared. Un-
der colonial conditions. there arose equality "in the faculties both
of body and mind," and an individual independence of judgment
impatient of interference from England. But south of the Mason
and Dixon line tobacco growing began, and the warmer climate
encouraged the establishment of plantations with gang labour.
Red Indian captives were employed ; Cromwell sent Irish prisoners
of war to Virginia, which did much to reconcile the Royalist planters
to republicanism; convicts were sent out, and there was a con-
siderable trade in kidnapped children, who were "spirited away"
to America to become apprentices or bond slaves. But the most
convenient form of gang labour proved to be that of negro slaves.
The first negro slaves were brought to Jamestown in Virginia by a
Dutch ship as early as 1620. By 1700 negro slaves were scattered
all over the states, but Virginia, Maryland, and the Carolinas were
their chief regions of employment, and while the communities to
the north were communities of not very rich and not very poor
farming men, the south developed a type of large proprietor and
a white community of overseers and professional men subsisting
1 See for the fundamental differences of north and south, W. Wilson, The State,
the historical sections at the beginning of the chapter on the United States Govern-
ment. — E. B.
REPUBLICS OF AMERICA AND FRANCE 285
on slave labour. Slave labour was a necessity to the social and
economic system that had grown up in the south ; in the north the
presence of slaves was unnecessary and in some respects incon-
venient. Conscientious scruples about slavery were more free,
therefore, to develop and flourish in the northern atmosphere.
To this question of the revival of slavery in the world we must
return when we come to consider the perplexities of American
Democracy. Here we note it simply as an added factor in the
heterogeneous mixture of the British Colonies.1
But if the inhabitants of the Thirteen Colonies were miscella-
neous in their origins and various in their habits and sympathies,
they had three very strong antagonisms in common. They had a
common interest against the Red Indians. For a time they
shared a common dread of French conquest and dominion. And
thirdly, they were all in conflict with the claims of the British
crown and the commercial selfishness of the narrow oligarchy who
dominated the British Parliament and British affairs.
So far as the first danger went, the Indians were a constant evil,
but never more than a threat of disaster. They remained divided
against themselves. Yet they had shown possibilities of combina-
tion upon a larger scale. The Five Nations of the Iroquois
(see map, p. 283) was a very important league of tribes. But it
never succeeded in playing off the French against the English to
secure itself, and no Red Indian Jengis Khan ever arose among
these nomads of the new world. The French aggression was a more
serious threat. The French never made settlements in America
on a scale to compete with the English, but their government set
about the encirclement of the colonies and their subjugation in a
terrifyingly systematic manner. The English in America were
colonists ; the French were explorers, adventurers, agents, mission-
aries, merchants, and soldiers. Only in Canada did they strike
root. French statesmen sat over maps and dreamt dreams, and
their dreams are to be seen in our map in the chain of forts creeping
southward from the Great Lakes and northward up the Mississippi
and Ohio rivers. The struggle of France and Britain was a world-
wide struggle. It was decided in India, in Germany, and on the
1 An admirable account of negro slavery is to be found in Sir H. H. Johnston's
The Negro in the New World.
286 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
high seas. In the Peace of Paris (1763) the French gave England
Canada, and relinquished Louisiana to the inert hands of declining
Spain. It was the complete abandonment of America by France.
The lifting of the French danger left the colonists unencumbered
to face their third common antagonist — the crown and govern-
ment of their mother land.
§3
We have noted in the previous chapter how the governing class
of Great Britain steadily acquired the land and destroyed the lib-
erty of the common people throughout the eighteenth century,
and how greedily and blindly the new industrial revolution was
brought about. We have noted also how the British Parliament,
through the decay of the representative methods of the House of
Commons, had become both in its upper and lower houses merely
the instrument of government through the big landowners. Both
these big property-holders and the crown were deeply interested
in America ; the former as private adventurers, the latter partly
as representing the speculative exploitations of the Stuart kings, and
partly as representing the state in search of funds for the expenses
of foreign policy, and neither lords nor crown were disposed to
regard the traders, planters, and common people of the colonies
with any more consideration than they did the yeomen and small
cultivators at home. At bottom the interests of the common man
in Great Britain, Ireland, and America were the same. Each was
being squeezed by the same system. But while in Britain op-
pressor and oppressed were closely tangled up in one intimate social
system, in America the crown and the exploiter were far away,
and men could get together and develop a sense of community
against their common enemy.
Moreover, the American colonist had the important advantage
of possessing a separate and legal organ of resistance to the British
government in the assembly or legislature of his colony that was
necessary for the management of local affairs. The common man
in Britain, cheated out of his proper representation in the Com-
mons, had no organ, no centre of expression and action for his dis-
contents.
It will be evident to the reader, bearing in mind the variety of
REPUBLICS OF AMERICA AND FRANCE 287
the colonies, that here was the possibility of an endless series of
disputes, aggressions, and counter-aggressions. The story of the
development of irritations between the colonies and Britain is a
story far too intricate, subtle, and lengthy for the scheme of this
Outline. Suffice it that the grievances fell under three main heads :
attempts to secure for British adventurers or the British govern-
ment the profits of the exploitation of new lands; systematic
restrictions upon trade designed to keep the foreign trade of the
colonies entirely in British hands, so that the colonial exports all
went through Britain and only British-made goods were used in
America ; 1 and finally attempts at taxation through the British
Parliament as the supreme taxing authority of the empire. Under
the pressure of this triple system of annoyances, the American
colonists were forced to do a very considerable amount of hard
political thinking. Such men as Patrick Henry and James Otis
began to discuss the fundamental ideas of government and political
association very much as they had been discussed in England in the
great days of Cromwell's Commonweal. They began to deny both
the divine origin of kingship and the supremacy of the British
Parliament, and (James Otis, 1762 2) to say such things as : -
" God made all men naturally equal.
" Ideas of earthly superiority are educational, not innate.
" Kings were made for the good of the people, and not the people
for them.
"No government has a right to make slaves of its subjects.
"Though most governments are de facto arbitrary, and conse-
1 1 disbelieve in this "commercial selfishness" emphasized in the text. Modern
American historians, such as Beer, themselves rebut the charge. On the whole,
English commercial policy was fair. (1) If the colonists could only export certain
"enumerated" commodities to England, the English market was the best, and they
were given privileges there ; while non-enumerated commodities could be exported
anywhere, and even "enumerated" articles were in practice smuggled everywhere.
(2) If the colonists had to import from England, it was their best market, and they
got "drawbacks" on dutiable goods imported into England from the Continent
when they took them out of England ; while again in practice they freely smuggled
goods from any country to America. (3) The English navigation laws, in the long
run, encouraged American shipbuilding ; and if some colonial manufactures were
stopped in order that they might not compete with English manufactures, the
amount of such restriction was slight. On all this, see Sir William Ashley, Surveys
Historic and Economic, pp. 300 seqq. — E. B.
2 See Tudor's Life of James Otis.
288 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
quently the curse and scandal of human nature, yet none are de
jure arbitrary."
Some of which propositions reach far.
This ferment in the political ideas of the Americans was started
by English leaven. One very influential English writer was John
Locke (1632-1704), whose Two Treatises on Civil Government may
be taken, as much as any one single book can be taken in such cases,
as the point of departure for modern democratic ideas. He was
the son of a Cromwellian soldier, he was educated at Christ Church,
Oxford, during the republican ascendancy, he spent some years in
Holland in exile, and his writings form a bridge between the bold
political thinking of those earlier republican days and the revolu-
tionary movement both in America and France.
But men do not begin to act upon theories. It is always some
real danger, some practical necessity, that produces action; and
it is only after action has destroyed old relationships and produced
a new and perplexing state of affairs that theory comes to its own.
Then it is that theory is put to the test. The discord in interests
and ideas between the colonists was brought to a fighting issue by
• the obstinate resolve of the British Parliament after the peace of
1763 to impose taxation upon the American colonies. Britain
was at peace and flushed with successes ; it seemed an admirable
opportunity for settling accounts with these recalcitrant settlers.
But the great British property-owners found a power beside their
own, of much the same mind with them, but a little divergent in
its ends — the reviving crown. King George III, who had
begun his reign in 1760, was resolved to be much more of a king
than his two German predecessors. He could speak English;
he claimed to "glory in the name of Briton" — and indeed it is
not a bad name for a man without a perceptible drop of English,
Welsh, or Scotch blood in his veins. In the American colonies
and the overseas possessions generally, with their indefinite
charters or no charters at all, it seemed to him that the crown might
claim authority and obtain resources and powers absolutely
denied to it by the strong and jealous aristocracy in Britain. This
inclined many of the Whig noblemen to a sympathy with the colo-
nists that they might not otherwise have shown. They had no
objection to the exploitation of the colonies in the interests of
REPUBLICS OF AMERICA AND FRANCE 289
British " private enterprise," but they had very strong objections
to the strengthening of the crown by that exploitation so as to
make it presently independent of themselves.1
The war that broke out was therefore in reality not a war be-
tween Britain and the colonists, it was a war between the British
government and the colonists, with a body of Whig noblemen and
a considerable amount of public feeling in England on the side of
the latter. An early move after 1763 was an attempt to raise
revenue for Britain in the colonies by requiring that newspapers
and documents of various sorts should be stamped. This was
stiffly resisted, the British crown was intimidated, and the Stamp
Acts were repealed (1766). Their repeal was greeted by riotous
rejoicings in London, more hearty even than those in the colonies.
But the Stamp Act affair was only one eddy in a turbulent
stream flowing towards civil war. Upon a score of pretexts, and
up and down the coast, the representatives of the British govern-
ment were busy asserting their authority and making British
government intolerable. The quartering of soldiers upon the
colonists was a great nuisance. Rhode Island was particularly
active in defying the trade restrictions ; the Rhode Islanders were
"free traders," - that is to say, smugglers; a government
schooner, the Gaspee, ran aground off Providence; she was sur-
prised, boarded, and captured by armed men in boats, and burnt.
In 1773, with a total disregard of the existing colonial tea trade,
special advantages for the importation of tea into America 2 were
given by the British Parliament to the East India Company.
It was resolved by the colonists to refuse and boycott this tea.
When the tea importers at Boston showed themselves resolute to
land their cargoes, a band of men disguised as Indians, in the
presence of a great crowd of people, boarded the three tea ships
and threw the tea overboard (December 16th, 1773).
1 1 disagree entirely with this. George, with the bulk of Parliament behind
him, was out to insist on the sovereignty of the British Parliament (not of himself)
over the colonists. Nor was it the Whig noblemen who opposed him, but Burke
(conservatively inclined, and therefore up in arms for the traditional rights of the
colonial legislatures) and Chatham (liberally inclined, and therefore up in arms
for the principle of "no representation, no taxation"). — E. B.
2 This again in my view is wrong. The system proposed, I read in an American
writer, meant cheaper tea in the colonies. The objection taken by the colonists
was legal. — E. B.
u
290 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
All 1774 was occupied in the gathering up of resources on either
side for the coming conflict. It was decided by the British Parlia-
ment in the spring of 1774 to punish Boston by closing her port.
Her trade was to be destroyed unless she accepted that tea. It
was a quite typical instance of that silly " firmness'7 which shatters
empires. In order to enforce this measure, British troops were
concentrated at Boston under General Gage. The colonists took
counter-measures. The first colonial Congress met at Philadel-
phia in September, at which twelve colonies were represented:
Massachusetts, Connecticut, New Hampshire, Rhode Island, New
York, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Maryland, Delaware, Virginia,
and North and South Carolina. Georgia was not present. True
to the best English traditions, the Congress documented its atti-
tude by a "Declaration of Rights." Practically this Congress
was an insurrectionary government, but no blow was struck until
the spring of 1775. Then came the first shedding of blood.
Two of the American leaders, Hancock and Samuel Adams, had
been marked down by the British Government for arrest and
trial for treason; they were known to be at Lexington, about
eleven miles from Boston; and in the night of April 18th, 1775,
Gage set his forces in motion for their arrest.
That night was a momentous one in history. The movement
of Gage's troops had been observed, signal lanterns were shown
from a church tower in Boston, and two men, Dawes and Paul
Revere, stole away in boats across the Back Bay to take horse and
warn the countryside. The British were also ferried over the
water, and as they marched through the night towards Lexington,
the firing of signal cannon and the ringing of church bells went
before them. As they entered Lexington at dawn, they saw a little
company of men drawn up in military fashion. It seems that the
British fired first. There was a single shot and then a volley, and
the little handful decamped, apparently without any answering
shots, leaving eight dead and nine wounded upon the village green.
The British then marched on to Concord, ten miles further,
occupied the village, and stationed a party on the bridge at that
place. The expedition had failed in its purpose of arresting Han-
cock and Adams, and the British commander seems to have been
at a loss what to do next. Meanwhile the colonial levies were
REPUBLICS OF AMERICA AND FRANCE 291
coming up from all directions, and presently the picket upon the
bridge found itself subjected to an increasing fire from a gathering
number of assailants firing from behind trees and fences. A re-
treat to Boston was decided upon. It was a disastrous retreat.
The country had risen behind the British; all the morning the
colonials had been gathering. Both sides of the road were now
swarming with sharpshooters firing from behind rock and fence
and building ; the soldiers were in conspicuous scarlet uniforms,
with yellow facings and white gaiters and cravats; this must
have stood out very vividly against the cold sharp colours of the
late New England spring; the day was bright, hot, and dusty,
and they were already exhausted by a night march. Every few
yards a man fell, wounded or killed. The rest tramped on, or
halted to fire an ineffectual volley. No counter-attack was possi-
ble. Their assailants lurked everywhere. At Lexington there
were British reinforcements and two guns, and after a brief rest
the retreat was resumed in better order. But the sharpshooting
and pursuit was pressed to the river, and after the British had
crossed back into Boston, the colonial levies took up their quarters
in Cambridge and prepared to blockade the city.
§4
So the war began. It was not a war that promised a conclu-
sive end. The colonists had no one vulnerable capital ; they were
dispersed over a great country, with a limitless wilderness behind
it, and so they had great powers of resistance. They had learnt
their tactics largely from the Indians; they could fight well in
open order, and harry and destroy troops in movement. But
they had no disciplined army that could meet the British in a
pitched battle, and little military equipment; and their levies
grew impatient at a long compaign, and tended to go home to their
farms. The British, on the other hand, had a well-drilled army,
and their command of the sea gave them the power of shifting
their attack up and down the long Atlantic seaboard. They were
at peace with all the world. But the king was stupid and greedy
to interfere in the conduct of affairs; the generals he favoured
were stupid "strong men" or flighty men of birth and fashion;
and the heart of England was not in the business. He trusted
292 . THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
rather to being able to blockade, raid, and annoy the colonists
into submission than to a conclusive conquest and occupation of
the land. But the methods employed, and particularly the use
of hired German troops, who still retained the cruel traditions of
the Thirty Years' War, and of Indian auxiliaries, who raped and
scalped the outlying settlers, did not so much weary the Americans
of the war as of the British. The Congress, meeting for the second
time in 1775, endorsed the actions of the New England colonists,
and appointed George Washington the American commander-in-
chief. In 1777, General Burgoyne, in an attempt to get down to
New York from Canada, was defeated at Freeman's Farm on the
Sketch, map-to shear
'BOSTON, &
Upper Hudson, and surrounded and obliged to capitulate at Sara-
toga with his whole army. This disaster encouraged the French
and Spanish to come into the struggle on the side of the colonists.
The French sent an army to the States under General Lafayette,
and their fleet did much to minimize the advantage of the British
at sea. General Cornwallis was caught in the Yorktown penin-
sula in Virginia in 1781, and capitulated with his army. The
British Government, now heavily engaged with France and Spain
in Europe, was at the end of its resources.
At the outset of the war the colonists in general seem to have
been as little disposed to repudiate monarchy and claim complete
independence as were the Hollanders in the opening phase of
Philip II 's persecutions and follies. The separatists were called
REPUBLICS OF AMERICA AND FRANCE 293
radicals; they were mostly extremely democratic, as we should
say in England to-day, and their advanced views frightened many
of the steadier and wealthier colonists, for whom class privileges
and distinctions had considerable charm. But early in 1776 an
able and persuasive Englishman, Tom Paine, published a pam-
phlet at Philadelphia with the title of Common Sense, which had an
enormous effect on public opinion. Its style was rhetorical by
modern standards. "The blood of the slain, the weeping voice of
Nature cries, "Tis time to part/" and so forth. But its effects
were very great. It converted thousands to the necessity of
separation. The turn-over of opinion, once it had begun, was
rapid.
Only in the summer of 1776 did Congress take the irrevocable
step of declaring for separation. "The Declaration of Indepen-
dence," another of those exemplary documents which it has been
the peculiar service of the English to produce for mankind, was
drawn up by Thomas Jefferson; and after various amendments
and modifications it was made the fundamental document of the
United States of America. There were two noteworthy amend-
ments to Jefferson's draft. He had denounced the slave trade
fiercely, and blamed the home government for interfering with
colonial attempts to end it. This was thrown out, and so too was
a sentence about the British : "we must endeavour to forget our
former love for them ... we might have been a free and a great
people together."
(But for the British crown and great proprietors and the mutual
ignorance of the common men in the two countries.) l
Towards the end of 1782, the preliminary articles of the treaty
in which Britain recognized the complete independence of the
1 1 think this gives an erroneous impression that there was no real chance of
reconciliation in 1776. There was. And indeed the whole separation was far
from inevitable. If the British had (1) recognized the autonomy in each colony
of its legislature, and (2) granted to the colonies cabinet government in place of
government by governors sent from England, there would have been no schism.
By 1839, the time of Lord Durham's report, the British had learned to make the
recognition and the grant ; and with greater wisdom they could have made both in
1776. A great statesman in 1776 could have stopped the separation, and made
history different. I am inclined to say that nothing is inevitable in history —
except that when you don't have good men, you don't get good results. And that
was the position under George III and Lord North. — E. B.
294 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
United States were signed at Paris. The end of the war was pro-
claimed on April 19th, 1783, exactly eight years after Paul Revere's
ride, and the retreat of Gage's men from Concord to Boston. The
Treaty of Peace was finally signed at Paris in September.
§5
From the point of view of human history, the way in which the
Thirteen States became independent is of far less importance than
the fact that they did become independent. And with the estab-
lishment of their independence came a new sort of community
into the world. It was like something coming out of an egg. It
was a western European civilization that had broken free from the
last traces of Empire and Christendom; it had not a vestige of
monarchy left and no state religion. It had no dukes, princes,
counts, nor any sort of title-bearers claiming to ascendancy or re-
spect as a right. Even its unity was as yet a mere unity for de-
fence and freedom. It was in these respects such a clean start in
political organization as the world had not seen before. The
absence of any binding religious tie is especially noteworthy. It
had a number of forms of Christianity, its spirit was indubitably
Christian; but as a state document of 1796 explicitly declared,
"The government of the United States is not in any sense founded
on the Christian religion." 1 The new community had in fact
gone right down to the bare and stripped fundamentals of human
association, and it was building up a new sort of society and a new
sort of state upon those foundations.
Here were about four million people scattered over vast areas
with very slow and difficult means of inter-communication, poor
as yet, but with the potentiality of limitless wealth, setting out
to do in reality on a huge scale such a feat of construction as the
Athenian philosophers twenty-two centuries before had done in
imagination and theory.
This situation marks a definite stage in the release of man from
precedent and usage, and a definite step forward towards the
conscious and deliberate reconstruction of his circumstances to
suit his needs and aims. It was a new method becoming practical
in human affairs. The modern states of Europe have been evolved
1 The Tripoli Treaty, see Channing, vol. iii. chap, xviii.
REPUBLICS OF AMERICA AND FRANCE
295
institution by institution slowly and planlessly out of preceding
things. The United States were planned and made.
In one respect, however, the creative freedom of the new nation
The UNITED 5TATE5, showing extent cfsettU-
ienk in, 1790 .\
N.H.-NKWHAMPSHIR
C.-CCNNECTICUT
*!RHCDE ISLAND
"N.t NEVVjERSEY
MARYLAND
P. DELAWARE
was very seriously restricted. This new sort of community and
state was not built upon a cleared site. It was not even so frankly
an artificiality as some of the later Athenian colonies, which went
out from the mother city to plan and build brand new city states
with brand new constitutions. The thirteen colonies by the end
296 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
of the war had all of them constitutions either like that of Con-
necticut and Rhode Island dating from their original charters
(1662) or, as in the case of the rest of the states, where a British
governor had played a large part in the administration, re-made
during the conflict. But we may well consider these reconstruc-
tions as contributory essays and experiments in the general con-
structive effort.
Upon the effort certain ideas stood out very prominently. One
is the idea of political and social equality. This idea, which we
saw coming into the world as an extreme and almost incredible
idea in the age between Buddha and Jesus of Nazareth, is now
asserted in the later eighteenth century as a practical standard of
human relationship. Says the fundamental statement of Vir-
ginia: "All men are by nature equally free and independent,"
and it proceeds to rehearse their "rights," and to assert that all
magistrates and governors are but "trustees and servants"; of
the commonweal. All men are equally entitled to the free exer-
cise of religion. The king by right, the aristocrat, the "natural
slave," the god king, and the god have all vanished from this
political scheme — so far as these declarations go. Most of the
states produced similar preludes to government. The Declara-
tion of Independence said that "all men are born equal." It is
everywhere asserted in eighteenth-century terms that the new
community is to be — to use the phraseology we have introduced
in an earlier chapter — a community of will and not a community
of obedience. But the thinkers of that time had a rather clumsier
way of putting the thing, they imagined a sort of individual
choice of and assent to citizenship that never in fact occurred -
the so-called Social Contract. The Massachusetts preamble, for
instance, asserts that the state is a voluntary association, "by
which the whole people covenants with each citizen and each
citizen with the whole people that all shall be governed by certain
laws for the common good."
Now it will be evident that most of these fundamental state-
ments are very questionable statements. Men are not born
equal, they are not born free ; they are born a most various mul-
titude enmeshed in an ancient and complex social net. Nor is
any man invited to sign the social contract or, failing that, to
REPUBLICS OF AMERICA AND FRANCE 297
depart into solitude. These statements, literally interpreted,
are so manifestly false that it is impossible to believe that the men
who made them intended them to be literally interpreted. They
made them in order to express certain elusive but profoundly im-
portant ideas — ideas that after another century and a half of
thinking the world is in a better position to express. Civilization,
as this outline has shown, arose as a community of obedience, and
was essentially a community of obedience. But generation after
generation the spirit was abused by priests and rulers. There was
a continual influx of masterful will from the forests, parklands, and
steppes. The human spirit had at last rebelled altogether against
the blind obediences of the common life ; it was seeking — and at
first it was seeking very clumsily — to achieve a new and better
sort of civilization that should also be a community of will. To
that end it was necessary that every man should be treated as the
sovereign of himself ; his standing was to be one of fellowship and
not of servility. His real use, his real importance depended upon
his individual quality.
The method by which these creators of political America sought
to secure this community of will was an extremely simple and crude
one. They gave what was for the time, and in view of American
conditions, a very wide franchise. Conditions varied in the dif-
ferent states; the widest franchise was in Pennsylvania, where
every adult male taxpayer voted, but, compared with Britain, all
the United States were well within sight of manhood suffrage by
the end of the eighteenth century. These makers of America also
made efforts, considerable for their times, but puny by more
modern standards, to secure a widely diffused common educa-
tion. The information of the citizens as to what was going on at
home and abroad, they left, apparently without any qualms of
misgiving, to public meetings and the privately owned printing
press.
The story of the various state constitutions, and of the con-
stitution of the United States as a whole, is a very intricate one,
and we can only deal with it here in the broadest way. The most
noteworthy point in a modern view is the disregard of women
as citizens. The American community was a simple, largely agri-
cultural community, and most women were married; it seemed
298 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
natural that they should be represented by their men folk. But
New Jersey admitted a few women to vote on a property qualifi-
cation. Another point of great interest is the almost universal
decision to have two governing assemblies, confirming or checking
each other, on the model of the Lords and Commons of Britain.
Only Pennsylvania had a single representative chamber, and that
was felt to be a very dangerous and ultra-democratic state of
affairs. Apart from the argument that legislation should be slow
as well as sure, it is difficult to establish any necessity for this
"bi-cameral" arrangement. It seems to have been a fashion with
constitution planners in the eighteenth century rather than a
reasonable imperative. The British division was an old one ; the
Lords, the original parliament, was an assembly of "notables,"
the leading men of the kingdom; the House of Commons
came in as a new factor, as the elected spokesmen of the
burghers and the small landed men. It was a little too hastily
assumed in the eighteenth century that the commonalty would
be given to wild impulses and would need checking ; opinion was
for democracy, but for democracy with powerful brakes always on,
whether it was going up hill or down. About all the upper houses
there was therefore a flavour of selectness ; they were elected on a
more limited franchise. This idea of making an upper chamber
which shall be a stronghold for the substantial man does not appeal
to modern thinkers so strongly as it did to the men of the eighteenth
century, but the bi-cameral idea in another form still has its ad-
vocates. They suggest that a community may with advantage
consider its affairs from two points of view — through the eyes
of a body elected to represent trades, industries, professions, public
services, and the like, a body representing function, and through
the eyes of a second body elected by localities to represent com-
munities. For the members of the former a man would vote by
his calling, for the latter by his district of residence. They point
out that the British House of Lords is in effect a body representing
function, in which the land, the law, and the church are no doubt
disproportionately represented, but in which industrialism, fi-
nance, the great public services, art, science, and medicine, also
find places; and that the British House of Commons is purely
geographical in its reference. It has even been suggested in
REPUBLICS OF AMERICA AND FRANCE 299
300 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
Britain that there should be "labour peers," selected from among
the leaders of the great industrial trade unions. But these are
speculations beyond our present scope.
The Central Government of the United States was at first a
very feeble body, a congress of representatives of the thirteen
governments, held together by certain Articles of Confederation.
This Congress was little more than a conference of sovereign repre-
sentatives ; it had no control, for instance, over the foreign trade
of each state, it could not coin money nor levy taxes by its own
authority. When John Adams, the first minister from the United
States to England, went to discuss a commercial treaty with the
British foreign secretary, he was met by a request for thirteen
representatives, one from each of the states concerned. He had
to confess his inadequacy to make binding arrangements. The
British presently began dealing with each state separately over the
head of Congress, and they retained possession of a number of posts
in the American territory about the great lakes because of the
inability of Congress to hold these regions effectually. In another
urgent matter Congress proved equally feeble. To the west of
the thirteen states stretched limitless lands into which settlers
were now pushing in ever-increasing numbers. Each of the states
had indefinable claims to expansion westward. It was evident
to every clear-sighted man that the jostling of these claims must
lead in the long run to war, unless the Central Government could
take on their apportionment. The feebleness of the Central
Government, its lack of concentration, became so much of an
inconvenience and so manifest a danger that there was some secret
discussion of a monarchy, and Nathaniel Gorham of Massachusetts,
the president of Congress, caused Prince Henry of Prussia, the
brother of Frederick the Great, to be approached on the subject.
Finally a constitutional convention was called in 1787 at Phila-
delphia, and there it was that the present constitution of the United
States was in its broad lines hammered out. A great change of
spirit had gone on during the intervening years, a widespread reali-
zation of the need of unity.
When the Articles of Confederation were drawn up, men had
thought of the people of Virginia, the people of Massachusetts, the
people of Rhode Island, and the like ; but now there appears a new
REPUBLICS OF AMERICA AND FRANCE 301
conception, "the people of the United States." The new govern-
ment, with the executive President, the senators, congressmen, and
the Supreme Court, that was now created, was declared to be the
government of "the people of the United States"; it was a syn-
thesis and not a mere assembly. It said "we the people," and not
"we the states," as Lee of Virginia bitterly complained. It was
to be a "federal" and not a confederate government.
State by state the new constitution was ratified, and in the
spring of 1788 the first congress upon the new lines assembled at
New York, under the presidency of George Washington, who had
been the national commander-in-chief throughout the War of
Independence. The constitution then underwent considerable
revision, and Washington upon the Potomac was selected as the
Federal capital.
§6
In an earlier chapter we have described the Roman republic,
and its mixture of modern features with dark superstition and
primordial savagery, as the Neanderthal anticipation of the modern
democratic state. A time may come when people will regard the
contrivances and machinery of the American constitution as the
political equivalents of the implements and contrivances of Neo-
lithic man. They have served their purpose well, and under their
protection the people of the States have grown into one of the
greatest, most powerful, and most civilized communities that the
world has yet seen ; but there is no reason in that for regarding
the American constitution as a thing more final and inalterable
than the pattern of street railway that overshadows many New
York thoroughfares, or the excellent and homely type of house
architecture that still prevails in Philadelphia. These things also
have served a purpose well, they have their faults, and they can
be improved. Our political contrivances, just as much as our
domestic and mechanical contrivances, need to undergo constant
revision as knowledge and understanding grow.
Since the American constitution was planned, our conception
of history and our knowledge of collective psychology has under-
gone very considerable development. We are beginning to see
many things in the problem of government to which the men of
302 ' THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
the eighteenth century were blind ; and, courageous as their con-
structive disposition was in relation to whatever political creation
had gone before, it fell far short of the boldness which we in these
days realize to be needful if this great human problem of estab-
lishing a civilized community of will in the earth is to be solved.
They took many things for granted that now we know need to be
made the subject of the most exacting scientific study and the most
careful adjustment. They thought it was only necessary to set
up schools and colleges, with a grant of land for maintenance,
and that they might then be left to themselves. But education
is not a weed that will grow lustily in any soil, it is a necessary and
delicate crop that may easily wilt and degenerate. We learn
nowadays that the under-development of universities and educa-
tional machinery is like some under-development of the brain and
nerves, which hampers the whole growth of the social body. By
European standards, by the standard of any state that has existed
hitherto, the level of the common education of America is high;
but by the standard of what it might be, America is an uneducated
country. And those fathers of America thought also that they
had but to leave the press free, and everyone would live in the
light. They did not realize that a free press could develop a sort
of constitutional venality due to its relations with advertisers,
and that large newspaper proprietors could become buccaneers
of opinion and insensate wreckers of good beginnings. And,
finally, the makers of America had no knowledge of the com-
plexities of vote manipulation. The whole science of elections was
beyond their ken, they knew nothing of the need of the trans-
ferable vote to prevent the "working" of elections by specialized
organizations, and the crude and rigid methods they adopted left
their political system the certain prey of the great party machines
that have robbed American democracy of half its freedom and
most of its political soul. Politics became a trade, and a very
base trade; decent and able men, after the first great period,
drifted out of politics and attended to " business/' and what I
have called elsewhere the "sense of the state" l declined. Private
enterprise ruled in many matters of common concern, because
political corruption made collective enterprise impossible.
1 Wells, The Future in America.
REPUBLICS OF AMERICA AND FRANCE
303
Yet the defects of the great political system created by the
Americans of the revolutionary period did not appear at once.
For several generations the history of the United States was one
of rapid expansion and of an amount of freedom, homely happi-
ness, and energetic work unparalleled in the world's history.
And the record of America for the whole last century and a half,
in spite of many reversions towards inequality, in spite of much
rawness and much blundering, is nevertheless as bright and
honourable a story as that of any other contemporary people.
In this brief account of the creation of the United States of Amer-
ica we have been able to do little more than mention the names
of some of the group of great
men who made this new de-
parture in human history. We
have named casually or we
have not even named such
men as Tom Paine, Benjamin
Franklin, Patrick Henry,
Thomas Jefferson, the Adams
brothers, Madison, Alexander
Hamilton, and George Washing-
ton. It is hard to measure the
men of one period of history
with those in another. Some
writers, even American writers,
impressed by the artificial splen-
dours of the European courts and by the tawdry and destructive
exploits of a Frederick the Great or a Great Catherine, display
a snobbish shame of something homespun about these makers
of America. They feel that Benjamin Franklin at the court of
Louis XVI, with his long hair, his plain clothes, and his pawky
manner, was sadly lacking in aristocratic distinction. But
stripped to their personalities, Louis XVI was hardly gifted
enough or noble-minded enough to be Franklin's valet. If human
greatness is a matter of scale and glitter, then no doubt Alexander
the Great is at the apex of human greatness. But is greatness
that? Is not a great man rather one who, in a great position or
amidst great opportunities — and great gifts are no more than
"Bciijamuv
304
THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
great opportunities — serves God and his fellows with a humble
heart? And quite a number of these Americans of the revolu-
tionary time do seem to have displayed much disinterestedness
and devotion. They were limited men, fallible men; Washing-
ton was, for example, a conspicuously indolent man; but on the
whole they seem to have cared more for the commonweal they
were creating than for any personal end or personal vanity.
They were all limited men. They were limited in knowledge
and outlook; they were limited by the limitations of the time.
And there was no perfect man
among them. They were, like
all of us, men of mixed motives ;
good impulses arose in their
minds, great ideas swept through
them, and also they could be
jealous, lazy, obstinate, greedy,
vicious. If one were to write a
true, full, and particular history
of the making of the United
States, it would have to be
written with charity and high
spirits as a splendid comedy.
?And in no other regard do
we find the rich tortuous
humanity of the American story so finely displayed as in regard
to slavery. Slavery, having regard to the general question of
labour, is the test of this new soul in the world's history, the
American soul.
Slavery began very early in the European history of America,
and no European people who went to America can be held alto-
gether innocent in the matter. At a time when the German is
still the moral whipping-boy of Europe, it is well to note that the
German record is in this respect the best of all. Almost the first
outspoken utterances against negro slavery came from German
settlers in Pennsylvania. But the German settler was working
with free labour upon a temperate countryside, well north of the
plantation zone; he was not under serious temptation in this
matter. American slavery began with the enslavement of Indians
REPUBLICS OF AMERICA AND FRANCE 305
for gang work in mines and upon plantations, and it is curious to
note that it was a very good and humane man indeed, Las Casas,
who urged that negroes should be brought to America to relieve
his tormented Indian protege's. The need for labour upon the
plantations of the West Indies and the south was imperative.
When the supply of Indian captives proved inadequate, the
planters turned not only to the negro, but to the jails and poor-
houses of Europe for a supply of toilers. The reader of Defoe's
Moll Flanders will learn how the business of Virginian white
slavery looked to an intelligent Englishman in the early eighteenth
century. But the negro came very early. The year (1620) that
saw the Pilgrim Fathers landing at Plymouth in New England
saw a Dutch sloop disembarking the first cargo of negroes at
Jamestown in Virginia. Negro slavery was as old as New Eng-
land ; it had been an American institution for over a century and
a half before the War of Independence. It was to struggle on for
the better part of a century more.
But the conscience of thoughtful men in the colonies was never
quite easy upon this score, and it was one of the accusations of
Thomas Jefferson against the crown and lords of Great Britain
that every attempt to ameliorate or restrain the slave trade on the
part of the colonists had been checked by the great proprietary
interests in the mother country.1 With the moral and intel-
lectual ferment of the revolution, the question of negro slavery
came right into the foreground of the public conscience. The
contrast and the challenge glared upon the mind. "All men are
by nature free and equal," said the Virginia Bill of Rights, and
outside in the sunshine, under the whip of the overseer, toiled the
negro slave.
It witnesses to the great change in human ideas since the Roman
Imperial system dissolved under the barbarian inrush, that there
could be this heart-searching. Conditions of industry, produc-
tion, and land tenure had long prevented any recrudescence of
gang slavery ; but now the cycle had come round again, and there
were enormous immediate advantages to be reaped by the owning
and ruling classes in the revival of that ancient institution in mines,
1 In 1776 Lord Dartmouth wrote that the colonists could not be allowed "to
check or discourage a traffic so beneficent to the nation."
306 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
upon plantations, and upon great public works. It was revived -
but against great opposition. From the beginning of the revival
there were protests, and they grew. The revival was counter to
the new conscience of mankind. In some respects the new gang
slavery was worse than anything in the ancient world. Pecu-
liarly horrible was the provocation by the trade of slave wars and
man hunts in Western Africa, and the cruelties of the long trans-
atlantic voyage. The poor creatures were packed on the ships
often with insufficient provision of food and water, without proper
sanitation, without medicines. Many who could tolerate slavery
upon the plantations found the slave trade too much for their
moral digestions. Three European nations were chiefly concerned
in this dark business, Britain, Spain, and Portugal, because they
were the chief owners of the new lands in America. The compara-
tive innocence of the other European powers is to be ascribed
largely to their lesser temptations. They were similar communi-
ties ; in parallel circumstances they would have behaved similarly.
Throughout the middle part of the eighteenth century there
was an active agitation against negro slavery in Great Britain as
well as in the States. It was estimated that in 1770 there were
fifteen thousand slaves in Britain, mostly brought over by their
owners from the West Indies and Virginia. In 1771 the issue came
to a conclusive test in Britain before Lord Mansfield. A negro
named James Somersett had been brought to England from Vir-
ginia by his owner. He ran away, was captured, and violently
taken on a ship to be returned to Virginia. From the ship he was
extracted by a writ of habeas corpus. Lord Mansfield declared that
slavery was a condition unknown to English law, an "odious"
condition, and Somersett walked out of the court a free man.
The Massachusetts constitution of 1780 had declared that "all
men are born free and equal." A certain negro, Quaco, put this
to the test in 1783, and in that year the soil of Massachusetts be-
came like the soil of Britain, intolerant of slavery ; to tread upon
it was to become free. At that time no other state in the Union
followed this example. At the census of 1790, Massachusetts,
alone of all the states, returned "no slaves."
The state of opinion in Virginia is remarkable, because it brings
to light the peculiar difficulties of the southern states. The great
REPUBLICS OF AMERICA AND FRANCE 307
Virginian statesmen, such as Washington and Jefferson, con-
demned the institution, yet because there was no other form of
domestic service, Washington owned slaves. There was in Vir-
ginia a strong party in favour of emancipating slaves. But they
demanded that the emancipated slaves should leave the state
within a year or be outlawed ! They were naturally alarmed at
the possibility that a free barbaric black community, many of its
members African-born and reeking with traditions of cannibalism
and secret and dreadful religious rites, should arise beside them
upon Virginian soil. When we consider that point of view, we can
understand why it was that a large number of Virginians should
be disposed to retain the mass of blacks in the country under
control as slaves, while at the same time they were bitterly op-
posed to the slave trade and the importation of any fresh blood
from Africa. The free blacks, one sees, might easily become a
nuisance ; indeed the free state of Massachusetts presently closed
its borders to their entry. . . . The question of slavery, which
in the ancient world was usually no more than a question of status
between individuals racially akin, merged in America with the
different and profounder question of relationship between two
races at opposite extremes of the human species and of the most
contrasted types of tradition and culture. If the black man had
been white, there can be little doubt that negro slavery, like white
servitude, would have vanished from the United States within a
generation of the Declaration of Independence as a natural conse-
quence of the statements in that declaration.
§7'
We have told of the War of Independence in America as the first
great break away from the system of European monarchies and
foreign offices, as the repudiation by a new community of Machi-
avellian statescraft as the directive form of human affairs. Within
a decade there came a second and much more portentous revolt
against this strange game of Great Powers, this tangled interaction
1 A very readable and remarkably well-illustrated book for the general reader
upon the French Revolution is Tyheeler's French Revolution. Carlyle's French
Revolution has some splendid passages, but it is often unjust and evil-spirited.
Madelin's French Revolution is a good recent book.
308 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
of courts and policies which obsessed Europe. But this time it
was no breaking away at the outskirts. In France, the nest and
home of Grand Monarchy, the heart and centre of Europe, came
this second upheaval. And, unlike the American colonists, who
simply repudiated a king, the French, following in the footsteps
of the English revolution, beheaded one.
Like the British revolution and like the revolution in the United
States, the French revolution can be traced back to the ambitious
absurdities of the French monarchy. The schemes of aggrandize-
ment, the aims and designs of the Grand Monarch, necessitated
an expenditure upon war equipment throughout Europe out of
all proportion to the taxable capacity of the age. And even the
splendours of monarchy were enormously costly, measured by the
productivity of the time. In France, just as in Britain and in
America, the first resistance was made not to the monarch as such
and to his foreign policy as such, nor with any clear recognition
of these things as the roots of the trouble, but merely to the incon-
veniences and charges upon the individual life caused by them.
The practical taxable capacity of France must have been relatively
much less than that of England because "of the various exemp-
tions of the nobility and clergy. The burthen resting directly
upon the common people was heavier. That made the upper
classes the confederates of the court instead of the antagonists of
the court as they were in England, and so prolonged the period of
waste further ; but when at last the bursting-point did come, the
explosion was more violent and shattering.
During the years of the American War of Independence there
were few signs of any impending explosion in France.1 There was
much misery among the lower classes, much criticism and satire,
much outspoken liberal thinking, but there was little to indicate
that the thing as a whole, with all its customs, usages, and familiar
discords, might not go on for an indefinite time. It was consuming
beyond its powers of production, but as yet only the inarticulate
classes were feeling the pinch. Gibbon, the historian, knew France
well; Paris was as familiar to him as London; but there is no
1 But see Rocquain's L' Esprit revolutionnaire avant la Revolution. He traces
the growth of a revolutionary spirit in the 18th century, and points to many pre-
dictions of a debacle in 18th-century French literature. — E. B.
REPUBLICS OF AMERICA AND FRANCE 309
suspicion to be detected in the passage we have quoted that days
of political and social dissolution were at hand. No doubt the
world abounded in absurdities and injustices, yet nevertheless,
from the point of view of a scholar and a gentleman, it was fairly
comfortable, and it seemed fairly secure.
There was much liberal thought, speech, and sentiment in
France at this time. Parallel with and a little later than John
Locke in England, Montesquieu (1689-1755) in France, in the
earlier half of the eighteenth century, had subjected social, polit-
ical, and religious institutions to the same searching and funda-
mental analysis, especially in his Esprit des Lois. He had stripped
the magical prestige from the absolutist monarchy in France.
He shares with Locke the credit for clearing away many of the
false ideas that had hitherto prevented deliberate and conscious
attempts to reconstruct human society. It was not his fault if
at first some extremely unsound and impermanent shanties were
run up on the vacant site. The generation that followed him in
the middle and later decades of the eighteenth century was boldly
speculative upon the mpral and intellectual clearings he had made.
A group of brilliant writers, the " Encyclopaedists," mostly rebel
spirits from the excellent schools of the Jesuits, set themselves
under the leadership of Diderot to scheme out, in a group of works,
a new world (1766). The glory of the Encyclopaedists, says
Mallet, lay "in their hatred of things unjust, in their denuncia-
tion of the trade in slaves, of the inequalities of taxation, of the
corruption of justice, of the wastefulness of wars, in their dreams
of social progress, in their sympathy with the rising empire of
industry which was beginning to transform the world." Their
chief error seems to have been an indiscriminate hostility to
religion. They believed that man was naturally just and polit-
ically competent, whereas his impulse to social service and self-
forgetfulness is usually developed only through an education
essentially religious, and sustained only in an atmosphere of honest
co-operation. Unco-ordinated human initiatives lead to nothing
but social chaos.
Side by side with the Encyclopaedists were tha^EconQmjsts or
Physiocrats, who were making bold and crude inquiries into the
production and distribution of food and goods. Morally, the
310 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
author of the Code de la Nature, denounced the institution of
private property and proposed a communistic organization of
society. He was the precursor of that large and various school of
collectivist thinkers in the nineteenth century who are lumped
together as Socialists.
Both the Encyclopaedists and the various Economists and
Physiocrats demanded a considerable amount of hard thinking
in their disciples. An easier and more popular leader to follow
was that eloquent sentimentalist, Rousseau (1712-78). He
preached the alluring doctrine that the primitive state of man
was one of virtue and happiness, from which he had declined
through the rather inexplicable activities of priests, kings, lawyers,
and the like. (We have tried to convey to our readers in chap,
ix, § 2, primitive man's state of virtue and happiness, as the vivid
vision of Mr. Worthington Smith has realized it; and we have
done our best to show both the necessity of priests and kings to
early civilization, and the possible inconveniences of their later
roles in human affairs.) Rousseau's work was essentially de-
moralizing. It struck not only at the existing social fabric, but
at any social organization. When he wrote of the Social Contract,
he did so rather to excuse breaches of the covenant than to empha-
size its necessity. Man is so far from perfect, that a writer who
could show that the almost universal disposition, against which
we all have to fortify ourselves, to repudiate debts, misbehave
sexually, and evade the toil and expenses of education for our-
selves and others, is not after all a delinquency, but a fine display
of Natural Virtue, was bound to have a large following in every
class that could read him. Rousseau's tremendous vogue did
much to swamp the harder, clearer thinkers of this time, and to
prepare a sentimental, declamatory, and insincere popular psy-
chology for the great trials that were now coming upon France.1
1 1 disagree utterly and entirely with this view of Rousseau, which is quite
unfair to the man who wrote Du Contrat Social. (1) He did not believe in the "state
of nature" ; he believed in the State, which had lifted man from being a brute that
followed its nose into a reasoning being and a man. (2) He did not write to excuse
breakers of the covenant. On the contrary, he wrote to preach the sovereignty of
the general will, and he believed in the entire control of the individual by that will.
Rousseau has been much misrepresented, and the text follows the misrepresen-
tations. See Vaughan, The Political Writings of Rousseau, introduction to Du
Contrat Social. — E. B.
REPUBLICS OF AMERICA AND FRANCE 311
We have already remarked that hitherto no human community
has begun to act upon theory. There must first be some break-
down and necessity for direction that lets theory into her own.
Up to 1788 the republican and anarchist talk and writing of French
thinkers must have seemed as ineffective and politically unim-
portant as the aesthetic socialism of William Morris at the end of
the nineteenth century. There was the social and political system
going on with an effect of an invincible persistence, the king hunting
and mending his clocks, the court and the world of fashion pursu-
ing their pleasures, the financiers conceiving continually more
enterprising extensions of credit, business blundering clumsily
along its ancient routes, much incommoded by taxes and imposts,
the peasants worrying, toiling, and suffering, full of a hopeless
hatred of the nobleman's chateau. Men talked — and felt they
were merely talking. Anything might be said, because nothing
would ever happen.
§8
The first jar to this sense of the secure continuity of life in
France came in 1787. Louis XVI (1774-92) was a dull, ill-edu-
cated monarch, and he had the misfortune to be married to a
silly and extravagant woman, Marie Antoinette, the sister of the
Austrian emperor. The question of her virtue is one of profound
interest to a certain type of historical writer, but we need not dis-
cuss it here. She lived, as Paul Wiriath 1 puts it, "side by side,
but not at the side" of her husband. She was rather heavy-
featured, but not so plain as to prevent her posing as a beautiful,
romantic, and haughty queen. When the exchequer was ex-
hausted by the war in America (an enterprise to weaken England
of the highest Machiavellian quality), when the whole country
was uneasy with discontents, she set her influence to thwart the
attempts at economy of the king's ministers, to encourage every
sort of aristocratic extravagance, and to restore the church and
the nobility to the position they had held in the great days of
Louis XIV. Non-aristocratic officers were to be weeded from
the army ; the power of the church over private life was to be ex-
tended. She found in an upper-class official, Calonne, her ideal
minister of finance. From 1783-87 this wonderful man produced
1 Article "France," Encyclopaedia Britannica.
312 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
money as if by magic — and as if by magic it disappeared again.
Then in 1787 he collapsed. He had piled loan on loan, and now
he declared that the monarchy, the Grand Monarchy that had
ruled France since the days of Louis XIV, was bankrupt. No
more money could be raised. There must be a gathering of the
Notables of the kingdom to consider the situation.
To the gathering of notables, a summoned assembly of leading
men, Calonne propounded a scheme for a subsidy to be levied
upon all landed property. This roused the aristocrats to a pitch
of great indignation. They demanded the summoning of a body
roughly equivalent to the British parliament, the States General,
which had not met since 1610. Regardless of the organ of opinion
they were creating for the discontents below them, excited only
by the proposal that they should bear part of the weight of the
financial burthens of the country, the French notables insisted.
And in May, 1789, the States General met.
It was an assembly of the representatives of three orders, the
nobles, the clergy, and the Third Estate, the commons. For the
Third Estate the franchise was very wide, nearly every tax-payer
of twenty-five having a vote. (The parish priests voted as clergy,
the small noblesse as nobles.) The States General was a body
without any tradition of procedure. Enquiries were sent to the
antiquarians of the Academy of Inscriptions in that matter. Its
opening deliberations turned on the question whether it was to
meet as one body or as three, each estate having an equal vote.
Since the Clergy numbered 308, the Nobles 285, and the Deputies
621, the former arrangement would put the Commons in an abso-
lute majority, the latter gave them one vote in three. Nor had
the States General any meeting-place. Should it meet in Paris
or in some provincial city? Versailles was chosen, "because of
the hunting."
It is clear that the king and queen meant to treat this fuss about
the national finance as a terrible bore, and to allow it to interfere
with their social routine as little as possible. We find the meet-
ings going on in salons that were not wanted, in orangeries and
tennis-courts, and so forth.
The question whether the voting was to be by the estates or by
head was clearly a vital one. It was wrangled over for six weeks.
REPUBLICS OF AMERICA AND FRANCE 313
The Third Estate, taking a leaf from the book of the English
House of Commons, then declared that it alone represented the
nation, and that no taxation must be levied henceforth without
its consent. Whereupon the king closed the hall in which it was
sitting, and intimated that the deputies had better go home.
Instead, the deputies met in a convenient tennis-court, and there
took oath, the Oath of the Tennis Court, not to separate until
they had established a constitution in France.
The king took a high line, and attempted to disperse the Third
Estate by force. The soldiers refused to act. On that the king
gave in with a dangerous suddenness, and accepted the principle
that the Three Estates should all deliberate and vote together as
one National Assembly. Meanwhile, apparently at the queen's
instigation, foreign regiments in the French service, who could
be trusted to act against the people, were brought up from the
provinces under the Marshal de Broglie, and the king prepared
to go back upon his concessions. Whereupon Paris and France
revolted. Broglie hesitated to fire on the crowds. A provisional
city government was set up in Paris and in most of the other large
cities, and a new armed force, the National Guard, a force de-
signed primarily and plainly to resist the forces of the crown, was
brought into existence by these municipal bodies.
The revolt of July, 1789 was really the effective French revolu-
tion. The grim-looking prison of the Bastille was stormed by the
people of Paris, and the insurrection spread rapidly throughout
France. Everywhere chateaux belonging to the nobility were
burnt by the peasants, their title-deeds carefully destroyed, and
the nobles murdered or driven away. In a month the ancient
and decayed system of the aristocratic order had collapsed. Many
of the leading princes and courtiers of the queen's party fled
abroad. The National Assembly found itself called upon to
create a new political and social system for a new age.1
§9
The French National Assembly was far less fortunate in the
circumstances of its task than the American Congress. The
1 There is a very picturesque account of the storming of the Bastille in Carlyle's
French Revolution, book v, chap. vi.
314 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
latter had half a continent to itself, with no possible antagonist
but the British Government. Its religious and educational or-
ganizations were various, collectively not very powerful, and on
the whole friendly. King George was far away in England, and
sinking slowly towards an imbecile condition. Nevertheless, it
took the United States several years to hammer out a working
constitution. The French, on the other hand, were surrounded
by aggressive neighbors with Machiavellian ideas, they were
encumbered by a king and court resolved to make mischief, and
the church was one single great organization inextricably bound
up with the ancient order. The queen was in close correspondence
with the Count of Artois, the Duke of Bourbon, and the other
exiled princes who were trying to induce Austria and Prussia to
attack the new French nation. Moreover, France* was already a
bankrupt country, while the United States had limitless unde-
veloped resources; and the revolution, by altering the condi-
tions of land tenure and marketing, had produced an economic
disorganization that has no parallel in the case of America.
These were the unavoidable difficulties of the situation. But
in addition the Assembly made difficulties for itself. There was
no orderly procedure. The English House of Commons had had
more than five centuries of experience in its work, and Mirabeau,
one of the great leaders of the early Revolution, tried in vain to
have the English rules adopted. But the feeling of the times was
all in favour of outcries, dramatic interruptions, and such-like
manifestations of Natural Virtue. And the disorder did not come
merely from the assembly. There was a great gallery, much too
great a gallery, for strangers; but who would restrain the free
citizens from having a voice in the national control ? This gallery
swarmed with people eager for a "scene," ready to applaud or
shout down the speakers below. The abler speakers were obliged
to play to the gallery, and take a sentimental and sensational line.
It was easy at a crisis to bring in a mob to kill debate.
So encumbered, the Assembly set about its constructive task.
On the Fourth of August it achieved a great dramatic success.
Led by several of the nobles, it made a clean sweep, in a series of
resolutions, of serfdom, privileges, tax exemptions, tithes, feudal
courts. Titles followed. Long before France was a republic it
REPUBLICS OF AMERICA AND FRANCE 315
was an offence for a nobleman to sign his name with his title.
For six weeks the Assembly devoted itself, with endless oppor-
tunities for rhetoric, to the formulation of a Declaration of the
Rights of Man — on the lines of the Bills of Rights that were the
English preliminaries to organized change. Meanwhile the court
plotted for reaction, and the people felt that the court was plotting.
The story is complicated here by the scoundrelly schemes of'the
king's cousin, Philip of Orleans, who hoped to use the discords of
the time to replace Louis on the French throne. His gardens at
the Palais Royal were thrown open to the public, and became a
great centre of advanced discussion. His agents did much to
intensify the popular suspicion of the king. And things were
exacerbated by a shortage of provisions — for which the king's
government was held guilty.
Presently the loyal Flanders regiment appeared at Versailles.
The royal family was scheming to get farther away from Paris —
in order to undo all that had been done, to restore tyranny and
extravagance. Such constitutional monarchists as General La-
fayette were seriously alarmed. And just at this time occurred
an outbreak of popular indignation at the scarcity of food, that
passed by an easy transition into indignation against the threat
of royalist reaction. It was believed that there was an abundance
of provisions at Versailles ; that food was being kept there away
from the people. The public mind had been much disturbed by
reports, possibly by exaggerated reports, of a recent banquet at
Versailles, hostile to the nation. Here are some extracts from
Carlyle descriptive of that unfortunate feast.
"The Hall of the Opera is granted ; the Salon d'Hercule shall be
drawing-room. Not only the Officers of Flandre, but of the Swiss,
of the Hundred Swiss ; nay of the Versailles National Guard, such
of them as have any loyalty, shall feast ; it will be a Repast like
few.
" And now suppose this Repast, the solid part of it, transacted ;
and the first bottle over. Suppose the customary loyal toasts
drunk; the King's health, the Queen's with deafening vivats;
that of the nation 'omitted/ or even 'rejected.' Suppose cham-
pagne flowing ; with pot-valorous speech, with instrumental music ;
empty featherheads growing ever the noisier, in their own empti-
316 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
ness, in each other's noise. Her Majesty, who looks unusually
sad to-night (His Majesty sitting dulled with the day's hunting),
is told that the sight of it would cheer her. Behold ! She enters
there, issuing from her State-rooms, like the Moon from clouds,
this fairest unhappy Queen of Hearts; royal Husband by her
side, young Dauphin in her arms ! She descends from the Boxes,
amid splendour and acclaim ; walks queen-like round the Tables ;
gracefully nodding ; her looks full of sorrow, yet of gratitude and
daring, with the hope of France on her mother-bosom ! And now,
the band striking up, 0 Richard, 0 mon Roi, I'univers t'abandonne
(Oh Richard, O my king, the world is all forsaking thee), could
man do other than rise to height of pity, of loyal valour? Could
feather-headed young ensigns do other than, by white Bourbon
Cockades, handed them from fair fingers; by waving of swords,
drawn to pledge the Queen's health; by trampling of National
Cockades ; by scaling the Boxes, whence intrusive murmurs may
come; by vociferation, sound, fury and distraction, within doors
and without — testify what tempest-tost state of vacuity they are
in? ...
"A natural Repast; in ordinary times, a harmless one: now
fatal. . . . Poor ill-advised Marie Antoinette ; with a woman's
vehemence, not with a sovereign's foresight ! It was so natural,
yet so unwise. Next day, in public speech of ceremony, her
Majesty declares herself ' delighted with Thursday."
And here to set against this is Carlyle's picture of the mood of
the people.
"In squalid garret, on Monday morning Maternity awakes, to
hear children weeping for bread. Maternity must forth to the
streets, to the herb-makers and bakers'-queues ; meets there with
hunger-stricken Maternity, sympathetic, exasperative. O we un-
happy women ! But, instead of bakers'-queues, why not to Aristo-
crats' palaces, the root of the matter? Allans! Let us assemble.
To the H6tel-de-Ville ; to Versailles. ..."
There was much shouting and coming and going in Paris before
this latter idea realized itself. One Maillard appeared with organ-
izing power, and assumed a certain leadership. There can be
little doubt that the revolutionary leaders, and particularly Gen-
eral Lafayette, used and organized this outbreak to secure the king,
REPUBLICS OF AMERICA AND FRANCE 317
before he could slip away — as Charles I did to Oxford — to begin
a civil war. As the afternoon wore on, the procession started on
its eleven mile tramp. . . .
Again we quote Carlyle :
"Maillard has halted his draggled Menads on the last hill-top;
and now Versailles, and the Chateau of Versailles, and far and
wide the inheritance of Royalty opens to the wondering eye.
From far on the right, over Marly and Saint-Germain-en-Laye ;
round towards Rambouillet, on the left, beautiful all ; softly em-
bosomed ; as if in sadness, in the dim moist weather ! And near
before us is Versailles, New and Old; with that broad frondent
Avenue de Versailles between — stately frondent, broad, three
hundred feet as men reckon, with its four rows of elms ; and then
the Chateau de Versailles, ending in royal parks and pleasances,
gleaming lakelets, arbours, labyrinths, the Menagerie, and Great
and Little Trianon. High-towered dwellings, leafy pleasant
places ; where the gods of this lower world abide : whence, never-
theless, black care cannot be excluded ; whither Menadic hunger
is even now advancing, armed with pike-thyrsi!"
Rain fell as the evening closed.
"Behold the Esplanade, over all its spacious expanse, is covered
with groups of squalid dripping women; of lank-haired male
rascality, armed with axes, rusty pikes, old muskets, iron-shod
clubs (batons ferres, which end in knives or swordblades, a kind
of extempore billhook) ; looking nothing but hungry revolt. The
rain pours; Gardes-du-Corps go caracoling through the groups
'amid hisses' ; irritating and agitating what is but dispersed here
to reunite there. . . .
" Innumerable squalid women beleaguer the President and De-
putation ; insist on going with him : has not his Majesty himself,
looking from the window, sent out to ask, What we wanted?
'Bread, and speech with the King/ that was the answer. Twelve
women are clamorously added to the deputation; and march
with it, across the Esplanade ; through dissipated groups, caracol-
ing bodyguards and the pouring rain."
" Bread and not too much talking!" Natural demands.
"One learns also that the royal Carriages are getting yoked, as
if for Metz. Carriages, royal or not, have verily showed them-
318 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
selves at the back gates. They even produced, or quoted, a
written order from our Versailles Municipality — which is a mon-
archic not a democratic one. However, Versailles patrols drove
them in again; as the vigilant Lecointre had strictly charged
them to do. . . .
"So sink the shadows of night, blustering, rainy; and all paths
grow dark. Strangest night ever seen in these regions; perhaps
since the Bartholomew Night, when Versailles, as Bassompierre
writes of it, was a chetif chateau.
"O for the lyre of some Orpheus, to constrain, with touch of
melodious strings, these mad masses into Order! For here all
seems fallen asunder, in wide-yawning dislocation. The highest,
as in down-rushing of a world, is come in contact with the lowest :
the rascality of France beleaguering the royalty of France ; ' iron-
shod batons' lifted round the diadem, not to guard it! With
denunciations of bloodthirsty anti-national bodyguards, are heard
dark growlings against a queenly name.
"The Court sits tremulous, powerless: varies with the varying
temper of the Esplanade, with the varying colour of the rumours
from Paris. Thick-coming rumours; now of peace, now of war.
Necker and all the Ministers consult ; with a blank issue. The
(Eil-de-Bceuf is one tempest of whispers : We will fly to Metz ;
we will not fly. The royal carriages again attempt egress -
though for trial merely; they are again driven in by Lecointres
patrols."
But we must send the reader to Carlyle to learn of the coming
of the National Guard in the night under General Lafayette him-
self, the bargaining between the Assembly and the King, the
outbreak of fighting in the morning between the bodyguard and
the hungry besiegers, and how the latter stormed into the palace
and came near to a massacre of the royal family. Lafayette and
his troops turned out in time to prevent that, and timely cartloads
of loaves arrived from Paris for the crowd.
At last it was decided that the king should come to Paris.
"Processional marches not a few our world has seen; Roman
triumphs and ovations, Cabiric cymbal-beatings, Royal progresses,
Irish funerals ; but this of the French Monarchy marching to its
bed remained to be seen. Miles long, and of breadth losing itself
REPUBLICS OF AMERICA AND FRANCE 319
in vagueness, for all the neighbouring country crowds to see.
Slow : stagnating along, like shoreless Lake, yet with a noise like
Niagara, like Babel and Bedlam. A splashing and a tramping;
a hurrahing, uproaring, musketj-volleying ; the truest segment of
Chaos seen in these latter Ages ! Till slowly it disembogue itself
in the thickening dusk, into expectant Paris, through a double
row of faces all the way from Passy to the H6tel-de-Ville.
" Consider this: Vanguard of National troops; with trains of
artillery; of pikemen and pikewomen, mounted on cannons, on
carts, hackney-coaches, or on foot. . . . Loaves stuck on the
points of bayonets, green boughs stuck in gun-barrels. Next, as
main-march, ' fifty cart-loads of corn/ which have been lent, for
peace, from the stores of Versailles. Behind which follow strag-
glers of the Garde-du-Corps ; all humiliated, in Grenadier bonnets.
Close on these comes the royal carriage; come royal carriages;
for there are a hundred national deputies too, among whom sits
Mirabeau — his remarks not given. Then finally, pell-mell, as
rear-guard, Flandre, Swiss, Hundred Swiss, other bodyguards,
brigands, whosoever cannot get before. Between and among all
which masses flows without limit Saint-Antoine and the Menadic
cohort. Menadic especially about the royal carriage. . . .
Covered with tricolor ; singing ' allusive songs ' ; pointing with
one hand to the royal carriage, which the allusions hit, and pointing
to the provision-wagons with the other hand, and these words :
* Courage, Friends ! We shall not want bread now ; we are bring-
ing you the Baker, the Bakeress, and Baker's boy.' . . .
"The wet day draggles the tricolor, but the joy is unextinguish-
able. Is not all well now? 'Ah Madame, noire bonne Heine?
said some of these Strong- women some days hence, 'Ah, Madame,
our good Queen, don't be a traitor any more and we will all love
you!' . . ."
This was October the sixth, 1789. For nearly two years the
royal family dwelt unmolested in the Tuileries. Had the court
kept common faith with the people, the king might have died there,
a king.
From 1789 to 1791 the early Revolution held its own ; France
was a limited monarchy, the king kept a diminished state in the
Tuileries, and the National Assembly ruled a country at peace.
320 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
The reader who will glance back to the maps of Poland we have
given in the previous chapter will realize what occupied Russia,
Prussia, and Austria at this time. While France experimented
with a crowned republic in the west, the last division of the crowned
republic of the east was in progress. France could wait.
When we consider its inexperience, the conditions under which
it worked, and the complexities of its problems, one must con-
cede that the Assembly did a very remarkable amount of construc-
tive work. Much of that work was sound and still endures, much
was experimental and has been undone. Some was disastrous.
There was a clearing up of the penal code; torture, arbitrary
imprisonment, and persecutions for heresy were abolished; and
the ancient provinces of France, Normandy, Burgundy, and the
like gave place to eighty departments. Promotion to the highest
ranks in the army was laid open to men of every class. An ex-
cellent, and simple system of law courts was set up, but its value
was much vitiated by having the judges appointed by popular
election for short periods of time. This made the crowd a sort
of final court of appeal, and the judges, like the members of the
Assembly, were forced to play to the gallery. And the whole
vast property of the church was seized and administered by the
state ; religious establishments not engaged in education or works
of charity were broken up, and the salaries of the clergy made a
charge upon the nation. This in itself was not a bad thing for the
lower clergy in France, who were often scandalously underpaid
in comparison with the richer dignitaries. But in addition the
choice of priests and bishops was made elective, which struck at
the very root idea of the Roman church, which centred every-
thing upon the Pope, and in which all authority is from above
downward. Practically the National Assembly wanted at one
blow to make the church in France Protestant, in organization if
not in doctrine. Everywhere there were disputes and conflicts
between the state priests of the republic and the recalcitrant
(non-juring) priests who were loyal to Rome. . . .
One curious thing the National Assembly did which greatly
weakened its grip on affairs. It decreed that no member of the
Assembly should be an executive minister. This was in imita-
tion of the American constitution, where also ministers are sepa-
REPUBLICS OF AMERICA AND FRANCE 321
rated from the legislature. The British method has been to have
all ministers in the legislative body, ready to answer questions and
account for their, interpretation of the laws and their conduct
of the nation's business. If the legislature represents the sovereign
people, then it is surely necessary for the ministers to be in the
closest touch with their sovereign. This severance of the legisla-
ture and executive in France caused misunderstandings and mis-
trust ; the legislature lacked control and the executive lacked moral
force. This led to such an ineffectiveness in the central govern-
ment that in many districts at this time, communes and towns
were to be found that were practically self-governing communities ;
they accepted or rejected the commands of Paris as they thought
fit, declined the payment of taxes, and divided up the church lands
according to their local appetites.
§10
It is quite possible that with the loyal support of the crown and
a reasonable patriotism on the part of the nobility, the National
Assembly, in spite of its noisy galleries, its Rousseauism, and its
inexperience, might have blundered through to a stable form of
parliamentary government for France. In Mirabeau it had a
statesman with clear ideas of the needs of the time ; he knew the
strength and the defects of the British system, and apparently he
had set himself to establish in France a parallel political organiza-
tion upon a wider, more honest franchise. He had, it is true, in-
dulged in a sort of Ruritanian flirtation with the queen, seen her
secretly, pronounced her very solemnly the "only man" about
the king, and made rather a fool of himself in that matter, but his
schemes were drawn upon a much larger scale than the scale of the
back stairs of the Tuileries. By his death in 1791 France cer-
tainly lost one of her most constructive statesmen, and the National
Assembly its last chance of any co-operation with the king. When
there is a court there is usually a conspiracy, and royalist schemes
and royalist mischief-making were the last straw in the balance
against the National Assembly. The royalists did not care for
Mirabeau, they did not care for France ; they wanted to be back
in their lost paradise of privilege, haughtiness, and limitless ex-
penditure, and it seemed to them that if only they could make
322
THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
the government of the National Assembly impossible, then by a
sort of miracle the dry bones of the ancient regime would live
again. They had no sense of
the other possibility, the gulf of
the republican extremists, that
yawned at their feet.
One June night in 1791, be-
tween eleven o'clock and mid-
night, the king and queen and
their two children slipped out of
the Tuileries disguised, threaded
their palpitating way through
Paris, circled round from the
north of the city to the east,
and got at last into a travelling-
carriage that was waiting upon
the road to Chalons. They
were flying to the army of the
east.1 The army of the east
was "loyal," that is to say, its
general and officers at least were
prepared to betray France to
the king and court. Here was
adventure at last after the
queen's heart, and one can
understand the pleasurable ex-
citement of the little party as
the miles lengthened between
themselves and Paris. Away
over the hills were reverence,
deep bows, and the kissing of
hands. Then back to Versailles.
A little shooting of the mob in
Paris — artillery, if need be.
A few executions — but not of
the sort of people who matter.
A White Terror for a few months. Then all would be well
1 Carlyle is at his best on this flight, French Revolution, book iv, chaps, iv and v.
REPUBLICS OF AMERICA AND FRANCE 323
again. Perhaps Calonne might return too, with fresh financial
expedients. He was busy just then gathering support among the
German princes. There were a lot of chateaux to rebuild, but
the people who burnt them down could hardly complain if the
task of rebuilding them pressed rather heavily upon their grimy
necks. . . .
All such bright anticipations were cruelly dashed that night at
Varennes. The king had been recognized at Sainte Menehould by
the landlord of the post house, and as the night fell, the eastward
roads clattered with galloping messengers rousing the country,
and trying to intercept the fugitives. There were fresh horses
waiting in the upper village of Varennes — the young officer in
charge had given the king up for the night and gone to bed —
while for half an hour in the lower village the poor king, disguised
as a valet, disputed with his postillions, who had expected reliefs
in the lower village and refused to go further. Finally they con-
sented to go on. They consented too late. The little party
found the postmaster from Sainte Menehould, who had ridden
past while the postillions wrangled, and a number of worthy re-
publicans of Varennes whom he had gathered together, awaiting
them at the bridge between the two parts of the town. The
bridge was barricaded. Muskets were thrust into the carriage:
"Your passports ?"
The king surrendered without a struggle. The little party was
taken into the house of some village functionary. "Well," said
the king, "here you have me!" Also he remarked that he was
hungry. At dinner he commended the wine, "quite excellent
wine." What the queen said is not recorded. There were royalist
troops at hand, but they attempted no rescue. The tocsin began
to ring, and the village "illuminated itself," to guard against
surprise. . . .
A very crestfallen coachload of royalty returned to Paris and
was received by vast crowds — in silence. The word had gone
forth that whoever insulted the king should be thrashed, and who-
ever applauded him should be killed. . . .
It was only after this foolish exploit that the idea of a republic
took hold of the French mind. Before this flight to Varennes there
was no doubt much abstract republican sentiment, but there was
324 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
scarcely any expressed disposition to abolish monarchy in France.
Even in July, a month after the flight, a great meeting in the
Champ de Mars, supporting a petition for the dethronement of
the king, was dispersed by the authorities, and many people were
killed. But such displays of firmness could not prevent the lesson
of that flight soaking into men's minds. Just as in England in
the days of Charles I, so now in France men realized that the
king could not be trusted — he was dangerous. The Jacobins,
the extreme republican party, grew rapidly in strength. Their
leaders, Robespierre, Danton, Marat, who had hitherto been a
group of impossibles on the extreme left, began to dominate the
National Assembly.
These Jacobins were the equivalents of the American radicals,
men with untrammelled advanced ideas. Their strength lay in
the fact that they were unencumbered and downright. They
were poor men with nothing to lose. The party of moderation,
of compromise with the relics of the old order, was led by such
men of established position as General Lafayette, the general
who had commanded the French troops in America, and Mira-
beau, an aristocrat who was ready to model himself on the rich
and influential aristocrats of England. But Robespierre was a
needy but clever young lawyer from Arras, whose most precious
possession was his faith in Rousseau; Danton was a scarcely
more wealthy barrister in Paris, one of those big roaring gesticu-
lating Frenchmen who are in normal times the heroic loud-talkers
of provincial cafes; Marat was an older man, a Swiss of very-
great scientific distinction, but equally unembarrassed by pos-
sessions. On Marat's scientific standing it is necessary to lay
stress because there is a sort of fashion among English writers to
misrepresent the leaders of great revolutionary movements as
ignorant men. This gives a false view of the mental processes
of revolution; and it is the task of the historian to correct it.
Marat, we find, was conversant with English, Spanish, German,
and Italian ; he had spent several years in England, he was made
an honorary M.D. of St. Andrew's, and had published some valu-
able contributions to medical science in English. Both Benjamin
Franklin and Goethe were greatly interested in his work in physics.
This is the man who is called by Carlyle "rabid dog," " atrocious,"
REPUBLICS OF AMERICA AND FRANCE 325
" squalid," and " Dog-leech" -this last by way of tribute to his
science.
The revolution called Marat to politics, and his earliest con-
tributions to the great discussion were fine and sane. There was
a prevalent delusion in France that England was a land of liberty.
His Tableau des vices de la constitution d'Angleterre showed the
realities of the English position. His last years were maddened
by an almost intolerable skin disease which he caught while hiding
in the sewers of Paris to escape the consequences of his denunciation
of the king as a traitor after the flight to Varennes. Only by
sitting in a hot bath could he collect his mind to write. He had
been treated hardly and suffered, and he became hard; never-
theless he stands out in history as a man of rare, unblemished
honesty. His poverty seems particularly to have provoked the
scorn of Carlyle.
"What a road he has travelled ; and sits now, about half-past
seven of the clock, stewing in slipper-bath; sore afflicted; ill of
Revolution Fever. . . . Excessively sick and worn, poor man:
with precisely elevenpence half penny of ready-money, in paper;
with slipper-bath; strong three-footed stool for writing on, the
while : and a squalid Washerwoman for his sole household . . .
that is his civic establishment in Medical-School Street; thither
and not elsewhere has his road led him. . . . Hark, a rap again !
A musical woman's voice, refusing to be rejected : it is the Cito-
yenne who would do France a service. Marat, recognizing from
within, cries, Admit her. Charlotte Corday is admitted."
The young heroine — for republican leaders are fair game, and
their assassins are necessarily heroines and their voices "musical"
— offered to give him some necessary information about the coun-
ter-revolution at Caen, and as he was occupied in making a note
of her facts, she stabbed him with a large sheath knife (1792). . .
Such was the quality of most of the leaders of the Jacobin party.
They were men of no property — untethered men. They were
more dissociated and more elemental, therefore, than any other
party; and they were ready to push the ideas of freedom and
equality to a logical extremity. Their standards of patriotic
virtue were high and harsh. There was something inhuman even
in their humanitarian zeal. They saw without humour the dis-
326 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
position of the moderates to ease things down, to keep the common
folk just a little needy and respectful, and royalty (and men of
substance) just a little respected. They were blinded by the
formulae of Rousseauism to the historicaltruth that man is by na-
ture oppressor and oppressed, and that it is only slowly by law,
education, and the spirit of love in the world that men can be
made happy and free.
And while in America the f ormulae of eighteenth-century democ-
racy were on the whole stimulating and helpful because it was
already a land of open-air practical equality so far as white men
were concerned, in France these formulas made a very heady and
dangerous mixture for the town populations, because considerable
parts of the towns of France were slums full of dispossessed, de-
moralized, degraded, and bitter-spirited people. The Parisian
crowd was in a particularly desperate and dangerous state, because
the industries of Paris had been largely luxury industries, and
much of her employment parasitic on the weaknesses and vices of
fashionable life. Now the fashionable world had gone over the
frontier, travellers were restricted, business disordered, and the
city full of unemployed and angry people.
But the royalists, instead of realizing the significance of these
Jacobins with their dangerous integrity and their dangerous grip
upon the imagination of the mob, had the conceit to think they
could make tools of them. The time for the replacement of the
National Assembly under the new-made constitution by the
"Legislative Assembly" was drawing near; and when the Jaco-
bins, with the idea of breaking up the moderates, proposed to make
the members of the National Assembly ineligible for the Legisla-
tive Assembly, the royalists supported them with great glee, and
carried the proposal. They perceived that the Legislative As-
sembly, so clipped of all experience, must certainly be a politically
incompetent body. They would "extract good from the excess
of evil," l and presently France would fall back helpless into the
hands of her legitimate masters. So they thought. And the
royalists did more than this. They backed the election of a Jaco-
bin as Mayor of Paris. It was about as clever as if a man brought
home a hungry tiger to convince his wife of her need of him.
i Wiriath.
REPUBLICS OF AMERICA AND FRANCE 327
There stood another body ready at hand with which these royalists
did not reckon, far better equipped than the court to step in and
take the place of an ineffective Legislative Assembly, and that was
the strongly Jacobin Commune of Paris installed at the H6tel de
Ville.
So far France had been at peace. None of her neighbours had
attacked her, because she appeared to be weakening herself by her
internal dissensions. It was Poland that suffered by the distrac-
tion of France. But there seemed no reason why they should not
insult and threaten her, and prepare the way for a later partition
at their convenience. At Pillnitz, in 1791, the King of Prussia
and the Emperor of Austria met, and issued a declaration 1 that the
restoration of order and monarchy in France was a matter of
interest to all sovereigns. And an army of emigre's, French nobles
and gentlemen, an army largely of officers, was allowed to accu-
mulate close to the frontier.
It was France that declared war against Austria. The mo-
tives of those who supported this step were conflicting. Many
republicans wanted it because they wished to see the kindred
people of Belgium liberated from the Austrian yoke. Many
royalists wanted it because they saw in war a possibility of restor-
ing the prestige of the crown. Marat opposed it bitterly in his
paper L'Ami du Peuple, because he did not want to see republican
enthusiasm turned into war fever. His instinct warned him of
Napoleon. On April 20th, 1792, the king came down to the As-
sembly and proposed war amidst great applause.
The war began disastrously. Three French armies entered
Belgium, two were badly beaten, and the third, under Lafayette,
retreated. Then Prussia declared war in support of Austria, and
the allied forces, under the Duke of Brunswick, prepared to invade
France. The duke issued one of the most foolish proclamations
in history; he was, he said, invading France to restore the royal
1 The Declaration of Pillnitz was a diplomatic demarche that failed. Great
Britain had definitely refused to intervene in favour of the French monarchy, and
Austrian statesmanship proposed to save the collective face of European mon-
archy by a sounding announcement of sympathy with the French Bourbons, fol-
lowed by a proviso that unanimity should be secured before' intervention waa
ftttempted. French opinion (and most historians) concentrated on the announce-
ment and overlooked the proviso. — P. G.
328 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
authority. Any further indignity shown the king he threatened
to visit upon the Assembly and Paris with " military execution."
This was surely enough to make the most royalist Frenchman a
republican — at least for the duration of the war.
The new phase of revolution, the Jacobin revolution, was the
direct outcome of this proclamation. It made the Legislative
Assembly, in which orderly republicans (Girondins) and royalists
prevailed, it made the government which had put down that re-
publican meeting in the Champ de Mars and hunted Marat into
the sewers, impossible. The insurgents gathered at the Hotel de
Ville, and on the tenth of August^he Commune launched an attack
on the palace of the Tuileries.
The king behaved with a clumsy stupidity, and with that dis-
regard for others which is the prerogative of kings. He had
with him a Swiss guard of nearly a thousand men as well as Na-
tional Guards of uncertain loyalty. He held out vaguely until
firing began, and then he went off to the adjacent Assembly to
place himself and his family under its protection, leaving his Swiss
fighting. No doubt he hoped to antagonize Assembly and Com-
mune, but the Assembly had none of the fighting spirit of the
Hotel de Ville. The royal refugees were placed in a box reserved
for journalists (out of which a small room opened), and there they
remained for sixteen hours while the Assembly debated their fate.
Outside there were the sounds of a considerable battle; every
now and then a window would break. The unfortunate Swiss
were fighting with their backs to the wall because there was now
nothing else for them to do. . . .
" The Assembly had no stomach to back the government's action
of July in the Champ de Mars. The fierce vigour of the Com-
mune dominated it. The king found no comfort whatever in the
Assembly. It scolded him and discussed his ''suspension." The
Swiss fought until they received a message from the king to desist,
and then — the crowd being savagely angry at the needless blood-
shed and out of control — they were for the most part massacred.
The long and tedious attempt to " Merovingianize " Louis, to
make an honest crowned republican out of a dull and inadaptable
absolute monarch, was now drawing to its tragic close. The
Commune of Paris was practically in control of France. The
REPUBLICS OF AMERICA AND FRANCE 329
Legislative Assembly — which had apparently undergone a change
of heart — decreed that the king was suspended from his office,
confined him in the Temple, replaced him by an executive com-
mission, and summoned a National Convention to frame a new
constitution.
The tension of patriotic and republican France was now becom-
ing intolerable. Such armies as she had were rolling back help-
lessly toward Paris. Longwy had fallen, the great fortress of
Verdun followed, and nothing seemed likely to stop the march of
the allies upon the capital. The sense of royalist treachery rose
to panic cruelty. At any rate the royalists had to be silenced
and stilled and scared out of sight. The Commune set itself to
hunt out every royalist that could be found, until the prisons of
Paris were full. Danton incited the crowd against the prisoners,
Marat saw the danger of a massacre. Before it was too late
Marat tried to secure the establishment of emergency tribunals to
filter the innocent from the guilty in this miscellaneous collection
of schemers, suspects, and harmless gentlefolk. He was disre^
garded, and early in September the inevitable massacre occurred.
Suddenly, first at one prison and then at others, bands of in-
surgents took possession. A sort of rough court was constituted,
and outside gathered a wild mob armed with sabres, pikes, and
axes. One by one the prisoners, men and women alike, were led
out from their cells, questioned briefly, pardoned with the cry of
"Vive la Nation," or thrust out to the mob at the gates. There
the crowd jostled and fought to get a slash or thrust at a victim.
The condemned were stabbed, hacked, and beaten to death, their
heads hewn off, stuck on pikes, and carried about the town, their
torn bodies thrust aside. Among others, the Princesse de Lam-
balle, whom the king and queen had left behind in the Tuileries,
perished. Her head was carried on a pike to the Temple for the
queen to see.
In the queen's cell were two National Guards. One would
have had her look out and see this grisly sight. The other, in
pity, would not let her do so.
Even as this red tragedy was going on in Paris, the French gen-
eral Dumouriez, who had rushed an army from Flanders into the
forests of the Argonne, was holding up the advance of the allies
330
THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
beyond Verdun. On September 20th occurred a battle, mainly
an artillery encounter, at Valmy. A not very resolute Prussian
advance was checked,1 the French infantry stood firm, their
artillery was better than the allied artillery. For ten days after
this repulse the Duke of Brunswick hesitated, and then he began
to fall back towards the Rhine. This battle at Valmy — it was
*Nbrth lEasterti Frontier
TRANCE-
snc'anwg'&ie -nuZtfaro position
little more than a cannonade — was one of the decisive battles
in the world's history. The Revolution was saved. The National
Convention met on September 21st, 1792, and immediately pro-
claimed a republic. The trial and execution of the king followed
with a sort of logical necessity upon these things. He died rather
as a symbol than as a man. There was nothing else to be done
with him ; poor man, he cumbered the earth. France could not
1 The sour grapes of Champagne spread dysentery In the Prussian army. P. G.
REPUBLICS OF AMERICA AND FRANCE 331
let him go to hearten the emigrants, could not keep him harmless
at home; his existence threatened her. Marat had urged this
trial relentlessly, yet with that acid clearness of his he would not
have the king charged with any offence committed before he signed
the constitution, because before then he was a real monarch, super-
legal, and so incapable of being illegal. Nor would Marat permit
attacks upon the king's counsel. . . . Throughout Marat played
a bitter and yet often a just part ; he was a great man, a fine intel-
ligence, in a skin of fire ; wrung with that organic hate in the blood
that is not a product of the mind but of the body.
Louis was beheaded in January, 1793. He was guillotined —
for since the previous August the guillotine had been in use as the
official instrument in French executions.
Danton, in his leonine role, was very fine upon this occasion.
"The kings of Europe would challenge us," he roared. "We
throw them the head of a king!"
§n
And now followed a strange phase in the history of the French
people. There arose a great flame of enthusiasm for France and
the Republic. There was to be an end to compromise at home
and abroad ; at home royalists and every form of disloyalty were
to be stamped out; abroad France was to be the protector and
helper of all revolutionaries. All Europe, all the world, was to
become republican. The youth of France poured into the Re-
publican armies ; a new and wonderful song spread through the
land, a song that still warms the blood like wine, the Marseillaise.
Before that chant and the leaping columns of French bayonets
and their enthusiastically served guns the foreign armies rolled
back ; before the end of 1792 the French armies had gone far be-
yond the utmost achievements of Louis XIV; everywhere they
stood on foreign soil. They were in Brussels, they had overrun
Savoy, they had raided to Mayence ; they had seized the Scheldt
from Holland. Then the French Government did an unwise thing.
It had been exasperated by the expulsion of its representative
from England upon the execution of Louis, and it declared war
against England. It was an unwise thing to do, because the revolu-
tion which had given France a new enthusiastic infantry and a
332 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
brilliant artillery, released from its aristocratic officers and many
cramping traditions,1 had destroyed the discipline of its navy, and
the English were supreme upon the sea. And this provocation
united all England against France, whereas there had been at
first a very considerable liberal movement in Great Britain in
sympathy with the revolution. It robbed France of her one
prospective ally.2
Of the fight that France made in the next few years against a
European coalition we cannot tell in any detail. She drove the
Austrians for ever out of Belgium, and made Holland a republic.
The Dutch fleet, frozen in the Texel, surrendered to a handful of
cavalry without firing its guns. For some time the French thrust
towards Italy was hung up, and it was only in 1796 that a new
general, Napoleon Bonaparte, led the ragged and hungry repub-
lican armies in triumph across Piedmont to Mantua and Verona.
An Outline of History cannot map out campaigns ; but of the new
quality that had come into war, it is bound to take note. The
old professional armies had fought for the fighting, as slack as
workers paid by the hour; these wonderful new armies fought
hungry and thirsty, for victory. Their enemies called them the
"New French." Says C. F. Atkinson,3 "What astonished the
Allies most of all was the number and the velocity of the Re-
publicans. These improvised armies had in fact nothing to delay
them. Tents were unprocurable for want of money, untransport-
able for want of the enormous number of wagons that would have
been required, and also unnecessary, for the discomfort that
would have caused wholesale desertion in professional armies was
cheerfully borne by the men of 1793-4. Supplies for armies of
then unheard-of size could not be carried in convoys, and the
French soon became familiar with 'living on the country/ Thus
1793 saw the birth of the modern system of war — rapidity of
1 The intelligence of the French army of the Revolution was largely due to a
period of intelligent military thinking and writing which set in among French
soldiers after the defeats of the army of Louis XV in the Seven Years War. Napo-
leon himself was full of traces of this inspiration. — P. G.
2 1 cannot agree that England was ever, at any moment, "a prospective ally"
of France. There was a deep divergence of interests ; and it is impossible to think
of Pitt and the Whig nobles being in any way the allies of th« France of 1793. —
E. B.
8 In his article, "French Revolutionary Wars," in the Encyclopedia Britannica.
REPUBLICS OF AMERICA AND FRANCE 333
movement, full development of national strength, bivouacs, req-
uisitions and force as against cautious manoeuvring, small pro-
fessional armies, tents and full rations, and chicane. The first
represented the decision-compelling spirit, the second the spirit
of risking little to gain a little. . . ."
And while these ragged hosts of enthusiasts were chanting the
Marseillaise and fighting for la France, manifestly never quite
clear in their minds whether they were looting or liberating the
countries into which they poured, the republican enthusiasm in
Paris was spending itself in a far less glorious fashion. Marat,
the one man of commanding intelligence among the Jacobins, was
now frantic with an incurable disease, and presently he was mur-
dered ; Danton was a series of patriotic thunderstorms ; the stead-
fast fanaticism of Robespierre dominated the situation. This man
is difficult to judge; he was a man of poor physique, naturally
timid, and a prig. But he had that most necessary gift for power,
faith. He believed not in a god familiar to men, but in a certain
Supreme Being, and that Rousseau was his prophet. He set him-
self to save the Republic as he conceived it, and he imagined it
could be saved by no other man than he. So that to keep in power
was to save the. republic. The living spirit of the republic, it
seemed, had sprung from a slaughter of royalists and the execu-
tion of the king. There were insurrections : one in the west, in
the district of La Vende*e, where the people rose against the con-
scription and against the dispossession of the orthodox clergy, and
were led by noblemen and priests ; one in the south, where Lyons
and Marseilles had risen and the royalists of Toulon had admitted
an English and Spanish garrison. To which there seemed no more
effectual reply than to go on killing royalists.
Nothing could have better pleased the fierce heart of the Paris
slums. The Revolutionary Tribunal went to work, and a steady
slaughtering began.1 The invention of the guillotine was oppor-
tune to this mood. The queen was guillotined, most of Robes-
pierre's antagonists were guillotined, atheists who argued that
there was no Supreme Being were guillotined, Danton was guillo-
tined because he thought there was too much guillotine ; day by
1 In the thirteen months before June, 1794, there were 1220 executions ; in the
following seven weeks there were 1376. — P. G.
334 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
day, week by week, this infernal new machine chopped off heads
and more heads and more. The reign of Robespierre lived, it
seemed, on blood, and needed more and more, as an opium-taker
needs more and more opium.
Danton was still Danton, leonine and exemplary upon the guil-
lotine. "Danton," he said, "no weakness!"
And the grotesque thing about the story is that Robespierre was
indubitably honest. He was far more honest than any of the
group of men who succeeded him. He was inspired by a consum-
ing passion for a new order of human life. So far as he could
contrive it, the Committee of Public Safety, the emergency gov-
ernment of twelve which had now thrust aside the Convention,
constructed. The scale on which it sought to construct was stu-
pendous. All the intricate problems with which we still struggle
to-day were met by swift and shallow solutions. Attempts were
made to equalize property. "Opulence," said St. Just, "is in-
famous." The property of the rich was taxed or confiscated in
order that it should be divided among the poor. Every man was
to have a secure house, a living, a wife and children. The la-
bourer was worthy of his hire, but not entitled to an advantage.
There was an attempt to abolish profit altogether, the rude incen-
tive of most human commerce since the beginning of society.
Profit is the economic riddle that still puzzles us to-day. There
were harsh laws against "profiteering" in France in 1793 —
England in 1919 found it necessary to make quite similar laws.
And the Jacobin government not only replanned — in eloquent
outline — the economic, but also the social system. Divorce was
made as easy as marriage ; the distinction of legitimate and ille-
gitimate children was abolished. . . . A new calendar was devised,
with new names for the months, a week of ten days, and the like—
that has long since been swept away ; but also the clumsy coinage
and the tangled weights and measures of old France gave place
to the simple and lucid decimal system that still endures. . . .
There was a proposal from one extremist group to abolish God
among other institutions altogether, and to substitute the worship
of Reason. There was, indeed, a Feast of Reason in the cathedral
of Notre-Dame, with a pretty actress as the goddess of Reason.
But against this Robespierre set his face; he was no atheist.
REPUBLICS OF AMERICA AND FRANCE 335
" Atheism," he said, "is aristocratic. The idea of a Supreme
Being who watches over oppressed innocence and punishes tri-
umphant crime is essentially the idea of the people."
So he guillotined Hubert, who had celebrated the Feast of Reason,
and all his party.
A certain mental disorder became perceptible in Robespierre
as the summer of 1794 drew on. He was deeply concerned with
his religion. (The arrests and executions of suspects were going
on now as briskly as ever. Through the streets of Paris every day
rumbled the Terror with its carts full of condemned people.) He
induced the Convention to decree that France believed in a Su-
preme Being, and in that comforting doctrine, the immortality
of the soul. In June he celebrated a great festival, the festival of
his Supreme Being. There was a procession to the Champ de
Mars, which he headed, brilliantly arrayed, bearing a great bunch
of flowers and wheat ears. Figures of inflammatory material,
representing Atheism and Vice, were solemnly burnt; then, by
an ingenious mechanism, and with some slight creakings, an in-
combustible statue of Wisdom rose in their place. There were
discourses — Robespierre delivered the chief one — but appar-
ently no worship. . . .
Thereafter Robespierre displayed a disposition to brood aloof
from affairs. For a month he kept away from the Convention.
One day in July he reappeared and delivered a strange speech
that clearly foreshadowed fresh prosecutions. "Gazing on the
multitude of vices which the torrent of Revolution has rolled
down/' he cried, in his last great speech in the Convention, "I
have sometimes trembled lest I should be soiled by the impure
neighbourhood of wicked men. ... I know that it is easy for
the leagued tyrants of the world to overwhelm a single individual ;
but I know also what is the duty of a man who can die in the de-
fence of humanity." . . .
And so on to vague utterances that seemed to threaten everyone.
The Convention heard this speech in silence ; then when a pro-
posal was made to print and circulate it, broke into a resentful up-
roar and refused permission. Robespierre went off in bitter resent-
ment to the club of his supporters, and reread his speech to them !
That night was full of talk and meetings and preparations for
336 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
the morrow, and the next morning the Convention turned upon
Robespierre. One Tallien threatened him with a dagger. When
he tried to speak, he was shouted down, and the President jingled
the bell at him. "President of Assassins," cried Robespierre, "I
demand speech !" It was refused him. His voice deserted him ;
he coughed and spluttered. "The blood of Danton chokes him,"
cried someone.
He was accused and arrested there and then with his chief
supporters.
Whereupon the Hotel de Ville, still stoutly Jacobin, rose against
the Convention, and Robespierre and his companions were
snatched out of the hands of their captors. There was a night
of gathering, marching, counter-marching ; and at last, about three
in the morning, the forces of the Convention faced the forces of the
Commune outside the Hotel de Ville. Henriot, the Jacobin com-
mander, after a busy day was drunk upstairs; a parley ensued,
and then, after some indecision, the soldiers of the Commune
went over to the Government. There was a shouting of patriotic
sentiments, and someone looked out from the H6tel de Ville.
Robespierre and his last companions found themselves betrayed
and trapped.
Two or three of these men threw themselves out of a window,
and injured themselves frightfully on the railings below without
killing themselves. Others attempted suicide. Robespierre, it
seems, was shot in the lower jaw by a gendarme. He was found,
his eyes staring from a pale face whose lower part was blood.
Followed seventeen hours of agony before his end. He spoke
never a word during that time ; his jaw being bound up roughly
in dirty linen. He and his companions, and the broken, dying
bodies of those who had jumped from the windows, twenty-two
men altogether, were taken to the guillotine instead of the con-
demned appointed for that day. Mostly, his eyes were closed, but,
says Carlyle, he opened them to see the great knife rising above
him, and struggled. Also it would seem he screamed when the
executioner removed his bandages. Then the knife came down,
swift and merciful.
The Terror was at an end. From first to last there had been
condemned and executed about four thousand people.
REPUBLICS OF AMERICA AND FRANCE 337
§12
It witnesses to the immense vitality and the profound lightness
of the flood of new ideals and intentions that the French Revo-
lution had released into the world of practical endeavour, that it
could still flow in a creative torrent after it had been caricatured
and mocked in the grotesque personality and career of Robespierre.
He had shown its deepest thoughts, he had displayed anticipa-
tions of its methods and conclusions, through the green and dis-
torting lenses of his preposterous vanity and egotism, he had
smeared and blackened all its hope and promise with blood and
horror, and the power of these ideas was not destroyed. They
stood the extreme tests of ridiculous and horrible presentation.
After his downfall, the Republic still ruled unassailable. Leader-
less, for his successors were a group of crafty or commonplace men,
the European republic struggled on, and presently fell and rose
again, and fell and rose and still struggles, entangled but invincible.
And it is well to remind the reader here of the real dimensions
of this phase of the Terror, which strikes so vividly upon the
imagination and which has therefore been enormously exaggerated
relatively to the rest of the revolution. From 1789 to late in 1791
the French Revolution was an orderly process, and from the sum-
mer of 1794 the Republic was an orderly and victorious state.
The Terror was not the work of the whole country, but of the
town mob which owed its existence and its savagery to the misrule
and social injustice of the ancient regime; and the explosion of
the Terror could have happened only through the persistent
treacherous disloyalty of the royalists which, while it raised the
extremists to frenzy, disinclined the mass of moderate republicans
from any intervention. The best men were busy fighting the
Austrians and royalists on the frontier. Altogether, we must
remember, the total of the killed in the Terror amounted to a few
thousands, and among those thousands there were certainly a
great number of active antagonists whom the Republic, by all the
standards of that time, was entitled to kill. It included such
traitors and mischief-makers as Philip, Duke of Orleans, of the
Palais Royal, who had voted for the death of Louis XVI. More
lives were wasted by the British generals alone on the opening day
338 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
of what is known as the Somme offensive of July, 1916, than in
the whole French revolution from start to finish. We hear so much
about the martyrs of the French Terror because they were notable,
well-connected people, and because there has been a sort of propa-
ganda of their sufferings. But let us balance against them in our
minds what was going on in the prisons of the world generally at
that time. In Britain and America, while the Terror ruled in
France, far more people were slaughtered for offences — very
often quite trivial offences — against property than were con-
demned by the Revolutionary Tribunal for treason against the
State. Of course, they were very common people indeed, but in
their rough way they suffered. A girl was hung in Massachusetts
in 1789 for forcibly taking the hat, shoes, and buckles of another
girl she had met in the street.1 Again, Howard the philanthropist
(about 1773) found a number of perfectly innocent people de-
tained in the English prisons who had been tried and acquitted,
but were unable to pay the gaoler's fees. And these prisons were
filthy places under no effective control. Torture was still in use
in the Hanoverian dominions of his Britannic majesty King George
III. It had been in use in France up to the time of the National
Assembly. These things mark the level of the age. It is not on
record that anyone was deliberately tortured by the French revo-
lutionaries during the Terror. Those few hundreds of French
gentlefolk fell into a pit that most of them had been well content
should exist for others. It was tragic, but not, by the scale of
universal history, a great tragedy. The common man in France
was more free, better off, and happier during the "Terror" than
he had been in 1787.
The story of the Republic after the summer of 1794 becomes
a tangled story of political groups aiming at everything from a
radical republic to a royalist reaction, but pervaded by a general
desire for some definite working arrangement even at the price of
considerable concessions. There was a series of insurrections of
the Jacobins and of the royalists, there seems to have been what
we should call nowadays a hooligan class in Paris which was quite
ready to turn out to fight and loot on either side ; nevertheless the
Convention produced a government, the Directory of five members,
1 Channing, vol. iii., chap, xviii.
REPUBLICS OF AMERICA AND FRANCE 339
which held France together for five years. The last, most threat-
ening revolt of all, in October, 1795, was suppressed with great
skill and decision by a rising young general, Napoleon Bonaparte.
The Directory was victorious abroad, but uncreative at home ;
its members were far too anxious to stick to the sweets and glories
of office to prepare a constitution that would supersede them,
and far too dishonest to handle the task of financial and economic
reconstruction demanded by the condition of France. We need
only note two of their names, Carnot, who was an honest repub-
lican, and Barras, who was conspicuously a rogue. Their reign
of five years formed a curious interlude in this history of great
changes. They took things as they found them. The propa-
gandist zeal of the revolution carried the French armies into
Holland, Belgium, Switzerland, south Germany, and north Italy.
Everywhere kings were expelled and republics set up. But such
propagandist zeal as animated the Directorate did not prevent the
looting of the treasures of the liberated peoples to relieve the
financial embarrassment of the French Government. Their wars
became less and less the holy war of freedom, and more and more
like the aggressive wars of the ancient regime. The last feature
of Grand Monarchy that France was disposed to discard was her
tradition of foreign policy, grasping, aggressive, restless, French-
centred. One discovers it still as vigorous under the Directorate
as if there had been no revolution.
§13
The ebb of this tide of Revolution in the world, this tide which
had created the great Republic of America and threatened to sub-
merge all European monarchies, was now at hand. It is as if
something had thrust up from beneath the surface of human
affairs, made a gigantic effort, and spent itself. It swept many
obsolescent and evil things away, but many evil and unjust things
remained. It solved many problems, and it left the desire for
fellowship and order face to face with much vaster problems that
it seemed only to have revealed. Privilege of certain types had
gone, many tyrannies, much religious persecution. When these
things of the ancient regime had vanished, it seemed as if they
had never mattered. What did matter was that for all their votes
340 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
and enfranchisement, and in spite of all their passion and effort,
common men were still not free and not enjoying an equal happi-
ness; that the immense promise and air of a new world with
which the Revolution had come, remained unfulfilled.
Yet, after all, this wave of revolution had realized nearly every-
thing that had been clearly thought out before it came. It was
not failing now for want of impetus, but for want of finished ideas.
Many things that had oppressed mankind were swept away for
ever. Now that they were swept away it became apparent how
unprepared men were for the creative opportunities this clearance
gave them. And periods of revolution are periods of action ; in
them men reap the harvests of ideas that have grown during
phases of interlude, and they leave the fields cleared .for a new
season of growth, but they cannot suddenly produce ripened new
ideas to meet an unanticipated riddle.
The sweeping away of king and lord, of priest and inquisitor,
of landlord and tax-gatherer and task-master, left the mass of men
face to face for the first time with certain very fundamental aspects
of the social structure, relationships they had taken for granted,
and had never realized the need of thinking hard and continuously
about before. Institutions that had seemed to be in the nature of
things, and matters that had seemed to happen by the same sort of
necessity that brought round the dawn and springtime, were dis-
covered to be artificial, controllable, were they not so perplexingly
intricate, and — now that the old routines were abolished and done
away with — in urgent need of control. The New ;0rder found
itself confronted with three riddles which it was quite unprepared
to solve : Property, Currency, and International Relationship.
Let us take these three problems in order, and ask what they are
and how they arose in human affairs. Every human life is deeply
entangled in them, and concerned in their solution. The rest of
this history becomes more and more clearly the development of
the effort to solve these problems ; that is to say, so to interpret
property, so to establish currency, and so to control international
reactions as to render possible a world-wide, progressive and
happy community of will. They are the three riddles of the
sphinx of fate, to which the human commonweal must find an
answer or perish.
REPUBLICS OF AMERICA AND FRANCE 341
The idea of property arises out of the combative instincts of
the species. Long before men were men, the ancestral ape was
a proprietor. Primitive property is what a beast will fight for.
The dog and his bone, the tigress and her lair, the roaring stag
and his herd, these are proprietorship blazing. No more non-
sensical expression is conceivable in sociology than the term
" primitive communism." The Old Man of the family tribe of
early palaeolithic times insisted upon his proprietorship in his
wives and daughters, in his tools, in his visible universe. If any
other man wandered into his visible universe he fought him, and if
he could he slew him. The tribe grew in the course of ages, as
Atkinson showed convincingly in his Primal Law, by the gradual
toleration by the Old Man of the existence of the younger men,
and of their proprietorship in the wives they captured from out-
side the tribe, and in the tools and ornaments they made and the
game they slew. Human society grew by a compromise between
this one's property and that. It was largely a compromise and an
alliance forced upon men by the necessity of driving some other
tribe out of its visible universe. If the hills and forests and streams
were not your land or my land, it was because they had to be our
land. Each of us would have preferred to have it my land, but
that would not work. In that case the other fellows would have
destroyed us. Society, therefore, is from its beginnings the miti-
gation of ownership. Ownership in the beast and in the primi-
tive savage was far more intense a thing than it is in the civilized
world to-day. It is rooted more strongly hi our instincts than in
our reason.
In the natural savage and in the untutored man to-day — for
it is well to keep in mind that no man to-day is more than four
hundred generations from the primordial savage — there is no
limitation to the sphere of ownership. , Whatever you can fight
for, you can own; women-folk, spared captive, captured beast,
forest glade, stone pit, or what not. As the community grew and
a sort of law came to restrain internecine fighting, men developed
rough and ready methods of settling proprietorship. Men could
own what they were the first to make or capture or claim. It
seemed natural that a debtor who could not pay up should become
the property of his creditor. Equally natural was it that, after
342 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
claiming a patch of land ("Bags I," as the schoolboy says), a man
should exact payments and tribute from anyone else who wanted
to use it. It was only slowly, as the possibilities of organized life
dawned on men, that this unlimited property in anything what-
ever began to be recognized as a nuisance. Men found themselves
born into a universe all owned and claimed, nay! they found
themselves born, owned, and claimed. The secial struggles of
the earlier civilization are difficult to trace now, but the history we
have told of the Roman republic shows a community waking up
to the idea that they may become a public inconvenience and
should then be repudiated, and that the unlimited ownership of
land is also an inconvenience. We find that later Babylonia
severely limited the rights of property in slaves. Finally, we
find in the teaching of that great revolutionist, Jesus of Nazareth,
such an attack upon property as had never been before. Easier
it was, he said, for a camel to go through the eye of a needle than
for the owner of great possessions to enter the kingdom of heaven.
A steady, continuous criticism of the permissible scope of property
seems to have been going on in the world for the last twenty-five
or thirty centuries. Nineteen hundred years after Jesus of Naza-
reth we find all the world that has come under the Christian
teaching persuaded that there could be no property in persons.
There has been a turn over in the common conscience in that mat-
ter. And also the idea that "a man may do what he likes with his
own" was clearly very much shaken in relation to other sorts of
property. But this world of the closing eighteenth century was
still only in the interrogative stage in this matter. It had got
nothing clear enough, much less settled enough, to act upon. One
of its primary impulses was to protect property against the greed
and waste of kings and the exploitation of noble adventurers. It
was to protect private property that the Revolution began. But
its equalitarian formulae carried it into a criticism of the very
property it had risen to protect. How can men be free and equal
when numbers of them have no ground to stand upon and nothing
to eat, and the owners will neither feed nor lodge them unless they
toil? Excessively — the poor complained.
To which riddle the Jacobin reply was to set about "dividing
up." They wanted to intensify and universalize property. Aim-
REPUBLICS OF AMERICA AND FRANCE 343
ing at the same end by another route, there were already in the
eighteenth century certain primitive socialists — or, to be more
exact, communists — who wanted to " abolish" private property
altogether. The state (a democratic state was of course under-
stood) was to own all property. It was only as the nineteenth
century developed that men began to realize that property was not
one simple thing, but a great complex of ownerships of different
values and consequences, that many things (such as human
beings, the implements of an artist, clothing, toothbrushes) are
very profoundly and incurably personal property, and that there
is a very great range of things, railways, machinery of various
sorts, homes, cultivated gardens,' pleasure-boats/f or example, which
need each to be considered very particularly to determine how
far and under what limitations it may come under private owner-
ship, and how far it falls into the public domain and may be adminis-
tered and let out by the state in the collective interest. On the
practical side these questions pass into politics, and the problem
of making and sustaining efficient state administration. They
open up issues in social psychology, and interact with the en-
quiries of educational science. We have to-day the advantage of a
hundred and thirty years of discussion over the first revolutionary
generation, but even now this criticism of property is still a vast
and passionate ferment rather than a science. Under the circum-
stances it was impossible that eighteenth-century France should
present any other spectacle than that of vague and confused popu-
lar movements seeking to dispossess owners, and classes of small
and large owners holding on grimly, demanding, before everything
else, law, order, and security, and seeking to increase their indi-
vidual share of anything whatever that could be legally possessed.
Closely connected with the vagueness of men's ideas about prop-
erty was the vagueness of their ideas about currency. Both the
American and the French republics fell into serious trouble upon
this score. Here, again, we deal with something that is not simple,
a tangle of usages, conventions, laws, and prevalent mental habits,
out of which arise problems which admit of no solution in simple
terms, and which yet are of vital importance to the everyday life
of the community. The validity of the acknowledgement a man
is given for a day's work is manifestly of quite primary importance
344 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
to the working of the social machine. The growth of confidence
in the precious metals and of coins, until the assurance became
practically universal that good money could be trusted to have its
purchasing power anywhere, must have been a gradual one in
human history. And being fairly established, this assurance was
subjected to very considerable strains and perplexities by the
action of governments in debasing currency and in substituting
paper promises to pay for the actual metallic coins. Every age
produced a number of clever people intelligent enough to realize
the opportunities for smart operations afforded by the complex
of faiths and fictions upon which the money system rested, and
sufficiently unsound morally to give their best energies to growing
rich and so getting people to work for them, through tricks and
tampering with gold, coinage, and credit. So soon as serious
political and social dislocation occurred, the money mechanism
began to work stiffly and inaccurately. The United States and
the French Republic both started their careers in a phase of
financial difficulty. Everywhere governments had been borrow-
ing and issuing paper promises to pay interest, more interest than
they could conveniently raise. Both revolutions led to much
desperate public spending and borrowing, and at the same time
to an interruption of cultivation and production that further
diminished real taxable wealth. Both governments, being unable
to pay their way in gold, resorted to the issue of paper money,
promising to pay upon the security of undeveloped land (in Amer-
ica) or recently confiscated church lands (France). In both cases
the amount of issue went far beyond the confidence of men in the
new security. Gold was called in, hidden by the cunning ones,
or went abroad to pay for imports ; and people found themselves
with various sorts of bills and notes in the place of coins, all of
uncertain and diminishing value.
However complicated the origins of currency, its practical
effect and the end it has to serve in the community may be stated
roughly in simple terms. The money a man receives for his work
(mental or bodily) or for relinquishing his property in some con-
sumable good, must ultimately be able to purchase for him
for his use a fairly equivalent amount of consumable goods.
(''Consumable goods" is a phrase we would have understood in
REPUBLICS OF AMERICA AND FRANCE 345
the widest sense to represent even such things as a journey, a
lecture or theatrical entertainment, housing, medical advice, and
so forth.) When everyone in a community is assured of this, and
assured that the money will not deteriorate in purchasing power,
then currency — and the distribution of goods by trade — is in a
healthy and satisfactory state. Then men will work cheerfully,
and only then. The imperative need for that steadfastness and
security of currency is the fixed datum from which the scientific
study and control of currency must begin. But under the most
stable conditions there will always be fluctuations in currency
value. The sum total of saleable consumable goods in the world
and in various countries varies from year to year and from season
to season; autumn is probably a time of plenty in comparison
with spring ; with an increase the purchasing power of currency will
increase, unless there is also an increase in the amount of cur-
rency. On the other hand, if there is a diminution in the produc-
tion of consumable goods or a great and unprofitable destruction
of consumable goods, such as occurs in a war, the share of the
total of consumable goods represented by a sum of money will
diminish and prices and wages will rise. In modern war the ex-
plosion of a single big shell, even if it hits nothing, destroys labour
and material roughly equivalent to a comfortable cottage or a
year's holiday for a man. If the shell hits anything, ' then that
further destruction has to be added to the diminution of consum-
able goods. Every shell that burst in the recent war diminished
by a little fraction the purchasing value of every coin in the whole
world. If there is also an increase of currency during a period
when consumable goods are being used up and not fully replaced —
and the necessities of revolutionary and war-making governments
almost always require this — then the enhancement of prices
and the fall in the value of the currency paid in wages is still
greater. Usually also governments under these stresses borrow
money, that is to say, they issue interest-bearing paper, secured
on the willingness and ability of the general community to endure
taxation. Such operations would be difficult enough if they were
carried out frankly by perfectly honest men, in the full light of
publicity and scientific knowledge. But hitherto this has never
been the case ; at every point the clever egotist, the bad rich man,
346 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
is trying to deflect things a little to his own advantage. Every-
where too one finds the stupid egotist ready to take fright and
break into panic. Consequently we presently discover the state
encumbered by an excess of currency, which is in effect a non-
interest-paying debt, and also with a great burthen of interest
upon loans. Both credit and currency begin to fluctuate wildly
with the evaporation of public confidence. They are, we say,
demoralized.
The ultimate consequence of an entirely demoralized currency
would be to end all work and all trade that could not be carried
'on by payment in kind and barter. Men would refuse to work
except for food, clothing, housing, and payment in kind. The im-
mediate consequence of a partially demoralized currency is to
drive up prices and make trading feverishly adventurous and
workers suspicious and irritable. A sharp man wants under such
conditions to hold money for as brief a period as possible; he
demands the utmost for his reality, and buys a reality again as
soon as possible in order to get this perishable stuff, the currency
paper, off his hands. All who have fixed incomes and saved
accumulations suffer by the rise in prices, and the wage-earners
find, with a gathering fury, that the real value of their wages is
continually less. Here is a state of affairs where the duty of every
clever person is evidently to help adjust and reassure. But all
the traditions of private enterprise, all the ideas of the later eight-
eenth century, went to justify the action of acute-minded and
dexterous people who set themselves to accumulate claims, titles,
and tangible property in the storms and dislocations of this cur-
rency breakdown. The number of understanding people in the
world who were setting themselves sincerely and simply to restore
honest and workable currency and credit conditions were few and
ineffectual. Most of the financial and speculative people of the
time were playing the part of Cornish wreckers — not apparently
with any conscious dishonesty, but with the completest self-
approval and the applause of their fellow men. The aim of every
clever person was to accumulate as much as he could of really
negotiable wealth, and then, and only then, to bring about some
sort of stabilizing political process that would leave him in advan-
tageous possession of his accumulation. Here were the factors
REPUBLICS OF AMERICA AND FRANCE 347
of a bad economic atmosphere, suspicious, feverish, greedy, and
speculative. . . .
In the third direction in which the Revolution had been unpre-
pared with clear ideas, the problem of international relationships,
developments were to occur that interacted disastrously with this
state of financial and economic adventure, this scramble and con-
fusion, this pre-occupation of men's minds with the perplexing
slipperiness of their private property and their monetary position
at home. The Republic at its birth found itself at war. For a
time that war was waged by the new levies with a patriotism and a
zeal unparalleled in the world's history. But that could not go on.
The Directory found itself at the head of a conquering country,
intolerably needy and embarrassed at home, and in occupation cf
rich foreign lands, full of seizable wealth and material and financial
opportunity. We have all double natures, and the French in par-
ticular seem to be developed logically and symmetrically on both
sides. Into these conquered regions France came as a liberator,
the teacher of Republicanism to mankind. Holland and Belgium
became the Batavian Republic, Genoa and its Riviera the Ligurian
Republic, north Italy the Cisalpine Republic, Switzerland was
rechristened the Helvetian Republic, Mtilhausen, Rome, and
Naples were designated republics. Grouped about France, these
republics were to be a constellation of freedom leading the world.
That was the ideal side. At the same time the French government,
and French private individuals in concert with the government,
proceeded to a complete and exhaustive exploitation of the resources
of these liberated lands.
So within ten years of the meeting of the States General, New
France begins to take on a singular likeness to the old. It is more
flushed, more vigorous; it wears a cap of liberty instead of a
crown; it has a new army — but a damaged fleet; it has new
rich people instead of the old rich people, a new peasantry working
even harder than the old and yielding more taxes, a new foreign
policy curiously like the old foreign policy disrobed, and — there is
no Millennium.
XXXVIII
THE CAREER OF NAPOLEON BONAPARTE1
§ 1. The Bonaparte Family in Corsica. § 2. Bonaparte as a
Republican General § 3. Napoleon First Consul, 1799-1804.
§ 4. Napoleon I, Emperor, 1804-14. § 5. The Hundred Days.
§ 6. The Cult of the Napoleonic. § 7. The Map of Europe in
1815.
§1
AND now we come to one of the most illuminating figures in
modern history, the figure of an adventurer and a wrecker,
whose story seems to display with an extraordinary vividness
the universal subtle conflict of egotism, vanity, and personality
with the weaker, wider claims of the common good. Against this
background of confusion and stress and hope, this strained and
heaving France and Europe, this stormy and tremendous dawn,
appears this dark little archaic personage, hard, compact, capable,
unscrupulous, imitative, and neatly vulgar. He was born (1769)
in the still half-barbaric island of Corsica, the son of a rather
prosaic father, a lawyer who had been first a patriotic Corsican
against the French monarchy which was trying to subjugate
Corsica, and who had then gone over to the side of the invader.
His mother was of sturdier stuff, passionately patriotic and a
strong and managing woman. (She birched her sons; on one
occasion she birched Napoleon when he was sixteen.) There were
numerous brothers and sisters, and the family pursued the French
1 Two very useful books have been Holland Rose's Personality of Napoleon
and his Life of Napoleon I. A compact and convenient biography, with good battle
maps, is R. M. Johnston's Napoleon. Thomas Hardy's great epic-drama, The
Dynasts, is a magnificent picture of Napoleon's career, historically very exact. It
is one of the great stars of English literature, too little known as yet to the general
public.
348
THE CAREER OF NAPOLEON BONAPARTE 349
authorities with importunities for rewards and jobs. Except for
Napoleon it seems to have been a thoroughly commonplace,
"hungry" family. He was clever, bad-tempered, and over-
bearing. From his mother he had acquired a romantic Corsican
patriotism.
Through the patronage of the French governor of Corsica he
got an education first at the military school of Brienne and then
at the military school of Paris, from which he passed into the
artillery in 1785. He was an industrious student both of mathe-
matics and history, his memory was prodigiously good, and he
made copious note-books which still exist. These note-books
show no very exceptional intelligence, and they contain short
pieces of original composition — upon suicide and similar ado-
lescent topics. He fell early under the spell of Rousseau; he
developed sensibility and a scorn for the corruptions of civiliza-
tion. In 1786 he wrote a pamphlet against a Swiss pastor who
had attacked Rousseau. It was a very ordinary adolescent pro-
duction, rhetorical and imitative. He dreamt of an independent
Corsica, freed from the French. With the revolution, he became
an ardent republican and a supporter of the new French regime in
Corsica. For some years, until the fall of Robespierre, he re-
mained a Jacobin.
§2
He soon gained the reputation of a useful and capable officer,
and it was through Robespierre's younger brother that he got his
first chance of distinction at Toulon. Toulon had been handed
over to the British and Spanish by the Royalists, and an allied
fleet occupied its harbour. Bonaparte was given the command
of the artillery, and under his direction the French forced the
allies to abandon the port and town.
He was next appointed commander of the artillery in Italy,
but he had not taken up his duties when the death of Robespierre
seemed likely to involve his own; he was put under arrest as a
Jacobin, and for a time he was in danger of the guillotine. That
danger passed. He was employed as artillery commander in an
abortive raid upon Corsica, and then went to Paris (1795) rather
down at heel. Madame Junot in her Memoirs describes his lean
350 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
face and slovenly appearance at this time, "his ill-combed, ill-
powdered hair hanging down over his grey overcoat," his gloveless
hands and badly blacked boots. It was a time of exhaustion and
reaction after the severities of the Jacobite republic. "In Paris,"
says Holland Rose, "the star of Liberty was paling before Mercury,
Mars, and Venus" — finance, uniforms, and social charm. The
best of the common men were in the armies, away beyond the
frontiers. We have already noted the last rising of the royalists
in this year (1795). Napoleon had the luck to be in Paris, and
found his second opportunity in this affair. He saved the Re-
public — of the Directory.
His abilities greatly impressed Carnot, the most upright of the
Directors. Moreover, he married a charming young widow,
Madame Josephine de Beauharnais, who had great influence with
Barras. Both these things probably helped him to secure the
command in Italy.
We have no space here for the story of his brilliant campaigns
in Italy (1796-7), but of the spirit in which that invasion of Italy
was conducted we must say a word or two, because it illustrates
so vividly the double soul of France and of Napoleon, and how
revolutionary idealism was paling before practical urgencies. He
proclaimed to the Italians that the French were coming to break
their chains — and they were! He wrote to the Directory: "We
will levy 20,000,000 francs in exactions in this country; it is one
of the richest in the world." To his soldiers he said, "You are
famished and nearly naked. ... I lead you into the most fertile
plain in the world. There you will find great towns, rich prov-
inces, honour, glory, riches. ..."
We are all such mixed stuff as this ; in all of us the intimations
of a new world and a finer duty struggle to veil and control the an-
cient greeds and lusts of our inherited past; but these passages,
, written by a young man of twenty-seven, seem to show the gilt
of honourable idealism rubbed off at an unusually early age.
These are the bribes of an adventurer who has brought whatever
impulse of devotion to a great cause once stirred within him, well
under the control of his- self love.
His successes in Italy were brilliant and complete; they enor-
mously stimulated his self-confidence and his contempt for the
THE CAREER OF NAPOLEON BONAPARTE 351
energy and ability of his fellow creatures. He had wanted to go
into Italy because there lay the most attractive task — he had
risked his position in the army by refusing to take up the irksome
duties of a command against the rebels in La Vendee — and there
are clear signs of a vast expansion of his vanity with his victories.
He had been a great reader of Plutarch's Lives and of Roman
history, and his extremely active but totally uncreative imagina-
tion was now busy with dreams of a revival of the eastern con-
quests of the Roman Empire. He got the republic of Venice out
of his way by cutting it up between the French and Austria, secur-
ing the Ionian Islands and the Venetian fleet for France. This
peace, the peace of Campo Formio, was for both sides a thoroughly
scoundrelly and ultimately a disastrous bargain. The new re-
public of France assisted in the murder of an ancient republic —
Napoleon carried his point against a considerable outcry in France
— and Austria got Venetia, in which land in 1918 she was des-
tined to bleed to death. There were also secret clauses by which
both France and Austria were later to acquire south German
territory. And it was not only the Roman push eastward that was
now exciting Napoleon's brain. This was the land of Caesar —
and Caesar was a bad example for the successful general of a not
very stable republic.
Caesar had come back to Rome from Gaul a hero and conqueror.
His new imitator would come back from Egypt and India —
Egypt and India were to be his Gaul. There was really none of
the genius about which historians write so glibly in this decision.
It was a tawdry and ill-conceived imitation. The elements of
failure stared him in the face. The way to Egypt and India was
by sea, and the British, in spite of two recent naval mutinies,
whose importance Napoleon exaggerated, were stronger than the
French at sea. Moreover, Egypt was a part of the Turkish em-
pire, by no means a contemptible power in those days. Never-
theless he persuaded the Directory, which was dazzled by his
Italian exploits, to let him go. An Armada started from Toulon
in May, 1798, captured Malta, and had the good luck to evade
the British fleet and arrive at Alexandria. He landed his troops
hurriedly, and the battle of the Pyramids made him master of
Egypt.
352
THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
The main British fleet at that time was in the Atlantic outside
Cadiz, but the admiral had detached a force of his best ships,
under Vice- Admiral Nelson — a man certainly as great a genius
in naval affairs as was Napoleon in things military — to chase
and engage the French flotilla.1 For a time Nelson sought the
French fleet in vain ; finally, on the evening of the first of August,
he found it at anchor in Aboukir Bay. He had caught it unawares ;
many of the men were ashore and a council was being held in the
flagship. He had no charts, and it was a hazardous thing to sail
into the shallow water in a bad light. The French admiral con-
cluded, therefore, that he would not attack before morning, and
so made no haste in recalling his men aboard until it was too late
to do so. Nelson struck at once — against the advice of some of
his captains. One ship only went aground. She marked the
shoal for the rest of the fleet. He sailed to the attack in a double
line about sundown, putting the French between two fires. Night
fell as the battle was joined ; the fight thundered and crashed in
the darkness, until it was lit presently by the flames of burning
French ships, and then by the flare of the French flag-ship, the
Orient, blowing up. . . . Before midnight the battle of the Nile
was over, and Napoleon's fleet was destroyed. Napoleon was
cut off from France.
1 See Mahan's Life of Nelson.
THE CAREER OF NAPOLEON BONAPARTE 353
Says Holland Rose, quoting Thiers, this Egyptian expedition
was "the rashest attempt history records." Napoleon was left
in Egypt with the Turks gathering against him and his army in-
fected with the plague. Nevertheless, with a stupid sort of per-
sistence, he went on for a time with this Eastern scheme. He
gained a victory at Jaffa, and, being short of provisions, massacred
all his prisoners. Then he tried to take Acre, where his own siege
artillery, just captured at sea by the English, was used against him.
Returning baffled to Egypt, he gained a brilliant victory over a
Turkish force at Aboukir, and then, deserting the army of Egypt
- it held on until 1801, when it capitulated to a British force —
made his escape back to France (1799), narrowly missing capture
by a British cruiser off Sicily.
Here was muddle and failure enough to discredit any general —
had it been known. But the very British cruisers which came so
near to catching him, helped him by preventing any real under-
standing of the Egyptian situation from reaching the French
people. He could make a great flourish over the battle of Aboukir
and conceal the shame and loss of Acre. Things were not going
well with France just then. There had been military failures at
several points; much of Italy had been lost, Bonaparte's Italy,
and this turned men's minds to him as the natural saviour of that
situation ; moreover, there had been much peculation, and some
of it was coming to light; France was in one of her phases of
financial scandal, and Napoleon had not filched ; the public was in
that state of moral fatigue when a strong and honest man is called
for, a wonderful, impossible healing man who will do everything
for everybody. People, poor lazy souls, persuaded themselves
that this specious young man with the hard face, so providentially
back from Egypt, was the strong and honest man required —
another Washington.
With Julius Caesar rather than Washington at the back of his
mind, Napoleon responded to the demand of his time. A con-
spiracy was carefully engineered to replace the Directory by three
"Consuls" — everybody seems to have been reading far too much
Roman history just then — of whom Napoleon was to be the chief.
The working of that conspiracy is too intricate a story for our
space ; it involved a Cromwell-like dispersal of the Lower House
2A
354 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
(the Council of Five Hundred), and in this affair Napoleon lost
his nerve. The deputies shouted at him and hustled him, and he
seems to have been very much frightened. He nearly fainted,
stuttered, and could say nothing, but the situation was saved
by his brother Lucien, who brought in the soldiers and dispersed
the council. This little hitch did not affect the final success of
the scheme. The three Consuls were installed at the Luxembourg
palace, with two commissioners, to reconstruct the constitution.
With all his confidence restored and sure of the support of the
people, who supposed him to be honest, patriotic, republican, and
able to bring about a good peace, Napoleon took a high hand with
his colleagues and the commissioners. A constitution was pro-
duced in which the chief executive officer was to be called the
First Consul, with enormous powers. He was to be Napoleon;
this was part of the constitution. He was to be re-elected or re-
placed at the end of ten years. He was to be assisted by a Council
of State, appointed by himself, which was to initiate legislation
and send its proposals to two bodies, the Legislative Body (which
could vote, but not discuss) and the Tribunate (which could dis-
cuss, but not vote), which were selected by an appointed Senate
from a special class, the "notabilities of France," who were elected
by the " notabilities of the departments," who were elected by
the " notabilities of the commune/' who were elected by the com-
mon voters. The suffrage for the election of the notabilities of
the commune was universal. This was the sole vestige of democ-
racy in the astounding pyramid. This constitution was chiefly
the joint production of a worthy philosopher Sieyes, who was one
of the three consuls, and Bonaparte. But so weary was France
with her troubles and efforts, and so confident were men in the
virtue and ability of this adventurer from Corsica, that when,
at the birth of the nineteenth century, this constitution was sub-
mitted to the country, it was carried by 3,011,007 votes to 1,562.
France put herself absolutely in Bonaparte's hands, and prepared
to be peaceful, happy, and glorious.
§3
Now surely here was opportunity such as never came to man
before. Here was a position in which a man might well bow himself
THE CAREER OF NAPOLEON BONAPARTE 355
in fear of himself, and search his heart and serve God and man to
the utmost. The old order of things was dead or dying ; strange
new forces drove through the world seeking form and direction ; the
promise of a world republic and an enduring world peace whispered
in a multitude of startled minds. Had this man any profundity of
vision, any power of creative imagination, had he been accessible
to any disinterested ambition, he might have done work for man-
kind that would have made him the very sun of history. All
Europe and America, stirred by the first promise of a new age,
was waiting for him. Not France alone. France was in his hand,
his instrument, to do with as he pleased, willing for peace, but
tempered for war like an exquisite sword. There lacked nothing
to this great occasion but a noble imagination. And failing that,
Napoleon could do no more than strut upon the crest of this great
mountain of opportunity like a cockerel on a dunghill. The
figure he makes in history is one of almost incredible self-conceit,
of vanity, greed, and cunning, of callous contempt and disregard
of all who trusted him, and of a grandiose aping of Caesar, Alex-
ander, and Charlemagne which would be purely comic if it were
not caked over with human blood. Until, as Victor Hugo said in
his tremendous way, "God was bored by him," and he was kicked
aside into a corner to end his days, explaining and explaining how
very clever his worst blunders had been, prowling about his dis-
mal hot island shooting birds and squabbling meanly with an
underbred gaoler who failed to show him proper " respect."
' His career as First Consul was perhaps the least dishonourable
phase in his career. He took the crumbling military affairs of
the Directory in hand, and after a complicated campaign in North
Italy brought matters to a head in the victory of Marengo, near
Alessandria (1800). It was a victory that at some moments
came very near disaster. In the December of the same year
General Moreau, in the midst of snow, mud, and altogether abom-
inable weather, inflicted an overwhelming defeat upon the Aus-
trian army at Hohenlinden. If Napoleon had gained this battle,
it would have counted among his most characteristic and brilliant
exploits. These things made the hoped-for peace possible. In
1801 the preliminaries of peace with England and Austria were
signed. Peace with England, the Treaty of Amiens, was con-
356 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
eluded in 1802, and Napoleon was free to give himself to the crea-
tive statecraft of which France, and Europe through France, stood
in need. The war had given the country extended boundaries, the
treaty with England restored the colonial empire of France and
left her in a position of security beyond the utmost dreams of
Louis XIV. It was open to Napoleon to work out and consolidate
the new order of things, to make a modern state that should be-
come a beacon and inspiration to Europe and all the world.
He attempted nothing of the sort. He did not realize that there
were such things as modern states in the scheme of possibility.
His little imitative imagination was full of a deep cunning dream
of being Csesar over again — as if this universe would ever tol-
erate anything of that sort over again ! He was scheming to
make himself a real emperor, with a crown upon his head and all
his rivals and school-fellows and friends at his feet. This could
give him no fresh power that he did not already exercise, but it
would be more splendid — it would astonish his mother. What
response was there in a head of that sort for the splendid creative
challenge of the time? But first France must be prosperous.
France hungry would certainly not endure an emperor. He set
himself to carry out an old scheme of roads that Louis XV had
approved ; he developed canals in imitation of the English canals ;
he reorganized the police and made the country safe; and, pre-
paring the scene for his personal drama, he set himself to make
Paris look like Rome, with classical arches, with classical columns.
Admirable schemes for banking development were available, and
he made use of them. In all these things he moved with the
times, they would have happened — with less autocracy, with less
centralization, if he had never been born. And he set himself
to weaken the republicans whose fundamental convictions he was
planning to outrage. He recalled the e'migre's, provided they gave
satisfactory assurances to respect the new regime. Many were
very willing to come back on such terms, and let Bourbons be
bygones. And he worked out a great reconciliation, a Concordat,
with Rome. Rome was to support him, and he was to restore the
authority of Rome in the parishes. France would never be obe-
dient and manageable, he thought ; she would never stand a new
monarchy, without religion. "How can you have order in a
THE CAREER OF NAPOLEON BONAPARTE 357
state," he said, "without religion? Society cannot exist with-
out inequality of fortunes, which cannot endure apart from religion.
When one man is dying of hunger near another who is ill of sur-
feit, he cannot resign himself to this difference, unless there is an
authority which declares — ' God wills it thus : there must be
poor and rich in the world : but hereafter and during all eternity
the division of things will take place differently.'" Religion —
especially of the later Roman brand — was, in fact, excellent
stuff for keeping the common people quiet. In his early honest
Jacobin days he had denounced it for that very reason.
Another great achievement which marks his imaginative scope
and his estimate of human nature was the institution of the Legion
of Honour, a scheme for decorating Frenchmen with bits of ribbon
which was admirably calculated to divert ambitious men from
subversive proceedings. (Washington, when he became President
of the United States, abolished the only order that has ever adorned
any citizen of the American republic, the Order of Cincinnatus,
because he had no use for the snob in his fellow man.)
And also Napoleon interested himself in Christian propaganda.
Here is the Napoleonic view of the political uses of Christ, a view
that has tainted all French missions from that time forth. "It is
my wish to re-establish the institution for foreign missions; for
the religious missionaries may be very useful to me in Asia, Africa,
and America, as I shall make them reconnoitre all the lands they
visit. The sanctity of their dress will not only protect them, but
serve to conceal their political and commercial investigations.
The head- of the missionary establishment shall reside no longer
at Rome, but in Paris."
These are the ideas of a roguish merchant rather than a states-
man. His treatment of education shows the same narrow vision,
the same blindness to the realities of the dawn about him. Ele-
mentary education he neglected almost completely; he left it to
the conscience of the local authorities, and he provided that the
teachers should be paid out of the fees of the scholars ; it is clear
he did not want the common people to be educated; he had no
glimmering of any understanding why they should be; but he
interested himself in the provision of technical and higher schools
because his state needed the services of clever, self-seeking, well-
358 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
informed men. This was an astounding retrogression from the
great scheme, drafted by Condorcet, for the Republic in 1792, for
a complete system of free education for the entire nation. Slowly
but steadfastly the project of Condorcet comes true; the great
nations of the world are being compelled to bring it nearer and
nearer to realization, and the cheap devices of Napoleon pass out
of our interest. As for the education of the mothers and wives
of our race, this was the quality of Napoleon's wisdom: "I do
not think that we need trouble ourselves with any plan of instruc-
tion for young females, they cannot be better brought up than by
their mothers. Public education is not suitable for them, because
they are never called upon to act in publics Manners are all in
all to them, and marriage is all they look to."
The First Consul was no kinder to women in the Code Napoleon.
A wife, for example, had no control over her own property ; she
was in her husband's hands. This code was the work very largely
of the Council of State. Napoleon seems rather to have hindered
than helped its deliberations. He would invade the session with-
out notice, and favour its members with lengthy and egotistical
monologues, frequently quite irrelevant to the matter in hand.
The Council listened with profound respect ; it was all the Coun-
cil could do. He would keep his councillors up to unearthly
hours, and betray a simple pride in his superior wakefulness. He
recalled these discussions with peculiar satisfaction in his later
years, and remarked on one occasion that his glory consisted not in
having won forty battles, but in having created the Code Napo-
leon. ... So far as it substituted plain statements for inac-
cessible legal mysteries his Code was a good thing; it gathered
together, revised and made clear a vast disorderly accumulation
of laws, old and new. Like all his constructive work, it made for
immediate efficiency, it defined things and relations so that men
could get to work upon them without further discussion. It was
of less immediate practical importance that it frequently defined
them wrongly. There was no intellectual power, as distinguished
from intellectual energy, behind this codification. It took every-
thing that existed for granted. ("Sa Majeste* ne croit que ce qui
est." *) The fundamental ideas of the civilized community and
1 Gourgaud quoted by Holland Rose.
THE CAREER OF NAPOLEON BONAPARTE 359
of the terms of human co-operation were in a process of recon-
struction all about Napoleon — and he never perceived it. He
accepted a phase of change, and tried to fix it for ever. To this
day France is cramped by this early nineteenth-century strait-
waistcoat into which he clapped her. He fixed the status of
women, the status of labourers, the status of the peasant; they
all struggle to this day in the net of his hard definitions.
So briskly and forcibly Napoleon set his mind, hard, clear, nar-
row, and base, to brace up France. That bracing up was only
a part of the large egotistical schemes that dominated him. His
imagination was set upon a new Csesarism. In 1802 he got him-
self made First Consul for life with the power of appointing a
successor, and his clear intention of annexing Holland and Italy,
in spite of his treaty obligations to keep them separate, made
the Peace of Amiens totter crazily from tne very beginning.
Since his schemes were bound to provoke a war with England, he
should, at any cost, have kept quiet until he had brought his
navy to a superiority over the British navy. He had the control
of great resources for ship-building, the British government was
a weak one, and three or four years would have sufficed to shift
that balance. But in spite of his rough experiences in Egypt, he
had never mastered the importance of sea power, and he had not
the mental steadfastness for a waiting game and long preparation.
In 1803 his occupation of Switzerland precipitated a crisis,1 and
war broke out again with England. The weak Addington in
England gave place to the greater Pitt. The rest of Napoleon's
story turns upon that war.
During the period of the Consulate, the First Consul was very
active in advancing the fortunes of his brothers and sisters. This
was quite human, very clannish and Corsican, and it helps us to
understand just how he valued his position and the opportunities
before him. Few of us can live without an audience, and the first
audience of our childhood is our family ; most of us to the end of
our days are swayed by the desire to impress our parents and
1 The resumption of war was more directly due to the publication in France of
the Sebastiani Report, a full account by the staff officer of the ports and strong
places of Egypt and Syria. The alarm occasioned by this document hardened the
determination of the British government to retain a garrison at Malta in spite of
the obligation to evacuate it imposed by the Peace of Amiens. — P. G.
360
THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
brothers and sisters. Few "letters home" of successful men or
women display the graces of modesty and self-forgetfulness. Only
souls uplifted, as the soul of Jesus of Nazareth was uplifted, can
say of all the world, "Behold my mother and my brethren !" A
large factor in the making of Napoleon was the desire to amaze,
astonish, and subdue the minds of the Bonaparte family, and their
neighbours. He promoted his brothers ridiculously — for they
were the most ordinary of men. The hungry Bonapartes were in
luck. Surely all Corsica was open-mouthed! But one person
who knew him well was neither amazed nor subdued. This was his
mother. He sent her money
to spend and astonish the
neighbours; he exhorted her
to make a display, to live as
became the mother of so mar-
vellous, so world-shaking, a son.
But the good lady, who had
birched the Man of Destiny at
the age of sixteen for grimacing
at his grandmother, was neither
dazzled nor deceived by him
at the age of thirty-two. All
France might worship him, but
Emperor she had no illusions. She put
by the money he sent her ; she
continued her customary economies. "When it is all over," she
said, "you will be glad of my savings."
§4
We will not detail the steps by which Napoleon became Em-
peror. His coronation was the most extraordinary revival of
stale history that it is possible to imagine. Caesar was no longer
the model; Napoleon was playing now at being Charlemagne.
He was crowned emperor, not indeed at Rome, but in the cathedral
of Notre-Dame in Paris ; the Pope (Pius VII) had been brought
from Rome to perform the ceremony; and at the climax Napo-
ileon I seized the crown, waved the Pope aside, and crowned him-
self. The attentive reader of this Outline will know that a thou-
THE CAREER OF NAPOLEON BONAPARTE 361
sand years before this would have had considerable significance ;
in 1804 it was just a ridiculous scene. In 1806 Napoleon revived
another venerable antiquity, and, following still the footsteps of
Charlemagne, crowned himself with the iron crown of Lombardy
in the cathedral of Milan. All this mummery was to have a
wonderful effect upon the imagination of western Germany, which
was to remember that it too had been a part of the empire of
Charlemagne.
The four daughter republics of France were now to become
kingdoms ; in 1806 he set up brother Louis in Holland and brother
Joseph in Naples. But the story of the subordinate kingdoms he
created in Europe, helpful though this free handling of frontiers
was towards the subsequent unification of Italy and Germany, is
too complex and evanescent for this Outline.
The pact between the new Charlemagne and the new Leo did
not hold good for very long. In 1807 he began to bully the Pope,
and in 1811 he made him a close prisoner at Fontainebleau. There
does not seem to have been much reason in these proceedings.
They estranged all Catholic opinion, as his coronation had
estranged all liberal opinion. He ceased to stand either for the
old or the new. The new he had betrayed ; the old he had failed
to win. He stood at last for nothing but himself.
There seems to have been as little reason in the foreign policy
that now plunged Europe into a fresh cycle of wars. Having
quarreled with Great Britain too soon, he (1804) assembled a
vast army at Boulogne for the conquest of England, regardless of
the naval situation. He even struck a medal and erected a
column at Boulogne to commemorate the triumph of this pro-
jected invasion. In some " Napoleonic" fashion the British fleet
was to be decoyed away, this army of Boulogne was to be smuggled
across the Channel on a flotilla of rafts and boats, and London was
to be captured before the fleet returned. At the same time his
aggressions in south Germany forced Austria and Russia steadily
into a coalition with Britain against him. In 1805 two fatal
blows were struck at any hope he may have entertained of ulti-
mate victory, by the British Admirals Calder and Nelson. In
July the former inflicted a serious reverse upon the French fleet
in the Bay of Biscay; in October the latter destroyed the joint
362
THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
J.f.Kt
fleets of France and Spain at the battle of Trafalgar. Nelson
died splendidly upon the Victory, victorious. Thereafter Napo-
leon was left with Britain in pitiless opposition, unattainable and
unconquerable, able to strike here or there against him along all
the coasts of Europe.
But for a while the mortal wound of Trafalgar was hidden from
the French mind altogether. They heard merely that " storms
have caused us to lose some ships of the line after an imprudent
fight." After Calder's victory he had snatched his army from
Boulogne, rushed it across half Europe, and defeated the Aus-
trian and Russian armies at Ulm and Austerlitz. Under these
inauspicious circumstances Prussia came into the war against him,
and was utterly defeated and broken at the battle of Jena (1806).
Although Austria and Prussia were broken, Russia was still a
fighting power, and the next year was devoted to this unnecessary
antagonist of the French, against whom an abler and saner ruler
.*• would never have fought at
all. We cannot trace in any
detail the difficulties of the
Polish campaign against Rus-
sia; Napoleon was roughly
handled at Pultusk — which
he announced in Paris as a
brilliant victory — and again
at Eylau. Then the Russians
were defeated at Friedland
(1807). As yet he had never
touched Russian soil, the Rus-
sians were still as unbeaten as
2P T the British ; but now came an
extraordinary piece of good
fortune for Napoleon. By a mixture of boasting, subtlety, and
flattery he won over the young and ambitious Tsar, Alexander I
— -he was just thirty years old — to an alliance. The two em-
perors met on a raft in the middle of the Niemen at Tilsit, and
there came to an understanding.
This meeting was an occasion for sublime foolishness on the
part of both the principal actors. Alexander had imbibed much
THE CAREER OF NAPOLEON BONAPARTE 363
liberalism during his education at the court of Catherine II, and
was all for freedom, education, and the new order of the world —
subject to his own pre-eminence. "He would gladly have every-
one free," said one of his early associates, " provided that everyone
was prepared to do freely exactly what he wished." And he
declared that he would have abolished serfdom if it had cost him
his head — if only civilization had been more advanced. He
made war against France, he said, because Napoleon was a tyrant,
to free the French people. After Friedland he saw Napoleon in a
different light. These twoi.men met eleven days after that rout;
Alexander no doubt in the state of explanatory exaltation natural
to his type during a mood of change.
To Napoleon the meeting must have been extremely gratifying.
This was his first meeting with an emperor upon terms of equality.
Like all men of limited vision, this man was a snob to the bone,
his continual solicitude for his titles 'shows as much, and here was
a real emperor, a born emperor, taking his three-year-old dignities
as equivalent to the authentic imperialism of Moscow. Two
imaginations soared together upon the raft at Tilsit. "What is
Europe?" said Alexander. "We are Europe." They discussed
the affairs of Prussia and Austria in that spirit, they divided Tur-
key in anticipation, they arranged for the conquest of India, and
indeed of most of Asia, and that Russia should take Finland from
the Swedes ; and they disregarded the disagreeable fact that the
greater part of the world's surface is sea, and that on the seas
the British fleets sailed now unchallenged. Close at hand was
Poland, ready to rise up and become the passionate ally of France
had Napoleon but willed it so. But he was blind to Poland.
It was a day of visions without vision. Napoleon even then,
it seems, concealed the daring thought that he might one day
marry a Russian princess, a real princess. But that, he was to
learn in 1810, was going a little too far.
After Tilsit there was a perceptible deterioration in Napoleon's
quality; he became rasher, less patient of obstacles, more and
more the fated master of the world, more and more intolerable
to everyone he encountered.
In 1808 he committed a very serious blunder. Spain was his
abject ally, completely under his control, but he saw fit to depose
364 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
its Bourbon king in order to promote his brother Joseph from the
crown of the two Sicilies. Portugal he had already conquered,
and the two kingdoms of Spain and Portugal were to be united.
Thereupon the Spanish arose in a state of patriotic fury, sur-
rounded a French army at Baylen, and compelled it to surrender.
It was an astonishing break in the French career of victory.
The British were not slow to seize the foothold this insurrection
gave them. A British army under Sir Arthur Wellesley (after-
wards the Duke of Wellington) landed in Portugal, defeated the
French at Vimiero, and compelled them to retire into Spain.
The news of these reverses caused a very great excitement in
Germany and Austria, and the Tsar assumed a more arrogant
attitude towards his ally.
There was another meeting of these two potentates at Erfurt,
in which the Tsar was manifestly less amenable to the dazzling
tactics of Napoleon than he had been. Followed four years of
unstable "ascendancy" for France, while the outlines on the
map of Europe waved about like garments on a clothesline on a
windy day. Napoleon's personal empire grew by frank annexa-
tions to include Holland, much of western Germany, much of
Italy, and much of the eastern Adriatic coast. But one by one
the French colonies were falling to the British, and the British
armies in the Spanish peninsula, with the Spanish auxiliaries,
slowly pressed the French northward. All Europe was getting
very_weary of Napoleon and very indignant with him ; his antago-
nists now were no longer merely monarchs and ministers, but
whole peoples also. The Prussians, after the disaster of Jena in
1807, had set to work to put their house in order. Under the
leadership of Freiherr von Stein they had swept aside their feudal-
ism, abolished privilege and serfdom, organized popular education
and popular patriotism, accomplished, in fact, without any in-
ternal struggle nearly everything that France had achieved in
1789. By 1810 a new Prussia existed, the nucleus of a new Ger-
many. And now Alexander, inspired it would seem by dreams
of world ascendancy even crazier than his rival's, was posing again
as the friend of liberty. In 1810 fresh friction was created by
Alexander's objection to Napoleon's matrimonial ambitions.
For he was now divorcing his old helper Josephine, because she
THE CAREER OF NAPOLEON BONAPARTE
365
was childless, in order to secure the " continuity" of his " dynasty."
Napoleon, thwarted of a Russian princess, snubbed indeed by Alex-
ander, turned to Austria, and married the arch-duchess Marie
Louise. The Austrian statesmen read him aright. They were
very ready to throw him their princess. By that marriage Napo-
leon was captured for the dynastic system ; he might have been
£MFIR£ of NAFOLEOM about 1B1O
the maker of a new world, he preferred to be the son-in-law of
the old.
In the next two years this adventurer's affairs crumbled apace.
Nobody believed in his pretensions any more. He was no longer
the leader and complement of the revolution; no longer the
embodied spirit of a world reborn ; he was just a new and nastier
sort of autocrat. He had estranged all free-spirited men, and he
had antagonized the church. Kings and Jacobins were at one,
when it came to the question of his overthrow. Only base and self-
366 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
seeking people supported him, because he seemed to have the secret
of success. Britain was now his inveterate enemy, Spain was
blazing with a spirit that surely a Corsican should have under-
stood; it needed only a breach with Alexander I to set this em-
pire of bluff and stage scenery swaying towards its downfall. The
quarrel came. Alexander's feelings for Napoleon had always
been of a very mixed sort; he envied Napoleon as a rival, and
despised him as an underbred upstart. Moreover, there was a
kind of vague and sentimental greatness about Alexander; he
was given to mystical religiosity, he had the conception of a
mission for Russia and himself to bring peace to Europe and the
world — by destroying Napoleon. In that respect he had an
imaginative greatness Napoleon lacked. But bringing peace to
Europe seemed to him quite compatible with the annexation of
Finland, of most of Poland, and of great portions of the Turkish
empire. This man's mind moved in a luminous fog. And par-
ticularly he wanted to resume trading with Britain, against which
Napoleon had set his face. For all the trade of Germany had been
dislocated and the mercantile classes embittered by the Napoleonic
" Continental System/' which was to ruin Britain by excluding
British goods from every country in Europe. Russia had suffered
more even than Germany.
The breach came in 1811, when Alexander withdrew from the
"Continental System." In 1812 a great mass of armies, amount-
ing altogether to 600,000 men, began to move towards Russia
under the supreme command of the new emperor. About half
this force was French ; the rest was drawn from the French allies
and subject peoples. It was a conglomerate army like the army
of Darius or the army of Kavadh. The Spanish war was still going
on ; Napoleon made no attempt to end it. Altogether, it drained
away a quarter of a million men from France. He fought his way
across Poland and Russia to Moscow before the winter — for
the most part the Russian armies declined battle — and even
before the winter closed in upon him his position became mani-
festly dangerous. He took Moscow, expecting that this would
oblige Alexander to make peace. Alexander would not make
peace, and Napoleon found himself in much the same position
as Darius had been in 2,300 years before in South Russia. The
THE CAREER OF NAPOLEON BONAPARTE 367
Russians, still unconquered in a decisive battle, raided his com-
munications, wasted his army — disease helped them ; even
before Napoleon reached Moscow 150,000 men had been lost.
But he lacked the wisdom of Darius, and would not retreat. The
winter remained mild for an unusually long time — he could have
escaped ; but instead he remained in Moscow, making impossible
plans, at a loss. He had been marvellously lucky in all his pre-
vious flounderings ; he had escaped undeservedly from Egypt,
he had been saved from destruction in Britain by the British
naval victories ; but now he was in the net again, and this time
he was not to escape. Perhaps he would have wintered in Mos-
cow, but the Russians smoked him out ; they set fire to and burnt
most of the city.1
It was late in October, too late altogether, before he decided to
return. He made an ineffectual attempt to break through to a
fresh line of retreat to the southwest, and then turned the faces
of the survivors of his Grand Army towards the country they had
devastated in their advance. Immense distances separated them
from any friendly territory. The winter was in no hurry. For
a week the Grand Army struggled through mud ; then came sharp
frosts, and then the first flakes of snow, and then snow and
snow. . . .
Slowly discipline dissolved. The hungry army spread itself
out in search of supplies until it broke up into mere bands of
marauders. The peasants, if only in self-defence, rose against
them, waylaid them, and murdered them ; a cloud of light cavalry
— Scythians still — hunted them down. That retreat is one of
the great tragedies of history.
At last Napoleon and his staff and a handful of guards and at-
tendants reappeared in Germany, bringing no army with him,
followed only by straggling and demoralized bands. The Grand
Army, retreating under Murat, reached Konigsberg in a disciplined
state, but only about a thousand strong out of six hundred thou-
sand. From Konigsberg Murat fell back to Posen. The Prus-
sian contingent had surrendered to the Russians; the Austrians
had gone homeward to the south. Everywhere scattered fugitives,
ragged, lean, and frost-bitten, spread the news of the disaster.
1 All this is admirably told in Tolstoy's wonderful War and Peace.
368 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
Napoleon's magic was nearly exhausted. He did not dare to
stay with his troops in Germany; he fled post haste to Paris.
He began to order new levies and gather fresh armies amidst the
wreckage of his world empire. Austria turned against him (1813) ;
all Europe was eager to rise against this defaulting trustee of
freedom, this mere usurper. He had betrayed the new order;
the old order he had saved and revived now destroyed him. Prus-
sia rose, and the German "War of Liberation" began. Sweden
joined his enemies. Later Holland revolted. Murat had rallied
about 14,000 Frenchmen round his disciplined nucleus in Posen,
and this force retreated through Germany, as a man might retreat
who had ventured into a cageful of drugged lions arid found that
the effects of the drug were evaporating. Napoleon, with fresh
forces, took up the chief command in the spring, won a great battle
at Dresden, and then for a time he seems to have gone to pieces
intellectually and morally. He became insanely irritable, with
moods of inaction. He did little or nothing to follow up the Battle
of Dresden. In September the " Battle of the Nations" was
fought round and about Leipzig, after which the Saxons, who had
hitherto followed his star, went over to the allies. The end of the
year saw the French beaten back into France.
1814 was the closing campaign. France was invaded from the
east and the south; Swedes, Germans, Austrians, Russians,
crossed the Rhine ; British and Spanish came through the Pyrenees.
Once more Napoleon fought brilliantly, but now he fought in-
effectually. The eastern armies did not so much defeat him as
push past him, and Paris capitulated in March. A little later at
Fontainebleau the emperor abdicated.
In Provence, on his way out of the country, his life was en-
dangered by a royalist mob.
§5
This was the natural and proper end of Napoleon's career.
So this raid of an intolerable egotist across the disordered be-
ginnings of a new time should have closed. At last he was sup-
pressed. And had there been any real wisdom in the conduct of
human affairs, we should now have to tell of the concentration of
human science and will upon the task his treachery and vanity
THE CAREER OF NAPOLEON BONAPARTE
369
2n
370 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
had interrupted, the task of building up a world system of jus-
tice and free effort in the place of the bankrupt ancient order.
"But we have to tell of nothing of the sort. Science and wisdom
were conspicuously absent from the great council of the allies.
Came the vague humanitarianism and dreamy vanity of the Tsar
Alexander, came the shaken Habsburgs of Austria, the resentful
Hohenzollerns of Prussia, the aristocratic traditions of Britain,
still badly frightened by the revolution and its conscience all awry
with stolen commons and sweated factory children. No peoples
came to the Congress, but only monarchs and foreign ministers;
and though you bray a foreign office in the bloodiest of war mor-
tars, yet will its diplomatic habits not depart from it. The
Congress had hardly assembled before the diplomatists set to work
making secret bargains and treaties behind each other's backs.
Nothing could exceed the pompous triviality of the Congress which
gathered at Vienna after a magnificent ceremonial visit of the
allied sovereigns to London. The social side of the congress was
very strong, pretty ladies abounded, there was a galaxy of stars
and uniforms, endless dinners and balls, a mighty flow of bright
anecdotes and sparkling wit. Whether the two million dead
men upon the battle-fields laughed at the jokes, admired the
assemblies, and marvelled at the diplomatists is beyond our
knowledge. It is to be hoped their poor wraiths got something
out of the display. The brightest spirit of the gathering was a
certain Talleyrand, one of Napoleon's princes, a very brilliant
man indeed, who had been a pre-revolutionary cleric, who had
proposed the revolutionary confiscation of the church estates, and
who was now for bringing back the Bourbons.
The allies, after the fashion of Peace Congresses, frittered away
precious time in more and more rapacious disputes ; the Bourbons
returned to France. Back came all the remainder of the emigres
with them, eager for restitution and revenge. One great egotism
had been swept aside — only to reveal a crowd of meaner egotists.
The new king was the brother of Louis XVI ; he had taken the
title of Louis XVIII very eagerly so soon as he learnt that his
little nephew (Louis XVII) was dead in the Temple. He was
gouty and clumsy, not perhaps ill-disposed, but the symbol of the
Ancient system ; all that was new in France felt the heavy threat
THE CAREER OF NAPOLEON BONAPARTE 371
of reaction that came with him. This was no liberation, only a
new tyranny, a heavy and inglorious tyranny instead of an active
and splendid one. Was there no hope for France but this? The
Bourbons showed particular malice against the veterans of the
Grand Army, and France was now full of returned prisoners of
war, who found themselves under a cloud. Napoleon had been
packed off to a little consolation empire of his own, upon the island
of Elba. He was still to be called Emperor and keep a certain
state. The chivalry or whim of Alexander had insisted upon this
treatment of his fallen rival. The Habsburgs, who had toadied
to his success, had taken away his Habsburg empress — she went
willingly enough — to Vienna, and he never saw her again.
After eleven months at Elba Napoleon judged that France had
had enough of the Bourbons; he contrived to evade the British
ships that watched his island, and reappeared at Cannes in France
for his last gamble against fate. His progress to Paris was a tri-
umphal procession ; he walked on white Bourbon cockades. For
a hundred days, "the Hundred Days/' he was master of France
again.
His return created a perplexing position for any honest French-
man. On the one hand there was this adventurer who had be-
trayed the republic ; on the other the dull weight of old kingship
restored. The allies would not hear of any further experiments
in republicanism; it was the Bourbons or Napoleon. Is it any
wonder that on the whole France was with Napoleon? And he
came back professing to be a changed man; there was to be no
more despotism; he would respect the constitution regime. . . .
He gathered an army, he made some attempts at peace with
the allies; when he found these efforts ineffectual, he struck
swiftly at the British, Dutch, and Prussians in Belgium, hoping
to defeat them before the Austrians and Russians could come up.
He did very nearly manage this. He beat the Prussians at Ligny,
but not sufficiently; and then he was hopelessly defeated by the
tenacity of the British under Wellington at Waterloo (1815), the
Prussians, under Bliicher, coming in on his right flank as the day
wore on. Waterloo ended in a rout; it left Napoleon without
support and without hope. France fell away from him again.
Everyone who had joined him was eager now to attack him, and
372 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
so efface that error. A provisional government in Paris ordered
him to leave the country ; was for giving him twenty-four hours
to do it in.
He tried to get to America, but Rochefort, which he reached,
was watched by British cruisers. France, now disillusioned and
uncomfortably royalist again, was hot in pursuit of him. He
went aboard a British frigate, the Bellerophon, asking to be re-
ceived as a refugee, but being treated as a prisoner. He was taken
to Plymouth, and from Plymouth straight to the lonely tropical
island of St. Helena.
There he remained until his death from cancer in 1821, devoting
himself chiefly to the preparation of his memoirs, which were
designed to exhibit the chief events of his life in a misleading and
attractive light and to minimize his worst blunders. One or two
of the men with him recorded his conversations and set down their
impressions of him.
These works had a great vogue in France and Europe. The
Holy Alliance of the monarchs of Russia, Austria, and Prussia
(to which other monarchs were invited to adhere) laboured under
the delusion that in defeating Napoleon they had defeated the
Revolution, turned back the clock of fate, and restored Grand
Monarchy — on a sanctified basis for evermore. The cardinal
document of the scheme of the Holy Alliance is said to have been
drawn up under the inspiration of the Baroness von Kriidener,
who seems to have been a sort of spiritual director to the Russian
emperor. It opened, "In the name of the Most Holy and In-
divisible Trinity," and it bound the participating monarchs " re-
garding themselves towards their subjects and armies as fathers
of families," and "considering each other as fellow-countrymen,"
to sustain each other, protect true religion, and urge their sub-
jects to strengthen and exercise themselves in Christian duties.
Christ, it was declared, was the real king of all Christian peoples,
a very Merovingian king, one may remark, with these reigning
sovereigns as his mayors of the palace. The British king had no
power to sign this document, the Pope and the sultan were not
asked ; the rest of the European monarchs, including the king of
France, adhered. But the king of Poland did not sign because
there was no king in Poland ; Alexander, in a mood of pious ab-
THE CAREER OF NAPOLEON BONAPARTE 373
straction, was sitting on the greater part of Poland. The Holy
Alliance never became an actual legal alliance of states; it gave
place to a real league of nations, the Concert of Europe, which
France joined in 1818, and from which Britain withdrew in 1822.
There followed a period of peace and dull oppression in Europe
over which Alexander brooded in attitudes of orthodoxy, piety,
and unquenchable self-satisfaction. Many people in those hope-
less days were disposed to regard even Napoleon with charity,
and to accept his claim that in some inexplicable way he had, in
asserting himself, been asserting the revolution and France. A
cult of him as of something mystically heroic grew up after his
death.1
§6
In the long perspectives of history the cult of Napoleon, and his
peculiar effect upon certain types of mind, is of far more interest
and far more importance than his actual adventures. The world
has largely recovered from the mischief he did; perhaps that
amount of mischief had to be done by some agency ; perhaps his
career, or some such career, was a necessary consequence of the
world's mental unpreparedness for the crisis of the revolution.
But that his peculiar personality should dominate the imaginations
of great numbers of people, throws a light upon factors of enduring
significance in our human problem.
It would be difficult to find a human being less likely to arouse
affection. One reads in vain through the monstrous accumula-
tions of Napoleonic literature for a single record of self-forgetful-
ness. Laughter is one great difference between man and the lower
animals, one method of our brotherhood, and there is no evidence
that Napoleon ever laughed. Nor can we imagine another of the
most beautiful of human expressions upon the face of this saturnine
egotist, that expression of disinterested interest that one sees in
the face of an artist or artisan "lost," as we say, in his work.
Out of his portraits he looks at us with a thin scorn upon his lips,
the scorn of the criminal who believes that he can certainly cheat
such fools as we are, and withal with a certain uneasiness in his
1 The best textbook to follow in expanding this chapter is W. A. Phillips' Con-
federation of Europe.
374 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
eyes. That uneasiness haunts all his portraits. Are we really
convinced he is quite right? Are his laurels straight? He had a
vast contempt for man in general and men in particular, a con-
tempt that took him at last to St. Helena, that same contempt
that fills our jails with forgers, poisoners, and the like victims of
self-conceit. There is no proof that this unbrotherly, unhumorous
egotist was ever sincerely loved by any human being. The Em-
press Josephine was unfaithful to him as he to her. His young
Austrian wife would not accompany him to Elba. A certain
Polish countess followed him thither, but not, it would seem, for
love, but on account of the son she had borne him. She wanted
settlements. She stayed only two days with him. He had never
even a dog to love him. He estranged most of his colleagues and
fellow generals. He had no familiar friend. No one who knew
him felt safe with him. In his intimacy, his unflinching self-
concentration must have been a terrible bore. His personal habits
were unpleasant ; the moodiness of bad health came to him early.
True it is that his soldiers, who, save for a few rare melodramatic
encounters, saw nothing of him, idolized their " Little Corporal."
But it was not him they idolized, but a carefully fostered legend
of an incredibly clever, recklessly brave little man, a little pet of
a man, who was devoted to France and them.
Why, then, is there an enormous cult of Napoleon, an endless
writing of books about him, an insatiable collecting of relics and
documents, a kind of worship of his memory? Marat was a far
more noble, persistent, subtle, and pathetic figure ; Talleyrand a
greater statesman and a much more amusing personality ; Moreau
and Hoche abler leaders of armies ; his rival, the Tsar Alexander,
as egotistical, more successful, more emotional, and with a finer
imagination. Are men dazzled simply by the scale of his flounder-
ings, by the mere vastness of his notoriety ?
No doubt scale has something to do with the matter ; he was a
"record," the record plunger; but there is something more in
it than that. There is an appeal in Napoleon to something deeper
and more fundamental in human nature than mere astonishment
at bigness. His very deficiencies bring out starkly certain qualities
that lurk suppressed and hidden in us all. He was unhampered.
He had never a gleam of religion or affection or the sense of duty.
THE CAREER OF NAPOLEON BONAPARTE 375
He was, as few men are or dare to be, a scoundrel, bright and com-
plete. Most of us are constrained more or less and now and then
to serve God or our fellow men, to do things disinterestedly, to
behave decently when no one is watching us. He was not so
constrained. Most men do a little regret and resent their good
deeds, and find a secret satisfaction in their unpunished bad ones.
The early palaeolithic strain is still strong in us ; we are being made
over, slowly and reluctantly, into social and fraternal creatures.
Few of us thoroughly enjoy being good citizens. Our moral con-
flicts, therefore, are intricate and comic; the constant effort to
explain to ourselves and others that there is a fine moral purpose
in this shirking of our duty or in that self-seeking act. We are all
regretfully of the race of Tsar Alexander, who destroyed the free-
dom of Poland, annexed Finland, and secured his imperial pre-
dominance piously, "in the name of the most Holy and Indi-
visible Trinity" — when it would have been far more agreeable
to have done it in the name of the most Holy and Magnificent
Alexander. There was none of this robing of greed and crime
about Napoleon. His self-conceit and his instinctive and funda-
mental atheism made him at least magnificently direct. What
we all want to do secretly, more or less, he did in the daylight.
Directness was his distinctive and immortalizing quality. He
had no brains to waste in secondary considerations. He flung
his armies across Europe straight at their mark, there never were
such marches before ; he fought to win ; when he struck he struck
with all his might. And what he wanted, he wanted simply and
completely, and got — if he could.
There lies his fascination. Since his time his name has been
one of the utmost reassurance to great multitudes of doubting
men; to the business man hesitating over a more than shady
transaction, to the clerk fingering a carelessly written cheque that
could so easily be altered, to the trustee in want of ready money,
to the manufacturer meditating the pros and cons of an adultera-
tion, to thousands of such people the word "Napoleonic" has
come with an effect of decisive relief. We live in a world full of
would-be Napoleons of finance, of the press, of the turf; half
the cells in our jails and many in our mad-houses are St. Helenas.
He was the very embodiment of that sound, clear, self-centred
376 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
common sense, without sentiment or scruples or reflection, that
struggles with our feebler better nature, that may ultimately
destroy mankind. In all history there is no figure so completely
antithetical to the figure of Jesus of Nazareth, whose pitiless and
difficult doctrine of self-abandonment and self-forgetfulness we
can neither disregard nor yet bring ourselves to obey. That sum-
mons to a new way of life haunts our world to-day, haunts wealth
and comfort and every sort of success. It is a trouble to us all.
Our uneasiness grows. Napoleon was free from it. The cultiva-
tion of the Napoleonic legend seems to offer a kind of refuge.
From salvation.
In that antithesis lies the essential historical importance of
Napoleon. His career marks the beginning of a new phase in
the elations of strong and able and energetic and advantageously
placed men to the main mass of mankind. They are robbed of
self-deception ; they must either serve or openly defy the idea of
service. They must be humble or Napoleonic ; there is no more
service with privilege and pride. Napoleon adorned himself with
ancient titles and antiquated robes, but the more he brought
himself into contact with tradition, the more manifestly he dis-
played himself as something new. In the Tsar Alexander I, who
was never direct, this direct new imperialism met the old. Hitherto
the kings and potentates of the world had taken themselves in
good faith, had had the support of religion in their consciences,
had believed they were serving God in their kingship, and that
they were necessary to mankind and beneficial to mankind. In
many cases they were no doubt swayed by very mixed motives,
his majesty had " weaknesses," his majesty almost always had a
sensitive personal vanity. Sometimes, indeed, a born rascal like
Charles II of England would have the grace or the gracelessness
to laugh at himself, but the generality of kings and tyrants had
the profoundest faith in themselves, and were sustained by the
sincere faith of their loyal supporters. The emperor Charles V
and his son Philip II, Charles I of England, Louis XIV, and the
Tsar Alexander were all inspired by a complete assurance of their
own righteousness, were convinced that opposition to them was
sheer wickedness, wickedness to be overcome in any way and
punished with the utmost severity. But Napoleon knew himself
THE CAREER OF NAPOLEON BONAPARTE 377
for what he was, an individual man getting the better of his fellow
men. He had small doubt in his struggle with the republicans,
where the moral superiority lay. With Napoleon, we note the
beginning of a clearer-headed age. The self-deceptions of wealth,
power, and prominence wear thin. His new imperialism reflected
_ upon the old.
For a time the Concert of Europe struggled valiantly to carry
on upon the old lines, but the French Revolution had shrivelled
the heart of monarchy. In 1830, and again in 1848, the evapora-
tion of the simple old royalist faith became very evident. Alex-
ander I and his narrow-minded successor, Nicholas I, could still
sustain the delusion of divine right in Russia — that did not
perish until 1917 — the idea hung on in Prussia in spite of much
muttere'd criticism,1 but for the rest of Europe the days of the
unchallenged claim of kingship had gone. "What good are you? "
said the world to monarchs; "and what do you do for us?"
So challenged, many of the monarchs became apologetic and
fussily useful. One or two, as we shall have to tell, became
"Napoleonic." But so far no European monarch has betrayed
any disposition to waive the remnant of his ancient trappings, to
cease his passive and traditional opposition to political readjust-
ment, and to move of his own accord towards that more broadly
conceived government of human affairs as one world-wide com-
munity of will, which the future welfare of mankind demands.
§7*
For nearly forty years the idea of the Holy Alliance, the Concert
of Europe which arose out of it, and the series of congresses and
conferences that succeeded the concert, kept an insecure peace in
war-exhausted Europe. Two main things prevented that period
from being a complete social and international peace, and pre-
pared the way for the cycle of wars between 1854 and 1871. The
first of these was the tendency of the royal courts concerned,
1 See J. W. Headlam's Life of Bismarck.
2 W. A. Phillips' Confederation of Europe is the leading textbook here. H. E.
Egerton's British Foreign Policy in the Nineteenth Century and L. S. Woolf's Inter-
national Government are very illuminating. See also Thatcher and Schwill's
convenient General History of Europe and Philip Guedalla's Partition of Europe;
1715-1816.
378 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
towards the restoration of unfair privilege and interference with
freedom of thought and writing and teaching. The second was
the impossible system of boundaries drawn by the diplomatists of
Vienna.
The obstinate disposition of monarchy to march back towards
past conditions was first and most particularly manifest in Spain.
Here even the Inquisition was restored. Across the Atlantic the
Spanish colonies had followed the example of the United States
and revolted against the European Great Power system, when
Napoleon set up his brother Joseph upon the Spanish throne in
1810. The Washington of South America was General Bolivar.
Spain was unable to suppress this revolt, it dragged on much as
the United States War of Independence had dragged on, and at
last the suggestion was made by Austria in accordance with the
spirit of the Holy Alliance, that the European monarchs should
assist Spain in this struggle. This was opposed by Britain in
Europe, but it was the prompt action of President Monroe of the
United States in 1823 which conclusively warned off this pro-
jected monarchist restoration. He announced that the United
States would regard any extension of the European system in the
Western Hemisphere as a hostile act. Thus arose the Monroe
Doctrine, which has kept the Great Power System out of America
for nearly a hundred years, and permitted the new states of Spanish
America to work out their destinies along their own lines. But
if Spanish monarchism lost its colonies, it could at least, under
the protection of the Concert of Europe, do what it chose in
Europe. A popular insurrection in Spain was crushed by a French
army in 1823, with a mandate from a European congress, and
simultaneously Austria suppressed a revolution in Naples. The
moving spirit in this conspiracy of governments against peoples
was the Austrian statesman, Metternich.
In 1824 Louis XVIII died, and was succeeded by that Count
d'Artois whom we have seen hovering as an emigre on the French
frontiers in 1789; he took the title of Charles X. Charles set
himself to destroy the liberty of the press and universities, and to
restore absolute government ; the sum of a billion francs was voted
to compensate the nobles for the chateau burnings and sequestra-
tions of 1789. In 1830 Paris rose against this embodiment of the
THE CAREER OF NAPOLEON BONAPARTE
379
ancient regime, and replaced him by the son of that sinister Philip,
Duke of Orleans, whose execution was one of the brightest achieve-
ments of the Terror. The other continental monarchies, in face
of the open approval of the revolution by Great Britain and a
strong liberal ferment in Germany and Austria, did not interfere
in this affair. After all, France was still a monarchy. This
EUROPE after ike
young man, Louis Philippe (1830-48), remained the constitutional
king of France for eighteen years. He went down in 1848, a very
eventful year for Europe, of which we shall tell in the next chapter.
Such were the uneasy swayings of the peace of the Congress of
Vienna, which were provoked by the reactionary proceedings to
which, sooner or later, all monarchist courts seem by their very
nature to gravitate. The stresses that arose from the unscientific
map-making of the diplomatists gathered force more deliberately,
380 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
but they were even more dangerous to the peace of mankind. It
is extraordinarily inconvenient to administer together the affairs
of peoples speaking different languages and so reading different
literatures and having different general ideas, especially if those
differences are exacerbated by religious disputes. Only some strong
mutual interest, such as the common defensive needs of the Swiss
mountaineers, can justify a close linking of peoples of dissimilar
languages and faiths ; and even in Switzerland there is the utmost
local autonomy. Ultimately, when the Great Power tradition
is certainly dead and buried, those Swiss populations may gravi-
tate towards their natural affinities in Germany, France, and
Italy. When, as in Macedonia, populations are mixed in a patch-
work of villages and districts, the cantonal system is imperatively
needed. But if the reader will look at the map of Europe as the
Congress of Vienna drew it, he will see that this gathering seems
almost as if it had planned the maximum of local exasperation.
It destroyed the Dutch Republic, quite needlessly, it lumped
together the Protestant Dutch with the French-speaking Catholics
of the old Spanish (Austrian) Netherlands, and set up a kingdom
of the Netherlands. It handed over not merely the old republic
of Venice, but all of North Italy as far as Milan to the German-
speaking Austrians. French-speaking Savoy it combined with
pieces of Italy to restore the kingdom of Sardinia.1 Austria and
Hungary, already a sufficiently explosive mixture of discordant
nationalities, Germans, Hungarians, Czecho-Slovaks, Jugo-Slavs,
Roumanians, and now Italians, was made still more impossible by
confirming Austria's Polish acquisitions of 1772 and 1795. The
Polish people, being catholic and republican-spirited, were chiefly
given over to the less civilized rule of the Greek-orthodox Tsar, but
important districts went to Protestant Russia. The Tsar was
also confirmed in his acquisition of the entirely alien Finns. The
very dissimilar Norwegian and Swedish peoples were bound
together under one king. Germany, the reader will see, was left
1 The Dukes of Savoy (ancestors of the present Italian kings) had been astride
the Alps, ruling in France and Italy, for centuries; and their strategic position
had long given them a European importance. The Dukes of Savoy had been
kings since 1713, first as Kings of Sicily, 1713-20, and then (when Sicily was ex-
changed for Sardinia in 1720) as Kings of Sardinia. — E. B.
THE CAREER OF NAPOLEON BONAPARTE 381
in a particularlyrdangerous state of muddle. Prussia and Austria
were both partly in and partly out of a German confederation,
which included a multitude of minor states. The King of Den-
mark came into the German confederation by virtue of certain
German-speaking possessions in Holstein. Luxembourg was in-
cluded in the German Confederation, though its ruler was also
King of the Netherlands, and though many of its peoples talked
French. Here was a crazy tangle, an outrage on the common
sense of mankind, a preposterous disregard of the fact that the
people who talk German and base their ideas on German literature,
the people who talk Italian and base their ideas on Italian litera-
ture, and the people who talk Polish and base their ideas on Po-
lish literature, will all be far better off and most helpful and least
obnoxious to the rest of mankind if they conduct their own affairs
in their own idiom within the ring-fence of their own speech.
Is it any wonder that one of the most popular songs in Germany
during this period declared that wherever the German tongue was
spoken, there was the German Fatherland?
Even to-day men are still reluctant to recognize that areas of
government are not matters for the bargaining and interplay of
tsars and kings and foreign offices. There is a natural and neces-
sary political map of the world which transcends these things.
There is a best way possible of dividing any part of the world into
administrative areas, and a best possible kind of government for
every area, having regard to the speech and race of its inhabitants,
and it is the common concern of all men of intelligence to secure
those divisions and establish those forms of government quite
irrespective of diplomacies and flags, " claims " and melodramatic
"loyalties" and the existing political map of the world. The
natural political map of the world insists upon itself. It heaves
and frets beneath the artificial political map like some misfitted
giant. In 1830 French-speaking Belgium, stirred up by the
current revolution in France, revolted against its Dutch associa-
tion in the kingdom of the Netherlands. The Powers, terrified at
the possibility of a republic and of annexation to France, hurried
in to pacify this situation, and gave the Belgians a monarch from
that rich breeding-ground of monarchs, Germany, Leopold I of
Saxe-Coburg Gotha. There were also ineffectual revolts in Italy
382 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
and Germany in 1830, and a much more serious one in Russian
Poland. A republican government held out in Warsaw for a
year against Nicholas I (who succeeded Alexander in 1825), and
was then stamped out of existence with great violence and cruelty.
The Polish language was banned, and the Greek Orthodox church
was substituted for the Roman Catholic as the State religion. . . .
An outbreak of the natural political map of the world, which
occurred in 1821, ultimately secured the support of England,
France, and Russia. This was the insurrection of the Greeks against
the Turks. For six years they fought a desperate war, while the
governments of Europe looked on. Liberal opinion protested
against this inactivity ; volunteers from every European country
joined the insurgents, and at last Britain, France, and Russia took
joint action. The Turkish fleet was destroyed by the French
and English at the Battle of Navalino (1827), and the Tsar in-
vaded Turkey. By the treaty of Adrianople (1829) Greece was
declared free, but she was not permitted to resume her ancient
republican traditions. There is a sort of historical indecency in a
Greek monarchy. But a Greek republic would have been danger-
ous to all monarchy in a Europe that fretted under the ideas of
the Holy Alliance. One monarch makes many. A German king
was found for Greece, one Prince Otto of Bavaria, slightly de-
mented, but quite royal — he gave way to delusions about his
divine right, and was ejected in 1862 — and Christian governors
were set up in the Danubian provinces (which are now Roumania)
and Serbia (a part of the Jugo-Slav region). This was a partial
concession to the natural political map, but much blood had still
to run before the Turk was altogether expelled from these lands.
A little later the natural political map was to assert itself in Italy
and Germany.
THE CAREER OF NAPOLEON BONAPARTE 383
XXXIX
THE REALITIES AND IMAGINATIONS OF THE
NINETEENTH CENTURY1
§ 1. The Mechanical Revolution. § 2. Relation of the Mechanical
to the Industrial Revolution. § 3. The Fermentation of Ideas,
1848. § 4. The Development of the Idea of Socialism. § 5.
Shortcomings of Socialism as a Scheme of Human Society. § 6.
How Darwinism Affected Religious and Political Ideas. § 7. Mr.
Gladstone and the Idea of Nationalism. § 8. Europe between
1848 and 1878. § 9. The (Second) Scramble for Overseas Em-
pires. § 10. The Indian Precedent in Asia. § 11. The History
of Japan. § 12. Close of the Period of Overseas Expansion.
§ 13. The British Empire in 1914.
§1
THE career and personality of Napoleon I bulks dispropor-
tionately in the nineteenth century histories. He was of
little significance to the broad onward movement of human
affairs ; he was an interruption, a reminder of latent evils, a thing
like the bacterium of some pestilence. Even regarded as a pesti-
lence, he was not of supreme rank ; he killed far fewer people than
the influenza epidemic of 1918, and produced less political and
social disruption than the plague of Justinian. Some such inter-
lude had to happen, and some such patched-up settlement of
Europe as the Concert of Europe, because there was no worked-
out system of ideas upon which a new world could be constructed.
1 An excellent book on the substance of this chapter is F. S. Marvin's Century
of Hope. Another is R. A. Gregory's Discovery. See also Seignobos' Political
history of Contemporary Europe.
384
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY 385
And even the Concert of Europe had in it an element of progress.
It did at least set aside the individualism of Machiavellian mon-
archy and declare that there was a human or at any rate a Euro-
pean commonweal. If it divided the world among the kings, it
made respectful gestures towards human unity and the service of
God and man.
The permanently effective task before mankind which had to
be done before any new and enduring social and political edifice was
possible, the task upon which the human intelligence is, with many
interruptions and amidst much anger and turmoil, still engaged,
was, and is, the task of working out and applying a Science of
Property as a basis for freedom and social justice, a Science of
Currency to ensure and preserve an efficient economic medium, a
Science of Government and Collective Operations whereby in
every community men may learn to pursue their common interests
in harmony, a Science of World Politics, through which the stark
waste and cruelty of warfare between races, peoples, and nations
may be brought to an end and the common interests of mankind
brought under a common control, and, above all, a world-wide
System of Education to sustain the will and interest of men in
their common human adventure. The real makers of history in
the nineteenth century, the people whose consequences will be
determining human life a century ahead, were those who advanced
and contributed to this fivefold constructive effort. Compared
to them, the foreign ministers and " statesmen" and politicians
of this period were no more than a number of troublesome and
occasionally incendiary schoolboys — and a few metal thieves —
playing about and doing transitory mischief amidst the accumu-
lating materials upon the site of a great building whose nature
they did not understand.
And while throughout the nineteenth century the mind of West-
ern civilization, which the Renascence had released, gathered
itself to the task of creative social and political reconstruction
that still lies before it, there swept across the world a wave of
universal change in human power and the material conditions of
life that the first scientific efforts of that liberated mind had made
possible. The prophecies of Roger Bacon began to live in reality.
The accumulating knowledge and confidence of the little succes-
2c
386 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
sion of men who had been carrying on the development of science,
now began to bear fruit that common men could understand.
The most obvious firstfruit was the steam-engine. The first
steam-engines in the eighteenth century were pumping engines
used to keep water out of the newly opened coal mines. These
coal mines were being worked to supply coke for iron smelting,
for which wood-charcoal had previously been employed. It was
James Watt, a mathematical instrument maker of Glasgow, who
improved this steam-pumping engine and made it available for
the driving of machinery. The first engine so employed was
installed in a cotton mill in Nottingham in 1785. In 1804 Trevi-
thick adapted the Watt engine to transport, and made the first
locomotive. In 1830 the first railway, between Liverpool and
Manchester, was opened, and Stephenson's " Rocket," with a
thirteen-ton train, got up to a speed of forty-four miles per hour.
From 1830 onward railways multiplied. By the middle of the
century a network of railways had spread all over Europe.
Here was a sudden change in what had long been a fixed condi-
tion of human life, the maximum rate of land transport. After
the Russian disaster, Napoleon travelled from near Vilna to Paris
in 312 hours. This was a journey of about 1,400 miles. He was
travelling with every conceivable advantage, and he averaged
under five miles an hour. An ordinary traveller could not have
done this distance in twice the time. These were about the same
maximum rates of travel as held good between Rome and Gaul
in the first century A.D., or between Sardis and Susa in the fourth
century B.C. Then suddenly came a tremendous change. The
railways reduced this journey for any ordinary traveller to less
than forty-eight hours. That is to say, they reduced the chief
European distances to about a tenth of what they had been. They
made it possible to carry out administrative work in areas ten
tunes as great as any that had hitherto been workable under one
administration. The full significance of that possibility in Eu-
rope still remains to be realized. Europe is still netted in bound-
aries drawn in the horse and road era. In America the effects
were immediate. To the United States of America, sprawling
westward, it meant the possibility of a continuous access to
Washington, however far the frontier travelled across the con-
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY 387
tinent. It meant unity, sustained on a scale that would otherwise
have been impossible.
The steamboat was, if anything, a little ahead of the steam-
engine in its earlier phases. There was a steamboat, the Charlotte
Dundas, on the Firth of Clyde Canal in 1802, and in 1807 an Amer-
ican named Fulton had a paying steamer, The Ckrmont, with
British-built engines, upon the Hudson River above New York.
The first steamship to put to sea was also an American, the
Phcenix, which went from New York (Hoboken) to Philadelphia.
So, too, was the first ship using steam (she also had sails) to cross
the Atlantic, the Savannah (1819). All these were paddle-wheel
boats, and paddle-wheel boats are not adapted to work in heavy
seas. The paddles smash too easily, and the boat is then dis-
abled. The screw steamship followed rather slowly. Many
difficulties had to be surmounted before the screw was a practicable
thing. Not until the middle of the century did the tonnage of
steamships upon the sea begin to overhaul that of sailing-ships.
After that the evolution in sea transport was rapid. For the first
time men began to cross the seas and oceans with some certainty
as to the date of their arrival. The transatlantic crossing, which
had been an uncertain adventure of several weeks — which might
stretch to months — was accelerated, until in 1910 it was brought
down, in the case of the fastest boats, to under five days, with a
practically notifiable hour of arrival. All over the oceans there
was the same reduction in the time and the same increase in the
certainty of human communications.
Concurrently with the development of steam transport upon
land and sea a new and striking addition to the facilities of
human intercourse arose out of the investigations of Volta,
Galvani, and Faraday into various electrical phenomena. The
electric telegraph came into existence in 1835. The first under-
seas cable was laid in 1851 between France and England. In a
few years the telegraph system had spread over the civilized
world, and news which had hitherto travelled slowly from point
to point became practically simultaneous throughout the earth.
These things, the steam railway and the electric telegraph, were
to the popular imagination of the middle nineteenth century the
most striking and revolutionary of inventions, but they were
388 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
only the most conspicuous and clumsy firstfruits of a far more
extensive process. Technical knowledge and skill were develop-
ing with an extraordinary rapidity, and to an extraordinary extent
measured by the progress of any previous age. Far less con-
spicuous at first in everyday life, but finally far more important,
was the extension of man's power over various structural materials.
Before the middle of the eighteenth century iron was reduced
from its ores by means of wood-charcoal, was handled in small
pieces, and hammered and wrought into shape. It was material
for a craftsman. Quality and treatment were enormously de-
pendent upon the experience and sagacity of the individual iron
worker. The largest masses of iron that could be dealt with
under those conditions amounted at most (in the sixteenth century)
to two or three tons. (There was a very definite upward limit,
therefore, to the size of cannon.) The blast furnace arose in the
eighteenth century, and developed with the use of coke. Not
before the eighteenth century do we find rolled sheet iron (1728)
and rolled rods and bars (1783). Nasmyth's steam hammer
came as late as 1838. The ancient world, because of its metal-
lurgical inferiority, could not use steam. The steam engine,
even the primitive pumping engine, could not develop before
sheet iron was available. The early engines seem to the modern
eye very pitiful and clumsy bits of ironmongery, but they were
the utmost that the metallurgical science of the time could do.
As late as 1856 came the Bessemer process, and presently (1864)
the open-hearth process, in which steel and every sort of iron
could be melted, purified, and cast in a manner and upon a scale
hitherto unheard of. To-day in the electric furnace one may see
tons of incandescent steel swirling about like boiling milk in a
saucepan. Nothing in the previous practical advances of mankind
is comparable in its consequences to the complete mastery over
enormous masses of steel and iron and over their texture and
quality which man has now achieved. The railways and early
engines of all sorts were the mere first triumphs of the new metal-
lurgical methods. Presently came ships of iron and steel, vast
bridges, and a new way of building with steel upon a gigantic
scale. Men realized too late that they had planned their railways
with far too timid a gauge, that they could have organized their
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY 389
travelling with far more steadiness and comfort upon a much
bigger scale.
Before the nineteenth century there were no ships in the world
much over 2,000 tons burthen ; now there is nothing wonderful
about a 50,000-ton liner. There are people who sneer at this kind
of progress as being a progress in "mere size," but that sort of
sneering merely marks the intellectual limitations of those who in-
dulge in it. The great ship or the steel-frame building is not,
as they imagine, a magnified version of the small ship or building
of the past ; it is a thing different in kind, more lightly and strongly
built, of finer and stronger materials ; instead of being a thing of
precedent and rule-of -thumb, it is a thing of subtle and intricate
calculation. In the old house or ship, matter was dominant — the
material and its needs had to be slavishly obeyed; in the new,
matter has been captured, changed, coerced. Think of the coal
and iron and sand dragged out of the banks and pits, wrenched,
wrought, molten and cast, to be flung at last, a slender, glittering
pinnacle of steel and glass, six hundred feet above the crowded
city!
We have given these particulars of the advance in man's know-
ledge of the metallurgy of steel and its results by way of illustration.
A parallel story could be told of the metallurgy of copper and tin,
and of a multitude of metals, nickel and aluminium to name but
two, unknown before the nineteenth century dawned. It is in
this great and growing mastery over substances, over different
sorts of glass, over rocks and plasters and the like, over colours
and textures, that the main triumphs of the mechanical revolution
have thus far been achieved. Yet we are still in the stage of the
firstfruits in the matter. We have the power, but we have still
to learn how to use our power. Many of the first employments of
these gifts of science have been vulgar, tawdry, stupid, or horrible.
The artist and the adaptor have still hardly begun to work with
the endless variety of substances now at their disposal.
Concurrently with this extension of mechanical possibilities
the new science of electricity grew up. It was only in the eighties
of the nineteenth century that this body of inquiry began to yield
results to impress the vulgar mind. Then suddenly came electric
light and electric traction; and the transmutation of forces,
390 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
the possibility of sending power, that could be changed into
mechanical motion or light or heat as one chose, along a copper
wire, as water is sent along a pipe, began to come through to the
ideas of ordinary people. . . .
The British and the French were at first the leading peoples in
this great proliferation of knowledge ; but presently the German,
who had learnt humility under Napoleon, showed such zeal and
pertinacity in scientific inquiry as to overhaul these leaders.
British science was largely the creation of Englishmen and Scotch-
men 1 working outside the ordinary centres of erudition.2 We have
told how in England the universities after the reformation ceased
to have a wide popular appeal, how they became the educational
preserve of the nobility and gentry, and the strongholds of the
established church. A pompous and unintelligent classical preten-
tiousness dominated them, and they dominated the schools of the
middle and upper classes. The only knowledge recognized was
an uncritical textual knowledge of a selection of Latin and Greek
classics, and the test of a good style was its abundance of quota-
tions, allusions, and stereotyped expressions. The early develop-
ment of British science went on, therefore, in spite of the formal
educational organization, and in the teeth of the bitter hostility
of the teaching and clerical professions. French education, too,
was dominated by the classical tradition of the Jesuits, and
consequently it was not difficult for the Germans to organize a
body of investigators, small indeed in relation to the possibilities
of the case, but large in proportion to the little band of British and
French inventors and experimentalists. And though this work
of research and experiment was making Britain and France the
most rich and powerful countries in the world, it was not making
scientific and inventive men rich and powerful. There is a neces-
sary unworldliness about a sincere scientific man; he is too pre-
occupied with his research to plan and scheme how to make money
out of it. The economic exploitation of his discoveries falls very
1 But note Boyle and Sir Wm. Hamilton as conspicuous scientific men who were
Irishmen.
2 It is worth noting that nearly all the great inventors in England during the
eighteenth century were working men,£that inventions proceeded from the work-
shop, and not from the laboratory. It is also worth noting that only two of these
inventors accumulated fortunes and founded families. — E. B.
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY 391
easily and naturally, therefore, into the hands of a more acquisitive
type ; and so we find that the crops of rich men which every fresh
phase of scientific and technical progress has produced in Great
Britain, though they have not displayed quite the same passionate
desire to insult and kill the goose that laid the national golden eggs
as the scholastic and clerical professions, have been quite content
to let that profitable creature starve. Inventors and discoverers
came by nature, they thought, for cleverer people to profit by.
In this matter the Germans were a little wiser. The German
" learned" did not display the same vehement hatred of the new
learning. They permitted its development. The German busi-
ness man and manufacturer again had not quite the same con-
tempt for the man of science as had his British competitor. Know-
ledge, these Germans believed, might be a cultivated crop, respon-
sive to fertilizers. They did concede, therefore, a certain amount
of opportunity to the scientific mind; their public expenditure
on scientific work was relatively greater, and this expenditure was
abundantly rewarded. By the latter half of the nineteenth
century the German scientific worker had made German a neces-
sary language for every science student who wished to keep abreast
with the latest work in his department, and in certain branches,
and particularly in chemistry, Germany acquired a very great
superiority over her western neighbours. The scientific effort
of the sixties and seventies in Germany began to tell after the
eighties, and the Germans gained steadily upon Britain and France
in technical and industrial prosperity.
In an Outline of History such as this it is impossible to trace
the network of complex mental processes that led to the incessant
extension of knowledge and power that is now going on; all we
can do here is to call the reader's attention to the most salient
turning-points that finally led the toboggan of human affairs into
its present swift ice-run of progress. We have told of the first
release of human curiosity and of the beginnings of systematic
inquiry and experiment. We have told, too, how, when the
plutocratic Roman system and its resultant imperialism had
come and gone again, this process of inquiry was renewed.
We have told of the escape of investigation from ideas of secrecy
and personal advantage to the idea of publication and a brother-
392 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
hood of knowledge, and we have noted the foundation of the
British Royal Society, the Florentine Society, and their like as a
consequence of this socializing of thought. These things were
the roots of the mechanical revolution, and so long as the root of
pure scientific inquiry lives, that revolution will progress. The
mechanical revolution itself began, we may say, with the exhaus-
tion of the wood supply for the ironworks of England. This led
to the use of coal, the coal mine led to the simple pumping engine,
the development of the pumping engine by Watt into a machine-
driving engine led on to the locomotive and the steamship. This
was the first phase of a great expansion in the use of steam. A
second phase in the mechanical revolution began with the appli-
cation of electrical science to practical problems and the develop-
ment of electric lighting, power-transmission, and traction.
A third phase is to be distinguished when in the eighties a new
type of engine came into use, an engine in which the expansive force
of an explosive mixture replaced the expansive force of steam. The
light, highly efficient engines that were thus made possible were
applied to the automobile, and developed at last to reach such a
pitch of lightness and efficiency as to render flight — long known
to be possible — a practical achievement. A successful flying-
machine — but not a machine large enough to take up a human
body — was made by Professor Langley of the Smithsonian
Institution of Washington as early as 1897. By 1909 the aeroplane
was available for human locomotion. There had seemed to be a
pause in the increase of human speed with the perfection of rail-
ways and automobile road traction, but with the flying-machine
came fresh reductions in the effective distance between one point
of the earth's surface and another. In the eighteenth century the
distance from London to Edinburgh was an eight days' journey;
in 1918 the British Civil Air Transport Commission reported that
the journey from London to Melbourne, half-way round the earth,
would probably, in a few years' time, be accomplished in that same
period of eight days.
Too much stress must not be laid upon these striking reductions
in the time distances of one place from another. They are merely
one aspect of a much profounder and more momentous enlarge-
ment of human possibility. The science of agriculture and agri-
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY 393
cultural chemistry, for instance, made quite parallel advances
during the nineteenth century. Men learnt so to fertilize the soil
as to produce quadruple and quintuple the crops got from the
same area in the seventeenth century. There was a still more
extraordinary advance in medical science; the average duration
of life rose, the daily efficiency increased, the waste of life through
ill-health diminished.
Now here altogether we have such a change in human life as
to constitute a fresh phase of history. In a little more than a
century this mechanical revolution has been brought about.
In that time man made a stride in the material conditions of his
life vaster than he had done during the whole long interval be-
tween the palaeolithic stage and the age of cultivation, or between
the days of Pepi in Egypt and those of George III. A new
gigantic material framework for human affairs has come unto
existence. Clearly it demands great readjustments of our social,
economical, and political methods. But these readjustments
have necessarily waited upon the development of the mechanical
revolution, and they are still only in their opening stage to-day.
§2
There is a tendency in many histories to confuse together what
we have here called the mechanical revolution, which was an entirely
new thing in human experience arising out of the development of
organized science, a new step like the invention of agriculture or the
discovery of metals, with something else, quite different in its
origins, something for which there was already an historical pre-
cedent, the social and financial development which is called the
industrial revolution. The two processes were going on together,
they were constantly reacting upon each other, but they were
in root and essence different. There would have been an industrial
revolution of sorts if there had been no coal, no steam, no machin-
ery ; but in that case it would probably have followed far more
closely upon the lines of the social and financial developments of
the later years of the Roman republic. It would have repeated
the story of dispossessed free cultivators, gang labour, great estates,
great financial fortunes, and a socially destructive financial process.
Even the factory method came before power and machinery.
394 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
Factories were the product not of machinery, but of the " division
of labour." Drilled and sweated workers were making such things
as millinery, cardboard boxes, and furniture, and colouring maps
and book illustrations, and so forth, before even water-wheels had
been used for industrial processes. There were factories in Rome
in the days of Augustus. New books, for instance, were dictated
to rows of copyists in the factories of the booksellers. The
attentive student of Defoe and of the political pamphlets of
Fielding will realize that the idea of herding poor people into
establishments to work collectively for their living was already
current in Britain before the close of the seventeenth century.
There are intimations of it even as early as More's Utopia (1516).
It was a social and not a mechanical development.
Up to past the middle of the eighteenth century the social and
economic history of western Europe was in fact retreading the
path along which the Roman State had gone in the three last
centuries B.C. America was in many ways a new Spain, and India
and China a new Egypt. But the political disunions of Europe,
the political convulsions against monarchy, the recalcitrance of
the common folk and perhaps also the greater accessibility of the
western European intelligence to mechanical ideas and inventions,
turned the process into quite novel directions. Ideas of human
solidarity, thanks to Christianity, were far more widely diffused
in this newer European world, political power was not so con-
centrated, and the man of energy anxious to get rich turned
his mind, therefore, very willingly from the ideas of the slave
and of gang labour to the idea of mechanical power and the
machine.
The mechanical revolution, the process of mechanical invention
and discovery, was a new thing in human experience, and it went
on regardless of the social, political, economic, and industrial
consequences it might produce. The industrial revolution, on
the other hand, like most other human affairs, was and is more
and more profoundly changed and deflected by the constant
variation in human conditions caused by the mechanical revolution.
And the essential difference between the amassing of riches, the
extinction of small farmers and small business men, and the phase
of big finance in the latter centuries of the Roman republic on
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY 395
the one hand, and the very similar concentration of capital in
the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries on the other, lies in the
profound difference in the character of labour that the mechanical
revolution was bringing about. The power of the old world was
human power ; everything depended ultimately upon the driving
power of human muscle, the muscle of ignorant and subjugated
men. A little animal muscle, supplied by draft oxen, horse
traction, and the like, contributed. Where a weight had to be
lifted, men lifted it ; where a rock had to be quarried, men chipped
it out ; where a field had to be ploughed, men and oxen ploughed
it; the Roman equivalent of the steamship was the galley with
its banks of sweating rowers. A vast proportion of mankind in
the early civilizations was employed in purely mechanical drudgery.
At its onset, power-driven machinery did not seem to promise any
release from such unintelligent toil. Great gangs of men were
employed in excavating canals, in making railway cuttings and
embankments, and the like. The number of miners increased
enormously. But the extension of facilities and the output of
commodities increased much more. And as the nineteenth cen-
tury went on, the plain logic of the new situation asserted itself
more clearly. Human beings were no longer wanted as a source
of mere indiscriminated power. What could be done mechanically
by a human being could be done faster and better by a machine.
The human being was needed now only where choice and in-
telligence had to be exercised. Human beings were wanted only
as human beings. The drudge, on whom all the previous civili-
zations had rested, the creature of mere obedience, the man whose
brains were superfluous, had become unnecessary to the welfare of
mankind.
This was as true of such ancient industries as agriculture and
mining as it was of the newest metallurgical processes. For
ploughing, sowing, and harvesting, swift machines came forward
to do the work of scores of men.1 The Roman civilization was
built upon cheap and degraded human beings; modern civil-
ization is being rebuilt upon cheap mechanical power. For a
hundred years power has been getting cheaper and labour dearer.
If for a generation or so machinery has had to wait its turn in the
1 Here America led the old world.
396 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
mine, it is simply because for a time men were cheaper than
machinery.1
Now here was a change-over of quite primary importance in
human affairs. The chief solicitude of the rich and of the ruler
in the old civilization had been to keep up a supply of drudges.
As the nineteenth century went on, it became more and more plain
to the intelligent directive people that the common man had now
to be something better than a drudge. He had to be educated —
if only to secure " industrial efficiency." He had to understand
what he was about. From the days of the first Christian prop-
aganda, popular education had been smouldering in Europe,
just as it has smouldered in Asia wherever Islam has set its foot,
because of the necessity of making the believer understand a little
of the belief by which he is saved, and of enabling him to read a
little in the sacred books by which his belief is conveyed. Chris-
tian controversies, with their competition for adherents, ploughed
the ground for the harvest of popular education. In England, for
instance, by the thirties and forties of the nineteenth century, the
disputes of the sects and the necessity of catching adherents young
had produced an abundance of night schools, Sunday schools,
and a series of competing educational organizations for children,
the dissenting British schools, the church National Schools, and
even Roman Catholic elementary schools. The earlier, less
enlightened manufacturers, unable to take a broad view of their
own interests, hated and opposed these schools. But here again
needy Germany led her richer neighbours. The religious teacher
found the profit-seeker at his side, unexpectedly eager to get the
commonalty, if not educated, at least " trained." The student of
the English magazines of the middle and later Victorian period
may trace the steadily spreading recognition of the new necessity
for popular education. The upper and middle classes of England,
themselves by no means well educated, for a generation or so
regarded popular education with a sort of tittering hostility. In
the middle Victorian period it was thought to be extraordinarily
funny that a shop assistant should lean across the counter and
1 In Northumberland and Durham in the early days of coal mining they were
so cheaply esteemed that it was unusual to hold inquests on the bodies of men killed
in mine disasters.
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY 397
ask two lady customers not to speak French, as he "understood
the langwidge." This was a "joke" in that monumental record
of British humour, Punch. It was almost as amusing to the
Victorian English as the story of Balaam's ass. The German com-
petitor later on robbed .that joke of its fun. Before the death of
Queen Victoria, English shop assistants were being badgered to
attend evening classes to learn French.
The second half of the nineteenth century was a period of rapid
advance in popular education throughout all the Westernized
world. There was no parallel advance in the education of the
upper classes, some advance no doubt, but nothing to correspond,
and so the great gulf that had divided that world hitherto into
the readers and the non-reading mass became little more than a
slightly perceptible difference in educational level. At the back
of this process was the mechanical revolution, apparently regard-
less of social conditions, but really insisting inexorably upon the
complete abolition of a totally illiterate class throughout the
world.
The economic revolution of the Roman republic had never been
clearly apprehended by the common people of Rome. The
ordinary Roman citizen never saw the changes through which he
lived, clearly and comprehensively as we see them. But the
industrial revolution, as it went on towards the end of the nine-
teenth century, was more and more distinctly seen as one whole
process by the common people it was affecting, because presently
they could read and discuss and communicate, and because they
went about and saw things as no commonalty had ever done
before.
In this Outline of History we have been careful to indicate the
gradual appearance of the ordinary people as a class with a will
and ideas in common. It is the writer's belief that massive move-
ments of the "ordinary people" over considerable areas only
became possible as a result of the propagandist religions, Chris-
tianity and Islam, and their insistence upon individual self-respect.
We have cited the enthusiasm of the commonalty for the First
Crusade as marking a new phase in social history. But before the
nineteenth century even these massive movements were com-
paratively restricted. The equalitarian insurrections of the
398 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
peasantry, from the Wycliffe period onward, were confined to the
peasant communities of definite localities, they spread only slowly
into districts affected by similar forces. The town artisan rioted
indeed, but only locally. The chateau-burning of the French
revolution was not the act of a peasantry who had overthrown
a government, it was the act of a peasantry released by the over-
throw of a government. The Commune of Paris was the first
effective appearance of the town artisan as a political power, and
the Parisian crowd of the First Revolution was a very mixed,
primitive-thinking, and savage crowd compared with any Western
European crowd after 1830.
But the mechanical revolution was not only pressing educa-
tion upon the whole population, it was leading to a big-capitalism
and to a large-scale reorganization of industry that was to produce
a new and distinctive system of ideas in the common people in
the place of the mere uncomfortable recalcitrance and elemental
rebellions of an illiterate commonalty. We have already noted
how the industrial revolution had split the manufacturing class,
which had hitherto been a middling and various sort of class, into
two sections, the employers, who became rich enough to mingle with
the financial, merchandizing, and landowning classes, and the em-
ployees, who drifted to a status closer and closer to that of mere gang
and agricultural labour. As the manufacturing employee sank, the
agricultural labourer, by the introduction of agricultural machinery
and the increase in his individual productivity, rose. By the
middle of the nineteenth century, Karl Marx (1818-83), a German
Jew of great scholarly attainments, who did much of his work in
the British Museum library in London, was pointing out that the
organization of the working classes by the steadily concentrating
group of capitalist owners, was developing a new social classifica-
tion to replace the more complex class systems of the past (see
chapter xx, §§ 4, 5, and 6). Property, so far as it was power, was
being gathered together into relatively few hands, the hands of
the big rich men, the capitalist class ; while there was a great
mingling of workers with little or no property, whom he called
the " expropriated," or "proletariat" —a misuse of this word
(see chap, xxvii, § 2) — who were bound to develop a common
"class consciousness" of the conflict of their interests with those
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY 399
of the rich men. Differences of education and tradition between
the various older social elements which were in process of being
fused up into the new class of the expropriated, seemed for a time
to contradict this sweeping generalization; the traditions of the
professions, the small employers, the farmer peasant and the like
were all different from one another and from the various craftsman
traditions of the workers ; but with the spread of education and the
cheapening of literature, this " Marxian" generalization becomes
now more and more acceptable. These classes, who were linked
at first by nothing but a common impoverishment, were and are
being reduced or raised to the same standard of life, forced to
read the same books and share the same inconveniences. A sense
of solidarity between all sorts of poor and propertyless men,
as against the profit-amassing and wealth-concentrating class, is
growing more and more evident in our world. Old differences
fade away, the difference between craftsman and open-air worker,
between black coat and overall, between poor clergyman and
elementary school-master, between policeman and bus-driver.
They must all buy the same cheap furnishings and live in similar
cheap houses ; their sons and daughters will all mingle and marry ;
success at the upper levels becomes more and more hopeless for the
rank and file. Marx, who did not so much advocate the class-
war, the war of the expropriated mass against the appropriating
few, as foretell it, is being more and more justified by events.1
§3
To trace any broad outlines in the fermentation of ideas that
went on during the mechanical and industrial revolution of the
nineteenth century is a very difficult task. But we must attempt
it if we are to link what has gone before in this history with the
condition of our world to-day.
1 It is sometimes argued against Marx that the proportion of people who have
savings invested has increased in many modern communities. These savings are
technically "capital" and their owners "capitalists" to that extent, and this is
supposed to contradict the statement of Marx that property concentrates into few
and fewer hands. Marx used many of his terms carelessly and chose them ill,
and his ideas were better than his words. When he wrote property he meant
"property so far as it is power." The small investor has remarkably little power
over his invested capital.
400 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
It will be convenient to distinguish two main periods in the
hundred years between ^1814 and 1914. First came the period
1814-48, in which there was a very considerable amount of liberal
thinking and writing in limited circles, but during which there were
no great changes or development of thought in the general mass of
the people. Throughout this period the world's affairs were living,
so to speak, on their old intellectual capital, they were going on in
accordance with the leading ideas of the Revolution and the counter-
revolution. The dominant liberal ideas were freedom and a cer-
tain vague equalitarianism ; the conservative ideas were monarchy,
organized religion, social privilege, and obedience.
Until 1848 the spirit of the Holy Alliance, the spirit of Metternich,
struggled to prevent a revival of the European revolution that
Napoleon had betrayed and set back. In America, both North
and South, on the other hand, the revolution had triumphed and
nineteenth-century liberalism ruled unchallenged. Britain was
an uneasy country, never quite loyally reactionary nor quite
loyally progressive, neither truly monarchist nor truly republican,
the land of Cromwell and also of the Merry Monarch, Charles ;
anti-Austrian, anti-Bourbon, anti-papal, yet weakly repressive.
We have told of the first series of liberal storms in Europe in and
about the year 1830; in Britain in 1832 a Reform Bill, greatly
extending the franchise and restoring something of its representa-
tive character to the House of Commons, relieved the situation.
Round and about 1848 came a second and much more serious
system of outbreaks, that overthrew the Orleans monarchy and
established a second Republic in France (1848-52), raised North
Italy and Hungary against Austria, and the Poles in Posen against
the Germans, and sent the Pope in flight from the republicans of
Rome. A very interesting Pan-Slavic conference held at Prague
foreshadowed many of the territorial readjustments of 1919. It
dispersed after an insurrection at Prague had been suppressed
by Austrian troops.
Ultimately all these insurrections failed; the current system
staggered, but kept its feet. There were no doubt serious social
discontents beneath these revolts, but as yet, except in the case
of Paris, these had no very clear form ; and this 1848 storm, so
far as the rest of Europe was concerned, may be best described, in
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY 401
a phrase, as a revolt of the natural political map against the
artificial arrangements of the Vienna diplomatists, and the system
of suppressions those arrangements entailed.
The history of Europe, then, from 1815 to 1848 was, generally
speaking, a sequel to the history of Europe from 1789 to 1814.
There were no really new motifs in the composition. The main
trouble was still the struggle, though often a blind and mis-
directed struggle, of the interests of ordinary men against the Great
Powers system which cramped and oppressed the life of mankind.
But after 1848, from 1848 to 1914, though the readjustment
of the map still went on towards a free and unified Italy and a
unified Germany, there began a fresh phase in the process of mental
and political adaptation to the new knowledge and the new material
powers of mankind. Came a great irruption of new social, religious,
and political ideas into the general European mind. In the next
three sections we will consider the origin and quality of these
irruptions. They laid the foundations upon which we base our
political thought to-day, but for a long time they had no very
great effect on contemporary politics. Contemporary politics
continued to run on in the old lines, but with a steadily diminish-
ing support in the intellectual convictions and consciences of men.
We have already described the way in which a strong intellectual
process undermined the system of Grand Monarchy in France
before 1789. A similar undermining process was going on through-
out Europe during the Great Power period of 1848-1914. Pro-
found doubts of the system of government and of the liberties of
many forms of property in the economic system spread throughout
the social body. Then came the greatest and most disorganizing
war in history, so that it is still impossible to estimate the power
and range of the accumulated new ideas of those sixty-six years.
We have been through a greater catastrophe even than the Napole-
onic catastrophe, and we are in a slack-water period, corresponding
to the period 1815-30. Our 1830 and our 1848 are still to come
and show us where we stand.
§4
We have traced throughout this history the gradual restriction
of the idea of property from the first unlimited claim of the strong
2D
402 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
man to possess everything and the gradual realization of brother-
hood as something transcending personal self-seeking (see especially
chap, xxxvii, § 13). Men were first subjugated into more than
tribal societies by the fear of monarch and deity. It is only within
the last three or at most four thousand years that we have any
clear evidence that voluntary self-abandonment to some greater
end, without fee or reward, was an acceptable idea to men, or that
anyone had propounded it. Then we find spreading over the
surface of human affairs, as patches of sunshine spread and pass
over the hillsides upon a windy day in spring, the idea that there
is a happiness in self-devotion greater than any personal gratifica-
tion or triumph, and a life of mankind different and greater and
more important than the sum of all the individual lives within it.
We have seen that idea become vivid as a beacon, vivid as sun-
shine caught and reflected dazzlingly by some window in the land-
scape, in the teaching of Buddha, Lao Tse, and, most clearly
of all, of Jesus of Nazareth. Through all its variations and
corruptions Christianity has never completely lost the suggestion
of a devotion to God's commonweal that makes the personal
pomps of monarchs and rulers seem like the insolence of an over-
dressed servant and the splendours and gratifications of wealth
like the waste of robbers. No man living in a community which
such a religion as Christianity or Islam has touched can be alto-
gether a slave ; there is an ineradicable quality in these religions
that compels men to judge their masters and to realize their own
responsibility for the world.
As men have felt their way towards this new state of mind from
the fierce self-centred greed and instinctive combativeness of the
early Palaeolithic family group, they have sought to express the
drift of their thoughts and necessities very variously. They
have found themselves in disagreement and conflict with old-
established ideas, and there has been a natural tendency to con-
tradict these ideas flatly, to fly over to the absolute contrary.
Faced by a world in which rule and classes and order seem to do
little but give opportunity for personal selfishness and unrighteous
oppression, the first impatient movement was to declare for a
universal equality and a practical anarchy. Faced by a world
in which property seemed little more than a protection for selfish-
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY 403
ness and a method of enslavement, it was as natural to repudiate
all property. Our history shows an increasing impulse to revolt
against rulers and against ownership. We have traced it in the
middle ages burning the rich man's chateaux and experimenting
in theocracy and communism. In the French revolutions this
double revolt is clear and plain. In France we find side by side,
inspired by the same spirit and as natural parts of the same revolu-
tionary movement, men who, with their eyes on the ruler's taxes,
declared that property should be inviolable, and others who, with
their eyes on the employer's hard bargains, declared that property
should be abolished. But what they are really revolting against
in each case is that the ruler and the employer, instead of becoming
servants of the community, still remain, like most of mankind,
self-seeking, oppressive individuals.
Throughout the ages we find this belief growing in men's minds
that there can' be such a rearrangement of laws and powers as
to give rule and order while still restraining the egotism of any
ruler and of any ruling class that may be necessary, and such a
definition of property as will give freedom without oppressive
power. We begin to realize nowadays that these ends are only
to be attained by a complex constructive effort; they arise
through the conflict of new human needs against ignorance
and old human nature; but throughout the nineteenth century
there was a persistent disposition to solve the problem by some
simple formula. (And be happy ever afterwards, regardless of
the fact that all human life, all life, is throughout the ages
nothing but the continuing solution of a continuous synthetic
problem.)
The earlier half of the nineteenth century saw a number of
experiments in the formation of trial human societies of a new kind.
One of these, the Oneida Community (1845-79), under the leader-
ship of a man of very considerable genius and learning, John
Humphry Noyes, did for a number of decades succeed in realizing
many of the most striking proposals of Plato's Republic; it be-
came wealthy and respected ; but it broke up in 1879 largely be-
cause of the disposition of the younger generation to leave its
peculiar limitations in order to play a part in the larger community
of the world outside. A powerful business corporation still pre-
404 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
serves its industrial tradition.1 But the Oneida experiment was
too bold and strange a departure to influence the general develop-
ment of modern civilization. Far more important historically
were the experiments and ideas of Robert Owen (1771-1858), a
Manchester cotton-spinner. He is very generally regarded as the
founder of modern Socialism ; it was in connection with his work
that the word "socialism" first arose (about 1835).
He seems to have been a thoroughly competent business man ;
he made a number of innovations in the cotton-spinning industry,
and acquired a fair fortune at an early age. He was distressed
by the waste of human possibilities among his workers, and he set
himself to improve their condition and the relations of employer
and employed. This he sought to do first at his Manchester
factory and afterwards at New Lanark, where he found himself in
practical control of works employing about two thousand people.
Between 1800 and 1828 he achieved very considerable things : he
reduced the hours of labour, made his factory sanitary and agree-
able, abolished the employment of very young children, improved
the training of his workers, provided unemployment pay during a
period of trade depression, established a system of schools, and
made New Lanark a model of a better industrialism, while at the
same time sustaining its commercial prosperity. He wrote vigor-
ously to defend the mass of mankind against the charges of intem-
perance and improvidence which were held to justify the economic
iniquities of the time.2 He held that men and women are largely
the product of their educational environment, a thesis that needs
no advocacy to-day. And he set himself to a propaganda of the
views that New Lanark had justified. He attacked the selfish
indolence of his fellow manufacturers, and in 1819, largely under
his urgency, the first Factory Act was passed, the first attempt
to restrain employers from taking the most stupid and intolerable
advantages of their workers' poverty. Some of the restrictions
of that Act amaze us to-day. It seems incredible now that it
should ever have been necessary to protect little children of
1 See J. H. Noyes, History of American Socialisms, and Eastlake, The Oneida
Community.
2 See his A New View of Society, or Essays on the Principles of the Formation of
the Human Character.
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY 405
nine ( \ ) from work in factories, or to limit the nominal working
day of such employees to twelve hours !
People are perhaps too apt to write of the industrial revolution
as though it led to the enslavement and overworking of poor
children who had hitherto been happy and free. But this mis-
interprets history. From the very beginnings of civilization the
little children of the poor had always been obliged to do whatever
work they could do. But the factory system gathered up all this
infantile toil and made it systematic, conspicuous, and scandalous.
The factory system challenged the quickening human conscience
on that issue. The British Factory Act of 1819, weak and feeble
though it seems to us, was the Magna Carta of childhood ; there-
after the protection of the children of the poor, first from toil
and then from bodily starvation and ignorance, began.
We cannot tell here in any detail the full story of Owen's life
and thought.1 His work at New Lanark had been, he felt, only
a trial upon a small working model. What could be done for one
industrial community could be done, he held, for every industrial
community in the country; he advocated a resettlement of the
industrial population in townships on the New Lanark plan. For
a time he seemed to have captured the imagination of the world.
The Times and Morning Post supported his proposals; among
the visitors to New Lanark was the Grand Duke Nicholas who
succeeded Alexander I as Tsar; a fast friend was the Duke of
Kent, son of George III and father of Queen Victoria. But all
the haters of change and all — and there are always many such
- who were jealous of the poor, and all the employers who were
likely to be troubled by his projects, were waiting for an excuse to
counter-attack him, and they found it in the expression of his
religious opinions, which were hostile to official Christianity, and
through those he was successfully discredited. But he continued
to develop his projects and experiments, of which the chief was a
community at New Harmony in Indiana (U. S. A.), in which he
sank most of his capital. His partners bought him out of the New
Lanark business in 1828.
Owen's experiments and suggestions ranged very widely, and
1 See F. Podmore, Life of Robert Owen, or his own Life of Robert Owen, Written
by Himself.
406 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
do not fall under any single formula. There was nothing doc-
trinaire about him. His New Lanark experiment was the first
of a number of " benevolent businesses" in the world ; Lord Lever-
hulme's Port Sunlight, the Cadburys' Bournville, and the Ford
businesses in America are contemporary instances; it was not
really a socialist experiment at all; it was a "paternal" experi-
ment. But his proposals for state settlements were what we
should call state socialism to-day. His American experiment
and his later writings point to a completer form of socialism, a
much wider departure from the existing state of affairs. It is
clear that the riddle of currency exercised Owen. He understood
that we can no more hope for real economic justice while we pay
for work with money of fluctuating value than we could hope for a
punctual world if there was a continual inconstant variability
in the length of an hour. One of his experiments was an attempt
at a circulation of labour notes representing one hour, five hours,
or twenty hours of work. The co-operative societies of to-day,
societies of poor men which combine for the collective buying
and distribution of commodities or for collective manufacture
or dairying or other forms of agriculture, arose directly out of his
initiatives, though the pioneer co-operative societies of his own
time ended in failure. Their successors have spread throughout
the whole world, and number to-day some thirty or forty million
of adherents.
A point to note about this early socialism of Owen's is that it
was not at first at all "democratic." Its initiative was benev-
olent, its early form patriarchal ; it was something up to which the
workers were to be educated by liberally disposed employers and
leaders. The first socialism was not a worker's movement ; it was
a master's movement.
Concurrently with this work of Owen's, another and quite
independent series of developments was going on in America and
Britain which was destined to come at last into reaction with his
socialistic ideas. The English law had long prohibited combina-
tions in restraint of trade, combinations to raise prices or wages
by concerted action. There had been no great hardship in these
prohibitions before the agrarian and industrial changes of the
eighteenth century let loose a great swarm of workers living from
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY 407
hand to mouth and competing for insufficient employment. Under
these new conditions, the workers in many industries found them-
selves intolerably squeezed. They were played off one against
another ; day by day and hour by hour none knew what conces-
sion his fellow might not have made, and what further reduction
of pay or increase of toil might not ensue. It became vitally
necessary for the workers to make agreements — illegal though
they were — against such underselling. At first these agree-
ments had to be made and sustained by secret societies. Or
clubs, established ostensibly for quite other purposes, social clubs,
funeral societies, and the like, served to mask the wage-protecting
combination. The fact that these associations were illegal dis-
posed them to violence; they were savage against "blacklegs"
and "rats" who would not join them, and still more savage with
traitors. In 1824 the House of Commons recognized the desira-
bility of relieving tension in these matters by conceding the right
of workmen to form combinations for "collective bargaining"
with the masters. This enabled Trade Unions to develop with a
large measure of freedom. At first very clumsy and primitive
organizations and with very restricted freedoms, the Trade Unions
have risen gradually to be a real Fourth Estate in the country,
a great system of bodies representing the mass of industrial
workers.
Arising at first in Britain and America, they have, with various
national modifications, and under varying legal conditions, spread
to France, Germany, and all the westernized communities.
Organized originally to sustain wages and restrict intolerable
hours, the Trade Union movement was at first something alto-
gether distinct from socialism. The Trade Unionist tried to make
the best -for himself of the existing capitalism and the existing
conditions of employment; the socialist proposed to change the
system. It was the imagination and generalizing power of Karl
Marx which brought these two movements into relationship.
He was a man with the sense of history very strong in him ; he
was the first to perceive that the old social classes that had endured
since the beginning of civilization were in process of dissolution
and regrouping. His racial Jewish commercialism made the
antagonism of property and labour very plain to him. And his
408 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
upbringing in Germany — where, as we have pointed out, the
tendency of class to harden into caste was more evident than in
any other European country — made him conceive of labour as
presently becoming " class conscious" and collectively antag-
onistic to the property-concentrating classes. In the Trade Union
movement which was spreading over the world, he believed he
saw this development of class-conscious labour.
What, he asked, would be the outcome of the " class war" of the
capitalist and proletariat ? The capitalist adventurers, he alleged,
because of their inherent greed and combativeness, would gather
power over capital into fewer and fewer hands,1 until at last they
would concentrate all the means of production, transit, and the
like into a form seizable by the workers, whose class consciousness
and solidarity would be developed pari passu by the process of
organizing and concentrating industry. They would seize this
capital and work it for themselves. This would be the social
revolution. Then individual property and freedom would be
restored, based upon the common ownership of the earth and the
management by the community as a whole of the great productive
services which the private capitalist had organized and con-
centrated. This would be the end of the "capitalist" system, but
not the end of the system of capitalism. State capitalism would
replace private owner capitalism.
This marks a great stride away from the socialism of Owen.
Owen (like Plato) looked to the common sense of men of any
or every class to reorganize the casual and faulty political, eco-
nomic, and social structure. Marx found something more in the
nature of a driving force in his class hostility based on expropria-
tion and injustice. And he was not simply a prophetic theorist ;
he was also a propagandist of the revolt of labour, the revolt of the
so-called "proletariat." Labour, he perceived, had a common
interest against the capitalist everywhere, though under the test
of the Great Power wars of the time, and particularly of the libera-
tion of Italy, he showed that he failed to grasp the fact that labour
everywhere has a common interest in the peace of the world. But
1 Increases or diminutions of the passive shareholding class would not affect
this concentration very materially. A shareholder has very little power over his
property.
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY 409
with the social revolution in view he did succeed in inspiring the
formation of an international league of workers, the First Inter-
national.
The subsequent history of socialism is chequered between the
British tradition of Owen and the German class feeling of Marx.
What is called Fabian Socialism, the exposition of socialism by the
London Fabian Society, makes its appeal to reasonable men of all
classes. What are called "Revisionists" in German Socialism
incline in the same direction. But on the whole, it is Marx who
has carried the day against Owen, and the general disposition
of socialists throughout the world is to look to the organization
of labour and labour only to supply the fighting forces that will
disentangle the political and economic organization of human
affairs from the hands of the more or less irresponsible private
owners and adventurers who now control it.
These are the broad features of the project which is called
Socialism. We will discuss its incompletenesses and inade-
quacies in our next section. It was perhaps inevitable that
socialism should be greatly distraught and subdivided by doubts
and disputes and sects and schools ; they are growth symptoms
like the spots on a youth's face. Here we can but glance at the
difference between state socialism, which would run the economic
business of the country through its political government, and the
newer schools of syndicalism and guild socialism which would
entrust a large measure in the government of each industry to
the workers of every grade — including the directors and managers
— engaged in that industry. This "guild socialism" is really a
new sort of capitalism with a committee of workers and officials
in each industry taking the place of the free private capitalists of
that industry. The personnel becomes the collective capitalist.
Nor can we discuss the undemocratic idea of the Russian leader
Lenin, that a population cannot judge of socialism before it has
experienced it, and that a group of socialists are therefore justified
in seizing and socializing, if they can, the life of a country without
at first setting up any democratic form of general government at
all, for which sort of seizure he uses the Marxian phrase, a very
incompetent phrase, the "dictatorship of the proletariat." All
Russia now is a huge experiment in that dictatorship (August,
410 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
1920). l The " proletariat " is supposed to be dictating through
committees of workmen and soldiers, the Soviets, but at present
we have no means of ascertaining how far Russian affairs are under
the direction of a genuine mass intelligence and will, and how far
the activities of the Soviets are restrained and directed by the
group of vigorous personalities which leads the revolution. Nor
do we know if the methods of election used for the Soviets are any
1 1 find in a book of essays and addresses by Professor Soddy an interesting and
compact statement of certain resemblances in spirit between scientific research and
modern socialism. I venture to quote a passage here because of its great signifi-
cance at the present time.
"The immense acquisition," he says, "to the wealth and resources of mankind
which has been the result of the past century of science, should have been the
golden opportunity of statesmen and humanitarians and the raw material out of
which the sum total of human happiness could have been augmented. Instead, it
has but revealed a growing incapacity and failure on the part of the altruist to
appreciate the nature and power of the new weapon that science has placed in his
hands, and an ever-increasing rapacity and far-sightedness on the part of the egotist
to secure it for his own ends.
"For many a decade now, owing primarily and indisputably to the intellectual
achievements of a comparative handful of men of communistic and cloisteral
habit of thought, a steady shower of material benefits has been raining down upon
humanity, and for these benefits men have fought in the traditional manner of the
struggle when the fickle sunlight was the sole hazardous income of the world. The
strong have fed and grown fat upon a larger and ever larger share of the manna.
Initial slight differences of strength and sagacity have become so emphasized by
the virile stream that the more successful are becoming monstrously so, and the
unsuccessful less and less able to secure a full meal than before the shower began.
"Already it savours of indelicacy and tactlessness to recall that the exploiters
of all this wealth are not its creators ; that the spirit of acquisitiveness which has
ensured success to them, rather than to their immediate neighbours, is the antithesis
of the spirit by which the wealth was won.
"Amid all the sneers at the impracticability and visionary character of com-
munist schemes, let it not be forgotten that science is a communism, neither theo-
retical nor on paper, but actual and in practice. The results of those who labour
in the fields of knowledge for its own sake are published freely and pooled in the
general stock for the benefit of all. Common ownership of all its acquisitions is
the breath of its life. Secrecy or individualism of any kind would destroy its
fertility."
So far Professor Soddy, but let the writer add that there is this point about the
scientific world not to be overlooked. Every worker in the latter is a specially
educated man, and he is free to leave the communism of science if he thinks fit.
This is very different from a communism imposed upon an unprepared mass of
people containing large recalcitrant minorities or majorities. A communism sus-
tained by a community of will based on education — an extension, that is, of the
communism of scientific research to human affairs generally — is the ideal under-
lying the political ideas of most intelligent modern men .
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY 411
improvement upon the unsatisfactory methods in use in the
Atlantic democracies. Non-workers have no representation in
this new Russian state.
§5
We are all socialists nowadays, said Sir William Harcourt years
ago, and that is loosely true to-day. There can be few people
who fail to realize the provisional nature and the dangerous in-
stability of our present political and economic system, and still
fewer who believe with the doctrinaire individualists that profit-
hunting "go as you please" will guide mankind to any haven of
prosperity and happiness. Great rearrangements are necessary,
and a systematic legal subordination of personal self-seeking to
the public good. So far most reasonable men are socialists. But
these are only preliminary propositions. How far has socialism
and modern thought generally gone towards working out the con-
ception of this new political and social order, of which our world
admittedly stands in need? We are obliged to answer that there
is no clear conception of the new state towards which we vaguely
struggle, that our science of human relationships is still so crude
and speculative as to leave us without definite guidance upon a
score of primarily important issues. In 1920 we are no more in
a position to set up a scientifically conceived political system in the
world than were men to set up an electric power station in 1820.
They could not have done that then to save their lives.
The Marxist system points us to an accumulation of revolu-
tionary forces in the modern world. These forces will continually
tend towards revolution. But Marx assumed too hastily that a
revolutionary impulse would necessarily produce an ordered state
of a new and better kind. A revolution may stop half way in mere
destruction. No socialist sect has yet defined its projected gov-
ernment clearly; the Bolsheviks in their Russian experiment
seem to have been guided by a phrase, the dictatorship of the
proletariat, and in practice, we are told, Trotsky and Lenin have
proved as autocratic as the less intelligent but equally well-
meaning Tsar, Alexander I. We have been at some pains to show
from our brief study of the French revolution that a revolution
can establish nothing permanent that has not already been thought
412 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
out beforehand and apprehended by the general mind. The
French republic, confronted with unexpected difficulties in eco-
nomics, currency, and international relationships, collapsed to the
egotisms of the newly rich people of the Directory, and finally
to the egotism of Napoleon. Law and a plan, steadily upheld,
are more necessary in revolutionary times than in ordinary hum-
drum times, because in revolutionary times society degenerates
much more readily into a mere scramble under the ascendancy of
the forcible and cunning.
If in general terms we take stock of the political and social
science of our age, we shall measure something of the preliminary
intellectual task still to be done by mankind before we can hope
to see any permanent constructive achievements emerging from
the mere traditionalism and adventuring that rule our collective
affairs to-day. This Socialism, which professes to be a complete
theory of a new social order, we discover, when we look into it,
to be no more than a partial theory — very illuminating, so far
as it goes- — about property. We have already discussed the
relationship of social development to the restriction of the idea
of property (chap, xxxvii, § 13). There are various schools of
thought which would restrict property more or less completely.
Communism is the proposal to abolish property altogether, or, in
other words, to hold all things in common. Modern Socialism,
on the other hand — or, to give it a more precise name, " Collec-
tivism"— does clearly distinguish between personal property
and collective property. The gist of the socialist proposal is that
land and all the natural means of production, transit, and dis-
tribution should be collectively owned. Within these limits there
is to be much free private ownership and unrestricted personal
freedom. Given efficient administration, it may be doubted
whether many people nowadays would dispute that proposal.
But socialism has never gone on to a thorough examination of
that proviso for efficient administration.
Again, what community is it that is to own the collective prop-
erty ; is it to be the sovereign or the township or the county or
the nation or mankind ? Socialism makes no clear answer. Social-
ists are very free with the word " nationalize," but we have been
subjecting the ideas of "nations" and "nationalism" to some
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY 413
destructive criticism in this Outline. If socialists object to a
single individual claiming a mine or a great stretch of agricultural
land as his own individual property, with a right to refuse or
barter its use and profit to others, why should they permit a single
nation to monopolize the mines or trade routes or natural wealth
of the territories in which it lives, against the rest of mankind?
There seems to be great confusion in socialist theory in this
matter. And unless human life is to become a mass meeting of
the race in permanent session, how is the community to appoint
its officers to carry on its collective concerns? After all, the
private owner of land or of a business or the like is a sort of public
official in so far as his ownership is sanctioned and protected by the
community. Instead of being paid a salary or fees, he is allowed
to make a profit. The only valid reason for dismissing him from
his ownership is that the new control to be substituted will be
more efficient and profitable and satisfactory to the community.
And, being dismissed, he has at least the same claim to considera-
tion from the community that he himself has shown in the past
to the worker thrown out of employment by a mechanical in-
vention.
This question of administration, the sound and adequate bar to
much immediate socialization, brings us to the still largely un-
solved problem of human association; how are we to secure the
best direction of human affairs and the maximum of willing co-
operation with that direction? This is ultimately a complex
problem in psychology, but it is absurd to pretend that it is an
insoluble one. There must be a definite best, which is the right
thing, in these matters. But if it is not insoluble, it is equally
unreasonable to pretend that it has been solved. The problem
in its completeness involves the working out of the best methods in
the following departments, and their complete correlation : —
(i) Education. — The preparation of the individual for an under-
standing and willing co-operation in the world's affairs.
(ii) Information. — The continual truthful presentation of
public affairs to the individual for his judgment and approval.
Closely connected with this need for current information is the
codification of the law, the problem of keeping the law plain, clear,
and accessible to all.
414 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
(iii) Representation. — The selection of representatives and
agents to act in the collective interest in harmony with the general
will based on this education and plain information.
(iv) The Executive. — The appointment of executive agents
and the maintenance of means for keeping them responsible to
the community, without at the same time hampering intelligent
initiatives.
(v) Thought and Research. — The systematic criticism of
affairs and laws to provide data for popular judgments, and through
those judgments to ensure the secular improvement of the human
organization.
These are the five heads under which the broad problem of
human society presents itself to us. In the world around us we
see makeshift devices at work in all those branches, ill co-ordinated
one with another and unsatisfactory in themselves. We see an
educational system meanly financed and equipped, badly organized
and crippled by the interventions and hostilities of religious bodies ;
we see popular information supplied chiefly by a venal press de-
pendent upon advertisements and subsidies; we see farcical
methods of election returning politicians to power as unrepresen-
tative as any hereditary ruler or casual conqueror; everywhere
the executive is more or less influenced or controlled by groups
of rich adventurers, and the pursuit of political and social science
and of public criticism is still the work of devoted and eccentric
individuals rather than a recognized and honoured function in
the state. There is a gigantic task before right-thinking men in
the cleansing and sweetening of the politician's stable ; and until
it is done, any complete realization of socialism is impossible.
While private adventurers control the political life of the State
it is ridiculous to think of the state taking over collective eco-
nomic interests from private adventurers.
Not only has the socialist movement failed thus far to produce
a scientifically reasoned scheme for the correlation of education,
law, and the exercise of public power, but even in the economic
field, as we have already pointed out, creative forces wait for the
conception of a right organization of credit and a right method
of payment and interchange. It is a truism that the willingness
of the worker depends, among other things, upon his complete
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY 415
confidence in the purchasing power of the currency in which he is
paid. As this confidence goes, work ceases, except in so far as
it can be rewarded by payment in goods. But there is no sufficient
science of currency and business psychology to restrain govern-
ments from the most disturbing interferences with the public
credit and with the circulation. And such interferences lead
straight to the cessation of work, that is, of the production of
necessary things. Upon such vital practical questions it is scarcely
too much to say that the mass of those socialists who would recast
the world have no definite ideas at all. Yet in a socialist world
quite as much as in any other sort of world, people must be paid
money for their work rather than be paid in kind if any such thing
as personal freedom is to continue. Here too there must be an
ascertainable right thing to do. Until that is determined, history
in these matters will continue to be not so much a record of experi-
ments as of flounderings.1
And in another direction the social and political thinking of the
nineteenth century was, in the face of the vastness of the mechani-
cal revolution, timid, limited, and insufficient, and that was in
regard to international relations. The reader of socialistic litera-
ture will find the socialists constantly writing and talking of the
"State," and never betraying any realization that the "State"
might be all sorts of organizations in all sorts of areas, from the
republic of San Marino to the British Empire. It is true that
Karl Marx had a conception of a solidarity of interests between
the workers in all the industrialized countries, but there is little
or no suggestion in Marxist socialism of the logical corollary of
this, the establishment of a democratic world federal government
(with national or provincial " state " governments) as a natural
1 We may note a very interesting experiment in wages payment here that has
been made by the American Oneida silver company. A committee on which the
workers are strongly represented makes a summary week by week of the current
prices of staple commodities and common necessities. Week by week it is noted
that prices are so much per cent, above the normal figure of January, 1914 (or
some such date) , which is taken as the standard. On pay-day every worker receives
his wages plus a percentage representing the higher prices, so that though the
actual sums paid vary week by week, the purchasing power of the wages paid
remains practically constant. Here, perhaps, we have a germ of a system that may
grow to considerable importance. The burthen of rising prices is shifted to the
employer, who can take them into account in fixing his prices.
416 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
consequence of his projected social revolution. At most there is a
vague aspiration. But if there is any logic about the Marxist, it
should be his declared political end for which he should work
without ceasing. Put to the test of the war of 1914, the socialists
of almost all the European countries showed that their class-
conscious internationalism was veneered very thinly indeed over
their patriotic feelings, and had to no degree replaced them.
Everywhere during the German war socialists denounced that
war as made by capitalist governments, but it produces little or
no permanent effect to denounce a government or a world system
unless you have a working idea of a better government and a
better system to replace it.
We state these things here because they are facts, and a living
and necessary part of a contemporary survey of human history.
It is not our task either to advocate or controvert socialism.
But it is in our picture to note that political and social life are,
and must remain, chaotic and disastrous without the development
of some such constructive scheme as socialism sketches, and to
point out clearly how far away the world is at present from any
such scheme. An enormous amount of intellectual toil and dis-
cussion and education and many years — whether decades or
centuries, no man can tell — must intervene before a new order,
planned as ships and railways are planned, runs, as the cables
and the postal deliveries run, over the whole surface of our earth.
And until such a new order draws mankind together with its net,
human life, as we shall presently show by the story of the European
wars since 1854, must become more and more casual, dangerous,
miserable, anxious, and disastrous because of the continually more
powerful and destructive war methods the continuing mechanical
revolution produces.
§ 61
While the mechanical revolution which the growth of physical
science had brought about was destroying the ancient social
classification of the civilized state which had been evolved through
1 For a closely parallel view of religion to that given here, see that admirable
book, Outspoken Essays, by Dean Inge, Essays VIII and IX on St. Paul and on
Institutionalism and Mysticism.
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY 417
thousands of years, and producing new possibilities and new
ideals of a righteous human community and a righteous world order,
a change at least as great and novel was going on in the field of
religious thought. That same growth of scientific knowledge
from which sprang the mechanical revolution was the moving
cause of these religious disturbances.
In the opening chapters of this Outline we have given the main
story of the Record of the Rocks; we have shown life for the
little beginning of consciousness that it is in the still waiting vast-
ness of the void of space and time. But before the end of the
eighteenth century, this enormous prospect of the past which
fills a modern mind with humility and illimitable hope, was hidden
from the general consciousness of our race. It was veiled by the
curtain of a Sumerian legend. The heavens were no more than a
stage background to a little drama of kings. Men had been too
occupied with their own private passions and personal affairs to
heed the intimations of their own great destiny that lay about
them everywhere.
They learnt their true position in space long before they
placed themselves in time. We have already named the earlier
astronomers, and told how Galileo was made to recant his
assertion that the earth moved round the sun. He was made
to do so by the church, and the church was stirred to make
him do so because any doubt that the world was the centre
of the universe seemed to strike fatally at the authority of
Christianity.
Now, upon that matter the teller of modern history is obliged
to be at once cautious and bold. He has to pick his way between
cowardly evasion on the one hand, and partisanship on the other.
As far as possible he must confine himself to facts and restrain
his opinions. Yet it is well to remember that no opinions can be
altogether restrained. The writer has his own very strong and
definite persuasions, and the reader must bear that in mind. It
is a fact in history that the teaching of Jesus of Nazareth had in
it something profoundly new and creative; he preached a new
Kingdom of Heaven in the hearts and in the world of men. There
was nothing in his teaching, so far as we can judge it at this dis-
tance of time, to clash or interfere with any discovery or expansion
2E ,
418 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
of the history of the world and mankind. But it is equally a fact
in history that St. Paul and his successors added to or completed
or imposed upon or substituted another doctrine for — as you may
prefer to think — the plain and profoundly revolutionary teach-
ings of Jesus by expounding a subtle and complex theory of salva-
tion, a salvation which could be attained very largely by belief
and formalities, without any serious disturbance of the believer's
ordinary habits and occupations, and that this Pauline teaching
did involve very definite beliefs about the history of the world and
man. It is not the business of the historian to controvert or ex-
plain these matters; the question of their ultimate significance
depends upon the theologian; the historian's concern is merely
with the fact that official Christianity throughout the world
adopted St. Paul's view so plainly expressed in his epistles and so
untraceable in the gospels, that the meaning of religion lay not
in the future, but in the past, and that Jesus was not so much a
teacher of wonderful new things, as a predestinate divine blood
sacrifice of deep mystery and sacredness made in atonement of a
particular historical act of disobedience to the Creator committed
by our first parents, Adam and Eve, in response to the temptation
of a serpent in the Garden of Eden. Upon the belief in that Fall
as a fact, and not upon the personality of Jesus of Nazareth, upon
the theories of Paul, and not upon the injunctions of Jesus, doc-
trinal Christianity built itself.
We have already noted that this story of the special creation of
the world and of Adam and Eve and the serpent was also an ancient
Babylonian story, and probably a still more ancient Sumerian
story, and that the Jewish sacred books were the medium by which
this very ancient and primitive " heliolithic " serpent legend entered
Christianity. Wherever official Christianity has gone, it has
taken this story with it. It has tied itself up to that story. Until a
century and less ago the whole Christianized world felt bound to
believe and did believe, that the universe had been specially created
in the course of six days by the word of God a few thousand years
before — according to Bishop Ussher, 4004 B.C. (The Universal
History, in forty-two volumes, published in 1779 by a group of
London booksellers, discusses whether the precise date of the first
day of Creation was March 21st or September 21st, 4004 B.C.,
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY 419
and inclines to the view that the latter was the more probable
season.)
Upon this historical assumption rested the religious fabric of
the Western and Westernized civilization, and yet the whole
world was littered, the hills, mountains, deltas, and seas were
bursting with evidence of its utter absurdity. The religious life
of the leading nations, still a very intense and sincere religious
life, was going on in a house of history built upon sand.
There is frequent recognition in classical literature of a sounder
cosmogony. Aristotle was aware of the broad principles of modern
geology, they shine through the speculations of Lucretius, and we
have noted also Leonardo da Vinci's (1452-1519) lucid interpre-
tation of fossils. A Frenchman, Descartes (1596-1650), specu-
lated boldly upon the incandescent beginnings of our globe, and an
Italian, Steno (1631-87), began the collection of fossils and the
description of strata. But it was only as the eighteenth century
drew to its close that the systematic study of geology assumed such
proportions as to affect the general authority of the Bible version
of that ancient Sumerian narrative. Contemporaneously with
the Universal History quoted above, a great French naturalist,
Buff on, was writing upon the Epochs of Nature (1778), and boldly
extending the age of the world to 70,000 or 75,000 years. He
divided his story into six epochs to square with the six days of the
Creation story. These days, it was argued, were figurative days ;
they were really ages. There was a general disposition to do this
on the part of the new science of geology. By that accommo-
dating device, geology contrived to make a peace with orthodox
religious teaching that lasted until the middle of the nineteenth
century.
We cannot trace here the contributions of such men as Hutton
and Playfair and Sir Charles Lyell, and the Frenchmen Lamarck
and Cuvier, in unfolding and developing the record of the rocks.
It was only slowly that the general intelligence of the Western
world was awakened to two disconcerting facts : firstly, that the
succession of life in the geological record did not correspond to the
acts of the six days of creation; and, secondly, that the record,
in harmony with a mass of biological facts, pointed away from
the Bible assertion of a separate creation of each species straight
420 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
towards a genetic relation between all forms of life, in which even
man was included! The importance of this last issue to the exist-
ing doctrinal system was manifest. If all the animals and man
had been evolved in this ascendant manner, then there had been
no first parents, no Eden, and no Fall. And if there had been no
fall, then the entire historical fabric of Christianity, the story of the
first sin and the reason for an atonement, upon which the current
teaching based Christian emotion and morality, collapsed like a
house of cards.
It was with something like horror, therefore, that great numbers
of honest and religious-spirited men followed the work of the great
English naturalist, Charles Darwin (1809-82) ; in 1859 he published
his Origin of Species by Means of Natural Selection, a powerful
and permanently valuable exposition of that conception of the
change and development of species which we have sketched briefly
in Chapter III ; and in 1871 he completed the outline of his work
with the Descent of Man, which brought man definitely into the
same scheme of development with the rest of life.
Many men and women are still living who can remember the
dismay and distress among ordinary intelligent people in the
Western communities as the invincible case of the biologists and
geologists against the orthodox Christian cosmogony unfolded
itself. The minds of many quite honest men resisted the new
knowledge instinctively and irrationally. Their whole moral
edifice was built upon false history; they were too old and set
to rebuild it ; they felt the practical truth of their moral convic-
tions, and this new truth seemed to them to be incompatible with
that. They believed that to assent to it would be to prepare a
moral collapse for the world. And so they produced a moral
collapse by not assenting to it. The universities in England par-
ticularly, being primarily clerical in their constitution, resisted
the new learning very bitterly. During the seventies and
eighties a stormy controversy raged throughout the civilized
world. The quality of the discussions and the fatal ignorance of
the church may be gauged by a description in Hackett's Common-
place Book of a meeting of the British Association in 1860, at
which Bishop Wilberforce assailed Huxley, the great champion of
the Darwinian views, in this fashion.
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY 421
Facing " Huxley with a smiling insolence, he begged to know,
was it through his grandfather or grandmother that he claimed his
descent from a monkey ? Huxley turned to his neighbour, and said,
'The Lord hath delivered him into my hands/ Then he stood
before us and spoke these tremendous words, ' He was not ashamed
to have a monkey for his ancestor; but he would be ashamed
to be connected with a man who used great gifts to obscure the
truth.'" (Another version has it : "I have certainly said that a
man has no reason to be ashamed of having an ape for his grand-
father. If there were an ancestor whom I should feel ashamed
in recalling, it would rather be a man of restless and versatile
intellect who plunges into scientific questions with which he has no
real acquaintance, only to obscure them by an aimless rhetoric and
distract the attention of his audience from the real point at issue
by eloquent digressions and skilled appeals to prejudice.") These
words were certainly spoken with passion. The scene was one
of great excitement. A lady fainted, says Hackett. . . . Such
was the temper of this controversy.
The Darwinian movement took formal Christianity unawares,
suddenly. Formal Christianity was confronted with a clearly
demonstrable error in her theological statements. The Christian
theologians were neither wise enough nor mentally nimble enough
to accept the new truth, modify their formulae, and insist upon the
living and undiminished vitality of the religious reality those
formulae had hitherto sufficed to express. For the discovery of
man's descent from sub-human forms does not even remotely
touch the teaching of the Kingdom of Heaven. Yet priests and
bishops raged at Darwin ; foolish attempts were made to suppress
Darwinian literature and to insult and discredit the exponents
of the new views. There was much wild talk of the "antagonism "
of religion and science. Now in all ages there have been sceptics
in Christendom. The Emperor Frederick II was certainly a
sceptic ; in the eighteenth century Gibbon and Voltaire were openly
anti-Christian, and their writings influenced a number of scattered
readers. But these were exceptional people. . . . Now the whole
of Christendom became as a whole sceptical. This new con-
troversy touched everybody who read a book or heard intelligent
conversation. A new generation of young people grew up, and
422 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
they found the defenders of Christianity in an evil temper, fighting
their cause without dignity or fairness. It was the orthodox
theology that the new scientific advances had compromised, but
the angry theologians declared that it was religion.
In the end men may discover that religion shines all the brighter
for the loss of its doctrinal wrappings, but to the young it seemed
as if indeed there had been a conflict of science and religion, and
that in that conflict science had won.
The immediate effect of this great dispute upon the ideas and
methods of people in the prosperous and influential classes through-
out the westernized world was very detrimental indeed. The new
biological science was bringing nothing constructive as yet to re-
place the old moral stand-bys. A real de-moralization ensued.
The general level of social life in those classes was far higher in
the early twentieth than in the early seventeenth century, but in
one respect, in respect to disinterestedness and conscientiousness
in these classes, it is probable that the tone of the earlier age was
better than the latter. In the owning and active classes of the
seventeenth century, in spite of a few definite "infidels," there was
probably a much higher percentage of men and women who prayed
sincerely, who searched their souls to find if they had done evil,
and who were prepared to suffer and make great sacrifices for what
they conceived to be right, than in the opening years of the twen-
tieth century. There was a real loss of faith after 1859. The
true gold of religion was in many cases thrown away with the
worn-out purse that had contained it for so long, and it was not
recovered. Towards the close of the nineteenth century a crude
misunderstanding of Darwinism had become the fundamental
mindstuff of great masses of the "educated" everywhere. The
seventeenth-century kings and owners and rulers and leaders
had had the idea at the back of their minds that they prevailed
by the will of God ; they really feared Him, they got priests to put
things right for them with Him ; when they were wicked, they tried
not to think of Him. But the old faith of the kings, owners, and
rulers of the opening twentieth century had faded under the
actinic light of scientific criticism. Prevalent peoples at the close
of the nineteenth century believed that they prevailed by virtue
of the Struggle for Existence, in which the strong and cunning
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY 423
get the better of the weak and confiding. And they believed
further that they had to be strong, energetic, ruthless, "practical,"
egotistical, because God was dead, and had always, it seemed, been
dead — which was going altogether further than the new knowledge
justified.
They soon got beyond the first crude popular misconception
of Darwinism, the idea that every man is for himself alone. But
they stuck at the next level. Man, they decided, is a social animal
like the Indian hunting dog. He is much more than a dog — but
this they did not see. And just as in a pack it is necessary to
bully and subdue the younger and weaker for the general good, so
it seemed right to them that the big dogs of the human pack should
bully and subdue. Hence a new scorn for the ideas of democracy
that had ruled the earlier nineteenth century, and a revived ad-
miration for the overbearing and the cruel. It was quite character-
istic of the times that Mr. Kipling should lead the children of the
middle and upper-class British public back to the Jungle, to learn
"the law," and that in his book Stalky and Co. he should give an
appreciative description of the torture of two boys by three others,
who have by a subterfuge tied up their victims helplessly before
revealing their hostile intentions.
It is worth while to give a little attention to this incident in
Stalky and Co., because it lights up the political psychology of the
British Empire at the close of the nineteenth century very vividly.
The history of the last half century is not to be understood without
an understanding of the mental twist which this story exemplifies.
The two boys who are tortured are "bullies," that is the excuse
of their tormentors, and these latter have further been incited
to the orgy by a clergyman. Nothing can restrain the gusto
with which they (and Mr. Kipling) set about the job. Before
resorting to torture, the teaching seems to be, see that you pump up
a little justifiable moral indignation, and all will be well. If you
have the authorities on your side, then you cannot be to blame.
Such, apparently, is the simple doctrine of this typical imperialist.
But every bully has to the best of his ability followed that doctrine
since the human animal developed sufficient intelligence to be
consciously cruel.
Another point in the story is very significant indeed. The head
424 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
master and his clerical assistant are both represented as being
privy to the affair. They want this bullying to occur. Instead
of exercising their own authority, they use these boys, who are
Mr. Kipling's heroes, to punish the two victims. Head master
and clergyman turn a deaf ear to the complaints of an indignant
mother. All this^Mr. Kipling represents as a most desirable
state of affairs. In this we have the key to the ugliest, most
retrogressive, and finally fatal idea of modern imperialism; the
idea of a tacit conspiracy between the law and illegal violence. Just as
the Tsardom wrecked itself at last by a furtive encouragement of
the ruffians of the Black Hundreds, who massacred Jews and other
people supposed to be inimical to the Tsar, so the good name of
the British Imperial Government has been tainted — and is still
tainted — by an illegal raid made by Doctor Jameson into the
Transvaal before the Boer War, and by the adventures, which we
shall presently describe, of Sir Edward Carson and Mr. F. E. Smith
(now Lord Birkenhead) in Ireland. By such treasons against
their subjects, empires destroy themselves. The true strength of
rulers and empires lies not in armies and emotions, but in the belief
of men that they are inflexibly open and truthful and legal. So
soon as a government departs from that standard, it ceases to be
anything more than "the gang in possession," and its days are
numbered.
It was just this dignity of government which the crude Darwin-
ism and the Kiplingism of the later Victorian years were destroying.
Competition and survival were accepted as the basal facts of life.
" War is the natural state of nations," said a popular London men's
weekly l the other day, with an air of repeating something univer-
sally known. "Peace is only the interval of rest and preparation
between wars." In accordance with such ideas the growing boy was
exhorted to be "loyal" to his school and contemptuous of other
schools, "loyal" to his class against other classes, "loyal" to his
nation and contemptuous and fierce towards other nations, "loyal"
to the English-speaking peoples and contemptuous and hostile to
the German or French-speaking. His instinct for brotherhood was
narrowed and debased. The universal brotherhood of mankind was
laughed to scorn. All life was bickering, he was taught ; and yet
i Town Topics, November 26th, 1919.
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY 425
the whole course of history has shown that the bickering nations
perish, and that the alliances and coalescences of peoples and
nations ensure the life they comprehend.
So the Darwinian crisis continued that destruction of Christian
prestige which the narrowness of priestcraft and the consequent
division of Christendom among the monarchist and national
Protestant churches of the Reformation had begun, and at a time
when man's need for pacifying and unifying ideas was greater
than it had ever been. Just when men of different races and lan-
guages and political ideas were being brought by the mechanical
revolution to a closeness of contact and a power of mutual injury
undreamt of before, the authority of the doctrines by which men
had hitherto transcended tribal and local limitations was under-
mined. Just when different classes were being aroused to a fierce
realization of mutual economic antagonism, the fundamental
teaching of brotherhood was discredited and a pseudo-scientific
sanction given to self-seeking and oppression.1 From this stage
onward the historian can tell no longer of ordinary clerical Chris-
tianity as a power in men's affairs. In politics and social questions
the appeal to its standards ceased. Yet never was there so impera-
tive a demand in the world of men for a common basis upon which
they could work together, a common conception of aim in which
they could lose themselves. We shall find great masses of people
inspired to passionate devotion, by ideas of nationalism, of im-
perialism, of class-conscious socialism. But official and orthodox
Christianity no longer inspired. Men would no longer live by it
or die for it.
This paradoxical final decline of a universal faith in the Western-
ized world, just when men were being drawn together by the
mechanical revolution into one inseparable political and economic
system, may have been due entirely to the coincidence of that
revolution with destructive scientific discovery, or it may also have
been accelerated by the irritations produced by the sudden close
clashing with unfamiliar peoples and races. It may have been a
merely temporary decline due to the need for a sloughing-off of the
out-worn theology and antique sacerdotalism which confined its
1 Kropotkin's Mutual Aid is worth noting here as one of the earliest correctives
to these popular misconceptions of Darwinism. — G. M.
426 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
appeal to the western world, preparatory to a reconstruction of
religious statement upon simpler world- wide lines. It may have
been merely a cleansing of the teachings of Jesus of Nazareth from
theological and ceremonial accretions. Upon such "may have
beens" we can speculate here, but we cannot decide. History can
deal with the small beginnings in the past of the great things of
the present, but in the present only with what is plain and obvious.
We cannot tell what seeds of the future may not be germinating
already amidst our present confusions.
§ 7
The vast changes we have been recording in the range of human
power and intercourse constitute the fundamental realities of nine-
teenth-century history. But the atlas and political history of a
time do not show what is being made, but what has been made, and
what is still going on. The formal history of the latter half of the
nineteenth century is not so much concerned with these per-
manent changes in human affairs, as with the schemes of Foreign
Offices and the continuing exploits of the Great Powers. The
men who were discovering, inventing, developing inventions and
working out ideas were far too busy and far too few for effective
interference in public affairs. The diplomatists, politicians, and
statesmen, on the other hand, were far too occupied with their
established interplay of nations and parties to heed what the
contemporary mind was doing. The Earl of Beaconsfield (1804-
81), a leading British statesman, remarked (of the Darwinian con-
troversy) that it seemed to be a dispute whether men were de-
scended from apes or angels, and that for his part, he was "on the
side of the angels" —a sprightly saying which added greatly to
his reputation. His rival, Gladstone (1809-98), was of a more
serious quality, and in the habit of plunging during his vacations
heavily and conspicuously into intellectual affairs; among other
such exploits he joined in public controversy with Huxley upon
Huxley's own subject. He revealed ideas derived from Buff on
(died 1788) uncontaminated by any later influence. The whole
field of modern discovery, says Lecky in his Democracy and Liberty
was outside his range.
When this Mr. Gladstone was taken by Sir John Lubbock to
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY
427
see Charles Darwin,1 he talked all the time of Bulgarian politics,
and was evidently quite unaware of the real importance of the
man he was visiting. Darwin, Lord Morley records, expressed
himself as deeply sensible of the honour done him by the visit of
"such a great man," but he offered no comments on the Bulgarian
discourse. Faraday, the English electrician, whose work lives
wherever a dynamo spins, who is in the aeroplane, the deep-sea
cable, the lights that light the ways of the world, and wherever
electricity serves our kind, was also visited by Gladstone when
the latter was Chancellor of the Exchequer. The man of
science tried in vain to explain some simple piece of apparatus
to this fine flower of the parlia-
mentary world. "But," said
Mr. Gladstone, "after all, what
good is it ? " "Why, sir, " said
Faraday, doing his best to bring
things home to him, "presently
you will be able to tax it. " 2
Mr. Gladstone was one of
the most central and represent-
ative politician statesmen of
the later nineteenth century,
and it will be worth while to
devote a paragraph or so to his
ideas and intellectual limita-
tions. They will help us to
understand better the astonishing irrelevance of the political lif e of
this period to the realities that rose about it. He was a person
of exceptional intellectual vigour ; he had flashes of real insight ;
but his circumstances and temperament conspired against his ever
attaining any real vision of the world in which he lived.
He was the son of Sir John Gladstone, a West Indian slave-
holder, the mortality among whose slaves was a matter of debate
in the House of Commons; he was educated at Eton College,
and at Christ Church, Oxford, and his mind never recovered from
the process. We have already told how after the Reformation
the English universities ceased to be the organs of the general
1 Morley's Life of Gladstone. 2 R. A. Gregory's Discovery.
GlacUfame
428 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
intellectual life, and shrank to be merely the educational preserves
of the aristocracy and the church. Jews, Roman Catholics, dis-
senters, sceptics, and all forms of intellectual activity were care-
fully barred out from those almost extinguished lamps of learning.
Their mathematical work was poor, a series of exercises in the
mere patience-games and formulae-writing of lower mathematics ;
science they despised and excluded, and their staple training was
the study, without any archaeology or historical perspective, of
the more rhetorical and " poetic" of the Latin and Greek classics.1
Such a training prepared men not so much to tackle and solve
the problems of life, as to plaster them over with more or less apt
quotations. It turned the mind away from living contemporary
things; it showed the world reflected in a distorting mirror of
bad historical analogies; all the fated convergencies of history
were refracted into false parallels. The British Parliament was
thought of as a Senate, statesmen postured as patricians and eques-
trians; the new industrial population, now learning to read and
think for itself, was transfigured into the likeness of the illiterate
savage and privileged citizen mob of later republican Rome.2 It
1 The great Oxford school of Literce Humaniores, which means a serious study of
Ancient Philosophy and Ancient History, was already thirty years old in Glad-
stone's time, and was a really serious training in solid philosophy and solid history.
It was all the more serious, as every candidate for Honours had to take two schools
and to offer Mathematics as well as Literce Humaniores. Both Peel (about 1810)
and Gladstone (about 1830) took these two schools, and both gained Firsts in both.
(This, by the way, is the only true and genuine "double first.") Men with such a
training were genuinely and nobly trained for statesmanship. — E. B.
With no knowledge of ethnology, no vision of history as a whole, misconceiv-
ing the record of geology, ignorant of the elementary ideas of biological science, of
modern political, social, and economic science and modern thought and literature !
— H. G. W.
2 The old classical training had great faults, but not quite those which are here
imputed to it. It was the education of an aristocratic leisured class who had not
to earn their living. Hence it was (1) entirely idealist and non-utilitarian. It
aimed not at fitting people for a paid profession, but at culture and inner develop-
ment. (2) It depended enormously on leisure. The work done in compulsory
work-hours was small in range, but severe, almost entirely classics and mathe-
matics. These were intended as a training of the mind and a test of ability, but
were not the real field of ambition. That lay in the large amount of time allotted
to free study. Peel, Gladstone, Macaulay, Hallam, etc., show what was expected
of the best men. Literature, modern history, French and Italian, theology and
philosophy, and even a good deal of generalized science, were things you read in
your free time. Think what Macaulay 's "schoolboy" was supposed to know, and
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY 429
was natural, therefore, that at the Oxford Union Society young
Gladstone should distinguish himself by an eloquent speech
reflect that practically none of it was taught in school hours ! Some of the best
papers on English literature that I ever read were done by a certain sixth form which
had, I was told, no time at all given to the subject in the time-table. As the Head
Master told me, "A good man was rather laughed at if he did not know Shakespeare
and Milton."
This conception of a small hard nucleus of compulsory work, combined with a
wide margin of leisure, was very good for the best men, who used their free time
in the right way, but left the weak men thoroughly uneducated. The reaction
against it came with long hours, wide curriculum, and compulsory games, leaving
no leisure either for study or for mischief.
The modern idea that school should teach all that a boy ought to know, is
educationally disastrous ; but it is the natural result of boys coming from uneducated
homes. The home, not the school, is the real key to the wider and higher side of
education. But this raises large questions. — G. M.
G. M., I submit, has not grasped the modern idea in education. The modern
idea of a public school as exemplified in such a case as Oundle does not fill up the
time of the boy with prescribed work and games; it leaves large spaces for self-
development ; but also it provides museums, a good collection of pictures, libraries,
and an abundance of good music in addition to the mere "playing fields" of the old
type of public school. And it inquires into the use a boy is making of his free
energies. The phase of "cram" is over, but the new schools do provide good
pasture, show the way thither, and "vet" a boy who displays no appetite. G. M.
ignores entirely the clear statement in the text that Gladstone was a grossly
ignorant man, and the instances given of the feebleness and worthlessness of the
" generalized science" these boys of the old persuasion picked up. So far from the
old classical training being the education of an aristocratic class, it was, as G. M.
admits within a line or so, the education of a few individuals, the rest of the class
remaining barbarians. It may have aimed at culture and inner development, but
it missed its aim. Consequently, the bright lads of the Gladstone-Macaulay-
Peel type who did not pick up a few enlightened ideas by accident or at home, were
quite unable to carry their own class with them ; it remained politically boorish.
They had to appeal for understanding to classes whose education had been free
from "classical" pretentiousness. . . .
These notes submitted to E. B. at this stage provoked him to a warm protest.
His sympathies were "heart and soul with G. M.," and Mr. Gladstone, he declared
with emphasis, was not an ignorant man. A little more must be said on this
question. If the reader realize, what we have been trying to make clear in this
history, that human progress is largely mental progress, a clearing and an enlarge-
ment of ideas, then he will understand why it is that the compiler, of this Outline
has given so much space here to these controversial notes upon the education of Mr.
Gladstone. For the education of Mr. Gladstone was typical of that ruling-class
education which has dominated British and European affairs, so far as they have
been dominated by ideas, up to the present time. It is most significant of the
differences and difficulties of our age that the statement, which seemed to the writer
a simple statement of an obvious fact, that Mr. Gladstone was a profoundly
ignorant man, should have so scandalized two of the editors of this work. No
doubt Mr. Gladstone knew much and knew many things, and it is just because
430 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
against the threatened reform of the worst electoral abuses (see
chap, xxxiv, § 2), should contest the immediate emancipation
of the parental slaves — slavery, he said, was "sanctioned by
Holy Scripture" — and should oppose on religious grounds the
removal of the disabilities of the Jews. He was returned to Parlia-
ment as Tory member for Newark in 1832, promising to resist
"that growing desire for change" which threatened to produce,
"along with partial good, a melancholy preponderance of mischief."
In his first Parliament he distinguished himself by his opposition
to the admission of religious dissenters to the universities.
Here we have a mind manifestly of a tradition and make-up akin
to that of the framers of the Holy Alliance, a mind set steadfastly
against all the vast creative tendencies of the nineteenth-century
world, as though they were no more than a mere mischievous
restlessness of slaves and lower-class persons that would presently
be allayed. But because of the streak of insight in his composition,
Gladstone did not remain set in a course of pure conservatism, he
presently began to realize the strength of the stream upon which
things were being carried forward ; his intelligence, in spite of its
perversion, set itself to grasp the real forms of the torrent of
change about him. He was a man of great ambitions and im-
mense energy; his animosity against his brilliant and flippant
Jewish rival Disraeli (afterwards Lord Beaconsfield), who was be-
coming a leader amid the shifting of groups and parties, swung this
man who had been the "rising hope of the stern unbending Tories"
more and more into a liberal attitude. He began to express belief
in the people, to support extensions of the franchise, to cultivate
the esteem of the dissenters, and, as Chancellor of the Exchequer,
he did so and was in many respects the fine flower of the education of his period,
that his ignorance is so interesting to us. Many Chinese mandarins knew much
and many things — beautifully. And were ignorant men. Mr. Gladstone's was
not the ignorance of deficiency, but the ignorance of excess, a copious ignorance;
it was not a , failure to know this or that particular fact, an ignorance excusable
enough, but a profound and sought-after and established ignorance of reality, so
that he did not grasp the bearing of definite facts presented to him or of far-reaching
ideas put before him, upon the great issues with which he was concerned. He
lived, as it were, in a luminous and blinding cloud. That cloud, which I call his
ignorance, my two editors call his wonderful and abounding culture. It was a
culture that wrapped about and adorned the great goddess Reality. But indeed
she is not to be adorned but stripped. She ceases to be herself or to bless her
votary unless she is faced stark and faced fearlessly. — H. G. W.
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY 431
to shift the burthen of taxation from the food and comforts of the
new classes of needy voters, that the franchise extensions were
bringing into the political world. It is clear that for some years he
was profoundly perplexed by the deep forces that evidently lay
beneath the stir and thrust of international politics; then he
became a great exponent of a half-true theory, the theory of
Nationalism, that has played and still plays an intensely mis-
chievous part in the world.
We have already pointed out that there must be a natural
political map of the world which gives the best possible geographi-
cal divisions for human administrations. Any other political
division of the world than this natural political map will necessarily
be a misfit, and must produce stresses of hostility and insurrection
tending to shift boundaries in the direction indicated by the
natural political map. These would seem to be self-evident
propositions were it not that the diplomatists at Vienna evidently
neither believed nor understood anything of the sort, and thought
themselves as free to carve up the world as one is free to carve up
such a boneless structure as a cheese. Nor were these propositions
evident to Mr. Gladstone. Most of the upheavals and conflicts
that began in Europe as the world recovered from the exhaustion
of the Napoleonic wars were quite obviously attempts of the ordi-
nary common men to get rid of governments that were such mis-
fits as to be in many cases intolerable. Generally the existing
governments were misfits throughout Europe because they were
not socially representative, and so they were hampering production
and wasting human possibilities; but when there were added to
these universal annoyances differences of religion and racial
culture between rulers and ruled (as in most of Ireland), differences
in race and language (as in Austrian North Italy and through-
out most of the Austrian Empire), or differences in all these re-
spects (as in Poland and the Turkish Empire in Europe), the
exasperation drove towards bloodshed. Europe was a system
of governing machines abominably adjusted. But Mr. Gladstone
was no patient mechanic set upon easing and righting the clumsy
injuries of those stupid adjustments. He was a white-faced,
black-haired man of incredible energy, with eyes like an eagle's,
wrath almost divine, and the "finest baritone voice in Europe."
432 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
He apprehended these things romantically, therefore, in a manner
suitable for passionate treatment in large halls.
He was blind to the pitiful and wonderful reality of mankind,
to these millions and millions of ill-informed, ill-equipped, inex-
pressive, and divided human beings, mostly very willing, could
they but do it, to live righteously and well. He fixed his eagle
eye on a fantastic vision of "nations rightly struggling to be
free." *
What is a nation? What is nationality? He never paused to
ask. No one under the spell of that fine baritone paused to ask.
But historians must stand to the questions a politician can evade.
If our story of the world has demonstrated anything, it has demon-
strated the mingling of races and peoples, the instability of human
divisions, the swirling variety of human groups and human ideas
of association. A nation, it has been said, is an accumulation of
human beings who think they are one people ; but we are told that
Ireland is a nation, and Protestant Ulster certainly does not share
that idea; and Italy did not think it was one people until long
after its unity was accomplished. When the writer was in Italy in
1916, people were saying: "This war will make us one nation."
Again, are the English a nation or have they merged into a "British
1 The impression made on me, an old Gladstonian, by Gladstone's politics, was
mainly twofold. (1) A strong assertion that politics were (as Aristotle said) a
development of ethics, and concerned with discovering and doing what is Right,
not what is convenient or profitable to any particular class or nation. (2) A strong
subconscious suggestion that the highest education and culture and knowledge
were useful for politics, which was in fact a very high practical art, demanding the
highest qualities. Hence largely the horror we had of Dizzy. (3) A general
sanguine conviction that Honesty was the best policy ; that what was right would
also prove to be ultimately the most profitable, so that there was no real conflict.
I do not say that Mr. G. acted consistently up to these principles, or that they
could be acted up to ; but they formed the milk of the word for most of us. — G. M.
I cannot agree that Gladstone was a prophet of nationalism. He was a prophet
of Liberalism, and, as such, a hater of oppression. He protested against Bourbon
oppression in Naples or Turkish oppression in Bulgaria or Armenia ; but to protest
against oppression is not to champion nationalism. Gladstone championed not
nationalism, but internationalism; he emphasized the idea that "public right"
should control the relations of states. The fine words which Mr. Asquith used to
state the British cause in August, 1914, were (unless I am mistaken) an echo of
Gladstone's own words. A noble objection to oppression; a noble championing
of the rule of public right — these were the staples of Gladstone's prophecy. The
pity was that, when it came to the actual handling of foreign affairs (e.g. in Egypt
about 1884), Gladstone could not translate his ideals into practice. — E. B.
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY 433
nationality"? Scotchmen do not seem to believe very much in
this British nationality. It cannot be a community of race or
language that constitutes a nation, because the Gaels and the
Lowlanders make up the Scotch " nation" ; it cannot be a common
religion, for England has scores ; nor a common literature, or why
is Britain separated from the United States, and the Argentine
Republic from Spain? We may suggest that a nation is in effect
any assembly, mixture, or confusion of people which is either
afflicted by or wishes to be afflicted by a foreign office of its own, in
order that it should behave collectively as if it alone constituted
humanity. We have already in Chapter xxxvi, § 6, traced the
development of the Machiavellian monarchies into the rule of their
foreign offices, playing the part of "Powers." The "nationality"
which Mr. Gladstone made his guiding political principle, is really
no more than the romantic and emotional exaggeration of the
stresses produced by the discord of the natural political map with
unsuitable political arrangements. These stresses could be used
for the benefit of this power or the detriment of that.
Throughout the nineteenth century, and particularly through-
out its latter half, there has been a great working up of this nation-
alism in the world. All men are by nature partisans and patriots,
but the natural tribalism of men in the nineteenth century was
unnaturally exaggerated, it was fretted and over-stimulated and
inflamed and forced into the nationalist mould. Nationalism was
taught in schools, emphasized by newspapers, preached and mocked
and sung into men. Men were brought to feel that they were as
improper without a nationality as without their clothes in a
crowded assembly. Oriental peoples who had never heard of
nationality before, took to it as they took to the cigarettes and
bowler hats of the west. India, a galaxy of contrasted races,
religions, and cultures, Dravidian, Mongolian, and Aryan, be-
came a "nation." There were perplexing cases, of course, as when
a young Whitechapel Jew had to decide whether he belonged to the
British or the Jewish nation.1 Caricature and political cartoons
played a large part in this elevation of the cult of these newer and
bigger tribal gods — for such indeed the modern "nations" are
1 G. B. Stern's Children of No Man's Land is a novel of this topic of British
nationality in relation to German Jews written with great insight.
2F
434
THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY 435
— to their ascendancy over the imagination of the nineteenth cen-
tury. If one turns over the pages of Punch, that queer contem-
porary record of the British soul, which has lasted now since 1841,
one finds the figures of Britannia, Hibernia, France, and Germania
embracing, disputing, reproving, rejoicing, grieving. It greatly
helped the diplomatists to carry on their game of Great Powers
to convey politics in this form to the doubting general intelli-
gence. To the common man, resentful that his son should be
sent abroad to be shot, it was made clear that instead of this being
merely the result of the obstinacy and greed of two foreign offices,
it was really a necessary part of a righteous inevitable gigantic
struggle between two of these dim vast divinities. France had
been wronged by Germania, or Italia was showing a proper spirit
to Austria. The boy's death ceased to appear an outrage on com-
mon sense; it assumed a sort of mythological dignity. And in-
surrection could clothe itself in the same romantic habiliments
as diplomacy. Ireland became a Cinderella goddess, Cathleen ni
Houlihan, full of heart-rending and unforgivable wrongs, and young
India transcended its realities in the worship of Bande Mataram.
The essential idea of nineteenth-century nationalism was the
" legitimate claim" of every nation to complete sovereignty, the
claim of every nation to manage all its affairs within its own terri-
tory, regardless of any other nation. The flaw in this idea is that
the affairs and interests of every modern community extend to
the uttermost parts of the earth. The assassination of Sarajevo
in 1914, for example, which caused the great war, produced the
utmost distress among the Indian tribes of Labrador because that
war interrupted the marketing of the furs upon which they relied for
such necessities as ammunition, without which they could not get
sufficient food. A world of independent sovereign nations means,
therefore, a world of perpetual injuries, a world of states constantly
preparing for or waging war. But concurrently and discordantly
with the preaching of this nationalism of which Gladstone was
the outstanding exponent,1 there was, among the stronger national-
1 The doctrine of nationalities was in reality a legacy of French revolutionary
theory. From the men of the First Republic, who found it a useful excuse for a
forward foreign policy in the best Richelieu tradition, it passed into the possession
of Napoleon, who gave more attention to it at St. Helena than he had ever done
436 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
ities, a vigorous propagation of another set of ideas, the ideas of
imperialism, in which a powerful and advanced nation was con-
ceded the right to dominate a group of other less advanced nations
or less politically developed nations or peoples whose nationality
was still undeveloped, who were expected by the dominating nation
to be grateful for its protection and dominance. This use of the
word empire was evidently a different one from its former universal
significance. The new empires did not even pretend to be a con-
tinuation of the world empire of Rome. The leading spirit in
British imperialism was Lord Beaconsfield, Gladstone's antagonist.
These two ideas of nationality and, as the crown of national success,
"empire," ruled European political thought, ruled indeed the polit-
ical thought of the world, throughout the latter half of the nine-
teenth century, and ruled it to the practical exclusion of any wider
conception of a common human welfare. They were plausible and
dangerously unsound working ideas. They represented nothing
I fundamental and inalterable in human nature, and they failed to
meet the new needs of world controls and world security that
the mechanical revolution was every day making more imperative.
They were accepted because people in general had neither the sweep-
ing views that a scientific study of history can give, nor had they
any longer the comprehensive charity of a world religion. Their
danger to all the routines of ordinary life was not realized until it
was too late.
/ § 8
After the middle of the nineteenth century, this world of new
powers and old ideas, this fermenting new wine in the old bottles
of diplomacy, broke out through the flimsy restraints of the Treaty
of Vienna into a series of wars. By an ironical accident the new
system of disturbances was preceded by a peace festival in London,
the Great Exhibition of 1851.
The moving spirit in this exhibition was Prince Albert of Saxe-
Coburg-Gotha, the nephew of Leopold I, the German king who
at the Tuileries. Thence it came naturally into the political inheritance of Napoleon
III, who sacrificed France to his belief in it. Gladstone only got it by a side wind,
the theory having drifted into the British tradition by reason of the accident of
Canning's anti-interventionist foreign policy during the Spanish-American War
of Independence. — P. G.
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY 437
had been placed upon the Belgian throne in 1831, and who was
also the maternal uncle of the young Queen Victoria of England.
She had become queen in 1837 at the age of eighteen. The two
young cousins — they were of the same age — had married in 1840
under their uncle's auspices, and Prince Albert was known to the
British as the "Prince Consort." He was a young man of sound
intelligence and exceptional education, and he seems to have been
greatly shocked by the mental stagnation into which England
had sunken. Oxford and Cambridge, those once starry centres,
were still recovering but slowly from the intellectual ebb of the
later eighteenth century. At neither university did the annual
matriculations number more than four hundred. The examina-
tions were for the most part mere viva voce ceremonies. Except
for two colleges in London (the University of London) and one
in Durham, this was all the education on a university footing
that England had to offer. It was very largely the initiative of
this scandalized young German who had married the British
queen which produced the university commission of 1850, and it
was with a view to waking up England further that he promoted
the first International Exhibition which was to afford some
opportunity for a comparison of the artistic and industrial
products of the various European nations.
The project was bitterly opposed. In the House of Commons
it was prophesied that England would be overrun by foreign rogues
and revolutionaries who would corrupt the morals of the people
and destroy all faith and loyalty in the country.
The exhibition was held in Hyde Park in a great building of glass
and iron — which afterwards was re-erected as the Crystal Palace.
Financially it was a great success. It made many English people
realize for the first time that theirs was not the only industrial
country in the world, and that commercial prosperity was not a
divinely appointed British monopoly. There was the clearest
evidence of a Europe recovering steadily from the devastation of
the Napoleonic wars, and rapidly overtaking the British lead in
trade and manufacture. It was followed directly by the organiza-
tion of a Science and Art Department (1853), to recover, if possible,
the educational leeway that Britain had lost.
The exhibition released a considerable amount of international
438 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
talk and sentiment. It had already found expression in the work
of such young poets as Tennyson, who had glanced down the vista
of the future.
"Till the war-drums throb'd no longer, and the battle-flags were furl'd
In the Parliament of man, the Federation of the world."
There was much shallow optimism on the part of comfortable
people just then. Peace seemed to be more secure than it had been
for a long time. The social gales of 1848 had blown, and, it seemed,
blown themselves out. Nowhere had the revolution succeeded.
In France it had been betrayed a second time by a Bonaparte, a
nephew of the first Napoleon, but a much more supple and in-
telligent man.1 He had posed as a revolutionary while availing
himself of the glamour of his name ; he had twice attempted raids
on France during the Orleans monarchy. He had written a manual
of artillery to link himself to his uncle's prestige, and he had also
published an account of what he alleged to be Napoleonic views,
Des I dees Napoleoniennes, in which he jumbled up socialism, so-
cialistic reform, and pacificism with the Napoleonic legend. The
republic of 1848 was soon in difficulties with crude labour experi-
ments, and in October he was able to re-enter the country and
stand for election as President. He took an oath as President
to be faithful to the democratic republic, and to regard as enemies
all who attempted to change the form of government. In two
years' time (December, 1852) he was Emperor of the French.
At first he was regarded with considerable suspicion by Queen
Victoria, or rather by Baron Stockmar, the friend and servant of
King Leopold of Belgium, and the keeper of the international con-
science of the British queen and her consort. All this group of
Saxe-Coburg-Gotha people had a reasonable and generous enthu-
siasm for the unity and well-being of Germany — upon liberal
lines — and they were disposed to be alarmed at this Bonapartist
revival. Lord Palmerston, the British foreign minister, was, on
the other hand, friendly with the usurper from the outset; he
offended the queen by sending amiable despatches to the French
President without submitting them for her examination and so
1 This is a paradox to which I cannot subscribe. Please put me down as con-
vinced of the opposite. — E. B.
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY
439
giving her sufficient time to consult Stockmar upon them, and he
was obliged to resign. But subsequently the British Court veered
round to a more cordial attitude to the new adventurer. The
opening years of his reign promised a liberal monarchy rather than
a Napoleonic career; a government of " cheap bread, great public
works, and holidays," l and he expressed himself warmly in favour
oF EUROPE,
sr "» twaxta.'
tol866..v..T.....||||||H|||
..territory seized
1866-7
M. German. Confederation. , 1866 . .
German Empire, 18/1
territory lost
(ALsace-LJbrraine , 1871 • •
territory lost"
•.1859.Ven£tia..l866
[For Itahf see. also separate, map]
of the idea of nationalism, which was naturally a very acceptable
idea to any liberal German intelligence. There had been a brief
all-German parliament at Frankfort in 1848, which was overthrown
in 1849 by the Prussian monarchy.
(This conflict between Palmerston and the Crown is interesting
because it shows the way in which the aristocratic ruling class of
the crowned republic of the Britain of the early Georges was now,
1 Albert Thomas in the Encyclopedia Britannica.
440 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
with an uneasy democracy below it, an educated royal consort
above, and an education which had not kept pace with the times,
losing power to the renascent energy of the Crown. A Stockmar
would have been impossible in the reigns of George I or George II,
or in a nineteenth-century Great Britain with a reasonably well-
educated peerage.)
Before 1848 all the great European courts of the Vienna settle-
ment had been kept in a kind of alliance by the fear of a second
and more universal democratic revolution. After the revolution-
ary failures of 1848 this fear was lifted, and they were free to resume
the scheming and counter-scheming of the days before 1789 —
with the vastly more powerful armies and fleets the first Napoleonic
phase had given them. The game of Great Powers was resumed
with zest, after an interval of sixty years, and it continued until
it produced the catastrophe of 1914.
The Tsar of Russia, Nicholas I, was the first to move towards
war. He resumed the traditional thrust of Peter the Great to-
wards Constantinople. Nicholas invented the phrase of the "sick
man of Europe" for the Sultan, and, finding an excuse in the mis-
government of the Christian population of the Turkish empire,
he occupied the Danubian principalities in 1853. European di-
plomatists found themselves with a question of quite the eighteenth-
century pattern. The designs of Russia were understood to clash
with the designs of France in Syria, and to threaten the Mediter-
ranean route to India of Great Britain, and the outcome was an
alliance of France and England to bolster up Turkey and a war,
the Crimean War, which ended in the repulse of Russia. One
might have thought that the restraint of Russia was rather the
business of Austria and Germany, but the passion of the foreign
offices of France and England for burning their fingers in Russian
affairs has always been very difficult to control.
The next phase of interest in this revival of the Great Power
drama was the exploitation by the Emperor Napoleon III and the
king of the small kingdom of Sardinia in Nbrth Italy, of the in-
conveniences and miseries of the divided state of Italy, and par-
ticularly of the Austrian rule in the north. The King of Sardinia,
Victor Emmanuel, made an old-time bargain for Napoleon's help
in return for the provinces of Nice and Savoy. The war between
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY
441
France and Sardinia on the one hand, and Austria on the other,
broke out in 1859, and was over in a few weeks. The Austrians
were badly beaten at Magenta and Solferino. Then, being threat-
ened by Prussia on the Rhine, Napoleon made peace, leaving
Sardinia the richer for Lombardy.
The next move in the game of Victor Emmanuel, and of his chief
<B£ KINGDOM of ITALY: 1861 .
minister Cavour, was an insurrectionary movement in Sicily led
by the great Italian patriot Garibaldi. Sicily and Naples were
liberated, and all Itafy, except only Rome (which remained loyal
to the Pope) and Venetia, which was held by the Austrians, fell
to the king of Sardinia. A general Italian parliament met at Turin
in 1861, and Victor Emmanuel became the first king of Italy.
But now the interest in this game of European diplomacy shifted
442 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
to Germany. Already the common sense of the natural political
map had asserted itself. In 1848 all Germany, including, of course,
German Austria, was for a time united under the Frankfort par-
liament. But that sort of union was particularly offensive to all
the German courts and foreign offices ; they did not want a Ger-
many united by the will of its people, they wanted Germany united
by regal and diplomatic action — as Italy was being united. In
1848 the German parliament had insisted that the largely German
provinces of Schleswig-Holstein, which had been in the German
Bund, must belong to Germany. It had ordered the Prussian
army to occupy them, and the king of Prussia had refused to take
his orders from the German parliament, and so had precipitated
the downfall of that body. Now the King of Denmark, Christian
IX, for no conceivable motive except the natural folly of kings,
embarked upon a campaign of annoyance against the Germans in
these two duchies. Prussian affairs were then very much in the
hands of a minister of the seventeenth-century type, Von Bismarck
(count in 1865, prince in 1871), and he saw brilliant opportunities
in this trouble. He became the champion of the German nation-
ality in these duchies — it must be remembered that the King of
Prussia had refused to undertake this role for democratic Germany
in 1848 — and he persuaded Austria to side with Prussia in a mili-
tary intervention. Denmark had no chance against these Great
Powers ; she was easily beaten and obliged to relinquish the duchies.
Then Bismarck picked a quarrel with Austria for the possession
of these two small states. So he brought about a needless and
fratricidal war of Germans for the greater glory of Prussia and the
ascendancy of the Hohenzollern dynasty in Germany. German
writers of a romantic turn of mind represent Bismarck as a great
statesman planning the unity of Germany ; but indeed he was doing
nothing of the kind. The unity of Germany was a reality in 1848.
It was and is in the nature of things. The Prussian monarchy was
simply delaying the inevitable in order to seem to achieve it in
Prussian fashion. That is why, when at last Germany was unified,
instead of bearing the likeness of a modern civilized people, it
presented itself to the world with the face of this archaic Bismarck,
with a fierce moustache, huge jack boots, a spiked helmet, and a
sword.
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY
443
J.F.H.
In this war between Prussia and Austria, Prussia had for an ally
Italy ; most of the smaller German states, who dreaded the schemes
of Prussia, fought on the side of Austria. The reader will naturally
want to know why Napoleon III did not grasp this admirable
occasion for statecraft and come into the war to his own advantage.
All the rules of the Great Power game required that he should.
But Napoleon, unhappily for himself, had got his fingers in a trap
on the other side of the Atlantic, and was in no position to inter-
vene.
In order to understand the entanglement of this shifty gentle-
man, it is necessary to explain that the discord in interests between
the northern and southern
states of the American union, -
due to the economic differences
based on slavery, had at last
led to open civil war. The
federal system established in
1789 had to fight the seces-
sionist efforts of the con-
federated slave-holding states.
We have traced the causes of
that great struggle in Chapter
XXXVII, § 6; its course we
cannot relate here, nor tell how
President Lincoln (born 1809,
died 1865, president from 1861)
rose to greatness, how the republic was cleansed from the stain
of slavery, and how the federal government of the union was
preserved.
For four long years (1861-65) this war swung to and fro, through
the rich woods and over the hills of Virginia between Washington
and Richmond, until at last the secessionist left was thrust back
and broken, and Sherman, the unionist general, swept across
Georgia to the sea in the .rear of the main confederate (secessionist)
armies. All the elements of reaction in Europe rejoiced during the
four years of republican dissension ; the British aristocracy openly
sided with the confederate states, and the British Government
permitted several privateers, and particularly the Alabama, to
444 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
be launched in England to attack the federal shipping. Napoleon
III was even more rash in his assumption that after all the new
world had fallen before the old. The sure shield of the Monroe
Doctrine, it seemed to him, was thrust aside for good, the Great
Powers might meddle again in America, and the blessings of an
adventurous monarchy be restored there. A pretext for interfer-
ence was found in certain liberties taken with the property of
foreigners by the Mexican president. A joint expedition of French,
British, and Spanish occupied Vera Cruz, but Napoleon's projects
were too bold for his allies, and they withdrew when it became clear
that he contemplated nothing less than the establishment of a
Mexican empire. This he did, after much stiff fighting, making
the Archduke Maximilian of Austria, Emperor of Mexico in 1864.
The French forces, however, remained in effectual possession of the
country, and a crowd of French speculators poured into Mexico
to exploit its mines and resources.
But in April, 1865, the civil war in the United States was brought
to an end by the surrender of the great southern commander,
General Lee, at Appomattox Court House, and the little group of
eager Europeans in possession of Mexico found themselves faced
by the victorious federal government, in a thoroughly grim mood,
with a large, dangerous-looking army in hand. The French im-
perialists were bluntly given the alternative of war with the United
States or clearing out of America. In effect this was an instruc-
tion to go. This was the entanglement which prevented Napoleon
III from interference between Prussia and Austria in 1866, and
this was the reason why Bismarck precipitated his struggle with
Austria.
While Prussia was fighting Austria, Napoleon III was trying to
escape with dignity from the briars of Mexico. He invented a
shabby quarrel upon financial grounds with Maximilian and with-
drew the French troops. Then, by all the rules of kingship,
Maximilian should have abdicated. But instead he made a fight
for his empire; he was defeated by his recalcitrant subjects,
caught, and shot as a public nuisance in 1867. So the peace of
President Monroe was restored to the new world. There remained
only one monarchy in America, the empire of Brazil, where a
branch of the Portuguese royal family continued to reign until
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY 445
1889. In that year the emperor was quietly packed off to Paris,
and Brazil came into line with the rest of the continent.
But while Napoleon was busy with his American adventure,
Prussia and Italy were snatching victory over the Austrians (1866).
Italy was badly beaten at Custozza and in the naval battle of Lissa,
but the Austrian army was so crushed by the Prussian at the battle
of Sadowa, that Austria made an abject surrender. Italy gained
the province of Venetia, so making one more step towards unity —
only Rome and Trieste and a few small towns on the north and
north-western frontiers remained — and Prussia became the head
of a North German Confederation, from which Bavaria, Wurttem-
berg, Baden, Plesse, and Austria were excluded.
Four years later came the next step towards the natural political
map of Europe, when Napoleon III plunged into war against
Prussia. A kind of self-destroying foolishness urged him to do
this. He came near to this war in 1867 so soon as he was free from
Mexico, by demanding Luxembourg for France; he embarked
upon it in 1870, when a cousin of the king of Prussia became a
candidate for the vacant throne of Spain. Napoleon had some
theory in his mind that Austria, Bavaria, Wiirttemberg, and the
other states outside the North German Confederation would side
with him against Prussia.1 He probably thought this would Hap-
pen because he wanted it to happen. But since 1848 the Germans,
so far as foreign meddling was concerned, had been in spirit a
united people; Bismarck was merely imposing the Hohenzollern
monarchy, with pomp, ceremony, and bloodshed, upon accom-
plished facts. All Germany sided with Prussia.
Early in August, 1870, the united German forces invaded France.
After the battles of Worth and Gravelotte, one French army under
Bazaine was forced into Metz and surrounded there, and, on Sep-
tember 1st, a second, with which was Napoleon, was defeated and
obliged to capitulate at Sedan. Paris found herself bare to the
invader. For a second time the promises of Napoleonism had
failed France disastrously. On September 4th, France declared
1 There were also hopes of an Italian alliance for France, and these, combined
with the anti-Prussian direction of Austrian policy, and the Franco-Russian
rapprochement which had followed the Crimean War, almost justified Napoleon
in believing that he would not be left entirely alone. — P. G.
446 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
herself a republic again, and thus regenerated, prepared to fight
for existence against triumphant Prussianism. For though it
was a united Germany that had overcome French imperialism, it
had Prussia in the saddle. The army in Metz capitulated in
October; Paris, after a siege and bombardment, surrendered in
January, 1871.
With pomp and ceremony, in the Hall of Mirrors at Versailles,
amidst a great array of military uniforms, the King of Prussia was
declared German Emperor, and Bismarck and the sword of the
Hohenzollerns claimed the credit for that German unity which
a common language and literature had long since assured.
The peace of Frankfort was a Hohenzollern peace. Bismarck
had availed himself of the national feeling of Germany to secure
the aid of the South German states, but he had no grasp of the
essential forces that had given victory to him and to his royal
master. The power that had driven Prussia to victory was the
power of the natural political map of Europe insisting upon the
unity of the German-speaking peoples. In the east, Germany
was already sinning against that natural map by her administra-
tion of Posen and other Polish districts. Now greedy for territory,
and particularly for iron mines, she annexed a considerable area
of French-speaking Lorraine, including Metz, and Alsace, which,
in spite of its German speech, was largely French in sympathy.
Inevitably there was a clash between German rulers and French
subjects in these annexed provinces; inevitably the wrongs and
bitterness of the subjugated France of Lorraine echoed in Paris
and kept alive the passionate resentment of the French. . . .
The natural map had already secured political recognition in
the Austrian Empire after Sadowa (1866). Hungary, which had
been subordinated to Austria, was erected into a kingdom on an
equal footing with Austria, and the Empire of Austria had become
the dual " monarchy" of Austria-Hungary. But in the southeast
of this empire, and over the Turkish empire, the boundaries and
subjugations of the conquest period still remained.
A fresh upthrust of the natural map began in 1875, when the
Christian races in the Balkans, and particularly the Bulgarians,
became restless and insurgent. The Turks adopted violent re-
pressive measures, and embarked upon massacres of Bulgarians
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY 447
on an enormous scale. Thereupon Russia intervened (1877), and
after a year of costly warfare obliged the Turks to sign the treaty
of San Stefano, which was, on the whole, a sensible treaty, break-
ing up the artificial Turkish Empire, and to a large extent estab-
lishing the natural map. But it had become the tradition of British
policy to thwart "the designs of Russia" -heaven knows why!
-whenever Russia appeared to have a design, and the British
foreign office, under the premiership of Lord Beaconsfield, inter-
vened with a threat of war if a considerable restoration of the Turks'
facilities for exaction, persecution, and massacre was not made.
For a time war seemed very probable. The British music-halls,
those lamps to British foreign policy, were lit with patriotic fire,
and the London errand-boy on his rounds was inspired to chant,
with the simple dignity of a great people conscious of its high des-
tinies, a song declaring that:
"We don't want to fight, but, by Jingo,1 if we do,
We got the ships, we got the men, we got the munn-aye too" . . .
and so on to a climax :
"The Russ'ns shall not 'ave Con-stan-te-no pie."
In consequence of this British opposition, a conference was
assembled in 1878 at Berlin to revise the treaty of San Stefano,
chiefly in the interests of the Turkish and Austrian monarchies,
the British acquired the island of Cyprus, to which they had no
sort of right whatever, and which has never been of the slightest
use to them, and Lord Beaconsfield returned triumphantly from
the Berlin Conference, to the extreme exasperation of Mr. Glad-
stone, with what the British were given to understand at the time
was " Peace with Honour."
This treaty of Berlin was the second main factor, the peace of
Frankfort being the first, in bringing about the great war of 1914-18.
These thirty years after 1848 are years of very great interest to
the student of international political methods. Released from
their terror of a world-wide insurrection of the common people,
the governments of Europe were doing their best to resume the
game of Great Powers that had been so rudely interrupted by the
American and French revolutions. But it looked much more like
1 Hence "Jingo" for any rabid patriot.
448
THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
the old game than it was in reality. The mechanical revolution
was making war a far more complete disturbance of the general
life than it had ever been before, and the proceedings of the diplo-
matists were ruled, in spite of their efforts to disregard the fact, by
imperatives that Charles V and Louis XIV had never known. Ir-
ritation with misgovernment was capable of far better organization
T&P 0AkrBAlIOVN5
• • ••n * .1
the
TREATYV BERLIN
187-6
by Rumania . . [ffiff
CfAoft by Rumania, to
Kussia.,
AW Princq3.yof BuZoaria, S
autonomous province t.Rumolia
Proposed. 'Big Bulgarian,*
frontier of Treaty of San
and far more effective expression than it had ever been before.
Statesmen dressed this up as the work of the spirit of Nationalism,
but there were times and occasions when that costume wore very
thin. The grand monarchs of the seventeenth and eighteenth cen-
turies had seemed to be free to do this or that, to make war or to
keep the peace, to conquer this province or cede that as they willed ;
but such a ruler as Napoleon III went from one proceeding to an-
other with something of the effect of a man who feels his way among
things unseen.
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY 449
None of these European governments in the nineteenth century
was in fact a free agent. We look to-day at the maps of Europe
since 1814, we compare them with the natural map, and we see
that the game the Great Powers played was indeed a game of fore-
gone conclusions. Whatever arrangements they made that were
in accordance with the natural political map of the world, and the
trend towards educational democracy, held, and whatever arrange-
ments they made contrary to these things, collapsed. We are
forced, therefore, to the conclusion, that all the diplomatic fussing,
posturing, and scheming, all the intrigue and bloodshed of these
years, all the monstrous turmoil and waste of kings and armies, all
the wonderful attitudes, deeds, and schemes of the Cavours, Bis-
marcks, Disraelis, Bonapartes, and the like " great men," might
very well have been avoided altogether had Europe but had the
sense to instruct a small body of ordinarily honest ethnologists,
geographers, and sociologists to draw out its proper boundaries
and prescribe suitable forms of government in a reasonable manner.
The romantic phase in history had come to an end. A new age
was beginning with new and greater imperatives, and these nine-
teenth-century statesmen were but pretending to control events.
§9
We have suggested that in the political history of Europe be-
tween 1848 and 1878, the mechanical revolution was not yet pro-
ducing any very revolutionary changes. The post-revolutionary
Great Powers were still going on within boundaries of practically
the same size and with much the same formalities as they had done
in pre-revolutionary times. But where the increased speed and
certainty of transport and telegraphic communications were al-
ready producing very considerable changes of condition and
method, was in the overseas enterprises of Britain and the other
European powers, and in the reaction of Asia and Africa to Europe.
The end of the eighteenth century was a period of disrupting
empires and disillusioned expansionists. The long and tedious
journey between Britain and Spain and their colonies in America
prevented any really free coming and going between the home
land and the daughter lands, and so the colonies separated into
new and distinct communities, with distinctive ideas and interests
2a
450
THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY 451
and even modes of speech. As they grew they strained more and
more at the feeble and uncertain link of shipping that joined them.
Weak trading-posts in the wilderness, like those of France in Can-
ada, or trading establishments in great alien communities, like
those of Britain in India, might well cling for bare existence to the
nation which gave them support and a reason for their existence.
That much and no more seemed to many thinkers in the early part
of the nineteenth century to be the limit set to overseas rule. In
1820 the sketchy great European " empires" outside of Europe
that had figured so bravely in the maps of the middle eighteenth
century, had shrunken to very small dimensions. Only the Rus-
sian sprawled as large as ever across Asia. It sprawled much
larger in the imaginations of many Europeans than in reality, be-
cause of their habit of studying the geography of the world upon
Mercator's projection, which enormously exaggerated the size of
Siberia.
The British Empire in 1815 consisted of the -thinly populated
coastal river and lake regions of Canada, and a great hinterland
of wilderness in which the only settlements as yet were the fur-
trading stations of the Hudson Bay Company, about a third of
the Indian peninsula, under the rule of the East India Company,
the coast districts of the Cape of Good Hope inhabited by blacks
and rebellious-spirited Dutch settlers ; a few trading stations on
the coast of West Africa, the rock of Gibraltar, the island of Malta,
Jamaica, a few minor slave-labour possessions in the West Indies,
British Guiana in South America, and, on the other side of the
world, two dumps for convicts at Botany Bay in Australia and in
Tasmania. Spain retained Cuba and a few settlements in the
Philippine Islands. Portugal had in Africa some vestiges of her
ancient claims. Holland had various islands and possessions in
the East Indies and Dutch Guiana, and Denmark an island or so
in the West Indies. France had one or two West Indian Islands
and French Guiana. This seemed to be as much as the European
powers needed, or were likely to acquire of the rest of the world.
Only the East Indian Company showed any spirit of expansion.
In India, as we have already told, a peculiar empire was being
built up, not by the British peoples, nor by the British Government,
but by this company of private adventurers with their monopoly
452
THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY 453
and royal charter. The company had been forced to become a
military and political power during the years of Indian division
and insecurity that followed the break-up of India after the death
of Aurangzeb in 1707. It had learnt to trade in states and peoples
during the eighteenth century. Clive founded, Warren Hastings
organized, this strange new sort of empire; French rivalry was
defeated, as we have already told ; and by 1798, Lord Mornington,
afterwards the Marquis Wellesley, the elder brother of that Gen-
eral Wellesley who became the Duke of Wellington, became Gover-
nor-General of India, and set the policy of the company definitely
upon the line of replacing the fading empire of the Grand Mogul
by its own rule. Napoleon's expedition to Egypt was a direct at-
tack upon the empire of this British company. While Europe
was busy with the Napoleonic wars, the East India Company,
under a succession of governors-general, was playing much the same
role in India that had been played before by Turkoman and
such-like invaders from the north. And after the peace of Vienna
it went on, levying its revenues, making wars, sending ambas-
sadors to Asiatic powers, a quasi-independent state, a state,
however, with a marked disposition to send wealth westward.
In Chapter XXXVI, § 9, we have sketched the break-up of the
empire of the Great Mogul and the appearance of the Mahratta
states, the Rajput principalities, the Moslem kingdoms of Oudh
and Bengal, and the Sikhs. We cannot tell here in any detail how
the British company made its way to supremacy sometimes as the
ally of this power, sometimes as that, and finally as the conqueror
of all. Its power spread to Assam, Sind, Oudh. The map of
India began to take on the outlines familiar to the English
schoolboy of to-day, a patchwork of native states embraced
and held together by the great provinces under direct British
rule. . . .
Now as this strange unprecedented empire of the company grew
in the period between 1800 and 1858, the mechanical revolution
was quietly abolishing the great distance that had once separated
India and Britain. In the old days the rule of the company had
interfered little in the domestic life of the Indian states; it had
given India foreign overlords, but India was used to foreign over-
lords, and had hitherto assimilated them ; these Englishmen came
454 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
into the country young, lived there most of their lives, and became
a part of its system. But now the mechanical revolution began
to alter this state of affairs. It became easier for the British officials
to go home and to have holidays in Europe, easier for them to bring
out wives and families ; they ceased to be Indianized ; they re-
mained more conspicuously foreign and western — and there were
more of them. And they began to interfere more vigorously
with Indian customs. Magical and terrible things like the tele-
graph and the railway arrived. Christian missions became offen-
sively busy. If they did not make very many converts, at least
they made sceptics among the adherents of the older faiths. The
young men in the towns began to be " Europeanized " to the great
dismay of their elders.
India had endured many changes of rulers before, but never the
sort of changes in her ways that these things portended. The
Moslem teachers and the Brahmins were alike alarmed, and the
British were blamed for the progress of , mankind. Conflicts of
economic interests grew more acute with the increasing nearness
of Europe ; Indian industries, and particularly the ancient cotton
industry, suffered from legislation that favoured the British manu-
facturer.1 A piece of incredible folly on the part of the company
precipitated an outbreak. To the Brahmin a cow is sacred; to
the Moslem the pig is unclean. A new rifle, needing greased car-
tridges — which the men had to bite — was served out to the com-
pany's Indian soldiers ; the troops discovered that their cartridges
were greased with the fat of cows and swine. This discovery pre-
cipitated a revolt of the company's Indian army, the Indian mutiny
(1857). First the troops mutinied at Meerut. Then Delhi rose
to restore the empire of the Great Mogul. . . .
The British public suddenly discovered India. They became
aware of that little garrison of British people, far away in that
strange land of fiery dust and weary sunshine, fighting for life
against dark multitudes of assailants. How they got there and
what right they had there, the British public did not ask. The
love of one's kin in danger overrides such questions. 1857 was a
year of passionate anxiety in Great Britain. With mere handfuls
1 See England's Debt to India by Lajpat Rai for a good statement of India's
economic grievance.
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY 455
of troops the British leaders, and notably Lawrence and Nichol-
son, did amazing things. They did not sit down to be besieged
while the mutineers organized and gathered prestige ; that would
have lost them India for ever. They attacked often against over-
whelming odds. "Clubs, not spades, are trumps," said Lawrence.
The Sikhs, the Gurkhas, the Punjab troops stuck to the British.
The south remained tranquil. Of the massacres of Cawnpore and
Lucknow in Oudh, and how a greatly outnumbered force of British
troops besieged and stormed Delhi, other histories must tell. By
April, 1859, the last embers of the blaze had been stamped out,
and the British were masters of India again. In no sense had the
mutiny been a popular insurrection ; it was a mutiny merely of the
Bengal Army, due largely to the unimaginative rule of the company
officials. Its story abounds in instances of Indian help and kind-
ness to British fugitives. But it was a warning.
The direct result of the mutiny was the annexation of the Indian
Empire to the British Crown. By the act entitled An Act for the
Better Government of India, the Governor-General became a Viceroy
representing the Sovereign, and the place of the company was taken
by a Secretary of State for India responsible to the British Parlia-
ment. In 1877, Lord Beaconsfield, to complete this work, caused
Queen Victoria to be proclaimed Empress of India.
Upon these extraordinary lines India and Britain are linked at
the present time. India is still the empire of the Great Mogul,
but the Great Mogul has been replaced by the "crowned republic"
of Great Britain. India is an autocracy without an autocrat. Its
rule combines the disadvantage of absolute monarchy with the
impersonality and irresponsibility of democratic officialdom. The
Indian with a complaint to make has no visible monarch to go to ;
his Emperor is a golden symbol; he must circulate pamphlets in
England or inspire a question in the British House of Commons.
The more occupied Parliament is with British affairs, the less atten-
tion India will receive, and the more she will be at the mercy of her
small group of higher officials.
This is manifestly impossible as a permanent state of affairs.
Indian life, whatever its restraints, is moving forward with the
rest of the world; India has an increasing service of newspapers,
an increasing number of educated people affected by Western ideas,
456 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
and an increasing sense of a common grievance against her govern-
ment. There had been little or no corresponding advance in the
education and quality of the British official in India during the
century. His tradition is a high one ; he is often a man of excep-
tional quality, but the system is unimaginative and inflexible.
Moreover, the military power that stands behind these officials
has developed neither in character nor intelligence during the last
century. No other class has been so stagnant intellectually as
the British military caste. Confronted with a more educated
India, the British military man, uneasily aware of his educational
defects and constantly apprehensive of ridicule, has in the last
few years displayed a disposition towards spasmodic violence that
has had some very lamentable results. For a time the great war
altogether diverted what small amount of British public attention
was previously given to India, and drew away the more intelligent
military men from her service. During those years, and the
feverish years of unsettlement that followed, things occurred in
India, the massacre of an unarmed political gathering at Amritzar
in which nearly two thousand people were killed or wounded,
floggings and humiliating outrages, a sort of official's Terror, that
produced a profound moral shock when at last the Hunter Commis-
sion of 1919 brought them before the home public. In liberal-
minded Englishmen, who have been wont to regard their empire
as an incipient league of free peoples, this revelation, of the
barbaric quality in its administrators produced a very understand-
able dismay. . . .
But the time has not yet come for writing the chapter of history
that India is opening for herself. . . . We cannot discuss here in
detail the still unsettled problems of the new India that struggles
into being. Already in the Government of India Act of 1919 we
may have the opening of a new and happier era that may culminate
in a free and willing group of Indian peoples taking an equal place
among the confederated states of the world. . . .
The growth of the British Empire in directions other than that
of India was by no means so rapid during the earlier half of the
nineteenth century. A considerable school of political thinkers in
Britain was disposed to regard overseas possessions as a source of
weakness to the kingdom. The Australian settlements developed
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY 457
slowly until in 1842 the discovery of valuable copper mines, and
in 1851 of gold, gave them a new importance. Improvements
in transport were also making Australian wool an increasingly
marketable commodity in Europe. Canada too was not remark-
ably progressive until 1849 ; it was troubled by dissensions between
its French and British inhabitants, there were several serious re-
volts, and it was only in 1867 that a new constitution creating a
Federal Dominion of Canada relieved its internal strains. It was
the railway that altered the Canadian outlook. It enabled Canada,
just as it enabled the United States, to expand westward, to market
its corn and other produce in Europe, and in spite of its swift and
extensive growth, to remain in language and sympathy and interests
one community. The railway, the steamship, and the telegraphic
cable were indeed changing all the conditions of colonial develop-
ment.
Before 1840, English settlements had already begun in New
Zealand, and a new Zealand Land Company had been formed to
exploit the possibilities of the island. In 1840 New Zealand also
was added to the colonial possessions of the British Crown.
Canada, as we have noted, was the first of the British possessions
to respond richly to the new economic possibilities the new methods
of transport were opening. Presently the republics of South
America, and particularly the Argentine Republic, began to feel,
in their cattle trade and coffee growing, the increased nearness of
the European market. Hitherto the chief commodities that had
attracted the European powers into unsettled and barbaric regions
had been gold or other metals, spices, ivory, or slaves. But in the
latter quarter of the nineteenth century the increase of the European
populations was obliging their governments to look abroad for
staple foods ; and the growth of scientific industrialism was creat-
ing a demand for new raw materials, fats and greases of every kind,
rubber, and other hitherto disregarded substances. It was plain
that Great Britain and Holland and Portugal were reaping a great
and growing commercial advantage from their very considerable
control of tropical and semi-tropical products. After 1871 Ger-
many and presently France and later Italy began to look for un-
annexed raw-material areas, or for Oriental countries capable of
profitable modernization.
458
THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
So began a fresh scramble all over the world, except in the Amer-
ican region where the Monroe Doctrine now barred such adven-
tures, for politically unprotected lands. Close to Europe was the
continent of Africa, full of vaguely known possibilities. In 1850
it was a continent of black mystery; only Egypt and the coast
were known. A map must show the greatness of the European
ignorance at that time. It would need a book as long as this Outline
to do justice to the amazing story of the explorers and adventurers
who first pierced this cloud of darkness, and to the political agents,
administrators, traders, settlers, and scientific men who followed
in their track. Wonderful races of men like the pigmies, strange
beasts like the okapi, marvellous fruits and flowers and insects, terri-
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY
459
ble diseases, astounding scenery of forest and mountain, enormous
inland seas, and gigantic rivers and cascades were revealed ; a whole
new world. Even remains (at Zimbabwe) of some unrecorded
and vanished civilization, the southward enterprise of an early
people, were discovered. Into this new world came the Euro-
AFRICA
1914
-British
"French
Gorman —
Portuguese..
BeZgian.
Spanish,....
Italian...,
peans, and found the rifle already there in the hands of the Arab
slave-traders, and negro life in disorder. By 1900, as our second
map must show, all Africa was mapped, explored, estimated, and
divided between the European powers, divided with much snarl-
ing and disputation into portions that left each power uneasy or
discontented. Little heed was given to the welfare of the natives
in this scramble. The Arab slaver was indeed curbed rather than
460 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
expelled, but the greed for rubber, which was a wild product
collected under compulsion by the natives in the Belgian Congo,
a greed exacerbated by the pitiless avarice of the King of the
Belgians, and the clash of inexperienced European administrators
with the native population in many other annexations, led to
horrible atrocities. No European power has perfectly clean hands
in this matter.
We cannot tell here in any detail how Great Britain got possession
of Egypt in 1883, and remained there in spite of the fact that Egypt
was technically a part of the Turkish Empire, nor how nearly this
scramble led to war between France and Great Britain in 1898,
when a certain Colonel Marchand, crossing Central Africa from
the west coast, tried at Fashoda to seize the Upper Nile. In Uganda
the French Catholic and the British Anglican missionaries dis-
seminated a form of Christianity so heavily charged with the spirit
of Napoleon, and so finely insistent upon the nuances of doctrine,
that a few years after its first glimpse of European civilization,
Mengo, the capital of Uganda, was littered with dead " Protes-
tants" and " Catholics" extremely difficult to distinguish from the
entirely unspiritual warriors of the old regime.
Nor can we tell how the British Government first let the Boers,
or Dutch settlers, of the Orange River district and the Transvaal
set up independent republics in the inland parts of South Africa,
and then repented and annexed the Transvaal Republic in 1877 ;
nor how the Transvaal Boers fought for freedom and won it after
the Battle of Majuba Hill (1881). Majuba Hill was made to
rankle in the memory of the English people by a persistent press
campaign. A war with both republics broke out in 1899, a three
years' war enormously costly to the British people, which ended at
last in the surrender of the two republics.
Their period of subjugation was a brief one. In 1907, after the
downfall of the imperialist government which had conquered
them, the Liberals took the South African problem in hand, and
these former republics became free and fairly willing associates
with Cape Colony and Natal in a confederation of all the states of
South Africa as one self-governing republic under the British Crown.
In a quarter of a century the partition of Africa was completed.
There remained unannexed three comparatively small countries:
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY 461
Liberia, a settlement of liberated negro slaves on the west coast ;
Morocco, under a Moslem Sultan ; 1 and Abyssinia, a barbaric
country, with an ancient and peculiar form of Christianity, which
had successfully maintained its independence against Italy at
the Battle of Adowa in 1896.
§10
It is difficult to believe that any large number of people really
accepted this headlong painting of the map of Africa in European
colours as a permanent new settlement of the world's affairs, but
it is the duty of the historian to record that it was so accepted.
There was but a shallow historical background to the European
mind in the nineteenth century, hardly any sense of what consti-
tutes an enduring political system, and no habit of penetrating
criticism. The quite temporary advantages that the onset of
the mechanical revolution in the west had given the European
great powers over the rest of the old world were regarded by people,
blankly ignorant of the great Mongol conquests of the thirteenth
and following centuries, as evidences of a permanent and assured
leadership. They had no sense of the transferability of science
and its fruits. They did not realize that Chinamen and Indians
could carry on the work of research as ably as Frenchmen or English-
men. They believed that there was some innate intellectual drive
in the west, and some innate indolence and conservatism in the
east, that assured the Europeans a world predominance for ever.
The consequence of this infatuation was that the various Euro-
pean foreign offices set themselves not merely to scramble with the
British for the savage and undeveloped regions of the world's
surface, but also to carve up the populous and civilized countries
of Asia as though these peoples also were no more than raw material
for European exploitation. The inwardly precarious but outwardly
splendid imperialism of the British ruling class in India, and the
extensive and profitable possessions of the Dutch in the East Indies,
filled the ruling and mercantile classes of the rival great powers
with dreams of similar glories in Persia, in the disintegrating Otto-
man Empire, and in Further India, China, and Japan. In the
closing years of the nineteenth century it was assumed, as the
1 Now a French Protectorate, — P. G.
462 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
reader may verify by an examination of the current literature of
the period, to be a natural and inevitable thing that all the world
should fall under European dominion. With a hypocritical pre-
tence of reluctant benevolent effort the European mind prepared
itself to take up what Mr. Rudyard Kipling called "the White
Man's Burthen " - - that is to say, the loot and lordship of the earth.
The Powers set themselves to this enterprise in a mood of jostling
rivalry, with half-educated or illiterate populations at home, with
a mere handful of men, a few thousand at most, engaged in scientific
research, with their internal political systems in a state of tension
or convulsive change, with a creaking economic system of the most
provisional sort, and with their religions far gone in decay. They
really believed that the vast populations of eastern Asia could be
permanently subordinated to such a Europe.
Even to-day there are many people who fail to grasp the essen-
tial facts of this situation. They do not realize that in Asia the
average brain is not one whit inferior in quality to the average
European brain; that history shows Asiatics to be as bold, as
vigorous, as generous, as self-sacrificing, and as capable of strong
collective action as Europeans, and that there are and must con-
tinue to be a great many more Asiatics than Europeans in the
world. It has always been difficult to restrain the leakage of
knowledge from one population to another, and now it becomes
impossible. Under modern conditions world-wide economic and
educational equalization is in the long run inevitable. An intellec-
tual and moral rally of the Asiatics is going on at the present time.
The slight leeway of a century or so, a few decades may recover.
At the present time, for example, for one Englishman who knows
Chinese thoroughly, or has any intimate knowledge of Chinese
life and thought, there are hundreds of Chinamen conversant with
everything the English know. The balance of knowledge in favour
of India may be even greater. To Britain, India sends students ;
to India, Britain sends officials. There is no organization whatever
for the sending of European students, as students, to examine and
inquire into Indian history, archaeology, and current affairs.
Since the year 1898, the year of the seizure of Kiau-Chau by
Germany and of Wei-hai-wei by Britain, and the year after the Rus-
sian taking of Port Arthur, events in China have moved more
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY 463
rapidly than in any other country except Japan. A great hatred
of Europeans swept like a flame over China, and a political society
for the expulsion of Europeans, the Boxers, grew up and broke
out into violence in 1900. This was an outbreak of rage and mis-
chief on quite old-fashioned lines. In 1900 the Boxers murdered 250
Europeans and, it is said, nearly 30,000 Christians. China, not
for the first time in history, was under the sway of a dowager em-
press, who, like the Empress Theodora of Constantinople, had once,
it is said, been a woman of no repute. She was an ignorant woman,
but of great force of character and in close sympathy with the
Boxers. She supported them, and protected those who perpe-
trated outrages on the Europeans. All that again is what might
have happened in 500 B.C. or thereabouts against the Huns.
Things came to a crisis in 1900. The Boxers became more and
more threatening to the Europeans in China. Attempts were
made to send up additional European guards to the Peking lega-
tions, but this only precipitated matters. The German ambassa-
dor was shot down in the streets of Peking by a soldier of the im-
perial guard. The rest of the foreign ambassadors gathered to-
gether and made a fortification of the more favourably situated
embassies and stood a siege of two months. A combined allied
force of 20,000 under a German general then marched up to Peking
and relieved the legations, and the old Empress fled northwestward.
Some of the European troops committed grave atrocities upon the
Chinese civil population.1 That brings one up to about the level
of 1850, let us say.
There followed the practical annexation of Manchuria by Russia,
a squabble among the powers, and in 1904 a British invasion of Tibet,
hitherto a forbidden country. But what did not appear on the
surface of these events, and what made all these events fundamen-
tally different, was that China now contained a considerable num-
ber of able people who had a European education and European
knowledge. The Boxer Insurrection subsided, and then the in-
fluence of this new factor began to appear in talk of a constitution
(1906), in the suppression of opium-smoking, and in educational
reforms. A constitution of the Japanese type came into existence
1 See Putnam Weale's Indiscreet Letters from Pekin, a partly fictitious book, but
true and vivid in its effects.
464 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
in 1909, making China a limited monarchy. But China is not
to be moulded to the Japanese pattern, and the revolutionary stir
continued. Japan, in her own reorganization, and in accordance
with her temperament, had turned her eyes to the monarchist west,
but China was looking across the Pacific. In 1911 the essential
Chinese revolution began. In 1912 the emperor abdicated, and
the greatest community in the world became a republic. The
overthrow of the emperor was also the overthrow of the Manchus,
and the Mongolian pigtail, which had been compulsory for the
Chinese since 1644, vanished again from the land.
At the present time it is probable that there is more good brain
matter and more devoted men working out the modernization and
the reorganization of the Chinese civilization than we should find
directed to the welfare of any single European people. China
will presently have a modernized practicable script, a press, new
and vigorous modern universities, a reorganized industrial system,
and a growing body of scientific and economic inquiry. The nat-
ural industry and ingenuity of her vast population will be released
to co-operate upon terms of equality with the Western world. She
may have great internal difficulties ahead of her yet ; of that no
man can judge. Nevertheless, the time may notibe very distant
when the Federated States of China may be at one with the United
States of America and a pacified and reconciled Europe in upholding
the organized peace of the world.
§n
The pioneer country, however, in the recovery of the Asiatic
peoples was not China, but Japan. We have outrun our story in
telling of China. Hitherto Japan has played but a small part in
this history; her secluded civilization has not contributed very
largely to the general shaping of human destinies ; she has received
much, but she has given little. The original inhabitants of the
Japanese Islands were probably a northern people with remote
Nordic affinities, the Hairy Ainu. But the Japanese proper are
of the Mongolian race. Physically they resemble the Amerindians,
and there are many curious resemblances between the prehistoric
pottery and so forth of Japan and similar Peruvian products. It
is not impossible that they are a back-flow from the trans-Pacific
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY 465
drift of the early heliolithic culture, but they may also have ab-
sorbed from the south a Malay and even a Negrito element.
Whatever the origin of the Japanese, there can be no doubt that
their civilization, their writing, and their literary and artistic tra-
ditions are derived from the Chinese. They were emerging from
barbarism in the second and third century of the Christian Era,
and one of their earliest acts as a people outside their own country
was an invasion of Korea under a queen Jingo, who seems to have
played a large part in establishing their civilization. Their history
is an interesting and romantic one ; they developed a feudal system
and a tradition of chivalry ; their attacks upon Korea and China
are an Eastern equivalent of the English wars in France. Japan
was first brought into contact with Europe in the sixteenth century ;
in 1542 some Portuguese reached it in a Chinese junk, and in 1549
a Jesuit missionary, Francis Xavier, began his teaching there. The
Jesuit accounts describe a country greatly devastated by perpetual
feudal war. For a time Japan welcomed European intercourse,
and the Christian missionaries made a great number of converts.
A certain William Adams, of Gillingham, in Kent, became the most
trusted European adviser of the Japanese, and showed them how to
build big ships. There were voyages in Japanese-built ships to
India and Peru. Then arose complicated quarrels between the
Spanish Dominicans, the Portuguese Jesuits, and the English and
Dutch Protestants, each warning the Japanese against the evil
political designs of the others. The Jesuits, in a phase of ascend-
ancy, persecuted and insulted the Buddhists with great acrimony.
These troubles interwove with the feudal conflicts of the time. In
the end the Japanese came to the conclusion that the Europeans
and their Christianity were an intolerable nuisance, and that Cath-
olic Christianity in particular was a mere cloak for the political
dreams of the Pope and the Spanish monarchy — already in posses-
sion of the Philippine Islands ; there was a great and conclusive per-
secution of the Christians, and in 1638 Japan was absolutely closed
to Europeans,1 and remained closed for over 200 years. During
1 With the exception of one wretched Dutch factory on the minute island of
Deshima in the harbour of Nagasaki. The Dutch were exposed to almost un-
endurable indignities. They had no intercourse with any Japanese except the
special officials appointed to deal with them.
2H
466 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
those two centuries the Japanese remained as completely cut off
from the rest of the world as though they lived upon another planet.
It was forbidden to build any ship larger than a mere coasting
boat. No Japanese could go abroad, and no European enter the
country.
For two centuries Japan remained outside the main current of
history. She lived on in a state of picturesque feudalism enlivened
by blood feuds, in which about five per cent, of the population, the
samurai, or fighting men, and the nobles and their families, tyran-
nized without restraint over the rest of the population. All com-
mon men knelt when a noble passed ; to betray the slightest dis-
respect was to risk being slashed to death by his samurai. The elect
classes lived lives of romantic adventure without one redeeming
gleam of novelty ; they loved, murdered, and pursued fine points
of honour — which probably bored the intelligent ones extremely.
We can imagine the wretchedness of a curious mind, tormented
by the craving for travel and knowledge, cooped up in these islands
of empty romance.
Meanwhile the great world outside went on to wider visions and
new powers. Strange shipping became more frequent, passing the
Japanese headlands; sometimes ships were wrecked and sailors
brought ashore. Through the Dutch settlement at Deshima, their
one link with the outer universe, came warnings' 'that Japan
was not keeping pace with the power of the Western world. In
1837 a ship sailed into Yedo Bay flying a strange flag of stripes
and stars, and carrying some Japanese sailors she had picked up
far adrift in the Pacific. She was driven off by a cannon shot.
This flag presently reappeared on other ships. One in 1849 came
to demand the liberation of eighteen shipwrecked American sailors.
Then in 1853 came four American warships under Commodore
Perry, and refused to be driven away. He lay at anchor in for-
bidden waters, and sent messages to the two rulers who at that
time shared the control of Japan. In 1854 he returned with ten
ships, amazing ships propelled by steam, and equipped with big
guns, and he made proposals for trade and intercourse that the
Japanese had no power to resist. He landed with a guard of 500
men to sign the treaty. Incredulous crowds watched this visita-
tion from the outer world, marching through the streets.
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY 467
Russia, Holland, and Britain followed in the wake of America.
Foreigners entered the country, and conflicts between them and
Japanese gentlemen of spirit ensued. A British subject was killed
in a street brawl, and a Japanese town was bombarded by the
British (1863). A great nobleman whose estates commanded the
Straits of Shimonoseki saw fit to fire on foreign vessels, and a
second bombardment by a fleet of British, French, Dutch, and
American warships destroyed his batteries and scattered his swords-
men. Finally an allied squadron (1865), at anchor off Kioto, im-
posed a ratification of the treaties which opened Japan to the
world.
The humiliation of the Japanese by these events was intense,
and it would seem that the salvation of peoples lies largely in such
humiliations. With astonishing energy and intelligence they set
themselves to bring their culture and organization up to the level
of the European powers. Never in all the history of mankind
did a nation make such a stride as Japan then did. In 1866 she
was a mediaeval people, a fantastic caricature of the extremist
romantic feudalism; in 1899 hers was a completely Westernized
people, on a level with the most advanced European powers, and
well in advance of Russia. She completely dispelled the persuasion
that Asia was in some irrevocable way hopelessly behind Europe.
She made all European progress seem sluggish and tentative by
comparison.
We cannot tell here in any detail of Japan's war with China in
1894-95. It demonstrated the extent of her Westernization. She
had an efficient Westernized army and a small but sound fleet.
But the significance of her renascence, though it was appreciated
by Britain and the United States, who were already treating her
as if she were a European state, was not understood by the other
great powers engaged in the pursuit of new Indias in Asia. Russia
was pushing down through Manchuria to Korea, France was al-
ready established far to the south in Tonkin and Annam, Germany
was prowling hungrily on the look-out for some settlement. The
three powers combined to prevent Japan reaping any fruits from
the Chinese war, and particularly from establishing herself on the
mainland at the points commanding the Japan sea. She was ex-
hausted by her war with China, and they threatened he_r with war,
468
THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
JAPA:NL
& -die Eastern Coast
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY 469
In 1898 Germany descended upon China, and, making the
murder of two missionaries her excuse, annexed a portion of the
province of Shang-tung. Thereupon Russia seized the Liao-tung
peninsula, and extorted the consent of China to an extension of
her trans-Siberian railway to Port Arthur; and in 1900 she
occupied Manchuria. Britain was unable to resist the imitative
impulse, and seized the port of Wei-hai-wei (1898). How alarm-
ing these movements must have been to every intelligent Japanese
a glance at the map will show. They led to a war with Russia
which marks an epoch in the history of Asia, the close of the period
of European arrogance. The Russian people were, of course,
innocent and ignorant of this trouble that was being made for
them half-way round the world, and the wiser Russian statesmen
were against these foolish thrusts ; but a gang of financial adven-
turers surrounded the Tsar, including the Grand Dukes, his cousins.
They had gambled deeply in the prospective looting of Manchuria
and China, and they would suffer no withdrawal. So there began
a transportation of great armies of Japanese soldiers across the
sea to Port Arthur and Korea, and the sending of endless train-loads
of Russian peasants along the Siberian railway to die in those
distant battlefields.
The Russians, badly led and dishonestly provided, were beaten
on sea and land alike. The Russian Baltic Fleet sailed round
Africa to be utterly destroyed in the Straits of Tshu-shima. A
revolutionary movement among the common people of Russia,
infuriated by this remote and reasonless slaughter, obliged the
Tsar to end the war (1905) ; he returned the southern half of
Saghalien, which had been seized by Russia in 1875, evacuated
Manchuria, resigned Korea to Japan. The White Man was
beginning to drop his " Burthen" in eastern Asia. For some years,
however, Germany remained in uneasy possession of Kiau-Chau.
§12
We have already noted how the enterprise of Italy in Abyssinia
had been checked at the terrible battle of Adowa (1896), in which
over 3000 Italians were killed and more than 4000 taken prisoner.
The phase of imperial expansion at the expense of organized non-
European states was manifestly drawing to a close. It had en-
i
470 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
tangled the quite sufficiently difficult political and social problems
of Great Britain, France, Spain, Italy, Germany, and Russia with
the affairs of considerable alien, unassimilable, and resentful popu-
lations; Great Britain had Egypt (not formally annexed as yet),
India, Burmah, and a variety of such minor problems as Malta and
Shanghai ; France had cumbered herself with Tonkin and Annam
in addition to Algiers and Tunis; Spain was newly entangled in
Morocco; Italy had found trouble for herself in Tripoli; and
German overseas imperialism, though its "place in the sun" seemed
a poor one, derived what satisfaction it could from the thought of a
prospective war with Japan over Kiau-Chau. All these " subject"
lands had populations at a level of intelligence and education very
little lower than those of the possessing country ; the development
of a native press, of a collective self -consciousness, and of demands
for self-government was in each case inevitable, and the states-
men of Europe had been far too busy achieving these empires
to have any clear ideas of what they would do with them when
they got them.
The Western democracies, as they woke up to freedom, dis-
covered themselves " imperial/ 'and were considerably embarrassed
by the discovery. The East came to the Western capitals with
perplexing demands. In London the common Englishman, much
preoccupied by strikes, by economic riddles, by questions of
nationalization, municipalization, and the like, found that his
path was crossed and his public meetings attended by a large and
increasing number of swarthy gentlemen in turbans, fezzes, and
other strange headgear, all saying in effect: "You have got us.
The people who represent your government have destroyed our
own government, and prevent us from making a new one. What
are you going to do with us?"
(A question whose answer still lies beyond the frontiers of
history.)
§13
We may note here briefly the very various nature of the con-
stituents of the British Empire in 1914. It was and is a quite
unique political combination ; nothing of the sort has ever existed
before.
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY 471
First and central to the whole system was the " crowned re-
public" of the United British Kingdoms, including (against the
will of a considerable part of the Irish people) Ireland. The
majority of the British Parliament, made up of the three united
parliaments of England, Scotland, and Ireland, determines the
headship, the quality, and policy of the ministry, and determines
it largely on considerations arising out of British domestic politics.
It is this ministry which is the effective supreme government,
with powers of peace and war, over all the rest of the empire ;
Next in order of political importance to the British States were
the " crowned republics " of Australia, Canada, Newfoundland (the
oldest British possession, 1583), New Zealand, and South Africa,
all practically independent and self-governing states in alliance
with Great Britain, but each with a representative of the Crown
appointed by the Government in office ;
Next the Indian Empire, an extension of the empire of the
Great Mogul, with its dependent and " protected" states reaching
now from Baluchistan to Burmah, and including Aden, in all
of which empire the British Crown and the Indian Office (under
Parliamentary control) played the role of the original Turkoman
dynasty ;
Then the ambiguous possession of Egypt, still nominally a part
of the Turkish Empire and still retaining its own monarch, the
Khedive, but under almost despotic British official rule ;
Then the still more ambiguous " Anglo-Egyptian" Sudan prov-
ince, occupied and administered jointly by the British and by the
(British controlled) Egyptian Government;
Then a number of partially self-governing communities, some
British in origin and some not, with elected legislatures and an
appointed executive, such as Malta,1 Jamaica, the Bahamas, and
Bermuda ;
Then the Crown colonies, in which the rule of the British Home
Government (through the Colonial Office), verged on autocracy, as
in Ceylon, Trinidad, and Fiji (where there was an appointed coun-
cil), and Gibraltar and St. Helena (where there was a governor) ;
Then great areas of (chiefly) tropical lands, raw-product areas,
1 A new and much more liberal Maltese constitution was promulgated in June,
1920, practically putting Malta on the footing of a self-governing colony.
472 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
with politically weak and under-civilized native communities,
which were nominally protectorates, and administered either by a
High Commissioner set over native chiefs (as in Basutoland) or
over a chartered company (as in Rhodesia). In some cases the
Foreign Office, in some cases the Colonial Office, and in some cases
the India Office had been concerned in acquiring the possessions
that fell into this last and least definite class of all, but for the most
part the Colonial Office was now responsible for them.
It will be manifest, therefore, that no single office and no single
brain had ever comprehended the British Empire as a whole. It
was a mixture of growths and accumulations entirely different
from anything that has ever been called an empire before. It
guaranteed a wide peace and security ; that is why it was endured
and sustained by many men of the "subject" races — in spite
of official tyrannies and insufficiencies, and of much negligence on
the part of the "home" public. Like the "Athenian empire,"
it was an overseas empire ; its ways were sea ways, and its com-
mon link was the British Navy. Like all empires, its cohesion was
dependent physically upon a method of communication; the
development of seamanship, ship-building, and steamships be-
tween the sixteenth and nineteenth centuries had made it a pos-
sible and convenient Pax — the "Pax Britannica," and fresh
developments of air or swift land transport might at any time
make it inconvenient.
Air transport may indeed be already opening the way to a still
more extensive and universal "Pax," in which the British system
may of its own accord merge. It is impossible to say whether this
unprecedented imperialism will obstruct or help forward that
final unification of the world's affairs towards which all history
is pointing. A system so various in its structure has many con-
tradictory aspects, some very attractive and some very repellent
to a liberal intelligence. The conversion of Canada, Australia,
New Zealand, and South Africa from mere administered depen-
dencies into quasi-independent allies, has been a very fine feat of
statescraft. But in these cases the British Government had to
deal with largely kindred and sympathetic populations, very
ready to renew the methods of the old country upon a distant
soil. In the case of mainly alien peoples the record is not so good,
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY 473
and, for reasons we have already partly analyzed (§ 6), it has been
worse during the last few decades than it was before. There has
been a deterioration in the quality of British imperialism in rela-
tion to " subject peoples. " Whether that is a temporary deteriora-
tion or whether it is a fated drift towards disruption is a question
of the profoundest moment to an English writer, but it is one
that it is impossible to discuss properly within the limits of this
Outline. But even at its worst it is open to question whether the
British rule in India does not compare favourably with any other
domination of one entirely remote and alien civilization by another.
What is wrong is not so much that Britain rules India and Egypt,
but that any civilized country should be ruled by the legislature
of another, and that there should be no impartial court of appeal
in the world yet to readjust this arrangement.1
1 All intelligent Englishmen or Englishwomen with a vote owe it to the Empire
and themselves to read at least one book dealing with India or Egypt from the
native point of view. For India, Lajpat Rai's Political Future of India is to be
recommended. A compact book running counter to the views in this text, and
giving the Church missionary point of view, is the Rev. W. E. S. Holland's Goal of
India. William Archer's India and the Future is an interesting display of the
temperamental clash of a Nordic writer with things Dravidian. It sustains the
argument that even the most high-minded Nordic type cannot be trusted to govern
other races sympathetically. (See also in that matter Archer's In A fro- America.')
The Aga Khan's India in Transition gives very admirably the views of a liberal
Indian gentleman. Sidney Low's A Vision of India is still not yet superseded
as a picture of India in 1905-6, when the present stir was only brewing.
474
XL
THE INTERNATIONAL CATASTROPHE OF 1914 *
§ 1. The Armed Peace before the Great War. § 2. Imperial
Germany. § 3. The Spirit of Imperialism in Britain and
Ireland. § 4. Imperialism in France, Italy, and the Balkans.
§ 5. Russia a Grand Monarchy. § 6. The United States and
the Imperial Idea. § 7. The Immediate Causes of the Great
War. § 8. A Summary of the Great War up to 1917. § 9. The
Great War from the Russian Collapse to the Armistice. § 10. The
Political, Economical, and Social Disorganization Caused by the
War. § 11. President Wilson and the Problems of Versailles.
§ 12. Summary of the First Covenant of the League of Nations.
§ 13. A General Outline of the Treaties of 1919 and 1920.
§ 14. A Forecast of the "Next War." § 15. The State of Men's
Minds in 1920.
§1
FOR thirty-six years after the Treaty of San Stefano and the
Berlin Conference, Europe maintained an uneasy peace within
its borders ; there was no war between any of the leading states
during this period. They jostled^ browbeat, and threatened one
another, but they did not come to actual hostilities. There was
a general realization after 1871 that modern war was a much
more serious thing than the professional warfare of the eighteenth
century, an effort of peoples as a whole that might strain the social
fabric very severely, an adventure not to be rashly embarked
1 A very good book for the expansion of this chapter is Stearns Davis' (with Ander-
son and Tyler) Armed Peace, a history of Europe from 1870 to 1914. Even more
illuminating is G. P. Gooch's History of Our Time (1885-1911). This is quite a
tiny book, but very clear and thorough. It was revised in its present form in
February, 1914, so that its title is misleading; it comes up to 1914. It contains
an excellent student's bibliography.
475
476 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
upon. The mechanical revolution was giving constantly more
powerful (and expensive) weapons by land and sea, and more
rapid methods of transport; and making it more and more im-
possible to carry on warfare without a complete dislocation of the
economic life of the community. Even the foreign offices felt the
fear of war.
But though war was dreaded as it had never been dreaded in the
world before, nothing was done in the way of setting up a federal
control to prevent human affairs drifting towards war. In 1898,
it is true, the young Tsar Nicholas II (1894-1917) issued a rescript
inviting the other Great Powers to a conference of states "seeking
to make the great idea of universal peace triumph over the ele-
ments of trouble and discord." His rescript recalls the declara-
tion of his predecessor, Alexander I, which gave its tone to the
Holy Alliance, and it is vitiated by the same assumption that
peace can be established between sovereign governments rather
than by a broad appeal to the needs and rights of the one people
of mankind. The lesson of the United States of America, which
showed that there could be neither unity of action nor peace until
the thought of the "people of Virginia" and the "people of Massa-
chusetts" had been swept aside by the thought of the "people of
the United States," went entirely disregarded in the European
attempts at pacification. Two conferences were held at The
Hague in Holland, one in 1899 and another in 1907, and at the
second nearly all the sovereign states of the world were represented.
They were represented diplomatically, there was no direction of the
general intelligence of the world to their deliberations, the ordinary
common man did not even know that these conferences were
sitting, and for the most part the assembled representatives haggled
cunningly upon points of international law affecting war, leaving
aside the abolition of war as a chimsera. These Hague Con-
ferences did nothing to dispel the idea that international life is
necessarily competitive. They accepted that idea. They did
nothing to develop the consciousness of a world commonweal
overriding sovereigns and foreign offices. The international
lawyers and statesmen who attended these gatherings were as little
disposed to hasten on a world commonweal on such a basis as
were the Prussian statesmen of 1848 to welcome an all-German
THE CATASTROPHE OF 1914 477
parliament overriding the rights and " policy" of the King of
Prussia.
In America a series of three Pan-American conferences in 1889,
1901, and 1906 went some way towards the development of a
scheme of international arbitration for the whole American conti-
nent.
The character and good faith of Nicholas II, who initiated these
Hague gatherings, we will not discuss at any length here. He
may have thought that time was on the side of Russia. But of the
general unwillingness of the Great Powers to face the prospect of a
merger of sovereign powers, without which permanent peace pro-
jects are absurd, there can be no sort of doubt whatever. It
was no cessation of international competition with its acute phase
of war that they desired, but rather a cheapening of war, which
was becoming too costly. Each wanted to economize the wastage
of minor disputes and conflicts, and to establish international
laws that would embarrass its more formidable opponents in war-
time without incommoding itself. These were the practical ends
they sought at the Hague Conference. It was a gathering they
attended to please Nicholas II, just as the monarchs of Europe had
subscribed to the evangelical propositions of the Holy AUiance
to please Alexander I ; and as they had attended it, they tried to
make what they conceived to be some use of it.
§2
The peace of Frankfort had left Germany Prussianized and
united, the most formidable of all the Great Powers of Europe.
France was humiliated and crippled. Her lapse into republican-
ism seemed likely to leave her without friends in any European
court. Italy was as yet a mere stripling. Austria sank now
rapidly to the position of a confederate in German policy. Russia
was vast, but undeveloped ; and the British Empire was mighty
only on the sea. Beyond Europe the one power to be reckoned
with by Germany was the United States of America, growing now
into a great industrial nation, but with no army nor navy worth
considering by European standards.
The new Germany which was embodied in the empire that had
been created at Versailles was a complex and astonishing mixture
478 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
of the fresh intellectual and material forces of the world, with the
narrowest political traditions of the European system. She was
vigorously educational; she was by far the most educational
state in the world ; she made the educational pace for all her
neighbours and rivals. In this time of reckoning for Germany,
it may help the British reader to a balanced attitude to recall the
educational stimulation for which his country has to thank first
the German Prince Consort and then German competition. That
mean jealousy of the educated common man on the part of the
British church and ruling class, which no patriotic pride or generous
impulse had ever sufficed to overcome, went down before a growing
fear of German efficiency. And Germany took up the organization
of scientific research and of the application of scientific method
to industrial and social development with such a faith and energy
as no other community had ever shown before. Throughout
all this period of the armed peace she was reaping and sowing
afresh and reaping again the harvests, the unfailing harvests, of
freely disseminated knowledge. She grew swiftly to become a
great manufacturing and trading power ; her steel output outran
the British; in a hundred new fields of production and com-
merce, where intelligence and system was of more account than
mere trader's cunning, in the manufacture of optical glass, of dyes,
and of a multitude of chemical products and in endless novel
processes, she led the world.
To the British manufacturer who was accustomed to see inven-
tions come into his works, he knew not whence nor why, begging
to be adopted, this new German method of keeping and paying
scientific men seemed abominably unfair. It was compelling for-
tune, he felt. It was packing the cards. It was encouraging a
nasty class of intellectuals to interfere in the affairs of sound busi-
ness men. Science went abroad from its first home like an un-
loved child. The splendid chemical industry of Germany was
built on the work of the Englishman Perkins, who could find no
" practical" English business man to back him. And Germany
also led the way in many forms of social legislation. Germany
realized that labour is a national asset, that it deteriorates through
unemployment, and that, for the common good, it has to be taken
care of outside the works. The British employer was still under
THE CATASTROPHE OF 1914 479
the delusion that labour had no business to exist outside the works,
and that the worse such exterior existence was, the better somehow
for him. Moreover, because of his general illiteracy, he was an
intense individualist : his was the insensate rivalry of the vulgar
mind; he hated his fellow manufacturers about as much as he
hated his labour and his customers. German producers, on the
other hand, were persuaded of the great advantages of combina-
tion and civility; their enterprises tended to flow together and
assume more and more the character of national undertakings.
This educating, scientific, and organizing Germany was the
natural development of the liberal Germany of 1848; it had its
roots far back in the recuperative effort after the shame of the
Napoleonic conquest. All that was good, all that was great in
this modern Germany, she owed indeed to her schoolmasters.
But this scientific organizing spirit was only one of the two factors
that made up the new German Empire. The other factor was the
Hohenzollern monarchy which had survived Jena, which had
tricked and bested the revolution of 1848, and which, under the
guidance of Bismarck, had now clambered to the legal headship of
all Germany outside Austria. Except the Tsardom, no other
European state had so preserved the tradition of the Grand Mon-
archy of the eighteenth century as the Prussian. Through the
tradition of Frederick the Great, Machiavelli now reigned in Ger-
many. In the head of this fine new modern state, therefore, there
sat no fine modern brain to guide it to a world predominance in
world service, but an old spider lusting for power. Prussianized
Germany was at once the newest and the most antiquated thing in
Western Europe. She was the best and the wickedest state of her
time.
The psychology of nations is still but a rudimentary science.
Psychologists have scarcely begun to study the citizen side of
the individual man. But it is of the utmost importance to our
subject that the student of universal history should give some
thought to the mental growth of the generations of Germans
educated since the victories of 1871. They were naturally in-
flated by their sweeping unqualified successes in war, and by their
rapid progress from comparative poverty to wealth. It would have
been more than human in them if they had not given way to some
480 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
excesses of patriotic vanity. But this reaction was deliberately
seized upon and fostered and developed by a systematic exploita-
tion and control of school and college, literature and press, in
the interests of the Hohenzollern dynasty. A teacher, a professor,
who did not teach and preach, in and out of season, the racial,
moral, intellectual, and physical superiority of the Germans to
all other peoples, their extraordinary devotion to war and their
dynasty, and their inevitable destiny under that dynasty to lead
the world, was a marked man, doomed to failure and obscurity.1
German historical teaching became an immense systematic
falsification of the human past, with a view to the Hohenzollern
future. All other nations were represented as incompetent and
decadent ; the Prussians were the leaders and regenerators of man-
kind. The young German read this in his school-books, heard
it in church, found it in his literature, had it poured into him
with passionate conviction by his professor. It was poured into
him by all his professors ; Hueffer (op. cit.) says that lectures in
biology or mathematics would break off from their proper subject
to indulge in long passages of royalist patriotic rant. Only minds
of extraordinary toughness and originality could resist such a
torrent of suggestion. Insensibly there was built up in the Ger-
man mind a conception of Germany and its emperor as of something
splendid and predominant as nothing else had ever been before,
a godlike nation in " shining armour" brandishing the "good Ger-
man sword " in a world of inferior — and very badly disposed
— peoples. We have told our story of Europe ; the reader may
judge whether the glitter of the German sword is exceptionally
blinding. Germania was deliberately intoxicated, she was sys-
tematically kept drunk, with this sort of patriotic rhetoric. It is
the greatest of the Hohenzollern crimes that the Crown constantly
and persistently tampered with education, and particularly with
historical teaching. No other modern state has so sinned against
education. The oligarchy of the crowned republic of Great
Britain may have crippled and starved education, but the Hohen-
zollern monarchy corrupted and prostituted it.
1 See F. M. Hueffer's able but badly named book, When Blood is their Argument.
It gives an admirable account of just how the pressure was applied to the teaching
organization.
THE CATASTROPHE OF 1914 481
It cannot be too clearly stated, it is the most important fact in
the history of the last half century, that the German people was
methodically indoctrinated with the idea of a German world-
predominance based on might, and with the theory that war was
a necessary thing in life. The key to German historical teaching
is to be found in Count Moltke's dictum: " Perpetual peace is a
dream, and it is not even a beautiful dream. War is an element
in the order of the world ordained by God." (Gladstone, we have
noted, in his Tory days showed the same pious acquiescence in
the family slave-holding.) "Without war the world would stag-
nate and lose itself in materialism." And the anti-Christian Ger-
man philosopher, Nietzsche, found himself quite at one with the
pious field-marshal. " It is mere illusion and pretty sentiment," he
observes, "to expect much (even anything at all) from mankind
if it forgets how to make war. As yet no means are known which
call so much into action as a great war that rough energy born of
the camp, that deep impersonality born of hatred, that conscience
born of murder and cold-bloodedness, that fervour born of effort
in the annihilation of the enemy, that proud indifference to loss,
to one's own existence, to that of one's fellows, that earthquake-
like soul-shaking which a people needs when it is losing its vi-
tality."1
This sort of teaching, which pervaded the German Empire from
end to end, was bound to be noted abroad, bound to alarm every
other power and people in the world, bound to provoke an anti-
German confederation) and it was accompanied by a parade of
military, and presently of naval preparation, that threatened
France, Russia, and Britain alike. It affected the thoughts, the
manners, and morals of the entire German people — for they are
a plastic people, and not refractory under instruction like the Irish
and English. After 1871, the German abroad thrust out his chest
and raised his voice. He threw a sort of trampling quality even
into the operations of commerce. His machinery came on the
markets of the world, his shipping took the seas with a splash of
patriotic challenge. His very merits he used as a means of offence.
(And probably most other peoples, if they had had the same expe-
1 These quotations are from Sir Thomas Barclay's article "Peace" in The
Encyclopaedia Britannica.
482
THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
riences and undergone the same training, would have behaved in a
similar manner.)
By one of those accidents in history that personify and precipi-
tate catastrophes, the ruler of Germany, the emperor William II,
embodied the new education of. his people and the Hohenzollern
tradition in the completest form. He came to the throne in
age
nine; his father, Frederick
III, had succeeded his grand-
father, William I, in the
March, to die in the June of
that year. William II was
the grandson of Queen Vic-
toria on his mother's side,
but his temperament showed
no traces of the liberal Ger-
man tradition that distin-
guished the Saxe-Coburg-
Gotha family. His head wa£
full of the frothy stuff of the?
new imperialism. He sig-
nalized his accession by an
address to his army and
navy; his address to his
people followed three days
later. A high note of con-
tempt for democracy was
sounded: "The soldier and
the army, not parliamentary
majorities, have welded together the German Empire. My trust
is placed in the army." So the patient work of the German
schoolmasters was disowned, and the Hohenzollern declared him-
self triumphant.
The next exploit of the young monarch was to quarrel with the
old Chancellor, Bismarck, who had made the new German Empire,
and to dismiss him (1890). There were no profound differences of
opinion between them, but, as Bismarck said, the Emperor intended
to be his own chancellor.
The Emperor 'WLULatn. IT.
THE CATASTROPHE OF 1914 483
These were the opening acts of an active and aggressive career.
This William II meant to make a noise in the world, a louder noise
than any other monarch had ever made. The whole of Europe
was soon familiar with the figure of the new monarch, invariably in
military uniform of the most glittering sort, staring valiantly,
fiercely moustached, and with a withered left arm ingeniously
minimized. He affected silver shining breastplates and long
white cloaks. A great restlessness was manifest. It was clear
he conceived himself destined for great things, but for a time it
was not manifest what particular great things these were. There
was no oracle at Delphi now to tell him that he was destined to
destroy a great empire.
The note of theatricality about him and the dismissal of Bismarck
alarmed many of his subjects, but they were presently reassured
by the idea that he was using his influence in the cause of peace
and to consolidate Germany. He travelled much, to London,
Vienna, Rome — where he had private conversations with the
Pope — to Athens, where his sister married the king in 1889, and
to Constantinople. He was the first Christian sovereign to be a
Sultan's guest. He also went to Palestine. A special gate was
knocked through the ancient wall of Jerusalem so that he could
ride into that place; it was beneath his dignity to walk in. jle
induced the Sultan to commence the reorganization of the Turkish
Army upon German lines and under German officers. In 1895
he announced that Germany was a "world power," and that "the
future of Germany lay upon the water" —regardless of the fact
that the British considered that they were there already — and
he began to interest himself more and more in the building up of a
great navy. He also took German art and literature under his care ;
he used his influence to retain the distinctive and blinding German
blackletter against the Roman type used by the rest of western
Europe, and he supported the Pan-German movement, which
claimed the Dutch, the Scandinavians, the Flemish Belgians and the
German Swiss as members of a great German brotherhood — as
in fact good assimilable stuff for a hungry young empire which
meant to grow. All other monarchs in Europe paled before him.
He used the general hostility against Britain aroused throughout
Europe by the war against the Boer Republics to press forward his
484 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
schemes for a great navy, and this, together with the rapid and chal-
lenging extension of the German colonial empire in Africa and the
Pacific Ocean, alarmed and irritated the British extremely. British
liberal opinion in particular found itself under the exasperating
necessity of supporting an ever-increasing British Navy. "I
will not rest," he said, "until I have brought my navy to the same
height at which my army stands. " The most peace-loving of the
islanders could not ignore that threat.
In 1890 he had acquired the small island of Heligoland from
Britain. This he made into a great naval fortress.
As his navy grew, his enterprise increased. He proclaimed
the Germans "the salt of the earth." They must not "weary in
the work of civilization; Germany, like the spirit of Imperial
Rome, must expand and impose itself." This he said on Polish
soil, in support of the steady efforts the Germans were making
to suppress the Polish language and culture, and to Germanize
their share of Poland. God he described as his "Divine Ally."
In the old absolutisms the monarch was either God himself or the
adopted agent of God ; the Kaiser took God for his trusty hench-
man. "Our old God," he said affectionately. When the Ger-
mans seized Kiau-Chau, he spoke of the German "mailed fist."
When he backed Austria against Russia, he talked of Germany in
her "shining armour."
The disasters of Russia in Manchuria in 1905 released the spirit of
German imperialism to bolder aggressions. The fear of a joint
attack from France and Russia seemed lifting. The emperor made
a kind of regal progress through the Holy Land, landed at Tangier
to assure the Sultan of Morocco of his support against the French,
and inflicted upon France the crowning indignity of compelling
her by a threat of war to dismiss Delcasse, her foreign minister.
He drew tighter the links between Austria and Germany, and in
1908, Austria, with his support, defied the rest of Europe by annex-
ing from the Turk the Yugo-Slav provinces of Bosnia and Herze-
govina. So by his naval challenge to Britain and these aggres-
sions upon France and the Slavs he forced Britain, France, and
Russia into a defensive understanding against him. The Bosnian
annexation had the further effect of estranging Italy, which had
hitherto been his ally.
THE CATASTROPHE OF 1914 485
Such was the personality that the evil fate of Germany set
over her to stimulate, organize, and render intolerable to the rest
of the world the natural pride and self-assertion of a great people
who had at last, after long centuries of division and weakness,
escaped from a jungle of princes to unity and the world's respect.
It was natural that the commercial and industrial leaders of this
new Germany who were now getting rich, the financiers intent
upon overseas exploits, the officials and the vulgar, should find this
leader very much to their taste. Many Germans who thought
him rash or tawdry in their secret hearts, supported him publicly
because he had so taking an air of success. Hoch der Kaiser!
Yet Germany did not yield itself without a struggle to the strong-
flowing tide of imperialism. Important elements in German life
struggled against this swaggering new autocracy. The old German
nations, and particularly the Bavarians, refused to be swallowed up
in Prussianism. And with the spread of education and the rapid
industrialization of Germany, organized labour developed its
ideas and a steady antagonism to the military and patriotic clatter-
ing of its ruler. A new political party was growing up in the state,
the Social Democrats, professing the doctrines of Marx. In the
teeth of the utmost opposition from the official and clerical organ-
izations, and of violently repressive laws against its propaganda
and against combinations, this party grew. The Kaiser denounced
it again and again ; its leaders were sent to prison or driven abroad.
Still it grew. When he came to the throne it polled not half a
million votes ; in 1907 it polled over three million. He attempted
to concede many things, old age and sickness insurance, for ex-
ample, as a condescending gift, things which it claimed for the
workers as their right. His conversion to socialism was noted,
but it gained no converts to imperialism. His naval ambitions
were ably and bitterly denounced ; the colonial adventures of the
new German capitalists were incessantly attacked by this party
of the common sense of the common man. But to the army, the
Social Democrats accorded a moderate support, because, much as
they detested their home-grown autocrat, they hated and dreaded
the barbaric and retrogressive autocracy of Russia on their
eastern frontier more.
The danger plainly before Germany was that this swaggering
2i
486 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
imperialism would compel Britain, Russia, and France into a com-
bined attack upon her, an offensive-defensive. The Kaiser
wavered between a stiff attitude towards Britain and clumsy
attempts to propitiate her, while his fleet grew and while he pre-
pared for a preliminary struggle with Russia and France. When
in 1913 the British government proposed a cessation on either hand
of naval construction for a year, it was refused. The Kaiser was
afflicted with a son and heir more Hohenzollern, more imperial-
istic, more Pan-Germanic than his father. He had been nurtured
upon imperialist propaganda. His toys had been soldiers and
guns. He snatched at a premature popularity by outdoing his
father's patriotic and aggressive attitudes. His father, it was felt,
was growing middle-aged and over-careful. The Crown Prince
renewed him. Germany had never been so strong, never so ready
for a new great adventure and another harvest of victories. The
Russians, he was instructed, were decayed, the French degenerate,
the British on the verge of civil war. This young Crown Prince
was but a sample of the abounding upper-class youth of Germany
in the spring of 1914. They had all drunken from the same cup.
Their professors and teachers, their speakers and leaders, their
mothers and sweethearts, had been preparing them for the great
occasion that was now very nearly at hand. They were full of
the tremulous sense of imminent conflict, of a trumpet call to
stupendous achievements, of victory over mankind abroad,
triumph over the recalcitrant workers at home. The country
was taut and excited like an athletic competitor at the end of his
training.
§3
Throughout the period of the armed peace Germany was making
the pace and setting the tone for the rest of Europe. The in-
fluence of her new doctrines of aggressive imperialism was par-
ticularly strong upon the British mind, which was ill-equipped to
resist a strong intellectual thrust from abroad. The educational
impulse the Prince Consort had given had died away after his
death; the universities of Oxford and Cambridge were hindered
in their task of effective revision of upper-class education by the
fears and prejudices the so-called "conflict of science and religion "
THE CATASTROPHE OF 1914 487
had roused in the clergy who dominated them through Convoca- /
tion; popular education was crippled by religious squabbling, i/
by the extreme parsimony of the public authorities, by the desire
of employers for child labour, and by individualistic objection to
" educating other people's children." The old tradition of the
English, the tradition of plain statement, legality, fair play, and a
certain measure of republican freedom had faded considerably
during the stresses of the Napoleonic Wars ; romanticism, of which
Sir Walter Scott, the great novelist, was the chief promoter, had
infected the national imagination with a craving for the florid and
picturesque. "Mr. Briggs," the comic Englishman of Punch
/in the fifties and sixties, getting himself into highland costume and
V stalking deer, was fairly representative of the spirit of the new
movement. It presently dawned upon Mr. Briggs as a richly
coloured and creditable fact he had hitherto not observed, that the
sun never set on his dominions. The country which had once
put Clive and Warren Hastings on trial for their unrighteous treat-
ment of Indians, was now persuaded to regard them as entirely
chivalrous and devoted figures. They were "empire builders."
Under the spell of Disraeli's Oriental imagination, which had made
Queen Victoria an "empress," the Englishman turned readily
enough towards the vague exaltations of modern imperialism.
The perverted ethnology and distorted history which was per-
suading the mixed Slavic, Keltic, and Teutonic Germans that
they were a wonderful race apart, was imitated by English writers
who began to exalt a new ethnological invention, the "Anglo-
Saxon.' ' This remarkable compound was presented as the culmina-
tion of humanity, the crown and reward of the accumulated effort
of Greek and Roman, Egyptian, Assyrian, Jew, Mongol, and such-
like lowly precursors of its white splendour. The senseless legend
of German superiority did much to exacerbate the irritations of
the Poles in Posen and the French in Lorraine. The even more
ridiculous legend of the superior Anglo-Saxon did not merely in-
crease the irritations of English rule in Ireland, but it lowered
the tone of British dealings with "subject" peoples throughout
the entire world. For the cessation of respect and the cultivation
of "superior" ideas are the cessation of civility and justice. In
the early days of British rule in India, British officials went out
488 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
modestly as to a wonderful country to learn and live ; now they
went out absurdly, as samples of a wonderful people, as lights to
a great darkness, to profit and prevail.
The imitation of German patriotic misconceptions did not end
with this "Anglo-Saxon" fabrication. The clever young men at
the British universities in the eighties and nineties, bored by the
flatness and insincerities of domestic politics, were moved to imita-
tion and rivalry by this new teaching of an arrogant, subtle, and
forceful nationalist imperialism, this combination of Machiavelli
and Attila, which was being imposed upon the thought and activi-
ties of young Germany. Britain, too, they thought, must have her
shining armour and wave her good sword. The new British im-
perialism found its poet in Mr. Kipling and its practical support
in a number of financial and business interests whose way to monop-
olies and exploitations was lighted by its glow. These Prussian-
izing Englishmen carried their imitation of Germany to the most
extraordinary lengths. Central Europe is one continuous economic
system, best worked as one ; and the new Germany had achieved
a great customs union, a Zollverein of all its constituents. It be-
came naturally one compact system, like a clenched fist. The
British Empire sprawled like an open hand throughout the world,
its members different in nature, need, and relationship, with no
common interest except the common guarantee of safety. But the
new Imperialists were blind to that difference. If new Germany
had a Zollverein, then the British Empire must be in the fashion ;
and the natural development of its various elements must be ham-
pered everywhere by "imperial preferences" and the like. . . .
Yet the imperialist movement in Great Britain never had the
authority nor the unanimity it had in Germany. It was not a natural
product of any of the three united but diverse British peoples.
It was not congenial to them. Queen Victoria and her successors,
Edward VII and George V, were indisposed, either by temperament
or tradition, to wear "shining armour," shake "mailed fists," and
flourish "good swords" in the Hohenzollern fashion. They had
the wisdom to refrain from any overt meddling with public ideas.
And this "British" imperialist movement had from the first
aroused the hostility of the large number of English, Welsh, Irish,
and Scotch writers who refused to recognize this new "British"
THE CATASTROPHE OF 1914 489
nationality or to accept the theory that they were these " Anglo-
Saxon" supermen. And many great interests in Britain, and
notably the shipping interest, had been built up upon free trade,
and regarded the fiscal proposals of the new imperialists, and the
new financial and mercantile adventurers with whom they were
associated, with a justifiable suspicion. On the other hand, these
ideas ran like wildfire through the military class, through Indian
officialdom and the like. Hitherto there had always been some-
thing apologetic about the army man in England. He was not na-
tive to that soil. Here was a movement that promised to make .
him as splendidly important as his Prussian brother in arms. And \
the imperialist idea also found support in the cheap popular press )
that was now coming into existence to cater for the new stratum /
of readers created by elementary education. This press wanteja
plain, bright, simple ideas adapted to the needs of readers who had
scarcely begun to think.
In spite of such support, and its strong appeal to national
vanity, British imperialism never saturated the mass of the British
peoples. The English are not a mentally docile people, and the
noisy and rather forced enthusiasm for imperialism and higher tariffs
of the old Tory Party, the army class, the country clergy, the mu-
sic-halls, the assimilated aliens, the vulgar rich, and the new large
employers, inclined the commoner sort, and particularly organized
labour, to a suspicious attitude. If the continually irritated sore
of the Majuba defeat permitted the country to be rushed into the
needless, toilsome, and costly conquest of the Boer republics in
South Africa, the strain of that adventure produced a sufficient
reaction towards decency and justice to reinstate the Liberal Party
in power, and to undo the worst of that mischief by the creation
of a South African confederation. Considerable advances contin-
ued to be made in popular education, and in the recovery of public
interests and the general wealth from the possession of the few.
And in these years of the armed peace, the three British peoples
came very near to a settlement, on fairly just and reasonable lines,
of their long-standing misunderstanding with Ireland. The great
war, unluckily for them, overtook them in the very crisis of this
effort.
Like Japan, Ireland has figured but little in this Outline of History,
490 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
and for the same reason, because she is an extreme island country,
receiving much, but hitherto giving but little back into the general
drama. Her population is a very mixed one, its basis, and probably
its main substance, being of the dark " Mediterranean " strain,
pre-Nordic and pre-Aryan, like the Basques and the people of Por-
tugal and south Italy. These people reached the island in Neo-
lithic times ; no Palaeolithic remains have been found in Ireland.
Over this original basis there flowed, about the sixth century B.C.
— we do not know to what degree of submergence — a wave of
Keltic peoples, in at least sufficient strength to establish a Keltic
language, the Irish Gaelic. There were comings and goings, in-
vasions and counter-invasions of this and that Keltic or Kelticized
people between Ireland, Scotland, Wales, and England. The island
was Christianized in the fifth century. Later on the east coast
was raided and settled by Northmen, but we do not know to what
extent they altered the racial quality. The Norman-English came
in 1169, in the time of Henry II and onward. The Teutonic strain
may be as strong or stronger than the Keltic in modern Ireland.
Hitherto Ireland had been a tribal and barbaric country, with a
few centres of security wherein the artistic tendencies of the more
ancient race found scope in metal-work and the illumination of
holy books. Now, in the twelfth century, there was an imperfect
conquest by the English Crown, and scattered settlements by Nor-
mans and English in various parts of the country. From the
outset profound temperamental differences between the Irish and
English were manifest, differences exacerbated by a difference of
language, and these became much more evident after the Protestant
Reformation. The English were naturally a non-sacerdotal people ;
they had the Northman's dislike for and disbelief in priests ; the
share of Englishmen in the European Reformation was a leading
one. The Irish found the priest congenial, and resisted the Ref-
ormation obstinately and bitterly.
The English rule in Ireland had been from the first an intermit-
tent civil war due to the clash of languages and the different laws of
land tenure and inheritance of the two peoples. It was further
embittered at the Reformation by this religious incompatibility.
The rebellions, massacres, and subjugations of the unhappy island
during the reigns of Elizabeth and James I we cannot tell of here ;
THE CATASTROPHE OF 1914
491
but under James came a new discord with the confiscation of large
areas of Ulster and their settlement with Presbyterian Scotch
colonists. They formed a Protestant community in necessary
permanent conflict with the Catholic remainder of Ireland.
In the political conflicts during the reign of Charles I and the
Commonweal, and of James II and William and Mary, the two
The English 'Pale',
2494....
ditto , tune of
Elizð&JzmesI
"Districts 'pZanioT(i.e.
con£scafed & settled by
English & Scots) time ^/x
IRELAND
sides in English affairs found sympathizers and allies in the Irish
parties. There is a saying in Ireland that England's misfortune
is Ireland's opportunity, and the English civil trouble that led to
the execution of Straff ord enabled the Irish Catholics to perpetrate
a ferocious massacre of the English in Ireland (1641) — a very
cruel and barbaric massacre in which neither women nor little
children were spared. Later on Cromwell was to avenge that
massacre by giving no quarter to any men actually found under
492 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
arms, a severity remembered by the Irish Catholics with extrava-
gant bitterness. Between 1689 and 1691 Ireland was again torn
by civil war. James II sought the support of the Irish Catholics
against William III, and his adherents were badly beaten at the
battles of the Boyne (1690) and Aughrim (1691).
There was a settlement, the Treaty of Limerick, a disputed set-
tlement in which the English Government promised much in the
way of tolerance for Catholics and the like, and failed to keep its
promises. Limerick is still a cardinal memory in the long story
of Irish embitterment. Comparatively few English people have
even heard of this Treaty of Limerick ; in Ireland it rankles to this
day.
The eighteenth century was a century of accumulating grievance.
English commercial jealousy put heavy restraints upon Irish trade,
and the development of a wool industry was destroyed in the south
and west. The Ulster Protestants were treated little better than
the Catholics in these matters, and they were the chief of the rebels.
There was more agrarian revolt in the north than in the south;
the Steel Boys, and later the Peep-o'-Day Boys, were Ulster ter-
rorists. There was a parliament in Ireland, but it was a Protes-
tant parliament, even more limited and corrupt than the contem-
porary British Parliament; there was a considerable civilization
in and about Dublin, and much literary and scientific activity,
conducted in English and centring upon the Protestant university
of Trinity College. This was the Ireland of Swift, Goldsmith,
Burke, Berkeley, and Boyle. It was essentially a part of the Eng-
lish culture. The Catholic religion and the Irish language were
outcast and persecuted things in the darkness.
It was from this Ireland of the darkness that the recalcitrant
Ireland of the twentieth century arose. The Irish Parliament, its
fine literature, its science, all its culture, gravitated naturally enough
to London, because they were inseparably a part of that world.
The more prosperous landlords went to England to live, and had
their children educated there. The increasing facilities of com-
munication enhanced this tendency and depleted Dublin. The
Act of Union (January 1st, 1801) was the natural coalescence of
two entirely kindred systems, of the Anglo-Irish Parliament with
the British Parliament, both oligarchic, both politically corrupt in
THE CATASTROPHE OF 1914 493
the same fashion. There was a vigorous opposition on the part,
not so much of the outer Irish as of Protestants settled in Ireland,
and a futile insurrection under Robert Emmet in 1803. Dublin,
which had been a fine Anglo-Irish city in the middle eighteenth
century, was gradually deserted by its intellectual and political
life, and invaded by the outer Irish of Ireland. Its fashionable life
became more and more official, centring upon the Lord Lieutenant
in Dublin Castle ; its chief social occasion is now a horse show.
But while the Ireland of Swift and Goldsmith was part and lot
with the England of Pope, Dr. Johnson, and Sir Joshua Reynolds,
while there has never been and is not now any real definable differ-
ence except one of geography between the "governing class" in
Ireland and in Britain, the Irish underworld and the English under-
world were essentially dissimilar. The upward struggle of the
English " democracy" to education, to political recognition, had
no Irish counterpart. Britain was producing a great industrial
population, Protestant or sceptical ; she had agricultural labourers
indeed, but no peasants. Ireland had become a land of peasants,
blankly ignorant and helplessly priest-ridden. Their cultivation
degenerated more and more into a growing of potatoes and a feeding
of pigs. The people married and bred ; except for the consumption
of whisky when it could be got, and a little fighting, family life
was their only amusement. This was the direct result of ortho-
dox Catholic teaching ; the priests were all-powerful with the people
and they taught them nothing; not even washing or drain-
age ; they forbade them to seek any Protestant learning, they al-
lowed their agricultural science to sink to mere potato-growing,
and they preyed upon their poverty. Here are the appalling con-
sequences. The population of Ireland
in 1785 was 2,845,932,
in 1803 was 5,536,594,
in 1845 was 8,295,061,
at which date the weary potato gave way under its ever-growing
burthen and there was a frightful famine. Many died, many
emigrated, especially to the United States ; an outflow of emigra-
tion began that made Ireland for a time a land of old people and
empty nests.
Now because of the Union of the Parliaments, the enfranchise-
494 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
ment of the English and Irish populations went on simultaneously.
Catholic enfranchisement in England meant Catholic enfranchise-
ment in Ireland. The British got votes because they wanted them ;
the Irish commonalty got votes because the English did. Ireland
was over-represented in the Union Parliament, because originally
Irish seats had been easier for the governing class to manipulate
than English; and so it came about that this Irish and Catholic
Ireland, which had never before had any political instrument at
all, and which had never sought a political instrument, found itself
with the power to thrust a solid body of members into the legis-
lature of Great Britain. After the general election of 1874, the
newly enfranchised "democracy" of Britain found itself confronted
by a strange and perplexing Irish " democracy," different in its
religion, its traditions, and its needs, telling a tale of wrongs, of
which the common English had never heard, clamouring passion-
ately for separation which they could not understand and which
impressed them chiefly as being needlessly unfriendly. The na-
tional egotism of the Irish is intense; their circumstances have
made it intense; they were incapable of considering the state of
affairs in England; the new Irish party came into the British
Parliament to obstruct and disorder English business until Ireland
became free, and to make themselves a nuisance to the English.
This spirit was only too welcome to the oligarchy which still ruled
the British Empire ; they allied themselves with the "loyal" Prot-
estants in the north of Ireland — loyal that is to the Imperial
Government because of their dread of a Catholic predominance in
Ireland — and they watched and assisted the gradual exasperation
of the British common people by this indiscriminate hostility of
the common people of Ireland.
The story of the relation of Ireland to Britain for the last half-
century is one that reflects the utmost discredit upon the govern-
ing class of the British Empire, but it is not one of which the
English commons need be ashamed. Again and again they have
given evidences of goodwill. British legislation in relation to
Ireland for nearly half a century shows a series of clumsy attempts
on the part of liberal England, made in the face of a strenuous op-
position from the Conservative Party and the Ulster Irish, to
satisfy Irish complaints and get to a footing of fellowship. In
THE CATASTROPHE OF 1914 495
1886 Gladstone, in pursuit of his idea of nationality, brought politi-
cal disaster upon himself by introducing the first Irish Home Rule
Bill, a genuine attempt to give over Irish affairs for the first time in
history to the Irish people. In many respects it was a faulty and
dangerous proposal, and it provided no satisfactory assurance to
the Protestant Irish, and especially the Ulster Protestants, of pro-
tection against possible injuries from the priest-ridden illiterates
of the south. This may have been a fancied danger, but these
fears should have been respected. The bill broke the Liberal
Party asunder ; and a coalition government, the Unionist Govern-
ment, replaced that of Mr. Gladstone.
This digression into the history of Ireland now comes up to the
time of infectious imperialism in Europe. The Unionist Govern-
ment which ousted Mr. Gladstone had a predominantly Tory ele-
ment, and was in spirit "imperialist" as no previous British Gov-
ernment had been. The British political history of the subsequent
years is largely a history of the conflict of the new imperialism,
through which an arrogant "British" nationalism sought to over-
ride the rest of the empire against the temperamental liberalism
and reasonableness of the English, which tended to develop the
empire into a confederation of free and willing allies. Naturally
the "British" imperialists wanted a subjugated Irish; naturally
the English Liberals wanted a free, participating Irish. In 1892
Gladstone struggled back to power with a small Home Rule major-
ity ; and in 1893 his second Home Rule Bill passed the Commons,
and was rejected by the Lords. It was not, however, until 1895
that an imperialist government took office. The party which sus-
tained it was called not Imperialist, but " Unionist "-— an odd
name when we consider how steadily and strenuously it has worked
to destroy any possibility of an Empire commonweal. These
Imperialists remained in power for ten years. We have already
noted their conquest of South Africa. They were defeated in
1905 in an attempt to establish a tariff wall on the Teutonic model.
The ensuing Liberal Government then turned the conquered [South
African Dutch into contented fellow-subjects by creating the
self-governing Dominion of South Africa. After which it embarked
upon a long-impending struggle with the persistently imperialist
House of Lords.
496 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
This was a very fundamental struggle in British affairs. On
the one hand were the Liberal majority of the people of Great
Britain honestly and wisely anxious to put this Irish affair upon a
new and more hopeful footing, and, if possible, to change the vin-
dictive animosity of the Irish into friendship ; on the other were
all the factors of this new British Imperialism resolved at any cost
and in spite of every electoral verdict, legally, if possible, but if
not, illegally, to maintain their ascendancy over the affairs of the
English, Scotch, and Irish and all the rest of the empire alike. It
was, under new names, the age-long internal struggle of the English
community ; that same conflict of a free and liberal-spirited com-
monalty against powerful "big men" and big adventures and
authoritative persons which we have already dealt with in our
account of the liberation of America. Ireland was merely a battle-
ground as America had been. In India, in Ireland, in England,
the governing class and their associated adventurers were all of
one mind ; but the Irish people, thanks to their religious difference,
had little sense of solidarity with the English. Yet such Irish
statesmen as Redmond, the leader of the Irish party in the House
of Commons, transcended this national narrowness for a time,
and gave a generous response to English good intentions. Slowly
yet steadily the barrier of the House of Lords was broken down,
and a third Irish Home Rule Bill was brought in by Mr. Asqurth,
the Prime Minister, in 1912. Throughout 1913 and the early part
of 1914 this bill was fought and re-fought through Parliament. At
first it gave Home Rule to all Ireland; but an Amending Act,
excluding Ulster on certain conditions, was promised. This
struggle lasted right up to the outbreak of the Great War. The
royal assent was given to this bill after the actual outbreak of
war, and also to a bill suspending the coming into force of Irish
Home Rule until after the end of the war. These bills were put
upon the Statute Book.
But from the introduction of the third Home Rule Bill onward
the opposition to it had assumed a violent and extravagant form.
Sir Edward Carson, a Dublin lawyer who had become a member
of the English Bar, and who had held a legal position in the minis-
try of Mr. Gladstone (before the Home Rule split) and in the sub-
sequent imperialist government, was the organizer and leader of
THE CATASTROPHE OF 1914 497
this resistance to a reconciliation of the two peoples. In spite of
his Dublin origin, he set up to be a leader of the Ulster Protestants ;
and he brought to the conflict that contempt for law which is all
too common a characteristic of the successful barrister, and those
gifts of persistent, unqualified, and uncompromising hostility which
distinguish a certain type of Irishman. He was the most " un-
English" of men, dark, romantic, and violent ; and from the open-
ing of the struggle he talked with gusto of armed resistance to this
freer reunion of the English and Irish which the third Home Rule
Bill contemplated. The excitement intensified throughout 1913.
A body of volunteers was organized in Ulster, arms were smuggled
into the country, and Sir Edward Carson and a rising lawyer named
F. E. Smith, trapped up in semi-military style, toured Ulster, in-
specting these volunteers and inflaming local passion. The arms
of these prospective rebels were obtained from Germany, and
various utterances of Sir Edward Carson's associates hinted at sup-
port from "a great Protestant monarch." The first bloodshed
occurred at Londonderry in August, 1913. Contrasted with Ulster,
the rest of Ireland was at that time a land of order and decency,
relying upon its great leader Redmond and the good faith of the
three British peoples.
Now these threats of civil war from Ireland were not in them-
selves anything very exceptional in the record of that unhappy
island ; what makes them exceptional and significant in the world's
history is the vehement support they found among the English
military and governing classes, and the immunity from punishment
and restraint of Sir Edward Carson and his friends. The virus
of reaction which came from the success and splendour of German
imperialism had spread widely, as we have explained, throughout
the prevalent and prosperous classes in Great Britain. A genera-
tion had grown up forgetful of the mighty traditions of their fore-
fathers, and ready to exchange the greatness of English freedom
for the tawdriest of imperialisms. A fund of a million pounds
was raised, chiefly in England, to support the Ulster Rebellion,
an Ulster Provisional Government was formed, prominent English
people mingled in the fray and careered about Ulster in automobiles,
assisting in the gun-running, and there is evidence that a number
of British officers and generals were prepared for a pronuncia-
2K
498 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
mento upon South American lines rather than obedience to the law.
The natural result of all this upper-class disorderliness was to
alarm the main part of Ireland, never a ready friend to England.
That Ireland also began in its turn to organize " National Volun-
teers" and to smuggle arms. The military authorities showed
themselves much keener in the suppression of the Nationalist than
of the Ulster gun importation, and in July, 1914, an attempt to run
guns at Howth, near Dublin, led to fighting and bloodshed in the
Dublin streets. The British Isles were on the verge of civil war.
; Such in outline is the story of the imperialist revolutionary
movement in Great Britain up to the eve of the great war. For
revolutionary this movement of Sir Edward Carson and his asso-
ciates was. It was plainly an attempt to set aside parliamentary
government and the slow-grown, imperfect liberties of the British
peoples, and, with the assistance of the army, to substitute a more
Prussianized type of rule, using the Irish conflict as the point of
departure. It was the reactionary effort of a few score thousand
people to arrest the world movement towards democratic law and
social justice, strictly parallel to and closely sympathetic with the
new imperialism of the German junkers and rich men. But in one
very important respect British and German imperialism differed.
In Germany it centred upon the crown ; its noisiest, most conspicu-
ous advocate was the heir-apparent. In Great Britain the king
stood aloof. By no single public act did King George V betray
the slightest approval of the new movement, and the behaviour
of the Prince of Wales, his son and heir, has been equally correct.
In August, 1914, the storm of the great war burst upon the
world. In September, Sir Edward Carson was denouncing the
placing of the Home Rule Bill upon the Statute Book. On the
same day, Mr. John Redmond was calling upon the Irish people
to take their equal part in the burthen and effort of the war.
For a time Ireland played her part in the war side by side with
England faithfully and well, until in 1915 the Liberal Govern-
ment was replaced by a coalition, in which this Sir Edward Carson,
with the bloodshed at Londonderry and Howth upon his head,
figured as Attorney-General (with a salary of £7000 and fees), to
be replaced presently by his associate in the Ulster sedition, Sir
F. E. Smith.
THE CATASTROPHE OF 1914 499
Grosser insult was never offered to a friendly people. The
work of reconciliation, begun by Gladstone in 1886, and brought
so near to completion in 1914, was completely and finally wrecked.1
In the spring of 1916 Dublin revolted unsuccessfully against
this new government. The ringleaders of this insurrection, many
of them mere boys, were shot with a deliberate and clumsy stern-
ness that, in view of the treatment of the Ulster rebel leaders,
impressed all Ireland as atrociously unjust. A traitor, Sir Roger
Casement, who had been knighted for previous services to the
empire, was tried and executed, no doubt deservedly, but his
prosecutor was Sir F. E. Smith of the Ulster insurrection, a shocking
conjunction. The Dublin revolt had had little support in Ireland
generally, but thereafter the movement for an independent republic
grew rapidly to great proportions. Against this strong emotional
drive there struggled the more moderate ideas of such Irish states-
men as Sir Horace Plunkett, who wished to see Ireland become a
Dominion, a "crowned republic " that is, within the empire, on an
equal footing with Canada and Australia.2
When in December, 1919, Mr. Lloyd George introduced his
Home Rule Bill into the Imperial Parliament there were no Irish
members, except Sir Edward Carson and his followers, to receive
it. The rest of Ireland was away. It refused to begin again that
old dreary round of hope and disappointment. Let the British
and their pet Ulstermen do as they would, said the Irish. . . .
§4
Our studies of modern imperialism in Germany and Britain
bring out certain forces common to the two countries, and we shall
find these same forces at work in variable degrees and with various
modifications in the case of the other great modern communities
at which we shall now glance. This modern imperialism is not a
synthetic uniting movement like the older imperialism ; it is essen-
tially a megalomaniac nationalism, a nationalism made aggressive
by prosperity ; and always it finds its strongest support in the mili-
1 St. John Ervine's novel, Changing Winds, gives a good account of the mental-
ity of this time.
2 See the various publications of the Irish Dominion League, St. Stephen's
Green, Dublin. A good recent account of Irish ideas is to be found in Lynd's
Ireland a Nation (1919).
500 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
tary and official castes, and in the enterprising and acquisitive
strata of society, in new money, that is, and big business; its
chief critics in the educated poor, and its chief opponents in the
peasantry and the labour masses. It accepts monarchy where
it finds it, but it is not necessarily a monarchist movement. It
does, however, need a foreign office of the traditional type for its
full development. Its origin, which we have traced very care-
fully in this book of our history, makes this clear. Modern impe-
rialism is the natural development of the Great Power system which
arose, with the foreign office method of policy, out of the Machia-
vellian monarchies after the break-up of Christendom. It will
only come to an end when the intercourse of nations and peoples
through embassies and foreign offices is replaced by an assembly
of elected representatives in direct touch with their peoples.
French imperialism during the period of the Armed Peace in
Europe was naturally of a less confident type than the German.
It called itself "nationalism" rather than imperialism, and it set
itself, by appeals to patriotic pride, to thwart the efforts of those
socialists and rationalists who sought to get into touch with liberal
elements in German life. It brooded upon the Revanche, the return
match with Prussia. But in spite of that pre-occupation, it set
itself to the adventure of annexation and exploitation in the Far
East and in Africa, narrowly escaping a war with Britain upon the
Fashoda clash (1898), and it never relinquished a dream of acquisi-
tions in Syria.1 Italy too caught the imperialist fever ; the blood
letting of Adowa cooled her for a time, and then she resumed in
1911 with a war upon Turkey and the annexation of Tripoli.2
1 Wilfred Scawen Blunt regards the English remaining in Egypt, when they
had pledged themselves to go, as the greatest cause of the troubles that culminated
in 1914. To pacify the French over Egypt, England connived at the French occu-
pation of Morocco, which Germany had looked upon as her share of North Africa.
Hence Germany's bristling attitude to France, and the revival in France of the
revanche idea, which had died down. See Blunt's My Diaries, vol. i, September 30th,
1891.— A. C. W.
2 It should not be forgotten that Italian action against Turkey was precipitated
by the granting of a charter by the Sultan to an Austro-German company or syn-
dicate for the "taking over" of the Tripoli taine : a process which could only have
ended by the hoisting of the Imperial German flag on the southern shores of the
Mediterranean, opposite Italy. Also, that through Morocco the Germans were
attempting to undermine the French position in Algeria and Tunis by supplying
the Moroccans with arms and money, and inducing them to attack French rule
THE CATASTROPHE OF 1914
501
The Italian imperialists exhorted their countrymen to forget
Mazzini and remember Julius Caesar ; for were they not the heirs
of the Roman Empire ? Imperialism touched the Balkans ; little
countries not a hundred years from slavery began to betray exalted
AUSTRIA - HUHGART
-RUlvCAKI
Bucharest0
ASIA
M I 2V O R
Snwnia,
Turicish. territory
acquired by Scpoia
New autonomous
prindp? of AZiaraa
Bulgarian territory
acquired
intentions; King Ferdinand of Bulgaria assumed the title of
Tsar, the latest of the pseudo-Caesars, and in the shop-windows
separately in Western Algeria, and even by way of Saharan oases in Southern Tunis.
The writer of this note has actually witnessed this process going on between 1898
and 1911. He asserts that, whether from right or wrong motives, Germany
forced France to tackle the thorny problem of Morocco. Either she had to do so
or prepare for the evacuation of Algeria. France may have made a few mistakes,
but she has conferred enormous benefits on North Africa. Under her control
the indigenous population has increased remarkably. — H. H. J.
502 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
of Athens the curious student could study maps showing the dream
of a vast Greek empire in Europe and Asia.
In 1913 the three states of Serbia, Bulgaria, and Greece fell upon
Turkey, already weakened by her war with Italy, and swept her
out of all her European possessions except the country between
Adrianople and Constantinople ; later in that year they quarrelled
among themselves over the division of the spoils. Roumania
joined in the game and helped to crush Bulgaria. Turkey recovered
Adrianople. The greater imperialisms of Austria, Russia, and
Italy watched that conflict and one another. . . .
§5
While all the world to the west of her was changing rapidly,
Russia throughout the nineteenth century changed very slowly in-
deed. At the end of the nineteenth century, as at its beginning,
she was still a Grand Monarchy, of the later seventeenth-century
type standing on a basis of barbarism, she was still at a stage where
court intrigues and imperial favourites could control her interna-
tional relations. She had driven a great railway across Siberia
to find the disasters of the Japanese war at the end of it ; she was
using modern methods and modern weapons so far as her undevel-
oped industrialism and her small supply of sufficiently educated
people permitted ; such writers as Dostoievski had devised a sort
of mystical imperialism based on the idea of Holy Russia and her
mission, colored by racial illusions and anti-Semitic passion ; but,
as events were to show, this had not sunken very deeply into the
imagination of the Russian masses. A vague, very simple Chris-
tianity pervaded the illiterate peasant life, mixed with much super-
stition. It was like the pre-Reformation peasant life of France or
Germany. The Russian moujik was supposed to worship and
revere his Tsar and to love to serve a gentleman ; in 1913 reaction-
ary English writers were still praising his simple and unquestioning
loyalty. But, as in the case of the western European peasant of
the days of peasant revolts, this reverence for the monarchy was
mixed up with the idea that the monarch and the nobleman had
to be good and beneficial, and this simple loyalty could, under
sufficient provocation, be turned into the same pitiless intolerance
of social injustice that burnt the chateaux in the Jacquerie (see
THE CATASTROPHE OF 1914 503
chapter xxxv, § 3) and set up the theocracy in Miinster (chapter
xxxv, § 3). Once the commons were moved to anger, there were
no links of understanding in a generally diffused education in
Russia to mitigate the fury of the outbreak. The upper classes
were as much beyond the sympathy of the lower as a different species
of animal. These Russian masses were three centuries away from
such nationalist imperialism as Germany displayed.
And in another respect Russia differed from modern Western
Europe and paralleled its mediaeval phase, and that was in the fact
that her universities were the resort of many very poor students
quite out of touch and out of sympathy with the bureaucratic autoc-
racy. Before 1917 the significance of the proximity of these two
factors of revolution, the fuel of discontent and the match of free
ideas, was not recognized in European thought, and few people
realized that in Russia more than in any other country lay the
possibilities of a fundamental revolution.1
§6
When we turn from these European Great Powers, with their
inheritance of foreign offices and national policies, to the United
States of America, which broke away completely from the Great
Power System in 1776, we find a most interesting contrast in the
operation of the forces which produced the expansive imperialism
of Europe. For America as for Europe the mechanical revolution
had brought all the world within the range of a few days' journey.
The United States, like the Great Powers, had worldwide financial
and mercantile interests ; a great industrialism had grown up and
was in need of overseas markets ; the same crises of belief that had
shaken the moral solidarity of Europe had occurred in the American
world. Her people were as patriotic and spirited as any. Why
then did not the United States develop armaments and an agres-
sive policy? Why was not the stars and stripes waving over
Mexico, and why was the're not a new Indian system growing up in
1 The general reader who wants some picture in his mind of the recent state of
Russia should read Ernest Poole's The Village. Pre-revolutionary Russia is admi-
rably sketched in Maurice Baring's Mainsprings of Russia, The Russian People, and
A Year in Russia. A small, very illuminating book on the Russian revolution is
M. H. Barber's A British Nurse in Bolshevik Russia.
504 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
China under that flag ? It was the American who had opened up
Japan. After doing so, he had let that power Europeanize itself
and become formidable without a protest. That alone was enough
to make Machiavelli, the father of modern foreign policy, turn in
his grave. If a Europeanized Great Power had been in the place
of the United States, Great Britain would have had to fortify the
Canadian frontier from end to end — it is now absolutely unarmed
— and to maintain a great arsenal in the St. Lawrence. All the
divided states of Central and South America would long since have
been subjugated and placed under the disciplinary control of United
States officials of the "governing class." There would have been a
perpetual campaign to Americanize Australia and New Zealand,
and yet another claimant for a share in tropical Africa.
And by an odd accident America had produced in President
Roosevelt (President 1901-1908) a man of an energy as restless as
the German Kaiser's, as eager for large achievements, as florid and
eloquent, an adventurous man with a turn for world politics and
an instinct for armaments, the very man, we might imagine, to
have involved his country in the scramble for overseas possession.
There does not appear to be any other explanation of this general
restraint and abstinence on the part of the United States except
their fundamentally different institutions and traditions. In
first place the United States Government has no foreign office
id no diplomatic corps of the European type, no body of " experts "
maintain the tradition of an aggressive policy. The president
great powers, but they are subject to the control of the senate,
rhich again is responsible to the state legislatures and the people,
foreign relations of the country are thus under open and public
[control. Secret treaties are impossible under such a system, and
/foreign powers complain of the difficulty and uncertainty of "under-
standings" with the United States, a very excellent state of affairs.
The United States are constitutionally incapacitated, therefore,
from the kind of foreign policy that has kept Europe for so long
constantly on the verge of war.
And, secondly, there has hitherto existed in the States no organ-
ization for and no tradition of what one may call non-assimilable
possessions. Where there is no crown there cannot be crown colo-
nies. In spreading across the American continent, the United States
THE CATASTROPHE OF 1914 505
had developed a quite distinctive method of dealing with new
territories, admirably adapted for unsettled lands, but very incon-
venient if applied too freely to areas already containing an alien
population. This method was based on the idea that there cannot
be in the United States system a permanently subject people.
The first stage of the ordinary process of assimilation had been the
creation of a " territory" under the federal government, having a
considerable measure of self-government, sending a delegate (who
could not vote) to congress, and destined, in the natural course of
things, as the country became settled and population increased, to
flower at last into full statehood. This had been the process of
development of all the latter states of the Union ; the latest terri-
tories to become states being Arizona and New Mexico in 1910.
The frozen wilderness of Alaska, bought from Russia, remained
politically undeveloped simply because it had an insufficient popu-
lation for state organization. As the annexations of Germany and
Great Britain in the Pacific threatened to deprive the United States
navy of coaling stations in that ocean, a part of the Samoan Islands
(1889) and the Sandwich Islands (Hawaii) were annexed (1898).
Here for the first time the United States had real subject popula-
tions to deal with. But in the absence of any class comparable to
the Anglo-Indian officials who sway British opinion, the American
procedure followed the territorial method. Every effort was made
to bring the educational standards of Hawaii up to the American
level, and a domestic legislature on the territorial pattern was or-
ganized so that these dusky islanders seem destined ultimately to
obtain full United States citizenship. (The small Samoan Islands
are taken care of by a United States naval administrator.)
In 1895 occurred a quarrel between the United States and Britain
upon the subject of Venezuela, and the Monroe Doctrine was up-
held stoutly by President Cleveland. Then Mr. Olney made this
remarkable declaration: "To-day the United States is practically
sovereign on this continent, and its fiat is law upon the subjects to
which it confines its interposition. ' ' This, together with the various
Pan-American congresses that have been held, points to a real open
" foreign policy" of alliance and mutual help throughout America.
Treaties of arbitration hold good over all that continent, and the
future seems to point to a gradual development of inter-state
506 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
organization, a Pax Americana, of the English-speaking and Span-
ish-speaking peoples, the former in the role of elder brother. Here
is something we cannot even call an empire, something going far
beyond the great alliance of the British Empire in the open equality
of its constituent parts.
Consistently with this idea of a common American welfare, the
United States in 1898 intervened in the affairs of Cuba, which had
been in a state of chronic insurrection against Spain for many years.
A brief war ended in the acquisition of Cuba, Porto Rico, and the
Philippine Islands. Cuba is now an independent self-governing
republic. Porto Rico and the Philippines have, however, a special
sort of government, with a popularly elected lower house and an
upper body containing members appointed by the United States
senate. It is improbable that either Porto Rico or the Philippines
will become states in the Union. They are much more likely to
become free states in some"comprehensive alliance with both Eng-
lish-speaking and Latin America.
Both Cuba and Porto Rico welcomed the American intervention
in their affairs, but in the Philippine Islands there was a demand
for complete and immediate freedom after the Spanish war, and
a considerable resistance to the American military administration.
There it was the United States came nearest to imperialism of the
Great Power type, and that her record is most questionable. There
was much sympathy with the insurgents in the states. Here is
the point of view of ex-President Roosevelt as he wrote it in his
Autobiography (1913) : —
"As regards the Philippines, my belief was that we should train
them for self-government as rapidly as possible, and then leave
them free to decide their own fate. I did not believe in setting the
time-limit within which we would give them independence, be-
cause I did not believe it wise to try to forecast how soon they
would be fit for self-government ; and once having made the prom-
ise, I would have felt that it was imperative to keep it. Within
a few months of my assuming office we had stamped out the last
armed resistance in the Philippines that was not of merely sporadic
character ; and as soon as peace was secured, we turned our energies
to developing the islands in the interests of the natives. We es-
tablished schools everywhere; we built roads; we administered
THE CATASTROPHE OF 1914 507
an even-handed justice ; we did everything possible to encourage
agriculture and industry; and in constantly increasing measure
we employed natives to do their own governing, and finally pro-
vided a legislative chamber. . . . We are governing, and have
been governing, the islands in the interests of the Filipinos them-
selves. If after due time the Filipinos themselves decide that
they do not wish to be thus governed, then I trust that we will
leave; but when we do leave, it must be distinctly understood
that we retain no protectorate — and above all that we take part
in no joint protectorate — over the islands, and give them no
guarantee, of neutrality or otherwise ; that in short, we are abso-
lutely quit of responsibility for them, of every kind and descrip-
tion." l
This is an entirely different outlook from that of a British or
French foreign office or colonial office official. But it is not very
widely different from the spirit that created the Dominions of
Canada, South Africa, and Australia, and brought forward the
three Home Rule Bills for Ireland. It is in the older and more
characteristic English tradition from which the Declaration of In-
dependence derives. It sets aside, without discussion, the detest-
able idea of "subject peoples."
Here we will not enter into political complications attendant
upon the making of the Panama Canal, for they introduce no fresh
light upon this interesting question of the •American method in
world politics. The history of Panama is American history purely.
But manifestly just as the political structure of the Union was a
new thing in the world, so too were its relations with the world be-
yond its borders.2
1 One very good reason for the provisional retention of the Philippines under
American control is the certainty that the "Moros," the Muhammadan peoples of
Palawan, and the southern islands of the main groups would proceed to conquer the
"Christian" Filipinos, and that after a welter of civil war and destruction, Japan
or some other outside power would be appealed to to intervene. — H. H. J.
2 An unfriendly critic might denounce the treaty-making power of the United
States, and the machinery by which it operates, as complicated and cumbersome,
ill adapted to the complex demands of international intercourse, slow in action
and uncertain in outcome. The requirement of a two-thirds rather than a majority
vote in the Senate he might criticize not unjustly as a dubious excess of caution. . . .
Believe me, the American people are like for many years to accomplish through this
means their compacts with mankind. The checks and balances by which it is
508 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
§7
We have been at some pains to examine the state of mind of
Europe and of America in regard to international relations in the
years that led up to the world tragedy of 1914 because, as more and
more people are coming to recognize, that great war or some such
war was a necessary consequence of the mentality of the period.
All the things that men and nations do are the outcome of instinc-
tive motives reacting upon the ideas which talk and books and
newspapers and schoolmasters and so forth have put into people's
heads. Physical necessities, pestilences, changes of climate, and
the like outer things may deflect and distort the growth of human
history, but its living root is thought.
All human history is fundamentally a history of ideas. Between
the man of to-day and the Cro-Magnard the physical and mental
differences are very slight; their essential difference lies in the
extent and content of the mental background which we have ac-
quired in the five or six hundred generations that intervene.
We are too close to the events of the Great War to pretend that
this Outline can record the verdict of history thereupon, but we
may hazard the guess that when the passions of the conflict have
faded, it will be Germany that will be most blamed for bringing
it about, and she will be blamed not because she was morally and
intellectually very different from her neighbours, but because she
had the common disease of imperialism in its most complete and
energetic form. No self-respecting historian, however superficial
and popular his aims may be, can countenance the legend, produced
by the stresses of the war, that the German is a sort of human being
more cruel and abominable than any other variety of men. All
surrounded, the free and full debate which it allows, are in their eyes virtues rather
than defects. They rejoice in the fact that all engagements which affect their
destinies must be spread upon the public records, and that there is not, and there
never can be, a secret treaty binding them either in law or in morals. Looking
back upon a diplomatic history which is not without its chapters of success, they
feel that on the whole the scheme the fathers builded has served the children
well. With a conservatism in matters of government as great perhaps as that of
any people in the world, they will suffer much inconvenience and run the risk of
occasional misunderstanding before they make a change. — J. W. Davis (U. S. A.
Ambassador to Britain), The Treaty Making Power of the United States. (Oxf.
Univ. Brit. Am. Club. Paper No. 1.)
THE CATASTROPHE OF 1914 509
the great states of Europe before 1914 were in a condition of ag-
gressive nationalism and drifting towards war ; the government of
Germany did but lead the general movement. She fell into the
pit first, and she floundered^ deepest. She became the dreadful
example at which all her fellow sinners could cry out.
For long, Germany and Austria had been plotting an extension
of German influence eastward through Asia Minor to the East.
The German idea was crystallized in the phrase " Berlin to Bagdad."
Antagonized to the German dreams were those of Russia, which
was scheming for an extension of the Slav ascendancy to Constan-
tinople and through Serbia to the Adriatic. These lines of ambi-
tion lay across one another and were mutually incompatible. The
feverish state of affairs in the Balkans was largely the outcome of
the intrigues and propagandas sustained by the German and Slav
schemes. Turkey turned for support to Germany, Serbia to
Russia. Roumania and Italy, both Latin in tradition, both nom-
inally allies of Germany, pursued remoter and deeper schemes in
common. Ferdinand, the Tsar of Bulgaria, was following still
darker ends ; and the squalid mysteries of the Greek court, whose
king was the German Kaiser's brother-in-law, are beyond our
present powers of inquiry.
But the tangle did not end with Germany on the one hand and
Russia on the other. The greed of Germany in 1871 had made
France her inveterate enemy. The French people, aware of their
inability to recover their lost provinces by their own strength, had
conceived exaggerated ideas of the power and helpfulness of Russia.
The French people had subscribed enormously to Russian loans.
France was the ally of Russia. If the German powers made war
upon Russia, France would certainly attack them.
Now the short eastern French frontier was very strongly de-
fended. There was little prospect of Germany repeating the suc-
cesses of 1870-71 against that barrier. But the Belgian frontier
of France was longer and less strongly defended. An attack in
overwhelming force on France through Belgium might repeat 1870
on a larger scale. The French left might be swung back south-
eastwardly on Verdun, as a pivot, and crowded back upon its right,
as one shuts an open razor. This scheme the German strategists
had worked out with great care and elaboration. Its execution
510 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
involved an outrage upon the law of nations, because Prussia had
undertaken to guarantee the neutrality of Belgium and had no
quarrel with her, and it involved the risk of bringing in Great
Britain (which power was also pledged to protect Belgium) against
Germany. Yet the Germans believed that their fleet had grown
strong enough to make Great Britain hesitate to interfere, and
with a view to possibilities they had constructed a great system
of strategic railways to the Belgian frontier, and made every prep-
aration for the execution of this scheme. So they might hope
to strike down France at one blow, and deal at their leisure with
Russia.
In 1914 all things seemed moving together in favour of the two
Central Powers. Russia, it is true, had been recovering since 1906,
but only very slowly ; France was distracted by financial scandals.
The astounding murder of M. Calmette, the editor of the Figaro,
by the wife of M. Caillaux, the minister of finance, brought these
to a climax in March ; Britain, all Germany was assured, was on
the verge of a civil war in Ireland. Repeated efforts were made
both by foreign and English people to get some definite statement
of what Britain would do if Germany and Austria assailed France
and Russia ; but the British Foreign Secretary maintained a front
of heavy ambiguity up to the very day of the British entry into
the war.1 As a consequence, there was a feeling on the continent
that Britain would either not fight or delay fighting, and this may
have encouraged Germany to go on threatening France. Events
were precipitated on June 28th by the assassination of the Arch-
duke Francis Ferdinand, the heir to the Austrian Empire, when
on a state visit to Sarajevo, the capital of Bosnia. Here was a
timely excuse to set the armies marching. "It is now or never,"
said the German Emperor.2 Serbia was accused of instigating
the murderers, and notwithstanding the fact that Austrian com-
missioners reported that there was no evidence to implicate the
1 1 think his policy was quite clear. He said to Germany, "If you bring on war,
you must expect England to support France and Russia." To France and Russia
he said: "If you are unreasonable, do not expect England to support you." He
thus brought pressure to bear on both sides. — G. M.
An illuminating book on the causes of the war is Lord Loreburn's How the War
Came. — H. H. J.
2 Kautsky's report on the origin of the war.
THE CATASTROPHE OF 1914 511
Serbian government, the Austro-Hungarian government contrived
to press this grievance towards war. On July 23rd Austria dis-
charged an ultimatum at Serbia, and, in spite of a practical sub-
mission on the part of Serbia, and of the efforts of Sir Edward Grey,
the British Foreign Secretary, to call a conference of the powers,
declared war against Serbia on July 28th.
Russia mobilized her army on July 30th, and on August 1st Ger-
many declared war upon her. German troops crossed into French
territory next day, and, simultaneously with the delivery of an
ultimatum to the unfortunate Belgians, the big flanking move-
ment through Luxembourg and Belgium began. Westward rode
the scouts and advanced guards. Westward rushed a multitude
of automobiles packed with soldiers. Enormous columns of grey-
clad infantry followed ; round-eyed, fair young Germans they were
for the most part — law-abiding, educated youngsters who had
never yet seen a shot fired in anger. "This was war," they were
told. They had to be bold and ruthless. Some of them did their
best to carry out these militarist instructions at the expense of the
ill-fated Belgians.
A disproportionate fuss has been made over the detailed atroci-
ties in Belgium, disproportionate, that is, in relation to the fun-
damental atrocity of August, 1914, which was the invasion of Bel-
gium. Given that, the casual shootings and lootings, the wanton
destruction of property, the plundering of inns and of food and
drink shops by hungry and weary men, and the consequent rapes
and incendiarism, follow naturally enough. Only very simple
people believe that an army in the field can maintain as high a level
of honesty, decency, and justice as a settled community at home.
And the tradition of the Thirty Years War still influenced the
Prussian army. It has been customary in the countries allied
against Germany to treat all this vileness and bloodshed of the
Belgian months as though nothing of the sort had ever happened
before, and as if it were due to some distinctively evil strain in the
German character. They were nicknamed "Huns." But noth-
ing could be less like the systematic destructions of the nomads (who
once proposed to exterminate the entire Chinese population in order
to restore China to pasture) than the German crimes in Belgium.
Much of that crime was the drunken brutality of men who for the
512 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
first time in their lives were free to use lethal weapons, much of it
was the hysterical violence of men shocked at their own proceed-
ings and in deadly fear of the revenge of the people whose country
they had outraged, and much of it was done under duress because
of the theory that men should be terrible in warfare and that popu-
lations are best subdued by fear. The German common people
were bundled from an orderly obedience into this war in such a
manner that atrocities were bound to ensue. They certainly did
horrible and disgusting things. But any people who had been
worked up for war and led into war as the Germans were, would
have behaved in a similar manner.
On the night of August 2nd, while most of Europe, still under
the tranquil inertias of half a century of peace, still in the habitual
enjoyment of such a widely diffused plenty and cheapness and
freedom as no man living will ever see again, was thinking about
its summer holidays, the little Belgian village of Vise* was ablaze,
and stupefied rustics were being led out and shot because it was
alleged someone had fired on the invaders. The officers who or-
dered these acts, the men who obeyed, must surely have felt scared
at the strangeness of the things they did. Most of them had never
yet seen a violent death. And they had set light not to a village,
but a world. It was the beginning of the end of an age of comfort,
confidence, and gentle and seemly behaviour in Europe.
So soon as it was clear that Belgium was to be invaded, Great
Britain ceased to hesitate, and (at eleven at night on August 4th)
declared war upon Germany. The following day a German mine-
laying vessel was caught off the Thames mouth by the cruiser
Amphion and sunk, — the first time that the British and Germans
had ever met in conflict under their own national flags upon land
or water. . . .
All Europe still remembers the strange atmosphere of those
eventful sunny August days, the end of the Armed Peace. For
nearly half a century the Western world had been tranquil and had
seemed safe. Only a few middle-aged and ageing people in France
had had any practical experience of warfare. The newspapers
spoke of a world catastrophe, but that conveyed very little meaning
to those for whom the world had always seemed secure, who were
indeed almost incapable of thinking of it as otherwise than secure.
THE CATASTROPHE OF 1914 513
In Britain particularly for some weeks the peace-time routine con-
tinued in a slightly dazed fashion. It was like a man still walking
about the world unaware that he has contracted a fatal disease
which will alter every routine and habit in his life. People went
on with their summer holidays; shops reassured their customers
with the announcement, " business as usual." There was much
talk and excitement when the newspapers came, but it was the
talk and excitement of spectators who have no vivid sense of par-
ticipation in the catastrophe that was presently to involve them
all.
§8*
We will now review very briefly the main phases of the world
struggle which had thus commenced. Planned by Germany, it
began with a swift attack designed to " knock out" France while
Russia was still getting her forces together in the East. For a time
all went well. Military science is never up to date under modern
conditions, because military men are as a class unimaginative,
there are always at any date undeveloped inventions capable of
disturbing current tactical and strategic practice which the military
intelligence has declined. The German plan had been made for
some years; it was a stale plan; it could probably have been
foiled at the outset by a proper use of entrenchments and barbed
wire and machine guns, but the French were by no means as ad-
vanced in their military science as the Germans, and they trusted
to methods of open warfare that were at least fourteen years be-
hind the times. They had a proper equipment neither of barbed
wire nor machine guns, and there was a ridiculous tradition that
the Frenchman did not fight well behind earthworks. The Bel- V
gian frontier was defended by the fortress of LiSge, ten or twelve
years out of date, with forts whose armament had been furnished
and fitted in many cases by German contractors ; and the French
1 For the common soldier's view of the war there is no better book than Le
Feu by Barbusse. An illustrated book of great quaintness, beauty, and veracity
is Andre Helle's Le Lime des Heures. No other book recalls so completely the feel
and effect of the phases of the war. An admirably written and very wise book is
Philip Gibbs' Realities of War. Some light uponjthe peculiar difference of the fight-
ing of the Great War from any previous warfare will be found in McCurdy's War
Neuroses and Eder's book on the same subject.
2L
514
THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
north-eastern frontier was very badly equipped. Naturally the
German armament firm of Krupp had provided nutcrackers for
these nuts in the form of exceptionally heavy guns firing high ex-
plosive shells. These defences proved therefore to be mere traps
for their garrisons. The French attacked and failed in the south-
ern Ardennes. The German hosts swung round the French left
TVfap to illustrate tki*
JfancfeBritish, lim fcefcre tfu> f&LL
rf f^rrm
V» » » aferfmht laier
with an effect of being irresistible ; Liege fell on August 9th, Brus-
sels was reached on August 20th, and the small British army of
about 70,000, which had arrived in Belgium, was struck at Mons
(August 22nd) in overwhelming force, and driven backward in
spite of the very deadly rifle tactics it had learnt during the South
African War. (The German troops could not believe that the
British were using rifles and not machine guns against them.) The
THE CATASTROPHE OF 1914 515
little British force was pushed aside westward, and the German
right swept down so as to leave Paris to the west and crumple the
entire French army back upon itself.
So confident was the German higher command at this stage of
having won the war, that by the end of August German troops were
already being withdrawn for the Eastern front, where the Russians
were playing havoc in East and West Prussia. And then came
the French counter-attack, strategically a very swift and brilliant
counter-attack. The French struck back on their centre, they
produced an unexpected army on their left, and the small British
army, shaken but reinforced, was still fit to play a worthy part in
the counter-stroke. The German right overran itself, lost its co-
hesion, and was driven back from the Marne to the Aisne (Battle
of the Marne, September 6th to 10th). It would have been driven
back farther had it not had the art of entrenchment in reserve.
Upon the Aisne it stood and dug itself in. The heavy guns, the
high explosive shell, the tanks, needed by the allies to smash up
these entrenchments, did not yet exist.
The Battle of the Marne shattered the original German plan.
For a time France was saved. But the German was not defeated ;
he had still a great offensive superiority in men and equipment.
His fear of the Russian in the east had been relieved by a tremen-
dous victory at Tannenberg. His next phase was a headlong, less
elaborately planned campaign to outflank the left of the allied
armies and to seize the Channel ports and cut off supplies coming
from Britain to France. Both armies extended to the west in a
sort of race to the coast. Then the Germans, with a great supe-
riority of guns and equipment, struck at the British round and about
Ypres. They came very near to a break through, but the British
held them.
The war on the Western front settled down to trench warfare.
Neither side had the science and equipment needed to solve the
problem of breaking through modern entrenchments and entangle-
ments, and both sides were now compelled to resort to scientific
men, inventors, and such-like umnilitary persons for counsel and
help in their difficulty. At that time the essential problem of
trench warfare had already been solved ; there existed in England,
for instance, the model of a tank, which would have given the allies
516 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
a swift and easy victory before 1916 ; but the professional military
mind is by necessity an inferior and unimaginative mind; no
man of high intellectual quality would willingly imprison his gifts
in such a calling; nearly all supremely great soldiers have been
either inexperienced fresh-minded young men like Alexander,
Napoleon, and Hoche, politicians turned soldiers like Julius Caesar,
nomads like the Hun and Mongol captains, or amateurs like Crom-
well and Washington ; whereas this war after fifty years of militar-
ism was a hopelessly professional war ; from first to last it was im-
possible to get it out of the hands of the regular generals, and
neither the German nor allied headquarters was disposed to regard
an invention with toleration that would destroy their traditional
methods.1 The tank was not only disagreeably strange to these
military gentlemen, but it gave an unprofessional protection to the
common soldiers within it. The Germans, however, did make some
innovations. In February (28th) they produced a rather futile
novelty, the flame projector, the user of which was in constant
danger of being burnt alive, and in April, in the midst of a second
grave offensive upon the British (second Battle of Ypres, April
17th to May 17th), they employed a cloud of poison gas. This
horrible device was used against Algerian and Canadian troops;
iit shook them by the physical torture it inflicted, and by the anguish
of those who died, but it failed to break through them. For some
weeks chemists were of more importance than soldiers on the allied
front, and within six weeks the defensive troops were already in
possession of protective methods and devices.
For a year and a half, until July, 1916, the Western front remained
in a state of indecisive tension. There were heavy attacks on
either side that ended in bloody repulses. The French made costly
1 "What mainly was wrong with our generalship was the system which put the
High Command into the hands of a group of men belonging to the old school of
war, unable by reason of their age and traditions to get away from rigid methods,
and to become elastic in face of new conditions. Our Staff College had been hope-
lessly inefficient in its system of training, if I am justified in forming such an opinion
from specimens produced by it, who had the brains of canaries and the manners
of Potsdam. There was also a close corporation among the officers of the Regular
Army, so that they took the lion's share of Staff appointments, thus keeping out
brilliant young men of the New Armies, whose brain power, to say the least of it,
was on a higher level than that of the Sandhurst standard." Philip Gibbs, Realities
of War,
THE CATASTROPHE OF 1914
517
but glorious thrusts at Arras and in Champagne in 1915, the Brit-
ish at Loos. From Switzerland to the North Sea there ran two
continuous lines of entrenchment, sometimes at a distance of a
mile or more, sometimes at a distance of a few feet (at Arras, e.g.),
and in and behind these lines of trenches millions of men toiled,
WES1 FRK
raided their enemies, and prepared for sanguinary and foredoomed
offensives. In any preceding age these stagnant masses of men
would have engendered a pestilence inevitably, but here again
modern science had altered the conditions of warfare. Certain
novel diseases appeared, trench feet for instance, caused by pro-
longed standing in cold water, new forms of dysentery, and the
like, but none developed to an extent to disable either combatant
518 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
force. Behind this front the whole life of the belligerent nations
was being turned more and more to the task of maintaining supplies
of food, munitions, and, above all, men to supply the places of
those who day by day were killed or mangled.1 The Germans
had had the luck to possess a considerable number of big siege
guns intended for the frontier fortresses ; these were now available
for trench smashing with high explosive, a use no one had foreseen
for them. The Allies throughout the first years were markedly
inferior in their supply of big guns and ammunition, and their
losses were steadily greater than the German. Mr. Asquith, the
British Prime Minister, though a very fine practitioner in all the
arts of Parliament, was wanting in creative ability ; and it is prob-
ably due to the push and hustle of Mr. Lloyd George (who presently
ousted him in December, 1916) and the clamour of the British press
that this inferiority of supplies was eventually rectified.2
There was a tremendous German onslaught upon the French
throughout the first half of 1916 round and about Verdun. The
Germans suffered enormous losses and were held, after pushing
in the French lines for some miles. The French losses were as great
or greater. "I Is ne passer out pas" said and sang the French in-
fantry — and kept their word.
The Eastern German front was more extended and less system-
atically entrenched than the Western. For a time the Russian
armies continued to press westward in spite of the Tannenberg dis-
aster. They conquered nearly the whole of Galicia from the Aus-
trians, took Lemberg on September 2nd, 1914, and the great for-
tress of Przemysl on March 22nd, 1915. But after the Germans
had failed to break the Western front of the Allies, and after an
1 "The smart society of G. H. Q. was best seen at the Officers' Club at dinner-
time. It was as much like musical comedy as any stage setting of war at the
Gaiety. The band played rag-time and light music while the warriors fed, and all
these generals and staff officers, with their decorations and Army bands, and polished
buttons and crossed swords, were waited upon by little W.A.A.C.s., with the G. H. Q.
colours tied up in bows on their hair, and khaki stockings under their short skirts,
and fancy aprons. Such a chatter ! Such bursts of light-hearted laughter ! Such
whisperings of secrets, of intrigues, and scandals in high places ! Such callous-
hearted courage when British soldiers were being blown to bits, gassed, blinded,
maimed, and shell-shocked in places that were far, so very far, from G. H. Q." —
Phillip Gibbs, The Realities of War.
2 But see Roch, Mr. Lloyd George and the War, and Arthur's Life of Lord Kitchener.
THE CATASTROPHE OF 1914 519
ineffective allied offensive made without proper material,1 they
turned to Russia, and a series of heavy blows, with a novel use of
massed artillery, were struck first in the south and then at the
north of the Russian front. On June 22nd, Przemysl was retaken,
and the whole Russian line was driven back until Vilna (September
2nd) was in German hands.
In May, 1915 (23rd), Italy joined the allies, and declared war upon
Austria. (Not until a year later did she declare war on Germany.)
She pushed over her eastern boundary towards Goritzia (which
fell in the summer of 1916), but her intervention was of little use
at that time to either Russia or the two Western powers. She
merely established another line of trench warfare among the high
mountains of her picturesque north-eastern frontier.
f While the main fronts of the chief combatants were in this state
or exhaustive deadlock, both sides were attempting to strike round
behind the front of their adversaries. The Germans made a series
of Zeppelin, and later of aeroplane, raids upon Paris and the east
of England. Ostensibly these aimed at dep6ts, munition works,
and the like targets of military importance, but practically they
bombed promiscuously at inhabited places. At first these raiders
dropped not very effective bombs, but later the size and quality
of these missiles increased, considerable numbers of people were
killed and injured, and very much damage was done. The English
people were roused to a pitch of extreme indignation by these out-
rages.2 Although the Germans had possessed Zeppelins for some
years, no one in authority in Great Britain had thought out the
proper methods of dealing with them, and it was not until late in
1916 that an adequate supply of anti-aircraft guns was brought into
play and that these raiders were systematically attacked by aero-
planes. Then came a series of Zeppelin disasters, and after the
spring of 1917 they ceased to be used for any purpose but sea scout-
ing, and their place as raiders was taken by large aeroplanes (the
Gothas). The visits of these latter machines to London and the
east of England became systematic after the summer of 1917. All
1 "The want of an unlimited quantity of high explosives was a fatal bar to our
success." — The Times, May 14th, 1915.
2 But compare the British bombardment of Japanese towns noted in Chap,
xxxix, § 11. And aeroplane bombs and machine-gun fire have since been used
by the British military authorities against Indian village crowds suspected of sedition.
520 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
through the winter of 1917-18, London on every moonlight night
became familiar with the banging of warning maroons, the shrill
whistles of the police alarm, the hasty clearance of the streets,
the distant rumbling of scores and hundreds of anti-aircraft guns
growing steadily to a wild uproar of thuds and crashes, the swish
of flying shrapnel, and at last, if any of the raiders got through the
barrage, with the dull heavy bang of the bursting bombs. Then
presently, amidst the diminuendo of the gun fire, would come the
inimitable rushing sound of the fire brigade engines and the hurry
of the ambulances. . . . War was brought home to every Lon-
doner by these experiences^
While the Germans were thus assailing the nerve of their enemy
home population through the air, they were also attacking the
overseas trade of the British by every means in their power. At
the outset of the war they had various trade destroyers scattered
over the world, and a squadron of powerful modern cruisers in
the Pacific, namely, the Scharnhorst, the Gneisenau, the Leipzig,
the Nurnberg, and the'Dresden. Some of the detached cruisers, and
particularly the Emden, did a considerable amount oi; commerce
destroying before they were hunted down, and the main squadron
caught an inferior British force off the coast of Chile and sank the
Good Hope and the Monmouth on November 1st, 1914. A month
later these German ships were themselves pounced upon by a
British force, and all (except the Dresden) sunk by Admiral Stur-
dee in the Battle of the Falkland Isles. After this conflict the
allies remained in undisputed possession of the surface of the sea,
a supremacy which the great naval Battle of Jutland (May 1st,
1916) did nothing to shake. The Germans concentrated their
attention more and more upon submarine warfare. From the
beginning of the war they had had considerable submarine suc-
cesses. On one day, September 22nd, 1914, the"y sank three power-
ful cruisers, the Aboukir, the Hogue, and the Cressy, with 1473 men.
They continued to levy a toll upon British shipping throughout
the war ; at first they hailed and examined passenger and mercantile
shipping, but this practice they discontinued for fear of traps,
and in the spring of 1915 they began to sink ships without notice.
In May, 1915, they sank the great passenger liner, the Lusitania,
without any warning, drowning a number of American citizens.
THE CATASTROPHE OF 1914 521
This embittered American feeling against them, but the possibility
of injuring and perhaps reducing Britain by a submarine blockade
was so great, that they persisted in a more and more intensified
submarine campaign, regardless of the danger of dragging the
United States into the circle of their enemies.
Meanwhile, Turkish forces, very ill equipped, were making
threatening gestures at Egypt across the desert of Sinai.
And while the Germans were thus striking at Britain, their
least accessible and most formidable antagonist, through the air
and under the sea, the French and British were also embarking
upon a disastrous flank attack in the east upon the Central Powers
through Turkey. The Gallipoli campaign was finely imagined,
but disgracefully executed. Had it succeeded, the Allies would
have captured Constantinople in 1915. But the Turks were
given two months' notice of the project by a premature bombard-
ment of the Dardanelles in February, the scheme was also probably
betrayed through the Greek Court, and when at last British and
French forces were landed upon the Gallipoli peninsula in April,
they found the Turks well entrenched and better equipped for
trench warfare 1 than themselves. The Allies trusted for heavy
artillery to the great guns of the ships, which were comparatively
useless for battering down entrenchments, and among every other
sort of thing that they had failed to foresee, they had not foreseen
hostile submarines. Several great battleships were lost; they
went down in the same clear waters over which the ships of Xerxes
had once sailed to their fate at Salamis. The story of the Gallipoli
campaign from the side of the Allies is at once heroic and pitiful,
a story of courage and incompetence, and of life, material, and
prestige wasted, culminating in a withdrawal in January, 1916.2
This failure was due in part to the refusal of the Greeks to co-
operate in the adventure. For a year and a half the Greek king,
the brother-in-law of the Kaiser, being protected by friends in
high quarters on the Allied side, tricked and misled the Allies,
and wasted the lives of great numbers of common British and
1 E.g. in hand grenades.
2 For the flighty incapacity of the British military authorities in this adventure,
see Sir Ian Hamilton's Gallipoli Diary. It is only fair to the British commander
to add that the incapacity was that of the home authorities to understand his de-
mands for men and material. — P. G.
522 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
French soldiers. In June, 1917, he was forced to abdicate, but in-
stead of permitting the Greeks, under their proper leader Venizelos,
to follow their natural and traditional republican disposition, his
son, Alexander, the Kaiser's nephew, was made king in his place
— by the Allies! This Greek chapter in the story of the great
war still awaits the investigations of the historian. It is at present
a quite inexplicable story, and we give these preposterous facts
with no attempt to rationalize them.
Linked up closely with this Greek vacillation was the entry of
Bulgaria into the war (October 12th, 1915). The king of Bulgaria
had hesitated for more than a year to make any decision between
the two sides. Now the manifest failure of the British at Gallipoli,
coupled with a strong Austro-German attack in Serbia, swung him
over to the Central Powers. While the Serbs were hotly engaged
with the Austro-German invaders upon the Danube he attacked
Serbia in the rear, and in a few weeks the country had been com-
pletely overrun. The Serbian army made a terrible retreat through
the mountains of Albania to the coast, where its remains were
rescued by an Allied fleet.
An Allied force landed at Salonika in Greece, and pushed inland
towards Monastir, but was unable to render any effectual assist-
ance to the Serbians. It was the Salonika plan which sealed the
fate of the Gallipoli expedition.
To the east, in Mesopotamia, the British, using Indian troops
chiefly, made a still remoter flank attack upon the Central Powers.
An army, very ill provided for the campaign, was landed at Basra
in the November of 1914, and pushed up towards Bagdad in the
following year. It gained a victory at Ctesiphon, the ancient
Arsacid and Sassanid capital within twenty-five miles of Bagdad,
but the Turks were heavily reinforced, there was a retreat to Kut,
and there the British army, under General Townshend, was sur-
rounded and starved into surrender on April 29th, 1916.
All these campaigns in the air, under the seas, in Russia, Turkey,
and Asia, were subsidiary to the main front, the front of decision,
between Switzerland and the sea; and there the main millions
lay entrenched, slowly learning the necessary methods of modern
scientific warfare. There was a rapid progress in the use of the
aeroplane. At the outset of the war this had been used chiefly
THE CATASTROPHE OF 1914 523
for scouting, and by the Germans for the dropping of marks for the
artillery. Such a thing as aerial fighting was unheard of. In 1916 the
aeroplanes carried machine guns and fought in the air ; their bomb-
ing work was increasingly important, they had developed a wonder-
ful art of aerial photography, and all the aerial side of artillery work,
both with aeroplanes and observation balloons, had been enor-
mously developed. But the military mind was still resisting the
use of the tank, the obvious weapon for decision in trench warfare.
Many intelligent people outside military circles understood this
quite clearly. The use of the tank against trenches was an alto-
gether obvious expedient. Leonardo da Vinci invented an early
tank, but what military "expert" has ever had the wits to study
Leonardo? Soon after the South African War, in 1903, there
were stories in magazines describing imaginary battles in which
tanks figured, and a complete working model of a tank was shown to
the British military authorities — who of course rejected it — in
1912. Tanks had been invented and re-invented before the war
began. But had the matter rested entirely in the hands of the
military, there would never have been any use of tanks. It was
Mr. Winston Churchill, at that time at the British Admiralty,
who insisted upon the manufacture of the first tanks, and it was in
the teeth of the grimmest opposition that they were sent to France.1
To the British navy, and not to the army, military science owes the
use of these devices. The German military authorities were equally
set against them. In July, 1916, Sir Douglas Haig, the British
commander-in-chief , began a great offensive which failed to break
through the German line. In some places he advanced a few miles ;
in others he was completely repulsed. There was a huge slaughter
of the new British armies. And he did not use tanks.
In September, when the season was growing too late for a sus-
tained offensive, tanks first appeared in warfare. A few were
put into action by the British in a not very intelligent fashion.
Their effect upon the German was profound, they produced some-
thing like a panic, and there can be little doubt that had they been
used in July in sufficient numbers and handled by a general of
imagination and energy, they would have ended the war there
and then. At that time the Allies were in greater strength than
1 See Stern, Tanks 1914-1918. See also Fuller, Tanks in the Great War.
524 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
the Germans upon the Western front. Russia, though fast ap-
proaching exhaustion, was still fighting, Italy was pressing the
Austrians hard, and Roumania was just entering the war on the
side of the allies. But the waste of men in this disastrous July
offensive, coupled with the obstinate neglect of the possibilities
of the tanks by the military authorities, brought the Allied cause
to the very brink of disaster.
Directly the British failure of July had reassured the Germans,
they turned on the Roumanians, and the winter of 1916 saw the
same fate overtake Roumania that had fallen upon Serbia in 1915.
The year that had begun with the retreat from Gallipoli and the
surrender of Kut, ended with the crushing of Roumania and with
ij volleys fired at a landing party of French and British marines by a
| royalist crowd in the port of Athens. It looked as though King
Constantine of Greece, that protege of the Allied foreign offices,
meant to lead his people in the footsteps of King Ferdinand of
Bulgaria. But the coast line of Greece is one much exposed to
naval action. Greece was blockaded, and a French force from
Salonika joined hands with an Italian force from Valona to cut
the king of Greece off from his Central European friends.
On the whole, things looked much less dangerous for the Hohen-
zollern imperialism at the end of 1916 than they had done after
the failure of the first great rush at the Marne. The Allies had
wasted two years of opportunity. Belgium, Serbia, and Rou-
mania, and large areas of France and Russia, were occupied by
Austro-German troops. Counterstroke after counterstroke had
failed, and Russia was now tottering towards a collapse. Had
Germany been ruled with any wisdom, she might have made a
reasonable peace at this time. But the touch of success had
intoxicated her imperialists. They wanted not safety, but
triumph, not world welfare, but world empire. " World power
or downfall" was their formula; it gave their antagonists no
alternative but a fight to a conclusive end.
§9
Early in 1917 Russia collapsed.
By this time the enormous strain of the war was telling hardly
upon all the European populations. There had been a great dis-
THE CATASTROPHE OF 1914 525
organization of transport everywhere, a discontinuance of the
normal repairs and replacements of shipping, railways, and the
like, a using-up of material of all sorts, a dwindling of food pro-
duction, a withdrawal of greater and greater masses of men from
industry, a cessation of educational work, and a steady diminution
of the ordinary securities and honesties of life. Nowhere was the
available directive ability capable of keeping a grip upon affairs
in the face of the rupture of habitual bonds and the replacement
of the subtle disciplines of peace by the clumsy brutalities of
military "order." More and more of the European population
was being transferred from surroundings and conditions to which
it was accustomed, to novel circumstances which distressed,
stimulated, and demoralized it. But Russia suffered first and
most from this universal pulling up of civilization from its
roots. The Russian autocracy was dishonest and incompetent.
The Tsar, like several of his ancestors, had now given way to
a crazy pietism, and the court was dominated by a religious
: impostor, Rasputin, whose cult was one of unspeakable foulness,
i a reeking scandal in the face of the world. Beneath the rule of
this dirty mysticism, indolence and scoundrelism mismanaged
the war. The Russian common soldiers were sent into battle
without guns to support them, without even rifle ammunition;
they were wasted by their officers and generals in a delirium of
militarist enthusiasm. For a time they seemed to be suffering
mutely as the beasts suffer ; but there is a limit to the endurance
even of the most ignorant. A profound disgust for the Tsardom
was creeping through these armies of betrayed and wasted men.
From the close of 1915 onwards Russia was a source of deepening
anxiety to her Western allies. Throughout 1916 she remained
largely on the defensive, and there were rumours of a separate
peace with Germany. She gave little help to Roumania.
On December 29th, 1916, the monk Rasputin was murdered
at a dinner-party in Petrograd, and a belated attempt was made
to put the Tsardom in order. By March things were moving
rapidly; food riots in Petrograd developed into a revolutionary
insurrection ; there was an attempted suppression of the Duma,
the representative body, attempted arrests of liberal leaders, the
formation of a provisional government under Prince Lvoff, and
526 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
an abdication (March 15th) by the Tsar. For a time it seemed
that a moderate and controlled revolution might be possible —
perhaps under a new Tsar. Then it became evident that the
destruction of confidence in Russia had gone too far for any such
adjustments. The Russian people were sick to death of the old
order of things in Europe, of Tsars and of wars and great powers ;
it wanted relief, and that speedily, from unendurable miseries.
The Allies had no understanding of Russian realities; their
diplomatists were ignorant of Russian ; genteel persons, with their
attention directed to the Russian Court rather than Russia, they
blundered steadily with the new situation. There was little
goodwill among the diplomatists for republicanism, and a mani-
fest disposition to embarrass the new government as much as
possible. At the head of the Russian republican government was
an eloquent and picturesque leader, Kerensky, who found himself
assailed by the deep forces of a profounder revolutionary move-
ment, the "social revolution," at home and cold-shouldered by
the Allied governments abroad. His allies would neither let him
give the Russian people land nor peace beyond their frontiers.
The French and the British press pestered their exhausted ally
for a fresh offensive, but when presently the Germans made
a strong attack by sea and land upon Riga, the British Admiralty
quailed before the prospect of a Baltic expedition in relief. The
new Russian republic had to fight unsupported. In spite of their
great naval predominance and the bitter protests of the great
English admiral, Lord Fisher (1841-1920), it is to be noted that
the Allies, except for some submarine attacks, left the Germans
the complete mastery of the Baltic throughout the war.
The Russian masses were resolute to end the war. There had
come into existence in Petrograd a body representing the workers
and common soldiers, the Soviet, and this body clamoured
for an international conference of socialists at Stockholm. Food
riots were occurring in Berlin at this time, war weariness in Austria
and Germany was profound, and there can be little doubt, in the
light of subsequent events, that such a conference would have
precipitated a reasonable peace on democratic lines in 1917 and
a German revolution. Kerensky implored his Western allies to
allow this conference to take place, but, fearful of a worldwide
THE CATASTROPHE OF 1914 527
outbreak of socialism and republicanism, they refused, in spite
of the favourable response of a small majority of the British Labour
Party. Without either moral or physical help from the Allies,
the " moderate" Russian republic still fought on and made a last
desperate offensive effort in July. It failed after some preliminary
successes and another great slaughtering of Russians.
The limit of Russian endurance was reached. Mutinies broke
out in the Russian armies, and particularly upon the northern
front, and upon November 7th, 1917, Kerensky's government was
overthrown and power was seized by the Soviet Government,
dominated by the Bolshevik socialists under Lenin, and pledged
to make peace regardless of the Western powers. Russia passed
definitely "out of the war."
In the spring of 1917 there had been a costly and ineffective
French attack upon the Champagne front which had failed to
break through and sustained enormous losses. Here, then, by
the end of 1917, was a phase of events altogether favourable to
Germany, had her government been fighting for security and well-
being rather than for pride and victory. But to the very end, to
the pitch of final exhaustion, the people of the Central Powers
were held to the effort to realize an impossible world imperialism.
To that end it was necessary that Britain should be not merely
resisted, but subjugated, and in order to do that Germany had
already dragged America into the circle of her enemies. Through-
out 1916 the submarine campaign had been growing in intensity,
but hitherto it had respected neutral shipping. In January, 1917,
a completer "blockade" of Great Britain and France was pro-
claimed, and all neutral powers were warned to withdraw their
shipping from the British seas. An indiscriminate sinking of
the world's shipping began which compelled the United States
to enter the war in April (6th), 1917. Throughout 1917, while
Russia was breaking up and becoming impotent, the American
people were changing swiftly and steadily into a great military
nation. And the unrestricted submarine campaign, for which the
German imperialists had accepted the risk of this fresh antagonist,
was far less successful than had been hoped. The British navy
proved itself much more inventive and resourceful than the British
army; there was a rapid development of anti-submarine devices
528
THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
under water, upon the surface, and in the air ; and after a month
or so of serious destruction, the tale of submarine sinkings declined.
The British found it necessary to put themselves upon food
rations ; but the regulations were well framed and ably adminis-
tered, the public showed an excellent spirit and intelligence, and
the danger of famine and social disorder was kept at arm's length.
Yet the German imperial government persisted in its course.
If the submarine was not doing all that had been expected, and if
THE CATASTROPHE OF 1914
529
the armies of America gathered like a thunder-cloud, yet Russia
was definitely down; and in October the same sort of Autumn
offensive that had overthrown Serbia in 1915 and Roumania
in 1916 was now turned with crushing effect against Italy. The
Italian front collapsed after the Battle of Caporetto, and the
Austro-German armies poured down into Venetia and came
almost within gunfire of Venice. Germany felt justified, therefore,
in taking a high line with the Russian peace proposals, and the
2M
530 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
peace of Brest Litovsk (March 2nd, 1918) gave the Western allies
some intimation of what a German victory would mean to them.
It was a crushing and exorbitant peace, dictated with the utmost
arrogance of confident victors.
{ All through the winter German troops had been shifting from
tne Eastern to the Western front, and now, in the spring of 1918,
the jaded enthusiasm of hungry, weary, and bleeding Germany
was lashed up for the one supreme effort that was really and truly
to end the war. For some months American troops had been in
France, but the bulk of the American army was still across the
Atlantic. It was high time for the final conclusive blow upon
the Western front, if such a blow was ever to be delivered. The
first attack was upon the British in the Somme region. The not
very brilliant cavalry generals who were still in command of
a front upon which cavalry was a useless encumbrance, were
caught napping; and on March 21st, in "Gough's Disaster,"
a British army was driven back in such disorder as no British
army had ever known before. Thousands of guns were lost, and
scores of thousands of prisoners. Many of these losses were due
to the utter incompetence of the higher command. No less than
a hundred tanks were abandoned because they ran out of petrol !
The British were driven back almost to Amiens.1 Throughout
April and May the Germans rained offensives on the Allied front.
They came near to a break through in the north, and they made
a great drive back to the Marne, which they reached again on
May 30th, 1918.
This was the climax of the German effort. Behind it was
nothing but an exhausted homeland. Fresh troops were hurrying
from Britain across the Channel, and America was now pouring
1 "I found a general opinion among officers and men under the command of the
Fifth Army that they had been victims of atrocious staff work, tragic in its con-
sequence. From what I saw of some of the Fifth Army staff officers, I was of the
same opinion. Some of these young gentlemen, and some of the elderly officers,
were arrogant and supercilious, without revealing any sign of intelligence. If they
had wisdom, it was deeply camouflaged by an air of inefficiency. If they had know-
ledge, they hid it as a secret of their own. General Gough in Flanders, though
personally responsible for many tragic happenings, was badly served by some of his
subordinates, and battalion officers and divisional staffs raged against the whole
of the Fifth Army organization, or lack of organization, with an extreme passion
of speech." — Philip Gibbs, Realities of War.
THE CATASTROPHE OF 1914 531
men into France by the hundred thousand. In June the weary
Austrians made a last effort in Italy, and collapsed before an Italian
counter-attack. Early in June the French began to develop a
counter-attack in the Marne angle. By July the tide was turning
and the Germans were reeling back. The Battle of Chateau
Thierry (July 18th) proved the quality of the new American
armies. In August the British opened a great and successful
thrust into Belgium, and the bulge of the German lines towards
Amiens wilted and collapsed. Germany had finished. The
fighting spirit passed out of her army, and October was a story
of defeat and retreat along the entire Western front. Early in
November British troops were in Valenciennes and Americans
in Sedan. In Italy also the Austrian armies were in a state of
disorderly retreat. But everywhere now the Hohenzollern and
Habsburg forces were collapsing. The smash at the end was
amazingly swift. Frenchmen and Englishmen could not believe
their newspapers as day after day they announced the capture
of more hundreds of guns and more thousands of prisoners.
In September, a great allied offensive against Bulgaria had pro-
duced a revolution in that country and peace proposals. Turkey
had followed with a capitulation at the end of October, and
Austro-Hungary on November 4th. There was an attempt to
bring out the German Fleet for a last fight, but the sailors mutinied
(November 7th).
The Kaiser and the Crown Prince bolted hastily, and without
a scrap of dignity, into Holland. It was like welshers bolting
from a racecourse to escape a ducking. On November llth an
armistice was signed, and the war was at an end. . . .
For four years and a quarter the war had lasted, and gradually
it had drawn nearly everyone, in the Western world at least, into
its vortex. Upwards of ten millions of people had been actually
killed through the fighting, another twenty or twenty-five million
had died through the hardships and disorders entailed. Scores
of millions were suffering and enfeebled by under-nourishment
and misery. A vast proportion of the living were now engaged
in war work, in drilling and armament, in making munitions,
in hospitals, in working as substitutes for men who had gone into
the armies and the like. Business men had been adapting them-
532 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
selves to the more hectic methods necessary for profit in a world
in a state of crisis. The war had become, indeed, an atmosphere,
a habit of life, a new social order. Then suddenly it ended.
In London the armistice was proclaimed about midday on
November llth. It produced a strange cessation of every or-
dinary routine. Clerks poured out of their offices and would not
return, assistants deserted their shops, omnibus drivers and the
drivers of military lorries set out upon journeys of their own
devising with picked-up loads of astounded and cheering passengers
going nowhere in particular and careless whither they went.
Vast vacant crowds presently choked the streets, and every house
and shop that possessed such adornments hung out flags. When
night came, many of the main streets, which had been kept in
darkness for many months because of the air raids, were brightly
lit. It was very strange to see thronging multitudes assembled
in an artificial light again. Everyone felt aimless, with a kind
of strained and aching relief. It was over at last. There would
be no more killing in France, no more air raids — and things
would get better. People wanted to laugh, and weep — and could
do neither. Youths of spirit and young soldiers on leave formed
thin noisy processions that shoved their way through the general
drift, and did their best to make a jollification. A captured
German gun was hauled from the Mall, where a vast array of
such trophies had been set out, into Trafalgar Square, and its
carriage burnt. Squibs and crackers were thrown about. But
there was little concerted rejoicing. Nearly everyone had lost
too much and suffered too much to rejoice with any fervour. M
§10
The world in the year after the great war was like a man who
has had some vital surgical operation very roughly performed,
and who is not yet sure whether he can now go on living or whether
he has not been so profoundly shocked and injured that he will
presently fall down and die. It was a world dazed and stunned.
German militarist imperialism had been defeated, but at an over-
whelming cost. It had come very near to victory. Everything
1 A very good account of the state of mind of Paris during and after the war is
in W. P. Adams' Paris Sees it Through.
THE CATASTROPHE OF 1914 533
went on, now that the strain of the conflict had ceased, rather
laxly, rather weakly, and with a gusty and uncertain temper.
There was a universal hunger for peace, a universal desire for the
lost safety and liberty and prosperity of pre-war times, without
any power of will to achieve and secure these things.
Just as with the Roman Republic under the long strain of the
Punic War, so now there had been a great release of violence
and cruelty, and a profound deterioration in financial and eco-
nomic morality. Generous spirits had sacrificed themselves
freely to the urgent demands of the war, but the sly and base
of the worlds of business and money had watched the convulsive
opportunities of the time and secured a firm grip upon the re-
sources and political power of their countries. Everywhere
men who would have been regarded as shady adventurers before
1914 had acquired power and influence while better men toiled
unprofitably. Such men as Lord Rhondda, the British food
controller, killed themselves with hard work, while the war
profiteer waxed rich and secured his grip upon press and party
organization.
In the course of the war there had been extraordinary experi-
ments in collective management in nearly all the belligerent
countries. It was realized that the common expedients of peace-
time commerce, the higgling of 'the market, the holding out for
a favourable bargain, were incompatible with the swift needs of
warfare. Transport, fuel, food supply, and the distribution of
the raw materials not only of clothing, housing, and the like, but
of everything needed for war munitions, had been brought under
public control. No longer had farmers been allowed to under-
farm; cattle had been put upon deer-parks and grass-lands
ploughed up, with or without the owner's approval. Luxury
building and speculative company promotion had been restrained.
In effect, a sort of emergency socialist state had been established
throughout belligerent Europe. It was rough-and-ready and
wasteful, but it was more effective than the tangled incessant
profit-seeking, the cornering and forestalling and incoherent
productiveness of " private enterprise."
In the earlier years of the war there was a very widespread
feeling of brotherhood and the common interest in all the bellig-
534 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
erent states. The common men were everywhere sacrificing life
and health for what they believed to be the common good of the
state. In return, it was promised, there would be less social
injustice after the war, a more universal devotion to the common
welfare. In Great Britain, for instance, Mr. Lloyd George was
particularly insistent upon his intention to make the after-war
Britain " a land fit for heroes." He foreshadowed the continuation
of this new war communism into the peace period in discourses
of great fire and beauty. In Great Britain there was created
a Ministry of Reconstruction, which was understood to be planning
a new and more generous social order, better labour conditions,
better housing, extended education, a complete and scientific
revision of the economic system. Similar hopes of a better world
sustained the common soldiers of France and Germany and Italy.
It was premature disillusionment that caused the Russian collapse.
So that two mutually dangerous streams of anticipation were
running through the minds of men in Western Europe towards
the end of the war. The rich and adventurous men, and partic-
ularly the new war profiteers, were making their plans to prevent
such developments as that air transport should become a state
property, and to snatch back manufactures, shipping, land trans-
port, the public services generally, and the trade in staples from
the hands of the commonweal into the grip of private profit;
they were securing possession of newspapers and busying them-
selves with party caucuses and the like to that end; while the
masses of common men were looking forward naively to a new
state of society planned almost entirely in their interest and
according to generous general ideas. The history of 1919 is largely
the clash of these two streams of anticipation. There was a
hasty selling off, by the " business" government in control, of
every remunerative public enterprise to private speculators. . . .
By the middle of 1919 the labour masses throughout the world
were manifestly disappointed and in a thoroughly bad temper.
The British " Ministry of Reconstruction" and its foreign equiva-
lents were exposed as a soothing sham. The common man felt
he had been cheated. There was to be no reconstruction, but
only a restoration of the old order — in the harsher form neces-
sitated by the poverty of the new time.
THE CATASTROPHE OF 1914 535
For four years the drama of the war had obscured the social
question which had been developing in the Western civilizations
throughout the nineteenth century. Now that the war was over,
this question reappeared gaunt and bare, as it had never been seen
before.
And the irritations and hardships and the general insecurity of
the new time were exacerbated by a profound disturbance of
currency and credit. Money, a complicated growth of con-
ventions rather than a system of values, had been deprived within
the belligerent countries of the support of a gold standard. Gold
had been retained only for international trade, and every govern-
ment had produced excessive quantities of paper money for
domestic use. With the breaking down of the war-time barriers
the international exchange became a wildly fluctuating confusion,
a source of distress to everyone except a few gamblers and wily
speculators. Prices rose and rose — with an infuriating effect
upon the wage-earner. On the one hand was the employer resist-
ing his demands for more pay; on the other hand, food, house-
room, and clothing were being steadily cornered against him.
And, which was the essential danger of the situation, he had lost
any confidence he had ever possessed that any patience or industrial
willingness he displayed would really alleviate the shortages and
inconveniences by which he suffered.
In the speeches of politicians towards the close of 1919 and the
spring of 1920, there was manifest an increasing recognition of
the fact that what is called the capitalist system — the private
ownership system that is, in which private profit is the working
incentive — was on its trial. It had to produce general prosperity,
they admitted, or it had to be revised. It is interesting to note
such a speech as that of Mr. Lloyd George, the British premier,
delivered on Saturday, December 6th, 1919. Mr. Lloyd George
had had the education and training of a Welsh solicitor; he
entered politics early, and in the course of a brilliant parliamentary
career he had had few later opportunities for reading and thought.
But being a man of great natural shrewdness, he was expressing
here very accurately the ideas of the more intelligent of the busi-
ness men and wealthy men and ordinary citizens who supported
him.
536 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
" There is a new challenge to civilization," he said. "What is
it? It is fundamental. It affects the whole fabric of society as
we know it; its commerce, its trade, its industry, its finance, its
social order — all are involved in it. There are those who main-
tain that the prosperity and strength of the country have been
built up by the stimulating and invigorating appeal to individual
impulse, to individual action. That is one view. The State must
educate; the State must assist where necessary; the State must
control where necessary ; the State must shield the weak against
the arrogance of the strong ; but the life springs from individual
impulse and energy. (Cheers.) That is one view. What is the
other ? That private enterprise is a failure, tried, and found want-
ing — a complete failure, a cruel failure. It must be rooted out,
and the community must take charge as a community, to produce,
to distribute, as well as to control.
"Those are great challenges for us to decide. We say that the
ills of private enterprise can be averted. They say, 'No, they can-
not. No ameliorative, no palliative, no restrictive, no remedial
measure will avail. These evils are inherent in the system. They
are the fruit of the tree, and you must cut it down.' That is the
challenge we hear ringing through the civilized world to-day, from
ocean to ocean, through valley and plain. You hear it in the
whining and maniacal shrieking of the Bolshevists. You hear it
in the loud, clear, but more restrained tones of Congresses and Con-
ferences. The Bolshevists would blow up the fabric with high ex-
plosive, with horror. Others would pull down with the crowbars
and with cranks — especially cranks. (Laughter.)
"Unemployment, with its injustice for the man who seeks and
thirsts for employment, who begs for labour and cannot get it,
and who is punished for failure he is not responsible for by the
starvation of his children — that torture is something that private
enterprise ought to remedy for its own sake. (Cheers.) Sweating,
slums, the sense of semi-slavery in labour, must go. We must
cultivate a sense of manhood by treating men as men. If I
— and I say this deliberately — if I had to choose between this
fabric I believe in, and allowing millions of men and women and
children to rot in its cellars, I would not hesitate one hour.
That is not the choice. Thank God it is not the choice. P*i-
THE CATASTROPHE OF 1914 537
vate enterprise can produce more, so that all men get a fair share
of it. .'.."»
Here, put into quasi-eloquent phrasing, and with a jest adapted
to the mental habits of the audience, we have the common-sense
view of the ordinary prosperous man not only of Great Britain,
but of America or France or Italy or Germany. In quality and
tone it is a fair sample of British political thought in 1919. The
prevailing economic system has made us what we are, is the under-
lying idea ; and we do not want any process of social destruction
to precede a renascence of society, we do not want to experiment
with the fundamentals of our social order. Let us accept that.
Adaptation, Mr. Lloyd George admitted, there had to be. Now
this occasion of his speaking was a year and a month after the
Armistice, and for all that period private enterprise had been failing
to do all that Mr. Lloyd George was so cheerfully promising it would
do. The community was in urgent need of houses. Throughout
the war there had been a cessation not only of building, but of
repairs. The shortage of houses in the last months of 1919
amounted to scores of thousands in Britain alone.2 Multitudes
of people were living in a state of exasperating congestion, and the
most shameless profiteering in apartments and houses was going
on. It was a difficult, but not an impossible situation. Given
the same enthusiasm and energy and self-sacrifice that had tidedj
over the monstrous crisis of 1916, the far easier task of providing
a million houses could have been performed in a year or so. But
there had been corners in building materials, transport was in a
disordered state, and it did not pay private enterprise to build
houses at any rents within the means of the people who needed
them. Private enterprise, therefore, so far from bothering about
the public need of housing, did nothing but corner and speculate
in rents and sub-letting. It now demanded grants in aid from the
State — in order to build at a profit. And there w,as a great crowd-
ing and dislocation of goods at the depots because there was in-
sufficient road transport. There was an urgent want of cheap
automobiles to move about goods and workers. But private enter-
prise in the automobile industry found it far more profitable to
1 The Times, December 8th, 1919.
1 Authorities vary between 250,000 and a million houses.
538 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
produce splendid and costly cars for those whom the war had made
rich. The munition factories built with public money could have
been converted very readily into factories for the mass production
of cheap automobiles, but private enterprise had insisted upon
these factories being sold by the State, and would neither meet
the public need itself nor let the State do so. So, too, with the
world, in the direst discomfort for need of shipping, private, enter-
prise insisted upon the shutting down of the newly constructed
State shipyards. Currency was dislocated everywhere, but pri-
vate enterprise was busy buying and selling francs or marks and
intensifying the trouble. While Mr. George was making the very
characteristic speech we have quoted, the discontent of the common
man was gathering everywhere, and little or nothing was being
done to satisfy his needs. It was becoming very evident that un-
less there was to be some profound change in the spirit of business,
under an unrestrained private enterprise system there was little
or no hope, in Europe at any rate, of decent housing, clothing, or
education for the workers for two or three generations.
These are facts that the historian of mankind is obliged to note
with as little comment as possible. Private enterprise in Europe
in 1919 displayed neither will nor capacity for meeting the crying
needs of the time. So soon as it was released from control, it ran
naturally into speculation, cornering, and luxury production. It
followed the line of maximum profit. It displayed no sense of its
own dangers ; and it resisted any attempt to restrain and moderate
its profits and make itself serviceable, even in its own interest.
And this went on in the face of the most striking manifestations
of the extreme recalcitrance on the part of the European masses
to the prolonged continuance of the privations and inconveniences
they suffered. In 1913 these masses were living as they had lived
since birth ; they were habituated to the life they led. The masses
of 1919, on the other hand, had been uprooted everywhere, to go
into the armies, to go into munition factories, and so on. They had
lost their habits of acquiescence, and they were hardier and more
capable of desperate action. Great multitudes of men had gone
through such brutalizing training as, for instance, bayonet drill;
they had learnt to be ferocious, and to think less either of killing
or being killed. Social unrest had become, therefore, much more
THE CATASTROPHE OF 1914 539
dangerous. Everything seemed to point to a refusal to tolerate
the current state of affairs for many years. Unless the educated
and prosperous and comfortable people of Europe could speedily
get their private enterprise under sufficient restraint to make it
work well and rapidly for the common good, unless they could
develop the idea of business as primarily a form of public service
and not primarily a method of profit-making, unless they could in
their own interest achieve a security of peace that would admit of
a cessation not only of war preparation, but of international com-
mercial warfare, strike and insurrection promised to follow strike
and insurrection up to a complete social and political collapse. It
was not that the masses had or imagined that they had the plan
of a new social, political, and economic system. They had not,
and they did not believe they had. The defects we have pointed
out in the socialist scheme (chapter xxxix, § 5) were no secret from
them. It was a much more dangerous state of affairs than that.
It was that they were becoming so disgusted with the current sys-
tem, with its silly luxury, its universal waste, and its general misery,
that they did not care what happened afterwards so long as they
could destroy it. It was a return to a state of mind comparable to
that which had rendered possible the debacle of the Roman Empire.
Already in 1919 the world had seen one great community go
that way, the Russian people. The Russians overturned the old
order and submitted to the autocratic rule of a small group of
doctrinaire Bolshevik socialists, because these men seemed to have
something new to try. They wrecked the old system, and at any
cost they would not have it back. The information available from
Russia at the time of writing this summary is still too conflicting
and too obviously tainted by propagandist aims for us to form any
judgment upon the proceedings and methods of the Soviet Govern-
ment, but it is very plain that from November, 1917, Russia has
not only endured that government and its mainly socialistic
methods, but has fought for it successfully against anything that
seemed to threaten a return to the old regime.
We have already (§5) pointed out the very broad differences
between the Russian and the Western communities, and the strong
reasons there are for doubting that they will move upon parallel
lines and act in similar ways. The Russian masses were cut off by
540 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
want of education and sympathy from the small civilized commu-
nity of prosperous and educated people which lived upon them.
These latter were a little separate nation. The masses below have
thrown that separate nation off and destroyed it and begun again,
so to speak, upon a new sort of society which, whether it succeed
or collapse, cannot fail to be of intense interest to all mankind.
But there is much more unity of thought and feeling between class
and class in the West than in Russia, and particularly in the At-
lantic communities. Even if they wrangle, classes can talk to-
gether and understand each other. There is no unbroken stratum
of illiterates. The groups of rich and speculative men, the "bad
men" in business and affairs, whose freedoms are making the very
name of "private enterprise" stink in the nostrils of the ordinary
man, are only the more active section of very much larger classes,
guilty perhaps of indolence and self-indulgence, but capable of
being roused to a sense not merely of the wickedness but of the
danger of systematic self-seeking in a strained, impoverished, and
sorely tried world. Many of these more reasonable and moral
people have shown themselves clearly aware of the nature of the
present situation, and some of them have made speeches and de-
livered sermons and written books — often addressed to the
working classes — expressing very generous and unselfish views.
Speeches and sermons and books will in themselves do little to allay
the gathering wrath of classes ill housed, ill fed, and unhealthy,
and angry because they believe things are so through the reckless
greed of others; but such utterances are valuable as admissions,
and if these good intentions, encouraged perhaps and aided by a
certain pressure from below, presently develop into a resolute com-
bining and direction of the energies of private enterprise — for a
time at least — towards socially necessary work and a restriction
of speculation and luxury, and if there begin a rapid provision,
even at some cost to the hoards and satisfactions of the successful
classes, of the decent homes and gardens, of the pleasant public
surroundings, the health services and the education and leisure
needed to tranquillize the fiercer discontents, it is still possible
that readjustment rather than revolution will be the method of
the Atlantic communities. But that readjustment cannot be
indefinitely delayed ; it must come soon.
THE CATASTROPHE OF 1914 541
In one way or another it seems inevitable now that the new stand-
ard of well-being which the mechanical revolution of the last
century has rendered possible, should become the general standard
of life. Revolution is conditional upon public discomfort. Social
peace is impossible without a rapid amelioration of the needless
discomforts of the present time. A rapid resort to willing service
and social reconstruction on the part of those who own and rule,
or else a worldwide social revolution leading towards an equaliza-
tion of conditions and an attempt to secure comfort on new and
untried lines, seem now to be the only alternatives before mankind.
^The choice which route shall be taken lies, we believe, in western
Europe, and still more so in America, with the educated, possessing,
and influential classes. The former route demands much sacrifice,
for prosperous people in particular, a voluntary assumption of
public duties and a voluntary acceptance of class discipline and
self-denial; the latter may take an indefinite time to traverse, it
will certainly be a very destructive and bloody process, and whether
it will lead to a new and better state of affairs at last is question-
able. A social revolution, if ultimately the western European
States blunder into it, may prove to be a process extending over
centuries ; it may involve a social breakdown as complete as that
of the Roman Empire, and it may necessitate as slow a recuperation.
Let us add to what has been written above a short passage from
an abler and far more authoritative pen.1 It approaches this ques-
tion of economic disorganization from a different angle, but the
drift of its implications is the same. It says as plainly to the pri-
vate capitalist system: "Mend, show more understanding, and
a better and a stronger will for the common welfare, or go."
11 In the latter stages of the war all the belligerent governments
practised, from necessity or incompetence, what a Bolshevist
might have done from design.2 Even now, when the war is over,
most of them continue out of weakness the same malpractices.
But further, the Governments of Europe, being many of them at
this moment reckless in their methods as well as weak, seek to
direct on to a class known as ' profiteers ' the popular indignation
against the more obvious consequences of their vicious methods.
1 J. M. Keynes, op. cit.
2 They debauched the currency, i.e. and wasted money recklessly.
542 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
These profiteers are, broadly speaking, the entrepreneur class of
capitalists, that is to say, the active and constructive element in
the whole capitalist society, who in a period of rapidly rising prices
cannot but get rich quick whether they wish it or desire it or not.1
If prices are continually rising, every trader who has purchased
for stock or owns property and plant inevitably makes profits.
By directing hatred against this class, therefore, the European
Governments are carrying a step further the fatal process which
the subtle mind of Lenin had consciously conceived. The profiteers
are a consequence and not a cause of rising prices. By combining
a popular hatred of the class of entrepreneurs with the blow
already given to social security by the violent and arbitrary dis-
turbance of contract and of the established equilibrium of wealth
which is the inevitable result of inflation, these governments are
fast rendering impossible a continuance of the social and economic
order of the nineteenth century. But they have no plan for re-
placing it.
" We are thus faced in Europe with the spectacle of an extraor-
dinary weakness, on the part of the great capitalist class, which
has emerged from the industrial triumphs of the nineteenth century
and seemed a very few years ago our all-powerful master. The
terror and personal timidity of the individuals of this class is now
so great, their confidence in their place in society and in their
necessity to the social organism so diminished, that they are the
easy victims of intimidation. This was not so in England twenty-
five years ago, any more than it is now in the United States. Then
the capitalists believed in themselves, in their value to society, in the
propriety of their continued existence in the full enjoyment of
their riches and the unlimited exercise of their power. Now they
tremble before every insult. Call them pro-Germans, international
financiers, or profiteers, and they will give you any ransom you
choose to ask not to speak of them so harshly. They allow them-
selves to be ruined and altogether undone by their own instruments,
governments of their own making, and a press of which they are
the proprietors. Perhaps it is historically true that no order of
society ever perished save by its own hand."
1 Mr. Keynes ignores the fortunes made by deliberately cornering and with-
holding commodities in a time of shortage.
THE CATASTROPHE OF 1914 543
We have dealt with the social and economic disorder of the Euro-
pean communities, and the rapid return of the "class-war" to the
foreground of attention, before giving any account of the work of
world settlement that centred on the Peace Conference at Paris,
because the worried and preoccupied state of everyone concerned
with private problems of income, prices, employment, and the like
goes far to explain the jaded atmosphere in which that Conference
addressed itself to the vast task before it.
The story of the Conference turns very largely upon the adven-
ture of one particular man, one of those men whom accident or
personal quality picks out as a type to lighten the task of the his-
torian. We have in the course of this history found it very helpful
at times to focus our attention upon some individual, Buddha,
Alexander the Great, Yuan Chwang, the Emperor Frederick II
and Charles V and Napoleon I for example, and to let him by re-
flection illuminate the period in which he lived. The conclusion
of the Great War can be seen most easily as the rise of the Ameri-
can President, President Wilson, to predominant importance in
the world's hopes and attention, and his failure to justify that pre-
dominance.
President Wilson (born 1856) had previously been a prominent
student and teacher of history, constitutional law, and the political
sciences generally. He had held various professorial chairs, and
had been President of Princeton University (New Jersey). There
is a long list of books to his credit, and they show a mind rather
exclusively directed to American history and American politics.
There is no evidence that he had at any time in his life made a
general study of the world problem outside the very peculiar and
exceptional American case. He was mentally the new thing in
history, negligent of and rather ignorant of the older things out of
1 Among the books consulted here, for this and the two following sections, were
Dr. Dillon's Peace Conference; H. Wilson Harris's The Peace in the Making and
President Wilson, his Problems and his Policy ; J. M . Keynes's Economic Consequences
of the Peace; Weyl' 8 The End of the War; S tally brass '3 Society of States; Bradford's
A League of Nations ; F.C.Howe's Why War? L. S. Woolf's International Govern-
ment; J. A. Hobson's Towards International Government; Lowes Dickinson's The
Choice before Us; Sir Walter Phillimore's Three Centuries of Treaties, and C. E.
Fayle's Great Settlement.
544 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
which his new world had arisen. He retired from academic life,
and was elected Democratic Governor of New Jersey in 1910. In
1913 he became the Democratic presidential candidate, and as a
consequence of a violent quarrel between ex-President Roosevelt
and President Taft, which split the dominant Republican party, he
became President of the United States.
The events of August 1914 seem to have taken President Wilson,
like the rest of his fellow-countrymen, by surprise. We find him
cabling an offer of his services as a mediator on August 3rd. Then,
for a time, he and America watched the conflict. At first neither
the American people nor their President seem to have had a very
clear or profound understanding of that long-gathered catastrophe.
Their tradition for a century had been to disregard the problems
of the Old World, and it was not to be lightly changed. The im-
perialistic arrogance of the German Court and the stupid inclina-
tion of the German military authorities towards melodramatic
"frightfulness," their invasion of Belgium, their cruelties there,
their use of poison gas, and the nuisance of their submarine cam-
paign created a deepening hostility to Germany in the States as
the war proceeded; but the tradition of political abstinence and
the deep-rooted persuasion that America possessed a political
morality altogether superior to European conflicts restrained the
President from active intervention. He adopted a lofty tone.
He professed to be unable to judge the causes and justice of the
Great War. It was largely his high pacific attitude that secured
his re-election as President for a second term. But the world is
not to be mended by merely regarding evil-doers with an expression
of rather undiscriminating disapproval. By the end of 1916 the
Germans had been encouraged to believe that under no circum-
stances whatever would the United States fight, and in 1917 they
began their unrestricted submarine warfare and the sinking of
American ships without notice. President Wilson and the Amer-
ican people were dragged into the war by this supreme folly.
And also they were dragged into a reluctant attempt to define
their relations to Old-World politics in some other terms than
those of mere aloofness. Their thoughts and temper changed
very rapidly. They came into the war side by side with the
Allies, but not in any pact with the Allies. They came into the
THE CATASTROPHE OF 1914 545
war, in the name of their own modern civilization, to punish and
end an intolerable political and military situation.
Slow and belated judgments are sometimes the best judgments.
In a series of " notes," too long and various for detailed treatment
in this Outline, thinking aloud, as it were, in the hearing of all man-
kind, President Wilson sought to state the essential differences of
the American State from the Great Powers of the Old World. We
have been at some pains in this history to make plain the develop-
ment of these differences. He unfolded a conception of interna-
tional relationships that came like a gospel, like the hope of a better
world, to the whole eastern hemisphere. Secret agreements were
to cease, "nations" were to determine their own destinies, mili-
tarist aggression was to cease, the sea-ways were to be free to all
mankind. These commonplaces of American thought, these secret
desires of every sane man, came like a great light upon the darkness
of anger and conflict in Europe. At last, men felt, the ranks of
diplomacy were broken, the veils of Great Power "policy "were
rent in twain. Here with authority, with the strength of a power-
ful new nation behind it, was the desire of the common man
throughout the world, plainly said.
Manifestly there was needed some over-riding instrument of
government to establish world law and maintain these broad and
liberal generalizations upon human intercourse. A number of
schemes had floated in men's minds for the attainment of that end.
In particular there was a movement for some sort of world league,
a "League of Nations." The American President adopted this
phrase and sought to realize it. An essential condition of the peace
he sought through the overthrow of German imperialism was, he
declared, to be this federal organ. This League of Nations was
to be the final court of appeal in international affairs. It was to
be the substantial realization of the peace. Here again he awak-
ened a tremendous echo.
President Wilson was the spokesman of a new age. Through-
out the war, and for some little time after it had ended, he held,
so far as the Old World was concerned, that exalted position. But
in America, where they knew him better, there were doubts. And
writing as we do now with the wisdom of subsequent events, we
can understand these doubts. America, throughout a century
2N
546 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
and more of detachment and security, had developed new ideals
and formulae of political thought, without realizing with any in-
tensity that, under conditions of stress and danger, these ideals
and formulae might have to be passionately sustained. To her
community many things were platitudes that had to the Old World
communities, entangled still in ancient political complications, the
quality of a saving gospel. President Wilson was responding to
the thought and conditions of his own people and his own country,
based on a liberal tradition that had first found its full expression
in English speech ; but to Europe and Asia he seemed to be think-
ing and saying, for the first time in history, things hitherto un-
developed and altogether secret. And that misconception he may
have shared.
We are dealing here with an able and successful professor of
political science, who did not fully realize what he owed to his con-
temporaries and the literary and political atmosphere he had
breathed throughout his life ; and who passed very rapidly, after
his re-election as President, from the mental attitudes of a political
leader to those of a Messiah. His "notes" are a series of explora-
tions of the elements of the world situation. When at last, in his
address to Congress of January 8th, 1918, he produced his Fourteen
Points as a definite statement of the American peace intentions,
they were, as a statement, far better in their spirit than in their
arrangement and matter.
Yet, since the Fourteen Points certainly mark a new epoch in
human affairs, and since it was in the belief that they would de-
termine and limit the pains and penalties of the peace treaty that
Germany capitulated,1 it may be well to summarize them here,
with a word or so of explanation.
(I) The First Point was the most vital of all. It summarizes
and dismisses the essential evils of the Great Power system. It
111 The Allied Governments," the effective passage ran, "have given careful
consideration to the correspondence which has passed between the President of the
United States and the German Government. Subject to the qualifications which
follow, they declare their readiness to make peace with the Government of Germany
on the terms of peace laid down in the President's Address to Congress of January
8th, 1918, and the principles of settlement enunciated in his subsequent Addresses."
(Note transmitted to the German Government by the Allies through the Swiss
Minister on November 5th, 1918.)
THE CATASTROPHE OF 1914 547
demands : "Open covenants of peace openly arrived at, after which
there shall be no private international understandings of any kind,
but diplomacy shall proceed always frankly and in the public view."
(II) "Absolute freedom of navigation upon the seas outside
territorial waters alike in peace and in war, except as the seas may
be closed in whole or in part by international action for the en-
forcement of international covenants."
(III) "The removal, so far as possible, of all economic barriers
and the establishment of an equality of trade conditions among all
the nations consenting to the peace and associating themselves for
its maintenance."
(IV) "Adequate guarantees given and taken that national arma-
ments will be reduced to the lowest point consistent with domestic
safety."
There are four points of universal importance, admirably stated.
But II is insufficient. Why should the sea-ways alone be free?
What of the air- ways above three thousand feet? What of the
great international land routes? Why, if Switzerland is at war
with Germany and Italy, should those powers be able to stop air
and land transit and the passage of peaceful people between France
and Constantinople?
After IV, the Fourteen Points embark upon the consideration
of particular cases, for which one general statement should have
sufficed.
(V) provides for "A free, open-minded and absolutely impartial
adjustment of all colonial claims based upon a strict observance
of the principle that in determining all such questions of sovereignty
the interests of the populations concerned must have equal weight
with the equitable claims of the government whose title is to be
determined." . . . This is hopelessly vague. What, for instance,
is this about claims and title ? There is no definition, no standard
here.
The drop towards particular current issues continues in the next
eight points, which betray clearly how limited and accidental was
the President's vision of European affairs.
(VI) is a vague demand for the evacuation of Russian territory
(then occupied by Germany), and the "assistance" (undefined)
of the Russian people.
548 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
(VII) Evacuation and restoration of Belgium.
(VIII) Evacuation and restoration of all French territory, and
the " righting" of the wrong done to France by Prussia in the
matter of Alsace-Lorraine.
(IX) The readjustment of the Italian frontier "on the lines of
nationality."
(X) "Autonomy" of the Austrian "subject nations."
(XI) The Balkans to be evacuated, Serbia to be granted an
outlet to the sea, and the independence of the Balkan States to
be guaranteed.
(XII) Turkish subject nations to be assured of "undoubted
security of life and unmolested opportunity of autonomous de-
velopment." The Dardanelles to be internationalized, and Otto-
man sovereignty to be recognized only in Turkish districts.
(XIII) Poland to be independent.
Finally the Fourteenth Point arises again to the Great Charter
level out of this peddling with special cases.
(XIV) "A general association of nations must be formed under
specific covenants for the purpose of affording mutual guarantees
of political and territorial independence for great and small States
alike."
So far the Fourteen Points. But some of the utterances of
President Wilson after this epoch-making address went much
further and much higher than this first statement. On September
27th, 1918, at New York, he said some very important things :
"As I see it, the constitution of that League of Nations and the
clear definition of its objects must be a part, in a sense the most
essential part, of the peace settlement itself. It cannot be formed
now. If formed now, it would be merely a new alliance confined
to the nations associated against a common enemy. . . .
"But these general terms do not disclose the whole matter.
Some details are needed to make them sound less like a thesis and
more like a practical programme. These, then, are some of the
particulars, and I state them with the greater confidence because
I can state them authoritatively as representing this Government's
interpretation of its own duty with regard to peace.
"First, the impartial justice meted out must involve no discrim-
ination between those to whom we wish to be just and those to
THE CATASTROPHE OF 1914 549
whom we do not wish to be just. It must be a justice that has no
favourites and knows no standards but the equal rights of the
several peoples concerned.
"Second, no special or separate interest of any single nation or
any group of nations can be made the basis of any part of the
settlement which is not consistent with the common interest of all.
" Third, there can be no leagues or alliances or special covenants
and understandings within the general and common family of the
League of Nations.
"Fourth, and more specifically, there can be no special selfish
economic combinations within the League, and no employment of
any form of economic boycott or exclusion, except as the power of
economic penalty, by exclusion from the markets of the world,
may be vested in the League of Nations itself as a means of dis-
cipline and control.
"Fifth, all international agreements and treaties of every kind
must be made known in their entirety to the rest of the world. . . .
"In the same sentence hi which I say that the United States
will enter into no special arrangements or understandings with
particular nations, let me say also that the United States is pre-
pared to assume its full share of responsibility for the maintenance
of the common covenants and understandings upon which peace
must henceforth rest.
"We still read Washington's immortal warning against en-
tangling alliances with full comprehension and an answering pur-
pose. But only special and limited alliances entangle; and we
recognize and accept the duty of a new day in which we are per-
mitted to hope for a general alliance, which will avoid entangle-
ments and clear the air of the world for common understandings
and the maintenance of common rights."
These Fourteen Points and their significant later addenda had
an immense reception throughout the world. Here at last seemed
a peace for reasonable men everywhere, as good and acceptable to
honest and decent Germans and Russians, as to honest and decent
Frenchmen and Englishmen and Belgians ; and for some months
the whole world was lit by faith in Wilson. Could they have been
made the basis of a world settlement in 1919, they would forth-
with have opened a new and more hopeful era in human affairs.
550 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
But, as we must tell, they did not do that. There was about
President Wilson a certain narrowness of mind, a certain suspicion
of egotism; there was in the generation of people in the United
States to whom this great occasion came, a generation born in
security, reared in plenty and, so far as history goes, in ignorance,
a generation remote from the tragic issues that had made Europe
grave, a certain superficiality and lightness of mind. It was not
that the American people were superficial by nature and necessity,
but that they had never been deeply stirred by the idea of a human
community larger than their own. It was an intellectual but not
a moral conviction, with them. One had on the one hand these
new people of the new world, with their new ideas, their finer and
better ideas, of peace and world righteousness, and on the other
the old, bitter, deeply entangled peoples of the Great Power system
/ and the former were crude and rather childish in their immense
inexperience, and the latter were seasoned and bitter and intricate.
The theme of this clash of the raw idealist youthfulness of a new
age with the experienced ripeness of the old, was treated years ago
by that great novelist, Henry James, in a very typical story called
Daisy Miller. It is the pathetic story of a frank, trustful, high-
minded, but rather simple-minded American girl, with a real dis-
position towards righteousness and a great desire for a "good time"
and how she came to Europe and was swiftly entangled and put
in the wrong, and at last driven to welcome death by the complex
tortuousness and obstinate limitations of the older world. There
have been a thousand variants of that theme in real life, a thousand
such trans-Atlantic tragedies, and the story of President Wilson
is one of them. But it is not to be supposed, because the new thing
succumbs to the old infections, that is the final condemnation of
the new thing.
Probably no fallible human being manifestly trying to do his
best amidst overwhelming circumstances has been subjected to
such minute, searching, and pitiless criticism as President Wilson.
He is blamed, and it would seem that he is rightly blamed, for con-
ducting the war and the ensuing peace negotiations on strictly
party lines. He remained the President representing the American
Democratic Party, when circumstances conspired to make him
the representative of the general interests of mankind. He made
THE CATASTROPHE OF 1914
551
no attempt to forget party issues for a time, and to incorporate
with himself such great American leaders as ex-President Roose-
velt, ex-President Taft, and the like. He did not draw fully upon
the moral and intellectual resources of the States; he made the
whole issue too personal, and he
surrounded himself with merely
personal adherents. And a still
graver error was his decision to
come to the Peace Conference
himself. Nearly every experi-
enced critic seems to be of opinion
that he should have remained in
America, in the r61e of America,
speaking occasionally as if a na-
tion spoke. Throughout the con-
cluding years of the war he had
achieved an unexampled position
in the world.
President WvUotv
Says Doctor Dillon:1 "Europe, when the President touched
its shores, was as clay ready for the creative potter. Never before
were the nations so eager to follow a Moses who would take them
to the long-promised land where wars are prohibited and blockades
unknown. And to their thinking he was that great leader. In
France men bowed down before him with awe and affection. La-
bour leaders in Paris told me that they shed tears of joy in his
presence, and that their comrades would go through fire and water
to help him to realize his noble schemes. To the working classes
in Italy his name was a heavenly clarion at the sound of which the
earth would be renewed. The Germans regarded him and his
humane doctrine as their sheet-anchor of safety. The fearless
Herr Muehlon said : ' If President Wilson were to address the Ger-
mans, and pronounce a severe sentence upon them, they would
accept it with resignation and without a murmur and set to work
at once/ In German- Austria his fame was that of a saviour, and
the mere mention of his name brought balm to the suffering and
surcease of sorrow to the afflicted. . . ."
Such was the overpowering expectation of the audience to which
1 In his book, The Peace Conference.
552
THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
President Wilson prepared to show himself. He reached France
on board the George Washington in December, 1918.
He brought his wife with him. That seemed no doubt a perfectly
natural and proper thing to an American mind. Quite a number
of the American representatives brought their wives. Unhappily
a social quality, nay, almost a tourist quality, was introduced into
the world settlement by these ladies. Transport facilities were
limited, and most of them arrived in Europe with a radiant air of
privilege. They came as if they
came to a treat. They were, it
was intimated, seeing Europe
under exceptionally interesting
circumstances. They would visit
Chester, or Warwick, or Wind-
sor en route — for they might
not have a chance of seeing these
celebrated places again. Impor-
tant interviews would be broken
off to get in a visit to some "old
historical mansion." This may
seem a trivial matter to note in
a History of Mankind, but it was
such small human things as this that threw a miasma of futility
over the Peace Conference of 1919. In a little while one discovered
that Wilson, the Hope of Mankind, had vanished, and that all the
illustrated fashion papers contained pictures of a delighted tourist
and his wife, grouped smilingly with crowned heads and such-like
enviable company. ... It is so easy to be wise after the event,
and to perceive that he should not have come over.
The men he had chiefly to deal with, for example M. Clemenceau
(France), Mr. Lloyd George and Mr. Balfour (Britain), Baron
Sonnino and Signor Orlando (Italy), were men of widely dissimilar
historical traditions. But in one respect they resembled him and
appealed to his sympathies. They, too, were party politicians,
who had led their country through the war. Like himself they
had failed to grasp the necessity of entrusting the work of settle-
ment to more specially qualified men. "They were the merest
novices in international affairs. Geography, ethnology, psychol-
THE CATASTROPHE OF 1914
553
ogy, and political history were sealed books to them. Like the
Rector of Louvain University, who told Oliver Goldsmith that,
as he had become the head of that institution without knowing
Greek, he failed to see why it should be taught there, the chiefs
of State, having obtained the highest position in their respective
countries without more than an inkling of international affairs,
were unable to realize the importance of mastering them or the im-
possibility of repairing the omission as they went along. . . ." l
"What they lacked, however,
might in some perceptible degree
have been supplied by enlisting
as their helpers men more happily
endowed than themselves. But
they deliberately chose medioc-
rities. It is a mark of genial spirits
that they are well served, but
the plenipotentiaries of the Con-
ference were not characterized by
it. Away in the background some
of them had familiars or casual
prompters to whose counsels they
were wont to listen, but many of
the ad joints who moved in the limelight of the world-stage were
gritless and pithless.
"As the heads of the principal Governments implicitly claimed
to be the authorized spokesmen of the human race, and endowed
with unlimited powers, it is worth noting that this claim was boldly
challenged by the people's organs in the Press. Nearly all the
journals read by the masses objected from the first to the dictator-
ship of the group of Premiers, Mr. Wilson being excepted. . . ." 2
The restriction upon our space in this Outline will not allow us
to tell here how the Peace Conference shrank from a Council of
Ten to a Council of Four (Wilson, Clemenceau, Lloyd George, and
Orlando), and how it became a conference less and less like a frank
and open discussion of the future of mankind, and more and more
1 Dillon.
2 Dillon. And see his The Peace Conference, Chapter III, for instances of the
amazing ignorance of various delegates.
'Mr.JJloiji Gsorgc
554 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
like some old-fashioned diplomatic conspiracy. Great and wonder-
ful had been the hopes that had gathered to Paris. "The Paris
of the Conference," says Dr. Dillon, " ceased to be the capital of
France. It became a vast cosmopolitan caravanserai teeming
with unwonted aspects of life and turmoil, filled with curious
samples of the races, tribes, and tongues of four continents who
came to watch and wait for the mysterious to-morrow.
"An Arabian Nights' touch was imparted to the dissolving pan-
orama by strange visitants from Tartary and Kurdistan, Corea
and Aderbeijan, Armenia, Persia, and the Hedjaz — men with
patriarchal beards and scimitar-shaped noses, and others from
desert and oasis, from Samarkand and Bokhara. Turbans and
fezzes, sugar-loaf hats and head-gear resembling episcopal mitres,
old military uniforms devised for the embryonic armies of new
states on the eve of perpetual peace, snowy-white burnouses, flow-
ing mantles, and graceful garments like the Roman toga, contrib-
uted to create an atmosphere of dreamy unreality in the city
where the grimmest of realities were being faced and coped with.
"Then came the men of wealth, of intellect, of industrial enter-
prise, and the seed-bearers of the ethical new ordering, members
of economic committees from the United States, Britain, Italy,
Poland, Russia, India, and Japan, representatives of naphtha in-
dustries and far-off coal mines, pilgrims, fanatics and charlatans
from all climes, priests of all religions, preachers of every doctrine,
who mingled with princes, field-marshals, statesmen, anarchists,
builders-up and pullers-down. All of them burned with desire
to be near to the crucible in which the political and social systems
of the world were to be melted and recast. Every day, in my walks
in my apartment, or at restaurants, I met emissaries from lands
and peoples whose very names had seldom been heard of before
in the West. A delegation from the Pont-Euxine Greeks called
on me, and discoursed of their ancient cities of Trebizond, Sam-
soun, Tripoli, Kerassund, in which I resided many years ago, and
informed me that they, too, desired to become welded into an in-
dependent Greek Republic, and had come to have their claims
allowed. The Albanians were represented by my old friend Tur-
khan Pasha, on the one hand, and by my friend Essad Pasha on the
other — the former desirous of Italy's protection, the latter de-
THE CATASTROPHE OF 1914 555
manding complete independence. Chinamen, Japanese, Coreans,
Hindus, Kirghizes, Lesghiens, Circassians, Mingrelians, Buryats,
Malays, and Negroes and Negroids from Africa and America were
among the tribes and tongues foregathered in Paris to watch the
rebuilding of the political world system and to see where they
'came in.' . . ."
To this thronging, amazing Paris, agape for a new world, came
President Wilson, and found its gathering forces dominated by a
personality narrower, in every way more limited and beyond com-
parison more forcible than himself: the French Premier, M.
Clemenceau. At the instance of President Wilson, M. Clemenceau
was elected President of the Conference. "It was," said President
Wilson, "a special tribute to the sufferings and sacrifices of France."
And that, unhappily, sounded the keynote of the Conference,
whose sole business should have been with the future of mankind.
Georges Benjamin Clemenceau l was an old journalist politician,
a great denouncer of abuses, a great upsetter of governments, a
doctor who had, while a municipal councillor, kept a free clinic,
and a fierce, experienced duellist. None of his duels ended fatally,
but he faced them with great intrepidity. He had passed from
the medical school to republican journalism in the days of the Em-
pire. In those days he was an extremist of the left. He was for
a time a teacher in America, and he married and divorced an
American wife. He was thirty in the eventful year 1871. He
returned to France after Sedan, and flung himself into the stormy
politics of the defeated nation with great fire and vigour. There-
after France was his world, the France of vigorous journalism,
high-spirited personal quarrels, challenges, confrontations, scenes,
dramatic effects, and witticisms at any cost. He was what people
call "fierce stuff," he was nicknamed the "Tiger," and he seems to
have been rather proud of his nickname. Professional patriot
rather than statesman and thinker, this was the man whom the
war had flung up to misrepresent the fine mind and the generous
spirit of France.2 His limitations had a profound effect upon the
1 See Clemenceau, by C. Ducray.
2 He wrote several novels. They are not very good novels ; they incline to
sentimental melodrama. Le Plus Fort is now available to English readers in a trans-
lation under the title of "The Stronger." It is tawdry and dull. A cinematograph
version has been shown.*
556 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
conference, which was further coloured by the dramatic resort
for the purpose of signature to the very Hall of Mirrors at Ver-
sailles in which Germany had triumphed and proclaimed her unity.
There the Germans were to sign. To M. Clemenceau and to
France, in that atmosphere, the war ceased to seem a world war ;
it was merely the sequel of the previous conflict of the Terrible
Year, the downfall and punishment of offending Germany. "The
world had to be made safe for democracy," said President Wilson.
That from M. Clemenceau's expressed point of view was " talking
like Jesus Christ." The world had to be made safe for Paris.
" Talking like Jesus Christ " seemed a very ridiculous thing to
many of those brilliant rather than sound diplomatists and poli-
ticians who made the year 1919 supreme in the history of human
insufficiency.
(Another flash of the "Tiger's" wit, it may be noted, was that
President Wilson with his fourteen points was "worse" than God
Almighty. "Le bon Dieu" only had ten. . . .)
M. Clemenceau sat with Signor Orlando in the more central chairs
of a semicircle of four in front of the fire, says Keynes. He wore
a black frock-coat and grey suede gloves, which he never removed
during these sessions. He was, it is to be noted, the only one of
these four reconstructors of the world who could understand and
speak both French and English.
The aims of M. Clemenceau were simple and in a manner at-
tainable. He wanted all the settlement of 1871 undone. He
wanted Germany punished as though she was a uniquely sinful
nation and France a sinless martyr land. He wanted Germany so
crippled and devastated as never more to be able to stand up to
France. He wanted to hurt and humiliate Germany more than
France had been hurt and humiliated in 1871. He did not care
if in breaking Germany Europe was broken ; his mind did not go
far enough beyond the Rhine to understand that possibility. He
accepted President Wilson's League of Nations as an excellent
proposal if it would guarantee the security of France whatever
she did, but he preferred a binding alliance of the United States
and England to maintain, uphold, and glorify France under prac-
tically any circumstances. He wanted wider opportunities for
the exploitation of Syria, north Africa, and so forth by Parisian
?THE CATASTROPHE OF 1914 557
financial groups. He wanted indemnities to recuperate France,
loans, gifts, and tributes to France, glory and homage to France.
France had suffered, and France had to be rewarded. Belgium,
Russia, Serbia, Poland, Armenia, Britain, Germany, and Austria
had all suffered too, all mankind had suffered, but what would you ?
that was not his affair. These were the supers of a drama in which
France was for him the star. ... In much the same spirit Signor
Orlando seems to have sought the welfare of Italy.
Mr. Lloyd George brought to the Council of Four the subtlety
of a Welshman, the intricacy of a European, and an urgent neces-
sity for respecting the nationalist egotism of the British imperialists
and capitalists who had returned him to power. Into the secrecy
of that council went President Wilson (leaving Point I at the door)
with the very noblest aims for his newly discovered American
world policy, his rather hastily compiled Fourteen (now reduced to
Thirteen) Points, and a project rather than a scheme for a League
of Nations.
The Second Point was presently observed to be missing. It may
have fallen into the Atlantic on the way over. It may have been
thrown into the sea as an offering to the British Admiralty.
"There can seldom have been a statesman of the first rank more
incompetent than the President in the agilities of the Council
Chamber." * From the whispering darknesses and fireside dis-
putes of that council, and after various comings and goings we
cannot here describe, he emerged at last with his Fourteen Points
pitifully torn and dishevelled, but with a little puling infant of a
League of Nations, which might die or which might live and grow
— no one could tell. This history cannot tell. We are at the end of
our term. But that much, at least, he had saved. . . .
Let us now consider briefly this Covenant of the League of Na-
tions, and recapitulate the terms of the quasi-settlement of the
world's affairs of 1919-20; and let us indicate here and there
where the latter departs from the promised standard of the Four-
teen Points, and where it is most dangerous to the future peace and
most manifestly contrary to the welfare of mankind. Because
just as the history of Europe in the nineteenth century was largely
the undoing of the Treaty of Vienna, and as the Great War was
1 Keynes,
558 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
the necessary outcome of the Treaty of Frankfort and the Treaty
of Berlin, so the general history of the twentieth century hence-
forth will be largely the amendment or reversal of the more un-
generous and unscientific arrangements of the Treaty of 1919,
and a struggle to establish those necessary impartial world con-
trols of which the League of Nations is the first insufficient and
unsatisfactory sketch.
§12
This homunculus in a bottle which it was hoped might become
at last Man ruling the Earth, this League of Nations as it was
embodied in the Covenant of April 28th, 1919, was not a league of
peoples at all; it was a league of " states, dominions, or colonies."
It was stipulated that these should be " fully self-governing," but
there was no definition whatever of this phrase. There was no
bar to a limited franchise and no provision for any direct control
by the people of any state. India figured — presumably as a
"fully self-governing state !" An autocracy would no doubt have
been admissible as a " fully self -go verning " democracy with a
franchise limited to one person. The League of the Covenant of
1919 was, in fact, a league of " representatives " of foreign offices,
and it did not even abolish the nonsense of embassies at every
capital. The British Empire appeared once as a whole, and then
India ( !) and the four dominions of Canada, Australia, South
Africa, and New Zealand appeared as separate sovereign states.
The Indian representative was, of course, sure to be merely a
British nominee; the other four would be colonial politicians.
But if the British Empire was to be thus dissected, a representative
of Great Britain should have been substituted for the Imperial
representative, and Ireland and Egypt should also have been given
representation. Moreover, either New York State or Virginia was
historically and legally almost as much a sovereign state as New
Zealand or Canada. The inclusion of India raised logical claims
for French Africa and French Asia. One French representative
did propose a separate vote for the little principality of Monaco.
There was to be an assembly of the League in which every mem-
ber state was to be represented and to have an equal voice, but
the working directorate of the league was to vest in a Council,
THE CATASTROPHE OF 1914 559
which was to consist of the representatives of the United States,
Britain, France, Italy, and Japan, with four other members elected
by the Assembly. The Council was to meet once a year ; the
gatherings of the Assembly were to be at " stated intervals," not
stated.
Except in certain specified instances the league of this Covenant
could make only unanimous decisions. One dissentient on the
council could bar any proposal — on the lines of the old Polish
liberum veto (chapter xxxvi, § 7). This was a quite disastrous
provision. To many minds it made the Covenant League rather
less desirable than no league at all. It was a complete recognition
of the unalienable sovereignty of states, and a repudiation of the
idea of an over-riding commonweal of mankind. This provision
practically barred the way to all amendments to the league con-
stitution in future except by the clumsy expedient of a simultaneous
withdrawal of the majority of member states desiring a change,
to form the league again on new lines. The covenant made in-
evitable such a final winding-up of the league it created, and that
was perhaps the best thing about it.
The following powers, it was proposed, should be excluded from
the original league : Germany, Austria, Russia, and whatever re-
mains there were of the Turkish Empire. But any of these might
subsequently be included with the assent of two thirds of the
Assembly. The original membership of the league as specified
in the projected Covenant was : the United States of America,
Belgium, Bolivia, Brazil, the British Empire (Canada, Australia,
South Africa, New Zealand, and India), China, Cuba, Ecuador,
France, Greece, Guatemala, Haiti, the Hedjas, Honduras, Italy,
Japan, Liberia, Nicaragua, Panama, Peru, Poland, Portugal, Ru-
mania, the Serb-Croat-Slovene State, Siam, Czecho-Slovakia, and
Uruguay. To which were to be added by invitation the following
powers which had been neutral in the war : the Argentine Republic,
Chile, Colombia, Denmark, Holland, Norway, Paraguay, Persia,
Salvador, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, and Venezuela.
Such being the constitution of the league, it is scarcely to be
wondered at that its powers were special and limited. It was given
a seat at Geneva and a secretariat. It had no powers even to inspect
the military preparations of its constituent states, or to instruct
560 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
a military and naval staff to plan out the armed co-operation needed
to keep the peace of the world. The French representative in the
League of Nations Commission, M. Leon Bourgeois, insisted lucidly
and repeatedly on the logical necessity of such powers. As a
speaker he was rather copious and lacking in " spice" of the Cle-
menceau quality . The final scene in the plenary session of April 28th,
before the adoption of the Covenant, is described compactly by
Mr. Wilson Harris, the crowded Banqueting Hall at the Quai
d'Orsay, with its "E" of tables for the delegates, with secretaries
and officials lining the walls and a solid mass of journalists at the
lower end of the room. "At the head of the room the 'Big Three*
diverted themselves in undertones at the expense of the worthy M.
Bourgeois, now launched, with the help of what must have been
an entirely superfluous sheaf of notes, on the fifth rendering of his
speech in support of his famous amendments."
They were so often " diverting themselves in undertones," those
three men whom God had mocked with the most tremendous
opportunity in history. Keynes (op. tit.) gives other instances
of the levities, vulgarities, disregards, inattentions, and inadequa-
cies of these meetings.
This poor Covenant arrived at in this fashion returned with
President Wilson to America, and there it was subjected to an
amount of opposition, criticism, and revision which showed, among
other things, how relatively unimpaired was the mental energy of
the United States. It was manifest that the people of America had
no mind to a compact that was virtually little more than a league
of allied imperialisms for mutual insurance. The Senate refused
to ratify the covenant, and the first meeting of the League Council
was held therefore without American representatives. The close
of 1919 and the opening months of 1920 saw a very curious change
come over American feeling after the pro-French and pro-British
enthusiasms of the war period. The peace negotiations reminded
the Americans, in a confused and very irritating way, of their pro-
found differences in international outlook from any European
power that the war had for a time helped them to forget. They
felt they had been "rushed" into many things without due con-
sideration. They experienced a violent revulsion towards that
policy of isolation that had broken down in 1917. The close of
THE CATASTROPHE OF 1914
561
2o
562 , THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
1919 saw a phase, a very understandable phase, of passionate and
even violent " Americanism/7 in which European imperialism and
European socialism were equally anathema. There may have
been a sordid element in the American disposition to "cut" the
moral responsibilities the United States had incurred in the affairs
of the Old World, and to realize the enormous financial and political
advantages the war had given the new world ; but the broad in-
stinct of the American people seems to have been sound in its dis-
trust of the proposed settlement.
§13
The main terms of the Treaties of 1919-20 with which the Con-
ference of Paris concluded its labours can be stated much more
vividly by a few maps than by a written abstract. We need
scarcely point out how much those treaties left unsettled, but we
may perhaps enumerate some of the more salient breaches of the
Twelve that survived out of the Fourteen Points at the opening
of the Conference.
One initial cause of nearly all those breaches lay, we believe,
in the complete unpreparedness and unwillingness of that pre-
existing league of nations, subjected states and exploited areas,
the British Empire, to submit to any dissection and adaptation of
its system or to any control of its naval and aerial armament. A
kindred contributory cause was the equal unpreparedness of the
American mind for any interference with the ascendancy of the
United States in the New World (compare Secretary Olney's
declaration in this chapter, § 6). Neither of those Great Powers,
who were necessarily dominant and leading Powers at Paris, had
properly thought out the implications of a League of Nations in
relation to these older arrangements, and so their support of that
project had to most European observers a curiously hypocritical
air ; it was as if they wished to retain and ensure their own vast
predominance and security while at the same time restraining any
other power from such expansions, annexations, and alliances as
might create a rival and competitive imperialism. Their failure
to set an example of international confidence destroyed all possi-
bility of international confidence in the other nations represented
at Paris.
THE CATASTROPHE OF 1914
563
564 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
Even more unfortunate was the refusal of the Americans to
assent to the Japanese demand for a recognition of racial equality.
Moreover, the foreign offices of the British, the French, and the
Italians were haunted by traditional schemes of aggression entirely
incompatible with the new ideas. A League of Nations that is to
be of any appreciable value to mankind must supersede imperial-
isms; it is either a super-imperialism, a liberal world-empire of
united states, participant or in tutelage, or it is nothing ; but few
of the people at the Paris Conference had the mental vigour even
to assert this obvious consequence of the League proposal. They
wanted to be at the same time bound and free, to ensure peace for
ever, but to keep their weapons in their hands. Accordingly the
old annexation projects of the Great Power period were hastily and
thinly camouflaged as proposed acts of this poor little birth of
April 28th. The newly born and barely animate League was
represented to be distributing, with all the reckless munificence •/
of a captive pope, " mandates " to the old imperialisms that, had
it been the young Hercules we desired, it would certainly have
strangled in its cradle. Britain was to have extensive "mandates"
in Mesopotamia and East Africa ; France was to have the same in
Syria ; Italy was to have all her holdings to the west and south-
east of Egypt consolidated as mandatory territory. Clearly, if
the weak thing that was being nursed by its Secretary in its cradle
at Geneva into some semblance of life, did presently succumb to
the infantile weakness of all institutions born without passion,
all these " mandates" would become frank annexations. More-
over, all the powers fought tooth and nail at the Conference for
" strategic" frontiers — the ugliest symptom of all. Why should
a state want a strategic frontier unless it contemplates war? If
on that plea Italy insisted upon a subject population of Germans in
the southern Tyrol and a subject population of Yugo-Slavs in
Dalmatia, and if little Greece began landing troops in Asia Minor,
neither France nor Britain was in a position to rebuke these out-
breaks of pre-millennial method.
We will not enter here into any detailed account of how Presi-
dent Wilson gave way to the Japanese and consented to their re-
placing the Germans at Kiau Chau, which is Chinese property,
how the almost purely German city of Dantzig was practically, if
THE CATASTROPHE OP 1914
565
566 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
not legally, annexed to Poland, and how the powers disputed over
the claims of the Italian imperialists, a claim strengthened by these
instances, to seize the Yugo-Slav part of Fiume and deprive the
Yugo-Slavs of a good Adriatic outlet. Nor will we do more than
note the complex arrangements and justifications that put the
French in possession of the Saar valley, which is German territory,
or the entirely iniquitous breach of the right of " self-determination"
which practically forbade German Austria to unite — as it is
natural and proper that she should unite — with the rest of Ger-
many. These burning questions of 1919-20, which occupied the
newspapers and the minds of statesmen and politicians, and filled
all our waste paper baskets with propaganda literature, may seem
presently very incidental things in the larger movement of these
times. All these disputes, like the suspicions and tetchy injustices
of a weary and irritated man, may lose their importance as the
tone of the world improves, and the still inadequately apprehended
lessons of the Great War and the Petty Peace that followed it be-
gin to be digested by the general intelligence of mankind.
It is worth while for the reader to compare the treaty maps we give
with what we have called the natural political map of Europe. The
new arrangements do approach this latter more closely than any pre-
vious system of boundaries. It may be a necessary preliminary to
any satisfactory league of peoples, that each people should first be
in something like complete possession of its own household.
It is absurd to despair of mankind because of these treaties, or
to regard them as anything more than feeble first sketches of a
world settlement. To do so would be to suppose that there is
nothing in France — that land of fine imaginations — better than
M. Clemenceau, nothing in America stronger and wiser than Presi-
dent Wilson, and nothing in Britain to steady the Keltic traits of
Mr. Lloyd George. The attention we have given to these three
personalities in this Outline is intended less to enhance their impor-
tance than to emphasize their unimportance, and to make it clear
to the reader how provisional and incidental all that they did must
be in the world's affairs. On no statesmen, on no particular men
or groups of men, on no state or organization indeed, and on no
Covenant or Treaty, does the future of our race now depend. The
year 1919 was not a year of creation and decision, it was just the
THE CATASTROPHE OF 1914 567
first cheerless dawn of a long day of creative effort. The confer-
ences of the Ten, of the Four, of the Big Three, had no trace of
creative power ; there was no light in the men of Versailles ; the
dawn was manifest rather as a grey light of critical disapproval
that broke through the shutters and staled the guttering candles
of the old diplomacy as the conference yawned and drawled to its
end. Creation was not there. But a great process of thought
spreads throughout the world ; many thousands of men and women,
in every country, for the most part undistinguished and unknown
people, are awakening to their responsibility, are studying, thinking,
writing, and teaching, getting together, correcting false impressions,
challenging foolish ideas, trying to find out and tell the truth ; and
upon them it is that we must rest our hope, such hope as we can
entertain, of a saner plan to take the place of this first flimsy League
and this patched and discomforting garment of treaties that has
been flung for a while over the naked distresses of our world.
§14
The failure to produce a more satisfactory world settlement in
1919-20 was, we have suggested, a symptom of an almost universal
intellectual and moral lassitude, resulting from the overstrain of
the Great War. A lack of fresh initiative is characteristic of a
fatigue phase ; everyone, from sheer inability to change, drifts on
for a time along the lines of mental habit and precedent.
Nothing could be more illustrative of this fatigue inertia than
the expressed ideas of military men at this time. It will round off
this chapter in an entirely significant way, and complete our picture
of the immense world interrogation on which our history must end,
if we give here the briefest summary of a lecture that was delivered
to a gathering of field-marshals, generals, major-generals, and the
like by Major-General Sir Louis Jackson, at the Royal United Ser-
vice Institution in London one day in December, 1919. Lord Peel,
the British Under-Secretary for War, presided, and the reader
must picture to himself the not too large and quite dignified room
of assembly in that building, and all these fine, grave, soldierly
figures quietly intent upon the lecturer's words. He is describing,
with a certain subdued enthusiasm, the probable technical develop-
ments of military method in the "next war."
568 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
Outside, through the evening twilight of Whitehall, flows the
London traffic, not quite so abundant as in 1914, but still fairly
abundant ; the omnibuses all overcrowded because there are now
not nearly enough of them, and the clothing of people generally
shabbier. Some little way down Whitehall is a temporary erection,
the Cenotaph, with its base smothered with a vast, pathetic heap
of decaying wreaths, bunches of flowers, and the like, a cenotaph
to commemorate the eight hundred thousand young men of the
Empire who have been killed in the recent struggle. A few people
are putting fresh flowers and wreaths there. One or two are crying.
The prospect stretches out beyond this gathering into the grey
vastness of London, where people are now crowded as they have
never been crowded before, whose food is dear and employment
more uncertain than it has ever been. But let not the spectacle
be one of unrelieved gloom; Regent Street, Oxford Street, and
Bond Street are bright with shoppers and congested with new
automobiles, because we must remember that everybody does not
lose by a war. Beyond London the country sinks into night, and
across the narrow sea are North France and Belgium devastated,
Germany with scores of thousands of her infants dwindling and
dying for want of milk, all Austria starving. Half the population
of Vienna, it is believed, unless American relief comes quickly, is
doomed to die of hardship before the spring. Beyond that bleak
twilight stretches the darkness of Russia. There, at least, no rich
people are buying anything, and no military men are reading essays
on the next war. But in icy Petrograd is little food, little wood,
and no coal. All the towns of Russia southward as far as the snow
reaches are in a similar plight, and in the Ukraine and to the south
a ragged and dingy war drags to its end. Europe is bankrupt, and
people's pockets rustle with paper money whose purchasing power
dwindles as they walk about with it.
But now we will return to Sir Louis in the well-lit room at the
United Service Institution.
He was of opinion — we follow the report in next morning's
Times l — that we were merely on the eve of the most extensive
modifications of the art of war known to history. It behoved us,
1 Checked by subsequent comparison with the published article in the Jour,
of the Roy. United Service Institution, vol. Ixv., No. 457, February, 1920.
THE CATASTROPHE OF 1914 569
therefore — us being, of course, the British and not the whole of
mankind — to get on with our armaments and to keep ahead ; a
fine opening generalization. "It was necessary to develop new
arms. . . . The nation which best did so would have a great ad-
vantage in the next war. There were people who were crying
aloud for a reduction of. armaments "
(But there the Director of Trench Warfare and Supplies was
wrong. They were just crying at the cenotaph, poor, soft, and
stupid souls, because a son or a brother or a father was dead.)
Sir Louis believed that one of the greatest developments in the
art of warfare would be brought about in mechanical transport.
The tank he treated with ingratitude. These military gentlemen
are ungrateful to an invention which shoved and butted them into
victory almost in spite of themselves. The tank, said Sir Louis,
was "a freak. . . . The outstanding feature" of the tank, he
said, was that it made mechanical transport independent of the
roads. Hitherto armies on the march had only been able to spoil
the roads; now their transport on caterpillar wheels would ad-
vance in open order on a broad front carrying guns, munitions,
supplies, bridging equipment, rafts, and men — and incidentally
ploughing up and destroying hedges, ditches, fields, and cultiva-
tion generally. Armies would wallow across the country, leaving
nothing behind but dust and mud.
So our imaginations are led up to the actual hostilities.
Sir Louis was in favour of gas. For punitive expeditions par-
ticularly, gas was to be recommended. And here he startled and
disconcerted his hearers by a gleam of something approaching
sentimentality. "It might be possible," he said, "to come to some
agreement that no gas should be used which caused unnecessary
suffering." But there his heart spoke rather than his head; it
should have been clear to him that if law can so far override war-
fare as to prohibit any sort of evil device whatever, it can override
warfare to the extent of prohibiting it altogether. And where
would Sir Louis Jackson and his audience be then? War is war;
its only law is the law that the maximum destruction of the forces
of the enemy is necessary. To that law in warfare all considera-
tions of humanity and justice are subordinate.
From gas Sir Louis passed to the air. Here he predicted "most
570 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
important advances. . . . We need not trouble ourselves yet
with flying destroyers or flying concrete forts, but in twenty years'
time the Air Force Estimates might be the most important part
of our preparations for war." He discussed the conversion of
commercial flying machines to bombing and reconnaissance uses,
and the need for special types of fighting machine in considerable
numbers and always ready. He gave reasons for supposing that
the bombers in the next war would not have the same targets
near the front of the armies, and would secure better results by
going further afield and bombing the centres "where stores are
being manufactured and troops trained." As everyone who
stayed in London or the east of England in 1917-18 knows, this
means the promiscuous bombing of any and every centre of
population. But, of course, the bombing of those 'prentice days
would be child's play to the bombing of the "next war." There
would be countless more aeroplanes, bigger and much nastier
bombs. . . .
Sir Louis, proceeding with his sketch, mentioned the "destruc-
tion of the greater part of London" as a possible incident in the
coming struggle. And so on to the culminating moral, that the
highest pay, the utmost importance, the freest expenditure, must
be allowed to military gentlemen. "The expense entailed is in
the nature of an absolutely necessary insurance." With which
his particular audience warmly agreed. And a certain Major-
General Stone, a little forgetful of the source of his phrases,1 said
he hoped that this lecture "may be the beginning not of trusting
in the League of Nations, but in our own right hand and our
stretched-out arm !"
But we will not go on with the details of this dream. For in-
deed no Utopia was ever so impossible as this forecast of a world
in which scarcely anything but very carefully sandbagged and ca-
mouflaged G. H. Q. would be reasonably safe, in which countless
bombers would bomb the belligerent lands incessantly and great
armies with lines of caterpillar transport roll to and fro, churning
the fields of the earth into blood-streaked mud. There is not energy
enough and no will whatever left in the world for such things.
Generals who cannot foresee tanks cannot be expected to foresee
1 Cp. Psalm cxxxvi.
THE CATASTROPHE OP 1914 571
or understand world bankruptcy ; still less are they likely to under-
stand the limits imposed upon military operations by the fluctuat-
ing temper of the common man. Apparently these military au-
thorities of the United Service Institution did not even know that
warfare aims at the production of states of mind in the enemy,
and is sustained by states of mind. The chief neglected factor in
the calculations of Sir Louis is the fact that no people whatever
will stand such warfare as he contemplates, not even the people
on the winning side. For as northern France, south-eastern Brit-
ain, and north Italy now understand, the victor in the "next war"
may be bombed and starved almost as badly as the loser. A phase
is possible in which a war-tormented population may cease to
discriminate between military gentlemen on this side or that, and
may be moved to destroy them as the common enemies of the
race. The Great War of 1914-18 was the culmination of the mili-
tary energy of the western populations, and they fought and fought
well because they believed they were fighting "the war to end war."
They were. German imperialism, with its organized grip upon
education and its close alliance with an aggressive commercialism,
was beaten and finished. The militarism and imperialism of Brit-
ain and France and Italy are by comparison feeble, disorganized,
and disorganizing survivals. They are things "left over" by the
great war. They have no persuasive power. They go on — for
sheer want of wits to leave off. No European Government will
ever get the same proportion of its people into the ranks and into
its munition works again as the governments of 1914-18 did. Our
world is very weak and feeble still (1920), but its war fever is over.
Its temperature is, if anything, sub-normal. It is doubtful if it
will take the fever again for a long time. The alterations in the
conditions of warfare are already much profounder than such au-
thorities as Sir Louis Jackson suspect.1
1 Here is another glimpse of the agreeable dreams that fill the contemporary
military mind. It is from Fuller's recently published Tanks in the Great War.
Colonel Fuller does not share that hostility to tanks characteristic of the older type
of soldier. In the next war, he tells us: "Fast-moving tanks, equipped with tons
of liquid gas . . . will cross the frontier and obliterate every living thing in the
fields and farms, the villages, and cities of the enemy's country. Whilst life is
being swept away around the frontier, fleets of aeroplanes will attack the enemy's
great industrial and governing centres. All these attacks will be made, at first,
572 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
§15
This Outline of our history would not be complete without at
least a few words by way of a stock-taking of the state of mind
in which we leave mankind to-day. For the history of our race
for the last few thousand years is no more than a history of the
development and succession of states of mind and of acts arising
out of them. Human history is in essence a history of ideas,
and these tremendous experiences of the war constitute a crowning
epoch. In the past six years there must have been a destruction
of fixed ideas, prejudices, and mental limitations unparalleled in
all history. Never before can there have been so great and so
universal an awakening from assumed and accepted things. Never
before have men stood so barely face to face with the community
of their interests and their common destiny. We do not begin to
realize yet how much of the pre-war world is done with for good
and all, and how much that is new is beginning. Few of us have
attempted to measure yet the change in our own minds.
And on the whole and in spite of much eddying and backwash
of motives and thought, there does seem to have been a step for-
ward towards the consciousness of a collective need and of the
possibility of a collective effort embracing all mankind. Death,
waste, hunger, and disease are very rife to-day; the world is full
of physical evils, but there is this mental awakening to set against
them.
In all material things the year 1913 seems now, to a European
at least, a year of amazing and unattainable plenty. But it was
a year of great social discontent and of waste, of vice and an ex-
travagant search for personal indulgence on the part of the free and
wealthy classes. The Great War was visibly approaching; yet
there was neither will nor understanding to prevent the catas-
trophe ; smart and fashionable life capered to nigger dance tunes,
and that hectic generation was disposed to welcome even a universal
war as a fresh and crowning excitement. War did not seem real
to the moods of that time ; nothing seemed real to the moods of
not against the enemy's army . . . but against the civil population, in order to
compel it to accept the will of the attacker."
For a good, w|||l-£>alanced account of what modern war really means, see Philip
Gibbs, Realities of War, already cited in <wo footnotes to § 8.
' THE CATASTROPHE OF 1914 573
that time. It was a world of lost or faded beliefs. It did not be-
lieve even in the florid nationalisms and imperialisms which waved
their flags and filled half the world with the stir and glitter of great
armies. But it set itself in the form of these things because they
trampled and glittered very entertainingly and because they prom-
ised sensational adventures. The catastrophe of the war was not
an unnecessary disaster ; it was a necessary fulfilment of such an
age of drift. Only through a catastrophe, it may be, could a new
phase of human thought and will have become possible.
This graver world of 1920 does seem to be awakening to the truth
that there are realities worth seeking and evils not to be tolerated.
The mental and moral backgrounds of hundreds of millions of
minds have been altered and are being altered by the stern lessons of
this age. Brotherhood through sorrow, sorrow for common suffer-
ings and for irreparable mutual injuries, is spreading and increasing
throughout the world. There are no doubt great countervailing
evils, a wild scramble for the diminishing surplus of wealth, a
propaganda, but a failing propaganda, of division and hatred.
The dominating fact, nevertheless, is a new sanity. . . .
(What a wonderful and moving spectacle is this of our kind to-
day ! Would that we could compress into one head and for the use
of one right hand the power of ten thousand novelists and play-
wrights and biographers and the quintessence of a thousand his-
tories, to render the endless variety, the incessant multitudinous
adventure, and at the same time the increasing unity of this dis-
play. Everywhere, with a mysterious individual difference, we
see youth growing to adolescence and the interplay of love, desire,
curiosities, passionate impulses, rivalries. As the earth spins
from darkness into the light, the millions wake again to a new day
in their life of toil, anxiety, little satisfactions, little chagrins,
rivalries, spites, generosities. From tropic to the bleakest north,
the cocks crow before the advancing margin of dawn. The early
toiler hurries to his work, the fox and the thief slink home, the
tramp stretches his stiff limbs under the haystack, and springs up
alert before the farmer's man discovers him, the ploughman is al-
ready in the field with his horses, the fires are lit in the cottage and
the kettle sings. The hours warm as the day advances; the
crowded trains converge upon the city centres, the_traffic thickens
574 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
in the streets, the breakfast-table of the prosperous home is spread,
the professor begins his lecture, the shop assistants greet their
first customers. . . . Outwardly it is very like the world before
the war. And yet it is profoundly different. The sense of in-
evitable routines that held all the world in thrall six years ago has
gone. And the habitual assurance of security has gone too. The
world 'has been roused — for a time at least — to great dangers
and great desires. These minds, this innumerable multitude of
minds, are open to fresh ideas of association and duty and relation-
ship as they were never open before. The old confused and di-
vided world is condemned; it is going on provisionally under a
sentence of great and as yet incalculable change.
Every one of these hundred of millions of human beings is in
some form seeking happiness, is driven by complex and conflicting
motives, is guided by habits, is swayed by base cravings, by end-
less suggestions, by passions and affections, by vague exalted ideas.
Every one of them is capable of cruelties and fine emotions, of
despairs and devotions and self-forgetful effort. All of them for-
get ; all of them become slack with fatigue and fearful or mean or
incapable under a sufficient strain. The follies of vanity entrap
them all into absurdities. Not one is altogether noble nor alto-
gether trustworthy nor altogether consistent ; and not one is alto-
gether vile. Every one of them can be unhappy, every one can
feel disappointment and remorse. Not a single one but has at
some time wept. And in every one of them is a streak of divinity.
Each one for all the obsessions of self is yet dimly aware of some-
thing in common, of something that could make a unity out of our
infinite diversity. And they are everyone more aware of this than
in 1913. Through all the world grows the realization that there
can be no securely happy individual life without a righteous general
life. Through all the world spreads the suspicion that this scheme
of things might be remade, and remade better, and that our present
evils need not be. Our lives, we see with a p rowing certitude, are
fretted and shadowed and spoilt because there is as yet no world-
wide law, no certain justice. Yet there is nothing absolutely un-
attainable in world law and world justice. More men are capable
of realizing this than was ever possible at any previous time. And
to be aware of a need is to be half-way towards its satisfaction.
THE CATASTROPHE OF 1914 575
We call this stir towards a new order, this refusal to drift on in the
old directions, unrest, but rather is it hope which disturbs the
world.
What real driving force is there in all this aspiration towards
a new and wider order? What directive forces are these stirring
millions likely to encounter? What accidents and subtle sugges-
tions may not waylay them and cheat them? An age is closing
and an age begins. This chapter of history which tells of the
Great Powers into which Christendom broke up and of the un-
bridled national and individual self-seeking which ensued, has cul-
minated in a world catastrophe and is at its end. What will be the
next stage in history?
. /v
4
" , ***
b
^
BOOK IX
THE NEXT STAGE IN HISTORY
XLI
THE POSSIBLE UNIFICATION OF THE WORLD INTO
ONE COMMUNITY OF KNOWLEDGE AND WILL
§ 1. The Possible Unification of Men's Wills in Political Matters.
§ 2. How a Federal World Government may come about. § 3.
Some Fundamental Characteristics of a Modern World State.
§ 4. What this World might be were it under one Law and
Justice. § 5. The Stages Beyond.
§1
\\ 7E have brought this Outline of History up to our own times,
V V but we have brought it to no conclusion. It breaks off ^
at a dramatic phase of expectation. The story of life which be-
gan inestimable millions of years ago, the adventure of mankind
which was already afoot half a million years ago, rises to a crisis
in the immense interrogation of to-day. The drama becomes our-
selves. It is you, it is I, it is all that is happening to us and all
that we are doing which will supply the next chapter of this con-
tinually expanding adventure.
Our history has traced a steady growth of the social and political
units into which men have combined. In the brief period of ten
thousand years these units have grown from the small family
tribe of the early neolithic culture to the vast united realms —
vast yet still too small and partial — of the present time. And
this change in size of the state — a change manifestly incomplete
- has been accompanied by profound changes in its nature. Com-
pulsion and servitude have given way to ideas of associated free-
dom, and the sovereignty that was once concentrated in an auto-
cratic king and god has been widely diffused throughout the com-
579
580 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
munity. Until the Roman republic extended itself to all Italy,
there had been no free community larger than a city state; all
great communities were communities of obedience under a monarch.
The great united republic of the United States would have been
impossible before the printing press and the railway. The tele-
graph and telephone, the aeroplane, the continual progress of land
and sea transit, are now insisting upon a still larger political
organization.
If our Outline has been faithfully drawn, and if these brief con-
clusions are sound, it follows that we are engaged upon an immense
task of adjustment to these great lines upon which our affairs are
moving. Our wars, our social conflict, our enormous economic
stresses, are all aspects of that adjustment. The loyalties and
allegiances to-day are at best provisional loyalties and allegiances.
Our true State, this state that is already beginning, this state to
which every man owes his utmost political effort, must be now
this nascent Federal World State to which human necessities point.
Our true God now is the God of all men. Nationalism as a God
must follow the tribal gods to limbo. Our true nationality is
mankind.
How far will modern men lay hold upon and identify themselves
with this necessity and set themselves to revise their ideas, remake
their institutions, and educate the coming generations to this final
extension of citizenship? How far will they remain dark, ob-
durate, habitual, and traditional, resisting the convergent forces
that offer them either unity or misery ? Sooner or later that unity
must come or else plainly men must perish by their own inventions.
We, because we believe in the power of reason and in the increas-
ing good-will in men, find ourselves compelled to reject the latter
possibility. But the way to the former may be very long and te-
dious, very tragic and wearisome, a martyrdom of many genera-
tions, or it may be travelled over almost swiftly in the course of a
generation or so. That depends upon forces whose nature we
understand to some extent now, but not their power. There has
to be a great process of education, by precept and by information
and by experience, but there are as yet no quantitative meas-
ures of education to tell us how much has to be learnt or how
soon that learning can be done. Our estimates vary with our
UNIFICATION OF THE WORLD 581
moods ; the time may be much longer than our hopes and much
shorter than our fears.
The terrible experiences of the Great War have made very many
men who once took political things lightly take them now very
gravely. To a certain small number of men and women the attain-
ment of a world peace has become the supreme work in life, has
become a religious self-devotion. To a much greater number it
has become at least a ruling motive. Many such people now are
seeking ways of working for this great end, or they are already
working for this great end, by pen and persuasion, in schools and
colleges and books, and in the highways and byways of public
life. Perhaps now most human beings in the world are well-
disposed towards such efforts, but rather confusedly disposed;
they are without any clear sense of what must be done and what
ought to be prevented, that human solidarity may be advanced.
The world-wide outbreak of faith and hope in President Wilson,
before he began to wilt and fail us, was a very significant thing
indeed for the future of mankind. Set against these motives of
unity indeed are other motives entirely antagonistic, the fear and
hatred of strange things and peoples, love of and trust in the old
traditional thing, patriotisms, race prejudices, suspicions, distrusts
- and the elements of spite, scoundrelism, and utter selfishness
that are so strong still in every human soul.
The overriding powers that hitherto in the individual soul and
in the community have struggled and prevailed against the fero-
cious, base, and individual impulses that divide us from one an-
other, have been the powers of religion and education. Religion
and education, those closely interwoven influences, have made
possible the greater human societies whose growth we have
traced in this Outline; they have been the chief synthetic
forces throughout this great story of enlarging human cooper-
ations that we have traced from its beginnings. We have found
in the intellectual and theological conflicts of the nineteenth
century the explanation of that curious exceptional disentangle-
ment of religious teaching from formal education which is a dis-
tinctive feature of our age, and we have traced the consequences
of this phase of religious disputation and confusion in the reversion
of international politics towards a brutal nationalism and in the
582 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
backward drift of industrial and business life towards harsh, selfish,
and uncreative profit-seeking. There has been a slipping off of
ancient restraints ; a real de-civilization of men's minds. We would
lay stress here on the suggestion that this divorce of religious
teaching from organized education is necessarily a temporary one,
a transitory dislocation, and that presently education must become
again in intention and spirit religious, and that the impulse to de-
votion, to universal service and to a complete escape from self,
which has been the common underlying force in all the great reli-
gions of the last five and twenty centuries, an impulse which ebbed
so perceptibly during the prosperity, laxity, disillusionment, and
scepticism of the past seventy or eighty years, will reappear again,
stripped and plain, as the recognized fundamental structural im-
pulse in human society.
Education is the preparation of the individual for the community,
and his religious training is the core of that preparation. With
the great intellectual restatements and expansions of the nine-
teenth century, and educational break-up, a confusion and loss of
aim in education was inevitable. We can no longer prepare the
individual for a community when our ideas of a community are
shattered and undergoing reconstruction. The old loyalties, the
old too limited and narrow political and social assumptions, the
old too elaborate religious formulae, have lost their power of con-
viction, and the greater ideas of a world state and of an economic
commonweal have been winning their way only very slowly to
recognition. So far they have swayed only a minority of excep-
tional people. But out of the trouble and tragedy of this present
time there may emerge a moral and intellectual revival, a religious
revival, of a simplicity and scope to draw together men of alien
races and now discrete traditions into one common and sustained
way of living for the world's service. We cannot foretell the scope
and power of such a revival ; we cannot even produce evidence of
its onset. The beginnings of such things are never conspicuous.
Great movements of the racial soul come at first "like a thief in
the night," and then suddenly are discovered to be powerful and
world-wide. Religious emotion — stripped of corruptions and
freed from its last priestly entanglements — may presently blow
through life again like a great wind, bursting the doors and flinging
UNIFICATION OF THE WORLD 583
open the shutters of the individual life, and making many things
possible and easy that in these present days of exhaustion seem
almost too difficult to desire.1
§2
If we suppose a sufficient righteousness and intelligence in men
to produce presently, from the tremendous lessons of history, an
effective will for a world peace — that is to say, an effective will
far a world law under a world government — for in no other fashion
is a secure world peace conceivable — in what manner may we
expect things to move towards this end? That movement will
certainly not go on equally in every country, nor is it likely to
take at first one uniform mode of expression. Here it will find a
congenial and stimulating atmosphere, here it will find itself an-
tagonistic to deep tradition or racial idiosyncrasy or well-organized
base oppositions. In some cases those to whom the call of the
new order has come will be living in a state almost ready to serve
the ends of the greater political synthesis, in others they will have
to fight like conspirators against the rule of evil laws. There is
little in the political constitution of such countries as the United
States or Switzerland that would impede their coalescence upon
terms of frank give and take with other equally civilized confedera-
tions; political systems involving dependent areas and " subject
peoples" such as the Turkish Empire was before the Great War,
seem to require something in the nature of a breaking up before
they can be adapted to a federal world system. Any state ob-
sessed by traditions of an aggressive foreign policy will be diffi-
cult to assimilate into a world combination. But though here the
government may be helpful, and here dark and hostile, the essen-
tial task of men of goodwill in all states and countries remains the
same, it is an educational task, and its very essence is to bring to
the minds of all men everywhere, as a necessary basis for world
cooperation, a new telling and interpretation, a common interpreta-
tion, of history.
Does this League of Nations which has been created by the
covenant of 1919 contain within it the germ of any permanent
1 A suggestive book here containing a good account of the drift of modern
religious thought is G. W. Cooke's Social Evolution of Religion.
584 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
federation of human effort ? Will it grow into something for which,
as Stally brass says, men will be ready to "work whole-heartedly
and, if necessary, fight" —as hitherto they have been willing to
fight for their country and their own people? There are few in-
timations of any such enthusiasm for the League at the present
time. The League does not even seem to know how to talk to
common men. It has gone into official buildings, and compara-
tively few people in the world understand or care what it is doing
there. It may be that the League is no more than a first project
of union, exemplary only in its insufficiencies and dangers, destined
to be superseded by something closer and completer as were the
United States Articles of Confederation by the Federal Constitu-
Hion (see chapter xxxvii, § 5). The League is at present a mere
partial league of governments and states. It emphasizes nation-
ality ; it defers to sovereignty. What the world needs is no such
league of nations as this nor even a mere league of peoples, but a
world league of men. The world perishes unless sovereignty is
merged and nationality subordinated. And for that the minds of
men must first be prepared by experience and knowledge and
thought. The supreme task before men at the present time is
political education.
It may be that several partial leagues may precede any world
league. The common misfortunes and urgent common needs of
Europe and Asia may be more efficacious in bringing the European
and Asiatic states to reason and a sort of unity, than the mere
intellectual and sentimental ties of the United States and Great
Britain and France. A United States of the Old World is a possi-
bility to set against the possibility of an Atlantic union. More-
over, there is much to be said for an American experiment, a Pan-
American league, in which the New World European colonies
would play an in-and-out part as Luxembourg did for a time in the
German confederation.
We will not attempt to weigh here what share may be taken in the
recasting and consolidation of human affairs by the teachings and
propaganda of labour internationalism, by the studies and needs
of international finance, or by such boundary-destroying powers as
science and art and historical teaching. All these things may exert
a combined pressure, in which it may never be possible to appor-
UNIFICATION OF THE WORLD 585
tion the exact shares. Opposition may dissolve, antagonistic cults
flatten out to a common culture, almost imperceptibly. The
bold idealism of to-day may seem mere common sense to-morrow.
And the problem of a forecast is complicated by the possibilities
of interludes and backwaters. History has never gone simply for-
ward. More particularly are the years after a great war apt to be
years of apparent retrocession; men are too weary to see what
has been done, what has been cleared away, and what has been
made possible.
Among the things that seem to move commandingly towards an
adequate world control at the present time are these : —
(1) The increasing destructiveness and intolerableness of war
waged with the new powers of science.
(2) The inevitable fusion of the world's economic affairs into
one system, leading necessarily, it would seem, to some common
control of currency, and demanding safe and uninterrupted com-
munications, and a free movement of goods and people by sea and
land throughout the whole world. The satisfaction of these needs
will require a world control of very considerable authority and
powers of enforcement.
(3) The need, because of the increasing mobility of peoples, of
effectual controls of health everywhere.
(4) The urgent need of some equalization of labour conditions,
and of the minimum standard of life throughout the world. This
seems to carry with it, as a necessary corollary, the establishment
of some minimum standard of education for everyone.
(5) The impossibility of developing the enormous benefits of
flying without a world control of the air-ways.
The necessity and logic of such diverse considerations as these
push the mind irresistibly, in spite of the clashes of race and tradi-
tion and the huge difficulties created by differences in language,
towards the belief that a conscious struggle to establish or prevent
a political world community will be the next stage in human his-
tory. The things that require that world community are perma-
nent needs, one or other of these needs appeals to nearly everyone,
and against their continuing persistence are only mortal difficulties,
great no doubt, but mortal; prejudices, passions, animosities,
delusions about race and country, egotisms, and such-like fluctuat-
586 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
ing and evanescent things, set up in men's minds by education and
suggestion ; none of them things that make now for the welfare and
survival of the individuals who are under their sway nor of the
states and towns and associations in which they prevail.
§3
Our Outline of History has been ill written if it has failed to con-
vey our conviction of the character of the state towards which
the world is moving. Let us summarize here, very briefly, the
main lines to which the developments of history seem to point
as the necessary lines of that world organization. The attainment
of this world state may be impeded and may be opposed to-day
by many apparently vast forces ; but it has, urging it on, a much
more powerful force, that of the free and growing common intel-
ligence of mankind. To-day there is in the world a small but in-
creasing number of men, historians, archaeologists, ethnologists,
economists, sociologists, psychologists, educationists, and the like,
who are doing for human institutions that same task of creative
analysis which the scientific men of the seventeenth and eighteenth
century did for the materials and mechanism of human life ; and
just as these latter, almost unaware of what they were doing, made
telegraphy, swift transit on sea and land, flying and a thousand
hitherto impossible things possible, so the former may be doing
more than the world suspects, or than they themselves suspect,
to clear up and make plain the thing to do and the way to do it,
in the greater and more urgent human affairs.
Let us ape Roger Bacon in his prophetic mood, and set down
what we believe will be the broad fundamentals of the coming
world state.
(i) It will be based upon a common world religion, very much
simplified and universalized and better understood. This will
not be Christianity nor Islam nor Buddhism nor any such special-
ized form of religion, but religion itself pure and undefiled;
the Eightfold Way, the Kingdom of Heaven, brotherhood, crea-
tive service, and self-forgetfulness. Throughout the world men's,
thoughts and motives will be turned by education, example, and
the circle of ideas about them, from the obsession of self to the cheer-
ful service of human knowledge, human power, and human unity.
UNIFICATION OF THE WORLD 587
(ii) And this world state will be sustained by a universal educa- i
tion, organized upon a scale and of a penetration and quality be- I
yond all present experience. The whole race, and not simply \
classes and peoples, will be educated. Most parents will have a
technical knowledge of teaching. Quite apart from the duties of
parentage, perhaps ten per cent, or more of the adult population
will, at some time or other in their lives, be workers in the world's
educational organization. And education, as the new age will
conceive it, will go on throughout life ; it will not cease at any par-
ticular age. Men and women will simply become self-educators
and individual students and student teachers as they grow older.
(iii) There will be no armies, no navies, and no classes of un-
employed people, wealthy or poor.
(iv) The world-state's organization of scientific research and
record compared with that of to-day will be like an ocean liner
beside the dug-out canoe of some early helioh'thic wanderer.
(v) There will be a vast free literature of criticism and dis-
cussion.
(vi) The world's political organization will be democratic, that I
is to say, the government and direction of affairs will be in immedi-
ate touch with and responsive to the general thought of the edu-
cated whole population.
(vii) Its economic organization will be an exploitation of all
natural wealth and every fresh possibility science reveals, by the
agents and servants of the common government for the common
good. Private enterprise will be the servant — a useful, valued,
and well-rewarded servant — and no longer the robber master of
the commonweal.
(viii) And this implies two achievements that seem very diffi-
cult to us to-day. They are matters of mechanism, but they are
as essential to the world's well-being as it is to a soldier's, no,
matter how brave he may be, that his machine gun should not jamj
and to an aeronaut's that his steering-gear should not fail him in
mid-air. Political well-being demands that electoral methods
shall be used, and economic well-being requires that a currency
shall be used, safeguarded or proof against the contrivances and
manipulations of clever, dishonest men.
588 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
§4
There can be little question that the attainment of a federa-
tion of all humanity, together with a sufficient measure of social
justice, to insure health, education, and a rough equality of oppor-
tunity to most of the children born into the world, would mean
such a release and increase of human energy as to open a new phase
in human history. The enormous waste caused by military prep-
aration and the mutual annoyance of competing great powers,
and the still more enormous waste due to the under-productiveness
of great masses of people, either because they are too wealthy for
stimulus or too poor for efficiency, would cease. There would
be a vast increase in the supply of human necessities, a rise in the
standard of life and in what is considered a necessity, a develop-
ment of transport and every kind of convenience ; and a multitude
of people would be transferred from low-grade production to such
higher work as art of all kinds, teaching, scientific research, and the
like. All over the world there would be a setting free of human
capacity, such as has occurred hitherto only in small places and
through precious limited phases of prosperity and security. Unless
we are to suppose that spontaneous outbreaks of super-men have
occurred in the past, it is reasonable to conclude that the Athens
of Pericles, the Florence of the Medici, Elizabethan England, the
great deeds of Asoka, the Tang and Ming periods in art, are but
samples of what a whole world of sustained security would yield
continuously and cumulatively. Without supposing any change
in human quality, but merely its release from the present system
of inordinate waste, history justifies this expectation.
We have seen how, since the liberation of human thought in
the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries, a comparatively few curious
and intelligent men, chiefly in western Europe, have produced a
vision of the world and a body of science that is now, on the ma-
terial side, revolutionizing life. Mostly these men have worked
against great discouragement, with insufficient funds and small
help or support from the mass of mankind. It is impossible to
believe that these men were the maximum intellectual harvest
of I their generation. England alone in the last three centuries
must have produced scores of Newtons who never learnt to read,
UNIFICATION OF THE WORLD 589
hundreds of Daltons, Darwins, Bacons, and Huxleys, who died
stunted in hovels, or never got a chance of proving their quality.
All the world over, there must have been myriads of potential
first-class investigators, splendid artists, creative minds, who never
caught a gleam of inspiration or opportunity, for every one of that
kind who has left his mark upon the world. In the trenches of
the Western front alone during the late war thousands of potential
great men died unfulfilled. But a world with something like a
secure international peace and something like social justice, will
fish for capacity with the fine net of universal education, and may
expect a yield beyond comparison greater than any yield of able
and brilliant men that the world has known hitherto.
It is such considerations as this indeed which justify the con-
centration of effort in the near future upon the making of a new
world state of righteousness out of our present confusions. War is
a horrible thing, and constantly more horrible and dreadful, so
that unless it is ended it will certainly^ end human society ; social
injustice, and the sight of the limited and cramped human beings
it produces, torment the soul ; but the strongest incentive to con-
structive political and social work for an imaginative spirit lies
not so much in the mere hope of escaping evils as in the opportunity
for great adventures that their suppression will open to our race.
We want tq get rid of the militarist not simply because he hurts
and kills, but because he is an intolerable thick-voiced blockhead \
who stands hectoring and blustering in oMr way to achievement. !
We want to abolish many extravagances of private ownership just
as we should want to abolish some idiot guardian who ref tfeed us
admission to a studio in which there were fine things to do.
There are people who seem to imagine that a world order and
one universal law of justice would end human adventure. It
would but begin it. But instead of the adventure of the past, the
" romance " of the cinematograph world, the perpetual reiterated
harping upon the trite reactions of sex and combat and the hunt
for gold, it would be an unending exploration upon the edge of ex-
perience. Hitherto man has been living in a slum, amidst quarrels,
revenges, vanities, shames and taints, hot desires, and urgent
appetites. He has scarcely tasted sweet air yet and the great
freedoms of the world that science has enlarged for him.
590 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
To picture to ourselves something of the wider life that world
unity would open to men is a very attractive speculation. Life
will certainly go with a stronger pulse, it will breathe a deeper
breath, because it will have dispelled and conquered a hundred
infections of body and mind that now reduce it to invalidism and
squalor. We have already laid stress on the vast elimination of
drudgery from human life through the creation of a new race of
slaves, the machines. This — and the disappearance of war and
the smoothing out of endless restraints and contentions by juster
social and economic arrangements — will lift the burthen of toil-
some work and routine work, that has been the price of human
security since the dawn of the first civilizations, from the shoulders
of our children. Which does not mean that they will cease to
work, but that they will cease to do irksome work under pressure,
and will work freely, planning, making, creating, according to
their gifts and instincts. They will fight nature no longer as dull
conscripts of the pick and plough, but for a splendid conquest.
Only the spiritlessness of our present depression blinds us to the
clear intimations of our reason that in the course of a few genera-
tions every little country town could become an Athens, every
human being could be gentle in breeding and healthy in body and
mind, the whole solid earth man's mine and its uttermost regions
his playground.
In this Outline we have sought to show two great systems of
development interacting in the story of human society. We have
seen, growing out of that later special neolithic culture, the helio-
lithic culture, and arising out of this in the warmer alluvial partsT
of the world, the great primordial civilizations, fecund systems of
subjugation and obedience, vast multiplications of industrious
and subservient men. We have shown the necessary relation-
ship of these early civilizations to the early temples and to king-
gods and god-kings. At the same time we have traced the develop-
ment from a simpler neolithic level of the wanderer peoples, who
became the nomadic peoples, in those great groups the Aryans and
the Hun-Mongol peoples of the north-west and the north-east and
(from a heliolithic phase) the Semites of the Arabian deserts. Our
history has told of a repeated overrunning and refreshment of the
originally brunet civilizations by these hardier, bolder, free-spirited
UNIFICATION OF THE WORLD 591
peoples of the steppes and desert. We have pointed out how these
constantly recurring nomadic injections have steadily altered the
primordial civilizations both in blood and in spirit ; and how the
world religions of to-day, and what we now call democracy, the
boldness of modern scientific inquiry and a universal restlessness,
are due to this " nomadization " of civilization. The old civiliza-
tions created tradition, and lived by tradition. To-day the power
of tradition is destroyed.1 The body of our state is civilization
still, but its spirit is the spirit of the nomadic world. It is the
spirit of the great plains and the high seas.
So that it is difficult to resist the persuasion that so soon as one
law runs in the earth and the fierceness of frontiers ceases to dis-
tress us, that urgency in our nature that stirs us in spring and au-
tumn to be up and travelling, will have its way with us. We shall
obey the call of the summer pastures and the winter pastures in
our blood, the call of the mountains, the desert, and the sea. For
some of us also, who may be of a different lineage, there is the call
of the forest, and there are those who would hunt in the summer
and return to the fields for the harvest and the plough. But this
does not mean that men will have become homeless and all adrift.
The normal nomadic life is not a homeless one, but a movement be-
tween homes. The Kalmucks to-day, like the swallows, go yearly
a thousand miles from one home to another. The beautiful and
convenient cities of the coming age, we conclude, will have their
seasons when they will be full of life and seasons when they will
seem asleep. Life will ebb and flow to and from every region sea-
sonally as the interest of that region rises or declines.
There will be little drudgery in this better-ordered world. Nat-
ural power harnessed in machines will be the general drudge.
What drudgery is inevitable will be done as a service and duty
for a few years or months out of each life ; it will not consume nor
degrade the whole life of anyone. And not only drudges, but
many other sorts of men and ways of living which loom large in
the current social scheme will necessarily have dwindled in impor-
tance or passed away altogether. There will be few professional
1 Compare Basil Thompson, The Fijians, a Study of the Decay of Custom; Intro-
duction and opening chapters. This is a fine study of an ancient " heliolithic "
culture breaking up under modernization.
592 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
fighting men or none at all, no custom-house officers ; the increased
multitude of teachers will have abolished large police forces and
large jail staffs, mad-houses will be rare or non-existent ; a world-
wide sanitation will have diminished the proportion of hospitals,
nurses, sick-room attendants, and the like ; a world-wide economic
justice, the floating population of cheats, sharpers, gamblers, fore-
stallers, parasites, and speculators generally. But there will be
no diminution of adventure or romance in this world of the days to
come. Sea fisheries and the incessant insurrection of the sea,
for example, will call for their own stalwart types of men ; the high
air will clamour for manhood, the deep and dangerous secret places
of nature. Men will turn again with renewed interest to the animal
world. In these disordered days a stupid, uncontrollable massacre
of animal species goes on — from certain angles of vision it is a
thing almost more tragic than human miseries ; in the nineteenth
century dozens of animal species, and some of them very interest-
ing species, were exterminated; but one of the first fruits of an
effective world state would be the better protection of what are
now wild beasts. It is a strange thing in human history to note
how little has been done since the Bronze Age in taming, using, be-
friending, and appreciating the animal life about us. But that
mere witless killing which is called sport to-day, would inevitably
give place in a better educated world community to a modification
of the primitive instincts that find expression in this way, changing
them into an interest not in the deaths, but in the lives of beasts,
and leading to fresh and perhaps very strange and beautiful at-
tempts to befriend these pathetic, kindred lower creatures we no
longer fear as enemies, hate as rivals, or need as slaves. And a
world state and universal justice does not mean the imprisonment
of our race in any bleak institutional orderliness. There will still
be mountains and the sea, there will be jungles and great forests,
cavred for indeed and treasured and protected; the great plains
will still spread before us and the wild winds blow. But men will
not hate so much, fear so much, nor cheat so desperately — and
they will keep their minds and bodies cleaner.
There are unhopeful prophets who see in the gathering together
of men into one community the possibility of violent race conflicts,
conflicts for "ascendancy," but that is to suppose that civilization
UNIFICATION OF THE WORLD 593
is incapable of adjustments by which men of different qualities and
temperaments and appearances will live side by side, following
different r61es and contributing diverse gifts. The weaving of
mankind into one community does not imply the creation of a
homogeneous community, but rather the reverse; the welcome
and the adequate utilization of distinctive quality in an atmos-
phere of understanding. It is the almost universal bad manners
of the present age which make race intolerable to race. The com-
munity to which we may be moving will be more mixed — which
does not necessarily mean more interbred — more various and
more interesting than any existing community. Communities
all to one pattern, like boxes of toy soldiers, are things of the past
rather than the future.
But one of the hardest, most impossible tasks a writer can set
himself, is to picture the life of people better educated, happier in
their circumstances, more free and more healthy than he is him-
self. We know enough to-day to know that there is infinite room
for betterment in every human concern. Nothing is needed but
collective effort. Our poverty, our restraints, our infections and
indigestions, our quarrels and misunderstandings, are all things
controllable and removable by concerted human action, but we
know as little how life would feel without them as some poor dirty,
ill-treated, fierce-souled creature born and bred amidst the cruel
and dingy surroundings of a European back street can know what
it is to bathe every day, always to be clad beautifully, to climb
mountains for pleasure, to fly, to meet none but agreeable, well-
mannered people, to conduct researches or make delightful things.
Yet a time when all such good things will be for all men may be
coming more nearly than we think. Each one who believes that
brings the good time nearer; each heart that fails delays it.
One cannot foretell the surprises or disappointments the future
has in store. Before this chapter of the World State can begin
fairly in our histories, other chapters as yet unsuspected may still
need to be written, as long and as full of conflict as our account of
the growth and rivalries of the Great Powers. There may be
tragic economic struggles, grim grapplings of race with race and
class with class. We do not know; we cannot tell. These are
unnecessary disasters, but they may be unavoidable disasters.
594 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
Human history becomes more and more a race between education
and catastrophe. Against the unifying effort of Christendom
and against the unifying influence of the mechanical revolution,
catastrophe won. New falsities may arise and hold men in
some unrighteous and fated scheme of order for a time, before
they collapse amidst the misery and slaughter of generations.
Yet, clumsily or smoothly, the world, it seems, progresses and
will progress. In this Outline, in our account of Palaeolithic men,
we have borrowed a description from Mr. Worthington Smith of the
very highest life in the world some fifty thousand years ago. It
was a bestial life. We have sketched too the gathering for a human
sacrifice, some fifteen thousand years ago. That scene again is
almost incredibly cruel to a modern civilized reader. Yet it is
not more than five hundred years since the great empire of the
Aztecs still believed that it could live only by the shedding of blood.
Every year in Mexico hundreds of human victims died in this
fashion : the body was bent like a bow over the curved stone of
sacrifice, the breast was slashed open with a knife of obsidian,
and the priest tore out the beating heart of the still living victim.
The day may be close at hand when we shall no longer tear out
the hearts of men, even for the sake of our national gods. Let
the reader but refer to the earlier time charts we have given in
this history, and he will see the true measure and transitoriness
of all the conflicts, deprivations, and miseries of this present period
of painful and yet hopeful change.
§5
History is and must always be no more than an account of be-
ginnings. We can venture to prophesy that the next chapters to
be written will tell, though perhaps with long interludes of set-
back and disaster, of the final achievement of world-wide political
and social unity. But when that is attained, it will mean no rest-
ing stage, nor even a breathing stage, before the development of a
new struggle and of new and vaster efforts. Men will unify only
to intensify the search for knowledge and power, and live as ever
for new occasions. Animal and vegetable life, the obscure pro-
cesses of psychology, the intimate structure of matter and the in-
terior of our earth, will yield their secrets and endow their con-
UNIFICATION OF THE WORLD 595
queror. Life begins perpetually. Gathered together at last under
the leadership of man, the student-teacher of the universe, unified,
disciplined, armed with the secret powers of the atom and with
knowledge as yet beyond dreaming, Life, for ever dying to be born
afresh, for ever young and eager, will presently stand upon this
earth as upon a footstool, and stretch out its realm amidst the
stars.
TIME CHARTS
AND
CHRONOLOGICAL TABLE
TIME CHARTS
599
600
THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
TIME CHARTS
601
602
THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
TIME CHARTS
603
CHRONOLOGICAL TABLE
TO conclude this Outline, we give here a Table of Leading
Events from the year 800 B.C. to 1920 A.D. With it we give
five time diagrams covering the period from 1000 B.C. onward,
which present the trend of events in a graphic form.
It is well that the reader should keep in mind an idea of the true
proportions of historical to geological time. The scale of these five
diagrams is such that by it the time diagram on page 196, vol. i,
would be about 8-J- times as long, that is to say about 4 feet ; that on
page 97, showing the length of time since the first true men, about 55
feet long ; that on page 60, showing the interval since the Eoliths,
555 feet ; and that on page 14, representing the whole of geological
time, would be somewhere between 12 and, at the longest and most
probable estimate, 260 miles ! Let the reader therefore take one
of these chronological tables we give, and imagine it extended upon
a long strip of paper to a distance of 55 feet. He would have to
get up and walk about that distance to note the date of the paint-
ing of the Altamira caves, and he would have to go ten times that
distance by the side of the same narrow strip to reach the earlier
Neanderthalers. A mile or so from home, but probably much
further away, the strip might be recording the last of the dinosaurs.
And this on a scale which represents the time from Columbus to
ourselves by three inches of space !
Chronology only begins to be precise enough to specify the exact
year of any event after the establishment of the eras of the First
Olympiad and the building of Rome.
About the year 1000 B.C. the Aryan peoples were establishing
themselves in the peninsulas of Spain, Italy, and the Balkans, and
they were established in North India, Cnossos was already de-
stroyed and the spacious times of Egypt, of Thothmes III, Ameno-
phis III, and Rameses II were three or four centuries away. Weak
monarchs of the XXIst Dynasty were ruling in the Nile Valley.
605
606 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
Israel was united under her early kings ; Saul or David or possibly
even Solomon may have been reigning. Sargon I (2750 B.C.) of
the Akkadian Sumerian Empire was a remote memory in Baby-
lonian history, more remote than is Constantine the Great from
the world of the present day. Hammurabi had been dead a
thousand years. The Assyrians were already dominating the
less military Babylonians. In 1100 B.c.Tiglath Pileser I had taken
Babylon. But there was no permanent conquest; Assyria and
Babylonia were still separate empires. In China the new Chow
Dynasty was flourishing. Stonehenge in England was already a
thousand years old.
The next two centuries saw a renascence of Egypt under the
XXIInd Dynasty, the splitting up of the brief little Hebrew
kingdom of Solomon, the spreading of the Greeks in the Balkans,
South Italy, and Asia Minor, and the days of Etruscan predomi-
nance in Central Italy. We may begin our list of ascertainable
dates with —
B.C.
800. The building of Carthage.
790. The Ethiopian conquest of Egypt (founding the XXVth
Dynasty).
776. First Olympiad.
753. Rome built.
745. Tiglath Pileser III conquered Babylonia and founded the
New Assyrian Empire.
738. Menahem, king of Israel, bought off Tiglath Pileser III.
735. Greeks settling in Sicily.
722. Sargon II armed the Assyrians with iron weapons.
721. He deported the Israelites.
704. Sennacherib.
701. His army destroyed by pestilence on its way to Egypt.
680. Esarhaddon took Thebes in Egypt (overthrowing the Ethi-
opian XXVth Dynasty).
667. Sardanapalus.
664. Psammetichus I restored the freedom of Egypt and founded
the XXVIth Dynasty (to 610). He was assisted against
Assyria by Lydian troops sent by Gyges.
CHRONOLOGICAL TABLE 607
B.C.
608. Necho of Egypt defeated Josiah, king of Judah, at the Battle
of Megiddo.
606. Capture of Nineveh by the Chaldeans and Medes. Foun-
dation of the Chaldean Empire.
604. Necho pushed to the Euphrates and was overthrown by
Nebuchadnezzar II. Josiah fell with him.
586. Nebuchadnezzar carried off the Jews to Babylon. Many
fled to Egypt and settled there.
550. Cyrus the Persian succeeded Cyaxares the Mede.
Cyrus conquered Crcesus.
Buddha lived about this time. So also did Confucius and
Lao Tse.
539. Cyrus took Babylon and founded the Persian Empire.
527. Peisistratus died.
525. Cambyses conquered Egypt.
521. Darius I, the son of Hystaspes, ruled from the Hellespont to
the Indus.
His expedition to Scythia.
490. Battle of Marathon.
484. Herodotus born. ^Eschylus won his first prize for tragedy.
480. Battles of Thermopylae and Salamis.
479. The Battles of Plat sea and Mycale completed the repulse of
Persia.
474. Etruscan fleet destroyed by the Sicilian Greeks.
470. Voyage of Hanno.
466. Pericles.
465. Xerxes murdered.
438. Herodotus recited his History in Athens.
431. Peloponnesian War began (to 404).
428. Pericles died. Herodotus died.
427. Aristophanes began his career. Plato born. He lived to 347.
401. Retreat of the Ten Thousand.
390. Brennus sacked Rome.
366. Camillus built the Temple of Concord.
359. Philip became king of Macedonia.
338. Battle of Chseronea.
336. Macedonian troops crossed into Asia. Philip murdered.
608 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
B.C.
334. Battle of the Granicus.
333. Battle of Issus.
332. Alexander in Egypt.
331. Battle of Arbela.
330. Darius III killed.
323. Death of Alexander the Great.
321. Rise of Chandragupta in the Punjab. The Romans com-
pletely beaten by the Samnites at the battle of the
Caudine Forks.
303. Chandragupta repulsed Seleucus.
285. Ptolemy Soter died.
281. Pyrrhus invaded Italy.
280. Battle of Heraclea.
279. Battle of Ausculum.
278. Gauls' raid into Asia Minor and settlement in Galatia.
275. Pyrrhus left Italy.
264. First Punic War. (Asoka began to reign in Behar — to
227.) First gladiatorial games in Rome.
260. Battle of Mylae.
256. Battle of Ecnomus.
246. Shi-Hwang-ti became king of Ch'in.
242. Battle of ^Egatian Isles.
241. End of First Punic War.
225. Battle of Telamon. Roman armies in Illyria.
220. Shi-Hwang-ti became emperor of China.
219. Second Punic War.
216. Battle of Cannae.
214. Great Wall of China begun.
210. Death of Shi-Hwang-ti.
202. Battle of Zama.
201. End of Second Punic War.
200-197. Rome at war with Macedonia.
192. War with the Seleucids.
190. Battle of Magnesia.
149. Third Punic War. (The Yueh-Chi came into Western
Turkestan.)
146. Carthage destroyed. Corinth destroyed.
CHRONOLOGICAL TABLE 609
B.C.
133. Attalus bequeathed Pergamum to Rome. Tiberius Grac-
chus killed.
121. Caius Gracchus killed.
118. War with Jugurtha.
106. War with Jugurtha ended.
102. Marius drove back Germans.
100. Triumph of Marius. (Wu-ti conquering the Tarim Valley.)
91. Social war.
89. All Italians became Roman citizens.
86. Death of Marius.
78. Death of Sulla.
73. The revolt of the slaves under Spartacus.
71. Defeat and end of Spartacus.
66. Pompey led Roman troops to the Caspian and Euphrates.
He encountered the Alani.
64. Mithridates of Pontus died.
53. Crassus killed at Carrhse. Mongolian elements with Par-
thians.
48. Julius Caesar defeated Pompey at Pharsalos.
44. Julius Caesar assassinated.
31. Battle of Actium.
27. Augustus Caesar princeps (until 14 A.D.).
4. True date of birth of Jesus of Nazareth.
A.D. Christian Era began.
6. Province of Mcesia established.
9. Province of Pannonia established. Imperial boundary
carried to the Danube.
14. Augustus died. Tiberius emperor.
30. Jesus of Nazareth crucified.
37. Caligula succeeded Tiberius.
41. Claudius (the first emperor of the legions) made emperor by
pretorian guard after murder of Caligula.
54. Nero succeeded Claudius.
61. Boadicea massacred Roman garrison in Britain.
68. Suicide of Nero. (Galba, Otho, Vitellus, emperors in suc-
cession.)
69. Vespasian began the so-called Flavian dynasty.
2R
610 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
A.D.
79. Titus succeeded Vespasian.
81. Domitian.
84. North Britain annexed.
96. Nerva began the so-called dynasty of the Antonines.
98. Trajan succeeded Nerva.
102. Pan Chau on the Caspian Sea. (Indo-Scythians invading
North India.)
117. Hadrian succeeded Trajan. Roman Empire at its greatest
extent.
138. Antoninus Pius succeeded Hadrian.
(The Indo-Scythians at this time were destroying the
last traces of Hellenic rule in India.)
150. [About this time Kanishka reigned in India, Kashgar, Yar-
kand, and Kotan.]
161. Marcus Aurelius succeeded Antoninus Pius.
164. Great plague began, and lasted to the death of M. Aurelius
(180). This also devastated all Asia.
180. Death of Marcus Aurelius.
(Nearly a century of war and disorder began in the Roman
Empire.)
220. End of the Han dynasty. Beginning of four hundred' years
of division in China.
227. Ardashir I (first Sassanid shah) put an end to Arsacid line
in Persia.
242. Mani began his teaching.
247. Goths crossed Danube in a great raid.
251. Great victory of Goths. Emperor Decius killed.
260. Sapor I, the second Sassanid shah, took Antioch, captured
the Emperor Valerian, and was cut up on his return from
Asia Minor by Odenathus of Palmyra.
269. The Emperor Claudius defeated the Goths at Nish.
270. Aurelian became emperor.
272. Zenobia carried captive to Rome. End of the brief glories
of Palmyra.
275. Probus succeeded Aurelian,
276. Goths in Pontus. The Emperor Probus forced back Franks
and Alemanni.
CHRONOLOGICAL TABLE 611
A.D.
277. Mani crucified in Persia.
284. Diocletian became emperor.
303. Diocletian persecuted the Christians.
311. Galerius abandoned the persecution of the Christians.
312. Constantine the Great became emperor.
313. Constantine presided over a Christian Council at Aries.
321. Fresh Gothic raids driven back.
323. Constantine presided over the Council of Nicsea.
337. Vandals driven by Goths obtained leave to settle in
Pannonia. Constantine baptized on his death-bed.
354. St. Augustine born.
361-3. Julian the Apostate attempted to substitute Mithraism
for Christianity.
379. Theodosius the Great (a Spaniard) emperor.
390. The statue of Serapis at Alexandria broken up.
392. Theodosius the Great, emperor of east and west.
395. Theodosius the Great died. Honorius and Arcadius redi-
vided the empire with Stilicho and Alaric as their masters
and protectors.
410. The Visigoths under Alaric captured Rome.
425. Vandals settling in south of Spain. Huns in Pannonia,
Goths in Dalmatia. Visigoths and Suevi in Portugal and
North Spain. English invading Britain.
429. Vandals under Genseric invaded Africa.
439. Vandals took Carthage.
448. Priscus visited Attila.
451. Attila raided Gaul and was defeated by Franks, Alemanni,
and Romans at Troyes.
453. Death of Attila.
455. Vandals sacked Rome.
470. Ephthalites' raid into India.
476. Odoacer, king of a medley of Teutonic tribes, informed Con-
stantinople that there was no emperor in the West. End
of the Western Empire.
480. St. Benedict born.
481. Clovis in France. The Merovingians.
483. Nestorian church broke away from the Orthodox Christian
church.
612 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
A.D.
493. Theodoric, the Ostrogoth, conquered Italy and became King
of Italy, but was nominally subject to Constantinople.
(Gothic kings in Italy. Goths settled on special con-
fiscated lands as a garrison.)
527. Justinian emperor.
528. Mihiragula, the (Ephthalite) Attila of India, overthrown.
529. Justinian closed the schools at Athens, which had flourished
nearly a thousand years. Belisarius (Justinian's general)
took Naples.
531. Chosroes I began to reign.
543. Great plague in Constantinople.
544. St. Benedict died.
553. Goths expelled from Italy by Justinian. Cassiodorus
founded his monastery.
565. Justinian died. The Lombards conquered most of North
Italy (leaving Ravenna and Rome Byzantine). The
Turks broke up the Ephthalites in Western Turkestan.
570. Muhammad born.
579. Chosroes I died.
(The Lombards dominant in Italy.)
590. Plague raged in Rome. (Gregory the Great — Gregory I
— and the vision of St. Angelo.) Chosroes II began to
reign.
610. Heraclius began to reign.
619. Chosroes II held Egypt, Jerusalem, Damascus, and had
armies on Hellespont. Tang dynasty began in China.
622. The Hegira.
623. Battle of Badr.
627. Great Persian defeat at Nineveh by Heraclius. The Meccan
Allies besieged Medina. Tai-tsung became Emperor of
China.
628. Kavadh II murdered and succeeded his father, Chosroes II.
Muhammad wrote letters to all the rulers of the earth.
629. Yuan Chwang started for India. Muhammad entered
Mecca.
631. Tai-tsung received Nestorian missionaries.
632. Muhammad died. Abu Bekr Caliph.
CHRONOLOGICAL TABLE 613
A.D.
634. Battle of the Yarmuk. Moslems took Syria. Omar second
Caliph.
637. Battle of Kadessia.
638. Jerusalem surrendered to Omar.
642. Heraclius died.
643. Othman third Caliph.
645. Yuan Chwang returned to Singan.
655. Defeat of the Byzantine fleet by the Moslems.
656. Othman murdered at Medina.
661. Ali murdered.
662. Moawija Caliph. (First of the Omayyad caliphs.)
668. The Caliph Moawija attacked Constantinople by sea-
Theodore of Tarsus became Archbishop of Canterbury.
675. Last of the sea attacks by Moawija on Constantinople.
687. Pepin of Heristhal, mayor of the palace, reunited Austrasia
and Neustria.
711. Moslem army invaded Spain from Africa.
714. Charles Martel mayor of the palace.
715. The domains of the Caliph Walid I extended from the
Pyrenees to China.
717-18. Suleiman, son and successor of Walid, failed to take
Constantinople. The Omayyad line passed its climax.
732. Charles Martel defeated the Moslems near Poitiers.
735. Death of the Venerable Bede.
743. Walid II Caliph, — the unbelieving Caliph.
749. Overthrow of the Omayyads. Abdul Abbas, the first Ab-
basid Caliph. Spain remained Omayyad. Beginning
of the break-up of the Arab Empire.
751. Pepin crowned King of the French.
755. Martyrdom of St. Boniface.
768. Pepin died.
771. Charlemagne sole king.
774. Charlemagne conquered Lombardy.
776. Charlemagne in Dalmatia.
786. Haroun al Raschid Abbasid Caliph in Bagdad (to 809).
795. Leo III became Pope (to 816).
800. Leo crowned Charlemagne Emperor of the West.
614 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
A.D.
802. Egbert, formerly an English refugee at the court of Charle-
magne, established himself as King of Wessex.
810. Krum of Bulgaria defeated and killed the Emperor Niceph-
orus.
814. Charlemagne died, Louis the Pious succeeds him.
828. Egbert became first King of England.
843. Louis the Pious died, and the Carlovingian Empire went to
pieces. Until 962 there was no regular succession of Holy
Roman Emperors, though the title appeared intermittently.
850. About this time Rurik (a Northman) became ruler of Nov-
gorod and Kieff.
852. Boris first Christian King of Bulgaria (to 884).
865. The fleet of the Russians (Northmen) threatened Constan-
tinople.
886. The Treaty of Alfred of England and Guthrum the Dane,
establishing the Danes in the Danelaw.
904. Russian (Northmen) fleet off Constantinople.
912. Rolf the Ganger established himself in Normandy.
919. Henry the Fowler elected King of Germany.
928. Marozia imprisoned Pope John X.
931. John XI Pope (to 936).
936. Otto I became King of Germany in succession to his father,
Henry the Fowler.
941. Russian fleet again threatened Constantinople.
955. John XII Pope.
960. Northern Sung Dynasty began in China.
962. Otto I, King of Germany, crowned Emperor (first Saxon
Emperor) by John XII.
963. Otto deposed John XII.
969. Separate Fatimite Caliphate set up in Egypt.
973. Otto II.
983. Otto III.
987. Hugh Capet became King of France. End of the Carlovin-
gian line of French kings.
1013. Canute became King of England, Denmark, and Norway.
1037. Avicenna of Bokhara, the Prince of Physicians, died.
1043. Russian fleet threatened Constantinople.
CHRONOLOGICAL TABLE 615
A.D.
1066. Conquest of England by William, Duke of Normandy.
1071. Revival of Islam under the Seljuk Turks. Battle of
Melasgird.
1073. Hildebrand became Pope (Gregory VII) to 1085.
1082. Robert Guiscard captured Durazzo.
1084. Robert Guiscard sacked Rome.
1087-99. Urban II Pope.
1094. Pestilence.
1095. Urban II at Clermont summoned the First Crusade.
1096. Massacre of the People's Crusade.
1099. Godfrey of Bouillon captured Jerusalem. Paschal II
Pope (to 1118).
1138. Kin Empire flourished. The Sung capital shifted from
Nanking to Hang Chau.
1147. The Second Crusade. Foundation of the Christian King-
dom of Portugal.
1169. Saladin Sultan of Egypt.
1176. Frederick Barbarossa acknowledged supremacy of the
Pope (Alexander III) at Venice.
1187. Saladin captured Jerusalem.
1189. The Third Crusade.
1198. Averroes of Cordoba, the Arab philosopher, died. Inno-
cent III Pope (to 1216). Frederick II (aged four), King
of Sicily, became his ward.
1202. The Fourth Crusade attacked the Eastern Empire.
1204. Capture of Constantinople by the Latins.
1206. Kutub founded Moslem state at Delhi.
1212. The Children's Crusade.
1214. Jengis Khan took Peking.
1215. Magna Carta signed.
1216. Honorius III Pope.
1218. Jengis Khan invaded Kharismia.
1221. Failure and return of the Fifth Crusade. St. Dominic died.
(The Dominicans.)
1226. St. Francis of Assisi died. (The Franciscans.)
1227. Jengis Khan died, Khan from the Caspian to the Pacific,
and was succeeded by Ogdai Khan.
616 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
A.D.
1227. Gregory IX Pope.
1228. Frederick II embarked upon the Sixth Crusade, and ac-
quired Jerusalem.
1234. Mongols completed conquest of the Kin Empire with the
help of the Sung Empire.
1239. Frederick II excommunicated for the second time.
1240. Mongols destroyed Kieff. Russia tributary to the Mon-
gols.
1241. Mongol victory at Liegnitz in Silesia.
1244. The Egyptian Sultan recaptured Jerusalem. This led to
the Seventh Crusade.
1245. Frederick II re-excommunicated. The men of Schwyz
burnt the castle of New Habsburg.
1250. St. Louis of France ransomed. Frederick II, the last Ho-
henstaufen Emperor, died. German interregnum until
1273.
1251. Mangu Khan became Great Khan. Kublai Khan governor
of China.
1258. Hulagu Khan took and destroyed Bagdad.
1260. Kublai Khan became Great Khan. Ketboga defeated in
Palestine.
1261. The Greeks recaptured Constantinople from the Latins.
1269. Kublai Khan sent a message of inquiry to the Pope by the
older Polos.
1271. Marco Polo started upon his travels.
1273. Rudolf of Habsburg elected Emperor. The Swiss formed
their Everlasting League.
1280. Kublai Khan founded the Yuan Dynasty in China.
1292. Death of Kublai Khan.
1293. Roger Bacon, the prophet of experimental science, died.
1294. Boniface VIII Pope (to 1303).
1295. Marco Polo returned to Venice.
1303. Death of Pope Boniface VIII after the outrage of Anagni
by Guillaume de Nogaret.
1305. Clement V Pope. The papal court set up at Avignon.
1308. Duns Scotus died.
1318. Four Franciscans burnt for heresy at Marseilles.
CHRONOLOGICAL TABLE 617
A.D.
1347. Occam died.
1348. The Great Plague, the Black Death.
1358. The Jacquerie in France.
1360. In China the Mongol (Yuan) Dynasty fell, and was suc-
ceeded by the Ming Dynasty (to 1644).
1367. Timurlane assumed the title of Great Khan.
1377. Pope Gregory XI returned to Rome.
1378. The Great Schism. Urban VI in Rome, Clement VII at
Avignon.
1381. Peasant revolt in England. Wat Tyler murdered in the
presence of King Richard II.
1384. Wycliffe died.
1398. Huss preached Wycliffism at Prague.
1405. Death of Timurlane.
1414-18. The Council of Constance. Huss burnt (1415).
1417. The Great Schism ended, Martin V Pope.
1420. The Hussites revolted. Martin V preached a crusade
against them.
1431. The Catholic Crusaders dissolved before the Hussites at
. , Domazlice. The Council of Basle met.
1436. The Hussites came to terms with the church.
1439. Council of Basle created a fresh schism in the church.
1445. Discovery of Cape Verde by the Portuguese.
1446. First printed books (Coster in Haarlem).
1449. End of the Council of Basle.
1453. Ottoman Turks under Muhammad II took Constantinople.
1480. Ivan III, Grand-duke of Moscow, threw off the Mongol
allegiance.
1481. Death of the Sultan Muhammad II while preparing for the
conquest of Italy. Bayazid II Turkish Sultan (to 1512).
1486. Diaz rounded the Cape of Good Hope.
1492. Columbus crossed the Atlantic to America. Rodrigo Bor-
gia, Alexander VI, Pope (to 1503).
1493. Maximilian I became Emperor.
1498. Vasco da Gama sailed round the Cape to India.
1499. Switzerland became an independent republic.
1500. Charles V born.
618 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
A.D.
1509. Henry VIII King of England.
1512. Selim Sultan (to 1520). He bought the title of Caliph.
Fall of Soderini (and Machiavelli) in Florence.
1513. Leo X Pope.
1515. Francis I King of France.
1517. Selim annexed Egypt. Luther propounded his theses at
Wittenberg.
1519. Leonardo da Vinci died. Magellan's expedition started to
sail round the world. Cortez entered Mexico city.
1520. Suleiman the Magnificent, Sultan (to 1566), who ruled from
Bagdad to Hungary. Charles V Emperor.
1521. Luther at the Diet of Worms. Loyola wounded at Pam-
peluna.
1525. Baber won the battle of Panipat, captured Delhi, and
founded the Mogul Empire.
1527. The German troops in Italy, under the Constable of Bour-
bon, took and pillaged Rome.
1529. Suleiman besieged Vienna.
1530. Pizarro invaded Peru. Charles V crowned by the Pope.
Henry VIII began his quarrel with the Papacy.
1532. The Anabaptists seized Minister.
1535. Fall of the Anabaptist rule in Minister.
1539. The Company of Jesus founded.
1543. Copernicus died.
1545. The Council of Trent (to 1563) assembled to put the
church in order.
1546. Martin Luther died.
1547. Ivan IV (the Terrible) took the title of Tsar of Russia.
Francis I died.
1549. First Jesuit missions arrived in South America.
1552. Treaty of Passau. Temporary pacification of Germany.
1556. Charles V abdicated. Akbar Great Mogul (to 1605).
Ignatius of Loyola died.
1558. Death of Charles V.
1563. End of the Council of Trent and the reform of the Catholic
Church.
1564. Galileo born.
CHRONOLOGICAL TABLE 619
A.D.
1566. Suleiman the Magnificent died.
1567. Revolt of the Netherlands.
1568. Execution of Counts Egmont and Horn.
1571. Kepler born.
1573. Siege of Alkmaar.
1578. Harvey born.
1583. Sir Walter Raleigh's expedition to Virginia.
1601. Tycho Brahe died.
1603. James I King of England and Scotland. Dr. Gilbert died.
1605. Jehangir Great Mogul.
1606. Virginia Company founded.
1609. Holland independent.
1618. Thirty Years War began.
1620. Mayflower expedition founded New Plymouth. First negro
slaves landed at Jamestown (Va.).
1625. Charles I of England.
1626. Sir Francis Bacon (Lord Verulam) died.
1628. Shah Jehan Great Mogul. The English Petition of Right.
1629. Charles I of England began his eleven years of rule without
a parliament.
1630. Kepler died.
1632. Leeuwenhoek born. Gustavus Adolphus killed at the
Battle of Ltitzen.
1634. Wallenstein murdered.
1638. Japan closed to Europeans (until 1865).
1640. Charles I of England summoned the Long Parliament.
1641. Massacre of the English in Ireland.
1642. Galileo died. Newton born.
1643. Louis XIV began his reign of seventy-two years.
1644. The Manchus ended the Ming dynasty.
1645. Swine pens in the inner town of Leipzig pulled down.
1648. Treaty of Westphalia. Thereby Holland and Switzerland
were recognized as free republics and Prussia became
important. The treaty gave a complete victory neither to
the Imperial Crown nor to the Princes.
War of the Fronde; it ended in the complete victory
of the French crown.
620 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
A.D.
1649. Execution of Charles I of England.
1658. Aurungzeb Great Mogul. Cromwell died.
1660. Charles II of England.
1674. Nieuw Amsterdam finally became British by treaty and
was renamed New York.
1683. The last Turkish attack on Vienna defeated by John III
of Poland.
1688. The British Revolution. Flight of James II. William
and Mary began to reign.
1689. Peter the Great of Russia (to 1725).
1690. Battle of the Boyne in Ireland.
1694. Voltaire born.
1701. Frederick I first King of Prussia.
1704. John Locke, the father of modern democratic theory, died.
1707. Death of Aurungzeb. The empire of the Great Mogul
disintegrated.
1713. Frederick the Great of Prussia born.
1714. George I of Britain.
1715. Louis XV of France.
1727. Newton died. George II of Britain.
1732. Oglethorpe founded Georgia.
1736. Nadir Shah raided India. (The beginning of twenty years
of raiding and disorder in India.)
1740. Maria-Theresa began to reign. (Being a woman, she
could not be empress. Her husband, Francis I, was em-
peror until his death in 1765, when her son, Joseph II,
succeeded him.)
1740. Accession of Frederick the Great, King of Prussia.
1741. The Empress Elizabeth of Russia began to reign.
1755-63. Britain and France struggled for America and India.
France in alliance with Austria and Russia against Prussia
and Britain (1756-63) ; the Seven Years' War.
1757. Battle of Plassey.
1759. The British general Wolfe took Quebec.
1760. George III of Britain.
1762. The Empress Elizabeth of Russia died. Murder of the
Tsar Paul, and accession of Catherine the Great of Russia
(to 1796).
CHRONOLOGICAL TABLE 621
A.D.
1763. Peace of Paris ; Canada ceded to Britain. British domi-
nant in India.
1764. Battle of Buxar.
1769. Napoleon Bonaparte born.
1774. Louis XVI began his reign. Suicide of Clive. The
American revolutionary drama began.
1775. Battle of Lexington.
1776. Declaration of Independence by the United States of
America.
1778. J. J. Rousseau, the creator of modern democratic sentiment,
died.
1780. End of the reign of Maria-Theresa. The Emperor Joseph
(1765 to 1790) succeeded her in the hereditary Habsburg
dominions.
1783. Treaty of Peace between Britain and the new United States
of America. Quaco set free in Massachusetts.
1787. The Constitutional Convention of Philadelphia set up the
Federal Government of the United States. France dis-
covered to be bankrupt. The Assembly of the Notables.
1788. First Federal Congress of the United States at New York.
1789. The French States-General assembled. Storming of the
Bastille.
1791. The Jacobin Revolution. Flight to Varennes.
1792. France declared war on Austria; Prussia declared war on
France. Battle of Valmy. France became a republic.
1793. Louis XVI beheaded.
1794. Execution of Robespierre and end of the Jacobin republic.
Rule of the Convention.
1795. The Directory. Bonaparte suppressed a revolt and went
to Italy as commander-in-chief .
1797. By the Peace of Campo Formio Bonaparte destroyed the
Republic of Venice.
1798. Bonaparte went to Egypt. Battle of the Nile.
1799. Bonaparte returned. He became First Consul with enor-
mous powers.
1800. Legislative union of Ireland and England enacted January
1st, 1801.
622 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
A.D.
1800. Napoleon's campaign against Austria. Battles of Ma-
rengo (in Italy) and Hohenlinden (Moreau's victory).
1801. Preliminaries of peace between France, England, and Aus-
tria signed.
1803. Bonaparte occupied Switzerland, and so precipitated war.
1804. Bonaparte became Emperor. Francis II took the title of
Emperor of Austria in 1805, and in 1806 he dropped the
title of Holy Roman Emperor. So the "Holy Roman
Empire" came to an end.
1805. Battle of Trafalgar. Battles of Ulm and Austerlitz.
1806. Prussia overthrown at Jena.
1807. Battles of Eylau and Friedland and Treaty of Tilsit.
1808. Napoleon made his brother Joseph King of Spain.
1810. Spanish America became republican.
1811. Alexander withdrew from the ' ' Continental System. ' '
1812. Moscow.
1814. Abdication of Napoleon. Louis XVIII.
1815. The Waterloo campaign. The Treaty of Vienna.
1819. The First Factory Act passed through the efforts of Robert
Owen.
1821. The Greek revolt.
1824. Charles X of France.
1825. Nicholas I of Russia.
1827. Battle of Navarino.
1829. Greece independent.
1830. A year of disturbance. Louis Philippe ousted Charles X.
Belgium broke away from Holland. Leopold of Saxe-
Coburg-Gotha became king of this new country, Bel-
gium. Russian Poland revolted ineffectually. First
railway (Liverpool to Manchester).
1832. The First Reform Bill in Britain restored the democratic
character of the British Parliament.
1835. The word socialism first used.
1837. Queen Victoria.
1840. Queen Victoria married Prince Albert of Saxe-Coburg-
Gotha.
1848. Another year of disturbance. Republics in France and
CHRONOLOGICAL TABLE 623
A.D.
Rome. The Pan-slavic conference at Prague, All Ger-
many united in a parliament at Frankfort. German unity
destroyed by the King of Prussia.
1851. The Great Exhibition of London.
1852. Napoleon III Emperor of the French.
1854. Perry (second expedition) landed in Japan. Nicholas I
occupied the Danubian provinces of Turkey.
1854-56. Crimean War.
1856. Alexander II of Russia.
1857. The Indian Mutiny.
1858. Robert Owen died.
1859. Franco-Austrian war. Battles of Magenta and Solferino.
1861. Victor Emmanuel First King of Italy. Abraham Lincoln
became President U.S.A. The American Civil War began.
1863. British bombarded a Japanese town.
1864. Maximilian became Emperor of Mexico.
1865. Surrender of Appomattox Court House. Japan opened to
the world.
1866. Prussia and Italy attacked Austria (and the south German
states in alliance with her). Battle of Sadowa.
1867. The Emperor Maximilian shot.
1870. Napoleon III declared war against Prussia.
1871. Paris surrendered (January). The King of Prussia became
William I, " German Emperor." The Hohenzollern Peace
of Frankfort.
1875. The "Bulgarian atrocities."
1877. Russo-Turkish War. Treaty of San Stefano. Queen Vic-
toria became Empress of India.
1878. The Treaty of Berlin. The Armed Peace of forty-six years
began in western Europe.
1881. The Battle of Majuba Hill. The Transvaal free.
1883. Britain occupied Egypt.
1886. Gladstone's first Irish Home Rule Bill.
1888. Frederick II (March), William II (June), German
Emperors.
1890. Bismarck dismissed. Heligoland ceded to Germany by
Lord Salisbury.
624 THE OUTLINE OF HISTORY
A.D.
1894-95. Japanese war with China.
1895. " Unionist" (Imperialist) government in Britain.
1896. Battle of Adowa.
1898. The Fashoda quarrel between France and Britain. Ger-
many acquired Kiau-Chau.
1899. The war in South Africa began (Boer war).
1900. The Boxer risings in China. Siege of the Legations at Pe-
king.
1904. The British invaded Tibet.
1904-5. Russo-Japanese war.
1906. The " Unionist" (Imperialist) party in Great Britain de-
feated by the Liberals upon the question of tariffs.
1907. The Confederation of South Africa established.
1908. Austria annexed Bosnia and Herzegovina.
1909. M. Bleriot flew in an aeroplane from France to England.
1911. Italy made war on Turkey and seized Tripoli.
1912. China became a republic.
1913. The Balkan league made war on Turkey. Bloodshed at
Londonderry in Ireland caused by " Unionist" gun
running.
1914. The Great War in Europe began (for which see special time
chart on pp. 528-29).
1917. The two Russian revolutions. Establishment of the Bol-
shevik regime in Russia.
1919-20. The Clemenceau Peace of Versailles.
1920. First meeting of the League of Nations, from which Ger-
many, Austria, Russia, and Turkey were excluded, and
at which the United States was not represented.
And here our Outline breaks off.
INDEX
KEY TO PRONUNCIATION
VOWELS
a as in far (far), father (fa' thux), mikado (mi ka' do).
a fat (fat), ample (am pi), abstinence (ab' stin ens).
a fate (fat), wait (wat), deign (dan), jade (jad).
aw " fall (fawl), appal (a pawl'), broad (brawd).
fair (far), bear (bar), where (hwar).
bell (bel), bury (ber' i).
beef (bef), thief (thef), idea (I de' a), beer (ber), casino (ka se' no).
i bit (bit), lily (lil' i), nymph (nimf), build (bild).
i bite (bit), analyze (an' a liz), light (lit).
o not (not), watch (woch), cough (kof), sorry (sor' i).
6 no (no), blow (bio), brooch (broch).
6 north (north), .absorb (ab sorb').
00 ' food (food), do (doo), prove (proov), blue (bloo), strew (stroo).
bull (bul), good (gud), would (wud).
sun (sun), love (luv), enough (e nuf).
u muse (muz), stew (stu), cure (ktir).
u her (hur), search (surch), word (wurd), bird (burd).
ou " bout (bout), bough (bou), crowd (kroud).
01 ' join (join), joy (joi), buoy (boi)
A short mark placed over italic a, e, o, or u (&, e, d, u), signifies that the
vowel has an obscure, indeterminate, or slurred sound, as in : —
advice (&d vis'), current (kur' £nt), notion (no' sMn),
breakable (bra' kd bl), sailor (sa' l<5r), pleasure (plezh' wr).
CONSONANTS
" s " is used only for the sibilant " s " (as in " toast," tost, " place," plas) ;
the sonant " s " (as in " toes," " plays ") is printed " z " (toz, plaz).
" c " (except in the combinations " ch " and " ch "), " q " and " x " are
not used.
b, d, f, h (but see the combinations below), k, 1, m, n (see n below), p, r, t, v,
z, and w and y when used as consonants have their usual values.
ch as in church (church), batch (bach), capriccio (ka pre' ch5).
ch ' " loch (loch), coronach (kor' o nacA), clachan (klac/i' an).
g || get (get), finger (fing' gSr).
j " join (join), judge (juj), germ (jurm), ginger (jin' j£r).
§"i (in List of Proper Names only) as in Ludwig (luf vigh).
( " " " ) " " Llandeilo (hlan di' 16).
hw as in white (hwit), nowhere (n5' hwar).
n " " cabochon (ka bo show'), conge (konf zha).
sh | " shawl (shawl), mention (men' sh#n).
zh ' " measure (mezh' wr), vision (vizh' dn).
th " " thin (thin), breath (breth).
th " " thine (thin), breathe (bre^).
The accent (') follows the syllable to be stressed.
INDEX
AAR (ar) VALLEY, ii, 199
Aaronson, Aaron, i, 184
Abbasids (abas'idz), ii, 30-36, 61, 64,
70, 106, 126, 613
Abbott, E., i, 6
Abbott, W. J. Lewis, i, 68
Abd Manif (abd man ef ') , ii, 5
Abdal Malik (abd jil ma' lik), ii, 28
Abelard, P., ii, 171
Aboukir (a boo ker'), ii, 352, 353
Aboukir, cruiser, ii, 520
Abraham the Patriarch, i, 196, 278, 282,
293-94, 576, ii, 6
Absolution, ii, 216
Abu Bekr (a/ boo bek' er) , ii, 6, 7, 8,
13-22, 34, 612
Abul Abbas, ii, 30, 31, 613
Abul Fazl (a' bool fa' zl), ii, 135
Abydos (d bl' dos), i, 335, 340
Abyssinia, i, 156, 160, 359, ii, 461
Abyssinian Christians, i, 603, 618, ii,
3, 8 ; language, i, 154
Academic des Sciences, ii, 239
Academy, Greek, i, 351, 354-57
Academy of Inscriptions, ii, 312
Achilles (a kil' ez), i, 177
Acre, i, 212, ii, 353
Acropolis (a krop' 6 lis), i, 306, 337
Act of Union, ii, 492
Actium (ak'ti#m), battle of, i, 514, ii,
609
Acts of the Apostles, i, 587, 589
Adam and Eve, ii, 418
Adams, Prof. G. B., ii, 46
Adams, John, ii, 300, 303
Adams, Samuel, ii, 290, 303
Adams, W. P., ii, 532
Adams, William, ii, 465
Addington, ii, 359
Aden, i, 160, 197, ii, 32, 471
Adowa (a'dowa), battle of, ii, 461,
469, 500, 624
Adrianople, i, 554, ii, 122, 502 ; Treaty
of, ii, 382
Adriatic, i, 274, 389, 452, 461, 471, 540,
561, 606, 616, ii, 54, 80, 364, 509
Adriatic river, i, 119, 120
^Egatian Isles, i, 471, ii, 608
JLgean (e je' tin), cities, i, 234; civili-
zation, i, 213-16, 281, 300; Dark
Whites, i, 447 ; hunters, i, 317
jEgina (e jl'nd), i, 337
^Eneid (e' ne id), the, i, 448
^Eolic dialect, i, 300
Aeroplanes, i, 5, ii, 392, 519, 523
^Eschylus (es' ki Ms), i, 221, 355, ii, 607
Afghanistan, i, 153, 201, 396, 431, 433,
627-28, 643, ii, 133, 257
Africa, i, 57, 74, 109, 120, 145, 154-56,
162, 281, 489, 509, ii, 114, 139, 153;
peoples of, i, 86, 109, 138, 141, 149,
158-60, 195-201, 206, 234 ; languages
of, i, 161-62; early trade with, i,
217, 273 ; Moslems in, i, 217, 565, ii,
22, 24, 30, 31, 41, 51, 64, 65, 613;
voyages and travels in, i, 218, 509, ii,
185-88, 252; Phoenicians in, i, 448,
482-84, 513, 570, 640 ; Roman, i, 470,
478-79, 498, 540, 560, 606; Vandals
in, i, 556, 606, 615, ii, 611; slavery
in, ii, 193, 225, 306 ; modern exploita-
tion of, ii, 451, 458-60, 484
Africa, Central, i, 158, 558 ; East, i, 42,
178 ; South (see South Africa) ; West,
i, 219, ii, 193
African lung fish, i, 25
Aga Khan (a' ga kan'), ii, 473
Agincourt, ii, 179
Agriculture, early, i, 104, 108, 113-14,
116, 133, 137, 158, 171, 190, 254, 317;
slaves in, i, 259 ; Arab knowledge of,
ii, 38 ; in Great Britain, ii, 272, 273
Agriculturists, i, 264, 267, 271
Agrigentum (ag ri gen' turn) , i, 469
Agrippina (ag ri pi' n#) , i, 525
Ahriman (a' ri man), i, 625, 626
Ainu (!' noo), i, 139, 148, ii, 262, 464
Air, the, i, 5, 23, 36
Air Force, ii, 570
Aisjie (an), ii, 515 ; battle of the, ii, 48
Aix-la-Chapelle, ii, 60, 63
Akbar (ak'bur), ii, 133-37, 256, 618
Akhnaton (akna'ton). (See Ameno-
phis IV)
627
628
INDEX
Akkadia (and Akkadians), i, 191, 245
Akkadian-Sumerian Empire, i, 196, 279,
ii, 606
Akki, i, 279
Alabama, the, ii, 443-^4
Alamanni, i, 553, ii, 48, 610
Alans, i, 549-54, 627-28, ii, 609
Alaric (al' & rik), i, 554, 561, ii, 611
Alaska, ii, 505
Alban, St., ii, 50
Alban Mount, i, 448
Albania, ii, 522
Albert, Prince Consort, ii, 436, 486, 622
Albertus Magnus, ii, 171
Albigenses (al bi jen' sez), ii, 92, 95, 219
Alcarez (al car' ez), ii, 208
Alchemists, ii, 174
Alcibiades (al si bi' a dez), i, 351
Alcmseonidse (alk me on' i de) , i, 314
Alcohol, discovery of, ii, 38
Alcuin (al'kwin), ii, 59
Alemanni. (See Alamanni)
Aleppo, ii, 76
Alexander the Great, i, 133, 195, 198,
200, 205, 217, 252, 253, 277, 345, 352,
357-59, 366-99, 412, 428, 430, 445,
452, 467, 484, 507, 510, 512, 522, 542,
546, 562, 597, 615-16, 643, ii, 20, 51,
78, 114, 145, 199, 303, 608; empire of
(maps) , i, 393, 398 ; mother of, i, 452
Alexander, son of Alexander the Great,
i, 394
Alexander II, king of Egypt, i, 500
Alexander I, tsar of Russia, ii, 362-66,
370-76, 382, 405, 411, 476-77, 622
Alexander II, tsar of Russia, ii, 623
Alexander III (pope), ii, 97, 615
Alexander VI (pope), ii, 195, 617
Alexandretta, i, 379, 383
Alexandria, i, 13, 383, 389, 395-96, 428,
463, 497, 515, 532, 538, 562, 587, 601,
602, 604, ii, 36, 91, 168, 351, 611;
museum at, i, 359, 402-13, 476, 490,
636; culture and religion of, i, 401-
14, 590-91, 602, ii, 37; library at,
i, 405, 411 ; Serapeum, i, 413, 414
Alexandrian cities, i, 273
Alexius Comnenus (a lek' si us kom ne'-
n#s), ii, 72-80
Alfred, king, ii, 54, 148, 614
Algae, i, 10
Algebra (al' je bra), i, 219, ii, 37, 88
Algeria, i, 102, 217, 565, ii, 501
Algiers, ii, 126, 225, 470
Ali (a' le), nephew of Muhammad, ii,
6-8, 13, 26-31, 64, 613
Alkmaar (alk mar'), siege of, ii, 230-32
Allah, ii, 9-20, 24, 20
Alleghany mountains, ii, 280
Allen, Grant, i, 131
Allen, W. A. C., i, 294
Alp Arslan (alp ars Ian'), ii, 72
Alphabets, i, 228, 304, 422, 627, 638-40
Alpine race, i, 146
Alps, the, i, 35, 52, 75, 471, 475, 508, 606,
ii, 58, 63, 69, 194
Alsace, i, 553, ii, 200, 236, 244, 446
Alstadt, ii, 180
Altai (al'ti), the, i, 546, 633
Altamira (al tamer' a), cave of, i, 93,
ii, 605
Aluminium, ii, 389
Alva, General, ii, 229-32
Alyattes (a Ii at' ez), i, 316
Amadis Cam' d dis) de Gaul, ii, 165, 166
Ambar, ii, 136
Amber, i, 105, 532
Amenophis (am <!? no' fis) III, i, 200, 220,
245, 250, 288
Amenophis IV, i, 196, 220, 245, 250, 251,
255, 281, 288, 412, 446, ii, 605
America, i, 56, 59, 100, 219, ii, 254, 400 ;
prehistoric, i, 100, 102-03, 107, 148,
207, 208 ; races of, i, 100, 102-03, 138,
141, 158; languages of, i, 150, 158,
164; discovery of, i, 635, 640, ii, 53,
84, 117, 185 sqq., 193, 251-52, 209,
617; European settlements in, ii,
252-55, 271, 273, 278-94, 304, 619.
(See also United States)
America, Central, drawings, i, 207
America, South, i, 207, ii, 166, 187, 192-
93, 200, 378, 457, 622
American Indians, i, 113, 124, 137, 143,
157-60, 207, 225, ii, 166, 187, 189,
254, 292, 304-05, 464
American king-crab, i, 10; picture
writing, i, 207
Amiens, ii, 530 ; Peace of, ii, 355, 359
Amir, ii, 124
Amman (Philadelphia), i, 621-22
Ammianus, i, 607
Ammon, i, 249-52, 383, 399, 412, 602
Ammonites, i, 46
Ammonites, a people, i, 294
Amoeba (d me' ba), i, 16
Amorites, i, 191, 279
Amos the prophet, i, 294
Amphibia, i, 26, 28, 38, 52, 55
Amphictyonies (am fik' ti <5n iz), i, 313,
ii, 3, 8
Amphion, cruiser, ii, 512
Amphipolis (am fip' 6 lis), i, 371, 372
Amritzar (am rit' sdr), ii, 456
INDEX
629
Amur (a moor'), ii, 261
Anabaptists, ii, 156, 157, 162, 618
Anabasis (d nab' & sis), the, i, 342
Anagni (a nan' ye), ii, 99, 616
Anatolia, ii, 72, 121
Anatolian peninsula, i, 623
Anatomy, i, 402-04, ii, 177
Anaxagoras (an dk sag' d ras) , i, 349,
358, 364
Andaman (an' dd man) Islands, i, 139
Andes, i, 35, 52
Andronicus (an dr<5 m' k#s), ii, 124
Angelo, St., ii, 612
Angles, i, 554, 605, ii, 50, 54, 66
Anglia, East, ii, 40
Anglicanism, ii, 163
Anglo-Norman feudalism, ii, 43
"Anglo-Saxon," ii, 487-88
Anglo-Saxons, i, 564, 605, 612, ii, 47,
130, 149
Animals, i, 10, 16-23, 25-27, 52-57, 64,
66, 67, 102, 105, 112, 116, 128, 254.
(See also Mammals)
Anio, the, i, 458, 610
Anna Comnena (kom ne' nd) , ii, 79
Annam, i, 634, 640, ii, 262, 467, 470
Anne, queen, ii, 226
Anselm, St., ii, 171
Antarctic birds, i, 44
Antigonus (an tig' 6 n#s) , i, 395
Antimony, i, 106
Antioch, i, 529, 589, 598, 604, 617-21,
ii, 19, 78-81, 610
Antiochus (an tl' 6 kfls) III, i, 474, 482,
483
Antiochus IV, i, 572
Antonines, i, 526-31, 537-40, ii, 610
Antoninus (an to m' n$s) , Marcus Aure-
lius, i, 526-2S, 540, ii, 153, 610
Antoninus Pius, i, 526, 530, ii, 610
Antony, i, 512, 514, 515
Antwerp, ii, 180, 184
Anu, i, 245
Anubis (dnu'bis), Egyptian god, i, 236
Anytus (an' i ttfs), i, 352
Apamea (ap d me' d), i, 621
Apes, i, 65-67, 230; anthropoid, i,
57, 63, 65-66, 73
Aphelion, i, 30-34
Apion, i, 500
Apis (a' pis), i, 382, 412, 413, 590
Apollinaris Sidonius, i, 607
Apollo, i, 313, 325, 376, 611
Apollonius (a p<5 16' ni Us), i, 402
Appian Way, i, 461, 505
Apples, i, 113
Appomattox Court House, ii, 444, 623
Apuleius (ap u le' Us), i, 607
Aquileia (a kwe la' yd), i, 461, 559
Aquinas (dkwl'nds), ii, 168, 171
Arabia, i, 37, 109, 121, 154, 156, 160, 184,
196, 197, 218, 229, 273, 281, 295, 401,
533, 618, 624, 634, ii, 1-6, 11, 17, 18,
24, 51, 75, 105. (See also Arabs)
Arabian Nights, the, ii, 32
Arabic language and literature, i, 148,
153, 530-31, 623, ii, 3-4, 22, 29, 31,
34-35, 159
Arabs, i, 188, 217, 327, 565, 570, 634,
ii, 1-8, 15-21, 28, 32, 39, 41, 61, 67,
114, 149, 159, 257, 613; culture of, i,
636, ii, 34-39, 88, 149, 168, 174-75
Aral sea, i, 153, 159, 387
Aral-Caspian region, i, 317
Arameans, i, 192, 218, 258, 259, 265,
570, 631, ii, 1
Arbela (arbe'ld), battle of, i, 384, 479,
ii, 608
Arcadius, i, 554, ii, 611
Archaeopteryx (ar ke op' ter iks), i, 45
Archseozoic (ar ke o zo' ik) period, i, 9.
(See also Azoic)
Archer, William, ii, 473
Archers, i, 370
Archimedes (ar ki me' dez) , i, 402, 476,
534
Architecture, ii, 60, 179
Arctic birds, i, 44 ; Circle, i, 632 ; Ocean,
i, 153 ; seas, ii, 142
Ardashir (ar da sher') I, i, 617, 625, ii,
610
Ardennes, ii, 514
Argentine republic, i, 161, ii, 457
Argon, ii, 119
Argonne, ii, 329
Argos, i, 453, 454
Ariadne (ariad'ni), i, 216
Arians (ar' i dnz), i, 592, 601
Aridams (ar i de' tfs), i, 375, 394
Aristagoras (ar is tag' 6 ras), i, 341, 342
Aristarchus, i, 384
Aristides (ar is ti' dez) , i, 312, 313, 337,
346
Aristocracy, i, 188, 265, 308
Aristodemus (ar is id de' mtfs), i, 336
Aristophanes (ar is tof a nez), i, 221, 355,
ii, 607
Aristotle, i, 220, 305, 314, 357-59, 379,
383, 392, 397, 402, 411, 434, 493, 530,
562, ii, 35, 37, 88, 146, 168-69, 173,
245, 419, 432 ; Politics of, i, 308, 309,
462, 467, ii, 169
Arithmetic, i, 219
Arius (a ri' iis), i, 592, 600, 648
630
INDEX
Arizona, ii, 505
Ark of bulrushes, i, 209
Ark of the Covenant, i, 245, 284-88
Aries (arl), i, 600, 601, 609, ii, 611
Armadillo, giant, i, 102, 207
Armenia (and the Armenians), i, 169,
318, 395, 505, 523, 526, 548, 549, 603,
616, 620, ii, 21, 64, 72, 114, 118, 121,
125, 153
Armenian language, i, 151, 169, ii, 138
Arno, i, 451, 460, 461
Arras, ii, 324, 517
Arrow, i, 508, 549
Arrow heads, i, 104, 107, 114, 130
Arrow straighteners, i, 90, 99
Arsacids (ar sas' idz), i, 523, 616, ii, 610
Arses, i, 342
Art, Buddhist, i, 428; Cretan, i, 215;
Neolithic, i, 130; Palaeolithic, i, 92-
99, 123
Artabanus (ar U ba' ntts), i, 335
Artaxerxes II, i, 342, 363
Artaxerxes UI, i, 342
Arthur, king, i, 531
Artillery, i, 372, ii, 124
Artisans, i, 264-269
Artois (ar twa') , Count of. (See Charles
X)
Aryan, definition of, i, 298 ; languages
and literature, i, 133, 151-55, 161-64,
167-69, 173, 298, 387, 446, ii, 247;
peoples and civilizations, i, 152, 160,
167 sqq., 189, 194, 201, 232-33, 243-44,
247, 281-82, 298-300, 305, 315-18,
387, 415-16, 446^8, 545, 549-51,
558, ii, 144, 168, 184, 190, 490, 605
Aryan Way, the, i, 417, 424, 433, 440, 449
As, Roman coin, i, 471
Ascalon, i, 282
Asceticism, i, 418, 420
Ashdod, i, 245, 282
Ashley, Sir W., ii, 287
Ashtaroth (ash' td roth), i, 282, 286, 288
Asia, general and early period, i, 56,
59, 75, 77, 86, 100, 102, 10S, 109, 118,
153, 157-160, 195, 273, 299, 317, 318,
536, 542^9, 551, 557, 624, 627, ii, 69,
98, 105-08, 114, 153, 168, 185, 247,
449, 464, 610 ; Greeks in, i, 327, 375,
390, 396 ; Romans in, i, 397, 482, 501,
533, 539 ; tribes and people of, i, 508,
545-52, ii, 113, 127, 134, 137, 259, 266;
Christianity in, i, 517, 597, 604, 617, ii,
79, 114, 116, 117; Turks in, i, 61&-23,
ii, 24, 28, 51, 64, 66, 121, 123 ; voyages
and travels in, i, 627-29, 642-43, ii,
187, 193, 194, 462
Asia, Central, i, 102, 138, 159, 160, 298,
541, 547, ii, 32, 139, 194, 261 ; tribes,
people, and civilization of, i, 184, 387,
507, 604, ii, 127
Asia, Eastern, i, 140-41
Asia, South-eastern, languages of, i, 157
Asia, Western, i, 89, 145, ii, 106, 168;
tribes, people, and civilization of, i,
141, 145, 218, 234, ii, 168
Asia Minor, i, 107, 109, 153, 196, 220,
265, 298, 318, 327, 395, 503-06, 509,
617, 622, ii, 28, 114, 137, 153; tribes
and people of, i, 189, 213, 298, 315-17,
388, 447-48; Greeks in, i, 300, 302,
304, 308, 315-16, 340, ii, 606 ; Gauls
in, i, 395, 449, ii, 608; Turks in, ii, 31,
33, 72, 106, 114, 121
Asiatics, intellectual status of, ii, 462
Asoka (asho'ka), King, i, 196, 411,
431, 432, 489, 628, 646, ii, 133, 608
Aspasia (aspa'shia), i, 345-46, 349-50,
355
Asquith, Rt. Hon. H. H., ii, 432, 496,
518
Ass, wild, i, 217
Assam, ii, 453
Assisi (ase'zi), ii, 93
Assur, i, 192, 412
AssurbanipaL (See Sardanapalus)
Assyria (and Assyrians), i, 192-94, 199,
205, 216, 225, 240, 243-47, 256, 262,
277, 290-95, 300, 315-17, 319, 327,
342, 383, 384, 446, 526, 570, ii, 1, 244,
606
Assyrian language and writing, i, 153,
228
Asteroids, i, 4
Astrologers, ii, 175
Astronomy, i, 5, 240, 364, ii, 37, 114,
175-76
Athanasius, i, 592, 601, 648
Atheism, ii, 333
Athene (& the' ne), i, 348
Athens, i, 262, 302-13, 330-52, 372, 378,
385, 457, 461, 467, 536, 589, 623, ii,
483, 502, 524; social and political, i,
220, 309-12, 348, 352-57, 368, 460, ii,
147 ; literature and learning, i, 343—
66, 404, 405, 409, 613, 618, 637, 645, ii,
54, 612
Atkinson, C. F., ii, 332
Atkinson, J. J., i, 79, 125, 257, ii, 341
Atlantic Ocean, i, 75-76, 119, 120, 138,
153, 532, 640, ii, 22, 84, 193, 267;
navigation of, i, 217, ii, 185-88, 192,
387, 617
Atlantosaurus (at Ian to saw' r#s) , i, 42
INDEX
631
Atmosphere, i, 4, 5, 34
Aton (a' ton), Egyptian god, i, 250
Atonement, i, 575, 588
Attalus (at'dltts), i, 375
Attalus I, i, 396
Attalus III, i, 397, 483, 499, ii, 609
Attica (at' i kd), i, 332-33, 457
Attila (at'ild), i, 174, 557-59, 608, 628-
29, ii, 42, 611
Aughrim, battle of, ii, 492
Augsburg, ii, 206, 210
Augurs, Roman, i, 464
Augustine, St., Bishop of Hippo, i,
592, 598, 604, 607, 612, ii, 56, 73, 611
Augustus Csesar, Roman Emperor, i,
513-18, 522, 523, 535, 542, 598, ii, 75,
609
Aurangzeb. (See Aurungzeb)
Aurelian, emperor, i, 528, 535, 553, 602,
617, ii, 610
Aurignac, i, 96
Aurignacian (aw rig na' shun) age, i,
96, 97, 173
Aurochs (aw'roks), i, 76, 92, 101
Aurungzeb (aw rung zab') , ii, 133, 256,
453, 620
Ausculum, battle of, i, 453, ii, 608
Ausonius (aw so' ni us) , i, 607
Austerlitz, ii, 362, 622
Austin, Mary, i, 264
Australia, i, 37, 82, 206, 635, ii, 451,
456, 471, 472 ; aborigines of, i, 98, 139-
40, 172
Australian language, i, 162 ; lung-fish, i,
25 ; throwing-stick, i, 90
Australoids, i, 139, 141, 148, 159, 206
Austrasia, ii, 45, 47, 48, 613
Austria, ii, 200, 204, 233, 240-44, 251,
278, 314, 320, 327, 378-80, 400, 446-
47; wars with France, ii, 327, 332,
351, 355, 361, 368, 441, 621; war
with Prussia, ii, 442-45, 623; in
Great War, ii, 510, 531, 566, 624
Autocracy, i, 342, ii, 220
Automobiles, ii, 392
Avars, i, 560, 564, 616, 620, ii, 24, 48,
69, 113
Avebury, i, 110, 183, 196, 448
Avebury, Lord, i, 80, 106-07, 110, 115,
118, 134, ii, 426
Averroes (aver'oez), ii, 37, 88, 168,
171, 615
Avicenna (avisen'a), ii, 37, 168, 614
Avignon (avenyon'), ii, 84, 99, 127,
148, 617
Axes, ancient, i, 104-07, 112-14, 132
Axis of e$rth, i, 57
Ayesha (I'esha), ii, 12, 26
Azilian age, i, 90, 94, 97, 101, 120, 133,
152
Azoic (a zo' ik) period, i, 9, 14, 17, 30
Azores, ii, 185
Aztecs, ii, 189-90
BAAL, i, 237, 283, 292
Baalbek (bal bek'), i, 621, ii, 3
Babel, Tower of, i, 190
Baber, ii, 133, 200, i256, 618
Baboons, i, 65, 67, 230
Babylon (and Babylonia), i, 192-201,
218-23, 228, 245-60, 263-67, 277-79,
290-95, 315, 317, 319-20, 326, 342,
364, 383, 385, 389, 394, 411-12, 416,
424, 436, 449, 483, 497, 508, 509, 533,
570, 583, 619-23, 631, 632, ii, 1, 71,
130, 276, 342, 606, 607 ; religion of, i,
238-^2, 245-48, 278, 296, 400, 431
Bacchus, i, 515
Bacharach, ii, 180
Back Bay, ii, 290
Bacon, Francis, Lord Verulam, i, 358, ii,
166, 176, 619
Bacon, Roger, ii, 168, 172-77, 385, 616
Bactria (and Bactrians), i, 385, 387-90,
396, 549, 616, ii, 138
Baden, ii, 445
Badr (bad' er), battle of, ii, 8, 28, 612
Baedeker, ii, 242
Baganda, i, 206
Bagaudse, ii, 157
Bagdad, ii, 31-38, 61, 64, 70, 71, 76, 80,
106, 113, 126, 130, 522, 613, 618
Bagoas (ba go' as), i, 342
Bahamas, ii, 254, 255, 471
Baikal (bikal'), ii, 108
Baldwin of Flanders, ii, 81, 168, 229
Balearic Isles, i, 556
Balfour, Rt. Hon. A. J., ii, 552
Balkan peninsula, i, 102, 153, 196, 298,
300, 317, 395, 451, ii, 58, 122, 139, 184,
446, 501, 509, 606, 624
Balkash, lake, ii, 108
Balkh, ii, 118
Ball, Dyer, i, 642
Ball, John, ii, 155, 156
Ball, Sir Robert, i, 30
Balliol College, ii, 96
Balloons, i, 5
Baltic Sea, i, 59, 102, 153, 159, 171, 510,
533, 539, 549-53, 641, ii, 53, 65, 71,
129, 182, 233, 235-36, 251, 266, 526
Baltimore, Lord, ii, 281
632
INDEX
Baluchistan. (See Beluchistan)
Bambyce (bam bl' se), i, 621
Bannockburn, ii, 175
Bantu, i, 158, 162, 189
Barbados, ii, 254
Barbarians, ii, 267-69
Barbarossa, Frederick. (See Frederick
I, emperor)
Barber, M. H., ii, 503
Barbusse, ii, 513
Barca family, i, 472, 473
Barcelona, ii, 51, 180
Bards, i, 172, 230
Baring, Maurice, ii, 503
Barley, i, 113, 172, 558
Baroda (ba ro' dd), ii, 257
Barons, Revolt of the, ii, 219
Barras (ba ra'), ii, 339, 350
Barrows, i, 109, 117, 144, 168, 171, 175,
176, 183, 196, 197
Barry, Comtesse du. (See Du Barry)
Basle, Council of, ii, 100, 153, 617
Basque language, i, 161, 162, 167, 189;
race, i, 161, 162, 168, ii, 490
Basra, ii, 36, 522
Bassett, ii, 282
Bassompierre, ii, 318
Bastille, ii, 313, 621
Basu, Bhupendranath, i, 179, 181, 182
Basutoland, ii, 472
Batavian Republic, ii, 347
Bateman, T., i, 134
Bats, i, 43
Bauer, i, 359
Bauernstand, i, 268
Bavaria (and Bavarians), ii, 48, 57, 178,
445, 485
Bayezid (bl e zed') II, Sultan, ii, 126, 617
Baylen, ii, 364
Bazaine, General, ii, 445
Beaconsfield, Earl of, ii, 227, 426, 430,
436, 447, 455, 487
Beal, i, 642
Bears, i, 69, 76, 78, 93, 94
Beauharnais, Josephine de, ii, 350, 364,
374
Beauty, artistic, i, 215
Beaver, European, i, 69
Beazley, Raymond, ii, 67, 129, 185
Bede, the Venerable, i, 608, ii. 50, 613
Bedouins, i, 264, 278, 622, ii, 3, 8, 10, 17,
24
Beech, fossil, i, 51
Beer, G. L., ii, 287
Bees, i, 51
Behar, ii, 608
Behring Straits, i, 57, 102, 159, 160
Bektashi, order of dervishes, ii, 122
Bel, i, 245, 246, 283, 326
Belgium, ii, 46, 78, 199, 230, 327, 331,
332, 339, 347, 371, 381, 509-14, 622
Belisarius, i, 611, ii, 612
Bellarmine (bel' ar men), card., ii, 164
Bellerophon (be ler' 6 f on) , frigate, ii, 372
Bel-Marduk (bel mar'dook) , i, 245-52,
385, 412, 602
Belshazzar, i, 247, 326
Beluchistan (bel oo chi stan') , ii, 471;
languages of, i, 189
Benaiah, i, 287
Benares (be na' rez), i, 417-22, 427, 449,
548, 628
Benedict, St., i, 610-14, ii, 35, 97, 611,
612
Benedictines, i, 612-13, ii, 149, 165
Beneventum, i, 454
Bengal, i, 181, 388, 416, 419, ii, 133, 257,
258
Bengal, Bay of, i, 160
Benin, i, 489
Benjamin, tribe of, i, 284
Benson, Hugh, i, 591
Beowulf (ba' 6 wulf), i, 176, 182, 198
Berar, ii, 133
Berber language, i, 154, 161, 168
Berbers, i, 206, 472, 565, ii, 41
Bergen, ii, 180, 182, 185
Berkeley, George, ii, 492
Berliere, i, 612
Berlin, Treaty of, ii, 447, 475, 558, 623
Bermuda, ii, 471
Bernard, brother, ii, 94
Bes, Egyptian god, i, 236
Bessemer process, ii, 388
Bessus, satrap, i, 385-86
Bethlehem, i, 574
Beth-shan, i, 286
Bhurtpur (bhurt poor7) , ii, 256
Bible, the, i, 193, 281, 282, 290, 402,
411, 570, 572, ii, 60, 92, 96, 150, 151,
159, 162, 167, 211, 244
Bigg, C., i, 625
Birch tree, i, 51
Birds, i, 5, 43, 44, 45, 54
Birkenhead, Lord. (See Smith, Sir F. E.)
Birkett, ii, 129
Birth-rate in ancient Athens, i, 314
Biscay, Bay of, ii, 361
Bismarck, Prince, ii, 442-46, 482, 483,
623
Bison (bl' son), i, 69, 70, 76, 92, 93, 101,
207
Bithynia, i, 395, 483, 500-06, 511, 560,
600
INDEX
633
Black Death, ii, 153-54, 617
Black Friars, ii, 95
Black Hundred, ii, 424
Black lead, i, 9
Black Prince, ii, 179
Black Sea, i, 120, 153, 159, 196, 260,
299, 300, 316, 340, 346, 395, 508, 510,
549-53, 600, 606, 621, ii, 66, 71, 76,
110
Blake, Admiral, ii, 225, 257
Bleriot, M., ii, 624
Blind bards, i, 174
Blood sacrifice, i, 588, 590, ii, 149
Blue Mountains, ii, 280
Blucher, Marshal, ii, 371
Blues, faction of the, ii, 247
Blumenbach, i, 141
Blunt, W. S., i, 146, ii, 500
Bo Tree, i, 421, 432
Boadicea (bo a di se' a), i, 526, ii, 609
Boars, i, 69
Boats, i, 209-12. (See also Ships)
Body, painting of, i, 93, 99, 100
Bceotia (be o' shi a), i, 337
Boer Republics, ii, 460, 483, 489
Boer War, i, 485, ii, 424, 460, 623
Boethius (bo e' thi us), ii, 37
Bohemia (and Bohemians), i, 554, ii, 51,
76, 152, 153, 162, 234
Bohemond, ii, 79
Bokhara (bokha'ra), i, 546, ii, 37, 110,
118
Boleyn, Anne, ii, 206
Bolivar (bol' i var), General, ii, 378
Bologna (bo Ion' ya), ii, 167, 168, 180,
205
Bolshevists, ii, 411, 527, 536, 539, 624
Bombay, ii, 258
Bonaparte, Joseph, ii, 361, 364, 378, 622
Bonaparte, Louis, ii, 361
Bonaparte, Lucien, ii, 354
Bonaparte, Napoleon. (See Napoleon I)
Boncelles (bon sel') , i, 67
Bone carvings, i, 95-99; implements,
i, 90, 96-99, 114
Boniface, St., ii, 48, 51, 613
Boniface VIII, Pope, ii, 99, 616
Boniface, Roman Governor, i, 556
Book-keeping, Aramean, i, 258
Books, i, 253, 405-09, ii, 159. (See
also Printing)
Bordeaux, ii, 180
Borgia, Alexander. (See Alexander VI,
Pope)
Borgia, Caesar and Lucrezia, ii, 195-
96
Boris, king of Bulgaria, ii, 70, 614
Borneo, i, 147, 148, 640
Bosnia, ii, 484, 624
Bosphorus, i, 120, 153, 302, 303, 315,
327, 329, 334, 340, 380, 395, 561, 600,
619, 621, ii, 29, 31, 78, 122
Bosses, American, i, 308
Boston, Mass., ii, 289-94
Bostra, i, 623
Botany Bay, ii, 451
Botticelli (boti chel' i), ii, 184
Boulogne, ii, 180, 362
Bourbon, Constable of, ii, 204, 618
Bourbon, Duke of, ii, 314
Bourbons, ii, 327, 356, 370, 371
Bourgeois (boor zhwa') , L6on, ii, 560
Bournville, ii, 406
Bow and arrow, i, 98, 114, 507-08
Bowmen, Mongol, ii, 119
Boxer rising, ii, 463, 624
Boyle, Robert, ii, 390, 492
Boyne, battle of the, ii, 492, 620
Brachiopods (brak' i 6 podz) , i, 10, 21
Brachycephalic (brak i se far ik) skull, i,
142, 143
Brahe (bra' h^), Tycho, ii, 175, 619
Brahma, i, 437, ii, 134
Brahminism (and Brahmins), i, 269-72,
416-17, 427, 430, 440, 629, 645-48,
ii, 108, 137, 256, 454
Brailsford, ii, 543
Brain, i, 56, 79, 87
Brandenburg, elector of, ii, 236
Brass, i, 106
Brazil, ii, 192, 193, 200, 444
Bread in Neolithic Age, i, 113
Bread-fruit tree, i, 51
Breasted, J. H., i, 248, 256, 294
Breathing, i, 23-28
Brehier, L., ii, 61
Bremen, ii, 69, 180, 182
Brennus, i, 450, ii, 607
Breslau, ii, 180
Brest-Li tovsk (brest le tovsk') , ii, 530
Breton language, i, 168
Briareus (bri' a roos) , i, 274
Brienne, ii, 349
Brindisi (bren' de ze), ii, 67
Bristol, ii, 154
Britain, i, 59, 113, 145, 196, 273, 489,
534, 613, ii, 41, 51, 66 ; invasions of, ii,
554, 605, ii, 130, 610, 611 ; Roman, i,
219, 507, 509, 522, 525, 526, 564, i,
40, 50, 610 ; Keltic, i, 299, 554. (See
also England and Great Britain)
British Army, officers of, ii, 516
British Association, ii, 420
British Channel, i, 170
634
INDEX
British Civil Air Transport Commission,
ii, 392
British Empire (1815), ii, 451; (1914),
ii, 470-72
British Empire, political life of, i, 493
British Museum, i, 630, ii, 398
"British" nationality, ii, 488-89
"British schools," ii, 396
Britons, ancient. (See Britain)
Brittany, i, 147, 171, 554, ii, 52, 200
Broglie, Marshal de, ii, 313
Brontosaurus (bron to saw' rus) , i, 40
Bronze, i, 106, 118, 172, 173, 207;
Chinese vessels of, i, 204 ; ornaments,
i, 114 ; weapons, i, 106
Bronze Age, i, 97, 108, 132, 133, 196,
197, 213
Brown, Campbell, ii, 38
Browne, Jukes, i, 50, 119
Bruce, Robert the, ii, 179
Bruges (broozh), ii, 180, 182, 229
Brunellesco (broo ne les' ko), ii, 183
Brunswick, Duke of, ii, 327, 330
Brussels, ii, 331, 514
Brutus, i, 490, 513
Bryce, ii, 54
Bubonic plague, i, 608
Buch, C. D., i, 300
Bucknall, i, 50
Buda-Pesth (boo' da pest), ii, 205
Buddha (bood'a), i, 196, 270, 420, 422,
433, 438, 449, 533, 573-74, 582, 586,
591, 610, 624, 626, 645, 646-47, ii, 13,
93, 263, 296, 607; life of, i, 416 sqq.;
teaching of, i, 422 sqq., 436, ii, 16, 402
Buddhism, i, 270, 411, 416 sqq., 582,
610, 626, 629, 632, 639, 645, 646, ii,
6, 106, 108, 114, 119, 127, 261. (See
also Buddha)
Buddhist art, i, 428
Budge, Wallis, i, 197, 198, 249
Buffon, Comte de, ii, 419, 426
Building, i, 197
Bulgaria (and Bulgarians), i, 328, 522,
553, 606, ii, 24, 58, 69-72, 92, 97,
122-24, 130, 446, 501, 502, 622, 531,
614
Bulgarian atrocities, ii, 623
Bulgarian language, i, 168
Bull fights, Cretan, i, 274
Bunbury, i, 217
Biirgerstand, i, 268
Burgoyne, General, ii, 292
Burgundy (and Burgundians) , i, 554,
606, ii, 48, 178, 200, 229, 244, 320
Burial, early, i, 84, 93, 109, 117, 123,
130, 167, 171, 175, 197, 545
Burke, Edmund, ii, 289, 492
Burmah (and Burmese), i, 114, 203, ii,
119, 262, 471
Burmese language, i, 157
Burnet, i, 349
Burning the dead, i, 171
Burrell, Prof., i, 6
Burton, Richard, i, 189
Bury, J. B., i, 305, 327, 454, 464, ii, 112
Bushman language, i, 162
Bushmen, i, 68, 95, 98, 141, 224
Butler, M. E., i, 85
Butler, Samuel, i, 150
Butter in Neolithic Age, i, 112
Butterflies, i, 17, 51
Buxar, ii, 258, 621
Byng, L. C., i, 541
Byzantine architecture, ii, 60
Byzantine church. (See Greek Church)
Byzantine Empire, i, 522, 562, 606, 617,
636, ii, 17-21, 24, 28, 39, 42, 53, 58,
60, 64-69, 72, 76, 79, 80, 81, 182, 613,
614
Byzantium (bi zan' tyum) , i, 380, 634,
ii, 18, 31, 35, 57, 62, 74, 105, 126, 129,
247. (See also Constantinople)
CABUL (ka' bul), i, 386, ii, 133
Cadbury, Messrs., ii, 406
Cadiz (ka/ diz), ii, 352
Caen (kan), ii, 325
Csesar, title, etc., i, 526, 564, 581, 589,
594, ii, 56, 59
Caesar, Julius, i, 113, 133, 196, 399, 465,
487, 493, 505, 510-17, 529, 534, 542,
ii, 51, 351, 353, 609
Caesars, the, i, 526, 538, 560
Cahors, ii, 202
Caiaphas (kl' a fas), i, 585
Caillaux, M., ii, 510
Cainozoic (ki no zo' ik) period, i, 12,
13, 14, 35, 37, 46, 49-56, 66
Cairo, ii, 36, 37
Calabria, i, 476, ii, 67, 68
Calcutta, ii, 258; University Commis-
sion, ii, 137
Calder, Admiral, ii, 362
Calendar, the, i, 129
Calicut, ii, 187, 257
California, i, 264
Calif ornian Indians, i, 98
Caligula (ka lig' u la), i, 525, ii, 609
Caliphs, ii, 17, 18, 24-34, 41, 61, 64, 71,
126, 144, 612, 613, 618
Callicratidas (ka Ii kra' ti das), i, 378
INDEX
635
Callimachus (ka lim' a kus) , i, 405
Callisthenes (ka Us' th<* nez) , i, 392
Calmette, ii, 510
Calonne, ii, 312, 323
Calvinism, ii, 164
Cambodia, i, 640
Cambridge, ii, 180; University of, i,
530, ii, 437, 486
Cambridge, Mass., ii, 291
"Cambulac," ii, 118
Cambyses (kam bl' sez), i, 326, 382, ii,
607
Camels, i, 56, 217, 323
Camillus (camirus), i, 459, 483, 499,
502, ii, 607
Campanella, ii, 211
Campo Formio, peace of, ii, 351, 621
Camptosaurus (kamp to saw' rus) i, 40
Canaan (and the Canaanites), i, 278-83,
ii, 1
Canada, i, 9, 161, ii, 254, 279, 285, 292,
451, 457, 471, 472, 621
Canadian dawn animal, i, 9
Canary Isles, ii, 185
Candahar, i, 389
Candles, ceremonial, i, 413, 414
Candolle (kandol'), de, i, 184
Cannae (kan' e), battle of, i, 476, 479, ii,
608
Cannes, ii, 371
Cannibalism, i, 167, ii, 156, 189, 190
Canning, George, ii, 436
Cannon, ii, 235, 268
Canoes, i, 210
Canterbury, ii, 50; archbishops of, ii,
50, 613
Canton, i, 634, 642, 647
Canusium (ca nuz' i iim) , i, 536
Canute, ii, 66, 614
Cape Colony, ii, 460
Capernaum, i, 584
Capet (ka pa'), Hugh, ii, 62, 178, 614
Capitalism, ii, 168, 276, 398-99, 407-08,
535
Caporetto, battle of, ii, 529
Cappadocia, i, 323, 395, 620, 623
Capua (kap' u a), i, 476, 505
Carboniferous rocks, i, 29
Cardinals, ii, 100, 127
Caria (ka'ria), i, 375, 621
Caribou (kari boo'), i, 78, 124, 137
Carlovingians, ii, 62, 614
Carlyle, Thomas, ii, 240, 307, 313 sag.,
336
Carnac, i, 109, 171
Carnivores, early type of, i, 56
Carnivorous animals, i, 43
Carnot (kar n5'), L. N. M., ii, 339, 350
Carolana, ii, 282
Carolina, ii, 253, 282, 283, 284, 290
Carpathians, ii, 69
Carrhse, i, 508, 540, 616, ii, 609
Carson, Sir Edward, i, 312, ii, 424, 497,
498, 499
Carthage (and the Carthaginians), i,
196, 212, 216-18, 241, 274, 294, 303,
352, 382, 401, 445, 448, 453, 497, 509-
14, 532, 550, 556, 560, 569, 571, ii,
41, 89, 144, 184, 606, 608 ; war with
Rome, i, 453, 467-85
Carvings, Palaeolithic. (See Art)
Casement, Sir Roger, ii, 499
Cash, Chinese, i, 631
Caspian Sea, i, 120, 153, 159, 196, 299,
317, 318, 327, 387, 507, 509, 542, 549,
553, 627, 634, ii, 67, 110, 154, 609, 610,
615
Caspian-Pamir region, i, 549
Cassander, i, 395
Cassiodorus (kas i 6 dor' tis), i, 612, 614,
ii, 36, 40, 612
Cassiterides (kas i ter' i dez), i, 217
Cassius, Spurius, i, 458
Caste, i, 268-71, 416, 431
Castelmaine, Lady, ii, 226
Castile, ii, 188, 200
Cat, i, 56, 230
Catalonians, ii, 185
Catapult, i, 372
Caterpillars, i, 83
Cathars, ii, 92
"Cathay," ii, 118
Catherine the Great, ii, 242, 264, 267,
303, 620
Catherine II, ii, 251, 363
Catholicism, ii, 142, 147-50, 160 sqq.,
164, 171, 194, 211, 234, 239, 248, 281,
490-94
Catiline, i, 511
Cato, Marcus Porcius, i, 473, 477,
479, 486, 489, 498, 528
Cattle, i, 69, 105, 219. (See also
Animals)
Caucasian languages, i, 151, 189
Caucasians, i, 141-42, 151-159, ii, 142
Caucasus (kaw'kasus), i, 106, 141, 161,
327, 620
Caudine Forks, ii, 608
Cavaliers, ii, 222-23
Cavalry, i, 370
Cave drawings, i, 93, 94 ; dwellings,
i, 167 ; men, i, 66, 72, 76, 78, 88
Cavour, ii, 441
Cawiipore, ii, 455
636
INDEX
Caxton, William, ii, 159
Celebes (sel' e bez), pile dwellings, i, 109
Celibacy, i, 414, ii, 74, 149
Celsus, i, 403
CelMberian script, i, 228
Celtic. (See Keltic)
Celts, bronze, i, 132
Cenotaph (Whitehall), ii, 568
Cephalus (sef a lus), i, 306
Ceremonies, early use of, i, 127
Cervantes (sur van' tez), ii, 140
Ceylon, i, 421, 432, 533, 643, ii, 257, 471
Chadwick, i, 177
Chseronea (kerone'a), battle of, i,
369, 372, ii, 607
Chalcedon (kal se' dtfn), i, 602, 618
Chaldea (and the Chaldeans), i, 194,
200, 247, 265, 291, 319, 344, 385, 508,
ii, 1, 607
Chaldean writing, i, 228
Chalons, ii, 322
Champagne, depart., ii, 330, 517, 527
Chancellor, Lord, of England, ii, 162
Chandernagore, ii, 258
Chandragupta (chan dra goop' id) , i, 430,
445, ii, 608
Chang Daoling, i, 433
Chang-tu, i, 434
Channa, the charioteer, i, 417
Channing, ii, 278, 280, 294, 338
Chapman, G., i, 175
Charcoal, ii, 275
Chariots, i, 177, 192, 370, 384
Charlemagne, emperor, i, 433, 560, 632,
633, ii, 47-48, 51-54, 56-62, 69, 97, 98,
116, 133, 148, 199, 208, 215, 238, 360,
361, 614
Charles V, emperor, ii, 140, 164, 182,
199 sqq., 229, 232, 242, 376, 618
Charles I, king of England, ii, 217-25,
236, 240, 253, 281-82, 317, 376
Charles II, king of England, ii, 177,
225, 238, 243, 253, 281-82, 376
Charles VII, king of France, ii, 179
Charles IX, king of France, ii, 282
Charles X, king of France, ii, 314, 378,
622
Charles III, king of Spain, ii, 267
Charlotte Dundas, steamboat, ii, 387
Charmides (kar'mi dez), i, 351
Charon, i, 489
Charter House, London, ii, 154
Chateau Thierry, ii, 531
Chateauroux, Duchess of, ii, 240
Chatham, Earl of. (See Pitt, William)
Chaucer, ii, 160
Cheese, i, 112
Chellean age, i, 60, 70, 78-81, 87
Chelles, i, 78
Chemistry, ii, 38
Chemosh (ke'mosh), i, 288
Chen, L. Y., i, 208, 211, 253, 641
Chen Tuan, i, 433
Cheops (ke' ops), i, 198
Chephren (kef ren), i, 198, 248-^9
Cherry-tree, i, 505
Chieftains, i, 134, 178
Child labour, ii, 404-05
Chimpanzee, i, 63, 67-74, 218
Chin, absence of, i, 72
China, i, 83, 106, 114, 160, 432, 532,
626, 627, ii, 17, 117, 134, 179, 194,
261-62 ; history (early history and
Great age of), i, 196, 201-06, 252-53,
271-72, 388, 449, 508, 528, 541-43, 545-
50, 617, 630-36, ii, 606, 610, 612 ; (Wth
to 18th century), ii, 106, 108-14, 127-
28, 130, 134, 154, 261-62, 266, 616,
617; (20^ century), ii, 461-69, 624;
Christianity in, i, 604, ii, 116-17,
119, 166; civilization and culture,
i, 147, 148, 183, 196. 201-03, 208, 271-
72, 307, 408, 541, 543, 626-27, 630-31,
633 sqq., ii, 38, 106, 147, 159; other
religions of, i, 252. 428-29, 433, 437, ii,
261 ; social, i, 181, 269-70, 271-72, 497,
630, ii, 464. (See also Chow, Han,
Kin, Ming, Shang, Sung, Suy, Tang,
Tsing, Wei, and Yuan dynasties)
China, Great Wall of, i, 205, 272, 526,
643, ii, 608
Chinese, the, i, 63, 157; classics, i, 225,
639; coinage, i, 631 ; emperor, i, 240,
252, 557; language, i, 157, 158, 162,
224-26, 638; script, i, 224-27, 272,
638-40, ii, 262
Chios (Id' os), ii, 79
Chnemu, Egyptian god, i, 239
Chosroes (koz' ro ez) I, i, 618, ii, 22,
211, 612
Chosroes II, i, 523, 618-19, 624, ii, 3,
17, 82, 612
Chow dynasty, i, 196, 204, 205, 253, 433,
ii, 606
Christ. (See Jesus of Nazareth)
Christ Church, Oxford, ii, 427
Christian IX, ii, 442
Christian era, ii, 609
Christian science, ii, 169
Christianity, i, 296, 519, 569, 617, ii, 129,
161, 244, 264-65, 421, 422; history
(early), i, 491, 586 sqq., 601-05, ii, 51,
53-54, 611; (middle ages), ii, 50 sqq.,
63, 71-75, 84-86, 95-96, 151-53;
INDEX
637
and Buddhism, i, 429, 441; and
Islam, ii, 14-16, 20-21, 28-34, 41
sqq., 63-64, 80 sqq., 114-15, 149
and Judaism, ii, 149 ; and learning
i, 609 sqq. ; missions and propaganda
i, 488, 617, 625, 634, ii, 3-6, 48-54
70, 114-22, 126-27, 134, 146-47, 357,
394-96, 465; official, i, 601 sqq., ii,
54, 265, 418, 425 ; ritual of, i, 413-14,
441, 538-39, 591-92, ii, 90-91, 148-152 ;
sects, i, 592, ii, 35, 106, 116-17; spirit
of, i, 414, 538-39, 576-77, ii, 157-58,
402. (See also Jesus of Nazareth)
Chronicles, book of the, i, 282
Chronology, ii, 51
Ch'u, state of, i, 205
Chu Hsi, i, 641
Church, the, i, 600-05, ii, 38, 85-88,
91, 92, 97-101, 150, 164, 176, 177-78,
272, 617
Church, Sir A. H., i, 7
Churches, orientation of, i, 238
Churchill, Rt. Hon. Winston, ii, 523
Cicero, M. TuHius, i, 131, 487, 491, 513,
516
Cilicia, i, 487, 620, ii, 72, 79, 118
Cilician Gates, ii, 32, 78
Cimmerians, i, 300, 316, 318, 388, 543,
ii, 121
Cincinnatus, Order of, ii, 357
Circumcision, i, 147
Cistercian order, ii, 150
Citizenship, i, 309, 311-12
City States, Chinese, i, 204; Greek,
i, 305-14, 362, 363, 370, 454 ; Sume-
rian, i, 191
Civilization, i, 635 sqq., ii, 138, 144,
157-58, 216; Aegean, i, 213-16;
Hellenic, i, 302 sqq. ; prehistoric,
i, 145, 169 sqq., 175-78; primitive, i,
182-208, ii, 143. (See also Culture)
Clans, i, 171
Class consciousness, ii, 399, 407-08;
distinction, i, 188, 267-68 ; war, i, 168
Classes, social, i, 263-72
Classics, study of the, ii, 390, 428
Classification, ii, 169
Claudian, the historian, i, 607
Claudius, emperor (A.D. 41-54), i, 525,
528, ii, 609
Claudius, emperor (A.D. 268-270), i, 553,
ii, 610
Claudius, Appius, decemvir, i, 458
Claudius, Appius, the Censor, i, 461-466
Claudius, Consul, i, 468
Clay documents, i, 190, 197-98, 246;
modelling, Palseolithic, i, 95, 99
Clemenceau, G. B., ii, 552-56, 566, 624
Clement V (pope), ii, 99, 616
Clement VII (anti-pope), ii, 100, 617
Cleon, i, 350
Cleopatra, i, 510-15
Cleopatra (wife of Philip II), i, 374, 376
Clergy, taxation of, ii, 86
Clermont, ii, 74, 615
Clermont, steamer, ii, 387
Cleveland, President, ii, 505
Climate, change of, i, 18, 20, 30-37,
46, 51, 52, 57, 100, 108, 170, 177, 317,
545, 550 ; effect of, i, 35-36, 232, 317
Clitus (kti' tus), i, 392, ii, 145
Clive, Robert, Lord, ii, 258, 453, 487, 621
Clodius, i, 511
Clothing, i, 99, 109, 114
Clovis, ii, 46, 47, 611
Cluniac order, ii, 150
Clyde, Firth of, ii, 387
Cnossos (nos'os), i, 196, 213-16, 223,
234, 257, 264, 281, 300, 303, 315, 318,
354, 446, 447, ii, 605
Coal, i, 28, 29, 34, 38, 635, ii, 275, 386,
392
Cockroaches, i, 28
Code Napoleon, ii, 358
Cogul, i, 354
Coinage, earliest, i, 220; Athenian, i,
220; Bactrian, i, 396; Carthaginian,
i, 468; Ephthalite, i, 629; Lydian, i,
316; pre-Roman British, i, 396;
Roman, i, 455, 471
Coinage of stamped leather, ii, 89
oke, ii, 275
ole, Langton, i, 212
ollectivism, ii, 412
Cologne, ii, 60, 180, 182
Colonies, British, ii, 279-83, 471 ; scram-
ble for, ii, 449-61
Colorado, i, 39
olosseum, i, 609, ii, 41
olumba, St., ii, 50
Columbus, Bartholomew, ii, 186
Columbus, Christopher, ii, 185 sqq.,
200, 605, 617
Comedy, Greek, i, 363
Comet, i, 4, 608
ommagene (kom d je'ne), i, 621
Commodus (kom'odus), i, 527-29
Commons, House of, ii, 219-28, 236,
286, 298, 313, 400
Commune, French Revolution, ii, 328,
336
Communism, ii, 153-58, 270 sqq., 341,
410, 412
Communities, i, 171, ii, 142-48
638
INDEX
Community of obedierce, ii, 296 ; of will,
ii, 296
Comnena, Anna. (See Anna)
Comnenus, Alexius. (See Alexius)
"Companions," equestrian order, i, 369,
371
Compass, i, 635, ii, 193
Concert of Europe, ii, 373, 377, 384
Concord, Mass., ii, 290, 294
Concord, Temple of, i, 499, ii, 607
Condor, the, i, 5
Condorcet (kon dor sa'), ii, 358
Confucianism, i, 433-40, 642
Confucius, i, 196, 270, 433-40, 449, 582,
618, 624, 636, ii, 607
Congo, i, 159, ii, 460
Congregationalism, ii, 163
Congress, American, ii, 300
Congress, 1st Colonial, ii, 290
Conifers, i, 38
Connecticut, ii, 281, 282, 290, 296
Conrad II, ii, 63
Conrad III, ii, 63, 80
Constance, ii, 151
Constance, Council of, ii, 96, 100, 151,
617
Constantine I the Great, i, 433, 488,
517, 529, 553, 560, 594, 597, 602, 615,
617, 618, 625, 647, 648, ii, 82, 133,
136, 268, 611, 612
Constantine, King of Greece, ii, 524
Constantinople, i, 554, 557, 559-65,
600-08, 614-19, ii, 2, 18-20, 24, 28,
57, 67, 70-72, 76-82, 97, 110, 118-24,
141, 168, 182, 247, 440, 483, 502, 509,
611, 612, 613, 614, 615, 616, 617.
(See also Byzantium)
Consuls, Roman, i, 455
Convicts sent to New England, ii, 284
Cooking, i, 105, 106, 113
Co-operative Societies, ii, 406
Copernicus (ko per' ni kus) , ii, 175, 618
Copper, i, 4, 105, 207, 217, ii, 189, 389
Copper axes, i, 132
Coptic language, i, 154
Coracles, i, 209
Corday, Charlotte, ii, 325
Cordoba (k6r' do ba), ii, 36, 37
Corfinium, i, 464
Corfu (korfoo'), ii, 180
Corinth (and Corinthians), i, 303, 321,
336, 375, 382, 485, 491, 497, 509, 511,
536, 560, 589, ii, 608
Corinth, isthmus of, i, 336
Cornish people, i, 152
"Cornstalks," i, 143
Cornwall, i, 106, 217, 605, ii, 40, 51, 225
Cornwallis, General, ii, 292
Corrosive sublimate, ii, 38
Corsets, i, 214
Corsica, i, 471, 556, ii, 348-49
Cortez, ii, 189-90, 618
Corvus, the, i, 470
Cossacks, ii, 129, 244, 259-61
Coster, printer, ii, 159, 617
Cotton industry, ii, 275
Cotylosaur (kof i lo sawr) , i, 27
Councils, Church, ii, 74, 95, 100, 151,
153, 167, 611, 617
Counting, i, 151
"Counts of Asia Minor," ii, 137
Court system, i, 263
Couvade (ku vad'), i, 147
Cow, sacred to Brahmins, ii, 454
Cow deities, i, 237
Cox, Hippesley, i, 110
Crab-apples, i, 113
Crabs, i, 10
Crabtree, Rev. W., i, 189
Cranach, ii, 203
Cranium, of apes, i, 72 ; Piltdown.
(See Piltdown)
Crassus, i, 352, 478, 507-11, 549, 616,
ii, 19, 609
Crawley, A. E., i, 131
Creation, story of, i, 278, 293, ii, 418-20
Crecy, ii, 179
Crediton, ii, 51
Creeds, Christian, i, 592, 609, ii, 73, 611
Cremation, i, 171
Cressy, cruiser, ii, 520
Cretan Labyrinth, i, 214-16 ; language,
i, 162, 289 ; script, i, 228
Crete (and Cretans), i, 104, 189, 196,
212-16, 234, 274, 282, 315, 316
Crimea, ii, 118, 153
Crimean War, ii, 440, 623
Criminals, Roman, i, 490-91 ; used for
vivisection, i, 403, 404
Crispus, son of Constantine, i, 599
Critias, i, 331
Croatia, i, 616
Crocodiles, i, 41, 46
Croesus (kre'sus), i, 220, 314, 320-26,
416, ii, 607
Croll, i, 30
Cro-Magnon race, i, 87, 88-95, 99-100
Cromwell, Oliver, ii, 222-25, 284, 287,
491
Cromwell, Thomas, ii, 197
Cross, in Buddhist ritual, i, 429 ; true,
i, 618, ii, 21, 82
Crown, the power of the, ii, 228
Crucifixion, i, 550, 590
INDEX
639
Crusades, ii, 34, 75 sqq., 80-84, 94, 97,
124, 152, 179, 229, 397, 615, 616, 617
Crustaceans, i, 25
Crystal Palace, ii, 437
Crystals, i, 9, 17
Ctesiphon (tea7 if on), i, 618, 022, 624,
626, 634, ii, 22, 31, 82, 129, 522
Cuba, ii, 193, 451, 506
Cubit, length of, i, 290
Culture, Aryan, i, 171-82; Heliolithic,
i, 147-49, 162, 171, 177, 184, 188,
196, 201, 207-13, 223, 415; Neolithic,
i, 104-5, 107-8, 110 sqq., 128, 146, 149,
152, 172-73, 184-88, 197, 203, 205-8,
415 ; prehistoric and primitive, i,
76 sqq., 122 sqq. (See also Civiliza-
tion)
Cumont, i, 412, 590
Cuneiform (ku' ne i form), i, 191, 227,
274
Cup, pebble, i, 90
Currency, ii, 342-47, 385, 406, 413, 535
Cuseeans, i, 394
Custozza, ii, 445
Cuvier (ku vya), ii, 419
Cyaxares (si ak' sa rez), i, 319, ii, 607
Cycads (si' kadz), i, 38, 51
Cynics, i, 360
Cyprus, i, 106, 213, 331, 340, 380, 395,
ii, 447
Cyrenaica (sir e na' i kd), i, 500
Gyrene (si re' ne), i, 529
Cyrus, the Great, i, 194, 196, 220, 248,
260, 278, 292, 314, 320-26, 370, 389,
416, 445, 523, 542, 622, 624, ii, 607
Cyrus, the Younger, i, 342
Czecho-Slovaks, ii, 380
Czechs (cheks), i, 554, ii, 153
D
DACIA, i, 526, 553, 564, ii, 71
Daedalus (de' dd lus), i, 215
Dagon, i, 245, 412
Dalai Lama (da ll' la/ ma) , i, 438
Dalmatia, i, 37, 554, 606, 616, ii, 51, 57,
564, 611, 613
Damascus, i, 192, 218, 273, 523, 618, 623,
ii, 1, 18, 20, 28, 31, 37, 154, 612
Damask, i, 273
Damietta, ii, 82
Damon, friend of Pericles, i, 349
Dancing, i, 174, 354
Danelaw, ii, 54, 614
Danes, ii, 53, 54, 66, 228, 614
Daniel, book of, i, 277
Danish language, i, 168
Dante, ii, 160
Danton, ii, 324, 329-36
Dantzig, ii, 180, 251, 564
Danube, i, 153, 298, 300, 327-31, 372,
377, 387, 507, 508, 523, 526, 533, 539,
545, 549, 551, 553, 557, 558, 564,
606, 616, 627, ii, 51, 69, 76, 142, 266,
522, 610
Danubian provinces, ii, 382, 440
Dardanelles, i, 302, ii, 121, 521
Darius (da rl' us) I, i, 248, 326-32,
334, 339, 386, ii, 607
Darius II, i, 342
Darius III, i, 379-80, 384-87, 390, 394,
507, 542, ii, 20, 122, 366-67, 608
Dark ages, the, i, 607
Darling region, i, 143
Dartmouth, Lord, ii, 305
Darwin, Charles, i, 67, ii, 420, 427
Darwin, Prof. G. H., i, 31
Darwinism, ii, 420-27
David, King, i, 286-89, 293, 569, 574,
580, ii, 156, 606
Davids, Rhys, i, 415, 420, 421, 428, 430
Davidson, J. L. Strachan, i, 513
Davis, i, 603
Davis, J. W., ii, 507-08
Davis, Stearns, ii, 475
Dawes, ii, 290
Dawson, Sir William, i, 9
Day, length of, i, 6, 51
Dead, eating the, i, 197
Dead Sea, i, 120
Debtor, slavery as fate of, i, 257
Dechelette, i, 111
Decimal notation, ii, 37
Decius, Emperor, i, 528, 553, 594, ii, 610
Declaration of Independence, ii, 293,
296
Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire
(Gibbon), ii, 263-69
Deer, i, 70
Defoe, Daniel, ii, 235, 272, 305, 394
Deformities, i, 147
Delaware, ii, 283, 290
Delcasse, ii, 484
Delhi, ii, 108, 132, 256, 257, 454, 455,
615
Delian League, i, 314, 346
Delos, Island of, i, 311, 313
Delphi, i, 313, 320-22, 370, 395, 536
Delphi, oracle of, i, 305, 321-23
Delphic amphictyony, i, 372
Demeter (deme't^r), i, 354, 374, 538
Democracy, i, 309-13, 456, ii, 163, 164,
273, 298, 326
Demos, i, 309
640
INDEX
Demosthenes (d£ mos' th£ nez), i, 358,
363, 368, 376, 387, 473, 513
Deniker, i, 102, 103
Denmark, i, 109, 110, 539, ii, 51, 65, I
162, 206, 225, 242, 252-53, 257,
266, 381, 442, 451, 614
Deportation, i, 193
Dervishes, ii, 122
Descartes (da kart'), ii, 419
Deshima, ii, 465, 466
Deuteronomy, book of, i, 281
Devon, ii, 225
Dewlish, i, 78
Dialects, i, 300
Diaspora (dl as' pd r#) , i, 411, 569-71
Diaz (de'as), ii, 185, 617
Dicasts, i, 310
Dickens, Charles, ii, 180
Dickinson, Lowes, ii, 543
Dicrorerus (di kro re' rus), i, 58
Dictator, Roman, i, 459
Diderot (ded r5'), ii, 308
Diet (assembly), ii, 234, 250
Dillon, Dr., ii, 543, 551, 553
Dinosaurs (di' rid sawrz), i, 41, 46
Dino there (di' no ther), i, 58
Diocletian, i, 529, 561, 594, 599-600, ii,
611
Dionysus, god, i, 354, 373
Dionysius of Syracuse, i, 434, 468
Diplodocus (dip lod' 6 kus) , i, 40
Disease, infectious, i, 126
Dispensations, papal, ii, 86, 93
Disraeli, Benjamin. (See Beaconsfield,
Earl of)
Divans, ii, 32
Divination, i, 464
Divine right, ii, 164, 377
Divus Caesar, i, 526
Dixon line, ii, 282, 284
Dnieper (ne'per), i, 153, 610, 553,
ii, 110, 260
Doctors, i, 235
Dog, the, i, 56, 105, 108, 112, 116, 230
Dolichocephalic (dol i k5 se fal' ik) skull,
i, 142-46
Dolmens, i, 109
Domazlice, ii, 152, 617
Dominic, St., ii, 95-96, 615
Dominican Order, ii, 95-96, 116, 127,
193, 465, 615
Domitian, i, 526, ii, 610
Don, river, i, 153, 549, ii, 261
Don Cossacks, ii, 260
Donatello, ii, 183
Dordogne (dor d5' nye), i, 100
Doric dialect, i, 300
Dorset, i, 78
Dortmund, ii, 182
Dostoievski (dos to ef ski), ii, 502
Doubs, i, 100
Douglas, Sir R. K., i, 253
Dover, ii, 180
Dover, Straits of, i, 507
Dragon flies, i, 28
Dragonnades, ii, 239, 253
Dravidian civilization, i, 196, 203, 415,
ii, 142 ; language, i, 158, 189
Dravidians, i, 146, 159, 160, 169, 182,
270, 315, ii, 134
Drepanum (drep' d num) , i, 470
Dresden, cruiser, ii, 520
Dresden, battle of, ii, 368
Driver, S. R., i, 288
Drogheda, ii, 224
Druids, i, 135
Drums, Neolithic, i, 115
Drusus, Livius, i, 503
Dryopithecus (dri 6 pi the' kus) , i, 66
Dubarry, Comtesse, ii, 240
Dublin, ii, 492, 493, 498, 499
Duma, the, ii, 525
Dumouriez (du moo rya') , General, ii,
329 -
Dunbar, battle of, ii, 225
Dunce, derivation of, ii, 172
Dunkirk, ii, 226
Duns Scotus, ii, 171, 616
Dunstan, ii, 150
Dupleix (du pla'), ii, 258
Durazzo (durad'zo), i, 561, ii, 67, 72,
80, 615
Durham, ii, 396; University of, ii, 437
Durham, Lord, ii, 293
Dusseldorf, i, 72
Dutch language, ii, 47, 228; people, ii,
47; Republic, ii, 228-33, 380; settle-
ments and seamanship, i, 84, ii, 188,
253, 282-83, 461, 465-66. (See also
Holland)
Duyvendak, Mr., i, 630, 641
Dwellings, Neolithic, i, 114
Dyeing, ii, 38
Dynamics, ii, 176
Dynasts, The, i, 335, ii, 348
E
EARTH, the, i, 3-8, 13-15, 29-34, 56-59
East, orientation to, i, 238
East India Company, ii, 258, 289,
451, 453
Easter, feast of, i, 129
Easter lamb, i, 588
INDEX
641
Eastern (Greek) Empire. (See Byzan-
tine Empire)
Eastlake, ii, 404
Ebenezer, i, 283
Ebro, river, i, 354, 472, 475
Ecbatana (ek bat' d nd), i, 626
Ecclesiastes, book of, i, 277
Echidna (e kid' nd), i, 54
Economists, French, ii, 309
Economus (e kon' 6 mus) , battle of,
i, 470, ii, 608
Eden, garden of, i, 293, ii, 418
Eder, ii, 513
Edessa, i, 621, ii, 78, 80
Edgar, ii, 150
Edom, ii, 244
Education, i, 267, 270, 272, 408-9, 612-
13, ii, 137, 146, 147, 166, 270 sqq.,
302, 357, 385, 390-92, 396-97, 413,
428-31
Edward I, ii, 219
Edward VI, ii, 218, 220
Edward VII, ii, 228, 488
Edward, Prince of Wales, son of George
V, ii, 498
Egbert, ii, 51, 53, 614
Egerton, H. E., ii, 377
Eggs, i, 39, 53, 54, 114
Egibi (ege'be).i, 265
Eginhard, ii, 59
Egmont, Count of, ii, 229
Egypt, i, 106, 154, 156, 395, 522,
561, 570, 572, 574, 618, ii, 1,
30, 83, 84, 94, 139, 153, 612; his-
tory (early), i, 133, 148, 183-86,
195-98, 200-01, 204, 209-13, 220, 228,
229, 233-34, 246, 248, 256, 261, 265,
267, 274, 277-82, 289, 290-95, 307,
315-16, 323, 326-27, 334, 340, 342,
359, 522, ii, 1, 189, 605, 606; (and
Greece), i, 382, 389, 401-02, ii, 607;
(and Rome), i, 480, 500, 510-12, 533;
(and Islam), ii, 21-24, 29-32, 37, 64,
71, 82-84, 106, 114, 118, 122, 126,
132, 614, 618; (modern period), ii,
351, 353, 359, 453, 460, 471, 500,
621, 623 ; Christianity in, i, 604, 610,
ii, 74, 149 ; Jews in, i, 402, 436, 572,
ii, 607; Kingship in, i, 248-52, 263,
520 ; religious systems, i, 197-98, 236-
42, 248-52, 296, 382-83, 404, 410-14,
431, 538, 590-91
Egyptian language, i, 154
Egyptian script, i, 208, 228
Egyptian shipping, i, 273
"Egyptians" (Gipsies), ii, 137
Elam (e'lam),i, 189, 318
Elamite language, i, 162
Elamites, i, 189, 194, 245, 385, ii, 105
Elba, ii, 371, 374
Elbe, ii, 80
Elections, i, 494, ii, 302
Electricity, ii, 388, 389-90
Electrum, i, 220
Elephants, i, 57, 70, 76, 78, 102, 207,
210, 317, 386, 453, 455, 470-79, ii, 20
Eli, judge, i, 283-85
Elixir of life, ii, 174
Elizabeth, Queen of England, ii, 218,
220, 232, 258, 280
Elizabeth, Empress of Russia, ii, 242,
620
El-lil, i, 190
Emden, cruiser, ii, 520
Emesa (em7 e sd), i, 621
Emigration, ii, 76
Emirs, ii, 31
Emmet, Robert, ii, 493
Emperor, title of, i, 565
Emperors of Germany, ii, 199
Employers and employed, ii, 276, 397-98
Enclosure Acts, ii, 272-76
"Encyclopaedists," the, ii, 309
England, i, 605, ii, 64, 66, 178, 200, 433,
470-71; history (early), i, 52, 101,
645, ii, 40, 50-54, 66, 614 ; (under the
Normans), ii, 67, 615; (in the 13th
and 14th centuries), ii, 176-77; (Civil
war), ii, 218, 221-25, 281; (war with
Holland), ii, 225-26, 282; (war with
Spain), ii, 220, 225; (reign of Charles
II), ii, 225-26; (in 18th century), ii,
226-28; (and America), ii, 253-54;
(union with Ireland), ii, 621; political
and constitutional, i, 463, 465, ii, 194,
216-17, 219-21, 226-28, 236 ; religion,
i, 642, ii, 49-54, 99, 150, 162, 206,
220, 221, 225, 252, 253, 282 ; social, ii,
154-56, 244, 271-73, 324, 334, 617. (See
also Britain, Great Britain, and the
Great War)
English, the, ii, 50, 58, 66-67, 611
English language, i, 151, 564, 638, ii, 50,
160
English seamen, ii, 188
Entelodont-(eii tel' 6 dont), i, 53
Eoanthropus (e 6 an thrd' piis) , i, 60,
70-74. (See also Man)
Eocene (e' 6 sen) period, i, 52-59
Eohippus, i, 56
Eolithic age, i, 75
Eoliths, i, 68, 102, ii, 605
Eozoon (e 6 zo' on) Canadense, i, 9
Ephesus (ef e sus), i, 340, 379, 589, ii, 79
642
INDEX
Ephesus, Council of, i, 602
Ephthalite (ef thd lit) coins, i, 329
Ephthalites, i, 628-30, 646, ii, 611, 612
Epics, i, 173, 175, 232
Epictetus (ep ik te' tus), i, 492
Epicureans (ep i ku re' dnz) , i, 360,
363, 632
Epirus (epi'rus), i, 375, 376, 452, 454,
ii, 67, 122
Equality, ii, 16, 296
Equator, i, 31-33
Equinoxes, i, 31
Equisetums (ek wi se' tumz) , i, 27
Erasistratus (er a sis' tra tus) , i, 404
Eratosthenes (er a tos' the nez), i, 13,
402, 405, 408
Erech, i, 190
Eretria, i, 332
Erfurt, ii, 364
Eridu (a'ridoo), i, 133, 190, 195, 196,
210, ii, 130
Ervine, St. John, ii, 499
Esarhaddon (e sar had' dn) , i, 246, 291,
319, ii, 606
Essad Pasha, ii, 554
Essenes (e senz'), i, 610
Essex, i, 623, ii, 40
Esthonians, ii, 244
Ethiopia (and Ethiopians), i, 200, 250,
383, ii, 606
Ethiopian dynasty, i, 195, ii, 606
Ethiopic language, i, 154
Ethnologists, i, 141
Etiquette in China, i, 434
Eton College, ii, 427
Etruria, i, 450, 460, 475
Etruscans, i, 447-50, 459, 464, ii, 91, 146,
606, 607
Eucharist, the, i, 591
Euclid, i, 364, 402, ii, 37
Euphrates, i, 148, 184-90, 194, 199, 203,
209, 238, 250, 291, 317, 507, 508, 523,
540, 562, 616, 622, ii, 2, 607
Euripides (urip'idez), i, 351, 355, 369,
392
Europe, i, 151, 159-62; Christianity in, i,
517, 603-05, 609, ii, 51, 84-86, 90, 96,
99-101, 114, 148, 159-63, 166-67, 206,
234, 244, 246, 270 ; common cause in, ii,
74-77 ; Concert of, ii, 373, 377, 378, 384,
385 : feudalism in, ii, 42 sqq. ; history
(general), i, 334, 544, 605-06, 625, ii, 42-
43, 54-57, 107, 140, 181, 200, 202, 206,
216, 232-36, 240-53, 262-63, 269-72.
360 sqq., 3G7, 370, 377-82, 431 ; Huns in,
i, 559, 628 ; Imperialism in, ii, 469-70,
475 sqq. ; industrial revolution in, ii,
276; intellectual development in, ii,
37-39, 88-89, 147, 167-69, 174-76;
languages of, i, 161 ; literature of, ii,
160; " Marriage with Asia," i, 390;
mechanical revolution in, ii, 393 sqq. ;
monarchy in, ii, 211, 230, 236-43,
253; Mongolians in, i, 549, ii, 112,
168; Moslems in, ii, 24, 28-32, 41,
47, 65, 121, 184, 186 ; natural political
map of, ii, 383, 446, 449, 566 ; peoples
and races of, i, 104, 138-39, 141, 145,
298-99, 546-48, ii, 137, 266 ; Powers
of, ii, 242-43, 278-79, 474; prehis-
toric, i, 59, 69, 75-77, 87-89, 95-105,
108, 118, 132-33, 140, 145, 149, 172-
76, 183-84, 196, 206, 234, 240, 317, ii,
189 ; social development in, ii, 140,
157, 176 sqq., 200, 215-16, 217, 246,
269-77, 400-401. (See also Great
War)
Europeans descended from Neolithic
man, i, 105
Euryptolemus (u rip tol' e mus), i, 347
Eusebius (u se' bi us), i, 600
Evans, i, 21
Evans, Sir Arthur, i, 104, 150, 212, 228
Evans, Sir John, i, 137
Everlasting League, ii, 199, 616
Evolution of the Earth, i, 5-6
Examinations, i, 270, 640
Excommunication, ii, 81
Executive, the, ii, 414
Exodus, book of, i, 279, 281
Experience, i, 230
Exploration, i, 217-18
"Expropriated," the, ii, 398
ex votos, i, 235, 414
Eylau (I' lou), battle of, ii, 362, 622
Ezekiel, i, 292, 294
FABIAN SOCIETY, ii, 409
Fabius, i, 477-78
Factories, growth of, ii, 275-77
Factory Act, ii, 404, 405, 622
Factory system, ii, 394, 405
Fairies, i, 182
Faith, decline of a universal, ii, 425
Faizi (fa'izi), ii, 135
Falkland Isles, battle of, ii, 520
Families, noble and plebeian, i, 267-68
Family groups, i, 79, 110, 178-82
Faraday, M., ii, 387, 427
Farming, Arab knowledge of, ii, 38
iFarrand, i, 158
Farrar, F. W., i, 527
INDEX
643
Fashoda (fa sh5' da), ii, 460, 500, 624
Fatepur-sikri (fut e poor' sik' ri), ii, 135,
136
Fatima (fat7 i ma), ii, 26, 31, 64
Fatimite caliphate, ii, 64, 76, 126, 614
Fauna, early, i, 101
Fausta, i, 599
Faustina (faws tl' na), i, 527
Fayle, C. E., ii, 543
Fear, i, 125
Feasts, Aryan, i, 172-73
Feathers, i, 43-44, 48-49
Ferdinand I, emperor, ii, 207, 210, 233
Ferdinand, king of Bulgaria, ii, 501,
509, 524
Ferdinand, king of Spain, ii, 186, 200
Ferguson, i, 252, 410
Fermentation, i, 172
Ferns, i, 24, 27
Ferrero (fer ra' ro), i, 455, 493, 502
Fetishism, i, 123, 129
Feudal system, the, i, 43 sqq.
Fezzan, i, 118
Fiefs, ii, 43
Field of the Cloth of Gold, i, 202
Fielding, H., ii, 272, 394
Fiji, ii, 471
Filmer, ii, 164
Finance, i, 496-98, ii, 202, 216
Finland (and the Finns), i, 549, 606, ii,
366, 375, 380
Finland, Gulf of, ii, 266
Finnish language, i, 156
Finno-Ugrian language, i, 560
Fire, early use of, i, 78-80
Fire-arms, i, 565
Fish, i, 10, 24, 25, 52
Fisher, Lord, ii, 526
Fisher, Osmond, i, 78
Fishing, i, 96-97, 114
Fiske, ii, 282
Fiume (fu' ma), ii, 566
Five Classics, the, i, 227
Flame projectors, ii, 516
Flanders, ii, 66, 78, 208, 329
Flavian dynasty, i, 526, ii, 609
Flax, i, 114
Fleming, Bishop, ii, 96
Flemings, the, ii, 47, 81, 178
Flemish language, ii, 47
Flint implements, i, 60, 68-69, 71, 78-
82, 88, 91, 94, 99, 107, 114, 137
Flood, story of the, i, 278, 293
Florence, ii, 180, 182-83, 195-97, 202,
239, 242, 618
Florentine Society, ii, 392
Florida, ii, 282
Flowers, Cainozoic, i, 51
Flying machines, i, 215, ii, 173, 174, 175,
392
Fontainebleau (f on tan bio') , ii, 361,
368
Food, i, 16, 20, 78-84, 113, 116, 186-87
Fools, i, 172
Foot of apes, men, and monkeys, i,
63-66
Forbes, ii, 129
Ford businesses, ii, 406
Forests, i, 37, 100-04
Fort St. Augustine, ii, 282
Fossils, i, 8-13, 26, 46-51, 57, 66, ii, 175,
419
Foucher, i, 429
"Fourteen Points," the, ii, 546-48, 556
Fowl, domesticated, i, 113, 114
Fowler, W. Warde, i, 148, 510
Fox, the, as food, i, 113
France, i, 74, 108; history (to Revo-
lutionary period), i, 88, 93, 146, 217,
522, 554, 606, 627, ii, 24, 41, 46-48,
51, 53, 62, 69, 75, 78-82, 87, 92, 98,
99, 127, 156-57, 166, 178, 179, 180,
193-205, 215-29, 234-39, 243-51, 267,
272, 279, 620, 621; (Revolutionary
period), ii, 157, 164, 242-47, 621 ; (Na-
poleonic period), ii, 248-74, 621; (to
Great War) , ii, 370-73, 382, 400, 438-^6,
484, 486, 509, 622, 623; (Great War),
ii, 48, 513 sqq. ; Imperialism, ii, 470,
500 ; overseas dominions, ii, 251—54,
279-86, 292, 363, 364, 451, 467. (See
also Franks, Gaul)
Francis, St., of Assisi, ii, 94-96, 161,
263, 615
Francis I, emperor, ii, 620
Francis II, emperor, ii, 622
Francis I, king of France, ii, 200-06,
618
Francis Ferdinand, archduke, ii, 510
Franciscan Order, ii, 94-96, 148, 171, 173,
193, 615, 616
Frankfort, ii, 180, 439, 623 ; Peace of, ii,
446-47, 477, 623
Franklin, Benj., ii, 303, 324
Franks, the, i, 552, 559, 564, 606, 609,
ii, 41, 42, 46-52, 57-62, 69, 78, 130,
144, 610
Frazer, Sir J. G., i, 116, 117, 125, 130-131,
249
Frederick I (Barbarossa), emperor, ii,
80, 86, 87, 89, 97, 615
Frederick II, emperor, ii, 80, 82, 86 sqq.,
112, 117, 148, 160-61, 199, 232, 421,
615, 616
644
INDEX
Frederick III, emperor, ii, 200
Frederick I, king of Prussia, ii, 240, 620
Frederick II (the Great) , king of Prussia,
ii, 240, 248, 264, 267, 300, 303, 620
Frederick III, king of Prussia, ii, 482
Frederick, don, ii, 230
Frederick, Margrave of Brandenburg, ii,
152
Free discussion, ii, 158 ; trade in Athens,
i, 460
Free intelligence, i, 262
Freedom, i, 259-60, ii, 279
Freeman's Farm, ii, 292
French language, i, 151, 564, ii, 47, 54,
66, 160, 199, 228
Freud, Sigismund, i, 127
Freya (fri'a), ii, 49
Friars, the, ii, 164, 172. (See also
Franciscan Order)
Friedland (f red ' lant) ,' battle of, ii, 362,
622
Frisian coast, i, 539 ; language, ii, 228
Frisians, the, ii, 49-51
Frog, the, i, 26
Froissart (frwa sar'), ii, 155
Fronde, the, ii, 234-36
Fu, S. N., i, 630-32, 641-42
Fuggers, the, ii, 202, 204, 271
Fulas, i, 206
Fuller, Colonel, ii, 571
Fulton, R., ii, 387
Furnace, blast, ii, 388 ; electric, ii, 389
Future life, belief in, i, 123, 538
G
GAELIC, i, 168, ii, 490
Gage, General, ii, 290, 294
Galatia, i, 449, ii, 608
Galatians, i, 395, 397, ii, 121
Galba, i, 526, ii, 609
Galerius, i, 594, 596, ii, 611
Galicia, ii, 518
Galilee, i, 571, 584, 587, 591, 621
Galileo (galile' 5), Galilei, ii, 176,
417, 618, 619
Gallas, language of the, i, 154
Galleys, i, 259
Galvani, ii, 387
Gama, Vasco da (vas kd' da ga' ma) , ii,
187-88, 257, 617
Gamaliel, i, 588
Gambia, i, 218
Games, i, 314
Gametes (gam ets'), i, 24
Gandhara (gan d ha' ra), i, 428
Ganesa (ga na' sha), i, 439
Gang labour, i, 265, 287
Ganges, i, 160, 201, 269, 270, 386, 388,
415, 430, ii, 106
Gardner, Alice, i, 625
Garibaldi, ii, 441
Gas, i, 170, 635
Gas in warfare, ii, 516, 569
Gaspee, vessel, ii, 289
Gath, i, 282
Gaul (and the Gauls), i, 196, 299, 388,
395, 450-51, 458-60, 471, 475, 500,
502-07, 509, 542, 553, 559, 564, 605,
613, ii, 41, 46, 61, 266, 608, 611
Gaulish language, i, 168
Gautama (gou' ta ma). (See Buddha)
Gaza, i, 261, 282, 379, 382
Gazelle, i, 56
Gaztelu, ii, 207, 208
Genesis, book of, i, 129, 277-82
Geneva, ii, 163, 199, 264, 559
Genoa (jen' o a) and the Genoese,
ii, 76, 80, 117, 153, 180, 182, 185, 347
Genseric (jen' serik), i, 556, 557, ii, 611
Gentiles, the, i, 580
Geography, i, 5
Geology, i, 5, 8, ii, 419
Geomancers (je 6 man' s£rs), i, 635
Geometry, ii, 37
George I, ii, 227, 620
George II, ii, 227, 620
George III, ii, 227, 288, 293, 314, 338, 620
George IV, ii, 228
George V, ii, 144, 228, 488, 498
George, Lloyd, ii, 499, 518, 534-38,
552-53, 557, 566
Georgia, ii, 282, 290, 443, 620
Gerasa (jer'asa), i, 621
Gerash, i, 623
Gerbert (gar' ber), ii, 37
German language, i, 151, 168, ii, 47, 160,
228; songs and tales, ii, 61
Germany, i, 101, 108, 318; history
(to Saxon kings), i, 502, 507, 509, 510,
522, 534, 539, 540, 552, 557, 603, ii,
46-47, 51, 57, 61-62, 144, 150, 609;
(Saxon kings to Napoleonic period), ii,
61, 69, 75, 80, 86, 87, 98-100, 112,
116, 138, 156, 157-62, 179, 180, 182,
188, 199-210, 216, 228, 232-36, 244-
48, 253, 256, 266-67, 283, 285, 292,
304, 339, 361-66, 614, 616, 618; (War
of Liberation to the Great War), ii, 367-
68, 381-82, 390-91, 396-401, 438-46,
467, 469-70, 476 sqq., 623; (Great
War), ii, 499 sqq. ; class distinction
in, i, 268; Imperialism of, ii, 470,
479-86, 508
INDEX
645
Gesture language, i, 163
Gethsemane, i, 585
Ghent, ii, 180, 199, 229
Gibbon, Edward, i, 531-35, 557, 558,
592, 595, 599, 608, 618, ii, 30, 42, 60,
62, 67, 69, 78, 82, 112, 227, 263-73,
277, 278, 308, 421
Gibbons (animal), i, 67
Gibbs, Philip, ii, 513, 516, 518, 530, 572
Gibraltar, i, 67, 120, 217, 532, ii, 41,
451, 471
Gideon, i, 283
Gigantosaurus (ji gan to saw' rus), i, 42
Gilbert, Dr., ii, 176, 619
Gilboa, Mount, i, 285
Gills, i, 23, 25, 52
Gin, i, 219
Giotto (jot' 6), ii, 183
Gipsies, ii, 137, 138
Gipsy language, ii, 138
Giraffe, i, 56
Girondins, ii, 328
Gizeh (ge' z£) , i, 198, 238
Glacial Age. (See Ice Age)
Gladiators, i, 489-91, 505, 529, 533, 589,
594, 609, ii, 608, 609
Gladstone, Sir John, ii, 427
Gladstone, W. EM i, 345, ii, 426-33, 447,
481, 495, 499, 623
Glasfurd, A. I. R., i, 114, 126
Glass, ii, 38
Glastonbury, i, 110, 171
Glaucia, i, 503
Glyptodon (glip' to don), i, 102, 207
Gneisenau (gni'z£nou), cruiser, ii, 520
Gneiss (nis), fundamental, i, 8
Gnosticism (nos' ti sizm), i, 592, 603
Goats in lake dwellings, i, 112
Gobi Desert, i, 160, 545, 634, 643, 644
God, i, 583, 592, 602, ii, 29, 171, 174;
idea of one true, i, 295-96, 400, 424,
436, 538, 569, 572, 576, ii, 5-7, 11, 18,
136; of Judaism, i, 219, 282 sqq.,
361, 412, ii, 16; Kingdom of, ii, 90,
97, 116, 149, 246
Godfrey of Bouillon, ii, 78, 228, 615
Gods, i, 234-39, 240, 245-46, 411-12,
483; Aryan, i, 233-34, 305 ; Egyptian,
i, 236-39, 248-52; Greek, i, 305,
361-62, 483; Japanese, i, 429; Se-
mitic, i, 233 ; tribal, i, 134, 295
Goethe, ii, 324
Gold, i, 105, 118, 220, ii, 89, 344
Golden Horde, the, ii, 134, 259
Goldsmith, Oliver, i, 376, ii, 273, 492,
493, 553
Golgotha, i, 586
Gooch, G. P., ii, 475
Good Hope, Cape of, ii, 257, 451, 617
Good Hope, cruiser, ii, 520
Goods, consumable, ii, 344
Goose, i, 113
Gorham, Nathaniel, ii, 300
Gorilla, i, 63, 67, 218
"Gorillas," i, 218
Goritzia (go ret' se d), ii, 519
Goshen, land of, i, 279
Gospels, the, i, 573, 576, 585-88, 593,
601, ii, 150, 418
Gotha (go' td) aeroplane, ii, 519
Gothic architecture, ii, 179; language,
i, 168
Goths, i, 528, 543, 549, 553, 556, 560-64,
606, 609, 611, 612, 615, ii, 41, 46, 57,
66, 610, 611, 612
Gough, General, ii, 530
Gould, Baring, i, 610
Gourgaud (goor go') , ii, 358
Government, i, 232-33, 241-42, 462-64,
ii, 147, 385
Gowland, Dr., i, 106
Gracchi, the, i, 502, ii, 147
Gracchus, Caius, i, 502, ii, 609
Gracchus, Tiberius, i, 483, 496-501,
ii, 609
Graham, Cunninghame, ii, 193
Grain, as food, i, 113-17, 184
Granada, ii, 186
Grand Remonstrance, ii, 221
Granicus (grani'kus), battle of the, i,
379, ii, 608
Grape, i, 172
Graphite, i, 9
Grasses, i, 51, 56
Gravelotte (gravlof), ii, 445
Gravesend, ii, 226
Gravitation, law of, ii, 176
Gray, G. B., i, 281
Gray, Thomas, ii, 227
Great Britain, history (general), ii,
244, 470; (and India), ii, 134-37,
254-59; (and America), ii, 253-54,
273, 279-82, 285-94, 621; (and
French Revolution), ii, 327, 331-32;
(in Napoleonic period), ii, 351-54,
359, 361, 366, 372, 621; (war with
Turkey), ii, 382; (Crimean war), ii,
440; (suspicion of Russia), ii, 447 ;
(in alliance against Germany), ii,
484-86; (the Great War), ii, 510 sqq.
(effect of Great War on), ii, 533-34
sqq. ; constitutional, political, and
social, i, 495, ii, 271-73, 298, 306-07,
321, 338, 388-89, 400, 486-87, 622.
646
INDEX
expansion and Imperialism, ii, 246-47,
451-60, 463, 469, 470-72, 486-99, 624.
(See also Britain and England)
Great Exhibition, the, ii, 436, 623
Great Mogul, ii, 256, 258
Great ox. (See Aurochs)
Great Schism. (See Papal Schism)
Great War, the, ii, 48, 166, 221, 235,
251, 510 sqq., 624
Greatness, ii, 303
Greece (and the Greeks), i, 86, 108, 114,
281, 313-18, 446-47, ii, 144, 160, 190 ;
history (to war with Persia), i, 13,
176-78, 213-16, 234, 281, 300 sqq.,
ii, 606; (war with Persia), i, 314-15,
327-42, ii, 607; (to 15th century), i,
343-45, 357, 362-64, 367-72, 377-78,
395, 449, 554, 611, 621, ii, 79, 98, 121-
26, 616; (modern), ii, 382, 502, 521-22,
524, 622 ; civilization, i, 304-14, 352-
53, 363-64, 455, 491-92, 623 ; consti-
tutional, i, 305-15, 360-64, 369, 378,
455, 488; religion, i, 240, 304-06,
354-55, 374, 412, 483, ii, 48 ; thought
and learning, i, 359-65, 399-404,
408-09, 488, 618, 636, ii, 35, 168
Greek, alphabet, i, 228-29 ; archipelago,
i, 119, 260; Church, i, 603, 617, ii,
58, 60, 73, 74, 78, 81, 98, 380, 611;
islands, i, 171, ii, 65; language and
literature, i, 151, 168, 173-76, 194,
300, 348, 354-56, 359-62, 402, 411,
530, 535, 562, 588, 614-15, 621, ii,
31, 35, 36, 50, 61, 73, 159, 211 ; war-
fare, i, 370
Greek (Eastern) Empire, see Eastern
(Greek) Empire
Green, J. R., ii, 154
Green flag, ii, 64
Greenland, i, 75, ii, 53, 185
"Greens," faction of the, ii, 247
Gregorovius, ii, 63
Gregory, Sir R. A., ii, 176, 384, 427
Gregory I, the Great, i, 612, 642, ii, 41,
50, 72, 97, 153, 167, 612
Gregory VII, ii, 72, 73, 74, 84, 149, 167,
615
Gregory IX, ii, 83, 87, 148, 616
Gregory XI, ii, 100, 127, 617
Grenfell, i, 137
Grey, Sir Edward, ii, 511
Grey Friars. (See Franciscan Order)
Grimaldi race, i, 88, 90-95, 120
Grimm's Law, i, 152
Grisons, i, 564
Grote, i, 351
Growth, i, 16
Guadalquivir (gaw dal kwiv' i?r) , ii, 188
Guianas, the, ii, 451
Guilds, i, 267
Guillemard, ii, 188
Guillotine, ii, 333
Guiscard (ges kar'), Robert, ii, 67, 69,
79, 615
Gulf Stream, i, 20
Gum-tree, i, 51
Gunpowder, i, 635, ii, 109, 121, 179, 268
Guptas (goop' tdz), i, 629
Gurkhas, ii, 455
Gustavus Adolphus, ii, 235, 236, 253
Gutenberg, ii, 159
Guthrum, ii, 54, 614
Gwalior, ii, 257
Gyges (gl' jez), i, 316, ii, 606
HAARLEM (harMem), ii, 159, 229, 231,
617
Habsburgs, ii, 63, 98, 140, 167, 199-202.
232, 235, 243, 248, 370, 371
Hackett, ii, 420-21
Hadrian, i, 526, 536, ii, 610
Hadrian, tomb of, i, 609, ii, 41
Hadrian's wall, i, 526-27
Hague Conferences, ii, 476-77
Haig, Sir Douglas, ii, 523
Hair, i, 49-54
Halicarnassus (hal i kar nas' us) , i, 260,
262, 340, 379, 380
Hall, i, 218
Hall, H. R., i, 184
Ham, son of Noah, i, 140
Hamburg, ii, 180, 182
Hamilcar, i, 471, 475
Hamilton, Alexander, ii, 303
Hamilton, Sir Ian, ii, 521
Hamilton, Sir William, ii, 390
Hamites, i, 158, 176, 189, 203, 244, ii, 41
Hamitic languages, i, 154, 155, 161, 162,
167 ; ships, i, 212
Hammond, ii, 269, 270
Hammurabi (ham moo ra' be) , i, 191,
196, 199, 201, 245, 258, 279, 385, ii,
606
Han, men of, i, 634
Han dynasty, i, 205, 253, 270, 433,
508, 509, 542, 543, 548, 630, 631, ii,
610
Hancock, ii, 290
Hang Chau (hang' chou), ii, 108, 615
Hannibal, i, 473-79, 483
Hanno, i, 196, 217-18, 221, 234, 241,
472, 509, 532, ii, 185, 607
INDEX
647
Hanover, ii, 338
Hanover, elector of. (See George I.)
Hanoverian dominions, ii, 244
Hanoverian dynasty, ii, 228, 236
Hansa towns, ii, 182-88
Hanse merchants, ii, 266
Harcourt, Sir William, ii, 411
Hardy, Thomas, i, 335, ii, 349
Hare, the, i, 113
Hariti, i, 428
Harnack, ii, 174
Haroun-al-Raschid (ha roon ar ra shed') ,
ii, 32, 33, 61, 613
Harpagos (har' pa g5s), i, 323
Harpalus (har' pa lus), i, 375, 387
Harpoons, i, 90, 96
Harran, i, 622
Harris, H. Wilson, ii, 543, 560
Harrison, Benjamin, i, 68
Harvey, John, ii, 177, 619
Hasan, son of Ali, ii, 27, 30
Hasdrubal, i, 472-76
Hastings, Warren, ii, 259, 453, 487
Hatasu (ha'tasoo), Queen of Egypt,
i,200
Hathor, i, 239, 249, 412, 413
Hatra, i, 622
Hatred, i, 472
Hauran, i, 623, ii, 2
Haverfield, F. J., i, 461, 605
Hawk gods, i, 237
Head, deformation of, i, 147
Headlam, J. W., ii, 377
Hearths, i, 171
Heaven, Kingdom of, i, 575-79, 582,
587, ii, 417. (See also God)
Hebert, ii, 335
Hebrew language, i, 153, 155, 164, 570,
572 ; literature, i, 293-94 ; prophets, i,
601 ; thought, i, 361 ; moral teaching,
i, 219. (See also Jewish)
Hebrews, i, 245, 279-283, ii, 1. (See
also Jews)
Hecataeus (hek a te' us) , i, 221
Hecker, ii, 154
Hector, i, 175, 183
Hedgehogs, i, 56
Hegira (hej' i ra), ii, 8, 12, 14, 17, 612
Heidelberg man, i, 60, 64, 69, 70-71, 84
Hekt, i, 239
Helen of Troy, i, 216
Helena, Empress, i, 618, ii, 82
Helena, mother of Constantine, i, 599
Heligoland, ii, 484, 623
Heliolithic (he Ii 5 lith' ik) culture, i,
147-49, 162, 171, 177, 184, 188, 196,
201, 207-13, 223, 415, ii, 189, 465
Heliolithic peoples, i, 206
Heliopolis (he Ii op' 6 lis), (Baalbek), i,
621, ii, 3
Helle, Andre, ii, 513
Hellenes, i, 300
Hellenic civilization, i, 302 sqq., n, 22,
168 ; tradition, i, 562
Hellenism, i, 353, 430, 570
Hellespont, i, 334-35, 339, 340, 362, 372,
379, 523, 621, ii, 20, 79, 137, 607, 612
Helmolt, H. F., i, 192, 541, 556, 635, ii,
18, 22, 136, 180
Helmont, van, i, 170
Helots, i, 305
Hen. (See Fowl, domesticated)
Henriot, ii, 336
Henry II, German Emperor, ii, 63
Henry V, German Emperor, ii, 63
Henry VI, German Emperor, ii, 86
Henry II, King of England, ii, 490
Henry III, King of England, ii, 219
Henry V, King of England, ii, 178
Henry VII, King of England, ii, 186,
218, 220
Henry VIII, King of England, ii, 163,
197, 200, 204, 206, 218, 220, 618
Henry of Prussia, Prince, ii, 300
Henry the Fowler, ii, 63, 70, 614
Henry, Patrick, ii, 287, 303
Hephaestion (he fes' ti <5n), i, 392, 394, 510
Hephaestus, i, 173
Heraclea (her a kle' <X), i, 453, ii, 608
Heraclius (her a kli' us), i, 615, 618, 623,
634, ii, 17-20, 82, 612, 613
Heraldry, i, 268
Herat, i, 386, 604
Herbivorous animals, i, 41, 43
Hercules, demi-god, i, 399, 515
Hercules, son of Alexander, i, 394
Hercules, temple of, i, 234
Herdsmen, i, 264, 267
Hereditary rule, ii, 144
Heredity, i, 230
Heretic, ii, 95
Heristhal, ii, 47
Hermon, Mount, i, 113, 184
Herne Island, i, 217
Hero, i, 402, 540
Herodes Atticus (herS'dez at'ikus),
i, 535, 536
Herodians, i, 579
Herodotus (he rod' 5 tus) , i, 186, 218,
221, 241, 260-62, 267, 296, 314, 319-
26, 332, 340, 342, 347, 350, 355, 356,
370, 399, 405, 497, 532, 615, 642, ii,
20, 607
Herods, the, i, 571, 574, 580, ii, 4
648
INDEX
Heroic Age, i, 177
Herophilus (he rof ' i lus) , i, 403, 404
Herzegovina (hert se gov' e na), ii, 484,
624
Hesperornis (hes per or' nis), i, 48
Hesse (hes' 2) and Hessians, ii, 51, 205,
445
Hezekiah, King, i, 291
Hieratic script, i, 228
Hiero (hi' & o), i, 468, 469, 476
Hieroglyphics, i, 208, 211, 227, 228
Hieronymus (hi er on' i miis) of Syra-
cuse, i, 476
Hildebrand. (See Gregory VII)
Himalayas, i, 35, 52, 160, 546
Hindu deities, i, 437, 439; priests, i,
180 ; schools, ii, 137
Hindu Rush, ii, 133
Hindus, i, 169, 179-81, 269-70, 299, 538,
ii, 134, 137, 256
Hindustan, ii, 108, 133
Hipparchus, i, 402
Hippias, i, 332
Hippo, i, 556, 604
Hippopotamus, i, 38, 69, 70, 76
Hippopotamus deities, i, 197, 236
Hira, ii, 18, 20
Hirai, K., i, 157
Hiram, King of Sidon, i, 287-90
Hirth, i, 435, 541, 582, 635
Histijeus, i, 330-31, 341, 561
Hittites, i, 192, 196, 200, 219, 278, 282,
283, 300, 327, ii, 121
Hi-ung-nu. (See Huns)
Hobson, J. A., ii, 543
Hoche, General, ii, 374
Hogarth, D. G., i, 367, 392
Hogarth, William, ii, 227
Hogue, cruiser, ii, 520
Hohenlinden, battle of, ii, 355, 622
Hohenstaufens (ho en stou' fenz), ii, 63,
98, 182, 199, 232, 616
Hohenzollerns, ii, 236, 240, 370, 442, 445,
479, 480
Holkham Hall, i, 13
Holland, i, 541, 605, ii, 47, 51, 159, 163,
182, 188, 193, 224, 229-30, 233, 236,
251, 257, 258, 282, 331, 339, 347, 359,
361, 368, 380, 381, 451, 457, 622
Holland, Rev. W. E. S., ii, 473
Holly, i, 51
Holmes, i, 615
Holmes, A., i, 13
Holmes, Rice, i, 104
Holstein, ii, 381
Holy Alliance, ii, 372, 377, 382, 400, 430,
476, 477
Holy Land. (See Crusades and Pales-
tine)
Holy Roman Empire, ii, 58, 63, 69, 130,
182, 198, 202 sqq., 210, 215, 238, 256,
614, 622
Homage, ii, 44
Home Rule Bill, i, 312
Homer, i, 114, 174-82, 196, 216, 219, 229,
300, 304, 508, 531
Homo antiquus. See Neanderthal man ;
Heidelbergensis, see Heidelberg man ;
Neanderthalensis, see Neanderthal
man ; primigenius, see Neanderthal
man ; sapiens, see Man, true)
Horns, i, 621
Honduras (hon dur' as) , British, ii, 254
Honey, i, 172
Honoria, i, 557
Honorius, i, 554, ii, 611
Honorius III, pope, ii, 87, 615
Hope in religion, i, 125
Hopf, Ludwig, i, 80, 118, 130
Hophni, i, 284
Horace, i, 407
Horn, Count of, ii, 229
Horn implements, i, 90, 107, 116
Horrabin, F., i, 119
Horses, i, 58, 64, 69, 70, 92-100, 105,
170, 177, 192, 299, 551
Horsuv Tyn, ii, 152
Horticulture, i, 254
Horus, i, 249, 252, 412-14, 429, 690,
591
Hose, i, 148
Hotel Cecil, i, 621
Hottentot language, i, 162
Households, growth of, i, 258
Houses, stone, i, 171
Howard, the philanthropist, ii, 338
Howe, F. C., ii, 543
Howorth, H. H., i, 541
Howth, ii, 498
Hrdlicka, Dr., i, 102
Hsia, Empire of, ii, 110
Hubbard, i, 536, 642
Hue, i, 429, 440
Hudson Bay Company, ii, 254, 451
Hudson Bay Territory, i, 158
Hudson River, ii, 292, 387
Hueffer, F. M., ii, 480
Hugo, Victor, ii, 355
Huguenots, ii, 244, 253, 282
Hulagu, ii, 114, 118, 120, 130, 154, 616
Human association, ii, 413
Human sacrifice, i, 116-17, 130-31, 134,
ii, 91, 190
Humayun (hoo ma' yoon), ii, 133
INDEX
649
Hungary (and the Hungarians), i, 106,
553, 558, 560, 600, ii, 51, 69, 70, 77,
100, 113, 122, 126, 139, 184, 204, 205,
233, 260, 380, 400, 446, 618. (See
also Austria)
Huns, i, 196, 203-05, 253, 272, 388, 508,
533, 539, 541, 543-52, 554, 557, 559,
618, 627-32, 644, ii, 66, 71, 106, 108,
113, 142, 266, 611
Hunter Commission, ii, 456
Hunting, i, 91, 92, 96-104, 112, 124, 317,
318
Husein, son of AH, ii, 27, 30
Huss, John, ii, 100, 151, 202, 263, 272,
615
Hussites, ii, 152-56, 617
Hut urns, i, 115
Hutchinson, i, 162
Hutchinson, H. N., i, 60
Hutton, ii, 419
Huxley, Prof., i, 13, 146, ii, 420-21, 426
Hwang-ho (hwang' ho), river, i, 205, 542,
641, ii, 108, 118
Hyaena cave, i, 76
Hysenodon (hi e' n5 don), i, 53
Hyde Park, ii, 437
Hyksos, i, 196, 199, ii, 1
Hyracodon (hi rak' 6 don), i, 53
Hystaspes (his tas' pez), i, 326, ii, 607
IBERIAN language, i, 167
Iberians, i, 101, 146, 167, 171, 176, 196,
213, 281, 298, 446, ii, 247. (See also
Mediterranean race)
Ibex, i, 93
Ibn Batuta (ibn ba too' ta), ii, 154
Ibn-rushd. (See Averroes)
Ibrahim, son of Muhammad, ii, 13
Icarus (ik' a rus), i, 215
Ice, effect of, i, 59
Ice Age, i, 52, 57-60, 68-72, 77, 82, 87,
119, 120, 159, 317
Iceland, ii, 53, 185, 252
Icelandic language, i, 168
I-chabod, i, 285
Ichthyosaurs (ik' thi 5 sawrz), i, 41, 45
Iconium, ii, 72
Ideograms, i, 224-26
Ideographs, i, 226
Idumeans, i, 570
Ignatius, St., of Loyola, ii, 164-66,
263, 618
Iliad, the. (See Homer)
Ilkhan, Empire of, ii, 114, 118, 127,
130
Illyria, i, 372, 375, 377, 472, 480, ii, 122,
608
Immortality, idea of, i, 124, 413, 423-
24, 538-39
Imperator, title of, i, 565
Imperial preference, ii, 488
Imperialism, i, 311, ii, 424, 436, 461,
475 sqq., 498-502
Implements, bone, i, 99 ; bronze, i, 132 ;
Chellean, i, 70 ; copper, i, 105 ; earliest
use of, i, 67-68; flint, i, 71, 76-81, 88,
91, 96, 99, 107, 114; horn, i, 90, 107,
116; iron, i, 107; Neolithic, i, 104-05,
114, 132 ; Palaeolithic, i, 76, 104, 137 ;
Pliocene, i, 68-69 ; stone, i, 57, 67, 69,
75, 80, 88, 96, 104, 106, 273; use of
by animals, i, 67 ; wooden, i, 76
Inca of Peru, ii, 190
Independency, ii, 163
India, i, 37, 74, 106, 109, 114, 160, 181-
82, 206, 327, 396, 432, 489, 509, 532,
548, 626, ii, 27, 33, 109, 133, 139, 144,
268, 351 ; history (Alexander in), i,
379, 386, 388, 428, 510; (Indo-
Scythians in), i, 548, 617, 628, ii, 610;
(Ephthalites in), i, 629, ii, 611 ; (Mon-
gols in), i, 550, 557, ii, 114, 133-37;
(17th and ISth centuries), ii, 254, 256-
58, 262; (British in), ii, 133-37, 254-
59, 279, 285, 451-56, 471, 487, 620, 621 ;
civilization, social development, and
culture, i, 147, 171, 179, 183, 196,
201, 268-70, 272, 307, 415-16, 430, ii,
136, 145, 455; European settlements
in, ii, 254-59, 279, 285, 620 ; languages
of, i, 158, 169, 189, ii, 139-40 ; peoples
and races, i, 138-39, 145, 158-60, 196,
201, 203, 317, 386, 629, ii, 106, 190;
religions of, i, 270, 416 sqq., 440, 604,
610, 625, ii, 108, 114, 136, 166; trade
of, i, 401, 533, 640, ii, 257; travels
and voyages to, i, 533, 642, 645, ii,
119, 185-87, 465, 612, 617
Indian corn, i, 113
Indian ocean, i, 47, 108, 118, 210, ii, 187
Indian sign-language, i, 150
Indians, American. (See American In-
dians)
Indies, East, i, 46, 148, 159, 162, 206,
210, 273, ii, 257, 451, 461
Indies, West, ii, 187, 252, 305, 306, 451
Individual, the free, i, 259
Individuality, in reproduction, i, 17
Indo-European languages. (See Aryan
languages)
Indo-Iranian language, i, 169; people,
i, 538
650
INDEX
Indonesian life, i, 177
Indore, ii, 257
Indo-Scythians, i, 548, 617, 628, ii, 610
Indulgences, ii, 93, 202
Indus, i, 159, 182, 201, 327, 385-89, 395,
430, 507, 523, ii, 22, 132, 607
Industrial Revolution, ii, 276, 393-98,
405
Industrialism, ii, 273-75
Infanticide, i, 134
Influenza, ii, 384
Information, ii, 413
Infusoria, i, 21
Inge, Dean, i, 583, 587, ii, 416
Innes, A. D., ii, 218
Innocent III, pope, ii, 82, 86-98, 167, 615
Innocent IV, ii, 81, 88, 116
Inns, early, i, 220
Innsbruck, ii, 207
Inquisition, the, ii, 95, 117, 166, 209, 378
Insects, i, 5, 28
Instruments, Neolithic musical, i, 115
Interglacial period, i, 60, 68-70, 75-76
"International," the, ii, 409
International relationship, ii, 347
Internationalism, ii, 432
Intoxicants, i, 172, 182
Investitures, ii, 44, 74, 85
Ion, poet, i, 347
lona, ii, 50
Ionian Islands, ii, 351
lonians, i, 314-16, 327-32, 337-40, ii, 121
Ionic dialect, i, 300
Ipsus (ip' sus), battle of, i, 395
Irak, ii, 33
Iran (gran7), i, 508, 626
Iranians, i, 299, 627
Ireland, i, 86, 102, 105, 110, 182, 209,
299, 312, 603, ii, 40, 50, 66, 97, 178,
224-26, 424, 432,471, 488-99, 621, 623,
624
Irene (I re' ne), Empress, ii, 58
Irish, Catholics, ii, 222, 224, 244; lan-
guage, i, 152, 168 ; prisoners, ii, 284 ;
race, i, 167
Irish sea, i, 75
Iron, i, 4, 79, 133 ; as currency, i, 219-
20 ; use of, i, 107, 187, 196, 205, 207,
ii, 275, 387-89, 606
Iron Age, i, 97, 108, 133
Ironsides, ii, 223
Iroquois (ir 6 kwoi') tribes, ii, 285
Irrigation, i, 37, 190
Irving, Washington, ii, 253
Isaac, patriarch, i, 278-79
Isabella of Castile, ii, 186, 200
Isaiah, i, 578
Ishmael, i, 279
Ishtar, i, 232, 245, 279, 283
Isis, i, 239, 249, 412-14, 428-29, 638,
575, 590-91
Iskender, i, 389
Islam, i, 296, 441, 583, 624, 636, ii,
4 sqq., 113, 142, 194; and Chris-
tianity, ii, 34, 35, 64, 114, 149; propa-
ganda of, ii, 15-16, 28, 51, 108, 116,
127, 142, 256, 396, 397 ; teaching of,
ii, 14 sqq., 64, 136, 146, 402. (See
also Moslems, and Muhammadanism)
Isocrates (I sok' ra tez), i, 351, 357, 363,
367, 373, 390, 397
Ispahan (is pa han') , ii, 132
Israel, Kingdom of (and Israelites),
i, 193, 277 sqq., 316, ii, 144, 244, 606.
(See also Jews)
Issik Kul (is' ik kool), i, 643
Issus, battle of, i, 380-84, ii, 20, 78, 608
Italian language, i, 151, 446, ii, 160,
199
Italy (and Italians), i, 106, 196, 213, 281,
388, 446-47, 526, 611, ii, 121, 144,
608; history (Greeks in), i, 302, 304,
346, 447, 451-52, ii, 606-08 ; (Gauls in),
i, 388, 449, 471; (Roman), i, 453,
460, 494, 499-505, ii, 147; (invasion
by Hannibal), i, 475-77; (Goths in),
i, 553, 606, ii, 46, 65, 612; (Huns
in), i, 559, 608; (Lombards in),
i, 606, 616, ii, 57, 153, 612 ; (Charle-
magne in), ii, 57—58; (Germans in),
ii, 58, 618; (Normans in), ii, 67, 69,
76; (Saracens in), ii, 67; (Magyars
in), ii, 69; (I3th-18th cent.'), ii, 83,
87-89, 97-98, 126, 127, 182-84, 195-
97, 204, 216, 233, 236, 621-22;
(Napoleonic period), ii, 332, 339, 347,
350-55, 359, 364, 622 ; (to unification
of), ii, 380-82, 400, 432; (Kingdom
of), ii, 440-45, 461, 469-70, 500-01,
519, 622, 624; imperialism of, ii,
470, 500. (See also Rome and Great
War)
Ivan III, ii, 129, 617; IV (the Terrible),
ii, 129, 618
Ivory, trade in, i, 273
Ivy, fossil, i, 51
JACKSON, SIR Louis, ii, 567 sqq.
Jackson, T. G., ii, 61
Jacob, patriarch, i, 278 sq.
Jacobins, French, ii, 324, 333 sqq., 342,
349, 621
INDEX
651
Jacquerie, ii, 156, 502, 621
Jade, i, 118
Jaffa, ii, 353
Jaipur (jl poor'), ii, 256
Jamaica, ii, 254, 451, 471
James I, i, 110, ii, 216 sqq., 237, 253,
280
James II, ii, 226, 491
James, St., i, 580
James, Henry, ii, 550
Jameson, Dr., ii, 424
Jamestown, ii, 284, 305
Janissaries, ii, 122, 132
Japan, i, 139, 429, 432, 642, ii, 119, 185,
187, 261-62, 463-70, 623, 624
Japanese, i, 66, 147, 636, ii, 464; lan-
guage and writing, i, 156, 638
Japhet, i, 140
Jarandilla, ii, 207
Jarrow, ii, 50
Java, i, 68, ii, 187
Jaw, chimpanzee, i, 72 ; human, ib.
Piltdown (see Piltdown)
Jefferson, Tho., ii, 293, 303 sqq.
Jehad (je had'), "holy war," ii, 80.
Jehan (je ban'), Shah, ii, 133
Jehangir, ii, 133
Jehovah, i, 282, 287, 293, 307, 412
Jena (y§/ na), battle of, ii, 362, 364, 476,
622
Jengis Khan (jen' gis kan), ii, 106,
108, 109 sq., 116 sq., 121, 128 sqq.,
261, 615
Jenne, i, 565
Jerboas, ii, 154
Jerome of Prague, ii, 151
Jerusalem, i, 247, 278, 288-93, 411, 523,
571-72, 575, 578, 580-81, 584-86,
589, 604, 618-19, 623, ii, 11, 21, 22,
64, 75, 78-84, 97, 229, 483, 612, 615
Jesuits, ii, 117, 127, 164 sq., 193, 309,
390, 465, 618 sq.
Jesus, spirit and teaching of, i, 296,
492, 572 sqq., 601, 617, 626, ii, 6,
13 sqq., 54, 64, 85, 90 sqq., 116, 127,
149 sq., 158, 163, 263, 296, 342, 360,
376, 402, 417, 426, 609 sq.
Jet, i, 105
Jevons, F. B., i, 118
Jewellery, iron, i, 107
Jewish religion and sacred books, i,
278, 294-96, 400, 411, 440, 538, 571-
72, 576, ii, 36, 417
Jews, i, 200, 247, 278, 292-97, 303, 402,
411, 569-72, 609-10, ii, 3-9, 18, 29,
32, 36, 41, 71, 77, 88, 121, 147, 242,
248, 424, 607. (See also Judaism)
"Jingo," ii, 447
Jingo, queen, ii, 465
Joab, i, 287
Joan of Arc, ii, 179
Job, Book of, i, 114, 294
Jodhpore (jod poor'), Raja of, ii, 135
John, king of England, ii, 81, 219
John II, king of Portugal, ii, 186
John III, king of Poland. (See So-
biesky, John)
John X, pope, ii, 62, 614
John XI, pope, ii, 62, 614
John XII, pope, ii, 62 sq., 73, 97, 614
John of Leyden, ii, 156
John, Prester, ii, 119
John, St., ii, 580, 598; Gospel of, i,
573, ii, 30, 50
Johnson, i, 238
Johnson, Samuel, ii, 493
Johnston, R. M., ii, 348
Jones, F. Wood, i, 63
Jones, H. Stuart, i, 454, 516, 522, 634,
609
Joppa, i, 282
Jordan, river, i, 278, ii, 19
Joseph, St., i, 574
Joseph II, emperor, ii, 240, 620 sq.
Josephine, empress. (See Beauharnais)
Josephus, i, 500, 571 sq.
Joshua, i, 282
Josiah, king of Judah, i, 292, ii, 607 sq,
Judah, kingdom of, i, 289 sqq., ii, 244
Judaism, i, 440, 570, 583, ii, 16, 142, 149.
(See also Jews)
Judas, i, 585
Judea, i, 196, 278, 365, 436, 538, 569 sqq.,
584 sqq., ii, 4, 27
Judges, Book of, i, 282 sq.
Judges of Israel, i, 467, ii, 144
Jugo-Slavs (u' g5 slavz) . (See Yugo-
slavs)
Jugurtha (joo gur' thd), i, 502 sq., ii,
609
Julian the Apostate, i, 625, ii, 611
Julius III, ii, 208
Jung, i, 361
Jungle fowl, i, 114
Juno, i, 218, 483
Junot, Mme., ii, 349
Jupiter, i, 233, 412 sq., 448, ii, 49
Jupiter, planet, i, 4
Jupiter Ammon, i, 252
Jupiter Serapis, i, 412
Justinian, i, 606, 608, 611, 613, 633,
ii, 46, 57 sq., 124, 153, 384, 612
Jutes, i, 554, 605, ii, 54, 66
Jutland, battle of, ii, 520
652
INDEX
KAABA (ka' a ba), ii, 6 sqq., 11, 27
Kadessia, battle of, ii, 20, 613
Kadija (ka de' jd~), ii, 6 sqq.
KafBrs, i, 219
Kaisar-i-Hind, i, 565, ii, 134
Kaisar-i-Roum, i, 565
Kaiser, Austrian, i, 565 ; German, i, 565
Kali (ka'le), i, 439
Kalifa. (See Caliph)
Kalinga, i, 431
Kalmucks (kal'muks), i, 137, 143, 545,
ii, 128
Kanishka (ka nish' kd), i, 628, 646, ii, 610
Kao-chang, i, 644
Karakorum (ka ra kor' am) , ii, 110 sqq.,
134
Karma (kar' ma) , doctrine of, i, 425
Karnak, i, 200
Kashgar (kashgar'), i, 546, 628, 643,
ii, 22, 109, 118, 610
Kashmir, Buddhists in, i, 432
Kautsky, ii, 510
Kavadh, i, 624, 634, ii, 1, 366, 612
Kazan (kazan'), ii, 118
Keane, A. H., i, 118, 161
Keith, Dr. A., i, 63, 71 sq.
Keltic languages, i, 168, 182, 299, 446, 605
Keltic race, i, 110, 168, 176, 182, 196, 299,
388, 395, 554, ii, 40, 48, 228, 490
Kelvin, Lord, i, 13
Kent, Duke of, ii, 405
Kent, Kingdom of, ii, 40
Kepler, ii, 176, 619
Kerensky, ii, 526-27
Kerne Island, i, 217
Ketboga, ii, 114, 132, 616
Keynes, J. M., ii, 541, 557, 560
Khalid (kaled'), ii, 18 sq.
Khans, i, 644, ii, 108 sqq., 126 sqq., 144,
615 SQ.
Kharismia, ii, 106, 109, 615
Khazars (kazarz'), ii, 70, 71
Khedive, the, of Egypt, ii, 471
Khitan people, ii, 109, 118
Khiva (ke' va), ii, 106, 108
Khokand (ko kand'), i, 546, ii, 110
Khorasan (ko ra sari'), ii, 31, 37
Khotan (ko tan'), i, 628, ii, 118, 610
Khyber Pass, i, 386, 548, 643, ii, 257
Kiau-Chau (kyou' chou'), ii, 469 sq.t
564, 624
Kidnapped children sent to New Eng-
land, ii, 284
Kieff, ii, 67, 110 SQ., 129, 134, 614;
Grand Duke of, ii, 110
Kin Empire, ii, 108-09 SQ., 128, 261, 615
Kings, book of, i, 193, 282, 287, 289, 291
Kings (and kingship), i, 134, 178, 218,
240 SQQ., 248 SQQ., 263, 285 SQQ., 305 SQ.,
430, ii, 142, 194, 233-34, 286, 375 SQ. ;
divine right of, ii, 216, 221
Kioto (kyo'to), ii, 467
Kipchak, Empire, ii, 114, 128 sg.
Kipling, Rudyard, ii, 423, 462, 488
Kirghis (kirgez'), ii, 109; steppe, i, 634
Kitchen-middens, i, 109, 110, 152
Kiwi, i, 207
Knighthood, i, 465, ii, 202
Knights, i, 268, ii, 179; of the Shire,
i, 463, ii, 218
Knipe, H. R., i, 50
Knives, flint, i, 96
Knots, records by means of, i, 208
Knowledge, diffusion of, i, 296, 397 SQQ.,
487, ii, 168-69
Konia, ii, 72, 78
Konigsberg, ii, 180, 367
Koran, ii, 9 SQ., 15, 29 sg., 257
Korea, i, 633, 638 sg., ii, 261, 465 sgg.
Korean alphabet, i, 638; language,
i, 156
Kosciusko (kos i us' ko), ii, 251
Krapina, i, 72
Kremlin, the, ii, 242
Krishna (krish' na), i, 439
Kropotkin, ii, 425
Kriidener, Baroness von, ii, 372
Krum, Prince of Bulgaria, ii, 58, 69, 614
Krupp, firm of, ii, 514
Kshatriyas (ksha tre' yaz), i, 269, 270
Kuan-yin, i, 429
Kublai Khan (koo' bll kirn), ii, 108
SQQ., 126 sg., 144, 616 SQ.
Kuen-lun (kwen loon') mountains, i,
201, 546, 548, 643
Kufa, ii, 36
Kushan (koo shan') dynasty, i, 628
Kusinagara, i, 646
Kut, ii, 522
Kutub, ii, 108, 615
LABOUR, i, 255, 265, 271, ii, 154-56,
157-58, 193, 404 sqq., 478
Labour Colleges, i, 487
Labourers, Statute of, ii, 156
Labrador, i, 78, 124, 137, ii, 435
Labyrinth, Cretan, i, 214, 216
Lacedemon (las e de' mon) , i, 303
Lacedemonians, i, 307, 322, 332
Lade, i, 331
S
INDEX
653
Ladrones (la dronz'), ii, 187
Lady smith, i, 485
Lafayette (la fa yet'), General, ii, 292,
316, 318, 324, 327
Lagash (la' gash), i, 195
Lahore, ii, 110
Lake dwellings, i, 109-112, 133. (See
also Pile dwellings)
La Madeleine, i, 96
Lamas, Grand, i, 429
Lamballe, princesse de, ii, 329
Lamps, Palaeolithic, i, 95
Lance head, bronze, i, 132
Land, tenure of, i, 256, 271
Lanfranc, Archbishop, ii, 150
Lang, Andrew, i, 79
Langley, Prof., ii, 392
Languages of mankind, i, 126, 133,
150-64, 167-74, 189, 227, 298, 446
Lankester, Sir Ray, i, 50, 63, 68, 72-74
Laodicea (la o di se'.a), ii, 79
Lao Tse (la'otz£), i, 433, 436, 582,
632, 641, 647, ii, 106, 402, 607
Laplace, i, 31
Lapland, i, 156
Larsa, i, 195
Las Casas (las ka' sas), ii, 193, 305
Lateran, the, ii, 57, 63, 73, 84, 90, 92, 97
Latin, emperors, ii, 97, 229 ; language
and literature, i, 168, 169, 189, 461,
530, 534-5, 564, 605, 613, ii, 60, 71,
73, 130, 160
Latins, the, i, 445-^54, ii, 616
Latium, i, 447
Laud, Archbishop, ii, 221
Laughter, ii, 373
Law, i, 309, 616, ii, 46
Lawrence, Colonel, i, 188
Lawrence, General, ii, 455
Leaf, Walter, i, 216
League of Nations, ii, 545, 548-49, 557-
564, 624
Learning, i, 240-11, 609, ii, 114
Leather, Arabian, ii, 38; money, i, 220,
ii, 89 ; as clothing, i, 408
Lebanon, i, 287, 621, 623
Lecky, i, 426
Lecointre (lekwantr'), ii, 318
Lee, General, ii, 301, 444
Leeuwenhoek (la/ ven huk), ii, 177
Legge, i, 401, 413, 538, 595
Legion of Honour, ii, 357
Legrain, L., i, 241
Leicestershire, ii, 156
Leiden, ii, 229
Leipzig (lip'sik), ii, 180; battle of, ii,
368
Leipzig, cruiser, ii, 620
Lemberg, ii, 518
Lemming, i, 58
Le Moustier, i, 78
Lemurs, i, 56-57, 65
Lena, river, ii, 267
Lenin (len' in), ii, 409-11, 527
Leo I, i, 559; III, ii, 57, 58, 60, 97, 613;
X, ii, 200-203, 618
Leo the Isaurian, ii, 29
Leonidas (leon'idas), i, 336
Leopold I, of Saxe-Coburg-Gotha, ii,
381, 436, 622
Leopold, king of Belgium, ii, 438
Lepanto, battle of, ii, 140, 184
Lepers, ii, 94
Lepidus (lep' i dus), i, 514
Levant, the, i, 598, ii, 194
Levantine lake, i, 210
Leverhulme, Lord, ii, 406
Levites, i, 288
Leviticus, Book of, i, 281
Lex Valeria, i, 457
Lexington, ii, 290-91, 621
Lhassa, i, 438, 591
Liang-chi-chao, i, 205
Liao-tung (le ou' toong'), ii, 469
Liberal Party, ii, 489
Liberia, i, 217, ii, 461
Libraries, i, 246, 292, 405-09
Libyan script, i, 228
Licinian Rogations and Laws, i, 459,
499, 631
Licinius, i, 459
Liege (le azh'), ii, 513, 514
Liegnitz (leg' nits), battle of, ii, 112,
616
Life, i, 6, 16; early forms of, i, 7-15,
19-22, 38 sqq. ; intellectual develop-
ment of human, i, 229-31
Light, essential to plants, i, 24
Ligny (lenye'), ii, 371
Ligurian republic, ii, 347
Lilybseum, i, 469, 470
Limerick, Treaty of, ii, 492
Lincoln, Abraham, i, 345, ii, 443, 623
Lion, the, i, 69, 70, 76, 102, 178, 317
Lippi, Filippo, ii, 183
Lisbon, i, 529, ii, 80, 180, 187, 207, 257
Lissa, battle of, ii, 445
Literature, prehistoric, i, 173
Lithuania, ii, 129, 244
Liu Yu, i, 633
Liverpool, ii, 386, 622
Lizards, i, 46
Llama, i, 56, 207
Lloyd, i, 346, 446
654
INDEX
Lloyd, L., i, 174
Lob Nor, ii, 118
Lochau (15 chou'), ii, 206
Locke, John, ii, 288, 309, 620
Lockyer, Sir Norman, i, 240
Logic, study of, ii, 168
Loire (Iwar), the, ii, 46
Lombardy (and Lombards), i, 143, 564,
606, 608, 612, 616, ii, 46, 57, 153, 361,
441, 612
London, ii, 154, 156, 180, 182, 221, 222,
249, 259, 289, 361, 370, 398, 437, 470,
483, 492, 520, 532, 623
London, Royal Society. (See Royal
Society of London)
London, University of, ii, 437
Londonderry, ii, 497-98, 624
Longinus (Ion ji' nus), i, 535
Long Island Sound, ii, 281
Longwy (lonve'), ii, 329
Loos, ii, 517
Lopez de Recalde, Inigo. (See Ignatius,
St., of Loyola)
Lords, House of, i, 466, 489, ii, 219,
224-26, 236, 298
Loreburn, Lord, ii, 510
Lorraine, ii, 446, 487
Lost Ten Tribes, i, 193
Louis the Pious,, ii, 47, 60-61, 614
Louis VII, ii, 80; IX, ii, 84, 116, 616;
XI, ii, 179 ; XIV, ii, 226, 236, 237-39,
249, 253, 311, 331, 356, 376; XV, ii,
239-40, 243^4, 264, 332, 356, 620;
XVI, ii, 240, 243, 267, 308, 311 sqq.,
337, 370, 621 ; XVII, ii, 370; XVIII,
ii, 370, 378, 622
Louis Philippe, ii, 379, 622
Louisiana, ii, 254, 286
Lourdes, i, 591
Louvain University, ii, 553
Low, Sidney, ii, 473
Loyalty, modern conceptions of, ii, 424
Loyola (15-yo' Id, loio'ld), St. (See
Ignatius, St., of Loyola)
Lu, i, 434
Lubbock, Sir John. (See Avebury,
Lord)
Lubeck, ii, 182
Lucerne, Lake of, ii, 198
Lu-chu Islands, i, 631
Lucknow, ii, 257, 455
Lucretius (lu kre' shi us) , i, 488, 534, ii,
419
Lucullus (lukul'us),i, 505
Luke, St., i, 573
Lull, Prof., i, 6, 7
Lunar month, i, 129
Lung-fish, i, 25
Lungs, i, 25, 55
"Lur," bronze, i, 132
Lusitania, liner, ii, 520
Luther, Martin, ii, 160, 162-63, 171,
202-03, 206, 618
Lutterworth, ii, 96
Liitzen (luf sen), ii, 236
Lutzow, Count, ii, 152
Luxembourg, ii, 381, 445, 511
Luxembourg Palace, ii, 354
Luxor, i, 200, 250
Lvoff, Prince, ii, 525
Lyceum, Athens, i, 357, 359
Lycia, sea-battle of, ii, 28
Lycurgus (Ii kur' gus), i, 221
Lydia (and Lydians), i, 220, 314-16,
320 sqq., 326-7, 370, 395, 416, 482, ii,
121, 606
Lydian language, i, 162 ; script, i, 228
Lyell, Sir C., i, 50, ii, 419
Lynd, ii, 499
Lyons, i, 560, ii, 333
Lysias (lis' i as) , orator, i, 306
Lysimachus (Ii sim' & kiis), i, 395
M
MACALLISTER, STEWART, i, 168
Macaulay, Lord, i, 450, ii, 270, 273, 428
Macaulay Island, i, 218
Maccabeans, i. 571, ii, 4
McCurdy, ii, 613
MacDougall, i, 148
Macedon, i, 622
Macedonia (and the Macedonians), i,
213, 303, 308, 331, 340, 363, 367 sqq.,
386-95, 401-2, 430, 452, 476, 480, ii,
2, 43, 122, 145, 268, 380, 607
Machiavelli (ma ke a vel' e) , N., ii,
195-98, 202, 210, 240, 479, 618
Machinery, ii, 275, 395
Mac Neilh, i, 168
Madagascar, i, 207
Madeira, ii, 185
Madelin, ii. 307
Madhurattha Vilasini (mad' hoo-
rat't'ha vi la' sine), i, 421
Madison, ii, 303
Madras, i, 179, 431, ii, 142, 258
Mseander (me an' der), ii, 79
Mselius, Spurius, i, 458, 500
Magdalenian Age, i, 96, 97 ; clothing,
i, 408 ; hunters, i, 317
Magdeburg, ii, 180, 235
Magellan, Ferdinand, ii, 187-88, 618
Magenta, ii, 441, 623
INDEX
655
Magic and magicians, i, 134, 235
Magna Carta, ii, 219, 615
Magna Grsecia, i, 302, 316, 451, 452
Magna Mater, i, 483
Magnesia, i, 397, 482, ii, 608
Magnetism, ii, 176
Magyar language, i, 156, 560, ii, 70
Magyars (mod' yorz, majarz'), i, 560,
606, ii, 69, 113
Mahaffy, i, 357, 389, 401, 404
Mahan, ii, 352
Mahrattas, ii, 257
Maillard, ii, 316-17
Maimonides (ml mon' i dez) , ii, 36
Maine, ii, 281, 282
Mainz (mints), ii, 60, 159, 180, 331
Maize, i, 113, 207
Majuba, ii, 460, 489, 623
Malabar, i, 533
Malay-Polynesian languages, i, 158
Malays, i, 203, ii, 465
Malleson, ii, 133
Mallet, ii, 309
Malory, Sir Thomas, i, 175
Malta, ii, 225, 351, 359, 451, 470
Mamelukes, ii, 122, 126, 132
Mammals, i, 46-50, 58-59, 64 sqq. (See
also Animals)
Mammoth, i, 58, 64, 69, 76, 78, 92, 95,
99, 101
Man, i, 5, 17, 21, 37, 41, 63-67, 101, 105-
109, 110, 134-35 ; ancestry of, i, 49, 56-
59, 63-69, ii, 420 ; brotherhood of, i, 584 ;
early, i, 57, 85-88, 91, 100-09, 115, 122-
35, 145, 149, 273, 407, ii, 341 ; Eoan-
thropus, i, 60, 70-74; Heidelberg, i,
60, 69, 71, 84 ; life of common, i, 255 ;
as mechanical power, ii, 394 ; Nean-
derthal, i, 60, 72, 90, 91-95, 97, 108,
122-25; primeval, i, 76-84; and the
State, ii, 244-45
Manchester, ii, 386, 404, 622
Manchu (man choo') language, i, 156
Manchuria, i, 546, 641, ii, 261, 463-69,
484
Manchus, ii, 128, 261, 464
Mandarins, i, 270, 272
Mangu Khan, ii, 113, 116, 616
Mani (ma'ne), i, 626-27, ii, 6, 13, 14,
91-92, 611
Manichseans (man i ke' #nz), i, 603, 626,
ii, 29, 91-92
Manichseism, i, 626
Manif (ma nef), ii, 5, 11
Mankind, i, 136-149, 295-7, 365;
brotherhood of, ii, 246
Manlius, Marcus, i, 458, 473, 500
Manny, Sir Walter, ii, 154
Manresa (man ra' sd), Abbey of, ii, 165
Mansfield, Lord, ii, 306
Mansur, ii, 31
Mantinea (man ti ne' a), i, 378
Mantua (man' tyu d), ii, 33,2
Manuscripts, i, 407, 627, ii, 159
"Manzi," ii, 118
Manzikert (man' zi kurt) , ii, 72
Mara, Indian god, i, 418
Marat (mara'), ii, 324-33, 374
Marathon, i,33J-7, 345, 346, ii, 607
Marchand, Colonel, ii, 460
Marcus Aurelius. (See Antoninus)
Mardonius (mar do ni iis), i, 339, 340
Marduk (mar dook), a god, i, 237
Marengo, ii, 355, 622
Margoliouth, D. S., ii, 1
Maria Theresa, ii, 240, 251, 620, 621
Marie Antoinette, ii, 311
Marie Louise, Archduchess, ii, 365, 374
Mariner's compass, i, 635, ii, 121
Maritime power, i, 215-16
Marius (mar' i us), i, 486, 502-05, ii, 511,
609
Mark, St., i, 573, 578, 579, 580
Marly, ii, 317
Marmots, i, 47
Marne, ii, 515, 530
Marozia, ii, 62, 614
Marriage and intermarriage, i, 179, 237,
250, 267
Mars, god, ii, 49
Mars, planet, i, 4, 5
Marseillaise, the, ii, 331
Marseilles (mar salz'), i, 203, 447, 475,
ii, 82, 94, 180, 204, 333, 616
Marston Moor, ii, 223
Martel, Charles, ii, 45, 47^8, 614
Martin V, Pope, ii, 96, 100, 152, 617
Marvin, F. S., i, 401, ii, 90, 384
Marx, Karl, ii, 398, 399, 408, 409, 411,
415-16, 485
Marxists, i, 268
Mary, the Egyptian, ii, 13
Mary, the Virgin, i, 575, 591
Mary I, Queen of England, ii, 218, 220
Mary II, Queen, of England, ii, 226
Maryland, ii, 282, 283, 284, 290
Mas d'Azil, i, 101
Masai hunters, i, 318
Masked Tuaregs, i, 154
Mason, Capt. John, ii, 282
Mason, Otis T., i, 63, 104
Mason and Dixon line, ii, 282, 284
Maspero, i, 250, 252
Mass, the, ii, 149
656
INDEX
Massachusetts, ii, 281, 282, 290, 296,
. 300, 306, 338, 621
Massage, i, 147
Massinissa, King, i, 479
Mastodon (mas' to don), i, 58, 73
Mathematics, ii, 35-36, 37, 114
Matheson, i, 445
Matthew, St., i, 573, 577, 587
Maulvi Muhammad Ali, ii, 9
Mauritius, ii, 257
Maxentius, i, 597
Maximilian, Emperor of Mexico, ii, 444,
623
Maximilian I, ii, 200, 617
Maximin, i, 557
Maya (ma/ ya) writing, i, 208
Mayence. (See Mainz)
Mayflower, the, ii, 253, 281, 284
Mayor, i, 491
Mayor of the Palace, ii, 47
Mazarin, Cardinal, ii, 236, 237, 246
Mazdaism, i, 627, ii, 16
Mead, i, 558
Mecca, ii, 3-17, 24-30
Meccan allies, ii, 612
Mechanical Revolution, the, ii, 386-96,
415, 425, 437, 449, 453, 461, 476, 541
Medes, i, 194, 200, 248, 291, 299, 315,
318-23, 332, 335, 342, 344, 387, 449,
543, ii, 607
Media (me'dia), i, 193, 293, 319, 327,
387, 508, 523
Medici (med' i che) family, ii, 182, 195,
196
Medicine, i, 402 sqq., ii, 35, 37
Medina (me de' nd), i, 624, 634, ii, 1, 3,
7-11, 14, 17, 18, 21, 24, 26, 27, 612
Mediterranean, i, 153, 160, 184, 190,
210, 212, 216, 218, 278, 304, 396, 445-6,
468, 508, 529, 540, 542, 560, 570, 621,
641, ii, 28, 53, 65, 139-40, 182, 184,
189, 194, 225
Mediterranean, alphabets, i, 228, 304,
638; civilization, i, 84, 149, 196,
228, 273, 562, ii, 1 ; early navigation
of, i, 210, 211, 216, 512; race and
peoples, i, 101, 108, 138, 141-45, 154,
160-62, 168, 176, 206, 281, 298, 300,
313, 445, 471-72, 538, ii, 122, 149, 490 ;
valley, i, 75, 108, 118, 119, 120, 184,
196
Medway, ii, 226
Meerut, ii, 454
Megabazus (meg & ba' zus), i, 331
Megalithic monuments, i, 109, 110, 125,
147, 240
Megara (meg'tf id), i, 337
Megatherium, i, 102, 207
Megiddo, i, 291, ii, 607
Meillet, A., i, 300
Melanesia, i, 148, 149
Melasgird, ii, 72, 615
Memphis, i, 326, 364, 382, 412
Menahem (men' d hem), i, 291, ii, 606
Mendicants, i, 221
Menelaus (men e la/ us) , i, 176
Menes (me' nez), i, 196, 204
Mengo, ii, 460
Menhir, i, 128
Mercator's projection, i, 546, ii, 461
Mercenary armies, ii, 197
Merchants, i, 264-67, 271
Mercia, ii, 40, 50, 54
Mercury, god, i, 457
Mercury, planet, i, 4
Merodach (mer' 5 dak), i, 245
Merovingians, ii, 46-47, 228
Merv, i, 604
Merycodus (mer i ko' dus) , i, 58
Mesopotamia, i, 102, 133, 183-86, 191,
196-99, 209, 233, 244 , 252, 265, 304,
389, 509, 526, 561, 565, 616, 619, 622,
ii, 1, 18, 21, 31, 118, 128, 130, 145,
522
Mesozoic (mes 6 zo' ik) period, i, 12, 14,
37-55, 66, 67, ii, 140
Messiah, i, 293, 538, 569, 575, 580-86
Messina (mese'nd), Straits of, i, 454,
460, 468, 469
Metallurgy, ii, 388
Metals, i, 105, 106, 205, 207, 219, ii, 174
Metaurus, i, 476
Methodist revival, ii, 263
Methuselah, i, 129
Metternich, ii, 378, 400
Metz, ii, 317, 318, 445, 446
Mexico (and the Mexicans), i, 147, 203,
207, 208, ii, 186, 189, 190, 193, 444,
445, 618
Mey, Peter van der, ii, 230
Michael VII, emperor, ii, 72
Michael VIII. (See Palseologus, Michael)
Michelangelo, ii, 183
Michelin guides, i, 224
Micklegarth, ii, 53
Microscope, ii, 177
Middelburg, ii, 182
Midianites, i, 283
Midsummer day, i, 240
Midwinter day, i, 240
Migrations, i, 105, 548-52
Mihiragula (mi her a goo' la) , i, 629, ii,
612
Miklagord, ii, 53
INDEX
657
Milan, i, 559, 560, ii, 180, 182, 197, 200,
204, 205, 361, 380
Miletus (mi le' tus), i, 303, 312, 330, 340,
379
Military organization, i, 190; service, i,
311 ; tactics, ii, 234
Milk, i, 92, 112, 187, 545
Miller, G. S., i, 72
Millet, i, 558
Milligan, Joseph, i, 163
Miltenburg, ii, 180
Miltiades (mil tl' & dez), i, 330, 346
Milvian Bridge, i, 597
Minerals, i, 9
Ming dynasty, i, 227, 635, 637, 641-42,
ii, 117, 128, 166, 261, 617
Minos (ml'nos), i, 196, 214, 216, 257,
316
Minotaur (min' 6 tawr), i, 214, 216
Minstrels, i, 174
Miocene (mi' 6 sen) period, i, 52, 58-
59, 66, 73
Mirabeau (me ra bo), ii, 314, 319-24
Misraim and Misrim, i, 281
Missionaries (and missions), i, 432, ii,
48, 50, 116, 166, 460, 618
Mississippi, ii, 285
Mitanni, i, 192
Mithraic inscriptions, i, 492
Mithraic Sun-day, i, 575
Mithraism, i, 538, 588, 590, 625, ii, 91,
149, 611
Mithras, i, 413, 538, 590, 625
Mithridates (mith ri da/ tez) , i, 504,
505, ii, 609
Mo Ti, i, 582
Moa, i, 207
Moab (and Moabites), i, 283, 294, ii,
244
Moawija. (See Muawija)
Modestov, i, 446
Moerbeke (moor'bak£), William of, ii,
168
Mcesia, i, 564, ii, 71, 609
Mogul, Great, ii, 471, 620
Mogul dynasty, ii, 133, 618
Mohammed. (See Muhammad)
Mokanna, ii, 31
Moloch, i, 288
Moltke, Count, ii, 481
Moluccas, ii, 187
Mommsen, i, 454, 464, 480, 483, 500
Monarchy, i, 263, 357, ii, 143, 211, 215,
216-17, 230, 236, 248, 251, 307. 339,
372
Monasteries (and monasticism) , i, 609
sag., ii, 50, 106, 150
2u
Monastir (mo nas ter'), ii, 522
Money, i, 219, 220, 265, 445, 457, 496,
629-30, ii, 344-45. (See also Cur-
rency)
Mongolia, i, 541, 543, 640, ii, 110-20,
261-62
Mongolian languages, i, 156, 162 ; races
and peoples, i, 100, 141-49, 158, 160,
174, 205, 299, 316, 387, 388, 507, 508,
543-51, 606, ii, 121-22, 139, 142,
247, 261, 262, 464
Mongoloid tribes, i, 207, ii, 189
Mongols, i, 541, 545, 551, 558, ii, 83, 106
sqq., 114, 122, 127, 128, 129, 130, 140,
142, 143, 168, 184, 193, 261, 268, 616,
617
Monitors, i, 46
Monkeys, i, 56, 57, 65, 67
Monks. (See Monasteries)
Monmouth, cruiser, ii, 520
Monosyllabic language, i, 157
Monotheism, ii, 15
Monroe, President, ii, 378, 444
Monroe Doctrine, ii, 444, 458, 505
Mons, ii, 514
Monte Cassino, i, 611, 612
Montefiore, C. G., i, 586
Montelius, i, 104
Montesquieu, ii, 309
Montezuma (mon te zoo' meE) , ii, 190
Montfort, Simon de, ii, 219
Montreal, ii, 254
Montserrat, ii, 165
Moon, i, 6, 128, 129
Moorish buffoon, i, 558
Moorish paper, ii, 159
Moors, i, 490, 565, ii, 193
Moose, i, 70
Moral ideas, i, 296
Moravia, i, 554
More, Sir Thomas, ii, 211, 394
Moreau, General, ii, 355, 374, 622
Morelly, ii, 309
Morgan, W., i, 587
Morley, Lord, ii, 427
Morning Post, ii, 405
Mornington, Lord, ii, 453
Morocco, i, 217, 565, ii, 142, 461, 470,
484, 500
Morris, William, ii, 311
Mortar, pebble, i, 90
Morte d' Arthur, i, 175
Mortillet, de, i, 96
Mosasaurs (mo' sd sawrz), i, 41, 45
Moscow, ii, 129, 134, 242, 366, 622
Moscow, Grand Duke of, ii, 129, 617
Moscow, Tsar of, ii, 259
658
INDEX
Moses, i, 196, 200, 209, 244, 279, 293,
626
Moslem schools, ii, 137; universities,
ii, 36 ; year, ii, 8
Moslems, the, ii, 19-29, 34, 64, 70, 74,
80-84, 94, 108, 113, 128, 136, 140,
159, 453, 613, 615: in Europe, ii,
28-32, 41, 47, 51, 57, 67, 88, 186,
242, 613, 615. (See also Crusades and
Islam)
Mosses, i, 24, 27
Mosso, i, 210
Most, ii, 152
Mosul, ii, 78, 132
Motley, ii, 230, 232
Mounds, i, 109, 117, 125
Mountains (and mountaineering), i,
5, 35, 36, 52
Mousterian Age (and implements), i,
60, 78, 81, 87, 97
Muawija (moo a we' ya), ii, 24-28, 613
Mudfish, i, 26, 55
Muehlon, Herr, ii, 551
Muhammad (mu ham' ad) , prophet, i,
296, 573, 583, 624, 634, 642, ii, 1, 126,
136, 149; life of, ii, 4 sqq., 26-27;
teaching of, ii, 13-16, 29
Muhammad II, sultan, ii, 124, 197,
617
Muhammad-Ibn-Musa, ii, 37
Muhammadan communistic movement,
ii, 157
Muhammadanism, ii, 29, 42, 135. (See
also Islam and Muhammad)
Mulberry tree, i, 530
Mules, i, 140
Millhausen (mul' hou zen), ii, 347
Miiller, Max, i, 235
Mummies, i, 147
Mummius, i, 483
Munich (mu'nik), ii, 180
Miinster (mun'ster), ii, 156, 157, 503,
618
Miinster, Bishop of, ii, 156
Munzuk, i, 559
Murad I, ii, 124
Murat (mu ra'), ii, 367
Murray, John, ii, 263
Murzuk, i, 118
Muscovites, ii, 244
Muscovy, empire of, ii, 242
Musical instruments, i, 115
Musk ox, i, 58, 64, 76, 101
Muskets, ii, 234
Mycale (mik' A le), i, 340, 343, ii, 607
Mycenae 'mlse'ne), i, 106 303 315,
317
Mycenean (ml se ne' dn) architecture, i,
448
Mycerinus (mis u ri' mis), i, 198
Myla*, i, 470, ii, 608
Myos-hormos, i, 533
Myres, J. L., i, 228
Myriapods (mir' i d podz), i, 28
Myrina (mi ri' na), i, 450
Myron, i, 346
Myrtalis (mur' ta lis), i, 376
Mysteries, religious, i, 373
Myth-making, i, 129
Mythology, i, 130, 361
N
NABATEAN KINGS, i, 622
Nabonidus (nab 6 ni' diis) , i, 247-50,
255, 278, 288, 292, 320, 326, 385, 416,
483
Nadir Shah (na' der sha'), ii, 257, 620
Nagasaki (na ga sa' ke), ii, 465
Nalanda, i, 645
Nanking, i, 642, ii, 108, 615
Naples, i, 451, 510, 611, ii, 88, 98, 180,
211, 347, 378, 441, 612
Napoleon I, ii, 89, 210, 327, 332, 339,
348-82, 384, 386, 453, 621, 622; III,
i, 565, ii, 436, 438-45, 448, 623
Narbonne, ii, 180
Naseby, ii, 223
Nasmyth, ii, 388
Natal, ii, 460
Nathan, i, 287
"National Schools," ii, 396
Nationalism, ii, 431-36, 439, 448, 498-
500
Nationalization, ii, 412
Natural History Museum, i, 50
Natural rights, ii, 156 ; selection, i, 18
Nautilus, Pearly, i, 47
Naval tactics, Roman, i, 469-71
Navarino (navare'no), battle of, ii,
382, 622
Navigation, early, i, 170, 209-18
Nazarenes, i, 587-91
Neanderthal (na an' der tal) man, i,
60, 71-87, 91, 92, 97, 108, 123, 124,
489, 496
Nebuchadnezzar (neb ti kad nez' ar) (the
Great) II, i, 194, 200, 217, 277, 290,
291, 319, 380, 385, ii, 607
Nebulse, i, 3
Necho (ne' ko), Pharaoh, i, 200, 218, 291,
401, 509, 532, ii, 185, 607
Necker, ii, 318
Needles, bone, i, 90, 96-97
INDEX
659
Negritos, ii, 465
Negroes, i, 63, 68, 141, 146, 197, 206,
533, ii, 193, 284-85, 305, 306
Negroid race, i, 88, 139-40, 145, 148,
160, 189, 195
Nehemiah, i, 294
Nelson, Horatio, ii, 352, 361-62
Neohipparion, i, 58
Neolithic Age, i, 75, 97-110, 112-16,
152-54, 158-62, 169 sqq., 196-97;
agriculture, i, 113-17, 130, 189, 254,
317 ; civilization and culture, i, 104-
16, 124-25, 129-34, 145-49, 151-53,
171-76, 181-88, 195, 197, 201-03, 206-
08, 209-13 ; man, 100-06, 126-30, 131-
35, 140, 145, 158-60, 167-72, 223, 273-
74, ii, 301
Neo-platonism, i, 592, ii, 169
Nepal (nepawl'), i, 416, 640, 643, ii,
262
Nephthys (nef this), i, 249
Neptune, planet, i, 4
Nero, i, 525-26, 589, 610, ii, 609
Nerva, i, 526, ii, 610
Nestorian Christians, i, 604, 617, 627,
634, 647, ii, 35, 106, 117-19, 611, 612
Netherlands, the, ii, 200, 207, 217, 228-
33, 238, 253, 380, 381. (See also
Dutch Republic o.nd Holland)
Nets, flax, i, 114
Neustadt (noi' stat) , ii, 180
Neustria, ii, 46, 47, 48, 613
Neva, river, ii, 242
New Amsterdam, ii, 253, 282-83
Newark, ii, 430
New England, i, 59, 143, ii, 185, 253,
281-84
Newfoundland, ii, 254, 471
New Guinea, i, 139, 141, 162
New Habsburg, ii, 199, 616
New Hampshire, ii, 281, 290
New Harmony (U. S. A.), ii, 405
New Jersey, ii, 283, 290, 298, 543-44
New Lanark, ii, 404-06
Newmarket, ii, 226
New Mexico, ii, 505
New Orleans, ii, 254
New Plymouth, ii, 281
Newton, Sir Isaac, i, 408, 534, ii, 176,
620
Newts, i, 26
New Year, festival of, i, 240
New York, i, 495, ii, 180, 253, 283, 290,
292, 301, 387, 621
New Zealand, i, 207, ii, 457, 471-72
Niarchus, i, 375
Nibelungenlied (ne' be lung en let), i, 177
Nicaea (m se' d), i, 600-01, ii, 72, 78, 79,
611
Nice, Province of, ii, 440
Nicene (nl' sen) Creed, i, 601, ii, 60, 611
Nicephorus (ni sef 6 rus) , ii, 58, 614
Nicholas I, tsar, ii, 377, 382, 405, 440,
622 ; II, ii, 476, 477
Nicholas of Myra, i, 600
Nicholson, Gen. John, ii, 455
Nickel, i, 4, ii, 389
Nicomedes (nik 6 me' dez) , King of
Bithynia, i, 500
Nicomedia, i, 560, 595, 600
Niemen (ne' men) , ii, 362
Nietzsche (ne' che), ii, 481
Nieuw Amsterdam. (See New Am-
sterdam)
Niger, river, i, 565
Nile, the, i, 119, 121, 137, 158, 200, 206,
210, 211, 274, 304, 359, 533, ii, 142,
460; battle of, ii, 352, 621; delta,
i, 197, 218, 238; valley, 195, 273, ii,
605, 612
Nineveh (nin'eve),i, 192-96, 200, 246,
292, 319, 384, 616, 619, 622, 624, ii,
130, 607
Nippur (nip poor'), i, 133, 184-85, 190,
196, 274, ii, 130
Nirvana (nirva'na), i, 423, 425, 431
Nish, i, 528, 553, 558, 599, ii, 610
Nisibin, i, 622
Nitrate of silver, ii, 38
Nitric acid, ii, 38
Noah, i, 140
Nobility, i, 258, 263
Nogaret, Guillaume de, ii, 99, 616
Nomadism (and Nomads), i, 105, 112,
137, 148, 177, 186-88, 206, 232-33,
387-88, 507-08, 545-52, 555, 627-28,
641, ii, 1, 105, 108-10, 128-30, 137-39,
143-45, 189
Nominalism, ii, 169 sqq.
Nonconformity, ii, 168
Nordic race, i, 146-154, 206, 298, 315,
368, 373, 387, 548, ii, 43, 66, 122,
144, 149, 168, 247, 262, 490
Normandy (and the Normans), ii,
54, 66-67, 69, 72, 74, 76, 78, 150, 157,
178, 185, 320, 615; dukedom of, ii,
62, 66
Norse language, i, 168, ii, 54
North, Lord, ii, 293
Northmen, i, 539, ii, 53-54, 64, 66, 71,
149, 490
North Pole, i, 31
North Sea, the, i, 75, 539, ii, 66, 182,
185
660
INDEX
Northumberland, ii, 396
Northumbria, kingdom of, ii, 40, 50
Norway, i, 102, 605, ii, 51, 66, 97, 162,
206, 252, 380, 614
Norwegian language, i, 168
Norwich, ii, 154
Norwood, i, 355
Nottingham, ii, 222, 386
Nova Scotia, ii, 185
Novgorod (novgorod'), ii, 66, 129, 180,
182, 259, 614
Noyes, J. H., ii, 403
Nubia, i, 259
Nubian wild ass, i, 217
Numbers, Book of, i, 281
Numbers, use of, i, 128
Numerals, Arabic, i, 219, ii, 37, 88
Numidia (and Numidians), i, 474, 479,
484, 502, 534
Nuns, ii, 149
Nuremberg, ii, 180 ; Peace of, ii, 206
Nurnberg (nurn' berc/0, cruiser, ii, 520
OAK, i, 59
Oars, i, 211
Obedience and will, ii, 140-43
Obi (6' be), river, i, 387, ii, 267
Occam, ii, 171, 172, 174, 617
Ocean, i, 5, 36
Oceania, i, 206
Octavian. (See Augustus)
Odenathus (od e na' thus) , i, 617, ii, 3,
610
Odin, ii, 49
Odoacer (odoa'sfr), ii, 58, 611
Odysseus, i, 508
Odyssey. (See Homer)
(Ecumenical councils, i, 601
Offerings, i, 234
Ogdal Khan, ii, 110, 113, 615
Oglethorpe, ii, 282, 620
Ohio (6 hi' 6), i, 59, ii, 285
Okakura, i, 641
"Old Man" in religion, i, 125, 131-35, ii,
341
Oligarchies, i, 307-10
Oligocene (ol' i gS sen) period, i, 52,
53, 66, 67
Olney, Mr., ii, 505, 562
Olympiad, first, i, 314, ii, 606
Olympian games, i, 314
Olympias, i, 373 sqq., 387, 394, 402, 452
Olympus, mount, i, 335
Omani (6 ma' ni) Arabs, i, 565
Omar I, caliph, ii, 18-26, 83, 613
Omayyads (omi'yadz), ii, 24-36, 61,
64, 613
Oneida community, ii, 403-04, 415
O'Neil of Tyrone, i, 110
Opossum, i, 56
Oracles, i, 252, 305, 321-23
Orange, house of, ii, 232
Orange, Duke of, ii, 232
Orange River, ii, 460
Orang-outang, i, 63, 67
Orbit of earth, i, 30-33, 57
Orient, ship, ii, 352
Orientation of temples, i, 238, 240
Origen (or' i jen), i, 592
Orissa, i, 440
Orlando, Signor, ii, 552, 556
Orleans, i, 559, ii, 180, 400
Ormonde, Duke of, ii, 271
Ormuz, ii, 118
Ormuzd (or' muzd), i, 625, 626
Ornaments, i, 114
Ornithorhynchus (or nith 6 ring' kus) , i,
54
Orpheus (or' fus), i, 354, 538
Orphic cult, i, 354, 373
Orsini (or se' ne) family, ii, 99
Orthodox Church. (See Greek Church)
Osborn, Prof. H. F., i, 7, 13, 50, 59, 63,
86, 96, 100, 534
Osiris (6 sir' is), i, 249, 412, 413, 590
Osman, House of, ii, 123
Ostia, i, 497
Ostracism, i, 312
Ostrogoths, i, 550, 553, 606, ii, 66, 612
Othman, ii, 24, 26, 613
Otho, Emperor, i, 526, ii, 609
Otis, James, ii, 287
Otranto, ii, 126
Otters, i, 38, 69
Otto I, ii, 63, 68, 70, 97, 614
Otto II, ii, 63, 614
Otto III, ii, 63, 614
Otto of Bavaria, ii, 382
Ottoman Empire, ii, 121-25, 131, 132,
136, 139, 184, 617. (See also Turkey
and Turks)
Oudh (oud), ii, 256, 258, 453
Oundle School, ii, 429
Ovid, i, 13
Owen, Robert, ii, 404-09, 623
Ownership, ii, 341
Ox, great, i, 101
Ox-carts, i, 282
Oxen, i, 112, 170, 178, 217
Oxford, i, 530, ii, 37, 96, 153, 168, 171,
172, 180, 222, 264, 271, 288, 317, 427-
30, 437, 486
INDEX
661
Oxide of iron, i, 9
Oxus, i, 629
Oxydactylus (ok si dak' ti His), i, 68
Oxygen (ok' si j$n) , i, 23
PAcinc OCEAN, i, 47, 82, 148, 206, 273,
ii, 110, 142, 187, 189, 261, 484
Paddling in navigation, i, 211
Padua, i, 559
Paine, Tom, ii, 293, 303
Painted pebbles, i, 94, 101
Painting, Palaeolithic, i, 93, 94, 95
Paionia, i, 339
Palseoanthropus Heidelbergensis (pal e 6-
an thro7 pus hi' del burg en' sis) , i, 57,
69-73, 84
Palaeolithic age, i, 25-27, 34, 56-60,
75-85, 91, 96-100, 108, 158, 171, 197;
art, i, 92-100, 123, 129 ; implements,
i, 76, 80, 104, 105, 107, 137; man, i,
82-85, 96-97, 102-06, 115-17, 128-30,
134-35, 137-38, 145, 148-52, 162, 169,
206, 223, 233, 273, 354, 408, ii, 142,
189, 341
Paleeologus (pal e ol' 5 gus) , Michael
(Michael VIII), ii, 98; Zoe, ii, 129
Palseopithecus (pal e 6 pi the' ktis), i, 67
Palaeozoic (pal e 6 zo' ik) period, i, 9-15,
25, 27, 28, 29, 39, 49, 55
Palais Royal, ii, 315
Palawan (pd la/ wdn), ii, 507
Palermo (pd ler' mo), i, 470
Palestine, i, 184, 261, 278, 280, 289, 447,
569, ii, 2, 71, 74, 80, 94, 106, 114,
118, 132, 483, 616
Pali (pa/ le) language, i, 417
Palmerston, Lord, ii, 438
Palms, Cainozoic, i, 51
Palmyra (p&lml'nJ), i, 617, 621 sqq.,
ii, 3, 610
Palos (pa/ 16s), ii, 186
Pamir (pa mer') Plateau, i, 387
Pamirs, i, 643, ii, 24, 109, 118, 128,
184
Pampeluna (pam pe loo' nd), ii, 164, 618
Pamphylia (pam fil' i &), ii, 79
Panama Canal, ii, 507
Panama, Isthmus of, ii, 187, 190
Pan-American Conferences, ii, 447, 505
Pan Chau, i, 549, ii, 610
Pan-German movement, ii, 483
Panipat (pa/ ne put), ii, 133, 618
Pannonia (pano'nid), i, 553-54, 606,
ii, 609
Panther in Europe, i, 318
Papacy (incl. popes), policy of, ii, 90;
outline of, ii, 96 ; and the Great
War, ii, 167; and world dominion,
ii, 252; miscellaneous, i, 603-05, 612,
ii, 41, 47, 56 sqq., 67, 72, 80 sqq.,
92, 95, 99, 114 sq., 124 sqq., 147 sq.,
161, 166-67, 188, 203, 246, 400, 618.
(See also Rome, Church of)
Papal Schism, ii, 99-100, 127, 151, 617
Paper, introduction and use of, i, 198,
408, ii, 38, 121, 158 sq., 194
Papua (pa/ pu #) , type of mankind in,
i, 139
Papuan speech, i, 162
Papyrus (pa pi' rus), i, 198, 408, ii, 38
Parchment, ii, 38
Parchment promissory notes, ii, 89
Pariahs, i, 269
Paris, Peace of, ii, 286, 621; during
the Revolution, ii, 313 sqq. ; Na-
poleon in, ii, 348, 360, 368, 371;
capitulation of, ii, 368 ; rising against
Charles X, ii, 378-79; revolution of
1848, ii, 400-01; siege of, ii, 446;
Zeppelin raids on, ii, 519; Peace
Conference at, ii, 543-58, 560-66;
miscellaneous, ii, 180, 294, 356, 398,
621
Paris, University of, ii, 37, 166 sq., 173,
271
Parisian artificers, ii, 114
Parker, E. H., i, 541, 542
Parkyn, i, 63, 96
Parliament, government by, ii, 194;
English, ii, 219-28, 248, 259, 287 sq.,
492 sq., 622; Polish, ii, 251
Parliamentary Monarchy in Europe, ii,
243
Parma, ii, 88
Parmenio (par me' ni 6), i, 375, 391
Parricide, i, 637
Parsees, i, 625, ii, 137
Parthenon (par' the non), i, 346
Parthia (and Parthians), i, 388 sq., 396,
506 sgq., 523, 526, 540, 543 sq., 616,
621 sq., ii, 609
Paschal II, ii, 615
Passau (pas' ou), Treaty of, ii, 207, 618
Passover, Feast of the, i, 586 sq.
Passy (pase'), ii, 319
Pasteur (pas tur'), i, 408
Pastor, L. v., ii, 127
Patriarchal groups, i, 110
Patricians, Roman, i, 454-63
Patrick, St., ii, 50
Patriotism, i, 310, 460, ii, 246
Patroclus (pa tro' klus), i, 177
662
INDEX
Pattison, Prof. Pringle, ii, 172
Patzinaks, ii, 71
Paul, St., i, 395, 462, 491, 583, 586 sqq.,
ii, 418
Paul, Tsar of Russia, ii, 620
Paulicians, i, 603
Pauline epistles, i, 588 sq.
Pauline mysteries, i, 591
Pa via (pa ve' a), ii, 204
Payne, E. S., i, 158
Peace, universal, i, 296-97, ii, 90
Peace Conference. (See Paris)
Peas, as food, i, 113
Peasant revolts, ii, 154 sq., 203, 271,
397-98, 617
Peasants, i, 151, 257
Pecunia, i, 219
Pecus, i, 219
Pedantry, advent of, i, 409
Peel, Lord, ii, 567
Peel, Sir Robert, ii, 428
Peep-o'-Day Boys, ii, 492
Peers, Council of, ii, 221
Peet, i, 446
Pegu (pegoo'), ii, 119
Peisistratidse (pi sis tra' ti de), i, 314
Peisistratus (pi sis' trd tils), i, 308, 332,
337, 354, 457, ii, 607
Peisker, T., i, 105
Pekinese language, i, 157
Peking, i, 240, 642, ii, 108, 109, 117 sq.,
134, 242, 261, 463, 615
Pelham, i, 454
Pella (pel'd), i, 373
Peloponnesian War, i, 306, 343, ii, 607
Pelycosaurs (pel' i ko sawrz) , i, 27
Penck, Albrecht, i, 59, 70
Pendulum, invention of, ii, 37
Penelope, i, 179
Perm, William, ii, 282
Pennsylvania, ii, 282, 283, 290, 297 sq.,
304
Pennsylvania, University of, i, 184
Pentateuch, i, 278 sqq., 293
Pepi, i, 199, 401, ii, 211
Pepin (pep' in), I, ii, 47, 48, 51, 69, 613 ;
son of Charlemagne, ii, 57 ; of Heris-
thal, ii, 47, 613
Pepys, Samuel, ii, 226
Perdiccas (pur dik' as) , i, 370
Pergamum (pur' g# mum), i, 395-96,
499 sq., 507, ii, 609
Pericles (per'iklez), i, 309, 342 sqq.,
364, 460, 528 sq., ii, 153, 182, 184,
607 ; Age of, i, 355 sq., 364
Perihelion, i, 30 sqq., 57
Peripatetic school, i, 402
Periplus, of Hanno, i, 217, 241
Perkins, ii, 478
Permian rocks, i, 29
Perry, Commodore, ii, 466, 623
Perry, Mr., i, 172
Persepolis (pur sep' 6 lis) , i, 364, 385,
ii, 18
Persia (and the Persians), i, 109, 139,
169, 182, 218, 247, 248, 291-92, 299,
317, 372, 377, 389, 394-95, 452, 507,
510, 533, 538, 542, 543, 551, 622,
623, 627-28, 634-37, ii, 2, 3, 17-21,
67, 71, 105, 109, 113-19, 128, 139,
157, 179, 257, 268, 610; history
(rise of) i, 194, 198-200, 206, 247,
260, 308, 311-15, 318-23, (Empire)
i, 523, ii, 607, (war with Greece)
i, 327 sqq., (war with Alexander) i,
379-80, 383-89, ii, 608, (Sassanid
Empire) i, 528, 616-18, 625, ii, 31,
610, (Islam and Persia) ii, 20-31, 64,
(Mongol Empire) ii, 113, 130-34; re-
ligion of, i, 412-13, 597, 604, 617-18,
624-27, 634, ii, 136
Persian Gulf, i, 160, 186, 190, 210, 387, ii,
118
Persian language, i, 151, 169, 189, 194,
ii, 136, 138
Peru, i, 147, 203, 207-08, ii, 189-90, 192,
465, 618
Peshawar (p£ shawr'), i, 428, 643
Pessinus (pes' i nus) , i, 483
Pestilence, i, 101, 528, 542, 607, 612,
616, 619, 632, ii, 41, 46, 57, 76, 153-
54, 384, 617 sqq.
Peter, St., i, 114, 585, ii, 57, 99; the
Great, ii, 243 sq., 259, 440, 620; the
Hermit, ii, 75 sq.
Peterhof, ii, 242
Petition of Right, ii, 220
Petra (pe' trd), ii, 2
Petrie, Flinders, i, 143, 197, 213, 552
Petrograd, i, 630, ii, 242, 525 sq., 568
Petronius (pe tro' ni us), i, 530
Petschenegs, ii, 71 sq.
Phalanx, i, 370 sq., 453
Phanerogams, i, 26
Pharaohs, the, i, 199, 214, 248 sq.,
256 sqq., 279, 388, 401 sq., 509, 532
Pharisees, i, 572, 578-79
Pharsalos (far sa' 16s), battle of, i, 511,
512, ii, 609
Pheidippides (fi dip' i dez) , i, 332
Phidias (fid' i as), i, 346 sq.
Philadelphia (ancient), i, 621, ii, 79;
U.S.A., ii, 282, 290 sq., 300, 387, 621
Philip, of Hesse, ii, 206
INDEX
663
Philip of Macedon, i, 343, 358, 367 sqq.,
390 sq., 397, 401-02, 434, 561, ii, 607
Philip, King of France, ii, 99
Philip II, King of Spain, ii, 207, 229 sq.,
233, 242, 292, 376
Philip, Duke of Orleans, ii, 315, 337, 379
Philippine Islands, ii, 187, 451, 465, 506
Philistia (and Philistines), i, 196, 245,
282 sqq., 447
Phillimore, Sir Walter, ii, 543
Phillips, W. A., ii, 373, 377
Philo (fi'16), the Jew, i, 410
Philonism, i, 592
Philosophers, at court of Frederick II,
ii, 88
Philosophy, primitive, i, 122-23 ; Greek,
i, 357-60, 410 ; medicinal, ii, 168 sqq. ;
experimental, ii, 176
Philotas (fi 16' tas), i, 375, 391
Phinehas, i, 284
Phocians (fo' shi dnz) , i, 372
Phocis (fo'sis), i, 378
Phoenicia (f e nish' d) , and Phoenicians,
i, 212 sqq., 223, 234, 273, 279 sq.,
287, 290 sqq., 331, 337, 380, 395, 401,
570, 640, ii, 1 ; language and script,
i, 153, 228 ; colonies, i, 303, 447
Phoenix, i, 177
Phoenix, steamship, ii, 387
Phonetic spelling, i, 639
Phonograms, i, 225 sq.
Phrygia (frij'id), and Phrygians, i,
303, 315, 388, 395, 448, ii, 121
Phrygian mysteries, i, 477
Phrygius, i, 375
Physics, ii, 37
Physiocrats, ii, 309
Piacenza (pya chen' ts#), ii, 74
Pictographs, i, 224 sqq.
Picts, i, 532
Picture writing, i, 197, 207, 224-28
Piedmont, ii, 332
Pig, i, 56, 224; unclean to Moslems,
ii, 454
Pigtails, Chinese, ii, 128, 261, 464
Pilate, Pontius, i, 585
Pile dwellings, i, 106, 171, 186. (See also
Lake dwellings)
Pilgrim Fathers, ii, 305
Pilgrims, i, 221, ii, 67, 75
Pillnitz, ii, 327
Piltdown skull, i, 60, 70 sqq.
Pindar (pin' ddr), i, 378
Pins, bone, i, 114
Piracy, ii, 182
Pirsson, L. V., i, 50
Pisa, ii, 176, 180
Pithecanthropus (pith e kan thro' pus)
erectus, i, 60, 65 sqq.
Pitt, William, 1st Earl of Chatham, ii,
289, 332, 359
Pius VII, ii, 360
Pixodarus (pik so dar' us) , i, 375
Pizarro (pi zar' o), ii, 190, 618
Placentia (pla sen7 shi #) . (See Pia-
cenza)
Plague. (See Pestilence)
Plaiting, Neolithic, i, 105
Planets, i, 3 sq., 30
Plants, i, 10 sqq.
Plassey, battle of, ii, 258, 620
Plataea (plate' <£), battle of, i, 336,
340 sqq., 348, ii, 607
Plato, i, 306, 344, 351, 355 sqq., 397, 399,
434, 468, 562, 618, ii, 169, 211, 403,
408, 607
Playfair, ii, 419
Plebeians, Roman, i, 455 sqq., 486, 487
Pleistocene (plis' t5 sen) Age, i, 52, 59,
60, 64 sq., 102, 156, 255
Plesiosaurs (pie' zi 5 sawrz) , i, 40, 45, 50
Pliny, the elder, i, 186; the younger,
i, 535, ii, 38
Pliocene (pti' o sen) Age, i, 52, 58, 60,
68 sq., 273
Plotinus (pl5 tl' mis), i, 410, 592
Plunkett, Sir Horace, ii, 499
Plutarch, i, 313, 346 sq.t 373, 374, '378,
390, 394, 474, 501, 505, 512 sqq., 598,
ii, 351
Pluvial Age, i, 159 sq., 177
Plymouth, ii, 372; (New England), ii,
305
Plymouth Company, ii, 281
Po, valley of the, i, 388, 449, 461, 471
Pocahontas (po ka hon' Us), ii, 280
Pocock, R. I., i, 28, 67, 95
Pocock, Roger, i, 299, 551
Podmore, F., ii, 405
Poitiers, ii, 47, 179, 613
Poland, ii, 71, 100, 112, 126, 129, 130,
179, 236, 244, 248-51, 260, 266, 274,
278, 320, 327, 363-66, 372, 375, 380-
382, 400, 566, 620, 622
Polish language, i, 168
Political ideas, common, i, 519
Politics (and Politicians), i, 496, ii, 140,
245
Polo, Maffeo, ii, 117
Polo, Marco, i, 541, ii, 117, 120-21, 185,
195, 616
Polo, Nicolo, ii, 117
Polyclitus (pol i kll' tus), i, 346
Polygamy, i, 232
664
INDEX
Polynesia, i, 147, 162; languages of, i,
158, 164 ; peoples of, i, 109, 148, 159,
177, 353
Pompadour, Madame de, ii, 240
Pompeii (pom pa/ ye) , i, 489
Pompey, i, 505, 509-14, 538-42, 549,
572, 625, ii, 609
Pondi cherry, ii, 258
Pontifex maximus, ii, 56
Pontus, i, 395, 504 sq., 553, 620, ii,
609 sq.
Poole, Ernest, ii, 503
Poor, the, ii, 269 sq.
Poor Laws, ii, 211
Pope, Alex., ii, 493
Popes. (See Papacy)
Poplicola (pop lik' 6 1<X), Valerius, i, 457
Poppaea (po pe' d), i, 525
Popular education, Christianity and, ii,
139 sqq.
Port Arthur, ii, 462, 469
Port Sunlight, ii, 406
Porto Rico, ii, 506
Portugal (and Portuguese), i, 168, 217,
299, 554, 564, 565 ; ii, 80, 100, 364, 490,
611, 617 ; overseas trade and expansion
of, ii, 184-88, 192-93, 251, 252, 257,
306, 451, 457, 465
Porus (po' rus), king, i, 386 sq., 430
Posen, ii, 367, 400, 446, 487 .
Post horses in ancient Persia, i, 327
Potash, ii, 38
Potato, i, 208
Potomac, river, ii, 301
Potsdam, ii, 240
Pottery, i, 105, 112 sq., 130 sq., 147, 448,
ii, 38
Poultry. (See Fowl)
Powers, Great, ii, 216 sqq., 246-47, 252,
278-79, 380, 440, 447, 500
Prague, ii, 151, 152, 175, 400 sq., 617,
623 ; University of, ii, 151
Prayer-flags, Buddhist, i, 438
Prayer-wheels, i, 438
Precession of the equinoxes, i, 31
Prehistoric Peeps, i, 50
Presbyterianism, ii, 163, 221
Prescott, ii, 207 sq.
Press, free, ii, 302 ; in politics, i, 463
Prester, John, ii, 119
Priam (pri' am), i, 335
Pride, Colonel, ii, 224 sq.
Priestcraft (incl. Priesthood and Priests),
i, 127, 130, 134, 178, 182, 190, 204,
232-53, 263, 266, 285, 305, 430, ii, 16,
85, 149-51, 246, 425
Primal law, i, 79
Prince, character of a, ii, 195 sqq.
Princes, an exclusive class, i, 267
Princeton, Univ. of, ii, 543
Printing, i, 231, 407-08, 463, ii, 121, 158
sq., 167, 174, 617; Chinese, i, 631
Priscus (pris' kus), i, 557 SQ., ii, 42, 611
Prisoners as slaves, ii, 305
Prisons, English, ii, 338
Private enterprise, ii, 273 sq., 535 sqq. ;
ownership, ii, 274 ; property, ii, 228
Pro bus (pro' bus), emperor, i, 528, 553,
ii, 610
Production, distribution and profits of,
ii, 274 ; of machinery, ii, 275-76
Profit, ii, 334
Profiteers, ii, 541
Prokop the Great, ii, 152
Proletariat, i, 268, 456, ii, 398, 408 sqq.
Promissory notes, early, i, 220
Property, i, 259, 265, ii, 146, 217, 308,
338 sqq., 385, 398 sq., 411
Prophets, Jewish, i, 294 sq.
Propitiation, i, 127, 134
Proterozoic (prot er 6 zo' ik) period, i,
10, 14, 17, 25 sq.
Protestantism, ii, 150, 160-67, 206, 209,
218-25, 229, 233, 239, 242, 252-53,
265, 269-71, 281-83, 465, 490-95
Provence, ii, 368
Proverbs, book of, i, 294
Providence, Rhode I., ii, 289
Prussia, ii, 236, 240, 243-53, 278, 314,
320, 327, 362, 364-67, 371, 381, 441-
46, 478-80, 619 sqq.
Przemysl (pshem'isl), ii, 518-19
Psalms, i, 277, 294
Psammetichus (sa met' i kus), i, 200, 291,
316, ii, 606
Pskof, ii, 180
Ptah-hetep (pta' het ep), tomb of, i, 260
Pteria (te'ridQ, i, 323
Pterodactyls (ter 6 dak' tilz), i, 40 sqq.
Ptolemies, i, 395, 401, 432, 571, 636
Ptolemy (tol' £ mi), I, i, 375, 401-02, 404,
409-13, ii, 608; Ptolemy II, i, 404;
Ptolemy III, i, 404
Public opinion, growth of, ii, 148
Public schools. (See Schools, public)
"Pul," Assyrian monarch, i, 290
Pultusk, ii, 362
Punch, ii, 397, 435, 487
Punic (pu' nik) , language, i, 528 ; wars,
i, 196, 454 sq., 460, 466 sqq., ii, 608
Punjab, i, 201, 388, 428 sq., ii, 114,
132 sq., 257, 608
Puritan Revolution, ii, 217
Puritans, ii, 226, 282
INDEX
665
Pyramids, i, 133, 198 sq., 238, 261, 274;
battle of the, ii, 351
Pyrenees, i, 160, 554, ii, 28, 41, 46 sq.,
51, 238, 368, 613
Pyrrhus (pir' us), i, 452 sqq., 467, ii, 67,
608
Pytho (pi' tho), i, 322
Q
QUACO, ii, 467, 621
Quadrupedal reptiles, i, 41
Quartz, i, 9
Quartzite implements, i, 137
Quaternary rocks, i, 12
Quebec, ii, 254, 620
Quinquereme (kwin' kw£ rem), i, 469
Quipus, i, 208
Quixada (ke ha' da), ii, 207, 208
R
RA, i, 250
Races of mankind, i, 87 sqq., 89, 95,
100-101, 120, 136-49
Radiolaria, i, 10
Ragusa (ra goo' zd) , ii, 180
Rahab, month of, ii, 8
Rai, Lajpat, ii, 454, 473
Railways, ii, 386, 622
Rajgir, i, 420
Rajput (raj poof) clans, i, 629
Rajput princes, ii, 256
Raiputana, i, 629, ii, 179, 256
Raleigh, Sir Walter, ii, 280
Ramah, i, 285
Rambouillet (ron boo ya'), ii, 317
Rameses (ram'e sez) II, i, 196, 200, 279,
281-82, 289, 401, ii, 605
Rameses III, i, 249, 282
Raphael, ii, 183
Rasputin (ras poof in) , ii, 525
Ratisbon, Diet of, ii, 206
Ratzel, i, 153, 208, 541, 551
Ravenna,-i, 554, 557, 561, 606, ii, 60, 612
Realism (and Realists), ii, 169 sqq.
Rebus, i, 227
Reconstruction, Ministry of, ii, 534
Red Cross, ii, 199
Red deer, i, 96
Red Indians, i, 546, ii, 285
Red Sea, i, 156, 160, 184, 210, 211, 279,
281, 287, 290, 401, 529, 533
"Red Sea" river, i, 119, 121
Redmond, John, ii, 496, 498
Reed, E. TM i, 50
Reed pipes, i, 115
Reeds, C. A., i, 59
Reform Bill, ii, 400, 622
Reformation, the, i, 596, ii, 161-64, 167,
204, 270, 272
Regicide, ii, 225
Reinach, Salomon, i, 6, 401
Reindeer, i, 64, 76, 78, 90, 93, 101, 115
Reindeer Age, i, 81, 90, 93-98
Reindeer men, i, 105, 108, 115, 118, 123,
124, 133, 170
Religion, i, 124, 127, 131-33, 178, 232,
235-37, 411-14, 582 sqq., ii, 163, 165,
309, 422; "Old Man" in, i, 125, 131,
134
Religious dances, i, 355
Religious wars, ii, 206-07
Remus (re' mus) and Romulus (rom' u-
lus), i, 448
Renaissance, ii, 139, 184
Renan, ii, 169
Renascence, ii, 139
Rent, i, 255-56, 264
Reparation, i, 219
Representation, political, i, 494-95, ii,
298, 414
Reproduction, i, 16-18; of amphibia, i,
26 ; of mammals, i, 54
Reptiles, i, 26, 28, 38 sqq.
Republicanism, i, 519, ii, 248, 264, 347
Republics, i, 307-08, ii, 142
Retailers, i, 265
Revelation, Book of, i, 598
Revere, Paul, ii, 290, 294
"Revisionists," ii, 409
Revolution, ii, 403, 411
Reynolds, Sir Joshua, ii, 227, 493
Rhine, i, 74, 206, 298, 507, 508, 523,
526, 539, 549, 552, 553, 557, ii, 61, 69,
203, 236, 238, 266, 330, 368, 441
Rhineland, i, 605, ii, 41, 47, 61, 67, 77, 82,
228
Rhino ceros, i, 56, 58, 64, 69, 70, 76
Rhode Island, ii, 281, 282, 289, 290,
296, 300
Rhodes, i, 396, ii, 79
Rhodesia, i, 174, ii, 472
Rhondda, Lord, ii, 533
Rhone Valley, i, 606, ii, 82
Rhys, Sir John, i, 168
Rice, i, 646
Richard I, Coeur de Lion, ii, 81, 219
Richard II, ii, 156, 617
Richelieu, Cardinal, ii, 237, 246, 253
Richmond, ii, 443
Ridgeway, W., i, 106, 298
Riga, ii, 180, 182, 526
Righteousness, i, 400
Rio de Oro (re' 6 da 6' r5), i, 217
666
INDEX
Ripley, i, 143
Ritual, ii, 149. (See also Christianity)
Rivers, i, 37
Rivers, W. H. R. i, 148
Riviera (revear'a), French, i, 447;
Italian, ii, 347
Rivoira, ii, 61
Robert of Sicily. (See Guiscard,
Robert)
Robertson, ii, 208
Robespierre (r5 bes pyar'), ii, 324, 333-
336, 349, 621
Robinson, J. H., ii, 99, 253
Roch, ii, 518
Rochefort, ii, 372
"Rocket," the, ii, 386
Rocks, i, 8-13, 27-30
Rocquain, ii, 308
Roger I, King of Sicily, ii, 86
Rolf the Ganger, ii, 54, 66, 614
Roman coins, i, 455
Roman Empire, i, 517 sqq. ; social
and political state of, i, 529, 534-42,
550 ; fall of, i, 550 sqq. ; separation
into Eastern and Western Empires,
1, 554 sqq. ; later Roman Empire
(Western), i, 597, 605, 614, 619, 632,
633, ii, 42, 54, 56, 58, 64, 157, 265, 268,
611- (See also Eastern (Greek) Empire)
Roman law, i, 458, 615-16 ; roads, i, 461,
540
Roman Republic (19th century), ii, 347,
622-23
Romansch language, ii, 47, 199
Rome, i, 407, 504, 510, 519, 548, 564-65,
572, 589, 606-11, 615-18, 621, 633, ii,
2, 50, 126, 182, 195, 202, 276, 441, 445,
483; early history of, i, 445-51, 458,
ii, 607-08 ; war with Carthage, i, 454 ;
social and political state of, i, 352,
454-66, 473, 480-503, 505, 515-16, 630-
31, ii, 145, 343, 394, 607 sqq. ; assem-
blies of, i, 462-66, 486, 488-89, 494, 507 ;
patricians and plebeians, i, 454-62, 486-
88; Senate, i, 455, 459, 463-66, 482,
483-87, 493-505, 511-16, 525; Con-
suls of, i, 455, 466; colonies of, i,
458, 461, 471-72; Punic wars, i,
196, 454 sq., 460, 466 sqq., ii, 608;
assimilation of, i, 483, 509; mili-
tary system of, i, 485, 502, 505, 520;
bequests to, i, 500, ii, 609; Social
war, i, 503, ii, 609 ; monarchy in,
and the fall of the Republic, i, 509
21 ; Roman Empire (see above) ; plague
in, i, 608, ii, 41, 612; true cross at, i,
613, ii, 82; "duke of," ii, 41; Pepin
crowned at, ii, 57; in 10th century, ii,
62 ; sacked by Guiscard, ii, 69, 615 ;
Germans raid, ii, 204, 618; Char-
lemagne crowned at, ii, 215
Rome, Church of (inc. general Chris-
tian associations), i, 589 sqq., 603-05,
612, ii, 41, 50, 53-58, 73, 74, 85, 90-
101, 127, 130, 197, 202, 215, 226, 356.
(See also Catholicism and Papacy)
Romulus and Remus, i, 448
Roosevelt, President, ii, 504, 506, 544,
551
Rose, Holland, ii, 348, 353, 358
Roses, Wars of the, ii, 179
Ross, i, 541, ii, 30
Rostro-carinate implements, i, 60, 81, 273
Roth, H. L., i, 85, 103
"Roum," Empire of, ii, 122
Roumania (and the Roumanians), i,
564, ii, 71, 113, 122, 380, 382, 502,
524
Rousseau (roo so'), J. J., ii, 163, 310,
324, 333, 349, 621
Rowing, i, 211, 469
Roxana, i, 390, 394
Royal Asiatic Society, i, 646
Royal families, marriage of, i, 267
Royal Society of London, i, 637, ii, 177,
239, 392
Rubicon (roo' bi kdn), the, i, 511
Rudolf I, German Emperor, ii, 63, 98,
199, 616
Rulers, deification of, i, 484
Ruling families, i, 307-08
Rumansch language. (See Romansch
language)
Rump Parliament, ii, 224
Rurik, ii, 67, 614
Russia, i, 102, 151, 159, 196, 294, 317,
327, 387, 507, 539, 541, 545, 549, 553,
561, 570, 600, ii, 17, 53, 64, 66-67, 70,
110-14, 127, 128, 129, 130, 134, 139,
157, 179, 236. 244-53, 259-61, 266, 267,
278', 320, 361, 366, 380, 410, 411, 440,
447, 463-69, 484, 485, 502, 509, 510,
524-27, 620-24. (See also Great War)
Russian language, i, 151, 168, 638
Russo-Japanese war, i, 642
Rustam, ii, 20, 21
Rusticiano, ii, 117-21
Ruth, Book of, i, 282
Rutilius, P. Rufus, i, 503
SAAR (sar) VALLEY, ii, 566
Sabatier, P., ii, 94
INDEX
667
Sabbath, Jewish, i, 572, 575, 579, 590
Sabellians, i, 592
Sachsenhausen (sach' sen hou zen) , ii,
180
Sacraments, i, 130-31
Sacrifice, i, 116, 134, 178, 204-05, 234, ii,
190, 418; human, i, 117, 130, 134,
352-54, 489
Sadducees, i, 572
Sadowa (sa' do va), battle of, ii, 445-46,
623
Safiyya (sa fye' ja), ii, 13
Sagas, i, 173, ii, 53
Saghalien (sa ga len') , ii, 469
Sahara, i, 75, 160, 206, 217, 228, ii, 501
Sails, use of, i, 210-11
St. Andrew's, ii, 324
St. Angelo, castle of, ii, 41, 62, 84, 205
St. Gall, monastery of, ii, 69
Saint-Germain-en-Laye, ii, 317
St. Gothard Pass, ii, 182
St. Helena, ii, 372, 374, 471
St. Just, ii, 334
St. Lawrence river, ii, 254
St. Medard, ii, 48
St. Peter's, Rome, i, 238, 591, ii, 202
St. Petersburg. (See Petrograd)
St. Sophia, Church of, i, 615, ii, 124
Sainte Menehould, ii, 323
Sakas (sa'kas), i, 628
Sakya (sa' kya) clan, i, 416
Saladin (sal' d din), ii, 80, 106, 615
Salamis (sal' d mis), i, 337-39, 344, 348,
469, ii, 20, 607
Salerno, ii, 89
Salian dynasty, ii, 63
Salisbury, Lord, ii, 623
Salmon of Reindeer Age, i, 94
Salonika, ii, 522, 524
Salt, i, 118
Salvation, Christian theory of, ii, 418
Salvation Army, i, 413, ii, 166
Samaria, i, 193, 293
Samarkand, i, 386, 390, 546, 604, 643,
645, ii, 110, 132, 133, 159
Samnites, i, 452, ii, 608
Samoan Islands, ii, 505
Samos, i, 303, 346
Samothrace (sam' 5 thras), i, 373
Samoyed (sam' 5 yed) language, i, 156
Samson, i, 283, 293
Samuel, Book of, i, 282-86
Samurai (sam' u ri), i, 642, ii, 466
San Casciano, ii, 195
Sanderson, F. W., ii, 271
Sandracottus. (See Chandragupta)
Sandstone, i, 7
Sandwich Islands, ii, 505
Sandys, ii, 169
Sanskrit, i, 169, 182, 639, 647, ii, 36,
136
Sans Souci (saw soo se') , park of, ii, 240
San Stefano, treaty of, ii, 447, 475, 623
Santa Maria, ship, ii, 186
Sapor I, i, 617, 626, ii, 610
Saracens, i, 565, ii, 3, 64-69
Sarajevo (sa ri' vo), ii, 435, 510
Saratoga, ii, 292
Sardanapalus (sar dd na pa' lus) , i, 194,
246, 290, 292, 316, ii, 606
Sardes, ii, 79
Sardinia, i, 217, 471, 556, ii, 200, 380, 440
Sardis, i, 316, 324, 331, 334, 340, 379
Sargon, I, i, 133, 191-95, 196, 247, 274,
279, 599, ii. 211, 606; II, i, 193, 196,
200, 246, 290, 318, ii, 606
Sarmatians, i, 300, 543, ii, 71
Sarum, Old, ii, 227
Sassanids (sas'anidz), i, 523, 625, ii,
31, 35, 610. (See also Persia)
Saturn, planet, i, 4
Saturninus (sat ur nl' mis), i, 503
Saul, king of Israel, i, 286, ii, 606
Saul of Tarsus. (See Paul, St.)
Savannah, ii, 254, 282
Savannah, steamship, ii, 387
Save, river, i, 560
Savoy, ii, 225, 242, 331, 380, 440
Saxe-Coburg-Gotha family, ii, 482
Saxony (and the Saxons), i, 554, 605, ii,
24, 48, 49, 51-54, 62, 66, 144, 236, 242,
368
Saxony, Duke of, ii, 152; Elector of,
ii, 203
Sayce, Prof., i, 186, 190, 210, 257, 265
Scandinavia, i, 102, 143, 299, 533, 539,
549
Scharnhorst, cruiser, ii, 520
Scheldt, the, ii, 76, 331
Schism, the Great, ii, 100, 127, 151, 617
Schleswig-Holstein, ii, 442
Schmalkalden, ii, 205
Schmalkaldic league, ii, 205
Schmidt, Dr., ii, 136
Schmit, E., ii, 135
Scholars, i, 409
Scholasticism, ii, 167 sqq.
Schools, monastic, i, 613, ii, 60 ; public,
ii, 269 sq., 428-30
Schrader, O., i, 118, 169
Schuchert, C., i, 50
Schurtz, Dr., i, 556, ii, 18, 22
Schwill, ii, 37, 51, 377
Schwyz (shvets), ii, 199, 616
668
INDEX
Science, i, 397 sqq., ii, 35, 174 sqq. ; ex-
ploitation of, ii, 388-91, 410; and
religion, i, 584, ii, 174, 177, 421-22
Science and Art Department, ii, 437
Scientific research, ii, 171
Scilly Isles, i, 217
Scind (and), ii, 113
Scipio, Lucius, i, 482
Scipio, P. Cornelius, i, 475
Scipio (sip' i 6) Africanus, the Elder, i,
477-79, 483, 486, 499, 540
Scipio Africanus Minor, i, 477, 483, 501
Scipio Nasica (na si' kd), i, 483, 501
Scorpion, i, 25, 28
Scorpion, sea. (See Sea-scorpion)
Scotch colonists, i, 110
Scotland, i, 59, 102, 109, 110, 532, ii, 40,
66, 100, 162, 163, 178, 221, 225, 244,
261, 433, 471
Scott, E. F., i, 581
Scott, Michael, ii, 88
Scott, Sir Walter, ii, 487
Scriptures, Arabic, ii, 22 ; Christian,
i, 627, 634
Scythia Csith' i d) and the Scythians,
i, 247, 261, 291, 300-01, 319/327-30,
377, 388, 396, 490, 507, 510, 532-33,
543-45, 558, ii, 66, 71, 113, 128, 367,
607
Sea, depth of, i, 5
Sea fights, ancient, i, 337-40
Sea power, ancient, i, 379-80, ii, 28
Sea trade, ii, 182
Seamanship, early, i, 209-11, 216-17,
218, 266, 272-73, ii, 185 sqq.
Seas, primordial, i, 8, 10, 16, 21-24, 46
Sea-scorpion, i, 10, 21, 24
Seasons, the, i, 30-33, 127, 128-29
Seaweed, i, 23
Sebastiani Report, ii, 359
Secunderabad (se kun der d bad') , i, 389
Sedan, ii, 445, 531
Seek, i, 598
Seeley, Sir J. R., ii, 140
Seignobos (sen yd bo'), ii, 384
Seine, the, i, 137
Seleucia, i, 622
Seleucid (s^lu'sid) dynasty, i, 395-97,
428, 432, 480, 523, 571-72, 616, ii,
608
Seleucus (s<T lu' kus) I, i, 395, 430
Selfishness, i, 423
Selim (salem'), sultan, ii, 126, 618
Seljuks (seljooks'), ii, 33, 71-72. 106,
114, 121, 615. (See also Turks)
Semites (and Semitic peoples), i, 148,
153-60, 188 sqq., 212, 218-19, 228, 232-
233, 237, 242, 264-65, 300, ii, 1, 2, 21,
105, 122, 143, 168, 249
Semitic languages, i, 153-55, 164
Seneca (sen'ekd), i, 491
Senegal river, i, 217
Sennacherib (se nak' er ib), i, 193-94,
200, 246, 291, ii, 606
Sepulchre, Holy, ii, 61, 64, 74, 78, 118
Sequoias (se kwoi' dz), i, 51
Serapeum (serdpe'um), i, 413, 414, ii,
149
Serapis (sera' pis), i, 412-14, 428, 538,
590-91, 602, ii, 611
Serbia (and the Serbs), i, 528, 553, 606,
616, ii, 24, 122, 224, 382, 502, 508-11,
524
Serbian language, i, 168
Serfdom, i, 600
Sergius III, Pope, ii, 63
Serpent in religion, i, 130, 147, ii, 418
Servants, domestic, i, 265
Set, Egyptian god, i, 236
Seton-Karr, Sir H. W., i, 137
Seven Years War, ii, 332, 620
Severus (se ver' us), Septimus, i, 528
Seville, ii, 188
Sex, i, 131
Seyffert, i, 464, 490, 491
Shakespeare, W., i, 173
Shale, i, 7
Shalmaneser (shal ma ne' zur;, i, 193,
291
Shamanism, ii, 114, 128, 146
Shamash, i, 245
Shang dynasty, i, 196, 204
Shanghai (shang hi'), ii, 470
Shang-tung, ii, 469
Sharifian emperors, i, 565
Sharpe, S., i, 249
Shaving the face, i, 391
Sheep in lake dwellings, i, 112
Shekel, i, 220, 265
Sheldonian Theatre, ii, 271
Shell Age, supposed, i, 68
Shellfish, i, 9, 10
Shells as implements, i, 68; as orna-
ments, i, 88
Shem, i, 140
Shen-si, i, 632
Sherbro Island, i, 218
Sherman, General, ii, 443
Shi-Hwang-ti, emperor, i, 196, 205, 253,
542^43, 548, 642, ii, 211, 608
Shiites (she' its), ii, 27, 30, 64, 70, 72, 80,
134, 256
Shiloh, i, 284
Shimei, i, 287
INDEX
669
Shimonoseki (she' m<5 no sak' £) , Straits
of, ii, 467
Shipbuilding, ii, 66, 388-89
Ships, earliest, i, 209-11
Shishak (shi' shak), i, 200, 388
Shrines, i, 234, 313
Siam (and Siamese), i, 203, 640
Siamese language, i, 157
Siberia, i, 100-02, 156-59, 532, 546, 632,
ii, 114, 132, 261
Siberian railway, ii, 469, 502
Sicilies, Two, ii, 200, 364
Sicily, i, 213, 217, 303, 308, 382, 447, 449,
451-54, 471, 480. 486, 498, 505, 566,
ii, 62, 64, 69, 78, 83, 86-88, 97, 182, 353,
380, 441, 615
Sickles, earthenware, i, 189
Siddhattha Gautama (sid hat' t'hd gou'-
tdmd). (See Buddha)
Sidon, i, 196, 212, 216, 266, 279, 290,
331, 380
Sieyes (sya yes'), ii. 354
Sign-language, i, 150
Sikhs (seks), ii, 257, 453
Silbury, i, 110, 135
Silesia, ii, 112, 251
Silk, i, 273, 530, ii, 238
Silver as standard of value, i, 220
Sin, idea of, ii, 190
Sinai, i, 259
Sind, ii, 453
Singan, i, 642, 644, 647, ii, 613
Singer, Dr., i, 403
Singing, i, 115
Sinope (si no' pe), i, 621
Siris, i, 339
Sirius (sir' i iis), a star, i, 238
Sirmium, i, 560
Sistrum, i, 413, 425
Siva, i, 437
Sivapithecus (si vd pi the kus) , i, 67
Siwalik Hills, i, 67
Skins, use of, as clothing, i, 80, 99, 114;
inflated, as boats, i, 209
Skrine, i, 541, ii, 30
Skull, shapes of, i, 100, 142-46
Slate, i, 7
Slavery (and slaves), i, 255-59, 305-09,
352, 363, 455, 489-92, 529, 589, 594,
631, ii, 15, 33, 130, 146, 193, 225, 276,
284-85, 293, 304-05 sqq. ; American,
ii, 342, 619
Slavic tribes, i, 527
Slavonian dialect, i, 168
Slavonic languages, ii, 69
Slavs, i, 616, ii, 24, 49, 57, 61, 69, 128
Sloth, i, 102, 207
Smelting, i, 106, 107
Smerdis, i, 326
Smilodon (sml' lo don) , i, 56
Smith, A. L., ii, 88
Smith, Elliot, i, 69, 84, 146, 147, 189, 207
Smith, Rt. Hon. F. E., ii, 424, 497-99
Smith, John, ii, 280
Smith, Worthington, i, 63, 79, ii, 310
Smithsonian Institution, ii, 392
Smyrna, ii, 79
Snails, i, 28
Sobieskv (so byes' ki), John (John III),
ii, 249, 620
Social Contract, ii, 296, 310
Social Democrats, ii, 485
Social War, the, i, 503, ii, 609
Socialism, ii, 157, 310, 339-46, 403 sqq., 622
Society, beginning of human, i, 178
Socrates (sok'rd tez) , i, 114, 350, 355-
56, 364, 420, 436
Soddy, Prof., ii, 410
Soderini, ii, 195-96, 618
Soil, protection of, i, 37
Soissons, ii, 47, 48
Solar year, i, 129
Solent, the, i, 137
Solferino (sol fe re' no), battle of, ii, 441,
623
Solis, ensign, ii, 231
Sollas, Prof., i, 63, 69, 84, 100
Solomon, King, i, 200, 287-94, 569, ii, 606
Solon, i, 221, 324-25
Solutre, i, 92, 96, 124
Solutrian Age, i, 96, 97, 317, ii, 189
Somaliland, i, 137, 160, 217
Somalis, language of, i, 154
Somersett, J., ii, 306
Somme, the, i, 137 ; battle of. ii, 338, 530
Sonnino, Baron, ii, 552
Sonoy, Governor, ii, 231
Soothsayers, i, 305
Sophists, Greek, i, 350
Sophocles (sof 6 klez), i, 351, 355
Soudan, tribes of, i, 118
Soul, the, i, 131
South Africa, i, 485, ii, 460, 471, 472, 489,
495, 623-24
South Kensington, Natural History
Museum, i, 50
South Sea Islanders, i, 68, 353
Southampton, ii, 180
Soviets (sov' yets), ii, 410, 526, 539
Sowing, and burial, i, 130; and human
sacrifice, i, 117, 134
Space, i, 3, 4, 15
Spain, i, 37, 93, 106, 108, 146, 161, 196,
213, 217, 299, 446-48, 589, 615, ii, 41,
670
INDEX
100, 140, 159, 179, 246; history
(Carthaginians in) , i, 472-79 ; (Romans
in), i, 480, 485-86, 499-502, 509, 522,
540, 569; (Vandals in), i, 554, 556,
ii, 611 ; (under the Goths), i, 606, ii, 46,
66, 613; (Moors in), i, 565, ii, 24-25,
31, 36-37, 57, 61, 64, 194, 242, 613;
(15th-16th cent.), ii, 186, 188, 193-95,
197, 200-04; (17th-Mh cent.), ii, 216,
218, 220, 225, 229, 233, 239, 242-43,
251-52, 279, 292; (19th cent.), ii, 362,
378, 445, 506 ; overseas dominions, i,
208, ii, 187-94 ; colonial expansion,
ii, 251-54, 282, 286, 292, 306, 378, 451,
470
Spanish language, i, 151, 564, ii, 160, 190
Sparta, i, 303-07, 332-36, 343, 349-50,
369, 378, 460
Spartacus (spar' id kus), i, 505, ii, 609
Spearheads, bone, i, 96
Species, i, 17-22, 25, 29, 138-40
Speech, development of, i, 72, 79, 124-
27, 129, 130, 150, 151, 162-63, 223-26
Spelling, need for reform of, i, 282-83
Spence, L., ii, 190
Sphinx, the, i, 238
Spices, Oriental, ii, 257
Spiders, early, i, 28
Spinden, i, 207
Spinnerets of spiders, i, 28
Spoleto (spo la/ to), i, 610
Spores, i, 24
Spurrell, H. G. F., i, 63, 98
Spy, i, 72
Stag, i, 94, 101
Stagira (sta jlr' d), i, 357
Stalky and Co., ii, 423
Stallybrass, Dr. C. O.( ii, 154, 543
Stambul (stam bool'), ii, 126
Stamp Acts, ii, 289
Stamps used for signatures, i, 408
Stars, i, 4 ; and early man, i, 127, 238,
240
State, the, i, 488 sqq., 519, ii, 142, 163,
197, 244, 415
States-General, the, ii, 234, 312, 621
Steam, use of, ii, 386, 392
Steamboat, introduction of the, ii, 387
Steam-engine, invention of, i, 540, ii,
275, 386
Steam-hammer, ii, 388
Steam-power, ii, 275
Steel, i, 273, ii, 388
"Steel Boys," the, ii, 492
Stegosaurus (steg 6 saw' rus) , i, 40
Stein, Freiherr von, ii, 364
Steno, ii, 419
Stephenson, G., ii, 386
Stern, G. B., ii, 433
Stettin, ii, 180
Stilicho (stil' i ko), i, 554, 561, ii, 611
Stockholm, ii, 526
Stockmar, Baron, ii, 438-39
Stoicism, i, 360, 363, 588
Stone, early use of, i, 171
Stone, Major-Gen., ii, 570
Stone Age, i, 60, 68, 75, 81, 96, 97, 104-
13, 197, 213, 274
Stonehenge, i, 109-10, 147, 171, 196, 240,
ii, 606
Stopes, Dr. Marie, i, 38
Story-telling, primitive, i, 129
Strabo (stra'bo), i, 13
Strafford, Earl of, ii, 221-22, 491
Strata, geological, i, 7 sqq.
Strikes in ancient Rome, i, 457-58, 496
Stuart dynasty, ii, 163, 225-26
Stubbs, Bishop, ii, 54
Sturdee, Admiral, ii, 520
Styria, ii, 200
Subiaco (soo be a' ko), i, 611
Submarine warfare, ii, 520, 527
Subutai, ii, 112
Sudan, the, ii, 471
Sudras, i, 269, 270, 645
Suetonius (swe t5' ni us), i, 525, 598
Suevi (swe' vi), i, 554, 606, ii, 46, 611
Suez, i, 156, 160, 195, 218
Suffering, cause of, i, 423
Suffrage, manhood, ii, 297
Sugar, ii, 38
Suleiman (soo la man') the Magnificent,
ii, 24, 28, 126, 200, 205, 613
Sulla, i, 503-04, 511, ii, 609
Sulphuric acid, ii, 38
Sulpicius (sul pish' i us), i, 504
Sultan, Turkish, i, 565
Sumatra, i, 635, ii, 120
Sumer (incl. Sumeria and Sumerians), i,
133, 188-96, 203, 208, 210, 212, 218,
227-28, 232, 234, 242-48, 254, 259,
274, 297, 307, 319, 370, 522, ii, 1, 105,
130, 189
Sumerian language and writing, i, 133,
162, 189, 198, 227, 229, 279, 408, 638
Sun, the, i, 3-4, 30, 34 ; worship, i, 130,
147, 235-38, 412-13
Sunday, i, 575, 590, ii, 149; schools, ii,
396
Sung dynasty, i, 634-35, 641, ii, 108,
112-13, 118. 614
Sunnites, ii, 27, 71, 80, 136
"Sunstone," i, 147
Superior, Lake, i, 225
INDEX
671
Surrey, ii, 275
Susa, i, 104, 189, 260, 318, 326-31, 337-
38, 364, 385-87, 390
Sussex, i, 70, ii, 40, 275
Suy dynasty, i, 632
Swabians, ii, 47, 63
Swansea, Lord, i, 106
Swastika Cswas' ti kd), i, 147, 176
Sweden (and the Swedes), i, 102, 553,
605, ii, 51, 53, 162, 206, 225, 234, 242,
244, 249, 257, 266, 283, 368, 380
Swedish language, i, 168
Swift, Dean, ii, 492, 493
Swift, Fletcher H., i, 297
Swimming-bladder, i, 25, 52, 56
Swine, keeping of, i, 112, ii, 180
Switzerland (including the Swiss), i, 106-
09, 113, 115, 171, 186, 564, ii, 69,
198 sq., 204, 236, 280, 319, 328, 339,
347, 359, 380, 616, 617
Swords, bronze, i, 132
Sykes, Ella and Percy, i, 548
Sykes, Sir Mark, i, 619, ii, 5, 9, 29-30,
121-23
Syndicalism, ii, 409
Syncecism of gods, i, 483-84
Syracuse, i, 351, 449, 452, 468, 476, 497,
534
Syria (and Syrians), i, 102, 160, 192,
194, 200, 250, 265, 278, 290, 292, 326,
342, 380, 500, 569-70, 587, 598, 604,
617, 619-21, ii, 1-2, 4, 7, 17-21, 71,
74, 79, 97, 106, 113, 130-32, 149, 359,
440, 500
Syrian language, i, 530, 627, ii, 35
TABRIZ, ii, 120
Tabu, i, 113, 125-29
Tachov (tak'hov), ii, 152
Tacitus (tas' i tus), i, 491, ii, 144
Tadpoles, i, 26, 52
Taft, President, ii, 544, 551
Tagus valley, ii, 207
Tain, an Irish epic, i, 182
Tai-tsung, i, 634, 642, 647, ii, 106, 612
Talleyrand, ii, 370, 374
Tallien, ii, 336
Tallies, i, 128
Tammany, i, 495
Tancred, ii, 79
Tang dynasty, i, 630-33, 641, ii, 106, 612
Tangier, ii, 484
Tanks, ii, 515-16, 523, 530, 569, 571
Tannenberg, ii, 515, 518
Taoism (tou' izm), i, 433, 438, 641
Tapir, i, 56
Tarentum, i, 452, 476
Tarim (ta rem') valley, i, 201-02, 387,
546, ii, 109, 609
Tarpeian Rock, i, 459
Tarquins, the, i, 450, 456
Tartar language, i, 156, ii, 119
Tartars (and Tartary), i, 388, 542, 545,
627, ii, 109, 112, 119, 129, 244, 260, 267
Tashkend, i, 643
Tasmania (and Tasmanians), i, 82, 84,
85, 138, 148, ii, 189, 451; language,
i, 162
Tattooing, i, 147
Taurus mountains, i, 395-97, ii, 21, 28,
34, 42, 122
Taxation, i, 255, 264, 310, ii, 217-18
Taxilla, i, 645
Tayf (tl'if), ii, 7
Taylor, H. O., ii, 172
Tea, i, 630, ii, 289
Teeth, i, 44, 69-73, 86, 87
Telamon (tel'dmon), battle of, i, 471,
475, ii, 608
Telegraph, electric, ii, 387
Tel-el- Amarna (tel el a mar' na) , i, 200,
220, 245, 250, 288
Telescope, invention of the, ii, 176
Tell, William, ii, 199
Tempe (tern' pe), vale of, i, 335
Temples, i, 190, 234^tl 250, 304
Ten Thousand, Retreat of the ti, 607
Ten Tribes, the, i, 193
Teneriffe, ii, 225
Tennyson, Lord, i, 175 531, ii, 438
Tertullian (tur tul' ytfn), i, 403
Testament, Old, i, 114, 277, 292, 294;
New, i, 114
Tetrabelodon (tet rd bel' 5 don), i, 58
Teutonic Knights, ti, 266
Teutonic tribes, i, 299, 509, 527, 552, ii,
611
Texel, ti, 332
Textile fabrics, Arab, ii, 38
Thames, the, i, 59, 137, ti, 182, 226, 512
Thatcher, ii, 37, 51, 377
Thebes (thebz) and Thebans, i, 252, 274,
303, 336, 343, 370-71, ii, 606
Themistocles (the mis' to klez) , i, 313,
337
Theocrasia, i, 412, 414, 538, 590, 626, ti,
149
Theodora, Empress, i, 615
Theodora, sister of Marozia, ti, 62
Theodore of Tarsus, ii, 50, 613
Theodoric (the od' 6 rik) the Goth, i, 560,
606, ii, 37, 612
672
INDEX
Theodosius (the 6 do' shi us), the Great,
1, 554, 602, 615, ii, 611
Theodosius II, i, 557-59
Theophrastus (the 6 fras' tus), i, 13
Theophylact, ii, 62
Theriodont (the' ri 6 dont) reptiles, i,
54
Theriomorpha, i, 41, 47, 48
Thermopylae (thur mop' i le) , i, 335, 336,
474, 536, ii, 607
Theseus (the' sus), i, 216
Thespians, i, 336
Thessalus (thes' a his), i, 375
Thessaly (and Thessalians) , i, 335-40,
384, 453, 511
Thibet, i, 432, 628
Thien Shan, i, 546, 643
Thiers (tyar), ii, 353
Thirty Tyrants, i, 351
Thirty Years' War, ii, 235, 262, 292,
511
Thomas, Albert, ii, 439
Thompson, R. Campbell, i, 189
Thor, i, 233, ii, 49
Thoth-lunus (thoth' lu' mis) , Egyptian
god, i, 239
Thothmes (thoth' mez), i, 199, 289, 317,
401, 445, ii, 605
Thought and research, i, 122-35, 352-53,
360-62, ii, 414
Thrace (thras) and Thracians, i, 303,
328-31, 340, 372, 377, 395, ii, 20, 123
Three Teachings, the, i, 436
Throwing sticks, i, 90
Thucydides (thu sid' i dez) , i, 344, 360,
399, 460
Thuringians, ii, 51
Tian Shan, i, 549
Tiber, river, i, 447, 448, 454, 458, ii, 41
Tiberius Csesar, i, 523, 572, 584, ii, 609
Tibet, i, 206, 438, 545^7, 591, 640, ii,
113, 128, 262, 463, 624
Tibetan language, i, 157
Tides, i, 8
Tiger, sabre-toothed, i, 56, 64, 69, 70,
76
Tiglath Pileser (tig' lath pi le' z^r) , I, i,
192, 196 ; III, i, 193, 200, 246, 290, 318,
ii, 606
Tigris, i, 186, 192, 210, 238, 260, 616, ii,
2, 106
Tii, Queen, i, 250
Tille, Dr., ii, 180
Tilly, ii, 235
Tilsit, Treaty of, ii, 363, 622
Timbuktu, i, 565
Time, i, 13-15, 128-29, ii, 605
Times, the, ii, 405
Timon (ti' mon), i, 515
Timurlane, ii, 132-33, 137, 154, 261,
617
Tin, i, 4, 106, 217, 273, ii, 389
Tinstone, i, 106
Tiryns (ti' rinz), i, 303
Titanothere (ti' tan 6 ther), i, 53, 56
Titus, i, 526, 571, ii, 610
Tobacco, i, 170, 219, ii, 281, 284
Toe, great, i, 66
Tolstoy, ii, 367
Tonkin, ii, 467, 470
Torr, Cecil, i, 210, 259
Tortoises, i, 40, 46
Torture, use of, ii, 338
Tory Party, ii, 489
Totila (tot' i la), i, 6-11
Toulon, ii, 333, 349, 351
Tours, ii, 47, 180
Towers of Silence, i, 625
Town life, European, ii, 180 sqq.
Town Topics, ii, 424
Townshend, General, ii, 522
Township, primitive, i, 256
Tracheal tubes, i, 25
Trachodon (trak' 6 don), i, 42
Trade, early, i, 118, 208-22, 257, 264-65;
routes, ii, 76, 183 ; sea, ii, 184-85
Trade Unions, i, 487, 536, ii, 407
Tradition, i, 55, 124-29, 230
Trafalgar, battle of, ii, 362, 622
Trajan (tra'jan), i, 524, 526, 614, 623,
ii, 2, 610
Transmigration of souls, i, 424, 427
Transport, ii, 386, 569
Transubstantiation, ii, 150-51, 171
Transvaal, ii, 424, 460, 623. (See also
South Africa)
Transylvania, i, 526, ii, 112
Trasimene, Lake, i, 475
Travels, early, i, 221, ii, 386
Trebizond, ii, 120
Trees, i, 27, 37
Trench warfare, ii, 515
Trent, Council of, ii, 167, 618
Tresas, i, 336
Trevithick, ii, 386
Trianon, the, ii, 317
Tribal system, i, 177, ii, 128
Trilobites, i, 10, 21-24
Triceratops (tri ser' a tops) , i, 42
Trieste, ii, 445
Trigonometry, ii, 37
Trinidad, ii, 471
Trinil, i, 68-69
Trinitarians, i, 592-93, 601-02
INDEX
673
Trinity, doctrine of the, i, 575, 592, 602,
625-26, ii, 171
Trinity College, Dublin, ii, 492
Tripoli, i, 228, ii, 470, 500, 624 ; Treaty
of, ii, 294
Trireme, i, 469
Trojans, i, 216, 448, ii, 121
Troltsch, i, 604
Trotsky, ii, 411
Troy, i, 216, 303, 318, 335, 446
Troyes (trwa), battle of, i, 559, ii, 611
Trumpet, bronze, i, 132
Tsar, title of. i, 565, ii, 129
Tshushima (tsoo she' ma) , Straits of, ii,
469
Ts'i (dynasty and state), i, 205, 508
Ts'in (dynasty and state), i, 205, 253
Tuaregs, i, 154, 206
Tudor, ii, 287
Tuileries, ii, 319, 322, 328, 329
Tulip tree, i, 51
Tunis, i, 470, ii, 84, 470, 500
Turanian language. (See Ural-Altaic
languages)
Turanians, i, 158, 620, 627, ii, 29, 69,
122
Turkestan, i, 153, 159, 206, 273, 317,
386, 387, 388, 428, 433, 546, 548, 549,
603, 618, 620, 627-29, 644, ii, 17, 24,
33,71, 109, 113, 121, 127-28, 132, 261,
262, 608, 612
Turkey, ii, 208, 366. 382, 440, 446, 483,
484, 500, 502, 521-22, 531, 623, 624.
(See also Turks)
Turkey. Great, ii, 114
Turkhan Pasha, ii, 554
Turkish fleet, ii, 140; language and
literature, i, 156, 627, ii, 122 ; peoples,
i, 541, 570, 627, ii, 28, 64, 66-72, 139-
40, 261 (see also Turks) ; princes, ii,
106, 124
Turko-Finnic language, ii, 70
Turko-Finnish peoples, i, 560, 606
Turkomans, i, 551, ii, 132-33, 261, 471
Turks, i, 388, 545, 618, 627, 629, 644,
ii, 24, 34-35, 61, 106, 121-22, 617; and
the Crusades, ii, 78 sqq. ; Ottoman, i,
615, ii, 121 sqq., 138-40, 182-84, 193-
94. 197, 200, 204-06, 233, 240, 249, 353,
447, 617, 620; Seljuk, ii, 34, 39, 70,
114, 121, 615
Turtles, i, 40, 46
Tuscany, ii, 225, 236, 242
Tusculum, i, 473
Tushratta, King, i, 192. 200, 245
Twelve Tables, the. i, 458, 487
Tyler, Wat, ii, 156, 617
2x
Tylor, E. B., i, 131
Tyndale, Bible of, i, 282
Typhon (ti' fon), Egyptian god, i, 236
Tyrannosaurus (t! ran 6 saw' rus) , i, 42
Tyrants, i, 308
Tyre, i, 196, 212, 216, 261, 264, 266, 279,
294, 331, 379, 380, 382-84, 401, 468,
569, 571, ii, 144, 244
Tyrol, ii, 283, 564
UGANDA, i, 206, ii, 51, 460
Uhud, battle of, ii, 9
Uigurs (we' goorz) , ii, 109
Uintathere (u in' ta ther), i, 53, 56
Ukraine Cossacks, ii, 260
Ukrainia (and Ukrainians), ii, 128-29,
244
Ulm, ii, 362, 622
Ulster, i, 110, ii, 432, 489-98
Uncleanness, i, 126, 131
"Unionist" party, ii, 495
United Provinces. (See Holland)
United Service Institution, ii, 567, 571
United States, i, 37, 546, ii, 294, 297 sqq. ;
constitution, i, 225, 520, ii, 293 sq.,
314, 378, 621 ; political and social
conditions, i, 268, 308, 493, ii, 292-96,
326, 338, 344, 386-87, 395, 551;
slavery in, ii, 193, 293 ; Declaration of
Independence, ii, 293, 621; treaty
with Britain, ii, 293-94, 621 ; Civil
War, ii, 443, 623; unity of, ii, 476;
modern foreign policy of, ii, 503-07 ;
in Great War, ii, 527, 583, 560-62.
(See also America)
Universal History, the, ii, 418, 419
Universal law, ii, 215
Universals, ii, 174
Universe, ii, 418
Universities, i, 613, ii, 37, 88, 168, 270,
390, 427
University Commission, ii, 437
Unterwalden (oon' ter val den) , ii, 199
Ur, i, 195
Ural mountains, i, 153, 549
Ural-Altaic languages, i, 155, 156, 160,
164, 174, 299, 560 ; people, i, 203
Uranus (ur' a mis), i, 4
Urban II (pope), ii, 72, 74, 84, 97, 167,
615
Urban VI (pope), ii, 100, 617
Urfa, i, 621
Uri, ii, 199
Urns, i, 115
Uruk, i, 195
674
INDEX
Urumiya (u rQ me' ya), lake, i, 318
Ussher, Bishop, ii, 418
Usury, i, 265
Utica (u'tikd), i, 212
Utopias, i, 358, ii, 211
Utrecht, ii, 229
VAISYAS (vis' yaz), i, 269, 270
Valais, i, 564
Valenciennes, ii, 531
Valens, Emperor, i, 554
Valerian, Emperor, i, 528, 617, ii, 610
Valladolid, ii, 207-09
Valmy, battle of, ii, 330, 621
Valona, ii, 524
Value, i, 219, 220
Van, i, 318
Vandals, i, 540, 553, 556, 564, 606, 615,
ii, 22, 611
Varangians (va ran' ji anz), ii, 67
Varennes (va ren'), ii, 323-25, 621
Varro, i, 476
Vasa (var sa), Gustava, ii, 234
Vases, i, 213
Vassalage, ii, 44
Vatican, ii, 57, 84, 100
Vaughan, ii, 310
Vedas (var daz), i, 173, 182, 417, ii, 257
Vegetarians, i, 182, 416
Vegetation, i, 37, 38
Veii (ve' yl), i, 450, 459, 483, 485
Vendee, ii, 333, 351
Venetia, ii, 441, 445, 529
Venezuela, ii, 505
Venice (and the Venetians), ii, 76, 80,
81, 97, 117, 120, 126, 139, 180, 182,
184, 257, 351, 380, 529, 616, 621
Venizelos (ven i ze' los), ii, 522
Venus, goddess, ii, 49
Venus, planet, i, 4, 6
Vera Cruz, ii, 444
Verbal tradition, i, 230
Verde, Cape, ii, 617
Verde, Cape, Islands, ii, 188
Verdun, ii, 329, 330, 509
Verona, ii, 180, 332
Versailles, ii, 238, 242, 248, 312-22, 446,
477, 556; Peace of, ii, 560 sqq., 624
Verulam, Lord. (See Bacon, Sir Francis)
Vespasian (ves pa/ zhi an), i, 526, 535,
571, ii, 609
Vessels of stone, i, 213
Vesuvius, i, 505
Via Flaminia, i, 471
Victims, human, i, 588
Victor Emmanuel, ii, 441, 623
Victoria, Queen of Great Britain, i,
175, 531, ii, 228, 437, 438, 455, 482,
487, 622, 623
Victory, flagship, ii, 362
Vienna, ii, 126, 140, 205, 249, 371, 483,
568, 618, 620; Congress of, ii, 370,
378, 379, 431, 436, 440, 453, 557, 622
Vigilius, i, 558, 559
Vikings (vik' ingz), ii, 53, 67
Village, the, i, 109, 256
Vilna, ii, 386, 519
Vimeiro (ve ma' e roo), ii, 364
Vinci (vin' che), Leonardo da, i, 13, 534,
ii, 175, 183, 419, 523, 618
Vindhya (vind' ya) mountains, i, 420
Vinland, ii, 185
Virgil, i, 407, 448, 531
Virginia, ii, 280, 283, 290, 292, 296,
300, 305, 306, 443
Virtue, i, 351
Vise, ii, 512
Vishnu, i, 180, 437
Visigoths, i, 550, 553, 559, 606, ii, 66,
611
Vistula, ii, 112
Vitellus, i, 526, ii, 609
Vittoria, ship, ii, 188
Viviparous animals, i, 54-55
Vivisection, i, 403, 404, 490
Vocabulary of man, i, 151
Volga, i, 153, 159, 432, 560, 606, ii, 267
Volscians, i, 458
Volta, ii, 387
Voltaire, F. M. A. de, ii, 238, 240, 264,
421, 620
Votes, ii, 147
Vowels, i, 304
Voyages, i, 217-18, ii, 191
Vulgate, the, i, 307
W
WAGES, i, 258, ii, 156
Wagons, i, 170
Waldenses, ii, 92, 94
Waldo, ii, 92, 94
Wales, i, 209, 605, ii, 40, 178
Waley, Arthur, i, 157
Walid (wa led') I, ii, 28, 613
Walid II, ii, 28, 613
Wallace, William, ii, 178
Wallenstein, ii, 235
Walpole, Sir Robert, ii, 227
Wang Yang Ming, i, 642
War, Great. (See Great War)
War and warfare, i, 171, 254, 256, 306,
INDEX
675
370-72, ii, 234, 424, 475-76, 481,
513 sqq., 567-70
War of American Independence, ii,
291 sqq.
Warsaw, ii, 382
Warwick, Lord, ii, 222
Washington, i, 520, ii, 279, 301, 357,
392, 443
Washington, George, ii, 292, 301, 303,
307, 353
Water, i, 23, ii, 275
Waterloo, ii, 371, 624
Watt, James, ii, 275, 386, 392
Watters, i, 541, 642, 645
Wealden Valley, i, 73
Weale, Putnam, ii, 461
Weapons, i, 78, 108, 114, 196, 205
Weaving, i, 105
Wedmore, Treaty of, ii, 52, 54
Wei dynasty, later, i, 633
Wei-hai-wei (wa hi wa'), ii, 462, 469
Wellesley, Marquis. (See Mornington,
Lord)
Wellesley, Sir Arthur. (See Welling-
ton, Duke of)
Wellington, Duke of, ii, 364, 371
Wells, J., i, 458, 467, 470
Welsh, the, ii, 244
Welsh language, i, 168
Wends, the, ii, 80
Were-wolf, i, 124
Wessex, ii, 40, 51, 614
Western civilization, i, 636
Westminster, i, 463, 489, ii, 159, 182,
222, 225, 228
Westphalia, Peace of, ii, 232, 236, 280
Weyl, ii, 543
Whales, i, 41
Wheat, i, 113, 184, 186
Wheeler, B. I., i, 359, 362, 367
Whigs, ii, 288-89, 332
Whistles, i, 115
White Man's Burthen, ii, 462
Whitehall, ii, 222, 224, 568
Wilberforce, Bishop, ii, 420
Wilhelm I, German Emperor, ii, 482
Wilhelm II, German Emperor, ii, 59,
60, 482-86, 623
Wilhelm, Crown Prince of Germany, ii,
486
Will and obedience, ii, 142-48
William I, etc., Emperors of Germany.
(See Wilhelm)
William the Conqueror, i, 408, ii, 54,
66, 150, 615
William III, Prince of Orange, ii, 226,
491-92, 620
William IV, King of England, ii, 228
William the Silent, ii, 229
Williams, Harold, ii, 71
Williams, S. Wells, i, 541
Wilson, W., President of U. S. A., ii, 221,
284, 543-46, 550-57, 564-67
Wiltshire, i, 110. 135
Winckler, H., i, 192, 195, 246, 342
Windsor, ii, 222
Wine, ii, 281
Wiriath, ii, 311, 326
Wisby, ii, 180
Witchcraft, i, 126, 374
Withington, E. T., i, 403
Wittenberg, ii, 156, 203, 618
Woden, ii, 144
Wolfe, General, ii, 254, 620
Wolsey, Cardinal, ii, 202
Wolves, i, 69, 448
Women, i, 95, 99, 181, 232, 251, 309, ii,
13, 297
Wood, i, 76
Wood Age, i, 68
Wood blocks, for printing, ii, 159
Woodruff, Prof. L. L., i, 7
Woodward, G. M., i, 50
Woodward, Smith, i, 72
Woolf, L. S., ii, 377, 543
Woollen industry, ii, 275
Workmen, ii, 404-407
World (geographical), i, 341, 405, 406,
ii, 187, 188, 191, 605 ; (political), i, 397,
399, 400, ii, 278, 381, 385, 431, 449
World, Old, nursery of mankind, i, 103
World dominion (and unity), i, 374, 397,
399, ii, 72, 90, 211, 243, 246, 252, 261-
262
Worms, town, ii, 60
Worms, Diet of, ii, 203, 618
Worship, i, 130
Worth (vurt),ii, 445
Wright, W. B., i, 30, 63, 78, 96, 100,
101, 120
Writing, i, 174, 176, 189, 197, 198, 207-
208, 214, 223-31, 296, 421, 639, ii, 59
Written word, i, 293
Wu Ti, i, 548, ii, 609
Wu Wang, i, 204
Wurttemberg, i, 102, ii, 445
Wycliffe, John, and his followers, ii,
96, 100, 150-53, 160, 171, 174, 202,
270, 272, 617
XAVIER (za/ vi ur), Francis, ii, 465
Xenophanes (ze nof ' & nez) , i, 13
676
INDEX
Xenophon, i, 342, 351, 357, 363, 399
Xerxes (zurk' sez), i, 334-42, 362, 385,
542, ii, 122, 607
YANBU, i, 634
Yang-chow, ii, 119
Yang-tse valley, i, 205, 542
Yang-tse-kiang (yang tse kyang'), i, 201,
641
Yarkand, i, 628, 643, ii, 610
Yarmuk, ii, 18, 613
Year, Moslem, ii, 8 ; solar, i, 129
Yeast, i, 172
Yedo bay, ii, 466
Yeliu Chutsai, ii, 110
Yemen, i, 618, 624, ii, 3-4
York, i, 529, ii, 221
Yorkshire, ii, 154
Yorktown, ii, 292
Ypres (e' pr), ii, 229, 515, 516
Yuan Chwang, i, 541, 642 sqq., ii, 22,
34, 106, 118, 612-13
Yuan dynasty, ii, 114, 117, 127, 617
Yucatan, i, 308, ii, 190
Yueh-Chi, i, 548, 628, 643, ii, 618
Yugo-Slavia (and Yugo-Slavs), i, 616,
ii, 122, 380 sq., 484, 564, 566
Yule, i, 541
Yuste (yoos' ta), ii, 207-09
ZADOK, i, 287
Zaid (za'id), ii, 12
Zainib, ii, 12
Zama (za' md), i, 476-80, 482, ii, 608
Zanzibar, ii, 187
Zara, ii, 81
Zarathustra (za ra thoos' trd). (See Zo-
roaster)
Zebedee, i, 580
Zeid (zld), a slave, ii, 6
Zend Avesta, i, 624
Zenobia, i, 535, 617, ii, 610
Zeppelin raids, ii, 519
Zeus (zus), i, 396, 412
Zeuxis (zuk' sis), i, 369
Zimbabwe (zem bab' wa), ii, 459
Zimmern, i, 305, 310, 343
Zinc, i, 106
Ziska, ii, 152
Zodiac, i, 240
Zollverein (tsol' fer In), ii, 488
Zoroaster (zo ro as' tur) and Zoroas-
trianism, i, 533, 538, 617, 618, 624,
625, 626, 627, ii, 4, 14, 16, 29, 137
Zoroastrian language, i, 626
Zosimus (aos' i mus) , i, 599
Zulus, i, 219, 370
Zyp, the, ii, 230
Printed In the United States of America.
Wells, Herbert George
21 The outline of history
W4
1920a
v.2
CO; .3
\
PLEASE DO NOT REMOVE
CARDS OR SLIPS FROM THIS POCKET
UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO LIBRARY